I had the pleasure of using this aberrant speech of Winder to argue its falsehood in front of elders. Of course they are the ones to whom God reveals mistakes! I never returned to the kingdom hall again. greetings!
Why would God (supposedly the greatest communicator and originator of all languages) incompetently supply humans a book, so complex that they require a few men to repeatedly clarify its meaning? These red flags are so bright, even the blind can identify them.
Because "god" is a made up figment of frightened and uninformed peoples imagination. It's OKAY not to know something, people don't need to attribute what they perceive as the unknown to some senile, angry and vengeful sky daddy.
Why would he go through a lot of the pantomime that is predicted? The Church has always maintained the same doctrines and some things remain a mystery. Such as when the last judgement is.
@@lesliethomas7234 who says that Jehovah has anything to do with what you are asserting? ❓ Bear in mind that Jehovah has an adversary that is working hard to impede the message that he wants to deliver and communicate to mankind. Therefore the difficulties that you perceive maybe instigated and sent by the devil and his demons. Their sole desire is to impede the truth and promote the LIE, and challenge Jehovah God's sovereignty, for this they live and for that they will die. And they know it, but they do not wish to die alone they wish to take as many of mankind as possible with them out of spite... A thing of insanity among them.
Brothers, it is obvious, if the governing body were receiving new light from Jehovah, then what they get cannot be false light. If they are getting lights wrong that does not come from Jehovah and Jehovah have not chose them. Jehovah chose our lord Jesus alone and we are all only brothers
That light is God’s Word, the Holy Bible: “Your word is a lamp to my foot, and a light to my roadway.”-Isa. 60:2; Ps. 119:105. True Christians make the sacred Scriptures the light in their life, letting them serve as a burning lamp lighting up the way for their feet to go. To walk without stumbling spiritually in this world of thick gloom we must walk in the light that comes from God.
@@Naegy-u4z And if I may add! No where in the written accounts about the son of God and savior JESUS, did he ever pray or call God Jehovah, Yahweh or by any other name, but only and always FATHER! That’s old light but it would be new light to the brainwashed JW’s and that is because they have put their GB leaders first instead of listening to the words of Jesus! They give him lip service, but their hearts are far removed from him!
For goodness sake, this new light has been changing, swinging back and forwards for over 100 years within this Organization. The Creator of this universe and us, is honest and true. This organization accuses Almighty God as being deceptive and secretive. Does that make sense? What would you think if your fleshly father behaved that way??
@@revzone3544 actually this statement is not true 😠. Do faulty people mean faulty doctrine? Our critics". Is a video prepared by Jehovah's witnesses that answered these charges explicitly.
@@revzone3544 what is more there is no apology needed..... When they are correct. Cannot say the same for Christendom. Though sometimes they may be slow to change.
@rawbrutaltruth Brainwashed people don't know they're being deceived..when lies are repeated over and over, it becomes the truth to many people.. and people like having their ears tickled..they will even defend it...
@@rawbrutaltruth Like the 1914 lie.. that's the lie they get to believing... we are not in the last days... those days do not start until the great tribulation...lie on top of lie...
@revzone3544 and what is your evidence that the Great tribulation marks the beginning of the last days In Scripture Jesus clearly pointed out what would be the beginning of the pains of distress in Scripture. And it is notable that some things in the Bible often did not get fulfillment until maybe 1 to 200 years later, sometimes even more.. I will wait for you to present it, so that I may consider it, all the while making no promises to agree with it. I do believe this is fair. But before you can make a credible standing to support your idea that this does not start until after the Great tribulation, you will have to discount all the scriptures that say what those kinds of distress are, add discount the fact that they ever happen to this day. So you will have to overcome the scriptural evidence that points to them having already begun. And then shore up your case afterward. You may begin now. I will wait.
And when they make a mistake, who had revealed that erroneous understanding to them? And who guarantees that the new understanding is correct on this occasion? Enough of lies!
Ah, the classic "who watches the watchers?" dilemma! It's like trying to find the end of a never-ending loop-just when you think you've got it, there's another twist!
Let's just put it this way to your question. . 9x out of 10 is not x witnesses nor is it opposers, nor is it Christendom with its be darkened luminaries.. . It is not uncommon for children to misunderstand their parents on occasion s......... Get serious... But last but not least I wouldn't want to rely on you for the corrections. Or Christendom seeing how they've gotten so much wrong, they have had their own predictions among their disorganized denominations, even as late as 2,000. Some of them were thinking the world would end then. Understanding the Bible is far from flawless.
(Matthew 11:25) At that time Jesus said in response: “I publicly praise you, Father, Lord of heaven and earth, because you have hidden these things from the wise and intellectual ones and have revealed them to young children. The inspired utterance says definitely that in later periods of time some will fall away from the faith, paying attention to misleading inspired utterances and teachings of demons.”-1 Tim. 4:1.
Hmmm, so 7 false prophecies over 100 years from an organisation stating they are inspired prophets and the light is still getting brighter ?????? Their "light" is not coming from God. 7 times the WT received the wrong light. 7 times this false prophet got 7 prophecies wrong. Ron Hansen to the rescue of the WT false prophet. Calling Ron
Excellent job eviscerating these pretenders. You make it a simple question of logic for any JW... 1. New Light is revealed to the GB. 2. How can you trust the GB if they are neither infallible or inspired? That should flip the switch on for them to recognize they put their faith in men.
@@treasureon25 you are incorrect Jehovah's witnesses faith is in their God Jehovah, the god of Jesus, who is the head of the congregation, of his witnesses,. The facts are all too often it is apostates and vehement opposers who pushed the idea that they are to be considered infallible and unerring. Which is far from the truth. And has been for quite some time. Who stands the benefit from these false allegations. The clergy of Christendom and all who aspire to be a part of that clergy. Not to mention those who have attempted to infiltrate God's congregation for personal gain. Envy is a strong emotion that consumes them, and materialism . Is the beast that consumes them as the desire for material things and status consumes them as well They have become consumed by what they can get out of this old world before Armageddon comes. It is not inconceivable but they believe that they can gain all that there is to gain before they cease to walk this Earth. Many have the hope to consume as much as they can materially before Armageddon comes and wipes it all out. Mini may be perfectly happy if they are capable of doing so despite the high cost of possibly losing their life. Short-sighted but true
Quoting David Splain..”We do not have..the spirit” Of course you don’t. God doesn’t anoint liars. They have spirit, but it’s not Holy. By their own mouth.
This is super creepy but Rutherford write in one of his books that he was inspired but it was from fallen angels noe demons who broke from Satan because they didn't want the lake of fire. Rutherford bragged about it and trusted them? Out of the frying pan and into the fire.
The Bible says throughout that anyone who speaks of things that will happen in prophesy and they do not happen that they are not of God, and to do not listen to them. Jeremiah says it many many times. The jws are not getting information from Yahweh, they are from their father the devil.
@morningglory9288 oh my, who has been whispering in your ears..you clearly have no understanding of anything in the Bible. I'm sad and will pray for you.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts, but I believe there’s a misunderstanding of the purpose of this discussion. My video is focused on the misinterpretation of scripture and the doctrinal errors related to the "new light" teaching in Jehovah’s Witnesses. The conversation here is about the issues with how the Governing Body uses scripture to justify their beliefs, not a theological debate about the nature of Jehovah/Yahweh or Jesus. If you wish to discuss your perspective on the nature of God, Jesus, or any other theological matter, there are plenty of forums dedicated to that conversation. However, I encourage you to keep this discussion focused on the specific topic of the video-how Jehovah’s Witnesses are misinterpreting scripture to support their organizational teachings. I also ask that you refrain from personal attacks or making statements that are not related to the subject at hand. This is not a place for venting or blasphemy, but for an open and respectful discussion about the points raised in the video. Let’s keep the conversation productive and focused on the issues at hand.
