@@mehmedcanozkan3268 , yes, this was a staged thing, but I promise they could set up tracking with this scene and have it look no different. Do you know how lenses work?... computer vision is just a camera, put the cameras back in the shadows, use lenses to get the framing how they need, calibrate the software as to where the positions are, and away they go.
They did a great job making this so dramatic, I guess that's a good thing to gain more table tennis fans but for the already table tennis fans and people who often watch table tennis matches would probably feel unsatisfied.
@@lupusk9productions nah he’s right In the current day and age no machine can beat a decent tt player no matter how elevated the machine is... it’s just too hard Maybe 5 years in the future we could see some exciting machines between humans and machines but for now... not even close
@@lupusk9productions only a person who doesn’t know about tt would say it. Till this moment the only robots who can actually match good players compete just because when you go against them you have to use a special racquet which can track your movements and usually is very slow. A good fast shot and they physically won’t be able to get it back due to their structure
Guys, who told you it was a real match... It was an amazing advertising move by KUKA with a very nice result. I really enjoyed it, and so you probably did. For God's sake you geek, technical, narrow minded guys. You make feel embarassed that we share common interests.
Me da gusto volver a ver este video La primera vez que lo vi recién me estaba adentrando al deporte Hoy después de 6 años lo vuelvo a ver ya sabiéndolo jugar a la perfección 😁
Kuka robotics makes industrial robots mostly. The recent release from Boston Dynamic: the mini robotic dog may play a better game if a metal arm with a butterfly blade and rubber are installed. More important, it has legs. Really scary !
Sorry but I have to disagree with the negative comments. Of course we still don't have technology for that. What I liked is use a charismatic and sportsmanship like Timo Boll plus put table tennis as evidence. Of course the ad could be better, maybe we have to wait another 30 years to have a good machine that can compete with man.
People who didn't read the description may not realise this is an _advertisment_ ... "a vision" ... a "realistic preview". A lot of people in the comments here have assumed this is real ... and the fact that it is not should have been stated more clearly for some. Where is the vision system? How were there so many camera angles (including some mobile) ... yet no camera ever caught sight of another? This is a good example for brushing up on your critical thinking skills, so as to be less likely to become duped in future.
предоставьте оригинальное видео игры с этим немецким теннисистом. смонтированный ролик не интересно смотреть! хотелось бы правдоподобности матча! provide original video games with this German tennis player. mounted video is not fun to watch! I would like to plausibility match!
Timo boll should not make such an edited tt video considering his legendary name unless it is a real game like in a tournament. Legend has its own distinct, Boll ?
Shite! I was waiting soooo eagerly to see this vid thinking (how naively) that they may have made a robot that could at least play a game of table tennis to an approximate human standard. What a massive dissapointment! Robot v Timo, pah! In their defence I'd never heard of Kuka before-hand, so job done in the awareness stakes, however in condemation, their robot is utterly incapabale of performing the task in hand, would'nt want it bulding my jet engines...
pour le robot, je ne sais pas, mais pour le cinéaste vous pouvez le virer. Il n'est pas payé pour nous "faire son cinéma" mais pour retranscrire une action. Un conseil à la direction : pour le prochain film, embauchez une machine.
The people at KUKA have no integrity for doing this. We were all expecting a live match of man vs. machine and instead we get this overly edited bullshit with quick cuts, slow motion and close-ups (used to hide its fakeness) as well as what is supposed to be inspirational music and sound effects to supposedly make it more interesting (name one sport that does that during play) . The people at KUKA who made and marketed this campaign are scumbags.
Common guys, I think it was all clear, that it's gonna be a commercial and nothing special. That it's not real is also clear, it wouldn't be that exiting for the audience with these special effects.
