My 48th birthday, 10 minutes from my home in Shepherds Bush. I was third row on the floor directly in front of Knopfler. I joked to friends on Expecting Rain about Dylan playing Forever Young for my birthday. When I heard the opening notes I wept. Best Birthday Ever.
I was right down there at the front about where MK was, a wonderful unforgettable evening and this finale so emotional! Perhaps you can see my arms waving around there, I’m not sure as I am only 5ft 2!
About Mark Knopfler I've written this before, but I make a point of reproducing my definition about the " Guitar Wizard, who I consider a genius and a complete artist. By seeing and listening to his performances, compositions and his performance on stage, we can perfectly identify his exceptional and unparalleled gifts and talents. The artist was notable for sound effects with special technical expertise, as a guitarist, composer and singer of greatest hits. By analogy, talking about his technical domain is equivalent to saying that he is the very personification of an entire symphony orchestra, reflected in the ability to harmonize, mobilize, coordinate and lead his band, by the way, formed by talented and multi-instrumentalists, who also perform , attracts and enchants crowds around the world. Undoubtedly, he is the greatest guitarist of all time and his guitar represents the extension of his body, his creative talent, his sensitivity and feelings, which can be recognized in the rhythms of various musical genres, already immortalized by several generations. His genius as instrumentalists, composer, singer, and diffuser of diverse genres, transition with great versatility from classical instrumental to country, from romantic to rock to pop dancing, etc. incomparably the greatest and the world's best representative of good music and a generation that gave rock and the Dire Straits style of being, which Mark Knopfler created and represents for the follow-up of music around the world.🎸❤️🎶🎵🎶😍
Excelente descrição deste grande artista…Grande Mark Knopfler que vivas mtos e mtos anos com saúde bem mereces por todos os momentos de alegria que nos proporcionaste…🎸🎸🎸
Yep, and the steel pedal guy recognizes that too, that little nod, the blink and the 'yeah' towards Mark says it all and Mark wasn't even done yet, he was just getting started🤣🥰 3:34 🥰🥰
Final night of a lovely tour together, I was lucky enough to catch this and the previous night. First times I'd seen Knopfler and made me a fan for life.
What is beautiful about Mark is that you know he is going to play the solo, exactly how you expect from him; he never disappoints and plays just the thing that is needed on every occasion. May you both stay forever young!
Oh my - THIS brings back SO many memories from my past AND present! Being 70ish now, I grew up listening to ALL of Dylan’s music. I realize that he’s aged a lot, and has basically lost his voice completely in this duet. But I do give him 👍 credit for performing in spite of it. It’s sad 😔 to me in a way, having ‘known’ Dylan and his music for more than 55 years. Now I’ve been listening to Mark since I 1st heard him in ‘15 as a soloist with ‘Are We in Trouble Now’. That was a song sent to me on a CD by a man I met, and spent time with every day for 3 weeks while I was on a 3 + month long world 🌍 cruise. He sent it to express how he felt about me/us, and the lyrics said it all - 100%! Living in different countries, we had a “long distance’ relationship, getting together in person whenever and wherever we could. In between, we exchanged emails on daily, and had weekly video chats. Sadly, he passed away 3 yrs later. Anyway, Mark’s music - esp his lyrics, continue to be just as meaningful now as they did in the 1st song. He brings back both some sad 😢, bittersweet, memories AND good 😊 ones now too! *** Sorry for posting my very long ‘true life story’ here! I doubt anyone’s interested enough to read it all!
Oh, the tree of life is growing Where the spirit never dies And the bright light of salvation shines In dark and empty skies ㅡ Dylan, Death is not the end
M. Knopfler!! Un ídolo que sigo desde mis 16 años y no me cansaré de escucharlo, quizás no lo conoceré en persona jamás pero solo con el hecho de disfrutar de su talento y que su musica haya sido parte de mi juventud es sufuciente!! Genio de los Genios MK
É um sonho ver meu 1° ídolo se apresentando com o meu ídolo há 40 anos, Mark Knopfler. É uma alegria e um privilégio vê-los juntos, essas duas estrelas maiores do rock de todos os tempos!!!! You two will be " Forever Young" !!! 🎩 🥂 cheers!!! 🌹❤️
Absolutely Amazing to see Both Bob and Mark. That's the beauty of music in bringing TWO GREAT ARTISTS together. Music brings us together. Have a Peaceful night everyone.