@@drkKennedy I thank you for your information. I was a jw for twenty plus years and I know first hand how they twist script ure for their benefit. If speaking of Yahweh isn't a part of any discussion then what's the point...
So if the governing body is not inspired nor infallible, then how can we say God came up with something new.. this is so annoying.. I stopped attending after the overlapping generations..that's when I couldn't put my discernment offline but had to accept that it has been changed due to their interpretation. It was also one of the first times I heard them say they are not inspired.. I appreciate their efforts, but...
The Bible conveys a message of moderation and avoiding extremes. Ecclesiastes 7:15-20 teaches that being overly righteous, overly wise, overly wicked, or overly foolish is dangerous. It also warns against making hasty judgments about a person's character. Ecclesiastes 7:15-20 15 In this meaningless life of mine I have seen both of these: the righteous perishing in their righteousness, and the wicked living long in their wickedness. 16 Do not be overrighteous, neither be overwise- why destroy yourself? 17 Do not be overwicked, and do not be a fool- why die before your time? 18 It is good to grasp the one and not let go of the other. Whoever fears God will avoid all extremes. 19 Wisdom makes one wise person more powerful than ten rulers in a city. 20 Indeed, there is no one on earth who is righteous, no one who does what is right and never sins.🙏✝️❤️
@@shortflims2165 wise words indeed maybe Christendom should take note it has missed the mark of perfection oh so many more times than Jehovah's witnesses.,..
There is no new light you liars! The light came to the world 2k + years ago and his light doesn’t change and there is nothing else to add to it! Jesus is the way, truth, life, resurrection and only way to the FATHER and not Jehovah because that is not Gods name!
@@unclesalty7778 Exodus 6:23 and God spoke unto Moses and said unto him, I am the Lord; and I appeared on to Abraham unto Isaac by the name God almighty, but by my name Jehovah I was not known to them." Oops looks like this is some old light 🚨 🚨 that was from Christendom that Just did not quite fall on you. Wonder how that happened..... The passage that is posted with God's name is coming out of the King James translation of the Bible. The light that has been there all this time has not hit you yet, yet and still, you claim to be one who can determine what is new light and what is not light 🤔🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨. Give me this sorry State of affairs that is demonstrated by your post. I think I'll go find my own light 😏🤣🤣🤣
@@unclesalty7778 guess you better break out that Old King James version of yours because it appears that you are willfully under informed. Also there is a Jew who really has the lowdown regarding God's name that would considerably update your knowledge, and it's not coming from Jehovah's witnesses get there quickly you're embarrassing yourself.
@@unclesalty7778 don't fool yourself, you claimed the number father when you don't even know his name 🤣🤣🤣🤣 crack open that Bible, you really need to, turn off that black and white television , Herbert 😂🥱 ... Bye-bye
Reveled is past tense, revels is future tense. To say old light was wrong is to say God is in error. There is an “evil slave” in charge. (Matt 24:48-51) He “beats the other slaves” and gets some to follow. (Luke 12:45-48) Upon seeIng this, Jesus orders us to leave and head for the mountains. (Matt 24:15) He says “let the reader use discernment” not listen to a “faithful slave.” Jehovah’s brilliant prophesy only gives us more reason to believe and trust in him.
@ You are mistaken you neither know God or the scriptures Notice that Jesus begins the warning by saying “if ever.” These words show that what Jesus next described would not necessarily happen. It was as if Jesus was saying: ‘If the faithful and discreet slave were ever to treat the other slaves cruelly in these ways, the master would punish him severely.’ (See also Luke 12:45.) But the faithful and discreet slave as a group has continued to stay alert and to give out spiritual food of good quality.
Such good quotes ality they give false prophecies repeatedly , allow children to dye through refusal of blood transfusion and encourage members toie Throw your Bible away truthseeker , for you show you do not use it
@ Tell me why are there bloodless hospitals in America and other parts of the world Quite from Google At present, there are a substantial number of bloodless surgery procedures including cardiac and orthopedic procedures, and there are 75 hospitals functioning in the U.S. and 105 in additional countries including Italy, Canada, Switzerland, Chile, France, and Australia.
My name is blasphemed among the nations because of you. Don’t these guys see that by repeatedly saying “Jehovah” and charging him after their mistakes, the people outside of their cult think less of the One God? This is embarrassing dudes, really embarrassing
You know, one side of my family are JW’s and I notice most of them are married but most haven’t had children, I don’t know why but they seem to be waiting for the “New system”. This mindset might be the same for other married Jw couples, there isn’t anyone to force into the JW organization and that’s why numbers are declining and people have discovered the organization does weird things that Jesus himself never said or did like disfellowshipping, Shunning etc and mostly them denying the divinity of Jesus. I’m not saying you have to have children but that seems to have been the main thing getting them members, no kids = no growth because no one who is an actual Christian would join them. No trying to be rude but there it is….
No one has ever become a Jehovah’s Witness by reading the Bible alone. But millions have come to a saving faith in Jesus Christ. He is the way truth and the life. Not an 18th century organization who has falsely predicted Armageddon for the last 150 years.
My question would be if it wasn't the proper time on the things they now have to chage; then why even teach it? That is misleading and admitting it without admitting it.. if they didnt understand it back then they shouldn't have acted as if they did let alone teach it as truth.. and their not inspired wow then why are they the ines leading 0 the irony is sickening
As long as these 11 men deny their followers the very hope THEY themselves entertain, they will continue to be blind guides, groping in spiritual darkness grasping for “new light”. Nowhere does the Bible teach there are 2 roads to life. Baptism is not about making a dedication vow, getting baptized in symbol of that dedication, living up to that vow,obeying the governing body to be God’s ‘friend’. One is not saved by hard work and sincerity. We’re either Children of God or Children of the Devil. There is no 3rd party option. 1 John 3:10. Ephesians 4:4-6
I regret wasting a huge portion of my life in the organization of Jehovah's witnesses six years as an elder. My waking up came when I was appointed as Watchtower Study conductor. It helped me to not only realize that these guys are lying to the world that they are God's channel of communication to all living humans but that God has got nothing to do with all of organized religion. Perhaps I realized something even crazier, namely that actually the Bible itself didn't exist in Bible times. For example the Apostle Paul whom the witnesses love so much did not have the volume that we today call the Bible. It's a cherry picked compilation which the Romans came up with. In my view it is such a blatant misnomer to even call the book "God's Word." JW's version of the Bible make things even worse by its title "New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures" because not everything in the compilation is "holy" scripture. For example, how can the Letter to Timothy where Paul said "All scripture is inspired of God" be part of scripture?😅 Or how could the Gospels which were only recorded as testimonial to the fulfilment of scripture be part of scripture. So, the New World Translation has perhaps the most blasphemous titles for a Bible version. In any case, not only the witnesses, but Christians in general have put the Bible on the wrong pedestal. Thankfully, Yeshua or Jesus is not even presented to be a member of an organized religion but a heretic and perhaps the greatest heretic to have walked this earth and religion hated him to death. He said he'd be gone but to keep worshipers on course did he promise a book? I think we all know the answer to that. Any way, I'm glad that I no longer put the love of my religion (or beliefs) between myself and another human. Never again will I waste even a second of my life to support such useless ideas as exposed in your video. Great job sir. 🇿🇲
You have obviously thrown the baby out with the bath water. I have never been a JW but as a“Born Again” Christian Jesus powerfully changed my life at the age 17. The “New Birth” is real as multiplied millions will testify. Please seek him afresh. 🥰
well.... if you can error ...then why should we trust you. Why should we trust you when God says do not put your trust in men ? OH and heaven forbid.... apologize for misinterpretation of scripture.
