Harmony of the Seas Passenger Accused of Aging 23 Years in Six Days | Jennifer Heath Box Analysis
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024
- This video answers the question: Can I analyze case of Jennifer Heath Box?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
Dr. Grande’s book Harm Reduction:
www.amazon.com...
Dr. Grande's book Psychology of Notorious Serial Killers: www.amazon.com...
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/...
What a terrible experience for an innocent person, and such a callous officer. I hope she wins the lawsuit.
same, and hope shes doesnt to the NDA version of the out of court settlement, where they bury the incident
If he's not capable of reviewing his own actions and changing course when wrong then he definitely doesn't belong being a cop. He should be fired.
Agreed. She needs a good attorney and at the very least, settle out of court for a good amount. Also, that officer needs to be suspended without pay for a couple of weeks, at the very least. Fired at the most. I'd have PTSD as well.
Looks like racism, and/or just deviant/sadistic behavior.
**Me too,
such abuse of law enforcement's power, as many Black men and Black boys, well know**
'the words on a warrant are not just decorative, they actually have meaning'🤣
Yeah!🤣😂
Wow the incompetence is staggering. Why did the police treat this lady with such disdain? Are they that hubris that they couldn’t pause for one moment to check their facts?
These people lack common decency and good manners, something that gets taught at home if you’re raised right.
Police treat people like this all the time. This happens more often than you think
**You're correct**
It's not incompetence, it's the rest of the officers going along with a bully
Dumber than a box of donuts.....
Good grief. As the victim of an incorrect arrest myself, I can relate to how poor Jennifer must have felt. Totally devastating 😮😮
Oh man. That is one of my biggest fears! Glad you seem okay!
If the detainment were short, it could be considered an accident. But, she was held for days so the police should be held accountable.
Over Christmas.
Police ego. They think they are right even if every bit of evidence says otherwise.
Accident? How about gross stupidity?
Hard to call it an acident when the victim and suspect have completely diferent caracteristics
Or gross negligence if you want to use official law type lingo lol@@Gary-u8r
Adding insult to injury, even after they admitted their mistake they were going to hold her in jail until her home county authorities could pick her up. Ridiculous.
This problem rises above the original error. The original can be explained with stupidity or evil of low level participants. The decision to continue holding her was made by people with even more power and responsibility.
They threatened to hold her for 30 days, to boot. Absolutely vile.
As a police man’s daughter, I hate dirty, arrogant cops. It gives the good cops a bad name. I hope she gets justice.
8 cops involved and not a single one helped her. The county knew they had the wrong person, and no one helped. No such thing as a good cop, all 🐷
She won't get justice but, she will get a large settlement! 😂😂😂
ACAB. Police forces see society as an opposing force that they are against.
Wow. She deserves a SIGNIFICANT settlement. This is inexcusable.
Incompetent and sloppy police work. Officers 1000% should be held responsible. That poor woman, and during the Christmas holidays where she should have been spending time with loved ones.
Qualified Immunity 🙃
That's not police work. That's badged bully baloney.
@@poindextertunesThat should not apply here. He’s either corrupt or incompetent. Those two situations are not supposed to be covered by qualified immunity.
I worked in security dealing with the police on occasion and I came to realize that young men, and women should not be police officers. I don't know if this officer in this case was all that young or not but he definitely fits the maturity level of too gung-ho
She was obviously the wrong person. All the officers who touched this case are culpable. No basic critical thinking. Peter is a public menace, he knew what he was doing.
Seems likely. 10 thousand dollar question: why?
@@Lisa-x3n5x She spurned his advances.....
Dr. Grande hit a grand slam on this one.
a grande slam
@@isaactuuri6488knot bad.
I have had multiple negative experiences in Florida with Law Enforcement. The main problem was People NOT doing their job correctly. Several of these experiences were for child support, I even lost a truck driving job because after I had paid child support the records were falsely showing they were unpaid. Florida suspended my Class A CDL license several times and I was let go. One time I even had the receipt and showed it to a police officer. He said "sorry, my hands are tied". This was so maddening because I was the one in cuffs!!!!
How can you pay what you owe if you can't work? STUPID!
Not to make light of your ordeal, because it sounds horrible and was completely unjust, but it could be turned into a chart-topping country song "The sheriff said his hands were tied, but I was the one in the 'cuffs!"