Tony Garnier comes across as if he is in heaven. Mark Knoffler’s guitar is so emotive. I love the tone that Mark gets. What a superb guitarist. A musical genius who like most genius’s is HUMBLE.
@@s0ld4u You completely missed the point. Many have played music, toured and worked hard their whole life to develop their skills as musicians but most of them (if any) don't reach Mark's level. I'm not religious myself but when I hear Mark play I sometimes wonder; maybe people like 'Jessi Perkins' is right. It doesn't mean we can't understand the dedication and hard work behind it.
@@s0ld4u "some invisible imaginary god gets all the credit?" No. God, our Creator, gets all of the credit. Without Him we wouldn't have our next breath.
Tenho 62 anos , com 16 , comprei Disere e depois Hard Rain ao vivo, meus dicos preferidos de Dylan , ele e Mark com sua arte fizeram minha adolescencia e juventude mais feliz, vida longa aos dois.
Interesting to watch their dynamic. Dylan can be a little difficult to play with but Mark has both patience and confidence. A less confident vocalist would come in with "young" after Bob's "forever," but Knopfler doesn't just defer, sticking to "forever young." It's the little stuff, but so many moments of the little stuff in so many songs. Knopfler is just about unparalleled in fluidly navigating the instrumental spaces he's given. We made it another year with both of them. 😅❤
What an unlikely pair of musicians together, AND how they managed to pull it off in this performance - imo at least they did! I’m a Baby Boomer going on 70 and grew up with ‘classic’ Dylan and his songs. Sadly, I only recently ‘discovered’ Knopfler as a ‘soloist’ in 2015, but have great respect for him both for his 👍 voice and guitar 🎸, in addition to what I feel are meaningful lyrics in many of his songs. Maybe I’m a minority in this case, as I’ve read some other comments that weren’t as positive like mine, but music in general is a personal choice and preference!
What a show! My God! Bob is a bandmaster too. We see him conduct her musicians during the show... Wonderful and Mark is a guitar show... Love his guitar.😄
Just his solos make it worth it to listen to. As far as Dylan in last 25 years, I have seen hundreds of shows. Some great, some duds. But ALWAYS at every show at least once, bob will take you to another place. Nothing like him. Him at 1% is better than anything out there
very ok//////bob is god driven........excellent he is working is devine things......god p-lease for fun bless all good p-eople.........and all animals.
Cette version est très rythmée , enjouée comment ne pas penser à notre enfance . La mélodie me fait danser une bonne manière d' être ds le présent alignée avec vous et votre groupe c' est comme de jouer a la marelle 😅 sans sa poser de question .Thank you !
Hello Patti. I was lucky enough to see you both sing this in London. But the reason for writing is that I’ve always wanted to find a way to say thank you both for all the happiness sadness and pleasure your music has given me for so long. I’m so sorry you have to cope with the health issues and though you have no idea who I am I send you my best possible wishes. Thank you. John
People say Bob is this that and the other thing, but you can see the warmth of his humanity in this selection, welcoming an old friend to the stage and then elevating the music accordingly.
John..:. I got chills when I read Your comment.What a landmark In your life. I truly didn’t expect How remarkable these two would sound together, I just knew MK HAS ALWAYS BEEN A FAN OF DYLAN… What a beautiful Suprise to see the video…. In person,like you, an absolute religious experience … I envy you 😮😮😮😮😮😮
Ho visto il concerto di Milano di quel tour, al Forum di Assago ed è stato un grande piacere vedere e sentire due mostri sacri assieme! Grande Bob e grande Mark. Grazie.
Mark desde el 75 te llevó escuchando hasta el día de hoy, un lujo verte con el Poeta del Bob, a ambos os vi más de una vez en diferentes sitios y ha sido precioso ver este vídeo, como decimos en Galicia Unha aperta ben grande❤
My 48th birthday, 10 minutes from my home in Shepherds Bush. I was third row on the floor directly in front of Knopfler. I joked to friends on Expecting Rain about Dylan playing Forever Young for my birthday. When I heard the opening notes I wept. Best Birthday Ever.