If these men dont understand what GOD is telling them maybe find some more competent men or maybe their connection is bad; get starlink & cancel at&t good Lord its all just to much from them to you to this whole damn world 🌎 it all sucks
Don't ask a question without providing an analysis. If you truly believe in the New Light Doctrine you should be able to justify because the question you have asked is not related to doctrinal changes your organization and not a church: Matthew 16:27-28 (NIV): "For the Son of Man is going to come in his Father’s glory with his angels, and then he will reward each person according to what they have done. Truly I tell you, some who are standing here will not taste death before they see the Son of Man coming in his kingdom."
If they had listened to Solomon, they wouldn't have to be burning books. Those tiresome worrisome books. The only light we need comes from the sun, and Solomon said there's nothing new under the Sun, so did they take that scripture out of their Bible too?
I have a hardback copy of the Revelation, it's climax book still. I have have tried to burn it but it doesn't ignite. Elon Musk could use it as a heat resistant tile on his starship
It is not only the Governing body that JEHOVAH reveals the deep things of to each servant of JEHOVAH also shares the same spirit and it confirms the truth to us individually through our personal study of the bible it also exposes your utter incompetence in spiritual matters,JEHOVAH'S Spirit helps the individual servant of JEHOVAH to separate between true and false teachers. We do not believe in modern day prophets the claims of lying propagandists notwithstanding
Now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom. - 2 Corinthians 3:17 JW has no idea what they're talking about. But to us, God revealed them through the Spirit, for the Spirit searches all things, even the depths of God.- 1 Corinthians 2:10 Where it says "the Spirit" substitute Christ, and it makes total sense. Get out of that religion, and learn about "the only true God, and Jesus Christ" who was sent.- John 17:3. Stop following man! (AKA Governing Body) For there is one God, and one mediator also between God and men, the man Christ Jesus, - 1 Timothy 2:5 Not the GB. Please wake up, and get out false religion!
1 Corinthians 2:10 (NWT) For it is to us God has revealed them+ through his spirit,+ for the spirit searches into all things, even the deep things of God.+ Did that verse mentioned any light or new light? No! Why do these charlatans think that everybody is a fool?
LOL...I the truely had any light they would realize Jesus is God and it is only through Him that you can be saved. Interesting thought. They say they are the TRUTH Jesus said ....I am the way the TRUTH and the life no man comes to the father except via me. If u have Jesus u have the TRUTH.
Here's my challenge again this alleged superior understanding of the bible you people are always crowing about I would like to see some demonstration of it,the identity of the most high God JEHOVAH is the most important truth of all so we shoikd begin there. Luke Ch.1:32NIV"He will be great and will be called the Son of the MOST HIGH. The LORD God will give him the throne of his father David," John Ch.10:29NIV"My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than ALL c ; no one can snatch them out of my Father’s hand. " The God and Father of Jesus christ is the MOST HIGH God and thus is co equal to no one. John Ch.8:54NIV"Jesus replied, “If I glorify myself, my glory means nothing. My Father, whom you claim as your God, is the one who glorifies me. " According to Jesus his God and Father is the one and only God of Israel . By common consent the God and Father of Jesus is not triune. Therefore the one and only God of Israel is not triune. John ch.20:17NIV"Jesus said, “Do not hold on to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father. Go instead to my brothers and tell them, ‘I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.’ ”" The God and Father of Jesus is not triune by common consent . The God and Father of Jesus is also the God and Father of Jesus' disciples . Therefore the God and Father of Jesus' disciples is not triune. Matthew Ch.24:36NIV"“But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, f but ONLY the Father. " ONLY the God and Father of Jesus Christ is omniscient thus only the God and Father of Jesus Christ is the MOST HIGH God. Roman's Ch.1:9EHV"To be sure, (the)God, whom I serve with my spirit by proclaiming the gospel of his Son, is my witness to how constantly I make mention of you. In all my prayers, " Roman's Ch.3:30NIV"since there is only ONE(Grk.eis) God, who will justify the circumcised by faith and the uncircumcised through that same faith. " Paul was an actual monotheist and thus rendered exclusive sacred service to one most high God. Whom he clearly identifies as the God and Father of Jesus Christ. Matthew Ch.16:16NKJV"Simon Peter answered and said, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.”" not merely the living Father but the living God to whom all believers owe EXCLUSIVE Devotion/Sacred Service. Malachi Ch.2:10NIV"Do we not all have one Father b ? Did not one God create us? Why do we profane the covenant of our ancestors by being unfaithful to one another?" The God and Father of Jesus Christ is the only true God.
Well, then how can the great father Jehovah allow his anointed ones to teach wrong ideas of his holy word to other people? I believe that the ruling brothers, the governing body, is in serious trouble by speculating with the Bible. and all in the name of God. so the problem doesn't change. greetings!
@@JwRetroverdad throughout sacred history JEHOVAH'S People have had mistaken ideas re:the fulfillment of messianic prophecy but they have been right about what matters most to JEHOVAH especially the identity of the most high God JEHOVAH and the standards necessary for maintaining religious purity. Daniel ch.12:8-10NKJV"Although I heard, I did not understand. Then I said, “My lord, what shall be the end of these things?” 9And he said, “Go your way, Daniel, for the words are closed up and sealed till the time of the end. 10Many shall be purified, made white, and refined, but the wicked shall do wickedly; and none of the wicked shall understand, but the wise shall understand." With the progressive cleansing will come increased understanding. Christendom continues to pollute herself with innocent blood
@aservantofJEHOVAH7849 Tell me how many false teachings the apostles taught the congregations. Of course, they could have wrong personal ideas, but that was not what they taught. Your justification is not valid. Do you know who taught human ideas to people?...the Jewish leaders of Jesus' time.
@@JwRetroverdad the bible is inspired and so is free from error but the apostles would have made erroneous extrapolations based on an incomplete understanding of prophecy see 1Corinthians ch.13:9,10 Also John 21:23 we had a erronrous understanding that spread among the BROTHERS that is those who the apostle considered his brothers.
@@aservantofJEHOVAH7849 Of course, a rumor...unofficial. It was not a doctrinal teaching that the apostles offered as an illumination from God. They also understood that they did not have a complete understanding, that is why they did not invent teachings in the name of God. No matter how much you want, the apostles did not deceive by offering a cat for a hare. On the other hand we have the governing body that does nothing but make mistakes in its teachings. greetings!
