28:30 In the book they explain that a patronus can change to match another’s, specifically the one we love. Lily Potter’s patronus was a doe. So when Dumbledore asks: “Lily… After all this time?” He is really asking: “You still love her… after all this time?”. If you rewatch the scene now a shiver will go down your spine as Snape say: “Always…”.
@@eglantinepapeau1582 maybe in a couple years they should release an extended version with little tidbits put in kind of like little fun facts about the movie or the books (toggable of course).
If you really want chills, re-watch the scene in the forbidden forest with Harry being surrounded by his dead loved ones. He asks his mother a question and she answers, "Always".
i do not understand how you can know he used Snapes tears and he is watching a memory of snapes and then think the greasy kid dressed in all black is james potter lol
30:48 mark: A lot of people get confused with the scene involving the Resurrection Stone. It doesn't bring people back to life, only has the power to recall loved ones from the spiritual realm. Like in the story Hermione read to us, the 2nd brother thought he could use the stone to bring his bride back to life. But he soon realized that she is only a spirit (no body to live in) so she was in a sort of purgatory, not belonging to the living world but unable to "move on". This drove the brother to suicide in order to join her in the spirit realm. Harry can't use the stone even if he wanted to. He's dead, so how could he summon the spell to save himself? He can't do it ahead of time because he's not technically dead yet so it wouldn't work that way either. Side note: Yes, Harry technically died. That's why he no longer needed glasses to see clearly when he woke up at the 31:51 mark. Many viewers miss that. 🤓 33:13 mark: Narcissa realizes that Harry is still alive & so she asks 'Draco? Is he still alive?" If you look real close, you can see Harry's head barely move to give her a nod "yes". Once she knew Draco was still inside Hogwarts, she lied to Voldemort in order to get to Draco.. Narcissa was never evil. She only cares about her son & doesn't give a shit about Voldy's plans. So if you think back on it, you realize that Harry was saved twice by a mother's love for her child - first Lily & then Narcissa. 🥰
Your explanation as to him being dead would apply for a dream too. I am pretty sure he never died even though he could choose to by boarding the train. Assuming you read the books, (spoilers ahead), he still had his mother's protection and the elder wand belonged to him. Voldemort uses the wand to torture him with Crucio, and Harry realizes that it actually didn't hurt. That was the wand protecting Harry. Stands to reason that it would also not kill him. I do wish this was made clear in the movies.
If I remember well, in the last movie Harry lets the resurrection stone fall from his hand (on the ground of the forbidden forest) after he could see his parents and Sirius again, to comfort him as he thinks he's going to die. So he doesn't even have the resurrection stone with him when Voldemort casts the death spell on him. But the spell didn't kill Harry, he killed the part of Voldemort that was still living (as a horcrux) in Harry. Harry was just unconscious, or maybe in a semi-coma state but I doubt it, as he emerged quickly (because he nodded to Narcissa's question). My interpretation is that Harry was in shock as a side effect of the Avada Kedavra spell, making him faint a moment. During that moment, his mind made him dream of Dumbledore, which is why Harry said something like "all of this is in my head ?" and Dumbledore answered "Of course IT IS. But that doesn't mean it isn't real" (because that's an interpretation of Harry's mind, based on reality. The real question would be "to what point ?"). Every dream has a part of reality in it. So if you dream of an event, maybe it says something about the reality it is related too ;)
@@ZetaReticuli87 "If I remember well, in the last movie Harry *lets the resurrection stone fall from his hand* (on the ground of the forbidden forest) after he could see his parents and Sirius again" That means he doesn't have the resurrection stone when he is hit by the killing curse
Harry’s father‘s Petronas is a stag, his mothers Petronas was a doe. We’re pretty sure that Snape’s original Petronas was something different but through his love for Lily his Petronas changed into a doe as well.
23:44 That's Lavender Brown, Ron's ex-girlfriend from HP6. She's dead in the movie, but her fate was never confirmed on canon (from the book or JKR) Despite she and Hermione didn't like each other, Lavender was still supportive of the trio and fought during the battle, and Hermione still tried to save her during the battle
@@tktopmoviesyeah She was lavender, bitten and killed by fenrir greyback (we saw him in sixth one) but the photograph guy colin creevey also died in the battle
The room of requirement turns into the room of hidden things when the user requires a place to hide things as long as the room is not in use. That’s where Draco was fixing vanishing cabinet and where Harry hid the potions book in the half blood prince. In the last book, Harry had to ask everyone to leave the room of requirement (their hideout) so he could enter that room.
And now you know why Snape is my favorite character. He really was so brave to do what he did. His last words were, "You have your Mother's eyes." He did it all because of his love for Lily. The whole story of Harry Potter is amazing. Great reaction. Much love.
Brave yes, paragon of virtue...no. He still was at one point a card carrying Death Eater and also bullied the crap out of Lily's son. Don't think she'd have been too thrilled about the way Snape treated Harry.
@@scottswenson383 So true. Plus, even a lot of people who had read the books gloss over the fact that Severus gave the partial prophesy to Voldemort and he also knew it could have meant Harry or Neville. He was just fine with Neville, Harry, and James dying. He bargained with Voldemort for Lily only, as if she would have been grateful to be spared while her husband and baby were killed. Dumbledore even asked him about it and he admitted it and begged him to keep Lily safe, only throwing in her baby and husband after Dumbledore was disgusted.
Narcissa Malfoy ( Draco's mother) Asks harry if draco is alive when she is asked to see whether he is dead or not then he nods and she lies to voldemort by saying he is dead which could've got her killed but all she wanted was to protect draco.Also harry dropped the reserection stone so it didnt bring him back
She didn’t lie to protect Draco really. It was almost tit for tat. She wanted an answer about the well being of her son and Harry slightly shook his head and gave himself away to answer her so she did him a solid in return by lying.
@@ScragsP22 Ye I wrote it wrong to what I was trying to say but I meant she wanted to know if Draco is alive because of her love for him and then lied to voldemort which is a big risk . The biggest thing to her in her life was draco's safety
James is Harry's dad. Severus Snape and Lily had the same patronus because of his love for her. Everything Snape did was to protect Harry because of him being Lily's son. I have thoroughly enjoyed watching all eight movies with you. Your reactions and the way you talked about how the characters evolved is wonderful. Thank you.
Hey Larry!! Thank you so much for watching with us :) We appreciate your kind words!! So happy to hear that you've enjoyed our videos! Stay tuned for more!!!
For clarity, because the movie isn't as clear as the books, Nacrissa asks Harry if Draco is still alive, because she can feel his heartbeat and knows that Harry is still alive. She doesn't answer to Voldemort anymore, she just cares about her son. Since Harry saved Draco in the Room of Requirement, he knew he was alive, so he was able to tell her that he is alive, thus causing her to lie to Voldemort. He was thwarted by a mothers love once again. Regarding how Harry came back, it had nothing to do with the Resurrection Stone. In the 4th book Voldemort uses Harry's blood to restore his body, which in turn caused Lily's protection charm to live on inside him. This means that Voldemort can NEVER kill Harry himself, he will always come back. Also fun fact: Harry dying in the forest cast the same protection spell on the entire school, so Voldemort could also not harm a single person himself.
@@MrZeuz666 Its way more clear in the books but its definitely the answer. Its even foreshadowed in book 4 Dumbledore's expression changes to triumph when Harry tells him Voldemort used his blood. Then Dumbledore explains it in book 7. Also Rowling has confirmed it.
Harry survived from Voldemord's Avada Kedavra because it only killed the 1/7 of Voldemord's soul inside Harry, which is that bloody infant resembles Voldemord under the bench in the limbo (the heaven-alike King's Cross Station). The Resurrection Stone was used to see the dead ones you loved, not actually bringing someone back to live. Harry dropped it after using it to see his parents, Sirius, and Remus, because he didn't want to be too attached to the stone and thus moved on. All he needed to know is those loved one who passed away have been always with him in his heart.
Yeah this is the plot hole. The worst plot hole in the series because the rest of the story is built on top of it. Harry wasn’t even supposed to be a horcrux. Firstly, you have to be intentional in creating a horcrux and Voldemort wasn’t when it happened with Harry. It gets worse. The only reason Harry is a horcrux is because Lily sacrificed herself. That’s sacrificial love, the most powerful form of love. So then you realize that the horcrux, the most evil object known to the wizarding world, is created directly out of Lily’s sacrifice, the most powerful form of love in the world. This is not only a plot hole that the whole story rests upon, but a mythological inconsistency. A greater good can come out of evil, but evil doesn’t really come from good. This is why when you really examine the Harry Potter mythology as a whole, it breaks down. If you’re looking for good mythology and good story, The Lord of the Rings is the best. Rowling has much to learn from Tolkien. And I say all this as a fan of both and as someone who grew up with Harry Potter and not The Lord of the Rings.
Harry came back to life, because of Voldemort's ignorance, when he did the spell and used Harry's blood to come back to life, there in Goblet of Fire, Voldemort linked himself to Harry's blood, and the same protection as the Harry's mother put it on him, so Voldemort himself served as Harry's Horcrux, in other words, as long as Voldemort lives, Harry cannot die, unless he doesn't want to come back to life.
Well simple explanation can be - when voldemort used the killing curse on harry, he killed the part of himself in harry and not harry himself. That's why harry had the choice to go back to life or stay dead like dumbledore told him.
Oh, man.... seeing Fred laying on the floor in the Great Hall dead is heartbreaking,. But seeing Ron, who's usually so cheerful, break down in tears makes it worse every time I watch. It's even worse for George. He was never able to cast the Patronus Charm again, since it relies on a person's happiest memories to function and all of his happy memories involved his twin brother Fred. Also, the prophecy spoke of a boy born at the end of July....there were actually two: Harry Potter and Neville Longbottom. They were born in the same month and year, but Neville is only one day older than Harry.
I know...the way that everybody's trying to be calm, even mrs.weasley stroking fred's head and george is the only one who's slightly frantic. You could feel the pain and confusion and the absence.
@@tktopmovies The whole thing with Severus being in love with Lily is even sadder when you learn that he accidentally insulted her by calling her a Mudblood and he never got the opportunity to apologize for it.
At the beginning of this reaction when Katie said that she was going to read the books, I had to smile. By reading the books all of the questions that Ty was asking at the end will be answered.
I fell in love with my husband when we read Wuthering Heights to each other. You guys should totally read the books to each other. Or at least some of them. You might be even more in love by the end.
