Why China wants to take India's territory | India's geopolitical dilemma (2/3) | DW Analysis
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 сен 2024
- India and China are locked in the world’s biggest territorial dispute, with Beijing even claiming control of an entire Indian state. At least 20 Indian soldiers were killed in the most recent clashes, and experts warn that the two giant neighbours could end up in a war. The West is paying little attention.
In Part 2 of “India’s Choice,” a special series on the geopolitical dilemmas facing India, DW’s Richard Walker explains just how dangerous the threat from China has become - with the help of one of India’s leading military experts - and the choices facing the leadership in Delhi in how to deal with it.
Featuring interviews with Jay Panda, Vice President of India’s ruling BJP, Shashi Tharoor of the opposition Congress, military expert Sushant Singh of the Centre for Policy Research, former Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott, Tobias Lindner, Minister of State in the German Foreign Office, Lisa Curtis, former Senior Director, US National Security Council, and Garima Mohan of the German Marshall Fund.
Subscribe: www.youtube.co...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#IndiasDilemma #India #Russia
Episode 3 - Why India & the West are weary of each other ruclips.net/video/OshZy7fhJKo/видео.html
The biggest duty of the western media is to create chaos, create contradictions and incite hatred. Now German media are worried that India and China stand together, so they re-amplify some contradictions between China and India, and stop the unity between China and India. They can't wait to stop the peace between China and India. Westerners want to see the war between China and India, once it happens, which will hit China, but westerners never care about the lives of Indians.
Western countries, led by the United States, are trying to sow discord among other countries and prevent their unity and cooperation. The United States is trying to create chaos among other countries and cover up all the chaos within the American border with the international community. The evil expansionism and imperialism of the United States and the West are prevalent, and extreme belligerence and advocating violence have become the mainstream thoughts of the whole western world.
Please show about Pakistan
Why is your reporting so unbalanced and prejudiced?
*A balanced approach is a norm of journalism, isn't it?*
Where is first part?
Key advice, never let the Brits draw your border.
what would of been the solution then? mr know it all..
🇮🇳 is a morden Country, there was no 🇮🇳 in history, more like a sub-continent with hundred of Countries. the border conflict only between British Raj and PRC.
@@wm4934 A Chinese who makes inferior products speaks volumes😂🤢
Pakistan and East Pakistan (Bangladesh) were the biggest land partitions for India and they are still contesting over Kashmir, which has been the subject of a dispute between India and Pakistan since 1947, and between India and China since 1962.. This piece of journalism needed to deliver to the audience the entire historical context and not just tunnel vision.
Divide and conquer.
There is no point in US pretending to be India's ally while having immense trade relationships with China because that's financially convenient for USA. If you really want to strengthen India to counter China, increase trade with India, instead of using the conflict to only expand military relations and sell weapons. That's the reason why the relations with US is still lukewarm
Why should US support India when India supports no one? Selfish people should be left alone. India should defend itself ALONE from China. One thing for sure, Russia will not help India against China because Russia is loyal to China, not India. 😂
@@davidc9214 Well we have been doing that for a while now, as there was no one supporting India except Russia so far....we have seen several wars with both Pakistan and China, and the only thing US did was, supply arms to Pakistan, position nuclear equipped ships at Indian Ocean, deny India geopositioning data of cross border infiltration, sanction India for developing its own nuclear weapon, threatened Russia with sanction to stop them from sharing technology with India for developing cryogenic rocket engine.
So there is no point in asking why India didn't allign with anyone in a war to protect territory with nuclear deposits where prominent US politicians have invested (Biden son)....
Why would Indian get into some one else's war, especially when that someone had till recently a hostile track record against India?First let's see if USA does anything to redeem itself for its past positions and can prove that it actually do indeed see India as an ally.
Biden himself was the author of the bill that threatened sanctions on Russia for sharing space tech with India...Why should India join a war to protect that same Biden's nuclear resource interest, and fight against a historically consistent ally that has helped India immensely to make technical advancement as well as against Chinese aggression?
You are telling Indian to fight against the same nation that has helped India to check China so far, that to by saying we should trust the country who has always sided against Indian interest to counter China. Russia has already done for India, what you claim India should trust US would do in future, especially when USA's track record as a dependable ally is extremely questionable
@@aleenaprasannan2146 Russia always prefers china.if any war erupted don't scream for help
@@killercell2472 Don't know the history that Russia and China have territorial disputes between them? China has the same obsessive compulsive 'land grabbing' tendency with whoever shares a border with them. If their is a war between China and Russia...Russia actually have a reason to side with India to get its rightful land back from China, meanwhile it wouldn't want India to approach USA because that means US defense would then expand as far till the Andaman islands. Russia wouldn't want the only thing between it and USA, to be the land grabbing China.
@@killercell2472 If there is anything consistent in geopolitical history, it's that allying for one war is never a guarantee for future wars. USA is not going to get to attack Russia from Chinese territory whether Russia sides with China or not. However, if Russia does not aid India in resisting China it is a sure shot that India will approach USA and USA is waiting eagerly just for that. That will not only bring US military right under Russia's nose and it will also force Russia to be much more compliant to with China. Having only one shaky neighbor to rely on is disempowering even for Russia.
My company employs around 5,000 contractors in India across a huge number of departments and on the whole working with them has always been incredibly successful. My department actually has a dedicated dev team that we work with in Bangalore and they have never been anything short of incredibly talented, hard working, and kind. I think most Americans who work in business would have a number of stories about extremely positive, productive relationships that we have with contractors and coworkers in India.
What it has to do with China wanting Indian territories?
@@sajjadkkl they are killing cutmullas in India..
@Robo Redneck true commenting things with no relation to the video
@@sajjadkkl I think indians are not intoxicated by religions .
To Kya Nachu mein...hehehe
"India needs powerful friends to help it deal with China"....and who will it be...the Americans who cannot make up their mind over how to defend Taiwan or whether to abandon them as they did with Ukraine or for that matter the Europeans who are heavily dependent on Russian energy as well as trade with China for their own economic well being. Seems like India is on its own and the irritation for West is that Indians know they are on their own and Indians do not hope for a "powerful friend" to come to their rescue when such a time comes.
India does have a powerful friend called Russia.
@@petehagen4794 no , Russia is also friend of China , the most Russia can do is stay neutral .
@@archismaanrudra876 I agree.
@Aman Jha Forget about "Journey to the West," China is officially an atheistic state today. Is India atheistic as well? Also, deception and duplicity are engrained in Chinese civilization. Is that true for India as well?
@@petehagen4794 Russia not going to help India against china. Indian government knows that Indian citizens knows that some of them just don't want to admit because communist influence still working here
No matter if we are friends of India or foe, we always end up harming India's interest and strengthening China's.
This needs to change asap
Also I don't believe China's death toll of 4, Russian, Indian and even Americans put it at 35-40 soldiers
India would benefit to ally itself with Western democracies. China is heading towards a economic/democraphic meltdown and India could take Chinas place as the worlds manufacturer.
@@FRIPPE_THE_GREAT just dream in sleeping/haha/
@@FRIPPE_THE_GREAT I think India is aligned with the west but I don’t think they would want a formal military alliance with us just yet. Maybe in the future but that depends on how much support we give to India
@@Alanom2007 alligned with the west? do you consider Russian supporting countries alligned with the west?
@@Maplelust Your comment indicates your poor knowledge of geopolitics. India is a ally against China and the only country which can balance China in Asia. India’s position on Russia is due to history and their weapons dependence on Russia.
The real threat is China not Russia, the sooner you realize the more chance we have of defending western values and democracy as we know it
As an American, I've always been confused by the chilliness of India's relations with my country. We ought to be natural allies, but American diplomatic overtures to India have been severely lacking
Clearly you are ignorant of India's history.