The overlapping generation teaching is a doctrine promoted by Jehovah’s Witnesses that relates to their interpretation of Jesus’ prophecy in Matthew 24:34, where he says, "Truly I tell you, this generation will certainly not pass away until all these things have happened." This prophecy is interpreted by Jehovah's Witnesses as referring to the events leading up to the end of the world, or the "Great Tribulation" and Armageddon, which they believe will soon occur. Historical Background In the early 20th century, Jehovah’s Witnesses (then known as the Bible Students) believed that the generation that witnessed the events of 1914-the year they interpret as marking the beginning of "the last days"-would not pass away before the arrival of God's Kingdom and the end of the world. However, over time, as the expected Armageddon did not come, Jehovah’s Witnesses adjusted their understanding. Here's how their interpretation evolved: The "Overlapping Generation" Teaching In 2010, the Governing Body of Jehovah's Witnesses introduced a new understanding to explain the passage. According to this revised doctrine: Two Generations: The “generation” spoken of by Jesus in Matthew 24:34 refers to two overlapping generations: The first generation refers to those who were alive in 1914 and witnessed the beginning of the "last days." The second generation refers to their children or those who were young in 1914, who would also witness the fulfillment of these end-time events. Overlapping Concept: The term "overlapping" means that the end of the first generation (those who saw 1914) is supposed to overlap with the beginning of the second generation (their children or younger people who would see the culmination of the events). So, according to the teaching, both generations contribute to the fulfillment of the prophecy. No Clear End Date: This new interpretation avoids giving a clear, specific time frame for when Armageddon will come. The implication is that the second generation (the children of those who saw 1914) could still be alive when Armageddon occurs, which allows for the continued belief that the end of the world is near. Why the Change? Adjusting the Time Frame: Since the original teaching was that the generation of 1914 would still be alive when the end came, and since this did not come to pass, the doctrine needed to evolve to explain why the prophecy appeared to be delayed. Evolving Interpretations: The "overlapping generation" doctrine allowed Jehovah’s Witnesses to maintain their expectation of the imminent arrival of Armageddon, while also adjusting their understanding of who is part of the "generation" that will see the fulfillment of Matthew 24:34. Biblical Basis and Criticism Matthew 24:34: Jehovah's Witnesses interpret this verse to mean that the generation that witnesses the signs of the last days will see the fulfillment of the prophecy. However, critics argue that this interpretation is inconsistent with the broader biblical context and that the term “generation” might not refer to a literal group of people, but rather a period of time or an age. Unclear Interpretation: Critics of the "overlapping generation" teaching often point out that the Bible does not clearly support the idea of two overlapping generations, and they argue that the doctrine reflects a response to failed predictions about the end times. Current Belief Currently, Jehovah's Witnesses teach that we are living in the "last days" that began in 1914, and they believe Armageddon could come at any time, but they avoid giving a precise date. The "overlapping generation" doctrine allows them to keep this belief intact while adjusting their interpretation to account for the passage of time. In conclusion, the overlapping generation teaching is a reinterpretation aimed at explaining the delay in Armageddon’s arrival. While it fits within their doctrinal framework, it is a controversial and debated concept, both within and outside of the Jehovah's Witnesses community.
As the bible says at Proverbs 4:18 But the path of the righteous is like the bright morning light That grows brighter and brighter until full daylight. If Jehovah reveals everything at once it would be overwhelming so he reveals things over time as the above scripture shows. If JWs are wrong then who is preaching the good news of the kingdom as Jesus told his true followers to do Matthew 24:14. There is is no other religion on earth that preaches from door to door as the early Christian’s did Acts 5:42 --20:20
If Jehovah does not reveal or explain everything at once, why does the GC speculate on matters that God has not yet explained? Why do they speculate on sacred things? And even more so, the CG has always said the explanations they give come from God and Jesus, but then it turns out that they misunderstood the Bible. Wouldn't that be using God's name in a bad way? It would be lying in the name of God.
Thank you for your comment. You’ve referenced Proverbs 4:18, and I understand how this scripture is used to suggest that Jehovah reveals truths gradually over time. However, my video focuses on how the "new light" doctrine, which justifies doctrinal changes, is being misused by the Governing Body to explain shifts in beliefs, and whether or not these shifts are truly in line with biblical teachings. While I agree that truth is often revealed progressively, we must also be cautious about the consistency of these revelations. Proverbs 4:18 speaks of the path of righteousness growing brighter, but it doesn’t necessarily imply doctrinal changes that contradict previous understandings. The concern I raise is about how those changes are presented-sometimes these shifts contradict earlier teachings without clear biblical justification. As for preaching the good news of the Kingdom, Matthew 24:14 does indeed speak about this mission, and Jehovah’s Witnesses are known for their door-to-door preaching. However, this doesn’t automatically validate all their teachings, as Jesus also warned of false prophets and encouraged discernment (Matthew 7:15-20). The fact that JWs are preaching doesn’t necessarily mean that all their interpretations are correct, and that’s what I’m addressing in the video-the need for careful examination of their doctrinal shifts. Let’s stay focused on the key issue-how these doctrinal changes are being justified through "new light" and whether they align with biblical principles. I’d be happy to discuss any of these points further.
TO ALL/EVERYONE..... BEWARE....!!!! Satan is on the war path, very busy attacking Jehovah and his followers, JW's...... Satan, knows what's coming...."The GREAT DAY of Jehovah is near" (Zeph.1:14) And Jesus is coming in his Father's name,,,,,Jehovah, Are YOU ready for The Great Day of Jehovah.... ........Woe for the earth and for the sea, because the Devil has come down to you having great anger, knowing he has a short period of time. (Rev.12:12) NWT The Devil is hard at work........ More HATE, more DIVISION......... Whose side are you on......????
Can you trust people who misinterpret the Bible and use God to confirm their mistakes? If they were always wrong...we already know what will happen with their interpretation of future biblical events.
Thank you for your comment, but it seems we're not addressing the actual topic of the video. My focus here is on the misinterpretation of scriptures by Jehovah's Witnesses and how the “new light” doctrine has been misused. The discussion should be about the ideas presented, not personal attacks or off-topic issues. The fact that you're focusing on ad hominem arguments-attacking the person instead of engaging with the content-diverts from the real issue at hand. This is a classic logical fallacy, and it doesn’t help to move the conversation forward. If you disagree with the points made, I invite you to engage with the arguments and the evidence presented, rather than focusing on personal attacks or making things about me. Let’s keep this conversation focused on the ideas and the important issues raised in the video.
Your dropping a video about JW's every other day it seems. Like an overly enthusiastic ex boyfriend. Why the intense interest in a bunch of volunteers who love God and his word?
@@JonnyDoe-k1k JW is a cult. Someday you will understand, perhaps when they change the understanding about the generation or 1914. Remember that you knew it before by entering an apostate channel.
If these men dont understand what GOD is telling them maybe find some more competent men or maybe their connection is bad; get starlink & cancel at&t good Lord its all just to much from them to you to this whole damn world 🌎 it all sucks
This is the talk that woke me up ‼️
What do you mean? Wake up from what?
I had the pleasure of using this aberrant speech of Winder to argue its falsehood in front of elders. Of course they are the ones to whom God reveals mistakes! I never returned to the kingdom hall again. greetings!
@@JwRetroverdad Greetings, thank you
@ from WT lies
@ 🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌
Why would God (supposedly the greatest communicator and originator of all languages) incompetently supply humans a book, so complex that they require a few men to repeatedly clarify its meaning? These red flags are so bright, even the blind can identify them.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts! It's always refreshing to see different viewpoints on such a profound topic.
Because "god" is a made up figment of frightened and uninformed peoples imagination. It's OKAY not to know something, people don't need to attribute what they perceive as the unknown to some senile, angry and vengeful sky daddy.
excellent point
Why would he go through a lot of the pantomime that is predicted?
The Church has always maintained the same doctrines and some things remain a mystery. Such as when the last judgement is.
@@lesliethomas7234 who says that Jehovah has anything to do with what you are asserting? ❓ Bear in mind that Jehovah has an adversary that is working hard to impede the message that he wants to deliver and communicate to mankind. Therefore the difficulties that you perceive maybe instigated and sent by the devil and his demons. Their sole desire is to impede the truth and promote the LIE, and challenge Jehovah God's sovereignty, for this they live and for that they will die. And they know it, but they do not wish to die alone they wish to take as many of mankind as possible with them out of spite... A thing of insanity among them.
Brothers, it is obvious, if the governing body were receiving new light from Jehovah, then what they get cannot be false light. If they are getting lights wrong that does not come from Jehovah and Jehovah have not chose them. Jehovah chose our lord Jesus alone and we are all only brothers
‘New shite/new light’
From the Freemason leaders.
Not inspired By WHO !???