Draco’s mom was asking Harry if Draco was alive. She clearly saw Harry nod, knowing Draco and Harry himself was alive. She lied and said Harry was dead to protect him
Come on, Narcissa clearly said "Drank it with a lime", and then Harry nodded in agreement. You got it right the first time 😆 That was probably the funniest unintentional moment I have seen! Kudos to you both for not making me wait another week for the conclusion to the series. Thanks
The reason why Voldemort couldn't kill Harry was not because of the stone, it was because of the wand. At the end of the movie we find out that the Elder wand belonged to Harry, and the want could never truly hurt its owner. So, that's why it didn't kill Harry, it only killed the Voldemort part of him.
Voldemort never wanted the Deathly Hallows; he only wanted the wand. He got the wand from Dumbledore’s corpse, but it betrayed him because the wand belonged to Draco Malfoy after Draco disarmed Dumbledore in the Astronomy Tower. The wand becomes Harry’s when he disarms Voldemort in the final battle.
@@valbonney2575 the wand Harry took off of Draco was not Dumbledore's wand; Draco never actually handled that wand. At Malfoy manor Harry took Draco's usual wand from him. Olivander evaluates the wand and tells Harry that since Harry took the wand from Draco the wand has now changed its allegiance.
@@ThatBlackPiano From an interview with JK Rowling: “To truly own the Elder Wand, which means to receive the full benefits, double-edged though it is, of all its power, you have to have conquered the previous owner,” explained Rowling. At the end of Book 6, “Half-Blood Prince,” Draco disarmed Dumbledore before Snape killed Dumbledore. “And that meant he conquered him, even though Dumbledore was very weak at the time, he was very ill. He was on the point of collapse when it happened,” Rowling said. “Dumbledore didn’t want to lose his wand at that point and Draco disarmed him. So that meant that the wand gave Draco its allegiance, even though Draco never knew it, even though Draco never touched it. “From that moment on, that wand gave its allegiance to Draco, and it wouldn’t work as well for anyone but Draco.” When Harry wrestles Draco’s “everyday” wand out of his hand at the Malfoy’s mansion, he conquers Draco, and therefore the Elder Wand - hidden in Dumbledore’s tomb at the time - transfers its allegiance to Harry.
I remember finishing the book right before the movie (part 1) was released. My husband had been following the film franchise only. So when I told him that Snape was my favorite character in the series, he thought I had lost my mind. No honey, my mind was lost long before Harry Potter - LOL. 🤪 I just kept telling him "OK, you hate Snape with a passion. You're entitled to your own opinion." BUT in my head, I was thinking to myself "Yeah, juuuust waaaaait....." 🤐 When the reveal was shown, I wasn't watching the flashback scenes, I was watching my hubby's facial reactions as he slowly came to understand that Snape, although a very complex character with many dark traits, was actually a good guy & the unnamed hero of this whole damn saga. Yes, Harry was "the chosen one" but it was all made possible because of Snape's loyalty to Lily. Now you know the reason why millions of Harry Potter fans got tattoos that read "Always". By the way there wasn't a year gap between these two final films. It was 8 months- part 1 came out in November 19, 2010 then part 2 dropped on July 15, 2011. Now that you've finished the films, please check out all the behind the scenes videos talking about casting, costume/set designs, CGI & practical effects, blooper reels, & most importantly all the deleted scenes. There are videos on RUclips that have compilations of all the deleted stuff. Oh, also back in January 2022 they released Harry Potter 20th Anniversary - Return to Hogwarts special on HBO. It was really good - a definite MUST SEE! There is one scene where "Hagrid" talks about how much the series meant to him & his kids. It was especially poignant because we lost Hagrid (aka Robbie Coltrane) last October. RIP Hagrid, it's not Hogwarts without you... 😢 But the biggest lost for me was when Alan Rickman passed away in 2016. I've been a fan of him since Die Hard came out in 1988. I can't believe it's been 7 years since he died. 💔 Before he played Snape, my favorite character he portrayed on screen was the over-the-top & completely looney, Sheriff of Nottingham in "Robin Hood - Prince of Thieves" (1991) starring Kevin Costner & Morgan Freeman. I know you're supposed to cheer for the "hero" Robin Hood & not the "bad guy", but I tell you, Alan's performance is riveting and hilarious! His character is my favorite part of the whole movie. 🤣
Snape's character development throughout the whole journey was insane!!!!! And ugh--That is so sad to hear about the passing of Robbie Coltrane and Alan Rickman :( :( :( We definitely will be checking out the reunion ASAP!!!!!!
I didn’t read the books until my blind daughter age 11 at the time in 2006 suggested I read the books since she was listening to books on audio. Then in 2007 we were waiting for Deathly Hallows book to be released. I read first 12 chapters to my daughter since the book on CD was not available in our local store yet. Once she got the book on CD we were racing each other to get to the end. After finishing, I woke her to say I was finished about 11 am. She said “Oh, I finished about 5 am this morning after all night binge” I really thought I won lol
A little detail that's there if you know about it. Lupin and Tonks were married, and trying for a baby. They did have a boy called Teddy before they both died in the Battle Of Hogwarts. Teddy is best mates with the Potter and Weasley kids. He was on the train with them.
Actually by that point he was 19 years old and out of Hogwarts. He was at Kings’ Cross to say goodbye to his girlfriend who was Bill and Fleur’s daughter.
Snape had the same patronus as Lilly because he truly loved her. James is Harry's dad. Great reaction BTW. I watched the whole series with you guys and it was a really fun ride.
When you love so much somebody, your patronus becomes the same as the person's, that's why Severus's patronus was the same as Lily's. And Snape was the only death eater that could produce a patronus
My favorite part about Voldemort's death was the fact that despite being the greatest evil wizard alive, he ultimately meets his demise by returning practically to a puff of smoke, as if he had never been anything more than a bad dream all along. Just that juxtaposition of his extreme power and the way he was so easily destroyed once all of his lifesources were no longer available to him always fascinates me. It's just another example of Rowling's amazing writing skills.
not actually. In the books Rowling wrote he just dies as a normal human. The thing he always tried to avoid. He pretended to be unique, magical and powerful but at the end... he was just like any other human.
Been following since the beginning and earned my subscription. I love how invested you both were and its always great to hear the theories that you both had.... definitely recommend watching the deleted scenes to get a lot of emotional moments they cut (and yes! Read the books!)
My favorite short moment in this movie is when Voldemort realizes Harry is alive. A very short scene, but I love it so much...An intence closeup of pure confusion and fear on Voldemort's face...He desperately tries to blow one hall after the other in a sheer pathetic desperation to catch Harry.. He wasted all his life on finding a key to immortality, tried to be the fearsome legend..But yet the kid he had failed to kill all those years ago is brought back to life..Not only did he failed to kill him AGAIN, Harry managed to do what he couldn't - he cheated death in the most purest way... And there he is, once menacing and powerful Dark Lord, trembling in fear and screaming in the void, once again unable to kill the same person, as his men left him behind in a cowardly escape, realizing their defeat..
It's why in the half blood Prince, Snape's avarda kedvra spell was blue rather than green because he had to kill him but he didn't want to, it will be green if you have the intent to kill the person
There’s this video this guy does that’s mind blowing, “Dumbledore’s Big Plan” I think it’s called. Incredible insight into everything Dumbledore did behind the scenes throughout the whole thing to orchestrate the circumstances surrounding Harry being able to pull this off.
at the 12:10 mark if you pay attention, Snape never casts a spell against McGonagall. It's not that he fears her but rather he respects her as she is a member of the Order like he was. He only blocks her attacks & again, look real close & you'll see him deflect her spells to the two figures standing behind him. Those are the Carrow twins & they are Deatheaters who are in charge of student discipline. Neville mentions that as they walk through the tunnel to Hogwart's Room of Requirement. Also, right before Snape flies out of the window, he quickly grabs each of the Carrows' wands too. It happens in a flash so you'll have to rewind & watch it again to catch all those little hidden "Easter egg" clues to Snape's real character. Note - McGonagall telling Flich to take all the Slytherin students to the dungeons is really not a big deal. They never mention it in the films, but the Slytherin dorms & common room are in a secret location hidden near the dungeons of Hogwarts. In the film, they are shown being locked in a cell & then breaking right out - LOL! Please remember that not all Slytherins are evil as they portray in the movies. There have been several dark wizards/witches who happened to have been in Slytherin House as students, but that doesn't make all Slytherins bad. It is a stereotype & no one ever mentions the fact that there have been numerous good Slytherins, some fought against Voldemort. A few examples of good Slytherins - Prof. Slughorn, Prof. & headmaster Snape, Regulus Black (Sirius' little brother), Narcissa Black (later Malfoy), Andromeda Tonks (Narcissa & Bellatrix's sister), and many more in the history of the wizarding world. Don't forget the Sorting Hat wanted to place Harry in Slytherin because he had the traits that Salazar Slytherin valued most - ambition, determination, & resourcefulness. I am a proud member of Slytherin House! 🐍
Starting at the 23:24 mark we see a visual recap of the first 3 films. As the trio run out of Hogwarts & through the courtyard, they are chased by a troll (Sorcerer's Stone), then giant spiders (Chamber of Secrets), & finally they see the werewolf, Fenrir Greyback attacking a student (Prisoner of Azkaban). The dead student wasn't Colin Creevey (the photographer); that was Lavender Brown, Ron's first girlfriend who always wanted to "snog" Ron all the time.
Wow! I've watched the movies countless times, 20 each at least, but NEVER did I realize this little visual recap or thought about it. That's frigging awesome, thank you so much for noticing me/us! :)
Jut finished your Harry Potter journey with you and just wanted to say: Thank you, that was awesome, I really really enjoyed this! Been a huge HP fan ever since (books, audiobooks and films) and can't get enough of it :)
So funny you mentioned reading the books out loud to each other. My daughter and I did this when she was little and the books and movies were being released. Midnight releases of all of them after the 3rd as she wasn't old enough until then. That said, the memories of those house spent snuggling up with bed picnics while we took turns reading out loud to each other are absolutely priceless. I highly suggest reading them or even listening on audiobook. There is just so much more information. There are entire storylines that never show up in the movies that just make this a world that is even fuller and richer and more complex. From Harry and Dumbledore having disagreements to Hermione actually doing some sketchy crap occasionally to things l ike Dobby being in nearly every book but not movies, and Ginny and Harry's relationship being much, much more developed, etc. The books will only expand your love of the world and the people in it. Every single character really is that mix of light and dark that Sirius talked about in the books and they don't really shy from making that part of the story. Even Harry has moments where he has cause to feel truly bad for things he does and says even if his motivations may have been good. I hope you will read them and maybe do a 'book club' sort of series of videos so you can talk with us all about the things you discover and what you think of it all with the entire plot and story.