Yea I agree with you but this is the official ITTF channel, they broadcast matches..so,we expected a genuine table tennis match..plus if this were a real table tennis match, I'm sure table tennis would gain more popularity..and as for table tennis lovers like me, we would be more than happy to see something new and exciting..have a good day brother :)
I love watching this while listening to the song Titanium by David Guetta or the one featuring Within Temptation, if anyone wants to see start either song at 0:06 right when they show the man's face, the entire thing is really uplifting =3
People at KUKA are Scumbags? Because you expected something other than you got? Are you serious? Maybe there is a misunderstanding caused by the fact that the clip was posted on this very channel, but: What else could it have been than an ad? A very intelligent one, by the way, because it illustrates very well how precise and fast a robot can be. People who have the smallest inkling about robots KNOW that it's not possible for a machine to play and win against a world class player. But this is an issue of sensor technology, not of a robot's motor abilities. And the latter are to be shown here. Whining and swearing without understanding what you see makes you what? (Insert suitable insult.)
It would be nice to see just one complete point without any of that stupid jump cut editing. Why not also have available a video of the complete match for us real table tennis fans?
they made tony stark's robotic thing with a camera that kept trying to put him out when testing his suit. (dont know its name if it has one) lol. perfect
tsp the ball barely over the net down the line. The robot will most likely not be able to reach that far but if it manages to, no matter where it returns the ball it leave the other side wide open for a smash
Bad placement by Boll. Always short topspins to allow his oponent to play wide angled balls. Summary: This is not Boll, it's another robot in disguise. Someone give that robot a cookie...
False advertising at it's best. They show it as if the robot arm can stand up to a pro player. In reality the robot arm can't play ping pong at any level. It's mostly cgi with a bit of well rehersed movements of the robot arm.
Overedited, all I want is a live game.
its not a real bot its an ad. The computer has no way of seeing the ball lol
@@ethernet389 ...so, there are self-driving cars, and you think there's no way to have a robot arm track a table tennis ball?... fascinating.
@@abates3747 they mean this specific robot lmao, this is just an ad no tracking etc... robot is a programmed actor lmao
@@mehmedcanozkan3268 , yes, this was a staged thing, but I promise they could set up tracking with this scene and have it look no different. Do you know how lenses work?... computer vision is just a camera, put the cameras back in the shadows, use lenses to get the framing how they need, calibrate the software as to where the positions are, and away they go.
@@abates3747 exactly what I wrote, you’re saying they “could”, but I was just saying they didn’t ... ? Don’t know why you’re so confused
Knowing how many lines of coding and men/hours of research there are inside a 6 axes robotic arm, I feel deeply in awe for this video!
They did a great job making this so dramatic, I guess that's a good thing to gain more table tennis fans but for the already table tennis fans and people who often watch table tennis matches would probably feel unsatisfied.
I love the way the robot serves. Btw there is no way a robot can match the speed and randomness of a decent player. At the moment
Now yes
only a person who doesn't understand computers, programming, technology would say that.
@@lupusk9productions yes
@@lupusk9productions nah he’s right
In the current day and age no machine can beat a decent tt player no matter how elevated the machine is... it’s just too hard
Maybe 5 years in the future we could see some exciting machines between humans and machines but for now... not even close
@@lupusk9productions only a person who doesn’t know about tt would say it. Till this moment the only robots who can actually match good players compete just because when you go against them you have to use a special racquet which can track your movements and usually is very slow. A good fast shot and they physically won’t be able to get it back due to their structure
the problem isnt the comercial, it is what they made us belive...
knowing we all where goona spect a real match, not just a fancy commercial
Would have been a better commercial using Forest Gump 🤣
!Excelente video!, buena publicidad, creíble y original, se le abona la creatividad, y Timo Boll muy bien en este interesante reto.
What a production!! that was great!!
Set the video play speed to 0.25 and watch from 1:56. Thank me later.
wait ha completly missed the ball
Super geil produzierte Video. Großes Kino! Und natürlich genialer TT-Spieler :-)
A good video, a little different, but still a good video and great work.
Countless hours of programming. $30,000 for a one arm robot. The look on the human's face after only round two, priceless...
Timo Boll is so great in table tennis I just can't believe he would lose so many marks!
Guys, who told you it was a real match... It was an amazing advertising move by KUKA with a very nice result. I really enjoyed it, and so you probably did. For God's sake you geek, technical, narrow minded guys. You make feel embarassed that we share common interests.
Me da gusto volver a ver este video
La primera vez que lo vi recién me estaba adentrando al deporte Hoy después de 6 años lo vuelvo a ver ya sabiéndolo jugar a la perfección 😁
Привет от Куплинова
Какое совпадение)
Is no one talking about how Timo is flipping the bat to his right hand on two occasions in the first rally?