That's what I call a proper birthday indeed :)
Thats a Birthday to remember..! 🤩💕💕
🦄 glad u were there 🦄 BlessingsBlessedBE🦋
Awesome!
GOOD FOR YOU
I was right down there at the front about where MK was, a wonderful unforgettable evening and this finale so emotional! Perhaps you can see my arms waving around there, I’m not sure as I am only 5ft 2!
Mark did his absolute best there, " may your song forever be sung"
We went WILD when he made that gesture, so much respect for Bob.
@@johnskiotis5492 Fantastic!
When two legends come together their music becomes eternal and epic!!! Thanks for this moment, Bob Dylan and Mark Knopfler!!!
Amen
Two great legends!!❤
They have worked together before .
You are 😅the w
Question pppplllkm my
They both can rest assured that their songs will always be sung as long as anyone performs on a stage... long live live music!
Long live great music
Everyone on stage is so aware of one antother,, the focus on this very special moment is wonderful
About Mark Knopfler
I've written this before, but I make a point of reproducing my definition about the " Guitar Wizard, who I consider a genius and a complete artist.
By seeing and listening to his performances, compositions and his performance on stage, we can perfectly identify his exceptional and unparalleled gifts and talents.
The artist was notable for sound effects with special technical expertise, as a guitarist, composer and singer of greatest hits.
By analogy, talking about his technical domain is equivalent to saying that he is the very personification of an entire symphony orchestra, reflected in the ability to harmonize, mobilize, coordinate and lead his band, by the way, formed by talented and multi-instrumentalists, who also perform , attracts and enchants crowds around the world.
Undoubtedly, he is the greatest guitarist of all time and his guitar represents the extension of his body, his creative talent, his sensitivity and feelings, which can be recognized in the rhythms of various musical genres, already immortalized by several generations.
His genius as instrumentalists, composer, singer, and diffuser of diverse genres, transition with great versatility from classical instrumental to country, from romantic to rock to pop dancing, etc.
incomparably the greatest
and the world's best representative of good music and a generation that gave rock and the Dire Straits style of being, which Mark Knopfler created and represents for the follow-up of music around the world.🎸❤️🎶🎵🎶😍
Excelente descrição deste grande artista…Grande Mark Knopfler que vivas mtos e mtos anos com saúde bem mereces por todos os momentos de alegria que nos proporcionaste…🎸🎸🎸
Mark Knopfler has unmatched wisdom.
já o vi 3 vezes. Alvalade, Porto e em Santiago. Ouvi sei lá 1 milhão de vezes
@Elisabet Perfectly stated👍
Nah
Two of my most favourite artistes on stage together 🥰
Those tasteful riffs from Mark...just wow!
Yep, and the steel pedal guy recognizes that too, that little nod, the blink and the 'yeah' towards Mark says it all and Mark wasn't even done yet, he was just getting started🤣🥰 3:34 🥰🥰
Mark, you have made this song forever and ever young.
Y
I'm a Dylan fan since mid 60's but Mark Knopfler owned this.
That’s like saying the disciples owned Jesus.
@@david-pb4bi No it isn't. It's just admitting that Peter was a better fisherman.
❤that's right
@@bazzy8376 Or you have zero taste in music
Sublime! Two of my favorite artists in the whole world.. So stirring.....
Un verdadero mounstro Mark tu musica siempre vivira nostalgica y profunda solo hay que oirla con el alma Nando Galizia
I LOVE THIS TO GENIUS, I HAVE TWO RECORDS ON YOU TUBE ON IS FROM ROBERT .
this song, with these two giants sharing the stage, never fails to move me to tears, the admiration in all directions, awesome...
Well said shane
Any ideas or Vids out there when Mark played on Bobs 83’release of Infidels ?
Amazing ❤ Love this 2 giants ❤🥰
This totally brings me to tears…..how absolutely Gorgeous ❤️
Brilliant rendition of a truly timeless song. Yes you are both Forever Young
A great show of comradeship. Heart warming. Two great artists in harmony with each other. Nothing like it!
Final night of a lovely tour together, I was lucky enough to catch this and the previous night. First times I'd seen Knopfler and made me a fan for life.