I noticed no one answered your question at the 3:58 mark regarding Griphook wanting the Sword of Gryffindor. They never say it (in the films) but the sword was made by goblins centuries ago & because of that, it is enchanted with powerful magic. Goblins have a different definition of "ownership" than humans (wizards in this case). There is a long standing history of ownership disputes & bad blood between the goblins & Godric's heirs after he died.
I have so enjoyed watching your reactions to these films. You are too stinkin' cute and I can't wait to see more. Just some quick answers--because you asked ;-) : Snape is definitely not Harry's father. James' Patronus was a stag and Lily's was a doe. In the books Harry says, 'Snape's Patronus was a doe...the same as my mother's, because he loved her for nearly all of his life, from the time when they were children'. Narcissa asks Harry if Draco is alive and he very quietly says "yes". At that point she just wants to get to her son so she tells Voldemort Harry is dead, knowing that Voledemort would immediately go to the castle to show off Harry's dead body to his enemies. At that point she no longer cared who won. I really, really hope you decide to read the books. There are so many things the movies simply don't have the time to explain. If you wanted to listen to them together I very much recommend the audiobooks narrated by Jim Dale. I know a lot of people like the Stephen Frye versions (and they are really good) but the Jim Dale is another level of wonderful. He has the kind of voice that really creates a mood and he does such distinct voices for every character that you know exactly who is talking, without even being told. Enjoy!
Hi Ne Pe!!! Thank you so much for the nice words and for watching our videos!! We had so much fun on this journey! And we will be checking out the reunion too!! The books would definitely be really nice to enjoy as well!
The resurrection stone DOESN'T BRING BACK TO LIFE, we saw in the previous part in the story of the 3 brothers how it works, and it works as follows: it can summon a person from beyond the grave just like Harry summoned his parents, Sirius and Lupine, but he didn't resurrect them and didn't give them life again only he could summon them in the form of a kind of spirit, but they did not belong to the world of the living. Harry survived because Voldemort, when reborn in the 4th part, used Harry's blood, the same blood that flowed in the veins of his mother and through her sacrifice gave protective power. Dumbledore knew that Harry must die because he is a Horcrux, but he also knew that if Harry was resigned to death and his fate and was willing to sacrifice, then Voldemort would only kill the part of his soul in Harry, not Harry himself, and thus he could return . Dumbledore didn't tell Harry this because if Potter knew it would survive his sacrifice wouldn't be sincere and thus he couldn't return, so Dumbledore kept it to himself. The resurrection stone itself DOES NOT RETURN LIFE, and Dumbledore gave it to Harry in a snitch with the signature, "I open at the close" so that Harry could just before meeting Voldemort, being reconciled with death, meet his loved ones to give him comfort before what he must become. And when Harry had supposedly died and in fact Voldemort only destroyed part of his soul in Harry, Narcissa Malfoy Draco's mother came over to check if he was dead, she noticed he was alive so she asked him if Draco survived the battle, Harry nodded yes and then Narcissa lied to Voldemort saying that the boy dies saving him for Harry saving her son earlier. It is worth noting the behavior of the Malfoys during the Battle of Hogwarts. They didn't fight at all, they just focused on finding their son and that's all that mattered to them, so Lucius tried to persuade Voldemort to stop the attack on the school because Draco was in it, and Narcissa, when she found out that he survived, lied to Voldemort. After Harry was revealed to be alive and the Malfoys had already found Draco, they left Voldemort and left. So they weren't entirely evil and served Voldemort out of fear and willingness to be on the winning side, not like Bellatrix who was his blindly obedient follower.
At 23:40 ish when Fenrir Greyback (a werewolf) was indulging in his prey, that was Lavender Brown, the girl that was all over Ron snogging him constantly during Half-Blood Prince. It was not the photographer boy. Aboyt 28:30 the doe. Was Lily's patronus, but Snape loved Lily so much, he had the same patronus as her. 33:20 when Narcissa Malfoy was talking to Harry, she could tell he was alive and breathing quietly. She asked Harry if Draco was alive and when he nodded, she lied to Voldemort. She has motherly compassion, but has a rotton husband and family, she helped Harry, especially after him saving Draco. You will learn in the books about a "life debt". 34:30 notice how Draco doesn't go when his father calls him, but responds when his mother does. He doesn't want to follow in his father's footsteps. 39:25 that is why Dumbledore allowed Draco to disarm him and let Snape kill him. Voldemort didnt know wand lore. Also there is a surprise you will find out in the book that Harry does with the Elder Wand using it to cast a spell. I'll let you learn about it when you read it. So keeping it a surprise and hope no one else spoils it. Now remember, all three of the Deathly Hallows belonged to Harry. The wand belonged to him, he had the cloak and the stone, he was a master of death. DEFINITELY read the books. There is a lot. Including a BIGGER battle in Half Blood Prince. A lot more action with Dobby and with Kreacher who is very involved in the battles as well. Now as you mentioned, you got to see these back to back. We had to wait a YEAR!!! Watching 1 midnight show then waiting a year for the next midnight movie. Over 1000 people were waiting at the movie theater to get in. Waiting outside in the cold winter temperatures for over an hour until the doors opened and then we waited INSIDE for over an hour. (made sure to use the bathroom before picking up my friend and going to the theater).
For a lot of us it was a little easier to wait the year for the second part because we had read the book, so we knew how the story ended. But, I can say that if I hadn't read the books, it would have been TORTURE!!!
It was torture waiting the year for the book came out. For me, i reread the entire series before the release of each new book just so the entire story would be fresh when i read the new content. Ive read the entire series probably 15 times.
42:09 if you really love someone, your patronus can compliment or become the same as your partner’s patronus😊 they didn’t explain it well in the movies. Snape’s patronus became the same as Lily’s patronus.
To explain the patronus being the same, that happens when you love someone. Lily was a doe and James (who is Harry's dad, think of all the times people say he looks just like James) was a stag so they were also paired.
It has been so much fun being on the journey with you both, but it's not quite over yet. The 20th anniversary reunion is a must, and I think you'd both find the 'Deathly Hallows' deleted scenes really interesting, particularly the ones involving Petunia, Dudley and Draco. Once again lovelies, thank you both for sharing this journey.
Snape is not Harry's father. Snape's patronus is the same as Harry's mother because she was his one true love, even if she only saw him as a friend. When Voldemort asks Draco's mother to check if Harry is dead, she sees he's alive and asks him if Draco is still alive, then because of this lies to Voldemort that Harry is dead. The Resurrection Stone is just to bring back loved ones, not to resurrect yourself.
Use your brains! The whole series Harry is being told that he looks like his dad: James Potter not Snape! The resurection stone only brings images of love ones, it only served to strengthen Harry's resolve and be a part of the united Hallows (master of death. Although Voldemort had the wand, he was not master of it. Harry was the master of all 3. The main reason Harry didn't die was Voldemort had Harry's blood in him from when he was regenerated. Lilly's ancient majic continued to protect Harry and he did similar: but see the books for this.
He used the resurrection stone to bring back the people he loved the most, to give him courage, to say what he needed to say, that he didn't mean for anyone to die for him, to give himself the strength to do what needed to be done. Then, when he was ready, he dropped the stone and let them go.
I thoroughly enjoyed watching with you. Harry was protected by ancient magic that his mother used on him. It came into effect when she sacrificed herself for him therefore protecting him. Harry also cast that same ancient magic on his friends there at hog warts when he chose to sacrifice himself. But because it blanketed so many people it was possibly not as strong as the one his mother placed on him. Severus’ deep love for Lily is what made his patrons the same as Lily’s and because he could see Lily in Harry he became attached to Harry and cared for him but could never display it.
My favorite part in this film is the final reveal at the end, but my 2nd favorite scene is Hermione disguised as Bellatrix. That is no CGI photoshop of Bellatrix's face on Hermione's body. That is really Helena Bonham Carter (Bellatrix) pretending to be Hermione, who is pretending to be Bellatrix - LOL! She even has all of Hermione's facial expressions down. If you watch the behind the scenes interviews, there is one of Helena talking about how she managed to capture all of Hermione's little quirks & personality traits. 😊
Every movie had some kind of twist at the end. The first had Quirrel as Voldemort's servant, the second had Tom Riddle as the heir to Slitherin and being Voldemort, the third had Sirius actually having been framed by Petigrew, the fourth was Voldemort returning, the fifth was Sirius dying, the sixth was Dumbledore dying, Snape being the one to kill him, and Snape being the titular Half-Blood Prince, the seventh was, actually did the first part of Deathly Hallows actually have one? Dobby died, but he wasn't the only death in it. The stuff about Snape in this one, though, was truly a crown moment for the series.
i know im 7 months late to the party but i really enjoyed watching this series with you guys. i am a huge harry potter fan and you guys bring me so much joy the way you genuinely get so immersed in the movies, trying to understand everything the best you can , remembering information is really heartwarming and you guys are great! keep this channel up, no doubt your subscribers will grow and grow
It took me several times seeing it to realize that when Snape does his patronus - that is the patronus doe that goes out in the woods and leads Harry to the Sword of Griffindor in Part I
Snapes patronus is a doe because Lily was a doe, and he was in love with her. Harry's is a Stag because his dad James was an animagus that could turn into a stag to help when Lupin became a wolf.
The reason I think Harry didn't die is because the Deathly Hallows all belonged to him.The invisibility cloak from his father, the stone from Dumbledore and the wand because he won it from Draco. As foretold the one who owns all 3 D.H. is the Master of Death.
Notice how each of the horcruxes was destroyed by a different person: Harry killed the diary. Dumbledore killed the ring. Ron killed the locket. Hermione killed the cup. Goyle killed the diadem.* Voldemort killed Harry. Neville killed the snake. *In the book, it was Crabbe that killed the diadem with the fiendfire spell - a very powerful "living fire" spell that can destroy horcruxes, but is very difficult to control. If you don't know what you're doing, it's extremely dangerous. And Goyle/Crabbe did not have sufficient skill to control it. Voldy used the same spell at the Ministry at the end of OotP. The actor that played Crabbe got himself into some legal trouble and was unavailable for the last movie. Doesn't really change the story much though.
Snape was not Harry's dad. He was in love with Lily though, and his Patronus was the same as Lily's because of that. I also feel like Snape did love Harry as well, since he was Lily's son and had her eyes. I feel for Snape, he cared for Harry but was always reminded of James when he looked at Harry and James was a bully to Snape and married the girl he loved. About the stone, remember Dumbledore left the Snitch to Harry on his will (the Malfoys had nothing to do with it). So, when you stop and think about it, Dumbledore had all the Deathly Hallows (he had the cloak, the stone and the wand).
The "Resurrection Stone" only allows you to see a shade of your loved ones. Harry didn't die b/c his protection still lived in his very skin thanks to Voldemort being reborn with his blood. Voldemort only killed the part of himself that was inside Harry.