That light is God’s Word, the Holy Bible: “Your word is a lamp to my foot, and a light to my roadway.”-Isa. 60:2; Ps. 119:105. True Christians make the sacred Scriptures the light in their life, letting them serve as a burning lamp lighting up the way for their feet to go. To walk without stumbling spiritually in this world of thick gloom we must walk in the light that comes from God.
@@Naegy-u4z
And if I may add! No where in the written accounts about the son of God and savior JESUS, did he ever pray or call God Jehovah, Yahweh or by any other name, but only and always FATHER! That’s old light but it would be new light to the brainwashed JW’s and that is because they have put their GB leaders first instead of listening to the words of Jesus! They give him lip service, but their hearts are far removed from him!
Comes from God , not watchtower who do the work of their father the devil
For goodness sake, this new light has been changing, swinging back and forwards for over 100 years within this Organization. The Creator of this universe and us, is honest and true. This organization accuses Almighty God as being deceptive and secretive. Does that make sense? What would you think if your fleshly father behaved that way??
Kikikiki😅😅😅
They will never admit any wrong nor will they opologize...
@@revzone3544 actually this statement is not true 😠. Do faulty people mean faulty doctrine? Our critics". Is a video prepared by Jehovah's witnesses that answered these charges explicitly.
@@revzone3544 what is more there is no apology needed..... When they are correct. Cannot say the same for Christendom. Though sometimes they may be slow to change.
@rawbrutaltruth
Brainwashed people don't know they're being deceived..when lies are repeated over and over, it becomes the truth to many people.. and people like having their ears tickled..they will even defend it...
@@rawbrutaltruth
Like the 1914 lie.. that's the lie they get to believing... we are not in the last days... those days do not start until the great tribulation...lie on top of lie...
@revzone3544 and what is your evidence that the Great tribulation marks the beginning of the last days
In Scripture
Jesus clearly pointed out what would be the beginning of the pains of distress in Scripture.
And it is notable that some things in the Bible often did not get fulfillment until maybe 1 to 200 years later, sometimes even more..
I will wait for you to present it, so that I may consider it, all the while making no promises to agree with it. I do believe this is fair. But before you can make a credible standing to support your idea that this does not start until after the Great tribulation, you will have to discount all the scriptures that say what those kinds of distress are, add discount the fact that they ever happen to this day. So you will have to overcome the scriptural evidence that points to them having already begun. And then shore up your case afterward. You may begin now. I will wait.
And when they make a mistake, who had revealed that erroneous understanding to them? And who guarantees that the new understanding is correct on this occasion?
Enough of lies!
Ah, the classic "who watches the watchers?" dilemma! It's like trying to find the end of a never-ending loop-just when you think you've got it, there's another twist!
@drkKennedy I was active for 35 years, preaching interpretations that changed over time. lies in the "name" of God. enough of that.
Great video!.
Let's just put it this way to your question. . 9x out of 10 is not x witnesses nor is it opposers, nor is it Christendom with its be darkened luminaries..
. It is not uncommon for children to misunderstand their parents on occasion s......... Get serious... But last but not least I wouldn't want to rely on you for the corrections. Or Christendom seeing how they've gotten so much wrong, they have had their own predictions among their disorganized denominations, even as late as 2,000. Some of them were thinking the world would end then. Understanding the Bible is far from flawless.
(Matthew 11:25) At that time Jesus said in response: “I publicly praise you, Father, Lord of heaven and earth, because you have hidden these things from the wise and intellectual ones and have revealed them to young children.
The inspired utterance says definitely that in later periods of time some will fall away from the faith, paying attention to misleading inspired utterances and teachings of demons.”-1 Tim. 4:1.
Hmmm, so 7 false prophecies over 100 years from an organisation stating they are inspired prophets and the light is still getting brighter ??????
Their "light" is not coming from God.
7 times the WT received the wrong light.
7 times this false prophet got 7 prophecies wrong.
Ron Hansen to the rescue of the WT false prophet.
Calling Ron
Isaiah 28:8.
Excellent job eviscerating these pretenders. You make it a simple question of logic for any JW...
1. New Light is revealed to the GB.
2. How can you trust the GB if they are neither infallible or inspired?
That should flip the switch on for them to recognize they put their faith in men.
But members are so blinded that the GB demands blind obedience
@@treasureon25 you are incorrect Jehovah's witnesses faith is in their God
Jehovah, the god of Jesus, who is the head of the congregation, of his witnesses,. The facts are all too often it is apostates and vehement opposers who pushed the idea that they are to be considered infallible and unerring. Which is far from the truth. And has been for quite some time. Who stands the benefit from these false allegations. The clergy of Christendom and all who aspire to be a part of that clergy. Not to mention those who have attempted to infiltrate God's congregation for personal gain. Envy is a strong emotion that consumes them, and materialism . Is the beast that consumes them as the desire for material things and status consumes them as well
They have become consumed by what they can get out of this old world before Armageddon comes. It is not inconceivable but they believe that they can gain all that there is to gain before they cease to walk this Earth.
Many have the hope to consume as much as they can materially before Armageddon comes and wipes it all out. Mini may be perfectly happy if they are capable of doing so despite the high cost of possibly losing their life. Short-sighted but true
Quoting David Splain..”We do not have..the spirit”
Of course you don’t.
God doesn’t anoint liars.
They have spirit, but it’s not Holy.
By their own mouth.
They speak from there father the devil, with his split serpent tongue, 🐍 a little bit of truth and alot of lies in the same breath
Very true
This is super creepy but Rutherford write in one of his books that he was inspired but it was from fallen angels noe demons who broke from Satan because they didn't want the lake of fire. Rutherford bragged about it and trusted them? Out of the frying pan and into the fire.
@@RebeccadeWinter-t1c interesting
The Bible says throughout that anyone who speaks of things that will happen in prophesy and they do not happen that they are not of God, and to do not listen to them. Jeremiah says it many many times. The jws are not getting information from Yahweh, they are from their father the devil.
@morningglory9288 oh my, who has been whispering in your ears..you clearly have no understanding of anything in the Bible. I'm sad and will pray for you.
@morningglory9288 where does Jesus come from if Yahweh is the devil as you say
Thank you for sharing your thoughts, but I believe there’s a misunderstanding of the purpose of this discussion. My video is focused on the misinterpretation of scripture and the doctrinal errors related to the "new light" teaching in Jehovah’s Witnesses. The conversation here is about the issues with how the Governing Body uses scripture to justify their beliefs, not a theological debate about the nature of Jehovah/Yahweh or Jesus.
If you wish to discuss your perspective on the nature of God, Jesus, or any other theological matter, there are plenty of forums dedicated to that conversation. However, I encourage you to keep this discussion focused on the specific topic of the video-how Jehovah’s Witnesses are misinterpreting scripture to support their organizational teachings.
I also ask that you refrain from personal attacks or making statements that are not related to the subject at hand. This is not a place for venting or blasphemy, but for an open and respectful discussion about the points raised in the video.
Let’s keep the conversation productive and focused on the issues at hand.
@@drkKennedy I thank you for your information. I was a jw for twenty plus years and I know first hand how they twist script ure for their benefit. If speaking of Yahweh isn't a part of any discussion then what's the point...
So if the governing body is not inspired nor infallible, then how can we say God came up with something new.. this is so annoying.. I stopped attending after the overlapping generations..that's when I couldn't put my discernment offline but had to accept that it has been changed due to their interpretation. It was also one of the first times I heard them say they are not inspired.. I appreciate their efforts, but...
@@DeathSentryCoH Esh
The Bible conveys a message of moderation and avoiding extremes. Ecclesiastes 7:15-20 teaches that being overly righteous, overly wise, overly wicked, or overly foolish is dangerous. It also warns against making hasty judgments about a person's character.