What is beautiful about Mark is that you know he is going to play the solo, exactly how you expect from him; he never disappoints and plays just the thing that is needed on every occasion. May you both stay forever young!
LOVE Mark's nod to Bob. This song!❤
Keeping Forever Young true to itself with this monumental version .... just awesome....
Sentire Mark Knopfler che canta a Bob Dylan "may your song always be sung" chiude il cerchio di una vita.
My God, it doesn't get any better than this, on this side! I AM over the moon!
Oh my - THIS brings back SO many memories from my past AND present! Being 70ish now, I grew up listening to ALL of Dylan’s music. I realize that he’s aged a lot, and has basically lost his voice completely in this duet. But I do give him 👍 credit for performing in spite of it. It’s sad 😔 to me in a way, having ‘known’ Dylan and his music for more than 55 years. Now I’ve been listening to Mark since I 1st heard him in ‘15 as a soloist with ‘Are We in Trouble Now’. That was a song sent to me on a CD by a man I met, and spent time with every day for 3 weeks while I was on a 3 + month long world 🌍 cruise. He sent it to express how he felt about me/us, and the lyrics said it all - 100%! Living in different countries, we had a “long distance’ relationship, getting together in person whenever and wherever we could. In between, we exchanged emails on daily, and had weekly video chats. Sadly, he passed away 3 yrs later. Anyway, Mark’s music - esp his lyrics, continue to be just as meaningful now as they did in the 1st song. He brings back both some sad 😢, bittersweet, memories AND good 😊 ones now too! *** Sorry for posting my very long ‘true life story’ here! I doubt anyone’s interested enough to read it all!
🇧🇷Eu li e achei tudo muito lindo, MK mora no meu coração 💓E também concordo com tudo que falou sobre voz de Dylan! Felicidades, sucesso e saúde!💓🥂💐🎸MK
Super cool to see these legends perform together ~ both are such talented musicians!
Oh, the tree of life is growing
Where the spirit never dies
And the bright light of salvation shines
In dark and empty skies
ㅡ Dylan, Death is not the end
As many Bob Dylan fan's know, Mark Knopfler worked with Bob Dylan on two Superb albums. Slow train coming 1979 album and Infidels 1983 album.
Love it. My favorite artists on one stage. Thank you Mark and Bob. ❤
❤❤Van telepatia! mindig szerettem volna ezt a két előadót
együtt játszani!. Köszönöm!!❤❤❤😊😊
M. Knopfler!! Un ídolo que sigo desde mis 16 años y no me cansaré de escucharlo, quizás no lo conoceré en persona jamás pero solo con el hecho de disfrutar de su talento y que su musica haya sido parte de mi juventud es sufuciente!! Genio de los Genios MK
👌👌👌
😊😊❤
Long, long, long life to this two great and beautiful souls.
You know, Mark could have written this himself. No wonder it's so good with the two of them sharing vocals.
Melhor músico do planeta é MARK KNOPFLER. Simplesmente inesquecível 💃🎸🇧🇷♥️
com certeza
Solo escuchaste a knofler?
Ouvindo hoje 31.05.24, 23:52 Obrigada vida por me permitir desfrutar deste amor, prazer...!🇧🇷💓🥂🥂💐🎸🎸👍🏻Brasil terra linda e abençoada...😅
É um sonho ver meu 1° ídolo se apresentando com o meu ídolo há 40 anos, Mark Knopfler. É uma alegria e um privilégio vê-los juntos, essas duas estrelas maiores do rock de todos os tempos!!!!
You two will be " Forever Young" !!! 🎩
🥂 cheers!!!
🌹❤️
Absolutely Amazing to see Both Bob and Mark. That's the beauty of music in bringing TWO GREAT ARTISTS together. Music brings us together. Have a Peaceful night everyone.
And watch the bass player! His face is filled with joy when he looks at the two legends back and forth.
@@AgentRafa Simply.... "👍 YEAH
Tony Garnier comes across as if he is in heaven. Mark Knoffler’s guitar is so emotive. I love the tone that Mark gets. What a superb guitarist. A musical genius who like most genius’s is HUMBLE.
Mark is incredible! What feel , timing, and space. God has gifted him...
A lifetime of touring, playing, working hard at developing a distinctive style.