Everyone seems to misinterpret what the Resurrection Stone even does. It doesn’t bring people back to life, it lets the user speak to a loved one kinda like a ghost. Also, Narcissa defies Voldemort by lying to him because Harry saved Draco. It’s supposed to illustrate one of the overarching themes: love conquers all.
I don’t know if someone has told you, but they named all of their kids after people they loved or admired. Albus Severus Potter. The other son’s name is James Sirius Potter and their daughter name is Lily Luna Potter. I enjoyed being on this journey with you guys. If you guys really read the books you should do a video review. You will be blown away with all the details the movies left out.
She's a mom worrying about her only son. We all know Narcissa just wants Draco. She knows Harry is not dead, instead of giving him away, she asked Harry if her son Draco is still alive. Remember, Narcissa doesn't want any of these to go far. She just wants to send her son to school and go back home. When Harry nodded yes, she decided to spare his life and lied to Voldemort. And how can you not know who is the little boy with little lily on Snape's memory? With the hair and black garments and all, and it was Snape's memory so it was him we were watching. Good grief.
I like how they spread around who kills the horcruxes... Tom Riddle's Diary - Harry The Ring - Dumbledore The Locket - Ron The Cup - Hermoine The Diadem - Group Effort, mostly Ron and Harry Harry - Voldemort Nagini - Neville
It wasn't the stone that brought him back, since he dropped it before he died (for him, the correct thing was to sacrifice himself for hogwarts so he really wanted to die). I think Harry didn't die in the forest because at that moment he had the 3 relics being "the lord of death". The wand had responded to him since the day he disarmed Draco, the stone was with him all the time and the cloak since the first movie
Griphook wanted the sword because it was goblin made. Goblins believe that once the owner of the item dies, or no longer wants the item, it should be returned to the goblins. They believe "Passing down, or inheriting" goblin items was like stealing. and that the sword was stolen from them for hundreds of years since the original owner was long dead.
Harry became the owner of the Resurrection Stone because Dumbledore left it for him. He did not have to have it in his possession when he went to Voldemort(no chance of anyone finding it on his person. If you think about it, in the end, Harry had all the Deathly Hallows: the Invisibility Cloak, the Resurrection Stone and the Elder Wand so he was The Master of Death. He broke the wand because he realized how dangerous it could be in the wrong hands and all the terrible things that others could do in pursuit of obtaining them. Snape's Patronus was the same as Lily's because he loved her so much, I'm not sure if it was always the same or his changed after her death.
I don't know if anyone said it in the comments last video but , In the chamber of secrets Dobby promised never to try to save Harry Potters life again , he died breaking this promise which makes his death even more tragic.
Harry was a horcrux. To kill a living horcrux, Voldemort himself HAD TO DO IT by a killing spell. Because it was his own part of soul so he destroyed it himself. The memories of Snape was a set up to motivate Harry for death. Dumbledore was a good guy, but he knew that in the future Harry will see those moments so he played like that and told Snape that Harry MUST DIE. So Harry was 100% motivated to go and die. Lilly has protected Harry by a love spell. It works as a shield. But the spell rebounded after her death so part of Voldemort's soul got inside Harry and nobody knew until Dumbledore discovered that in Half-Blood Prince movie.
Mothers are a dominant theme - Lily’s love protected Harry- Molly Weasley defeated Bellatrix protecting her daughter - Draco’a mum lied to Voldemort so she could get into Hogwarts to save her son - other character mothers had great effect on them and how they lived which are more apparent in the books. (Voldermort Sirius Snape Dumbledore)
Snape is not Harry’s father. Snape was in love with Lily until the end but Lily loved James. Snape only protected Harry because of Lily. James is Harry’s father. The resurrection stone can’t bring you back from the dead. Like Dumbledore said in Goblet of Fire “No Spell can re-awaken the dead.” You can only use the stone to bring loved one’s back but it’s just a shadow of your loved one. Harry used the resurrection stone to see his parents and Sirius and Lupin before he “greeted death as an old friend.”
The resurrection stone did NOT bring Harry back from the dead, it only brought his loved ones back to him for a few moments. In the Wizarding World NOTHING can bring anyone back from the dead, it’s a steadfast rule (and I really respect that). So, what made Harry not die when Voldemort strikes him, was the fact that a piece of Voldemort’s soul was inside of Harry then, so Voldemort killed his own soul (even if unintentionally), not Harry himself.
The Prince's Tale, which is the Chapter in the book looking at Snape's memories, is a complete game changer, because it finally reveals everything that has been going on behind the scenes from the very beginning. Snape is one of the deepest and most complex characters in literature, and secretly one of the most powerful wizards in the world. In fact, Dumbledore (The Archmage), Voldemort (Master of the Dark Arts), Snape (Master of Mental Magic), and Harry (Master of Death) are all the most powerful wizards of the respective generations. (Voldemort is actually about 30 years older than Snape.)
@@jowbloe3673 it makes sense to me because McGonagall knows they aren’t all bad. She wouldn’t punish a whole because of a few. I think she had a deeper meaning.
Also, the resurrection stone can't bring people back from the dead, it can recall the spirit, which is why the third brother killed himself because he couldn't let her go and he couldn't physically bring her back. This allowed him to see his parents and Sirius and Remus, but it couldn't have brought them back physically. Dumbledore told Harry, I think in the 1st or 2nd movie, when he found that mirror that shows you your heart's desire, that no magic can bring people back from the dead.
The patronus changes based on deep emotion, you can take on someone else’s patronus. He loved Lily so Snape’s patronus became hers, the doe. That’s why Dumbledore saw the doe and looked at him in amazement, and said “lily”. Snape responded “always”. Shape never loved again. His patronus took on Lily’s patronus because he loved her so much. No, he was not Harry’s father.
Snape's patronus is a doe, just like Lily Potter's is a doe. I didn't read the book, but someone informed me that when someone really cares for another, their patronus can change to the other person's patronus, or it could just be that the share a strong bond or connection. He isn't Harry's father, both Harry and his father James share a stag for their patronus. Also, that was his second son that was named Albus Severus Potter, the older boy that went first had initials JSP, which stands for James Sirius Potter, in honor of his father and godfather.
They asked for Bellatrix’s wand because they knew Harry had it, so they knew it wasn’t her. She asked Harry if Draco was alive and he nodded yes, so she lied to Voldemort when she said he was dead.
If you want to have a movie night and sync up your copy of the film, let's watch it together!! www.patreon.com/tktopmovies
You guys have to do hunger games
Honestly, Snape's memories reveal is the best part of watching Harry Potter reactions
Facts man
Definitely!! But I also love watching Helena playing Emma playing Helena... what an amazing actress she is!
I have to agree. That’s my favorite scene from all the films. It was so beautifully acted and produced.
100%
tell me a better scene in cinema history sheeesh
Yes, Narcisa Malfoy saw that Harry was alive, and she asked "Is Draco alive?" then she deceived Voldemort, saying that Harry is dead.
Yes, showing that it was a mother's love that saved Harry once again (First Lily, then Narcissa).
Once again, a mother's love saved Harry... and brought down Voldemort.
@@caretaker158 same thing that brought down Bellatrix, such poetic
Harry saved Draco. So She saved Harrry.
@@alickrozier3799 but she wasn't there in the castle so she couldn't know that Harry literally saved Draco's life.
28:30 In the book they explain that a patronus can change to match another’s, specifically the one we love. Lily Potter’s patronus was a doe. So when Dumbledore asks: “Lily… After all this time?” He is really asking: “You still love her… after all this time?”. If you rewatch the scene now a shiver will go down your spine as Snape say: “Always…”.
this movie doesn't reallly take the non readers into consideration . David Yates should not have directed
@@eglantinepapeau1582 maybe in a couple years they should release an extended version with little tidbits put in kind of like little fun facts about the movie or the books (toggable of course).
Yes, exactly and this is what happens with Snape.
@@eglantinepapeau1582 I wouldn't go that far. I didn't read the books but I thought that was pretty clear.
If you really want chills, re-watch the scene in the forbidden forest with Harry being surrounded by his dead loved ones. He asks his mother a question and she answers, "Always".
12:10 Snape not only deflects McGonagall's spell towards the Carrows but also takes their wands before leaving....just love it !!
i do not understand how you can know he used Snapes tears and he is watching a memory of snapes and then think the greasy kid dressed in all black is james potter lol
Neville getting that heroic ending was so satisfying, considering he could've also been that chosen one which Harry was. True Griffyndor
30:48 mark: A lot of people get confused with the scene involving the Resurrection Stone. It doesn't bring people back to life, only has the power to recall loved ones from the spiritual realm. Like in the story Hermione read to us, the 2nd brother thought he could use the stone to bring his bride back to life. But he soon realized that she is only a spirit (no body to live in) so she was in a sort of purgatory, not belonging to the living world but unable to "move on". This drove the brother to suicide in order to join her in the spirit realm. Harry can't use the stone even if he wanted to. He's dead, so how could he summon the spell to save himself? He can't do it ahead of time because he's not technically dead yet so it wouldn't work that way either.
Side note: Yes, Harry technically died. That's why he no longer needed glasses to see clearly when he woke up at the 31:51 mark. Many viewers miss that. 🤓
33:13 mark: Narcissa realizes that Harry is still alive & so she asks 'Draco? Is he still alive?" If you look real close, you can see Harry's head barely move to give her a nod "yes". Once she knew Draco was still inside Hogwarts, she lied to Voldemort in order to get to Draco.. Narcissa was never evil. She only cares about her son & doesn't give a shit about Voldy's plans. So if you think back on it, you realize that Harry was saved twice by a mother's love for her child - first Lily & then Narcissa. 🥰
Thanks for giving us more clarity on that, Nancy!!! What a fantastic series! The films were so captivating!!
Your explanation as to him being dead would apply for a dream too. I am pretty sure he never died even though he could choose to by boarding the train. Assuming you read the books, (spoilers ahead), he still had his mother's protection and the elder wand belonged to him. Voldemort uses the wand to torture him with Crucio, and Harry realizes that it actually didn't hurt. That was the wand protecting Harry. Stands to reason that it would also not kill him. I do wish this was made clear in the movies.
If I remember well, in the last movie Harry lets the resurrection stone fall from his hand (on the ground of the forbidden forest) after he could see his parents and Sirius again, to comfort him as he thinks he's going to die.
So he doesn't even have the resurrection stone with him when Voldemort casts the death spell on him.
But the spell didn't kill Harry, he killed the part of Voldemort that was still living (as a horcrux) in Harry.