India looks out for India. Don’t mistake short term friends with long term friends
so many Mexicain lands were annexed by USA, and Canada has burnes White House,
US have only two land neighbours, but China has more than 10,
Thats bcz US expects India too to clap on it's Hypocrisy just like Europe does.
@Earthling Sanctioned them with tax exceptions?
After working in customer service, and dealing closely with Indian partners I developed a deep respect for many of them. They deal with an immense level of disrespect and racism and work harder for far less. I am far from one who claims to see racism everywhere. I only say that because I personally witnessed it on a near daily basis. And over 8 years, not a SINGLE time, did my Indian colleagues snap or become confrontational. They always performed their job admirably and professionally. I nolonger work at that company, but I often look to those interactions as an example for myself when I encounter difficult situations in my life. Special people indeed.
They didn't snap because they couldn't. If they said something back or complained to someone they could lose their jobs and be deported.
Maybe the immense level of disrespect they deal with has something to do with the Scam Call Centres from India that are constantly reaching out to try and steal from North American seniors and vulnerable people. On a regular day, I get 4-5 calls claiming to be: The Canadian Revenue Agency, Credit Card Company or whatever the scam is that week. So at least from me, it's an instant hang up as soon as I hear the magic words. If they want to be harassing and stealing from people on the other side of the world, it's bound to have a negative response.
That being said, I condemn any racist comments and attitudes when dealing with them.
@@Sr.ChilePepper We hate those scammers too. They started scamming us (and still do) before they realised that scamming westerners was easier (because they weren't used to scammers like we are) and more profitable. So yeah hang up on the scammers.
Lol they are nice Indian ppl but most now days are just Hindutva extremist fascist . India is being ruined by Modi
@@thechosenone1533 well than it's very unfortunate, they should snap, jobs are everywhere and no job is greater than the dignity and self respect of a human being . Westerners are not doing any favours to Indians, they work hard and professionally, I think racism should be dealt with strongly, your comment suggest a colonial mindset, people like you should also be dealt with appropriately.
People of Arunachal are proudly indian .. despite there is racism and poverty problem in india ..our people are only ours ....
North east is our brothers and sisters. We are a family. And families do fight. But blood is thicker than wTer and family first
Good thing u acknowledged that...so u would also know that racism in India is only in the surface...
Ones race skin colour will never determine his fate in India..it will be skill and anyone is welcome in any part of India provided they have the skills ...
BTW I hv seen thousands from the East working down south in blue collared jobs for over a decade..
Most of them runaways from homes for reasons known to them
But they look more like chinese than Narindra Modi.
@@yamdood1 there not only Chinese in the east asia...there are many mongoloids country...even it is called mongoloids not Chinese...learn more before comment...
@@yamdood1 chinese is not the term buddy, it's mongoloid
Yes they are part or full mongoloids
So what?
I don't know when the West will understand that india is not seeking Russian support against China like it did in 1971. What IND wants is Russian neutrality during conflict. Ind should try to reassure the neutrality of Russia even if USA or its allies get involved in the India- China conflict.
they try to spin doctor these viewpoints, making India seem like the nation needs help from the West. Fact is, India hasn't needed help from the West for more than 2 centuries, and has never received help from the West.
You said the truth which is misunderstood by western people
Lets ask this question. Who helped China gain such a big economic power?
Obviously you need money to get this far, but who's to blame about the help given to China?
I remember few good years back where almost all world big companies rushed to China to increase their profits and in exchange they passed over to Chinese a lot a technology which China didn't possess but now they do and are making it better.
你显然缺乏最基础的政治经济学基础知识，国家的发展有内因和外因，内因起主导作用，外因起辅助作用，中国人本身的勤劳、聪明、坚毅，才是助推中国经济发展的主要动力，1949年-1976年之间，虽然有政治运动，但中国依然建立起了完善全面的工业基础，文盲率低于2%，劳动力文盲率＝0%，有完善的交通和通信基础设施，这些为中国的改革开放提供了充足的准备，将中国的发展简单定义为外国的帮助是既幼稚又白痴的想法，你们对中国的全方位误判将会使你们在与中国的竞争中处于极大的劣势中，孙子曰：知己知彼百战不殆，你们不了解中国却还想和中国竞争，你们迟早会被中国消灭掉
@@大毛猪乔治 yes China had its own industry but with the help of developmed countries manged to upgrade, modernize dhe even multiply that industry.
Tons of studies show just that. The Chinese economic growth started soaring around year 2000.
Around 2002 foreign investment flooded into the country.
That's a big WELL DONE from the Chinese government to manage to attract so many foreign investment which other countries do dream of having even today.
@@大毛猪乔治 Very insightful perspective. I think the world would be a much better place if China was a free and democratic country.
@@RAFCMC702 I disagree.
If China took your preferred route the country would be in tatters and Balkanized.
Knowing how sadistic westerns are i can see that its your preferred outcome
you got a good point here,
Recently FM of India, Mr. S. Jaishankar clarified this question at a meet in Slovakia in response to the remarks the cheif of European commission.
1:- Don't compare Ukraine-Russia war with Indo-china conflicts.
It started since Ukraine wasn't even separated from the USSR.
2:- India never expect any help from you.
3:- India is well capable of defending itself.
4:- Even if we need your help at some point, we won't be asking for arms but buying.
I accept points 2-4 (especially if Murica is asking to help) but point 1 is incorrect. Never separated from the USSR? The Soviet Union doesn't even exist anymore since over 30 years.
@@carpetclimber4027 read the 1st point again.
@@dazzlingrudra5485 How does me reading it again make what he said more correct?
@@carpetclimber4027 the tensions rose in that area during cold war. And if u want to understand Russia Ukraine war u have to understand their history first.
@@degreecelsius6142 I know why Russia attacked. Same thing as last time and the one before that. Control over oil and gas = money.
If China is gona claim that wherever there are Buddhist monasteries, that piece of land is theirs ,than Buddhism has its roots in Hinduism, and Hinduism originated in India ,so whole South Asia and China itself belongs to India .😈😈
We will also create a map of 1000 years old and claim that the Arabian sea ,Indian Ocean, Bay of Bengal belong to India just like Chinese 7 dot map ,by which they claim the whole South China sea is theirs
ok now I do understand: the point is to tell India why they can only ally with the US. I watched the entire video wondering why this subject now. As an european (portuguese), I would ask my german brothers to consider the following: Why not get a spine of our own in Europe, not separated but all together (I'm pro-EU), and get out of the US shadow? And then yes, build ties with India. Leave Russia on the side for the moment. If there is 1 thing I do agree with Putin is the distate for the US hegemony. Nothing against the US, I will distate China's hegemony as much, believe me. Why not the regions in second best place to ally? As I see it, it's the only way to balance the powers in the world. I'm not proposing to "unfriend" neither the US, nor China. Just to get enough leverage that allows us to balance things a little. Please, give it a thought.
ya as an Indian I also don't get why EU which is rich and can have a powerful defense force needs to depend on the US. They need a spine.
Europe has suffered from poor leadership and ignorance of reality. The EU is not what many seem to think and undermines National governments. Many EU members and indeed European Countries are in N.A.T.O. but many do/did not meet their commitments. Europe could potentially be a military power in it's own right , but never comparable to Russia/China/U.S. on the strategic scale. In fact Europe is weak (very evident right now) and the U.S. has weakened it's own position significantly in recent times. The West is in decline in essence...
@@poojan423 Because it doesnt have a powerful defense. Have you taken a look at Defense to GDP spending? I know education in India is poor, but you are really pushing it.
European nations have too much history and culture to form a cohesive political entity, and too little will to finance it, given the desire for comfort and 6+ week long summer vacations for its workers, and other First World perks.