Kuka robotics makes industrial robots mostly. The recent release from Boston Dynamic: the mini robotic dog may play a better game if a metal arm with a butterfly blade and rubber are installed. More important, it has legs. Really scary !
It was funny!!! Guys from Kuka made good their job. Nice commercial for the table tennis fans.
yeah i knew it was just commercial not a real deal
Sorry but I have to disagree with the negative comments. Of course we still don't have technology for that. What I liked is use a charismatic and sportsmanship like Timo Boll plus put table tennis as evidence. Of course the ad could be better, maybe we have to wait another 30 years to have a good machine that can compete with man.
Wtf is this? O.O this is not a man vs machine match... This is just a crappy ad.
I Have Laughted From The Lucky Scene and The Last Scene XDD!
This may be the best thing I've ever seen in my simple life!!!!
Excelente, eso es control diferencial dinamico jejeje
Music?
Awesome project, but the video is hardly watchable... too many camera moves and changes. That spoils the whole thing.
We know its fake (it's obvious), but the important thing we are forgetting is that we are advancing in technology, step by step.
Memories broken, the truth goes unspoken
"Somewhere on the planet." Come on man, which planet?! Narrow it down for me.
Beide eine klasse für sich
Timo is a two-handed robot)
People who didn't read the description may not realise this is an _advertisment_ ... "a vision" ... a "realistic preview". A lot of people in the comments here have assumed this is real ... and the fact that it is not should have been stated more clearly for some. Where is the vision system? How were there so many camera angles (including some mobile) ... yet no camera ever caught sight of another? This is a good example for brushing up on your critical thinking skills, so as to be less likely to become duped in future.
すごい…。
しかも、最後のはいったい…?
もう一回見ようｗ
Hand-switch-shot at 2:18 :D nice!
Really cool!
Great technology ...
lol timo boll: "inviting me to do this commercial, they drove a dump truck full of money to my front door. i am only human."
Omg the editing.
para mim o timoboll é o melhor do mundo ele é muinto bom
This looks like it suits the theme from Metal Gear, The Only Thing I Know For Real, well.
Epic Video ! :D
Ещё одно объявление и чемпион...отдыхает 🙃
предоставьте оригинальное видео игры с этим немецким теннисистом. смонтированный ролик не интересно смотреть! хотелось бы правдоподобности матча!
provide original video games with this German tennis player. mounted video is not fun to watch! I would like to plausibility match!
Timo boll should not make such an edited tt video considering his legendary name unless it is a real game like in a tournament. Legend has its own distinct, Boll ?
Sorprendente buen vídeo!!
Which racket does the robot use?
KUKA Robot vs KUKA Robot?
Since the game started with the service of Timo Boll, so at 6-0, the Robot should have served instead of Timo Boll. :D
[This comment has been removed because it was too cringy] -2020 me
Yeah, damn dood. Nice catch!!! It's so obvious and not even close. That ball was a good 6 inches to the right of his racket too hahaha
Just set the speed to 0.25 and watch from 1:56.
wish to have one kuka for practice
Muito bom,,sou um mesatenista amador,, e jogo campeonatos regionais
dissapointed it wasn't an actual match... pretty cool vid though...
Programmed robots - yes they can play. But they can never demonstrate the sportsman spirit and emotions which make a game - The game.
Bitana bile Türk yok mu
I find it awesome :c
Foul, Kuka, ball not thrown up off palm of flat hand.
Foul, Kuka, double contact to ball with racket.
Shite! I was waiting soooo eagerly to see this vid thinking (how naively) that they may have made a robot that could at least play a game of table tennis to an approximate human standard. What a massive dissapointment! Robot v Timo, pah! In their defence I'd never heard of Kuka before-hand, so job done in the awareness stakes, however in condemation, their robot is utterly incapabale of performing the task in hand, would'nt want it bulding my jet engines...