Harry was just unconscious, or maybe in a semi-coma state but I doubt it, as he emerged quickly (because he nodded to Narcissa's question).
My interpretation is that Harry was in shock as a side effect of the Avada Kedavra spell, making him faint a moment.
During that moment, his mind made him dream of Dumbledore, which is why Harry said something like "all of this is in my head ?" and Dumbledore answered "Of course IT IS. But that doesn't mean it isn't real" (because that's an interpretation of Harry's mind, based on reality. The real question would be "to what point ?").
Every dream has a part of reality in it.
So if you dream of an event, maybe it says something about the reality it is related too ;)
Harry was able to return from the dead since he was at the time the rightful owner of the hallows, which made him a master of death.
@@ZetaReticuli87 "If I remember well, in the last movie Harry *lets the resurrection stone fall from his hand* (on the ground of the forbidden forest) after he could see his parents and Sirius again"
That means he doesn't have the resurrection stone when he is hit by the killing curse
Harry’s father‘s Petronas is a stag, his mothers Petronas was a doe. We’re pretty sure that Snape’s original Petronas was something different but through his love for Lily his Petronas changed into a doe as well.
Patronus* sorry had too
I think Snape has this petronas all time, because he love Lily in school, maybe before, and after THAT he will know on the lessons how make petronas
@@SherriLyle80s no worries. I did not catch the typo. I’m usually better than that.
I thought he said it was always a doe.
I don't think he ever had a different one..
Lilly was his only happy memory and happy thing in his life in general... 😭❤️
23:44 That's Lavender Brown, Ron's ex-girlfriend from HP6. She's dead in the movie, but her fate was never confirmed on canon (from the book or JKR)
Despite she and Hermione didn't like each other, Lavender was still supportive of the trio and fought during the battle, and Hermione still tried to save her during the battle
Lavender?! Ugh!! Tragic
@@tktopmoviesyeah She was lavender, bitten and killed by fenrir greyback (we saw him in sixth one) but the photograph guy colin creevey also died in the battle
The room of requirement turns into the room of hidden things when the user requires a place to hide things as long as the room is not in use. That’s where Draco was fixing vanishing cabinet and where Harry hid the potions book in the half blood prince. In the last book, Harry had to ask everyone to leave the room of requirement (their hideout) so he could enter that room.
And now you know why Snape is my favorite character. He really was so brave to do what he did. His last words were, "You have your Mother's eyes." He did it all because of his love for Lily. The whole story of Harry Potter is amazing. Great reaction. Much love.
He really is an amazing character!
He definitely loved her that's why after her death his patronus changed to a doe
@@Port19692 didn’t he say it was always a doe?
Brave yes, paragon of virtue...no. He still was at one point a card carrying Death Eater and also bullied the crap out of Lily's son. Don't think she'd have been too thrilled about the way Snape treated Harry.
@@scottswenson383 So true. Plus, even a lot of people who had read the books gloss over the fact that Severus gave the partial prophesy to Voldemort and he also knew it could have meant Harry or Neville. He was just fine with Neville, Harry, and James dying. He bargained with Voldemort for Lily only, as if she would have been grateful to be spared while her husband and baby were killed. Dumbledore even asked him about it and he admitted it and begged him to keep Lily safe, only throwing in her baby and husband after Dumbledore was disgusted.
Narcissa Malfoy ( Draco's mother) Asks harry if draco is alive when she is asked to see whether he is dead or not then he nods and she lies to voldemort by saying he is dead which could've got her killed but all she wanted was to protect draco.Also harry dropped the reserection stone so it didnt bring him back
Isn't the Resurrection Stone only meant to ressurect (make them appear) other people and not the holder?
can you pls explain how lying to voldemort that harry is dead protects draco?
She didn’t lie to protect Draco really. It was almost tit for tat. She wanted an answer about the well being of her son and Harry slightly shook his head and gave himself away to answer her so she did him a solid in return by lying.
@@ScragsP22 Ye I wrote it wrong to what I was trying to say but I meant she wanted to know if Draco is alive because of her love for him and then lied to voldemort which is a big risk . The biggest thing to her in her life was draco's safety
@@ScragsP22 I agree with that its kind of what i was trying to say but i struggle with explanations
James is Harry's dad. Severus Snape and Lily had the same patronus because of his love for her. Everything Snape did was to protect Harry because of him being Lily's son.
I have thoroughly enjoyed watching all eight movies with you. Your reactions and the way you talked about how the characters evolved is wonderful. Thank you.
Hey Larry!! Thank you so much for watching with us :) We appreciate your kind words!! So happy to hear that you've enjoyed our videos! Stay tuned for more!!!
For clarity, because the movie isn't as clear as the books, Nacrissa asks Harry if Draco is still alive, because she can feel his heartbeat and knows that Harry is still alive. She doesn't answer to Voldemort anymore, she just cares about her son. Since Harry saved Draco in the Room of Requirement, he knew he was alive, so he was able to tell her that he is alive, thus causing her to lie to Voldemort. He was thwarted by a mothers love once again.
Regarding how Harry came back, it had nothing to do with the Resurrection Stone. In the 4th book Voldemort uses Harry's blood to restore his body, which in turn caused Lily's protection charm to live on inside him. This means that Voldemort can NEVER kill Harry himself, he will always come back. Also fun fact: Harry dying in the forest cast the same protection spell on the entire school, so Voldemort could also not harm a single person himself.
Plus the elder wand wouldn’t kill Harry because it recognized him as its true master.
@@brendafrazier811 yeah, also this! but the outcome would’ve been the same had it not been the EW :)
One of the theories.
@@MrZeuz666 Its way more clear in the books but its definitely the answer. Its even foreshadowed in book 4 Dumbledore's expression changes to triumph when Harry tells him Voldemort used his blood. Then Dumbledore explains it in book 7. Also Rowling has confirmed it.
Thanks for watching with us and for clarifying some of our questions!!! We appreciate it :)
Harry survived from Voldemord's Avada Kedavra because it only killed the 1/7 of Voldemord's soul inside Harry, which is that bloody infant resembles Voldemord under the bench in the limbo (the heaven-alike King's Cross Station).
The Resurrection Stone was used to see the dead ones you loved, not actually bringing someone back to live. Harry dropped it after using it to see his parents, Sirius, and Remus, because he didn't want to be too attached to the stone and thus moved on. All he needed to know is those loved one who passed away have been always with him in his heart.
1/8th of Voldemort’s soul.
@@MrsLauraD 1/1000th
The Elderwand refused to kill its owner (Harry) so it just killed the Horcrux inside Harry's body.
Yeah this is the plot hole. The worst plot hole in the series because the rest of the story is built on top of it. Harry wasn’t even supposed to be a horcrux. Firstly, you have to be intentional in creating a horcrux and Voldemort wasn’t when it happened with Harry. It gets worse. The only reason Harry is a horcrux is because Lily sacrificed herself. That’s sacrificial love, the most powerful form of love. So then you realize that the horcrux, the most evil object known to the wizarding world, is created directly out of Lily’s sacrifice, the most powerful form of love in the world. This is not only a plot hole that the whole story rests upon, but a mythological inconsistency. A greater good can come out of evil, but evil doesn’t really come from good. This is why when you really examine the Harry Potter mythology as a whole, it breaks down. If you’re looking for good mythology and good story, The Lord of the Rings is the best. Rowling has much to learn from Tolkien. And I say all this as a fan of both and as someone who grew up with Harry Potter and not The Lord of the Rings.
@rafiki1017 lol it's not a plothole simply because you don't like it.
Harry came back to life, because of Voldemort's ignorance, when he did the spell and used Harry's blood to come back to life, there in Goblet of Fire, Voldemort linked himself to Harry's blood, and the same protection as the Harry's mother put it on him, so Voldemort himself served as Harry's Horcrux, in other words, as long as Voldemort lives, Harry cannot die, unless he doesn't want to come back to life.
This is one of the many "good" theories. It's however not the only one, and it is not canon exactly what is the deciding factor.
Well simple explanation can be - when voldemort used the killing curse on harry, he killed the part of himself in harry and not harry himself. That's why harry had the choice to go back to life or stay dead like dumbledore told him.
@@MrZeuz666 In fact, the author confirms this "theory", and all Harry Potter channels and websites say the same thing.
@@AmitKumar-yl6bz No, he didn't die because of his blood on Voldemort.
@@MrZeuz666 I’m pretty sure that in the book Dumbledore actually tells Harry that this is the case
Harry asking “does it hurt?” always gets me 😭
The "Dungeons" aren't as ominous as McGonagall makes it sound. The dungeons are the Slytherin common room.
Oh, man.... seeing Fred laying on the floor in the Great Hall dead is heartbreaking,. But seeing Ron, who's usually so cheerful, break down in tears makes it worse every time I watch. It's even worse for George. He was never able to cast the Patronus Charm again, since it relies on a person's happiest memories to function and all of his happy memories involved his twin brother Fred. Also, the prophecy spoke of a boy born at the end of July....there were actually two: Harry Potter and Neville Longbottom. They were born in the same month and year, but Neville is only one day older than Harry.
Fred
@@tktopmovies It really is. The entire Weasley family took a slap in the face in this one.
@@rainbowpegacornstudios And his death in the books is SO MUCH more painful :')
I know...the way that everybody's trying to be calm, even mrs.weasley stroking fred's head and george is the only one who's slightly frantic. You could feel the pain and confusion and the absence.
@@tktopmovies
The whole thing with Severus being in love with Lily is even sadder when you learn that he accidentally insulted her by calling her a Mudblood and he never got the opportunity to apologize for it.
At the beginning of this reaction when Katie said that she was going to read the books, I had to smile. By reading the books all of the questions that Ty was asking at the end will be answered.
I would watch them reading the books!
And so much more will also be answered!
I fell in love with my husband when we read Wuthering Heights to each other. You guys should totally read the books to each other. Or at least some of them. You might be even more in love by the end.
Draco’s mom was asking Harry if Draco was alive. She clearly saw Harry nod, knowing Draco and Harry himself was alive. She lied and said Harry was dead to protect him
Come on, Narcissa clearly said "Drank it with a lime", and then Harry nodded in agreement.
You got it right the first time 😆
That was probably the funniest unintentional moment I have seen!
Kudos to you both for not making me wait another week for the conclusion to the series. Thanks
Just laughed out loud!!!!! LOL Thanks for watching with us, Phillip!
The reason why Voldemort couldn't kill Harry was not because of the stone, it was because of the wand. At the end of the movie we find out that the Elder wand belonged to Harry, and the want could never truly hurt its owner. So, that's why it didn't kill Harry, it only killed the Voldemort part of him.
