I never imagined that with cellos and violins could be achieve the same spirit of this theme that with the voices of Gilmour and Waters. Simply beautiful.....
Several orchestras also played "Kashmir" (LZ).(my 2nd favourite band after PF) It's great to see these classics played like this.ruclips.net/video/vgvdZsxc8fM/видео.html
@@patricktrudeau2680 Bonjour, Patrick. C'était l'école Mgr A.-M.-Parent, à St-Hubert. Il y avait là une concentration musicale, au secondaire. Le programme de musique a maintenant été transféré à l'école Saint-Edmond. Il y a donc une concentration harmonie et une concentration cordes. Dans les concerts donnés par les cordes, il y a surtout des pièces classiques... et assez rarement, des pièces rock. Comfortably Numb était une heureuse exception.
I’ve looked through about 6 billion versions of this song with violins! And you are the ones who got it all right! Even the backing parts excellent! Read solo! Right on point! Friggin brilliant!🎸👨🎤👍
How has this been on RUclips for just under two years without me viewing it??? I thought I'd viewed every video to do with Pink Floyd... So glad I stumbled across this outstanding performance... Awesome....
I watched this video for the first time about 3 years ago and I often find myself coming back. Hats off to such a wonderful song and performance! Love from the United States
It's been a few years since I discovered this video and I still listen to it. Even the London Philharmonic Orchestra doesn't sound as good. I love that you guys stuck to the original melody! 10/10
Thank you, Kai. In fact, Pink Floyd being a classic, I tried to stick as closely as possible to the original. I wanted to serve the classic, and not use the classic to show how I can add something of my own!
Splendide! J’ai souvent vu des jeunes jouer (les deux filles de mon ex, et les enfants de son frère et de sa sœur), et j’ai rarement aimé une performance autant que celle-ci. Bravo!
After a hectic day of work, this is bliss! goose pimples all over and the sheer music envelopes me! This would be the song my pall bearers will play when i am gone!
I'm still listening to this 9 years later. So I must leave a comment to let you know how much I appreciate this piece of brilliance. It's helped me through some of my darkest days, and it still helps.
Ce sont des professeurs comme vous, cher Bertrand, qui font LA différence. Je me considère privilégiée d'avoir été votre élève en 78-79, 79-80. L'inspiration et la curiosité pour la musique sont demeurés très forts depuis! Bonne continuité et bravo à vous et tous vos élèves.
Mille Merci Bertrand pour cette arrangement magnifique ! Encore une autre de tes merveilles ! J'ai adoré jouer cette pièce ! Encore une fois Merci avec un brin de nostalgie ! xoxoxox
Respectfully, it didn't suck. I saw the music flowing in some of you. Hats off to the music instructor. Well done. Remember the spaces of silence between the notes. In conclusion, rise together due to it being part of the performance in addition to acknowledging the conductor which is respect.
I wondered what would happen in the second guitar solo but really liked the arrangement. It reminded me what a melodic genius Gilmore was who after all was said and done stayed pretty comfortably in the blues scale.
I heard the london orchestra before this, i find this way better, maybe its because they are younge, and more free, you can feel they with no strings attached ( no pun intended) this is how you arrange and play a rock song like that, simply epic.
M. Lamoureux, je vous lève mon chapeau! Vous avez fait un excellent travail et je dois vous avouer franchement que je préfère de loin cette version à l'originale. Que dire de ces magnifiques musiciens talentueux!?!?! Kelly et Stephanie vous êtes superbes. Continuer d'évoluer comme vous l'avez fait jusqu'à présent car s'exprimer au travers de la musique est l'un des plus beaux cadeaux que l'on peut souhaiter. Bravo!!!
Great version of one of my favourite songs. Love the way you are playing the guitar solos. The fact that you are using a drummer to guide the piece is in my opinion the best you could have done. Many orchestra's when playing pop/rock songs, do not use a drummer, which quite often ends up in playing the songs too fast or too slow. Chapeau guys!