It must have been scary for her. These police officers were incompetent and should be held accountable. Have a great weekend, Dr Grande 😊❤
They knew she was the wrong woman, but said she needed to stay in custody until they caught the right woman!? That has to be illegal.
Yes! It's called the Fourth Amendment to the US Constitution...
yes--complete bull-shit.
This is some North Korean shit right there. These cops would have made good Stasi members.
The people that hire and do not evaluate these idiots, should be held accountable also, and fired!
you wouldn't have many left at this point...they're already short
@@brucesmith1544 how short could they be if they sent eight (8 - think about that) armed officers to arrest a 5’-4”, 50+ year old woman on a cruse ship? Did the watch commander think; ‘well I know they are all stupid, but maybe if I send eight, someone will get something right?’
there are not idiots they are Evil, they knew exactly what they were doing, they got a bonus for arresting her, they did it for money, they knew she was not the right person, but i guess they are idiots because they did not realize they could not keep this up for long.
its common knowledge that LEO/PD departments are notorious for not hiring people with common sense, its all about hubris and lack of accountability
The taxpayers are always paying for police misconduct.
Some day, all the parties will know each other, know what they are doing, and scam the tax payers.
This is negligence
@@KingfishStevens-di9jiit’s a crime, not negligence. Knowingly imprisoning innocent people is a violation of their human rights
This is why I agree with Libertarians on ending qualified immunity.
One thing you can say about Dr. Grande: Fame hasn't changed him.
That's why we like him.
Wait. He’s famous now??
What fame? Did he do something ?
How do you know? You only see his RUclips persona.
I think they mean his following -- over a million
Professional should mean being held accountable
Dr. Grande, I don't know where you find the time to upload daily videos and still practice. Keep up the good work.
I think there's a good chance that when he moved on from educational videos, he probably employed a researcher, writer and editor (and likely other people I am not aware are needed for this type of video production). I would guess that he still gives input as a doctor and as the channel host, then records these videos, perhaps in batches. That may give him enough freedom to at least have a part time private practice. Just guessing, of course - and *hoping* he isn't worked to the bone doing both.
@whelkpeopleofdoom yes you can schedule your videos for release in advance ie Friday, do 3, Saturday do 3, Sunday do 1 release from Monday to Friday. Rinse, repeat. Just a guess. 😊
Yes dude. Any normal employee at any company would be fired. No qualified immunity. You still have to pay attention and do quality work.
I just came back from Europe. I was pulled out of the customs line in Chicago. They took me to an office and asked me all kinds of questions and took my picture a number of times. Nobody would tell me why I was being questioned. They asked for another form of ID, which I provided. After like 30 scary minutes, they finally released me. Not anywhere near as horrible as Jennifer's situation, but crazy for me, nonetheless!
Wow. Did they ever say why?
That's awful and sounds criminal on their part.
It’s legal 😳
should have snuck in from the south, you would have gotten a 150K loan and a debit card
Usually people from different land migration ilgail or rafugess because European land full of those people
Broward county sherrifs dept are an absolute nightmare to deal with. I used to work out of port everglades on a ship and they were always making life unnecessarily difficult for us.
“I’m sorry, it happens..”
Its like they were trying to rub salt in the wound smh 😒
It's like how dismissive could they be?
Its disturbing what police get away with.
As a retired officer, this case makes my skin crawl.
… please, as if you haven’t done the same .. or worse.
You understand why it happens out of spite rather than just Peter protecting his ego of insisting on going forward with the arrest when he knew the suspects details were inaccurate, though. It'd be more like Peter didn't feel like he receives adequate regard from the citizens he deals with combined with the feelings that the support from his superiors whenever he relied on them was never available, has influenced how he passive aggressively acts in his Police work..
@@richardhart9204that’s a nasty comment. You don’t know this person there are good cops you know. Just like there are good people. You suspicion leads me to posture that you may be a bad person to be so vehemently cynical. A changed attitude would enhance you state of well being. Cheers from Montreal
@@carpathianken … what?
As a retired cop you clearly know that way worse gets covered up to cover people's asses.
For me, this is malice, not merely incompetence. I hope she wins her case and another internal investigation is required for the suit. Hopefully, the Sherrif will go this time.