@@birdstwin1186 what do you mean poor education??Explain it elaborately.
China is the reason for the development of friendship between India and the West. The cause of both headaches is currently China. Instead of supporting India in the West before the rise of China, it has repeatedly hurt Indian interests
@@sosoable 1967**
@@alchemist7412 Thanks bro. We left them with a bloody nose (because of no Nehru in 1967)
@@jameammarijr.2248 We were lied to by Nehru. We have no rightful claim to the so called disputed reguons. Nehru own ministerial records are evidence of this. Please read the insightful and undisputed book by Avtar Singh Bhasin and learn the truth ji.
@@kabeerharrythakur8288 The whole of erstwhile J&K was ceeded to India by their King. We have the papers. Similarly, when Tibet was free, they agreed to ceed Arunachal (South Tibet) to British India. We have the papers. Thoda history padhley bhai shab.
@@jameammarijr.2248 Ceeded like surrender at gunpoint ya ji ..... Sikkim, Nagaland etc etc. Ceeded by who to whom under what circumstance ? The disputed regions were never ceeded as claimed. WHERE are those evidential papers ? No historians have come up with any evidence to contradict Avtar Singh Bhasin and neither have you ji🤌.
Allowing china to invade Tibet was a strategic blunder
Then Allowing USA to invade America was a much bigger mistake.
India would have lost if it fought a war with China on Tibet in the 1950s.
Allowing India to gain independence from UK was a mistake.
But the west is ok with that.🤡
who are you?
Strategic partnership between India and Russia has no parallel. Helping in building nuclear subs is one of them. I don't see in my wildest dreams that US would help India to that length and anyway US is a new entry in relations with India and past had been shaky, whereas relationship with Russia is time tested. IMO it depends on US majorly as to how much they are willing to engage with India.
Russia likes China better than India though, lol.
Russia won't help you with China. As you can see, they are even doing military drills. Sorry, Russia chose China over India. India chose wrong. Russia says heyyyyy baby, you know I still love youuu come onnnnn.
You're right about the USA I'm afraid. Can't trust them. Maybe Europe and India should team up?
Where on the same continent, and have the same genes ,Indo-European Arian.
go for ur belief that russia is a strategic one antagonizing india through its actios towards china... do u think u can rely on that... russia is hawkish
@@lynettefrancia8702 hawkish, how exactly and compared to what, care to explain more through past behaviours or examples. Equally important is if India can't trust Russia enough than can it trust US whose past record is to say very poor with India.
It's not like India would be the only one benefiting, chinese power is increasing at a pace where it is not a hyperbole to say that by 2040s, chinese will be the most powerful armed forces on Earth . In the region, not many countries offer a good capability against chinese.
4 Chinese troops died
Hmmm seems he doesn’t know
What’s his claim is
or perhaps these media groups genuinely interview only those people who can criticise India for whatever we do and try to make us think inferior of ourselves to gain benefit & advantage over Indians.
@@utkarshtiwari12 It's our favourite pasttime.
You should have heard his other views as well... that China is superior to India,China's military spending is 4 times that of India, China competes with the US whereas India can't even compete with China. He is a leftist and has a lot of inferiority complex. He also seemed to justify China's historical claim over Arunachal Pradesh. No wonder DW chose him to interview.
@@utkarshtiwari12 He served in Indian army I think he is more patriotic to India then you will ever be. That 4 toppers claim can be a slip of tongue because only that has been verified
@@akashdobhal3054 US military and international media verified it to be 35-50. 4 soldiers is the claim made by china last year(even tho china said, there was no casualty for over 8-9 months).
DW doesn’t dare mention Tibet or show it in the map. Arunachal Pradesh doesn’t border China, it borders Tibet.
I see the point of this whole series. It is to push the American point. Russia absolutely needs india to avoid completely becoming a Xinese vassal. So india absolutely has some cards to play in the Russia China game.
They literally said in the video that the region is considered "South Tibet" and that a Dalai Lama was born there so it was of historical and cultural interest to China as it occupies Tibet. Did you even watch it? Then again, it seems you have a narrative to push against this channel.
@@Blodhelm Indian conservative guy did but not DW reporter or their graphic
You need to move with the times.. Tibet is China. Check with the UN
Another deluded Indian.. India is a 3rd world poor country with a tiny GDP and even tinier GDP per capita. It ranks 101 out of 116 on the world hunger index. It makes almost nothing indigenously for its military. Its high tech industry is tiny as is its precision machinery industry. It imports most of what it needs in technology. It is still a largely agricultural economy. Absolutely not a superpower than Indians like to trumpet.
@@nielsenn7012 : There are many things which are not necessary, but which only a fool will give up. Russia is already playing a dangerous game, stacking the deck further against itself would be reckless.
The US and Western countries have helped China to become a superpower. Therefore India has a major worry to defuse the situation for a long period of time. India needs to build with powerful hi-tech army to deal with China.
It's not that simple ! They're many other reasons that justifies why they succeeded
India needs more improvements, but dont forget,India is one among top 5 military power in the world.
@Zack Smith your opinion is irrelevant 🤣
As an American I never understood how we allowed corrupt politicians & CEO's to offshore manufacturing & security to an autocratic adversary to such a degree. They should be investigated & held accountable. I'm glad China has lifted many out of poverty & can contribute to global innovation, but they aren't democratic, are often problematic, and shouldn't have been facilitated by corrupt selfish elites.
India has the 4th largest and powerful military in the world ...India can control china alone ..
I'll put it simple. India has their own brain. They don't play for the West or the east. India thinks for themselves. If we want India as our ally we need to GENUINLY support them and LET THEM ask for our help. We must respect their internal political structures and independence.
The wisest alliance is the one that helps when asked. We should understand this when we deal with India. Having smart members in the alliance that thinks for themselves makes the alliance stronger.
Truly said!!
who is "we" exactly?
aren't you indian?
@@mariacheebandidos7183I think American
It’s always been this way too, India was an isolated self-sufficient country before the Brits came and took over.
@@pablopiccaso-jw7qn India wasn't isolated, infact it had trade routes stretching from east asia to europe
Although there are disputes between China and India, the border is still peaceful. Indians should not be provoked by Westerners. Economic development is the primary goal of China and India
Indians don't trust PRC they lied about South China sea and the sino British agreement on Hong Kong
It's upto u.u must learn that.we r just any country .even u r advanced in tech dosent mean u will win. No one can beat morals of indian soldiers.
Bet you got 1000 social credits for supporting CCP
😂
@@hgff69 and I m here thinking isn't RUclips banned there.
Bhutan is a sovereign state, not a part of China.
he said tiny state of bhutan, not chinese
He said "tiny state", not "Chinese state".
Bhutanese look Chinese
@@Janovial British look likes American
@@Janovial bhutan is a chad, which does not recognise China, and neither Taiwan.
The world should be demanding that China leave Tibet. Tibet has always been a separate country.
Perhaps usa can lead by example and leave the american continent, Hawaii, Puerto Rico, Diego Garcia, Guam, Wake Island & many other locations.
@@aspark7251 Did you know that USA "bought" Alaska, Hawaii, Diego Garcia and Puerto Rico with the residents consent ! also did you know that USA is an "invited" caretaker of Guam and Wake Island following WW2. The USA has never taken any territory as the "USA".
@@michaellincoln3739 Yes I know u.s.a bought alaska from Russia which why I didn't mention Alaska. (Though in many countries buying stolen property does not give the buyer legitimate title to the property, and how did Russia obtain Alaska? )
However Hawaii was certainly not bought, it was despicable collusion between conniving american planters and the u.s. government to steal the land of Hawaii from the Hawaian people. In fact, other than Alaska, most u.s. territories are stolen or robbed from the native people.