Voldemort never wanted the Deathly Hallows; he only wanted the wand. He got the wand from Dumbledore’s corpse, but it betrayed him because the wand belonged to Draco Malfoy after Draco disarmed Dumbledore in the Astronomy Tower. The wand becomes Harry’s when he disarms Voldemort in the final battle.
@@ThatBlackPiano I believe the wand became Harry's when he disarmed Draco at Malfoy Manor.
@@valbonney2575 the wand Harry took off of Draco was not Dumbledore's wand; Draco never actually handled that wand. At Malfoy manor Harry took Draco's usual wand from him. Olivander evaluates the wand and tells Harry that since Harry took the wand from Draco the wand has now changed its allegiance.
@@ThatBlackPiano From an interview with JK Rowling: “To truly own the Elder Wand, which means to receive the full benefits, double-edged though it is, of all its power, you have to have conquered the previous owner,” explained Rowling.
At the end of Book 6, “Half-Blood Prince,” Draco disarmed Dumbledore before Snape killed Dumbledore.
“And that meant he conquered him, even though Dumbledore was very weak at the time, he was very ill. He was on the point of collapse when it happened,” Rowling said. “Dumbledore didn’t want to lose his wand at that point and Draco disarmed him. So that meant that the wand gave Draco its allegiance, even though Draco never knew it, even though Draco never touched it.
“From that moment on, that wand gave its allegiance to Draco, and it wouldn’t work as well for anyone but Draco.”
When Harry wrestles Draco’s “everyday” wand out of his hand at the Malfoy’s mansion, he conquers Draco, and therefore the Elder Wand - hidden in Dumbledore’s tomb at the time - transfers its allegiance to Harry.
I remember finishing the book right before the movie (part 1) was released. My husband had been following the film franchise only. So when I told him that Snape was my favorite character in the series, he thought I had lost my mind. No honey, my mind was lost long before Harry Potter - LOL. 🤪 I just kept telling him "OK, you hate Snape with a passion. You're entitled to your own opinion." BUT in my head, I was thinking to myself "Yeah, juuuust waaaaait....." 🤐 When the reveal was shown, I wasn't watching the flashback scenes, I was watching my hubby's facial reactions as he slowly came to understand that Snape, although a very complex character with many dark traits, was actually a good guy & the unnamed hero of this whole damn saga. Yes, Harry was "the chosen one" but it was all made possible because of Snape's loyalty to Lily. Now you know the reason why millions of Harry Potter fans got tattoos that read "Always". By the way there wasn't a year gap between these two final films. It was 8 months- part 1 came out in November 19, 2010 then part 2 dropped on July 15, 2011.
Now that you've finished the films, please check out all the behind the scenes videos talking about casting, costume/set designs, CGI & practical effects, blooper reels, & most importantly all the deleted scenes. There are videos on RUclips that have compilations of all the deleted stuff. Oh, also back in January 2022 they released Harry Potter 20th Anniversary - Return to Hogwarts special on HBO. It was really good - a definite MUST SEE! There is one scene where "Hagrid" talks about how much the series meant to him & his kids. It was especially poignant because we lost Hagrid (aka Robbie Coltrane) last October. RIP Hagrid, it's not Hogwarts without you... 😢
But the biggest lost for me was when Alan Rickman passed away in 2016. I've been a fan of him since Die Hard came out in 1988. I can't believe it's been 7 years since he died. 💔 Before he played Snape, my favorite character he portrayed on screen was the over-the-top & completely looney, Sheriff of Nottingham in "Robin Hood - Prince of Thieves" (1991) starring Kevin Costner & Morgan Freeman. I know you're supposed to cheer for the "hero" Robin Hood & not the "bad guy", but I tell you, Alan's performance is riveting and hilarious! His character is my favorite part of the whole movie. 🤣
Snape's character development throughout the whole journey was insane!!!!! And ugh--That is so sad to hear about the passing of Robbie Coltrane and Alan Rickman :( :( :( We definitely will be checking out the reunion ASAP!!!!!!
I didn’t read the books until my blind daughter age 11 at the time in 2006 suggested I read the books since she was listening to books on audio. Then in 2007 we were waiting for Deathly Hallows book to be released. I read first 12 chapters to my daughter since the book on CD was not available in our local store yet. Once she got the book on CD we were racing each other to get to the end. After finishing, I woke her to say I was finished about 11 am. She said “Oh, I finished about 5 am this morning after all night binge” I really thought I won lol
LOVE to hear that!!! What an incredible story, huh?!
A little detail that's there if you know about it. Lupin and Tonks were married, and trying for a baby. They did have a boy called Teddy before they both died in the Battle Of Hogwarts. Teddy is best mates with the Potter and Weasley kids. He was on the train with them.
Actually by that point he was 19 years old and out of Hogwarts. He was at Kings’ Cross to say goodbye to his girlfriend who was Bill and Fleur’s daughter.
@@brendafrazier811 good point. I got that wrong.
Also Harry is Teddys godfather ❤❤
Indeed harry is teddy’s godfather
They also weren't trying for a baby Lupin was distraught and upset about the baby until after he was born. And he realized the baby wasent a werewolf.
Snape had the same patronus as Lilly because he truly loved her. James is Harry's dad. Great reaction BTW. I watched the whole series with you guys and it was a really fun ride.
So happy to hear you've enjoyed our journey! WHAT A STORY!
When you love so much somebody, your patronus becomes the same as the person's, that's why Severus's patronus was the same as Lily's. And Snape was the only death eater that could produce a patronus
My favorite part about Voldemort's death was the fact that despite being the greatest evil wizard alive, he ultimately meets his demise by returning practically to a puff of smoke, as if he had never been anything more than a bad dream all along. Just that juxtaposition of his extreme power and the way he was so easily destroyed once all of his lifesources were no longer available to him always fascinates me. It's just another example of Rowling's amazing writing skills.
not actually. In the books Rowling wrote he just dies as a normal human. The thing he always tried to avoid. He pretended to be unique, magical and powerful but at the end... he was just like any other human.
@@keyjenkable And that's why the book death is far superior! But I get it that film is another medium to book so you have to visualize more
When I read the book, I kept flipping back to reread it all over and over. It blew me away. It was a total mind blower. I couldn't believe it.
Literally just finished watching part 1 half an hour ago and now get this! Love it! Just starting it now. Can't wait for you to reach the end.
What a journey it has been!! Thanks for watching with us :)
Been following since the beginning and earned my subscription. I love how invested you both were and its always great to hear the theories that you both had.... definitely recommend watching the deleted scenes to get a lot of emotional moments they cut (and yes! Read the books!)
Yes, watching deleted scenes is a great idea!
Hey Steven!! Aw thank you so much for the kind words!! We are thrilled to hear that you are enjoying our videos!! More to come! :)
My favorite short moment in this movie is when Voldemort realizes Harry is alive.
A very short scene, but I love it so much...An intence closeup of pure confusion and fear on Voldemort's face...He desperately tries to blow one hall after the other in a sheer pathetic desperation to catch Harry..
He wasted all his life on finding a key to immortality, tried to be the fearsome legend..But yet the kid he had failed to kill all those years ago is brought back to life..Not only did he failed to kill him AGAIN, Harry managed to do what he couldn't - he cheated death in the most purest way...
And there he is, once menacing and powerful Dark Lord, trembling in fear and screaming in the void, once again unable to kill the same person, as his men left him behind in a cowardly escape, realizing their defeat..
It's why in the half blood Prince, Snape's avarda kedvra spell was blue rather than green because he had to kill him but he didn't want to, it will be green if you have the intent to kill the person
You guys are so nice and wholesome❤️❤️ loved your reactions to this series!
Aww :) Thank you SO much for watching and for being so kind!
There’s this video this guy does that’s mind blowing, “Dumbledore’s Big Plan” I think it’s called. Incredible insight into everything Dumbledore did behind the scenes throughout the whole thing to orchestrate the circumstances surrounding Harry being able to pull this off.
Super Carlin Brothers or Harry Potter Theory do these ‘what ifs’ really well.
Watching on the side of the road because I'm so excited 😂😂😂
Hahaha awwwww! That made us smile :) Thank you SO much for watching, Katherine!!!!
You guys made this watch emotional, and it was great. Thank you for sharing this journey with us. Really enjoyed it.
What a journey it has been!!!
at the 12:10 mark if you pay attention, Snape never casts a spell against McGonagall. It's not that he fears her but rather he respects her as she is a member of the Order like he was. He only blocks her attacks & again, look real close & you'll see him deflect her spells to the two figures standing behind him. Those are the Carrow twins & they are Deatheaters who are in charge of student discipline. Neville mentions that as they walk through the tunnel to Hogwart's Room of Requirement. Also, right before Snape flies out of the window, he quickly grabs each of the Carrows' wands too. It happens in a flash so you'll have to rewind & watch it again to catch all those little hidden "Easter egg" clues to Snape's real character.
Note - McGonagall telling Flich to take all the Slytherin students to the dungeons is really not a big deal. They never mention it in the films, but the Slytherin dorms & common room are in a secret location hidden near the dungeons of Hogwarts. In the film, they are shown being locked in a cell & then breaking right out - LOL!
Please remember that not all Slytherins are evil as they portray in the movies. There have been several dark wizards/witches who happened to have been in Slytherin House as students, but that doesn't make all Slytherins bad. It is a stereotype & no one ever mentions the fact that there have been numerous good Slytherins, some fought against Voldemort. A few examples of good Slytherins - Prof. Slughorn, Prof. & headmaster Snape, Regulus Black (Sirius' little brother), Narcissa Black (later Malfoy), Andromeda Tonks (Narcissa & Bellatrix's sister), and many more in the history of the wizarding world. Don't forget the Sorting Hat wanted to place Harry in Slytherin because he had the traits that Salazar Slytherin valued most - ambition, determination, & resourcefulness. I am a proud member of Slytherin House! 🐍
Starting at the 23:24 mark we see a visual recap of the first 3 films. As the trio run out of Hogwarts & through the courtyard, they are chased by a troll (Sorcerer's Stone), then giant spiders (Chamber of Secrets), & finally they see the werewolf, Fenrir Greyback attacking a student (Prisoner of Azkaban). The dead student wasn't Colin Creevey (the photographer); that was Lavender Brown, Ron's first girlfriend who always wanted to "snog" Ron all the time.