@@bertrandlamoureux1 Despite the amazing job the violinists did on the lead breaks, it would have been cool to have an electric guitar player in there.
VIVE NOUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Hey hey, je suis content: j'apparais dans la vidéo! (^v^) Merci Bertrand pour ce très bel arrangement. Et au revoir, finissant: votre mémoire resteras toujours présente dans les murs de cette école qui vous a accueillie.
I never imagined that with cellos and violins could be achieve the same spirit of this theme that with the voices of Gilmour and Waters. Simply beautiful.....
Thank you, sir!
Several orchestras also played "Kashmir" (LZ).(my 2nd favourite band after PF) It's great to see these classics played like this.ruclips.net/video/vgvdZsxc8fM/видео.html
WOW! What an amazing performance! I'll bet those students will remember this for a good long time. Absolutely incredible performance by all involved.
Thank you for this lovely comment!
WOW!!!!!!👌👌👌👌😊😊😊😊
I do believe it’s working. Good!
@Anonymous Well played sir (golf clap)
I watched this before but forgot to leave a like. So here i come again.
Thank you!
Yes, it is a high school in Québec (Canada) The school provides a special music program.
Bertrand Lamoureux just beautiful amazing
Poo poo pee pee
A school did this?! Holy Heck!
ou est l'ecole a quebec? je suis a montreal. Si vous fetes un concert, j'aimerais y aller.
@@patricktrudeau2680 Bonjour, Patrick. C'était l'école Mgr A.-M.-Parent, à St-Hubert. Il y avait là une concentration musicale, au secondaire. Le programme de musique a maintenant été transféré à l'école Saint-Edmond. Il y a donc une concentration harmonie et une concentration cordes. Dans les concerts donnés par les cordes, il y a surtout des pièces classiques... et assez rarement, des pièces rock. Comfortably Numb était une heureuse exception.
Hold those notes...this is Pink Floyd.
I’ve looked through about 6 billion versions of this song with violins! And you are the ones who got it all right! Even the backing parts excellent! Read solo! Right on point! Friggin brilliant!🎸👨🎤👍
💯
MERCI AMI, GREAT
pink floyd made the best music ever. kings would have paid to hear them back in the day
Pink Floyd, a classic!
Wonderful, wonderful. Coming from kids, too? Great talent. I admire them.
Absolutely faithful to the source material. A beautiful performance.
Thank you very much!
A most beautiful song regardless of who plays it or how it's played! Pink Floyd!!!!!
Imagine this a couple hundred years ago played by the greats of the day
And it was thrilling to play, too!
How has this been on RUclips for just under two years without me viewing it??? I thought I'd viewed every video to do with Pink Floyd... So glad I stumbled across this outstanding performance... Awesome....
I watched this video for the first time about 3 years ago and I often find myself coming back. Hats off to such a wonderful song and performance! Love from the United States
Thank you so much, Diego.
Bless those music teachers who encourage their students to know Pink Floyd
A classic is a classic!
Wow that guitar solo at the end of the song is beautiful done with the orchestra!!!!!!!!!!!!!! it tears me up every time
Thank you, Sebastiann.
God... It's so beautiful!
A difficult and intricate piece to play and done very well.Hats off to all!
Thank you!
This is way up the list of favorite Floyd songs. You get an A for effort and few extra points to that for delivery.
Thank you, Michael!
best arrangement by far .. you really captured the feeling of the song ..
Superb transcription of the guitar solos for the strings. Glad you didn't shy away from it like the LSO did in their arrangement.
Exactly! Pink Floyd being a classic, you must preserve every note as you would with a Mozart piece!
@@bertrandlamoureux1 Well said!!
It's been a few years since I discovered this video and I still listen to it. Even the London Philharmonic Orchestra doesn't sound as good. I love that you guys stuck to the original melody! 10/10
Thank you, Kai. In fact, Pink Floyd being a classic, I tried to stick as closely as possible to the original. I wanted to serve the classic, and not use the classic to show how I can add something of my own!
When I started listening, it seemed to me to be just average. Once I finished listening, I must say: Best in the galaxy!