It is very devastating how our life events often depend of ignorant,
uneducated , incompetent self - righteous individuals.
Thanks for bringing this to our attention, as we all Will Remember
to avoid this location. Greetings from Canada
that's fn disgusting and the grossest part (if there is such a thing) is the sheriff's office defending this. wow. absolutely disgusting.
Bravo Dr. Grande! One of your best in illustrating the incompetency of law enforcement in the U.S.
They are so used to getting away with stuff like this, that people's rights are beneath them. They knew but didn't care is the simple truth.
There are few things worse than trying to reason with a bureaucracy. Once the system says something, it's like everyone in the system just turns into an effin' drone and cannot imagine a mistake was made. Just wait until A.I. is implemented everywhere and people think that the system is absolutely infallible.
I'm not sure what fair compensation looks like this this case, but she certainly deserves a considerable sum.
They should have run her fingerprints since there was a discrepancy with her driver's license. It's unacceptable that no one was punished. If I had made a mistake like this as a nurse, I would have gotten a written warning, even if no one was harmed. Since detention threatens lives, police officers who don't verify identities properly should be punished, and be fired if they repeat the behavior.
So as usual, the Broward County Sheriffs Dept [investigated Itself] and found no wrong doing.
May she be very bountifully compensated!!! “I’m sorry, it happens.” omg
The words on the warrant are not just decorative 🤣🤣🤣 Love you Dr. Grande!
I’m sorry to say it, but America’s government is failing at all levels.
yup, our local PD and sherif here are solid organizations and people, but it makes sadly not a lot of impact because we have liberal judges and DA here, so nothing ever gets handled right
Liberal judges? That just reductive thinking.
@@isaactuuri6488 Our sheriff just resigned in an accounting fraud scandal but likely won’t be prosecuted. Most of the deputies seem ok, and hopefully the sheriff’s replacement will be, but the county prosecutor is corrupt as hell. Circuit judges and state police are not much better.
Police departments have been failing for centuries. It's just very recently they're being held remotely or occasionally accountable.
We live in a world where most of us have the collective knowledge of humanity and a high definition camera in our pockets but the Florida police can't figure out if they have the right person? Ridiculous!
Since Desantis became Governor the police standards have dropped significantly. They can basically do whatever they want without any fear of consequences.
Dr. Grande throwing shade at Carnaval Cruises!
@cameltrophy3 😂🚢😎👍
Aww Carnival isn't that bad 😂😂
Fun
They get free advertising 😂
How humiliating.
There is so much corruption in this sheriff’s department that it’s laughable that they pretend to be law enforcement officers.
On separate occasions, I was arrested for trespassing on my own property and breaking and entering my own house, of which I was the sole owner. These are not crimes in my state, according to a plain reading of the applicable statutes. The charges were eventually dismissed -- after I paid an attorney thousands of dollars. The arresting cops suffered no consequences for their violations of my civil rights.
One of the most bizarre elements of this egregious case is that the jail appears to be running a torture regime. Why is this not causing an outrage? Are Americans really so desensitised to brutality in their criminal justice system?
Dr. Grande's analysis here is extremely satisfying. 👍👍
Nah, he left out a key point, how did Broward County find Mrs. Box anyway, based only on her picture? Are they using facial recognition software to scan cruise passengers?
One other thing , the Agency issueing the warrant has the liability to make sure the warrant is correct. She needs to sue them, they are liable.
I agree
This seems to accurately reflect the competence of the entire American modern justice system as of lately.
I appreciate your optimism but it’s always been this way.
@@DottieMinervaI sobered up in 2014. Been questioning that decision ever since.
All systems are this incompetent. Of course that the CJS is, is the most dangerous to the average person.
"This was Royal Caribbean, not Carnival" 😂😂😂😂😂
Facts facts facts 💯
Larping officers.
IMO they pretended to read the warrant but only checked the picture.
They can't admit that.
They most definitely should be held accountable there is no reason for it to take several days to find out they made a mistake.
I agree with you about Princess Cruise lines. I took my first & LAST cruise on Princess. It was a horrible experience
the "they followed procedure correctly" excuse/argument merely points to the underlying systemic problems with American policing
Florida is especially backwards.
This is a scary case, incompetence and arrogance and no consequences...
Thank you for the analysis on this case, Dr. Grande!