And then some invisible imaginary god gets all the credit?
I like how Bob's pedal steel player mouth NICE! to him during his solo.
@@s0ld4u You completely missed the point.
Many have played music, toured and worked hard their whole life to develop their skills as musicians but most of them (if any) don't reach Mark's level. I'm not religious myself but when I hear Mark play I sometimes wonder; maybe people like 'Jessi Perkins' is right. It doesn't mean we can't understand the dedication and hard work behind it.
@@s0ld4u "some invisible imaginary god gets all the credit?" No. God, our Creator, gets all of the credit. Without Him we wouldn't have our next breath.
Impossibile pensare questa canzone senza la voce e la chitarra di Mark. Wow, semplicemente fantastico.
Forever Young and forever fantastic - both of the them!
These two made magic together ❤️
I Love Both Of These Legends🎸🎶❤️
i love the looks mr dylan gives his bandmates near the end of the harp solo
Forever young es un himno, escuchar y ver a estos dos grandes interpretala es un lujo, gracias señor Dylan y gracias señor Knopfler
More than 10 years later. They are forever young and definitely friends
Best friends ❤
Tenho 62 anos , com 16 , comprei Disere e depois Hard Rain ao vivo, meus dicos preferidos de Dylan , ele e Mark com sua arte fizeram minha adolescencia e juventude mais feliz, vida longa aos dois.
I was there next to the stage, legendary performance ❤️
Extraordinarily gifted artists!
10 years ago exactly from this epic performance. Will endure forever!
Interesting to watch their dynamic. Dylan can be a little difficult to play with but Mark has both patience and confidence. A less confident vocalist would come in with "young" after Bob's "forever," but Knopfler doesn't just defer, sticking to "forever young." It's the little stuff, but so many moments of the little stuff in so many songs. Knopfler is just about unparalleled in fluidly navigating the instrumental spaces he's given. We made it another year with both of them. 😅❤
Mark Knopfler plays guitar Bob Dylan plays everyone in the house ❤
La calda voce di Mark, il tocco inconfondibile delle sue magiche mani sulla chitarra. ....cosa si può pretendere di più? Struggente!!!
Forever young., of course!
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐That's the A-Class!
Best Liveversion of this Song I've ever heard and seen!
What an unlikely pair of musicians together, AND how they managed to pull it off in this performance - imo at least they did! I’m a Baby Boomer going on 70 and grew up with ‘classic’ Dylan and his songs. Sadly, I only recently ‘discovered’ Knopfler as a ‘soloist’ in 2015, but have great respect for him both for his 👍 voice and guitar 🎸, in addition to what I feel are meaningful lyrics in many of his songs. Maybe I’m a minority in this case, as I’ve read some other comments that weren’t as positive like mine, but music in general is a personal choice and preference!
Mark Knopfler is superb, as always. Dylan did a nice harp solo.
What a show! My God! Bob is a bandmaster too. We see him conduct her musicians during the show... Wonderful and Mark is a guitar show... Love his guitar.😄
@Bob Dylan 🌼😘
@Bob Dylan Fine! Thanks.😘
@dahlbergmusictv9339 🎸🎸
🌻🌻😘😘
So awesome. Knopfler and Dylan.
So beautiful that I weep inside and out.
@OfficialMarkKnopflerChannel Stop your pathetic spamming! You're not in any way shape or form affiliated with MK so just go away!
Just his solos make it worth it to listen to. As far as Dylan in last 25 years, I have seen hundreds of shows. Some great, some duds. But ALWAYS at every show at least once, bob will take you to another place. Nothing like him. Him at 1% is better than anything out there
very ok//////bob is god driven........excellent he is working is devine things......god p-lease for fun bless all good p-eople.........and all animals.
We can all relate..that's what makes him great@dgsidecarscom
Thanks for this comment, you said it!!
Cette version est très rythmée , enjouée comment ne pas penser à notre enfance . La mélodie me fait danser une bonne manière d' être ds le présent alignée avec vous et votre groupe c' est comme de jouer a la marelle 😅 sans sa poser de question .Thank you !