Wow! I've watched the movies countless times, 20 each at least, but NEVER did I realize this little visual recap or thought about it. That's frigging awesome, thank you so much for noticing me/us! :)
Jut finished your Harry Potter journey with you and just wanted to say: Thank you, that was awesome, I really really enjoyed this! Been a huge HP fan ever since (books, audiobooks and films) and can't get enough of it :)
Thank you SO much for enjoying with us! :)
So funny you mentioned reading the books out loud to each other. My daughter and I did this when she was little and the books and movies were being released. Midnight releases of all of them after the 3rd as she wasn't old enough until then. That said, the memories of those house spent snuggling up with bed picnics while we took turns reading out loud to each other are absolutely priceless. I highly suggest reading them or even listening on audiobook. There is just so much more information. There are entire storylines that never show up in the movies that just make this a world that is even fuller and richer and more complex. From Harry and Dumbledore having disagreements to Hermione actually doing some sketchy crap occasionally to things l ike Dobby being in nearly every book but not movies, and Ginny and Harry's relationship being much, much more developed, etc. The books will only expand your love of the world and the people in it. Every single character really is that mix of light and dark that Sirius talked about in the books and they don't really shy from making that part of the story. Even Harry has moments where he has cause to feel truly bad for things he does and says even if his motivations may have been good. I hope you will read them and maybe do a 'book club' sort of series of videos so you can talk with us all about the things you discover and what you think of it all with the entire plot and story.
Very well said ❤❤❤
Hi Monique!! LOVE to hear that you have those special memories with your daughter! This was a fantastic series!!!!!!
I would watch the Harry Potter reunion next its really good and has a lot of the cast its not a movie but we find out secrets and other stuff!
I dunno, maybe wait a while first? Then it's extra warm and fuzzy
Yes
Coming soon! CAN'T WAIT for that!
@@tktopmovies Yayyy i'm so excited!
"drink it with a lime" has me rolling. ya'll are good fun. thanks for the upload.
LOL!!! Thanks for being here and enjoying with us! :)
I noticed no one answered your question at the 3:58 mark regarding Griphook wanting the Sword of Gryffindor. They never say it (in the films) but the sword was made by goblins centuries ago & because of that, it is enchanted with powerful magic. Goblins have a different definition of "ownership" than humans (wizards in this case). There is a long standing history of ownership disputes & bad blood between the goblins & Godric's heirs after he died.
I have so enjoyed watching your reactions to these films. You are too stinkin' cute and I can't wait to see more.
Just some quick answers--because you asked ;-) :
Snape is definitely not Harry's father. James' Patronus was a stag and Lily's was a doe. In the books Harry says, 'Snape's Patronus was a doe...the same as my mother's, because he loved her for nearly all of his life, from the time when they were children'.
Narcissa asks Harry if Draco is alive and he very quietly says "yes". At that point she just wants to get to her son so she tells Voldemort Harry is dead, knowing that Voledemort would immediately go to the castle to show off Harry's dead body to his enemies. At that point she no longer cared who won.
I really, really hope you decide to read the books. There are so many things the movies simply don't have the time to explain. If you wanted to listen to them together I very much recommend the audiobooks narrated by Jim Dale. I know a lot of people like the Stephen Frye versions (and they are really good) but the Jim Dale is another level of wonderful. He has the kind of voice that really creates a mood and he does such distinct voices for every character that you know exactly who is talking, without even being told. Enjoy!
Hi Ne Pe!!! Thank you so much for the nice words and for watching our videos!! We had so much fun on this journey! And we will be checking out the reunion too!! The books would definitely be really nice to enjoy as well!
23:43 that part had me laughing "young boy"
That was Lavender Brown, Rons ex girlfriend in the 6th film/book
The resurrection stone DOESN'T BRING BACK TO LIFE, we saw in the previous part in the story of the 3 brothers how it works, and it works as follows: it can summon a person from beyond the grave just like Harry summoned his parents, Sirius and Lupine, but he didn't resurrect them and didn't give them life again only he could summon them in the form of a kind of spirit, but they did not belong to the world of the living.
Harry survived because Voldemort, when reborn in the 4th part, used Harry's blood, the same blood that flowed in the veins of his mother and through her sacrifice gave protective power.
Dumbledore knew that Harry must die because he is a Horcrux, but he also knew that if Harry was resigned to death and his fate and was willing to sacrifice, then Voldemort would only kill the part of his soul in Harry, not Harry himself, and thus he could return . Dumbledore didn't tell Harry this because if Potter knew it would survive his sacrifice wouldn't be sincere and thus he couldn't return, so Dumbledore kept it to himself.
The resurrection stone itself DOES NOT RETURN LIFE, and Dumbledore gave it to Harry in a snitch with the signature, "I open at the close" so that Harry could just before meeting Voldemort, being reconciled with death, meet his loved ones to give him comfort before what he must become.
And when Harry had supposedly died and in fact Voldemort only destroyed part of his soul in Harry, Narcissa Malfoy Draco's mother came over to check if he was dead, she noticed he was alive so she asked him if Draco survived the battle, Harry nodded yes and then Narcissa lied to Voldemort saying that the boy dies saving him for Harry saving her son earlier.
It is worth noting the behavior of the Malfoys during the Battle of Hogwarts.
They didn't fight at all, they just focused on finding their son and that's all that mattered to them, so Lucius tried to persuade Voldemort to stop the attack on the school because Draco was in it, and Narcissa, when she found out that he survived, lied to Voldemort.
After Harry was revealed to be alive and the Malfoys had already found Draco, they left Voldemort and left.
So they weren't entirely evil and served Voldemort out of fear and willingness to be on the winning side, not like Bellatrix who was his blindly obedient follower.
At 23:40 ish when Fenrir Greyback (a werewolf) was indulging in his prey, that was Lavender Brown, the girl that was all over Ron snogging him constantly during Half-Blood Prince. It was not the photographer boy.
Aboyt 28:30 the doe. Was Lily's patronus, but Snape loved Lily so much, he had the same patronus as her.
33:20 when Narcissa Malfoy was talking to Harry, she could tell he was alive and breathing quietly. She asked Harry if Draco was alive and when he nodded, she lied to Voldemort. She has motherly compassion, but has a rotton husband and family, she helped Harry, especially after him saving Draco. You will learn in the books about a "life debt".
34:30 notice how Draco doesn't go when his father calls him, but responds when his mother does. He doesn't want to follow in his father's footsteps.
39:25 that is why Dumbledore allowed Draco to disarm him and let Snape kill him. Voldemort didnt know wand lore.
Also there is a surprise you will find out in the book that Harry does with the Elder Wand using it to cast a spell. I'll let you learn about it when you read it. So keeping it a surprise and hope no one else spoils it.
Now remember, all three of the Deathly Hallows belonged to Harry. The wand belonged to him, he had the cloak and the stone, he was a master of death.
DEFINITELY read the books. There is a lot. Including a BIGGER battle in Half Blood Prince. A lot more action with Dobby and with Kreacher who is very involved in the battles as well.
Now as you mentioned, you got to see these back to back. We had to wait a YEAR!!! Watching 1 midnight show then waiting a year for the next midnight movie. Over 1000 people were waiting at the movie theater to get in. Waiting outside in the cold winter temperatures for over an hour until the doors opened and then we waited INSIDE for over an hour. (made sure to use the bathroom before picking up my friend and going to the theater).
Hey Dave!!! Thank you for typing all of these awesome facts to answer our questions :) We appreciate that!!!
I've been waiting this 😩what a reaction and what a hp Journey with u two😍 thanks and good luck 💛⚡
Thank you so much for watching along with us :)
For a lot of us it was a little easier to wait the year for the second part because we had read the book, so we knew how the story ended. But, I can say that if I hadn't read the books, it would have been TORTURE!!!
YESSSS! The way Part 1 ended was totally torture with Voldemort with the elder wand! Ahhhhhh!!! Loved this series. Thanks for watching with us :)
It was torture waiting the year for the book came out. For me, i reread the entire series before the release of each new book just so the entire story would be fresh when i read the new content. Ive read the entire series probably 15 times.
@@donaldriddle230 Yes, waiting for the books was complete torture. I absolutely agree.
42:09 if you really love someone, your patronus can compliment or become the same as your partner’s patronus😊 they didn’t explain it well in the movies. Snape’s patronus became the same as Lily’s patronus.
33:27 "drink it with a lime" killed me amazing reaction both of you :)
LOL!!!! Laughing! Thanks for watching with us, Daxellz!!!! (:
To explain the patronus being the same, that happens when you love someone. Lily was a doe and James (who is Harry's dad, think of all the times people say he looks just like James) was a stag so they were also paired.
It has been so much fun being on the journey with you both, but it's not quite over yet. The 20th anniversary reunion is a must, and I think you'd both find the 'Deathly Hallows' deleted scenes really interesting, particularly the ones involving Petunia, Dudley and Draco. Once again lovelies, thank you both for sharing this journey.
Aww thank you so much Christine!
Snape is not Harry's father. Snape's patronus is the same as Harry's mother because she was his one true love, even if she only saw him as a friend. When Voldemort asks Draco's mother to check if Harry is dead, she sees he's alive and asks him if Draco is still alive, then because of this lies to Voldemort that Harry is dead. The Resurrection Stone is just to bring back loved ones, not to resurrect yourself.
The book The Golden Child starts right at the end of this movie. Hasn't been made into a movie yet but it's a good one
Use your brains! The whole series Harry is being told that he looks like his dad: James Potter not Snape! The resurection stone only brings images of love ones, it only served to strengthen Harry's resolve and be a part of the united Hallows (master of death. Although Voldemort had the wand, he was not master of it. Harry was the master of all 3. The main reason Harry didn't die was Voldemort had Harry's blood in him from when he was regenerated. Lilly's ancient majic continued to protect Harry and he did similar: but see the books for this.
He used the resurrection stone to bring back the people he loved the most, to give him courage, to say what he needed to say, that he didn't mean for anyone to die for him, to give himself the strength to do what needed to be done. Then, when he was ready, he dropped the stone and let them go.
I thoroughly enjoyed watching with you. Harry was protected by ancient magic that his mother used on him. It came into effect when she sacrificed herself for him therefore protecting him. Harry also cast that same ancient magic on his friends there at hog warts when he chose to sacrifice himself. But because it blanketed so many people it was possibly not as strong as the one his mother placed on him. Severus’ deep love for Lily is what made his patrons the same as Lily’s and because he could see Lily in Harry he became attached to Harry and cared for him but could never display it.
Thank you so much for watching with us, Eve!!!!
My favorite part in this film is the final reveal at the end, but my 2nd favorite scene is Hermione disguised as Bellatrix. That is no CGI photoshop of Bellatrix's face on Hermione's body. That is really Helena Bonham Carter (Bellatrix) pretending to be Hermione, who is pretending to be Bellatrix - LOL! She even has all of Hermione's facial expressions down. If you watch the behind the scenes interviews, there is one of Helena talking about how she managed to capture all of Hermione's little quirks & personality traits. 😊
Oh wow!!!!