Ecclesiastes 7:15-20
15 In this meaningless life of mine I have seen both of these: the righteous perishing in their righteousness, and the wicked living long in their wickedness.
16 Do not be overrighteous, neither be overwise- why destroy yourself?
17 Do not be overwicked, and do not be a fool- why die before your time?
18 It is good to grasp the one and not let go of the other. Whoever fears God will avoid all extremes.
19 Wisdom makes one wise person more powerful than ten rulers in a city.
20 Indeed, there is no one on earth who is righteous, no one who does what is right and never sins.🙏✝️❤️
@@shortflims2165 wise words indeed maybe Christendom should take note it has missed the mark of perfection oh so many more times than Jehovah's witnesses.,..
I thought he just finished saying that they are not inspired???? This is where the mind control comes in
Serious Ming control
@drkKennedy I was a part of it for twenty plus years. I saw from the inside. Thank my God Yahweh for making a way out for me..
Exactly. Not inspired, yet talk about new light being revealed in the next sentence... SMH
There is no new light you liars! The light came to the world 2k + years ago and his light doesn’t change and there is nothing else to add to it! Jesus is the way, truth, life, resurrection and only way to the FATHER and not Jehovah because that is not Gods name!
@@unclesalty7778 Exodus 6:23 and God spoke unto Moses and said unto him, I am the Lord; and I appeared on to Abraham unto Isaac by the name God almighty, but by my name Jehovah I was not known to them."
Oops looks like this is some old light 🚨 🚨 that was from Christendom that Just did not quite fall on you. Wonder how that happened..... The passage that is posted with God's name is coming out of the King James translation of the Bible. The light that has been there all this time has not hit you yet, yet and still, you claim to be one who can determine what is new light and what is not light 🤔🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨. Give me this sorry State of affairs that is demonstrated by your post. I think I'll go find my own light 😏🤣🤣🤣
@@unclesalty7778 guess you better break out that Old King James version of yours because it appears that you are willfully under informed. Also there is a Jew who really has the lowdown regarding God's name that would considerably update your knowledge, and it's not coming from Jehovah's witnesses get there quickly you're embarrassing yourself.
@
The only Jew I listen to is JESUS ! MY FRIEND!
Remember get out of your shell, we all witnessed the moon landing too! RIGHT?
@@unclesalty7778 don't fool yourself, you claimed the number father when you don't even know his name 🤣🤣🤣🤣 crack open that Bible, you really need to, turn off that black and white television , Herbert 😂🥱
... Bye-bye
@unclesalty7778 no you don't , 😂😂😂 he doesn't know you salty😏
Probably my all time favorite teaching is the overlapping generation that says king tut and I are in the same generation… cool 😎 cool cool 😎
Reveled is past tense, revels is future tense. To say old light was wrong is to say God is in error. There is an “evil slave” in charge. (Matt 24:48-51) He “beats the other slaves” and gets some to follow. (Luke 12:45-48) Upon seeIng this, Jesus orders us to leave and head for the mountains. (Matt 24:15) He says “let the reader use discernment” not listen to a “faithful slave.” Jehovah’s brilliant prophesy only gives us more reason to believe and trust in him.
Are you saying the GB is actually the not discret and Faith slave but the evil slave who was beating his fellow servants?
@
You are mistaken you neither know God or the scriptures
Notice that Jesus begins the warning by saying “if ever.” These words show that what Jesus next described would not necessarily happen. It was as if Jesus was saying: ‘If the faithful and discreet slave were ever to treat the other slaves cruelly in these ways, the master would punish him severely.’ (See also Luke 12:45.) But the faithful and discreet slave as a group has continued to stay alert and to give out spiritual food of good quality.
Such good quotes ality they give false prophecies repeatedly , allow children to dye through refusal of blood transfusion and encourage members toie
Throw your Bible away truthseeker , for you show you do not use it
@
Tell me why are there bloodless hospitals in America and other parts of the world
Quite from Google
At present, there are a substantial number of bloodless surgery procedures including cardiac and orthopedic procedures, and there are 75 hospitals functioning in the U.S. and 105 in additional countries including Italy, Canada, Switzerland, Chile, France, and Australia.
@
I haven’t heard you quote the bible
My name is blasphemed among the nations because of you.
Don’t these guys see that by repeatedly saying “Jehovah” and charging him after their mistakes, the people outside of their cult think less of the One God? This is embarrassing dudes, really embarrassing
Agreed
Very embarrassing
These frauds really elevated themselves to the judgment seat of Moses.
You know, one side of my family are JW’s and I notice most of them are married but most haven’t had children, I don’t know why but they seem to be waiting for the “New system”. This mindset might be the same for other married Jw couples, there isn’t anyone to force into the JW organization and that’s why numbers are declining and people have discovered the organization does weird things that Jesus himself never said or did like disfellowshipping, Shunning etc and mostly them denying the divinity of Jesus. I’m not saying you have to have children but that seems to have been the main thing getting them members, no kids = no growth because no one who is an actual Christian would join them. No trying to be rude but there it is….
No one has ever become a Jehovah’s Witness by reading the Bible alone. But millions have come to a saving faith in Jesus Christ. He is the way truth and the life. Not an 18th century organization who has falsely predicted Armageddon for the last 150 years.
My question would be if it wasn't the proper time on the things they now have to chage; then why even teach it? That is misleading and admitting it without admitting it.. if they didnt understand it back then they shouldn't have acted as if they did let alone teach it as truth.. and their not inspired wow then why are they the ines leading 0 the irony is sickening
It's true. They talk about more.
Genesis 15:12-14 , Acts 7:6 OVERSTAND THAT !!!!
As long as these 11 men deny their followers the very hope THEY themselves entertain, they will continue to be blind guides, groping in spiritual darkness grasping for “new light”. Nowhere does the Bible teach there are 2 roads to life. Baptism is not about making a dedication vow, getting baptized in symbol of that dedication, living up to that vow,obeying the governing body to be God’s ‘friend’. One is not saved by hard work and sincerity. We’re either Children of God or Children of the Devil. There is no 3rd party option. 1 John 3:10. Ephesians 4:4-6
Run for the hills. Huge scam. So your research. 😮
I am not sure I understand your comment! Thank you anyway
GB NEVER HAS RECEIVED LIGHT FROM JEHOVA....THEY HAVE RECEIVED LIGHT FROM...******
I regret wasting a huge portion of my life in the organization of Jehovah's witnesses six years as an elder. My waking up came when I was appointed as Watchtower Study conductor. It helped me to not only realize that these guys are lying to the world that they are God's channel of communication to all living humans but that God has got nothing to do with all of organized religion. Perhaps I realized something even crazier, namely that actually the Bible itself didn't exist in Bible times. For example the Apostle Paul whom the witnesses love so much did not have the volume that we today call the Bible. It's a cherry picked compilation which the Romans came up with. In my view it is such a blatant misnomer to even call the book "God's Word." JW's version of the Bible make things even worse by its title "New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures" because not everything in the compilation is "holy" scripture. For example, how can the Letter to Timothy where Paul said "All scripture is inspired of God" be part of scripture?😅 Or how could the Gospels which were only recorded as testimonial to the fulfilment of scripture be part of scripture. So, the New World Translation has perhaps the most blasphemous titles for a Bible version. In any case, not only the witnesses, but Christians in general have put the Bible on the wrong pedestal. Thankfully, Yeshua or Jesus is not even presented to be a member of an organized religion but a heretic and perhaps the greatest heretic to have walked this earth and religion hated him to death. He said he'd be gone but to keep worshipers on course did he promise a book? I think we all know the answer to that. Any way, I'm glad that I no longer put the love of my religion (or beliefs) between myself and another human. Never again will I waste even a second of my life to support such useless ideas as exposed in your video. Great job sir. 🇿🇲
You have obviously thrown the baby out with the bath water. I have never been a JW but as a“Born Again” Christian Jesus powerfully changed my life at the age 17. The “New Birth” is real as multiplied millions will testify. Please seek him afresh. 🥰
Have they ever gotten anything right that stayed right ??