Terminator 5 .... Hasta la vista humanity.Unreal
Now I feel stupid for thinking it was real
arkadaşlar hiçbir robot bir insanı yenemez çünkü insan iç güdülerle çalışır robotlar ise kodlarla
pour le robot, je ne sais pas, mais pour le cinéaste vous pouvez le virer. Il n'est pas payé pour nous "faire son cinéma" mais pour retranscrire une action. Un conseil à la direction : pour le prochain film, embauchez une machine.
it Looks like the Robot Hand of Howard Wolowitz from Big Bang Theory
9plk
timo can act:)
What about XU XIN Robot or MA LONG Robot?
Robot is made by humans. Human is made by the God. Robot has no chance, when the human trust in the God
Are they going to make this an anime?
my respect
The people at KUKA have no integrity for doing this. We were all expecting a live match of man vs. machine and instead we get this overly edited bullshit with quick cuts, slow motion and close-ups (used to hide its fakeness) as well as what is supposed to be inspirational music and sound effects to supposedly make it more interesting (name one sport that does that during play) . The people at KUKA who made and marketed this campaign are scumbags.
Totally agree with you! :/ we waited so long just to watch a commercial..disappointing -_-
Common guys, I think it was all clear, that it's gonna be a commercial and nothing special. That it's not real is also clear, it wouldn't be that exiting for the audience with these special effects.
Yea I agree with you but this is the official ITTF channel, they broadcast matches..so,we expected a genuine table tennis match..plus if this were a real table tennis match, I'm sure table tennis would gain more popularity..and as for table tennis lovers like me, we would be more than happy to see something new and exciting..have a good day brother :)
+spiegel
I dont want the engineers of this company....i want the marketing!
I watched this in engineering class
I love watching this while listening to the song Titanium by David Guetta or the one featuring Within Temptation, if anyone wants to see start either song at 0:06 right when they show the man's face, the entire thing is really uplifting =3
*I'M MY OWN MASTER NOW*
This is CG?
Wer ist besser der Mensch oder die Machine?🍳🍳🍳🍳
People at KUKA are Scumbags? Because you expected something other than you got? Are you serious?
Maybe there is a misunderstanding caused by the fact that the clip was posted on this very channel, but: What else could it have been than an ad? A very intelligent one, by the way, because it illustrates very well how precise and fast a robot can be.
People who have the smallest inkling about robots KNOW that it's not possible for a machine to play and win against a world class player. But this is an issue of sensor technology, not of a robot's motor abilities. And the latter are to be shown here.
Whining and swearing without understanding what you see makes you what? (Insert suitable insult.)
Bruce Lee playing tabletennis with nunchucks is more real..
Камеру к руке надо было привязать
It would be nice to see just one complete point without any of that stupid jump cut editing. Why not also have available a video of the complete match for us real table tennis fans?
because it's not real
, x m
they made tony stark's robotic thing with a camera that kept trying to put him out when testing his suit. (dont know its name if it has one) lol. perfect
i'm so glad noone has thought of putting a gun on the robot haha right?
KUKA on suomalainen?
More dramatic it is, less effective this is.
Do the short ball
The robot's serve though
If only they shot this with more camera angles.
Muy malo el video, bastaba dejar la cámara fija para poder apreciar bien el juego.- El de la cámara quería demostrar lo hábil que es con ella?
tsp the ball barely over the net down the line. The robot will most likely not be able to reach that far but if it manages to, no matter where it returns the ball it leave the other side wide open for a smash
0:10 what it is called.. anybody please tell
no sweat, no shout.... duhh
Bad placement by Boll. Always short topspins to allow his oponent to play wide angled balls.
Summary: This is not Boll, it's another robot in disguise.
Someone give that robot a cookie...
Not fair. The robotic arm should be able to stretch higher, lower, longer, shorter. Now you bully it. It may annihilate humanity in the near future.
Remember, this is a stationary robot.
False advertising at it's best. They show it as if the robot arm can stand up to a pro player. In reality the robot arm can't play ping pong at any level. It's mostly cgi with a bit of well rehersed movements of the robot arm.
No robot can deal with long pips.
Long live the table tennis hackers \o/
why do i here mvm music?
Demi-God & Sharigan mode 3:31 damn
Hi i know you are watching at 2030
日本でCMとして流してほしい(・Д・)ノ
Bravo boll na to liczylem
Have a migraine after all the video cuts
to much editing not real yet