Whys Tibetian people support Chinese government is that most of the people there were slaves of upper class like Dalai Lama, do some research man. By the way, Tibet was never a sovern state.
By India having a strong military presence it is good for world peace because it puts the brakes on what China can do in relation to any expansion pursuits .
In a war broke out with China and another country , China knows that it could end up with more than one enemy to fight .
India would no join in any war with China. India has only India's interests at heart, who would they possibly support in a war against gigantic nuclear China?
Nuke the himalayas, and nobody gets through.
The country that took India was the UK a western country... not China...
And yet China was already an imperialist which colonized Vietnam for thousand years .. before UK was even exist and came to india.. and China even claimed India's territory in 1962 based on "ancient history basis". Sooo.. China is not a saint either, here.
And u invade indias land in 62 cpc 10 cent army
@@rajibchakroborthy4181 and weak india lose it
@@loks117 i know we are weak but u guys can't do anything now we have nukes as well...so war means total destruction for both sides
Tibet ' was & will ' a Independent country .. 🇮🇳
Indians do not get to decide that.
@@sanejugal indians do. Coz India is only country in the world that can help taiwan.
@@Ksgggg you have not been able to help yourself against Chinese how are you going to help others? Big mouth doesn't help in wars.
@@sanejugal we will .. in future
As China did in past ..
Be ready
@@aalphadw keep dreaming
How dare you to call BHUTAN 🇧🇹 as a Chinese state 😤at 2:50
He said the Tiny State of Bhutan, not the Chinese State of Bhutan. Go listen to it again.
Bhutan's flag also comes from China.🥹The leader of all dragon flags, the Chinese Empire😭My golden dragon flag with five claws
Pradeep is dumb.
@@知-k3q bodhi dharma is from india
@@Zergcerebrates yes brother got it
Glory to our motherland!! India Above All! India Above everything else in this world!!! Humanity and civilisations originated in India!!!
PROUD TO BE AN INDIAN!!! 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
😂
Today's western news always tells why India should allign with West and not Russia all that BS...
Let me clarify,
1. Why tf west thinking that India seeks help of Russia in case of Chinese conflict? No, it doesn't! India needs some basic technology and technical co-operation, which is only offered by Russia. Like hypersonic missile technology, brahmos missile, crucial arms and modifications at cheap cost, (but eventually India will be self reliant in these) and also Russian technical assistance will help India becoming self reliant.
2. What Russia benefits from Indian self reliance? Actually when India sells weapons developed by joint venture,Russia will get 40-49% of profits. And India will be a very good manufacturing base of weapons.
3. Russia rather wants Indian influence in Central Asia rather than Chinese influence which will affect them badly. (China is eating Russian weapons sells).
4. Russia will provide India cheap energy and minerals reliably and will be a significant market for goods export.
5. India's bargaing power in Indo-Russian friendship is more than in India-west friendship.
6. Russia will help India becoming as par with China by becoming self reliant in many core sectors and they themselves will benefit from it.
@@gourisankarmandal6733 india is an L india is irrelvent india is 3rd world lol
@@scrimsaccesman9323 cry baby cry, world speaks otherwise
One dollar enough to buy your loyalty to us
The whole narrative is when you dont like someone, you concern about them and their actions lmao.
China is wonderful. These authoritarian pricks are not China, they are a political party
@@robertgittings8662 just leave Taiwan ALONE. piss off
True.
what? "don't like" is a very insignificant expression to unnecessary killing of 20 innocent soldiers just patrolling the border don't you think?
@@kb9880 Chinese lost their soldiers too. It’s a tragedy for both sides. Fortunately they found ways to make peace. The eastern wisdom has always been great. Both neighbors will always be neighbors whatever the outsiders may say or preach.
India is not ukraine, China is not Russia. Wake up DW
Well Ukraine is still resisting 90 times stronger Russia
@Kaushal Batavia Nato gives Ukraine a few dozen MLR systems while Russia has thousands of old soviet systems and tens of thousands of old artillery pieces.
Ukrainians resist because they are fighting patriotically for their homeland against a foreign invader. They are still seriously outgunned by Russian tanks, artillery air power etc.
@Kaushal Batavia Um, what about the Indo-Pacific trade alliance that was just announced by the 4 QUAD members India, Japan, Australia, and the US? It's supposed to include most of Southeast Asia including Vietnam and Indonesia so we might be getting a Pacific "NATO" soon, IPTO? Indo-Pacific Trade Organization?
@Kaushal Batavia Maybe not kissing the Russians backside for cheap oil so they can continue their war crimes would be a step in the right direction. Yes, the Europeans import more oil right now but their are phasing out their imports to help stop Russia's crimes against civilians. Trusting Russia is almost always a bad idea, especially since their main ally China hates India.
Sorry sweet heart, the US and the collective west no longer interested with the Russian-Ukriane war, they are turning their attention towards China 😂😂😂😂
@Kaushal Batavia "once was". Ukraine has almost no arms industry today. They are outmatched in every aspect. There soviet stockpile is dwarfed by the Russians. The Russians also modernised much of theirs...
I stand with Russia and India. Indian food is simply too yummy when cooked with Russian gas. America's endless war crimes must be stopped.
those are not Indian native food . sold by name of India.
@@aslamazad9066 cry harder coz even your culture, language and national anthem is imported.
The main problem is that the UK drew the wrong India-China territory line for its British East India Company to gain profit.
What was the right one?
@@edc1569 we just know the UK have no right to draw the India China border line itself, understand?
The main problem is that US built up China economically
@@yingfengxuan Then why did we draw that line? why does it remain?
@@davidschwarzguitar6301
yes, it is true to counter the Japanese Economic and Russian Economic.
I think china has made a strategic error in targeting india. They have basically pushed india into an alliance with the united states. Furthermore india has a lot of growth ahead of it. India will be in a stronger position in the later half of this century and this aggression will be remembered.
I thought the West has pushed India towards Russland?
All this being pushed. I hope I never hear it one of my people say.
If you say Tibet does not belong to China, you mean that we should support the separatists in your country, help them become independent and help them split your country, right? You should first acknowledge the independence demands of the separatists in your country, and support their successful independence from your country just as you support Tibet's independence. I hope your attitude towards the separatists in your country is consistent with your attitude of supporting Tibet's independence.
@@globalanti-hegemonicallian200 the issue around Tibet is the boundaries. Rather then trying to change the borders both india and china should come to a agreement.
In my opinion the current line of control should be turned into an actual border. But the one that has to make the first move is china, since they are the ones that have initiated this current standoff.
@@kek209 Accusing others is easy, without any skill or technical content, especially thieves, who always try to cover up their identity as real thieves by accusing passers-by of being real thieves. The purpose is to confuse the public, confuse the police, and escape guilt and moral pressure for themselves. Thieves always think that everything in other people's pockets is their own. Thieves also habitually like to complain that the anti-theft measures taken by passers-by to prevent thieves from stealing have increased the difficulty of stealing and even led to the complete failure of theft. This is what Indians are doing now.
@@globalanti-hegemonicallian200 if that is what you belive then I don't know what to tell you.... an alliance with the u.s is not something indians want but it will happen and china has itself to blame for its stupidity.
Picking up China-Indian conflict won't make your oil lower, boring trick dw
Unqualified comment
@@davidschwarzguitar6301 so?
@@jiashu2668 Pretty normal for an international channel to pick up global affairs. Why should it be a trick. To conflict is very well known.
@@jiashu2668 As you say, “I am Chinese, and it’s really hard for me to understand Europe”. That’s why you are against DW discussing China and it’s threats against India. That’s why your comment is unqualified 😂🤣👎🏼👎🏼
@@Interactive-gp8xf hhahah
Well India was the place where Buddha gained Enlightenment.