Dr. Grande’s sarcasms and dark humor were his hidden talents not displayed unabashedly🤣👍👏
There's a saying in the law enforcement business that the customer is always wrong.
This poor woman! So nice to see an analysis on a crime I wasn’t aware of. TY Dr. Your so hysterical Dr😊🙏🙏🙏Blessing’s
Keep backing that blue till it happens to you.
Good evening Dr. Grande, thank you for your informative analysis on this extremely scary case of how a misuse of power, and a lack of police work. I feel so bad for Jennifer. What a way to end a cruise, and spend Christmas day! I always sincerely appreciate your humor 😂
Can you cover the recent case of a Kentucky sheriff that shot and killed a judge in his own chambers in an upcoming video?
Just woke up from my nap.
What a treat to have Dr. Grandes video ready for Me to listen too.
Always interesting
Thank you❤
Poor Chick!! Yes they should be held accountable
I grew up in Broward. It was corrupt 30+ years ago. Some of the things I witnessed most wouldn't believe, so I'll save it, but yeah, the (BSO) particularly were the worst dealing with with so I see nothing has changed.
Absolutely outrageous. Peter should get the sack and never work in crime investigation again
These are the people we pay to Protect and Serve us, folks. Let that sink in.
They booked her for the overtime pay.
People with active warrants almost always tell LEOs they have the wrong person. Once they verified with fingerprints that she was NOT a match she should have been released immediately. So it sounds like she has a good lawsuit. Also it's common for criminals to jumble their names around on various IDs. So warrants aren't always name matches. She should have been fingerprinted at the jail and then released when she wasn't a match. Also Not matching the physical description is kinda a dead giveaway... She has a good lawsuit. The photo match on the warrant is a problem for her case. But still fingerprints should have cleared her.
Wait a minute. WHAT triggered the search of her name?! She went on a cruise. WHY were they searching her background AFTER the cruise? What set this off? Are the cruise lines taking peoples money, getting people onboard and THEN doing background checks? This means cruise lines are collaborating with law enforcement but making sure they get that money first and reporting AFTER the cruise is over.
I bet it was some kind of AI system that flagged her because her photo was on the warrant. It was probably facial recognition that notified police
This is the question that is not answered. Either Broward Co. or Royal Caribbean are using some Facial Recognition software on Cruise Passengers. Is the PUBLIC being TOLD?
@marlenestewart7442 I'm pretty sure the last cruise I went on they used facial recognition while we were disembarking, but did they tell us that they were feeding that info to the police, I doubt it.
Just wait until they start arresting people at self check outs or while walking through a mall. It's coming. They use facial recognition everywhere now.
@marlenestewart7442 just wait until they start arresting people at the self check outs of Walmart & stuff like that. It's coming.
@marlenestewart7442 this is wild. My comment has been deleted twice because of a certain thing I am saying. Let's try again.. they used facial recognition on my last cruise while we were disembarking (and I think during port stops), but did they tell us that police would have access? I don't remember.
This will become more & more common.
You gotta love Dr. Grande’s dry sense of humor 🤣
I love it. One of the best episodes you have produced so far Dr g!
I have a very common name and this sort of false arrest is a genuine concern of mine, particularly if they discount things like height and age!
I’ve heard several stories like this recently. THIS is why so many people don’t trust the police. There’s some shady people in there.
Peraza was charged with manslaughter in 2021 as well. Seems like he’s not cut out to be in his position
Not every cop is bad, but any cop can be. Even when you do absolutely nothing wrong....
Disagree, ALL cops are bad. No good person would ever be one.
Dr. Grande, stay out of Broward County... they won't let you leave.
Do a article on Sheriff Greg Tony. 🚔 BSO
Good job, Todd, I've been waiting for you to tap-into the criminal injustice system
I was in the shower listening to this and thought, “how haven’t I heard about this, it has to be old. How terrifying that would be in todays world” and then when I got out I saw it was 3 hours old.
One of my biggest fears is being blamed for something I didn’t do. This is terrifying
Case of carly gregg soon please thanks.
After having lived in Broward County for a few years I’m certainly not surprised that the cops were soo incompetent. I’ve met some of them.
"The words are not decorative..." 😂
Not falsely detained. Kidnapped at gun point, held hostage, strip searched, tortured with blasted music and cold air for multiple days. I am pro-cop but are you kidding me!