Yes 🙌🏻 the overlapping generation is absolutely sound logic
Jesus said
I will b with u for all times.
Mt 28
JWs skipped 1900yrs.
They are a joke
well.... if you can error ...then why should we trust you. Why should we trust you when God says do not put your trust in men ? OH and heaven forbid.... apologize for misinterpretation of scripture.
@@JeanniejeannirJeanieyerigan very true
If these men dont understand what GOD is telling them maybe find some more competent men or maybe their connection is bad; get starlink & cancel at&t good Lord its all just to much from them to you to this whole damn world 🌎 it all sucks
Jw gb doesn't lie or mislead came right from their own mouth . Scarey that statement
Yeah and the Syncopathic Clapping angered me
Doesn't the Bible give new light ..Matthew 16: 27-28??
Don't ask a question without providing an analysis. If you truly believe in the New Light Doctrine you should be able to justify because the question you have asked is not related to doctrinal changes your organization and not a church: Matthew 16:27-28 (NIV):
"For the Son of Man is going to come in his Father’s glory with his angels, and then he will reward each person according to what they have done. Truly I tell you, some who are standing here will not taste death before they see the Son of Man coming in his kingdom."
All the extra screen noise distracted me so much I could not continue to watch.
You mean the powerpoint?
If they had listened to Solomon, they wouldn't have to be burning books. Those tiresome worrisome books. The only light we need comes from the sun, and Solomon said there's nothing new under the Sun, so did they take that scripture out of their Bible too?
I have a hardback copy of the Revelation, it's climax book still. I have have tried to burn it but it doesn't ignite.
Elon Musk could use it as a heat resistant tile on his starship
It is not only the Governing body that JEHOVAH reveals the deep things of to each servant of JEHOVAH also shares the same spirit and it confirms the truth to us individually through our personal study of the bible it also exposes your utter incompetence in spiritual matters,JEHOVAH'S Spirit helps the individual servant of JEHOVAH to separate between true and false teachers. We do not believe in modern day prophets the claims of lying propagandists notwithstanding
Stop being silly friend
@@FantasyVisuals no actual argument as per usual.
Now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom.
- 2 Corinthians 3:17 JW has no idea what they're talking about. But to us, God revealed them through the Spirit, for the Spirit searches all things, even the depths of God.- 1 Corinthians 2:10 Where it says "the Spirit" substitute Christ, and it makes total sense. Get out of that religion, and learn about "the only true God, and Jesus Christ" who was sent.- John 17:3. Stop following man! (AKA Governing Body) For there is one God, and one mediator also between God and men, the man Christ Jesus,
- 1 Timothy 2:5 Not the GB. Please wake up, and get out false religion!
1 Corinthians 2:10 (NWT)
For it is to us God has revealed them+ through his spirit,+ for the spirit searches into all things, even the deep things of God.+
Did that verse mentioned any light or new light? No!
Why do these charlatans think that everybody is a fool?
Shocking not so!
LOL...I the truely had any light they would realize Jesus is God and it is only through Him that you can be saved.
Interesting thought.
They say they are the TRUTH
Jesus said ....I am the way the TRUTH and the life no man comes to the father except via me.
If u have Jesus u have the TRUTH.
Here's my challenge again this alleged superior understanding of the bible you people are always crowing about I would like to see some demonstration of it,the identity of the most high God JEHOVAH is the most important truth of all so we shoikd begin there.
Luke Ch.1:32NIV"He will be great and will be called the Son of the MOST HIGH. The LORD God will give him the throne of his father David,"
John Ch.10:29NIV"My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than ALL c ; no one can snatch them out of my Father’s hand. "
The God and Father of Jesus christ is the MOST HIGH God and thus is co equal to no one.
John Ch.8:54NIV"Jesus replied, “If I glorify myself, my glory means nothing. My Father, whom you claim as your God, is the one who glorifies me. "
According to Jesus his God and Father is the one and only God of Israel . By common consent the God and Father of Jesus is not triune. Therefore the one and only God of Israel is not triune.
John ch.20:17NIV"Jesus said, “Do not hold on to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father. Go instead to my brothers and tell them, ‘I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.’ ”"
The God and Father of Jesus is not triune by common consent . The God and Father of Jesus is also the God and Father of Jesus' disciples . Therefore the God and Father of Jesus' disciples is not triune.
Matthew Ch.24:36NIV"“But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, f but ONLY the Father. "
ONLY the God and Father of Jesus Christ is omniscient thus only the God and Father of Jesus Christ is the MOST HIGH God.
Roman's Ch.1:9EHV"To be sure, (the)God, whom I serve with my spirit by proclaiming the gospel of his Son, is my witness to how constantly I make mention of you. In all my prayers, "
Roman's Ch.3:30NIV"since there is only ONE(Grk.eis) God, who will justify the circumcised by faith and the uncircumcised through that same faith. "
Paul was an actual monotheist and thus rendered exclusive sacred service to one most high God. Whom he clearly identifies as the God and Father of Jesus Christ.
Matthew Ch.16:16NKJV"Simon Peter answered and said, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.”" not merely the living Father but the living God to whom all believers owe EXCLUSIVE Devotion/Sacred Service.
Malachi Ch.2:10NIV"Do we not all have one Father b ? Did not one God create us? Why do we profane the covenant of our ancestors by being unfaithful to one another?"
The God and Father of Jesus Christ is the only true God.
Well, then how can the great father Jehovah allow his anointed ones to teach wrong ideas of his holy word to other people? I believe that the ruling brothers, the governing body, is in serious trouble by speculating with the Bible. and all in the name of God. so the problem doesn't change. greetings!
@@JwRetroverdad throughout sacred history JEHOVAH'S People have had mistaken ideas re:the fulfillment of messianic prophecy but they have been right about what matters most to JEHOVAH especially the identity of the most high God JEHOVAH and the standards necessary for maintaining religious purity.
Daniel ch.12:8-10NKJV"Although I heard, I did not understand. Then I said, “My lord, what shall be the end of these things?”
9And he said, “Go your way, Daniel, for the words are closed up and sealed till the time of the end. 10Many shall be purified, made white, and refined, but the wicked shall do wickedly; and none of the wicked shall understand, but the wise shall understand."
With the progressive cleansing will come increased understanding. Christendom continues to pollute herself with innocent blood
@aservantofJEHOVAH7849 Tell me how many false teachings the apostles taught the congregations. Of course, they could have wrong personal ideas, but that was not what they taught. Your justification is not valid. Do you know who taught human ideas to people?...the Jewish leaders of Jesus' time.
@@JwRetroverdad the bible is inspired and so is free from error but the apostles would have made erroneous extrapolations based on an incomplete understanding of prophecy see 1Corinthians ch.13:9,10
Also John 21:23 we had a erronrous understanding that spread among the BROTHERS that is those who the apostle considered his brothers.
@@aservantofJEHOVAH7849 Of course, a rumor...unofficial. It was not a doctrinal teaching that the apostles offered as an illumination from God. They also understood that they did not have a complete understanding, that is why they did not invent teachings in the name of God. No matter how much you want, the apostles did not deceive by offering a cat for a hare. On the other hand we have the governing body that does nothing but make mistakes in its teachings. greetings!
I'll bet you all now believe the trinity !!!