Hello Patti. I was lucky enough to see you both sing this in London. But the reason for writing is that I’ve always wanted to find a way to say thank you both for all the happiness sadness and pleasure your music has given me for so long. I’m so sorry you have to cope with the health issues and though you have no idea who I am I send you my best possible wishes. Thank you. John
What a wonderful performance ! thanks for posting.
People say Bob is this that and the other thing, but you can see the warmth of his humanity in this selection, welcoming an old friend to the stage and then elevating the music accordingly.
❤️ thank you Mark Knopfler n Bob Dylan forever Young ❤️
Yes, that gesture from Knopfler was beauty itself. Brought tears to my eyes.
Great video, thanks for sharing. And best recording of "The Formation" from Bob and the band I think I've seen on tape.
I caught this act on their tour stop in Mannheim, DE in October 2011. A memory for a lifetime.
Per sempre giovani....quando si suona in modo cosi meraviglioso.
Love the Rickenbacker bass. Knopfler superb as always.
😊❤🕯Love this the wonderful song with Bob and Mark together 🍀🕊👍🏻
Fusione di due grandi artisti,con eclatante musica, bravissimi, intramontabili che rimarranno nella storia della musica,complimenti! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Love Mark n Bobby zee. May we all stay forever young.
John..:. I got chills when I read
Your comment.What a landmark
In your life. I truly didn’t expect
How remarkable these two
would sound together, I just knew MK HAS ALWAYS BEEN A FAN OF DYLAN… What a beautiful Suprise to see the video…. In person,like you, an
absolute religious experience …
I envy you 😮😮😮😮😮😮
Just soooo beautiful !!!!!!! Love this soooooo much !!!!!!! That's what its all about folks !!!!!!
Thank you for sharing such great footage ❤️
Watched it so many times..RESPECT
Dois feras!! SAUDAÇÕES BRASILEIRAS 🇧🇷♥️💪🏻🥂MK 🎸🌷
MK showing serious respect to Bob
Hi Frankie, how are you doing today
Sempre!👍
Ho visto il concerto di Milano di quel tour, al Forum di Assago ed è stato un grande piacere vedere e sentire due mostri sacri assieme! Grande Bob e grande Mark. Grazie.
thanks for this video... it truely is a historical document...
B-AA-I-T-A S-O-M!!
Difícil parar d ouvir..
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
🎶🎸🎹🎵
ficar sempre jovan sempre jovan o voz de Bob Dylan está nao bom neste ocacāo
Que genios los dos he tenido el privilegio de verlos en directo por separado y me volví loca
MEU DEUS...MEUS DOIS ÍDOLOS AO MESMO TEMPO NO MESMO PALCO...WOWWWWW
Wonderful! Thank you! 🙌🤍
Two greats together.
TWO OF THE 'BEST. OF my age. Totally gifted 🙌 👊👊👊
Thank you so so much for puting this version online. Thank you... I can't tell what it means 4me- t h a n k s
Mark è sempre emozionante sentirti. Numero 1 assoluto!!!!!
My absolute favourite two artist long may they stay for ever young❤
@OfficialMarkKnopflerChannel Thank you xx
Just keeps getting better and better ❤❤❤😊
My favourite what a talent you cant find today wow brings back so many memories
Wow . . hard to beat that . . legends both.
Two legend singing one of my favourite song👍
Super!!! Belle Chanson !!! 🎸🏛️🎹🎼❤️🌺🌷
Two legends together ❤️
Уважение и Бобу и Марку,они делают мою жизнь светлей,а песня Боба замечательна.
Парни только живите!
Mark Knopfler smiles (1:18) hearing Dylan sing the song in a different way
"May your Songs Always be Sung!"
To my 2 sweet kids. May you stay forever young. Thanks dylan
Hope I and Bob Dylan live long enough, to see him live, live on the east coast,willing to do travel ❤
So refreshing to see Dylan in 'animated' form.
Wow that was great. Never know what gems your going to run into.
a melodic genius and a lyrical genius.
Yes. The other one is Dylan.
Fantastic masters..wonderful❤
Mark desde el 75 te llevó escuchando hasta el día de hoy, un lujo verte con el Poeta del Bob, a ambos os vi más de una vez en diferentes sitios y ha sido precioso ver este vídeo, como decimos en Galicia Unha aperta ben grande❤