DAMM! arresting a woman who looks great in tight jeans!!! A CRIME MOST FOUL!!
Dr. Grande, You should look for more material out of the Broward County Sheriff's Department. I passed through there once, ONCE. On that ONE trip, I was pulled over twice because of my out of state plates, both times hasseled about why I was in Florida. They're the most corrupt, incompetent fools in law enforcement, second only to Louisville Metro.
See Sheriff Greg Tony. BSO. He has 60+ staff under IRS, PPP crimes-fraud.
Excellent title! 💎
Thank you again Dr. Grande
Clerk of Courts lady in Houston, call her tell her nicely why she should not work there anymore.
These cops had more devious intentions with this woman i believe.
Please return to the third grade to learn grammar.
@@lesliewoinarowicz7018 Meanwhile maybe you should go back to kindergarden to learn basic kindness.
@@lesliewoinarowicz7018 what Grammer do you refer to ?
"No amount of evidence will ever persuade an idiot" Mark Twain. Yet the amount of evidence that Box is the wrong person was not enough to convince Paraza and the other county deputies.
As a massive death metal fan, I have always been curious what sort of reaction I would get if I ever found myself in a situation wherein I was detained and the people detaining me were attempting to use my favorite genre of music to deprive me of sleep.
You gotta 🤘
Never having taken a Carnival Cruise but hearing plent of scuttlebutt about them...but having taken many Royal Caribbean crossing to Europe I can attest. at least Royal is very relaxing amd I look YOUNGER when I disembark. NOT OLDER! This woman SHOULD win her suit!!!
Love the shade to Carnival Cruises
What type of sick powertrip were these officers on? And why the piping in of music? She was being held on a warrant from another state - not like they were trying to get any info out of her. Plus - are there no other crimes they SHOULD be investigating? Alarming and scary!!!
Guilty of contempt of cop perhaps. No talking back ... even if you are the wrong perp!😂
BCSO: Corruption is job 1.
If she would have just confessed- she would have been released earlier.
This is one of the reasons why the public has lost trust in the justice system. It's actually terrifying to consider that this goes on every single day, all across the country. I'm sorry, it happens.... Not a sentence one ever wants to hear from a weapon wielding public servant.
This happen to a good friend of mine. Even his PD ignored the fact that he was not the guy they thought they arrested. They shared first names but the last name was his middle name. Birthdays were different too. None of this seemed to matter BUT Luckily he was black and the criminal was white. Which my friend had to discover on his own at arraignment. Even then they didn’t want to let him go. They kept asking you sure it’s not you.
Ha! Not surprised!….. I am a Broward resident myself…. A few years about I had a legal whoopsie, and had to deal with the Broward County Sherif’s Office….. biggest bunch of nasty, inept, smug clowns….
I saw this case somewhere previously. Clearly negligent on all of the officers parts for not speaking up after examining the warrant and finding conflicting data between the two subjects. Then allowing the arrest to go forward. Then, Typical government fox guarding the hen house, we investigate ourselves and find no wrongdoing. I guess they believe if they find no wrongdoing it absolves them of liability. The most dangerous part of this is, as you stated, this guy Peter is still out there making mistakes with impunity, and no fear of being held accountable. Sounds like Freemasonry at work behind the scenes to me. Hope she wins a large settlement for her trouble and even more for the lack of an apology. We know cops never admit they were wrong.
Thank you for this interesting and informative video, Dr. Grande.❤ I always get a lot from your videos. They mean a lot to us.
I love in Galveston county but I work mostly in Harris county the guards and the police will never admit to errors and errors happen all the time. I feel so bad for Jennifer because the officers refused to do the correct thing even though she was falsely identified. It take me so much to prove an error on police reports arrests etc.
This all came down to facial recognition software. When her photo was placed on the paperwork in Texas, Jennifer's nightmare began. She should be suing both departments. It will settle out of court. Ridiculous.
I was thinking of a cruise,but doesn’t sound very relaxing.i’ve been wrongfully arrested 3 times as it is.What a nightmare for her! ❤
Dude just mercilessly roasted an entire county lol. I wonder how many county employees and Broward County residents have seen this.
I like this one ! A bit of lightness for the weekend !