And Buddha himself was a Hindu Prince so Tawang Monastery doesn't make sense according to China when it killed 1.2 Tibetans who were killed .
@ bharat is called as India you nalla
This fight took place 2years ago , why is the western media suddenly interested in this story now?
To try get India on their side
The strategy is to keep the negative excitement about China to be constantly in play. Very important to keep anti Chinese sentiment up all the time.
It's happening again....Don't blame the West....
We were interested in what happened, it WAS reported.
@@wayangpok China's doing that by itself, just look at Hong Kong.
It's used Russia as a crash test dummy, so is facing more scrutiny
Oh! They're good!!! at pointing to our old wounds,in order to get us side with them!! All Anglo's tactics ( divide& rule) I do not condone any wars!! But, tell us?? Did Western countries came to your rescue when those wars we're going on with China and India???
Tired of this former bbc reporter’s bias and prejudice mindset towards both China and India. There does exist arguments between India and China, but the two have lived together with each other for thousands of years and more ahead. History shows they can perfectly solve their own problems without westerners’ too biased and western-angled interference. China and India, love both as well as their long history and unsurpassed wisdom and philosophy.
Ask Indians about their opinions of China and you'll see how well your comment holds up.
@@transfo47 when one day India’s gdp gets more close to the US and is in a fiercer competition against the west as China now is, you will know better about everything.
I agree with you. Both China and India don't want war and China knows it can't have victory over India. Both will lose a lot .There will be small skirmishes but full war is not wanted by Both countries. Only thing we need to do is become economically and militarily stronger so Noone says anything about us.
@@vanroad3882 With the failed ISRO launch in 2020, the huge deaths and subsequent coverup of the pandemic, farmer's protests, and now military protests, GDP growth is not on the forefront of India's collective consciousness right now. And moreover, it's HDI and Gini coefficient that are important for the actual people living there. China has more developed areas but inequality is still huge. This is one area where the USSR excelled at its zenith in 1990.
@@transfo47 why that failed ISRO launch is so significant?
*Perhaps 4 Chinese would have died after 8 or 9 months because China did not even believe for 8 months that even one of their CCP troops died in the clash of Galwan.😂😂😂😂*
Lol we are actually strong enough to defend against china. We can cutoff their trade routes at Indian ocean.
So unlike the video portrays, we are not that weak as you imagined.
I understand the west is trying to imply in this video that india needs west for military and so on. And yeah, the west doesn't like our independent foreign policy. So this trick is being employed now. Lol the last video questions russia whether it will be a reliable defence partner anymore etc...(and ya our sashi taroor saab was in it too...lol). Leave that decision to us, okay .
Can't resist lecturing us yeah?
We know who is miscalculating and doesn't need your lecture.
Why the video doesn't show bharat for its defence strength? About our increased defence equipments coming up , as make in bharat initiative?
This video is more likely aimed at the West than at India. There's a small but persistent fear in the West that China will soon do _something_ similar to what Russia is doing in Ukraine.
You first stop living in the shadow and legacy made by North Indians.. Start making your own existence and live proudly
@@dragonjpt1195 are you drunk....cos what you said absolutely makes no sense...lol....what north indian shadow of legacy are you talking about? Lol...there is no such thing.
There is bharat as one nation. I don't know what you have smoked sir!!
@@pranavvenugopal2609 don't worry i can see that @Dragon JPT is not Bhartiya(may be porkistoni Or a peaceful etc.)
There is only one Bharat, Bharat mata ki jay.
@@dragonjpt1195 wat r u smoking these days??🤣🤣
Economically, the hilly frigid border areas are not of much significance to both China and India. Although India and China got into a bloody incident recently, India and China have not fired shots at each other since 1962. India and China have deep historical relations and exchanges in education and philosophy. Although India and China were the largest two economies for 3,000 years till 1800, they never went to war with each other in the entire history, until 1962.
Yeah that land is econimically insignificant (for Indians). CHina can have it.
This is a classic example of Western media adding fuel to fire, hoping both China and India will go into war.
Only if you ignore the empires of France, Spain, Britain, Mongolia and ROME. Also India and China both had many periods of fractured kingdoms, that it would make no sense to pretend were solid economic zones as those states often warred amongst themselves. For example, the Three Kingdoms period, the Five Dynasties and 10 kingdoms period, the Summer and Autumn period's Seven Kingdoms and pre-Mongolian Apocalypse's three concurrent dynasties...in China alone. India's history is similar with large empires falling into warring fragments, mass migrations and invasions leading to disparate factions that persist to this day. In fact, Hindustan is currently broken into 3 countries that are economically distinct and China still has Taiwan separate.
And seeing what happens with Russia at the moment you would think that both China and India can find a way to walk together. Not that I would like to imagine the difficult situation for Europe in that case with a bankrupt Russia to stabilise and India and China working and growing together....but I would wish it for them. Not easy though with Xi Ping in power and being yet another one with a 'vision' to make his country great again. But this one goes for real-world domination.
India and China fought again in 1967. India won this round, with China suffering over 700 dead and India just over 250. After this shots were fired in 1975 in a border skirmish. There were no more lethal interactions until 2020.
Tibet together with Xinjiang was occupied by china very recently that is after the fall of the country to communism...Both these states are ethnically, culturally and religiously very distinct and different from the rest of china...It is kind of strange that after usurping both these areas, they are looking at justification to take even more territory.
..instead of using its resources to uplift its existing population..
tibet is part of china since 1720 (politically). culturally tibet is tibet with influences form china and india + little also from mongolia. india should stop lying to the world and more importantly to themselves. otherwise you will be weak and poor forever. since 1960 china offers a bordertreaty by which china gets aksaichin from india and india gets arunachal p. from china. thats fair offer (arunachal was part of tibet/china before treaty of simly which chinese never signed and tibetans under military threat from britain.). please, get real, for the sake of india. stop dreaming!
@@babahanuman83 The Qing dynasty was Manchurian, they are not Han Chinese. The Manchus were so loyal to Han Chinese that they sided with the Japanese under Machuko.
@@babahanuman83 Nice handle for a silly wumao. China dreams up history to justify her crooked claims to the territory of other nations. Your claim to Tibet is as ridiculous as your claim to the South China Seas.
While north Tibet is occupied by China the south Tibet is occupied by India . There is not difference between China and India .
@@incomebooster4728 To compare the genocide of Tibetans in their own land to the lives of the Indian Northern state is supremely idiotic.
Indian EA Minister said: Many areas of the border disputes have been settled but not all. We are capable of solving the disputes with China ourselves. The West's enemies are not our enemies.
DW: Poor India. It's China's fault. It's aggressive. It is expanding everywhere. It wants to be hegemon etc etc.
Kisdinger, the master of divide and rule, said: US opened up China to keep it away from the Soviet. It's a mistake to drive China and Russia together. Study their differences to drive them apart.
DW is using the same playbook with this video.
What is completely true! Yet! No one with a sane mind in the west, India/Asia or much of the world thinks that China will be a benevolent power for most of the world!!
They are highly aggressive & DRUGGED!!
Today's western news always tells why India should allign with West and not Russia all that BS...
Let me clarify,
1. Why tf west thinking that India seeks help of Russia in case of Chinese conflict? No, it doesn't! India needs some basic technology and technical co-operation, which is only offered by Russia. Like hypersonic missile technology, brahmos missile, crucial arms and modifications at cheap cost, (but eventually India will be self reliant in these) and also Russian technical assistance will help India becoming self reliant.
2. What Russia benefits from Indian self reliance? Actually when India sells weapons developed by joint venture,Russia will get 40-49% of profits. And India will be a very good manufacturing base of weapons.