Thank you, Michal.
I love it so much. I got goosebumbs of my life. VERYYYY beautiful. I love Pink Floyd so much
Just found today 12/14/24. Fantastic arrangement. Fantastic preparation. Beautiful kids playing their hearts out.
Thank you, Barbara!
SPLENDID!
I love that you were faithful to the solos.
Thank you. Pink Floyd being a classic, we must stick as close as possible to the original!
Splendide! J’ai souvent vu des jeunes jouer (les deux filles de mon ex, et les enfants de son frère et de sa sœur), et j’ai rarement aimé une performance autant que celle-ci. Bravo!
outstanding....and props to the teacher for picking a classic
Pink Floy fabulous band. Virtuose in maximum degree. My respects of Brazil
Bravo Mr. Lamoureux, à tous les jeunes et à Mme. Lapierre. C`est génial!! Félicitations!!
in the words of Jeff Spicoli... "Awesome... totally awesome!" you nailed the beginning and the whole song was beautiful.
Absolutely beautiful. Better than I thought. Getting the vocals and guitar parts down, was brilliant
Thank you so much, Angela!
THANK YOU EVERYONE GIRLS AND BOYS......AND THE DIRECTOR!......YOU TOUCHED MY SOUL...THANK YOU SO MUCH|
Thank you, Marky!
After a hectic day of work, this is bliss! goose pimples all over and the sheer music envelopes me! This would be the song my pall bearers will play when i am gone!
Wow!
I think this performance is far better than the Royal Philharmonic orchestra version. A thousand thumbs up.
I'm still listening to this 9 years later. So I must leave a comment to let you know how much I appreciate this piece of brilliance. It's helped me through some of my darkest days, and it still helps.
Very touching comment, Thank you!
Congrats to this wonderful group of young talents and the teacher that thought this wonderful place of music to them.
Fantastic to see such young talents perform one of my favourite songs. Well done!
Merci!
Ce sont des professeurs comme vous, cher Bertrand, qui font LA différence. Je me considère privilégiée d'avoir été votre élève en 78-79, 79-80. L'inspiration et la curiosité pour la musique sont demeurés très forts depuis! Bonne continuité et bravo à vous et tous vos élèves.
After 10 years of this video out, I just now found this masterpiece! Beautiful! Makes me wanna cry😭❤️
Thank you!!!!!
Это, конечно, нечто выдающиеся. Полсотни скрипок на одну ноту. Великолепное исполнение. Bravo!
Mille Merci Bertrand pour cette arrangement magnifique ! Encore une autre de tes merveilles ! J'ai adoré jouer cette pièce ! Encore une fois Merci avec un brin de nostalgie ! xoxoxox
It`s wonderful. Great interpretation!
+Alexander Pleitez Thank you, M. Pleitez.
Respectfully, it didn't suck. I saw the music flowing in some of you. Hats off to the music instructor. Well done. Remember the spaces of silence between the notes. In conclusion, rise together due to it being part of the performance in addition to acknowledging the conductor which is respect.
Fantastic!!! Well done guys!!!
I wondered what would happen in the second guitar solo but really liked the arrangement. It reminded me what a melodic genius Gilmore was who after all was said and done stayed pretty comfortably in the blues scale.
I listen to this at least once a week. You have composed the best cover of Comfortably Numb I have ever heard
I heard the london orchestra before this, i find this way better, maybe its because they are younge, and more free, you can feel they with no strings attached ( no pun intended) this is how you arrange and play a rock song like that, simply epic.
Thank you so much for your fine commentary!
M. Lamoureux, je vous lève mon chapeau! Vous avez fait un excellent travail et je dois vous avouer franchement que je préfère de loin cette version à l'originale. Que dire de ces magnifiques musiciens talentueux!?!?! Kelly et Stephanie vous êtes superbes. Continuer d'évoluer comme vous l'avez fait jusqu'à présent car s'exprimer au travers de la musique est l'un des plus beaux cadeaux que l'on peut souhaiter.