Always gets me when I see Harrys Son having a father to take him onto the platform, something Harry himself never had.
Every movie had some kind of twist at the end. The first had Quirrel as Voldemort's servant, the second had Tom Riddle as the heir to Slitherin and being Voldemort, the third had Sirius actually having been framed by Petigrew, the fourth was Voldemort returning, the fifth was Sirius dying, the sixth was Dumbledore dying, Snape being the one to kill him, and Snape being the titular Half-Blood Prince, the seventh was, actually did the first part of Deathly Hallows actually have one? Dobby died, but he wasn't the only death in it. The stuff about Snape in this one, though, was truly a crown moment for the series.
Not me still crying over Fred Weasley 16 years after that midnight release of the book....I'll still be crying when I'm 90 in the nursing home.
i know im 7 months late to the party but i really enjoyed watching this series with you guys. i am a huge harry potter fan and you guys bring me so much joy the way you genuinely get so immersed in the movies, trying to understand everything the best you can , remembering information is really heartwarming and you guys are great! keep this channel up, no doubt your subscribers will grow and grow
This is so nice 🥰 Thank you so much for watching with us! We appreciate that so much!!!! We are so happy to hear that you’re enjoying our videos :)
It took me several times seeing it to realize that when Snape does his patronus - that is the patronus doe that goes out in the woods and leads Harry to the Sword of Griffindor in Part I
"Severus, please." has new meaning after you see this.
Snapes patronus is a doe because Lily was a doe, and he was in love with her. Harry's is a Stag because his dad James was an animagus that could turn into a stag to help when Lupin became a wolf.
ah yes, everyday on youtube this is what i look for, people reacting to harry potter. time to bingewatch all of your HP videos now.
The reason I think Harry didn't die is because the Deathly Hallows all belonged to him.The invisibility cloak from his father, the stone from Dumbledore and the wand because he won it from Draco. As foretold the one who owns all 3 D.H. is the Master of Death.
That's my favorite theory
Notice how each of the horcruxes was destroyed by a different person:
Harry killed the diary.
Dumbledore killed the ring.
Ron killed the locket.
Hermione killed the cup.
Goyle killed the diadem.*
Voldemort killed Harry.
Neville killed the snake.
*In the book, it was Crabbe that killed the diadem with the fiendfire spell - a very powerful "living fire" spell that can destroy horcruxes, but is very difficult to control. If you don't know what you're doing, it's extremely dangerous. And Goyle/Crabbe did not have sufficient skill to control it. Voldy used the same spell at the Ministry at the end of OotP.
The actor that played Crabbe got himself into some legal trouble and was unavailable for the last movie. Doesn't really change the story much though.
*Is literally watching snapes memories*
"Who's that?"
Snape was not Harry's dad. He was in love with Lily though, and his Patronus was the same as Lily's because of that. I also feel like Snape did love Harry as well, since he was Lily's son and had her eyes. I feel for Snape, he cared for Harry but was always reminded of James when he looked at Harry and James was a bully to Snape and married the girl he loved.
About the stone, remember Dumbledore left the Snitch to Harry on his will (the Malfoys had nothing to do with it). So, when you stop and think about it, Dumbledore had all the Deathly Hallows (he had the cloak, the stone and the wand).
The "Resurrection Stone" only allows you to see a shade of your loved ones. Harry didn't die b/c his protection still lived in his very skin thanks to Voldemort being reborn with his blood. Voldemort only killed the part of himself that was inside Harry.
Everyone seems to misinterpret what the Resurrection Stone even does. It doesn’t bring people back to life, it lets the user speak to a loved one kinda like a ghost.
Also, Narcissa defies Voldemort by lying to him because Harry saved Draco. It’s supposed to illustrate one of the overarching themes: love conquers all.
Snape changed his patronus to Lily’s because he loved her. Remember the doe showing Harry the sword in the lake? That was Snape.
*doe
Only a pure of heart can produce a patronous
I don’t know if someone has told you, but they named all of their kids after people they loved or admired. Albus Severus Potter. The other son’s name is James Sirius Potter and their daughter name is Lily Luna Potter. I enjoyed being on this journey with you guys. If you guys really read the books you should do a video review. You will be blown away with all the details the movies left out.
She's a mom worrying about her only son. We all know Narcissa just wants Draco. She knows Harry is not dead, instead of giving him away, she asked Harry if her son Draco is still alive. Remember, Narcissa doesn't want any of these to go far. She just wants to send her son to school and go back home. When Harry nodded yes, she decided to spare his life and lied to Voldemort.
And how can you not know who is the little boy with little lily on Snape's memory? With the hair and black garments and all, and it was Snape's memory so it was him we were watching. Good grief.
I like how they spread around who kills the horcruxes...
Tom Riddle's Diary - Harry
The Ring - Dumbledore
The Locket - Ron
The Cup - Hermoine
The Diadem - Group Effort, mostly Ron and Harry
Harry - Voldemort
Nagini - Neville
narcissa just wanted to make sure that harry knows how to properly enjoy a corona beer xD
drink it with a lime!
LAUGHING!!!!!!
It wasn't the stone that brought him back, since he dropped it before he died (for him, the correct thing was to sacrifice himself for hogwarts so he really wanted to die). I think Harry didn't die in the forest because at that moment he had the 3 relics being "the lord of death". The wand had responded to him since the day he disarmed Draco, the stone was with him all the time and the cloak since the first movie
Griphook wanted the sword because it was goblin made. Goblins believe that once the owner of the item dies, or no longer wants the item, it should be returned to the goblins. They believe "Passing down, or inheriting" goblin items was like stealing. and that the sword was stolen from them for hundreds of years since the original owner was long dead.
Harry became the owner of the Resurrection Stone because Dumbledore left it for him. He did not have to have it in his possession when he went to Voldemort(no chance of anyone finding it on his person. If you think about it, in the end, Harry had all the Deathly Hallows: the Invisibility Cloak, the Resurrection Stone and the Elder Wand so he was The Master of Death. He broke the wand because he realized how dangerous it could be in the wrong hands and all the terrible things that others could do in pursuit of obtaining them.
Snape's Patronus was the same as Lily's because he loved her so much, I'm not sure if it was always the same or his
changed after her death.
I don't know if anyone said it in the comments last video but , In the chamber of secrets Dobby promised never to try to save Harry Potters life again , he died breaking this promise which makes his death even more tragic.
Harry was a horcrux. To kill a living horcrux, Voldemort himself HAD TO DO IT by a killing spell. Because it was his own part of soul so he destroyed it himself. The memories of Snape was a set up to motivate Harry for death. Dumbledore was a good guy, but he knew that in the future Harry will see those moments so he played like that and told Snape that Harry MUST DIE. So Harry was 100% motivated to go and die.
Lilly has protected Harry by a love spell. It works as a shield. But the spell rebounded after her death so part of Voldemort's soul got inside Harry and nobody knew until Dumbledore discovered that in Half-Blood Prince movie.
Mothers are a dominant theme - Lily’s love protected Harry- Molly Weasley defeated Bellatrix protecting her daughter - Draco’a mum lied to Voldemort so she could get into Hogwarts to save her son - other character mothers had great effect on them and how they lived which are more apparent in the books. (Voldermort Sirius Snape Dumbledore)
Snape is not Harry’s father. Snape was in love with Lily until the end but Lily loved James. Snape only protected Harry because of Lily. James is Harry’s father.
The resurrection stone can’t bring you back from the dead. Like Dumbledore said in Goblet of Fire “No Spell can re-awaken the dead.” You can only use the stone to bring loved one’s back but it’s just a shadow of your loved one. Harry used the resurrection stone to see his parents and Sirius and Lupin before he “greeted death as an old friend.”
The resurrection stone did NOT bring Harry back from the dead, it only brought his loved ones back to him for a few moments. In the Wizarding World NOTHING can bring anyone back from the dead, it’s a steadfast rule (and I really respect that). So, what made Harry not die when Voldemort strikes him, was the fact that a piece of Voldemort’s soul was inside of Harry then, so Voldemort killed his own soul (even if unintentionally), not Harry himself.
If you want a great read. Listen to the Jim Dale audiobooks, he won a Grammy award for his narration of Goblet of Fire.
The Prince's Tale, which is the Chapter in the book looking at Snape's memories, is a complete game changer, because it finally reveals everything that has been going on behind the scenes from the very beginning. Snape is one of the deepest and most complex characters in literature, and secretly one of the most powerful wizards in the world. In fact, Dumbledore (The Archmage), Voldemort (Master of the Dark Arts), Snape (Master of Mental Magic), and Harry (Master of Death) are all the most powerful wizards of the respective generations. (Voldemort is actually about 30 years older than Snape.)
I stayed up late last night to see the full reaction. I loved watching these movies with you two.
Trina!!!! You're the best!!!!!
12:48 some theorize that McGonagall sent slytherin house to the dungeons so they didn’t have to fight their parents❤
I like that explanation other than Slytherin were bad.
@@jowbloe3673 it makes sense to me because McGonagall knows they aren’t all bad. She wouldn’t punish a whole because of a few. I think she had a deeper meaning.
Also, the resurrection stone can't bring people back from the dead, it can recall the spirit, which is why the third brother killed himself because he couldn't let her go and he couldn't physically bring her back. This allowed him to see his parents and Sirius and Remus, but it couldn't have brought them back physically. Dumbledore told Harry, I think in the 1st or 2nd movie, when he found that mirror that shows you your heart's desire, that no magic can bring people back from the dead.
The patronus changes based on deep emotion, you can take on someone else’s patronus. He loved Lily so Snape’s patronus became hers, the doe. That’s why Dumbledore saw the doe and looked at him in amazement, and said “lily”. Snape responded “always”. Shape never loved again. His patronus took on Lily’s patronus because he loved her so much. No, he was not Harry’s father.
Snape's patronus is a doe, just like Lily Potter's is a doe. I didn't read the book, but someone informed me that when someone really cares for another, their patronus can change to the other person's patronus, or it could just be that the share a strong bond or connection. He isn't Harry's father, both Harry and his father James share a stag for their patronus. Also, that was his second son that was named Albus Severus Potter, the older boy that went first had initials JSP, which stands for James Sirius Potter, in honor of his father and godfather.
lmao "drink it with a lime" 33:27 ....
LMAO i'm 33:23 😂
LOL!!!!
@@tktopmovies 🤣🤣
the curious thing is that the act that made Snape was the only one who knew from the beginning the importance of his character in the story
They asked for Bellatrix’s wand because they knew Harry had it, so they knew it wasn’t her.
She asked Harry if Draco was alive and he nodded yes, so she lied to Voldemort when she said he was dead.