3. Russia rather wants Indian influence in Central Asia rather than Chinese influence which will affect them badly. (China is eating Russian weapons sells).
4. Russia will provide India cheap energy and minerals reliably and will be a significant market for goods export.
5. India's bargaing power in Indo-Russian friendship is more than in India-west friendship.
6. Russia will help India becoming as par with China by becoming self reliant in many core sectors and they themselves will benefit from it.
@@gourisankarmandal6733 Well analyzed!!
I love this comment. FACT...the blind are too blind to see, though. That's why Italy's importing BF 7 by the planeload...
when in India , army recruitment happens around 100 thousand application come for 10, 000 posts for Indian army.
where as in china teenagers are forced , drafted and due one child , Chinese army works under pressure and fear of getting killed is high.
that's why china can't invade any country except making strange noise form their mouth
India China is boarder dispute， seems you describe it as UK colonied India. you can not dealvwith your life if you cannot give a correct judgmemt for anything
Who told you the Chinese child are froced to join army?
Nice joke india is a fragmented nation with a genocide brooming soon lol over some religious fued too nice try though
That shows rising unemployment of a Failed British colony.
Guys, chill out! We do not need yet another war in these difficult times.
states such as China say no
Right now, China is not going to enter in a war with India but will likely concentrate on Taiwan
That’s the whole point of the evil agreement between China and Russia.
The fact is western world doesn't understand the complexity of India China Pakistan problem....Any potential flashpoint can impact the world in way which is beyond imagination of west. Remeber Ukraine Russia war is happening under non nuclear domain. Same is not true here. The conflict will be devastating and much more bloodier than Ukraine.
Chill. China has not waged a war against any country for more than 40 years. Unlike the US who is almost constantly at war since its independance from the British Empire.
4 Chinese soldiers?? There were more than 35 Chinese soldiers died in galwan valley clashes.
As per various foreign sources.
there were more than 600 Chinese soldiers died galwan valley clashes.
As per various foreign sources.
@@darthvadeth6290 No, not 600 but atleast 35.
@@Aegon_Targaryen Some Russian state owned media also claimed over 700 Chinese died, and Poland claimed 800+
2:10 😂 both the Russians and Americans confirmed 40 plus deaths on the Chinese side.
India and Russia will always stay united 🇷🇺 🤝 🇮🇳
Russia likes China better than India though, lol
@@darthvadeth6290 lol you’re clueless. Do you work for the Russian government or are you a western puppet?
@@Aegon_Targaryen LMAO that's the most confused group of flags I've ever seen 😂😂
@@darthvadeth6290 you're illiterate, you've never seen a flag.
so you indian are enemy of the west, good to know
DW:- nuclear powered china is a threat for India.
Me:- What do we have ?!
☢️Nukes aren't made for Diwali celebrations.
Bardast nahi huwa.. Bardast nahi huwa.. Again one more humiliation after centuries of humiliation....
@@dragonjpt1195 Pakistani abdul supporting his new stepdaddy china. what happened with your previous stepdaddy USA?
@@srimanjha5112 PKMB
@@dragonjpt1195 pkmb
DW is so good at taking side, while pretending to play by the journalism rule No. 1. -- The land dispute between india and china was caused by a colonial history and by the UK occupiers a hundred years ago. I guess because DW "shares the same democratic value" as India, so the disputed land should belong to India now in DW's eyes. LOL
That's what DW always do, play the role of a dog of the US.
It should belong to India because history has shown that revisionism is a neverending spiral of hatred and war.
Sushant singh is spreading wrong message to Indians China's economy is 5 times not 6 of Indian economy.....and our army is very much capable to defeat the Chinese......also according to US report around 40 Chinese soldiers were killed by Indian army but china doesn't claim it
Mr. Sushant Singh's answer is very very disappointing. given what happened in 1950s, it is a futile exercise to discuss and make the border issue a political football as it happened in 1950s leading 1962 war. Problem with these self appointed experts is that they know very little about how China operates and how it exploits democracy.
Furthermore, size does NOT matter much as recent Ukraine war has shown and also how much smaller Vietnam (compared to China) fought China in 1979. One can not expect these lutyen experts to know all the truths
True. His comments are baseless regarding Tawang being part of South China, if so then whole Arunachal is part of China and Myanmar Bangladesh afghanistan Pakistan are part of india. Such basless military expert.
@ABHRA TALUKDER yeah it's true. We used to trade for salt and other ornaments with our animal products. Our people used to move freely. At one time, in early 1920s there were few settlements in boundry regions of NEFA tibet which some local tribes allowed.but after sometime Skirmishes started between the local tribes and the new tibetian arrivals. They had weapons but tribel people fought with gurella tactics and a whole district was freed of them.its a local historical saga. Tibetians were a free nation and so also were the mountains and it's people of NEFA always free until it became integral part of India.
Yup , this is what i was thinking .
👏👏
Today's western news always tells why India should allign with West and not Russia all that BS...
Let me clarify,
1. Why tf west thinking that India seeks help of Russia in case of Chinese conflict? No, it doesn't! India needs some basic technology and technical co-operation, which is only offered by Russia. Like hypersonic missile technology, brahmos missile, crucial arms and modifications at cheap cost, (but eventually India will be self reliant in these) and also Russian technical assistance will help India becoming self reliant.
2. What Russia benefits from Indian self reliance? Actually when India sells weapons developed by joint venture,Russia will get 40-49% of profits. And India will be a very good manufacturing base of weapons.
3. Russia rather wants Indian influence in Central Asia rather than Chinese influence which will affect them badly. (China is eating Russian weapons sells).
4. Russia will provide India cheap energy and minerals reliably and will be a significant market for goods export.
5. India's bargaing power in Indo-Russian friendship is more than in India-west friendship.
6. Russia will help India becoming as par with China by becoming self reliant in many core sectors and they themselves will benefit from it.
Didn’t India’s foreign minister just tell Europeans to Butt out of their relationship with China. I’m pretty sure that’s what he said.
Yes stay away from warmongering, we have seen how Ukraine support turned out
Chess was Invented in India...Chess is for smart guys.... West Rarely able to understand India's Perspective..... Every problem in world has diplomatic solution and is applied only when wanted too..... Also kudis for West for saving Ukraine
We can manage minor skirmishes with China quite easily. What china does at our border is like it visits our territory and stay there for a month or two and then get back to their own country as if they were having a picnic.
@THE ZOLDICS So insulting the EU is good because...?
@@dominikforstner1351 You can see Videos of Jaishankar. He is not insulting but just saying, EU needs to come out of "EU problem is world problem and World Problem is not EU problem"
You may still not agree with him but you'll fall in love with him. Pls do watch his video's with western interviewers
If this is any sort of attempt to sway public Indian opinion towards the West and turn a blind eye to its blatant hypocrisy......I would admit its a very poor attempt DW !!
I guess the reviews in the Modi Documentary fell to deaf ears and blind eyes like always 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Probably the other way around, swinging Western opinions in favor of India.
@@absalomdraconis it may happen not sure
Lol I agree
What happened with that documentary related to modi. Now I'm not able to find it. Pls provide link.
Lol chinese troll.
India can handle china. We did it before. We can do it in future. And we are proud of our forces.
Not 4 Chinese soldiers died , it's 45
2:46 what did he say "Chinese State of Bhutan" are u kidding me 🙂
West would've never helped India.
We want russia to remain neutral in India china war.
West needs India more than India need west. India can handle China.
Rise of China is inevitable if it plays and calculates carefully. Russia and India are the only two powers who can neutralise it when needed the most due to geography. So USA will need India.
Just wait and watch. This decade is just full of Geopolitics.
Conflicts between India and China accords with Western interests.