Bravo!!!
Awesome!
Great version of one of my favourite songs. Love the way you are playing the guitar solos.
The fact that you are using a drummer to guide the piece is in my opinion the best you could have done.
Many orchestra's when playing pop/rock songs, do not use a drummer, which quite often ends up in playing the songs too fast or too slow. Chapeau guys!
Thank you for this fine comment!
I think you’ll find the conductor is the one guiding the piece, not the drummer.
Awesome !!! PF is for ever alive
I just sent this to my sister!! Love ya Mary!!!!!!!
Excellent
Thank you Trinity Orchestra. Just wonderful
Not Trinity?
Well done. Thank you for this wonderful video.
Very rich sounding with the detail and the nuances of the original. Excellent work.
I don´t find the words to describe. Wonderful, marvellous,great,etc.....
Grazias!
BEAUTIFUL ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤MY GOD I LOVE IT. THANK YOU .I'LL BE LISTENING THIS VERSION FOR THE REST OF MY LIFE . I LOVE PINK FLOYD.
Ha ha! Thank you, Oscar!
They played music and words too... so nice!!
Ha visto giusto, signor Fabione. Grazie per il commento tanto giusto!
BRAVO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! well done all of you!!!
Thanks!
this is out of the world WOW. thank you
Thank you, Mohamed!
Thank you so much for your kind commentary.
Fantastique !
WOW that was just simply amazing.
This deserves more views. One of the most beutiful cover ever
Thank you so much, Saul!
Wonderfully done, every note was correct, you should all be proud of yourselves
Thank you very much!
A beautiful performance...Well arranged, finely conducted, and played skillfully by all musicians...AMAZING!!!!
Absolutely beautiful.
Thank you, Mr. Heydorn!
beautiful job.
Thank you!
Bravo, Bravo, stunning, gives us a chance to sing along as we know the words, Thank you.
Excellent. Really liking this arrangement.
Coming through in pleasant waves
how many times i have listened this songs,thanks....a beautiful arrangement,girls and boys
onore ai pink floyd la loro musica sarà immortale eseguita da questa orchestra ha un impatto grandioso veramente immenso grazie pink floyyd
Beautiful work by these kids.
Yes! Thank you!
@@bertrandlamoureux1
Despite the amazing job the violinists did on the lead breaks, it would have been cool to have an electric guitar player in there.
Du tres beau travail, *MERCI* pour le partage.
WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Bookmarking this for lots of play in the future!!
beautiful, beautiful.......very nice. Thank you for the hard work and arrangement.....
Thank you to you.
crazy, crazy, crazy...
without another word, I loved !!!
Simply beautiful...
Thank you very much!
incredible, DG would be so proud
The thrill is back... This is really amazing, oh my Godness!!!
Thanks, Chus!
@@bertrandlamoureux1 this is magnificent my favourite Pink Floyd song. C'est Magnifique Tres bien Bertrand
@@bertrandlamoureux1 I'm from Burlington Ontario
@@robertlongwill8856 Merci, monsieur Longwill!
@@bertrandlamoureux1 keep up the good work Bertrand. Happy New Year to you and your family and all you love
Excellent travaille
Wah wah wah....... amazing interpretation, great "solo" too......; great job really!!!!
Majestic! Absolutely majestic!
Grazias, senor Alejandro!
Sounds fantastic!!!
Thanks!
A very competent performance.
Woww fantastic
Amazing work!
great ! my fav song
Excellent!
VIVE NOUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Hey hey, je suis content: j'apparais dans la vidéo! (^v^) Merci Bertrand pour ce très bel arrangement. Et au revoir, finissant: votre mémoire resteras toujours présente dans les murs de cette école qui vous a accueillie.
I can see Richard Wright smiling from heaven and I think David would say nice tribute!!
Thank you for this amiable remark!
Beautifully done
Merci beaucoup, monsieur Guenste,
C super !!! Très très bon !!! Bravo !
amazing!! only one I have heard with the guitar solo part. perfect!
wow the solo is amazing!