Explain the overlapping generation 🙏 please… 😊
The overlapping generation teaching is a doctrine promoted by Jehovah’s Witnesses that relates to their interpretation of Jesus’ prophecy in Matthew 24:34, where he says, "Truly I tell you, this generation will certainly not pass away until all these things have happened." This prophecy is interpreted by Jehovah's Witnesses as referring to the events leading up to the end of the world, or the "Great Tribulation" and Armageddon, which they believe will soon occur.
Historical Background
In the early 20th century, Jehovah’s Witnesses (then known as the Bible Students) believed that the generation that witnessed the events of 1914-the year they interpret as marking the beginning of "the last days"-would not pass away before the arrival of God's Kingdom and the end of the world.
However, over time, as the expected Armageddon did not come, Jehovah’s Witnesses adjusted their understanding. Here's how their interpretation evolved:
The "Overlapping Generation" Teaching
In 2010, the Governing Body of Jehovah's Witnesses introduced a new understanding to explain the passage. According to this revised doctrine:
Two Generations: The “generation” spoken of by Jesus in Matthew 24:34 refers to two overlapping generations:
The first generation refers to those who were alive in 1914 and witnessed the beginning of the "last days."
The second generation refers to their children or those who were young in 1914, who would also witness the fulfillment of these end-time events.
Overlapping Concept: The term "overlapping" means that the end of the first generation (those who saw 1914) is supposed to overlap with the beginning of the second generation (their children or younger people who would see the culmination of the events). So, according to the teaching, both generations contribute to the fulfillment of the prophecy.
No Clear End Date: This new interpretation avoids giving a clear, specific time frame for when Armageddon will come. The implication is that the second generation (the children of those who saw 1914) could still be alive when Armageddon occurs, which allows for the continued belief that the end of the world is near.
Why the Change?
Adjusting the Time Frame: Since the original teaching was that the generation of 1914 would still be alive when the end came, and since this did not come to pass, the doctrine needed to evolve to explain why the prophecy appeared to be delayed.
Evolving Interpretations: The "overlapping generation" doctrine allowed Jehovah’s Witnesses to maintain their expectation of the imminent arrival of Armageddon, while also adjusting their understanding of who is part of the "generation" that will see the fulfillment of Matthew 24:34.
Biblical Basis and Criticism
Matthew 24:34: Jehovah's Witnesses interpret this verse to mean that the generation that witnesses the signs of the last days will see the fulfillment of the prophecy. However, critics argue that this interpretation is inconsistent with the broader biblical context and that the term “generation” might not refer to a literal group of people, but rather a period of time or an age.
Unclear Interpretation: Critics of the "overlapping generation" teaching often point out that the Bible does not clearly support the idea of two overlapping generations, and they argue that the doctrine reflects a response to failed predictions about the end times.
Current Belief
Currently, Jehovah's Witnesses teach that we are living in the "last days" that began in 1914, and they believe Armageddon could come at any time, but they avoid giving a precise date. The "overlapping generation" doctrine allows them to keep this belief intact while adjusting their interpretation to account for the passage of time.
In conclusion, the overlapping generation teaching is a reinterpretation aimed at explaining the delay in Armageddon’s arrival. While it fits within their doctrinal framework, it is a controversial and debated concept, both within and outside of the Jehovah's Witnesses community.
@@drkKennedy It is a false teaching.
@Linda-ux8un What is the false teaching?
@@JohnMaxwell-v6c You mean JWs?
As the bible says at Proverbs 4:18 But the path of the righteous is like the bright morning light That grows brighter and brighter until full daylight.
If Jehovah reveals everything at once it would be overwhelming so he reveals things over time as the above scripture shows.
If JWs are wrong then who is preaching the good news of the kingdom as Jesus told his true followers to do Matthew 24:14.
There is is no other religion on earth that preaches from door to door as the early Christian’s did Acts 5:42
--20:20
If Jehovah does not reveal or explain everything at once, why does the GC speculate on matters that God has not yet explained? Why do they speculate on sacred things? And even more so, the CG has always said the explanations they give come from God and Jesus, but then it turns out that they misunderstood the Bible. Wouldn't that be using God's name in a bad way? It would be lying in the name of God.
I’ll take one overlapping generation burger 🍔 with a side of lies plz…
It is shocking to say the least
Thank you for your comment. You’ve referenced Proverbs 4:18, and I understand how this scripture is used to suggest that Jehovah reveals truths gradually over time. However, my video focuses on how the "new light" doctrine, which justifies doctrinal changes, is being misused by the Governing Body to explain shifts in beliefs, and whether or not these shifts are truly in line with biblical teachings.
While I agree that truth is often revealed progressively, we must also be cautious about the consistency of these revelations. Proverbs 4:18 speaks of the path of righteousness growing brighter, but it doesn’t necessarily imply doctrinal changes that contradict previous understandings. The concern I raise is about how those changes are presented-sometimes these shifts contradict earlier teachings without clear biblical justification.
As for preaching the good news of the Kingdom, Matthew 24:14 does indeed speak about this mission, and Jehovah’s Witnesses are known for their door-to-door preaching. However, this doesn’t automatically validate all their teachings, as Jesus also warned of false prophets and encouraged discernment (Matthew 7:15-20). The fact that JWs are preaching doesn’t necessarily mean that all their interpretations are correct, and that’s what I’m addressing in the video-the need for careful examination of their doctrinal shifts.
Let’s stay focused on the key issue-how these doctrinal changes are being justified through "new light" and whether they align with biblical principles. I’d be happy to discuss any of these points further.
@@drkKennedy
What changes are you referring to
Look up bottlegate
TO ALL/EVERYONE.....
BEWARE....!!!!
Satan is on the war path, very busy attacking Jehovah and his followers, JW's......
Satan, knows what's coming...."The GREAT DAY of Jehovah is near" (Zeph.1:14)
And Jesus is coming in his Father's name,,,,,Jehovah,
Are YOU ready for The Great Day of Jehovah....
........Woe for the earth and for the sea, because the Devil has come down to you having great anger, knowing he has a short period of time. (Rev.12:12) NWT
The Devil is hard at work........
More HATE, more DIVISION.........
Whose side are you on......????
Can you trust people who misinterpret the Bible and use God to confirm their mistakes? If they were always wrong...we already know what will happen with their interpretation of future biblical events.
I'll take one overlapping generation burger
- with a side of lies plz...
Thank you for your comment, but it seems we're not addressing the actual topic of the video. My focus here is on the misinterpretation of scriptures by Jehovah's Witnesses and how the “new light” doctrine has been misused. The discussion should be about the ideas presented, not personal attacks or off-topic issues.
The fact that you're focusing on ad hominem arguments-attacking the person instead of engaging with the content-diverts from the real issue at hand. This is a classic logical fallacy, and it doesn’t help to move the conversation forward.
If you disagree with the points made, I invite you to engage with the arguments and the evidence presented, rather than focusing on personal attacks or making things about me. Let’s keep this conversation focused on the ideas and the important issues raised in the video.
Shocking
The Dr has obsession issues.
Meaning?
Your dropping a video about JW's every other day it seems.
Like an overly enthusiastic ex boyfriend.
Why the intense interest in a bunch of volunteers who love God and his word?
@@JonnyDoe-k1k JW is a cult. Someday you will understand, perhaps when they change the understanding about the generation or 1914. Remember that you knew it before by entering an apostate channel.
Lots of jws in the chat !! lol y’all’s elders know your using the satanic internet? 😊
More bollocks spoken , no evidence ever presented just opinions, im not a JW either
Another thumbs down
Why cant you people back tf off..
If these men dont understand what GOD is telling them maybe find some more competent men or maybe their connection is bad; get starlink & cancel at&t good Lord its all just to much from them to you to this whole damn world 🌎 it all sucks