@robert_almado a tsar bomba on new york and a dongfeng 41 in washington would be much better
@@Pandora21285 , I would love to see USA China Europe getting Nuked.
I know we too won't live but Ego of these countries areas will be decimated to Ground.
@@Pandora21285 I think it's much closer than india china nuclear war. If Russia lost everything it will choose go nuclear
"Rise of China is inevitable if it plays and calculates carefully. Russia and India are the only two powers who can neutralise it when needed the most due to geography. "
The delusion that Russia would help contain China with India... ^^
You clearly haven't followed either Russian or even Chinese geopolitics.
There are many issues inside India but when it comes to international security we all are United
12:01 When has the west been a reliable option for anyone?
I think we have a live example of Ukraine who relied on the west
🤣🤣
@Omkar
Well Ukraine wouldn't have been able to stay their ground without West's aid in weapons, food, medicine, etc.
Europeans need to understand Asia better. When Jaishankar said, China and India predates Ukraine, he was talking about China's claim and aggression.
China is willing to break the rules based order and they did when they broke their own agreements and killed Indian troops.
Exactly
great insightful documentary. thank you, DW 🙏🏽
greetings from Kenya 🙏🏽🇰🇪
DW News: You have completely missed the point.
Tibet is NOT part of China.
Tibet, a peaceful sovereign nation in its own right, was forcibly invaded and colonised by China in the 1950, forcing the Dali Lama into excile, while the whole world stood idly by much to the shame of the United Nations 🇺🇳.
Therefore China has NO lawful claim to ’South Tibet’.
Had the UN 🇺🇳 back in the 1950’s forcibly kicked China out of Tibet and restored Tibet’s international borders, we wouldn’t be having all the problems we’re now facing in the Indo-Pacific region with Chins. And Russia would have not dared to invade Ukraine.
The World 🌍 is now reaping what it sowed! ☹️
We dont need to prove west about our kindness,being having friends with all nations .
India knows how to tackle her problems.
We dont need any assistance from anyone
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
The best policy for India to contain china is 10% growth for 1 decade at least.
That seems extremely unlikely as things are right now..........
@@shashwatgaur7258 hmm hard but not unlikely. We are at 8 already.
@@shashwatgaur7258 Not extremely though
Nope India needs to grow at 15% for 40 years
@@ernestkhalimov1007 If that's our goal then China also grows with help of our own rapid growth because by containing Chinese growth we can't grow with 15% rate because china means 20% of world population like us.
Our strategy want be grow with more speed but by containing chinese growth so 8 to 10 % will be good be containing Chinese growth brlow 6%
Did he say 4. Actually according to various data atleast 35 Chinese soldiers had died during skirmish.
Understand brother he is paid by DW
What type expert is he only criticizing india
Because of international pressure India's active personnel is 1.3 million but when you combined Reserve personnel.. Paramilitary forces... special forces..itbp.. SSB etc the numbers is about 5.5+ millions strong well equipped force...which is largest ever in the world...and India's airforce 3rd in the list of modernised airforce above china...and in galwan valley 20+ Indian soldiers were martyred but but china always hide death tolls of their soldiers which is nearly about 43+ soldiers as said by USA think tanks and Australian newspaper and also Indian military forces communication channels...So world's need to India to tackle china not india needed it ...Jai Hind 🙏🏻🙏🏻
abee ek nuke maarenge inko. Ab khoon ka badla khoon se hoga bohot seh liya China ko. ab inko sabak seekhaana hi padega
+ RSS (6 MILLION)
@@velayudhammadhusoodhanan5190 ye badhiya tha guru😂
@@velayudhammadhusoodhanan5190 bhai sahab lol !
Another stupidly i see in the comments, "British drew the border line"
Tibetan representatives were there when the lines of Arunachal were drawn and they agreed to it.
Ah, but india didnt exist back then
...sooo...it kinda null.
@@eleethtahgra7182
Where did India go!?
@@asi2765 eh? India as a state didnt exist before ww2.
@Devyan Utsav ergo, sit down n talk. Just like what the russian did with china n what vietnam did with china regarding land border.
Sit down n talk. Fight it on diplomatic table instead on the physical border.
Peace China and India, we Asian don’t like wars, China and India can be great allies to each other.
Not as long as China keeps stealing the territory of her neighbors.
Yes , no wars. Don't even need to be allies just live peacefully and do trade that's all.
This is a classic example of Western media adding fuel to fire, hoping both China and India will go into war.
China wants war..
Never. China can never be trusted
I heard a news few days back that someone had pasted a poster outside the US embassy in India in which it was written that"stop bullying us we don't need you against china ,you need us to counter china"😂
India Is Taking Nepal's Territory!! VERY BAD!!!!
i hope India will still stay with the US and EU, it would be rather scary to see the world be dominated by the autocratic Russia and China, where human liberties and freedom are not in importance at all
India will stay with USA and EU but you have to understand that doing business with Russia doesn't mean that we are against you. That's why India's stance is Neutral.
We are with democracies but we can't forget the Friend's of Russian federation who helped us in our hard times
And EU and US want to accept our relation with Russia.
And we live in a neighbourhood where 2 nuclear countries are a direct threat ( China and Pakistan) and on top of that terror exports of Afghanistan which is in 4 hrs distance from our line of control and Myanmar is politically unstable and sri Lanka is economically unstable and illegal infiltration from Bangladesh.
So we also don't want add Russia to above list because even Israel wont have as many threats that we have today.
中国人也无法想象，美国百万人死于病毒的伤害时，竟然没有一个美国官员因此受到惩罚。
@@dreamlee6465 నువ్వు చెపింది ఒక్క ముక్క కూడా అర్థం కాలెదు.
@@dreamlee6465
Because Chinese are not left alive to even imagine.
Imagine a person put in caged cabin in shanghai in the name of 0 covid.
Hahaha..... Lol
U were born free and now ur government rules your freedom.
What kind of sick life this is.
tibet back to tibetans, problem solved
America back to Native Americans
Australia back to aborigines
New Zeeland back to Maori
Hawai back to Hawaiians
and so on
Why deleted the comment lol ?
Actually I'm not a fan of imperialism but what to do it's literally a fact and i actually don't like when people cry being Burt hurt saying this invaded this over indigenous bla bla bla
Europeans were more powerful than natives right so they conquered and Start ruling living there ruled there so did By the Yamoto Japanese to Ainu So did by Turks to Greeks and Chinese to Tibetan
What's so serious issue this??
@@unconscious1076 I suggested a solution to a problem of today, what you said will not solve anything (and happend a long time ago)
China can’t have anything, but the US and India can have everything😂, what a joking logic!
Where was America in 1971 when Pakistan attacked India while millions of East Pakistanis were slaughtered? They imposed sanctions on India while providing arms to Pakistan. They even tried to open a new front on India in a time of war.
that was over 50 years ago, move on.
I do not see India as a weaker here, as in case of any Chinese experiments, we can establish a blockade of mellaca strait and strait of hormus and baar-al-madan strait which can simply stop China its oil supply.
Once you cut oil from any economy, the economy will be done the so called 5 time India's GDP will be 1/4 of it.
The question is can we do that? Partially yes!!!
India has capabilities to establish a blockade but risk will be very higher and there woun't be a good ROI of that, so it is the last resort that we should use. Chinese navy do not have supply chains established but India does with US, France, and Russia (Soon) we can use these countries bases for supplies which can further increase Naval capabilities. Also we have many naval bases like Singapore base, vietnam base, Seychelles base, Andaman base all these bases are strategic in nature couple with Diago garcia and freedon island china will be f cked.
First learn to read and write in English. Also read some geography books.
@@sng2260 I think u should learn some geography yourself, just open the map and you'll know what I am talking about.
Perhaps you are not well versed in military strategis and logistics.
It is logistics that help the military win
No of aircraft or how big your army is.
There is a reason why India signed a partnership agreement with US and France. We can use their naval base across the Indian ocean, South China Sea, etc.
Chinese have to travel 3000+ Km if the malacca strait is denied to them.
Their close naval base to malacca strait is at least 1500Km (not sure) away comparatively India just 30 KM (Andaman)
Comma, exclamation, dalke likne ke liye there baap ka naukar hu. Padhna hai padh nahi tho bhu d mar a
Blockade of the Straits of Malacca? Check out how close New Delhi is to the Chinese border😅
So you need your white master to protect you? Look India, only recently China ban its citizen from being the world "recycle" garbage dumbing ground because beggar cannot be choosers. India seriously in no position to assert her geopolitical ambition. India is dreaming of flying without even learning to walk. Whatever you just said have no leverage on China, just boasting in fear or worst ignorance.
First - China is not entirely dependent on Malacca straight.
Second - Chinese navy have 700+ naval vessels which have armed missiles of thousands of km range.
Indian navy will be sunk in an afternoon.
These places were given to the British empire by a Tibet breakaway government before WW2. China simply never recognized Tibets authority in giving away what they consider to be Chinese territory.
We consider Beijing as indian territory....so can we claim that now...PoS
@@justryingme You considered Sikkim, Goa, and Hyderabad Indian territory and annexed it, so that's exactly what you did. Look in the mirror when accusing someone else.
Beautifully crafted for Indian audience to divide India and China. India + China will be too much for the West to bear.
Kissinger, master of divide and rule playbook, said, "Study the differences. Use the differences to keep them apart,"
Indian EA Minister to West: Your enemies are not my enemies. We are capable of resolving our border disputes with China ourselves.
China don't have the intentions of attacking India. They cannot afford it. West is making so much noise on this issue because they want India in their camp. Sorry, we know what we are doing.
Dear Western leaders instead of asking India to take a side you people must work with Indian diplomats to bring peace in Ukraine.
Remember it's only India which can convince Russia for peace.
It's only peace which can save Ukraine.
We tried the same but got reprimanded by Ukraine. They said they do not want others to dictate what peace conditions are acceptable, only Ukraine will determine that.. and guess what? They are right. They got invaded, who are we to dictate them what conditions they have to accept for peace?
@@dominikforstner1351 stop arming Ukraine they will accept all conditions for peace without any second thought.
The current situation between Russia vs Nato in Ukraine....India and China understand well the geopolitical aspects. So problem will be solved by diplomacy, not with military. Both countries have sovereign foreign policy. Third party entry not allowed ....
Are you the head of the United Nations? You sound like you know the solution to all geopolitical problems 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼
India 🇮🇳 and Japan 🇯🇵 are the strongest counterweights to
China 🇨🇳.
Both nations need to remain happy 😀 alert 🧐 and strong 👊.
Greetings from Germany...🍺🖐
What I cannor digest in this presentation is the opinions of Indian " activsts," lefitsts, mainly, for whom the greatset enemeu in the world is the Indian State. These are representative of the friends of China in India; those who will quietly open the castle's door when it is under attack.
Thank you for this 🙏
I guess the defence analyst might have received a good pay cheque from China as all his points are in appraising china. I would like to make him remember that 38 chinese soldiers died and not just 4. Indian army has the highest number of personnel compared to anyother country on the planet. Let him check the data of standing and reserve army before he's making any point. At last we dont need any lecture or sympathy from US, instead if they want a good relationship with us then they should earn by cutting economic ties with china and after that let them expect us to cut our ties with Russia.
There were atleast 30 casualties from the Chinese side
But there are more than 500 casualties in India.
It's actually more 45 alone died trying to cross river at night
I was told 30 million death or more from the Chinese side.😃
@@xiajiayu3443 If they did, you know the CCP wouldn't report it just like Great Famine and Cultural Revolution.
@@xiajiayu3443 I heard that not only are all Indians dead, but sadly, even all the children are dead, so there will never be any Indians again!
Chinese body structure is inferior to Indian body structure, the fundamentals of everything.
The Indian guy was wrong in quoting the number of Chinese casualties. It was around 50+ as researched by some Chinese journalist
"Chinese journalist" = Da-Lie Llama?? 😆
Weird how they don't frame it as India trying to take China's territory.
Because not everyone is a Chinese bot like you. Wumao😂😂
Because it is China trying to take it.. they do it all the time. You know this too. That’s the funny thing 🤣
Bs
Because according to western media and some countries which don’t have a good relationship with China, everything bad that happened in one country is always China’s fault. China should be blamed.
Does anyone else ever think that we're still basically just territorial apes fighting over which rocks and trees belong to us? The only difference is that instead of sharpened sticks were now killing eachother with planes, cruise missiles and nukes. We have come so far as a species. We have built vast civilizations, sent men to the moon, and created innumerable inventions that have improved our quality of life like never before... yet still we let ourselves be guided by our base territorial instincts instead of using logic, reason, and diplomacy to step hand in hand into a future free of territorial aggressions.
*Nancy Pelosi disrespected you Chinese, and you kept leaving rockets in the sea*
😂😂😂😂😂😘❤️😘😂😂😄😄
They talk about China signing an agreement with the Solomon Island, but they don't talk about America's 1000 overseas military bases many of which encircle China.
Why don't interview some Chinese? After two boys fight, you just listen to one boy and blame the other.
Don't expect an unbiased attitude from Western Media. I'm saying this as an Indian.
India never intruded into the Chinese held territory but it was China which did it. We have no benefit in creating rifts with an economic powerhouse like China. Also China will not be able to become an Asian hegemon with an India against it.
Sponsor of this video will not allowed that happened
Continually calling them "A Superpower" is giving in to the psych-ops designed to paper over their internal weaknesses. (2) Tawang may have Tibetan roots but who does Tibet belong to? (3) That Indian analyst kept saying, "China is a much bigger economy". Maybe. But that would only come into play if the contest was about one taking over the other. Not the case. Penetrating Indian Territory, defeating the Army and holding on to Indian Territory may involve more than having a network of factories on the East cost funded by Fed's Quant easing and fluffy US consumer spending.
A fellow economist, eh?
Western countries want India to ally with them ,
also Western countries do not show Kashmir as an integral part of India on their maps.
"it would like to displace US power and influence" and she doesn't see anything wrong with USA Global hegemony...
It's only wrong when it's people of different culture and nose
US and European hegemony is Western hegemony. That’s desirable and should always be the norm. The others should compete with each other at best but never have hegemony. Russia, China, India, Pakistan, Latin America shall have no hegemony.
@@timsummers870 : Eh, the problem with Latin America is mostly that it started a few centuries behind the US & Canada (e.g. in the Bolivarian revolution they decided to _keep_ aristocracy under the theory that the commoners weren't yet fit to participate in government, and that philosophy _still_ somewhat exists- in contrast, in the time from the Constitution to the Civil War the US abandoned aristocracy enough that the closest equivalent is corporations occasionally remembering that noone cares about them unless it pays lobbyists...).
As for the rest, it's really just various caveats, and India is doing better on most fronts than Latin America (the biggest concern is that India might go down the same road as Turkey and Russia).
@@timsummers870 what a racist person you are 😡😡
Hypocrisy is the highest orda is the feature is anglos
@@timsummers870 desirable by whom? Talk about bigotry. Seems like colonialism is not something that happened in the past, it’s a permanent condition.
The EU without UK could and must build a NEW relationship.
Suddenly came appeasement news 🤣🤣🤣
China 's superiority vs a vi India is a myth cleverly manipulated by China . Chinese troops are no match for India's battle hardened troops. India has world's best mountain warfare troop and weapons. India , also ,has the Tibet card