5 “What Ifs” that Change Big Brother History 3.0
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 июл 2024
- What if? Big Brother as we know it could have been extremely different had a few things changed in the past. This is the third one of these jokers so if you don't know what it is, I suggest you check out the other two videos on Big Brother "What If" scenarios. This what if is a particular favorite of mine, because it includes Josh.
I am so sorry for the annoying buzzing at times. It sucks and I didn't pick up on it until after I uploaded.
Support me by joining the channel! Click the JOIN button on my channel home page to find out more.
Follow me on Twitter! / ethanimale
Become an animal and join the Discord! (we talk about all sorts of things) / discord
I don't own the clips, all rights go to CBS or Viacom or whoever they belong too, just don't copyright me please.
CHAPTERS:
00:00 What If?
01:28 Dick missed the Perfect Shot at the final 9 veto
04:29 Dan's Wedding isn't during BB13
06:57 Josh and Kaycee are on BB22
10:08 Paul wins BB18
14:23 Derek X wins the HOH that sent him home
16:30 Ending
17:23 Josh gets a little scared 
Развлечения
For your next "What Ifs" video you could figure out "What If I didn't spoil every fking season of Big Brother"...
its not a brand new season airing right now you cant be mad at ethanimale for that. you're kinda spoiling yourself watching these types of videos!
@@Wehndigo yup. I avoid all the BBCan videos because I’m only on season 9
Is it a spoiler if it is in the past?
What if….you didn’t watch a video like this then, if you don’t want to be “spoiled”?
Goofy
Victor and Nicole never get together if he's on 19 too, since they reconnected at a BB19 premiere party 😂
I was about to comment this!
One of these days, the fandom is going to consider Josh Matinez a legend that was underrated from the beginning, and it's all going to be traced back here to your channel.
I can only dream
Your version of All Stars 2 sounds much much better than how it actually went
FACTS
All Stars 2 was so rigged. Hated watching it.
Right? Top 10 season even, but sadly, we live in the darkest timeline
It could have been 30 episodes of someone taking a shit and it would have been much better than how it actually went
I guess for a future one, what if Production didn't allegedly 'fix' the competition in 16 to allow Franky to win the veto solo.
Paul not being in BB19 is honestly pretty interesting to me. If some of the twists aren't here due to one less houseguest, I think it could be very interesting (possibly?) I think Jody, Maven, and Marlena stay aligned, but Dominique and Christmas might also stay loyal to them to, as they were originally in the Team (I think?) Jason Josh and Cameron have high chances of going early, but I could also see some combo of outsiders like Cam/Jason/Alex flipping the script on The Team. I also see Dominique getting very far, possibly playing both sides (Showmances and the Jillian/Ramses/Megan alliances) It could be very interesting
Here’s a interesting video idea. What player (it can’t be the winner) impacted each season the most. Meaning if that player wasn’t in the season, how different could it have been. Similar to what you talked in here about with Dan in bb14. Also Vanessa in bb17 greatly impacted the game. Could be interesting
I like that idea!
@@EthanimaleSooo can you do it!
I like the What If that Josh never came on The Challenge. 😭😭😭
Then there's substantially less annoying clips
@@DevinEDB hahaha you're not lucky then
Idk if this is a valid what-if since I'd be changing the whole game at this point, but on BB23, Claire and Derex were literally on the cusp of figuring out the Cookout but doubted themselves cause they couldn't imagine Tiffany betraying them. Imagine a scenario if they were able to figure it out. This then relies on some contingencies:
- They are somehow able to convince Tiffany to turn her back on the Cookout men (This would have to take place before Derex is evicted obviously)
- Tiffany then convinces Hannah over to their side
- Tiffany and Hannah use their consecutive HOH's to evict the men (worth noting that Xavier + Kyland do not win veto in Tiffany's HOH's)
With Alyssa Sarah Beth likely being next evicted, Tiffany literally wins the game by the time of the top 5 (Azah takes her as she sees her as the most deserving, Claire realizes the bigger mission and is willing to throw her game for her, I can't imagine Derex evicting her considering how hard Tiffany has fought for him in the game, and there is maybe a slight possibility that Hannah is willing to turn back on her final 2 deal, but I really don't think so)
Goes to show that if Tiffany played self-interestedly, she still accomplishes the Cookout's goal.
Facts tiff couldve done well for herself by actually turning on the cookout guys
To add to the Paul winning season 18, If Jessica or Cody were to have won Big Brother 19 in a season that didn't have Paul, they likely would not have gone on the 30th season of Amazing Race, which they won
great video dude i friggin love this format for a vid idea and with so many what if's in BB you should definitely make a part 4!
This one’s BBCAN but I still think it’s interesting and also plausible. What if Karen discovers Williams search for the black hole veto like she almost did several times. We saw her looking for Will while he was in the hidden vent as well as before when he was looking under the pool table. If he’s discovered, the show said that the veto would disappear and no longer have value. Because of this, in week 7 with both Kevin and Bruno on the block, Kevin can no longer be saved using the black hole veto meaning that there are 2 possible scenarios that come up. Since William also won the veto that week, the two main possibilities I see are him using it or not using it. Firstly, if Will uses the veto on Kevin some interesting things would happen, Demetres as the HOH could nominate Dre, Will’s number one ally but since up to that point and until week 8 Ika was close with Dre that’s unlikely. My theory in this part is that Karen still goes up as the rep nom, Bruno still goes home. However, Will’s betrayal likely causes Kevin who’s wins the next week to favour Will, since he has openly taken sides. This creates another two possibilities. In the first one, it’s quite possible Kevin doesn’t feel extremely alone and doesn’t try and curry favour with Demika for the next week, and leaves Demetres and Ika on the block, where for the first time the newbies actually control the votes. Since this is the week of Dre and Ika becoming enemies and Will has taken Kevin’s side openly, I actually think Ika gets voted out 3-2 by Jackie, Dre and William. If that happens, Demetres wins the triple and honestly, I think puts up Kevin, Dre and Jackie. Kevin wins veto(although Jackie was pretty good at veto, Jackie winning creates a whole other timeline I don’t want to get into) and takes himself off, and Will goes up as the rep. In this situation I think Will is the most likely to stay. Jackie has a chance but I don’t think can pull Dillon or Karen’s votes, so likely goes home. Dre unfortunately I think has zero change at this point, and is out in the triple. This leaves us with a final five of Kevin, William, Demetres, Karen and Dillon. Now either Kevin or William win HOH, but their noms are the same so it doesn’t matter, Kevin or Will wins veto, and Demetres goes fifth. At final four, Demetres won HOH, which he can no longer do. Because of that, I think in the interests of saving me time, Dillon/Karen wins. The alternate scenario is whichever of Will/Kevin winning, so I’ll goes through those quickly. If Kevin wins final four HOH, Kevin wins the game. It’s possible for Karen to win if Dillon wins, but I digress. Will wins, he either takes out Kevin by winning veto or doesn’t and loses. If Dillon/Karen wins, yet again whoever wins veto like wins the game. Now to fully rewind to if will doesn’t use the veto. To start, Kevin gets evicted. This makes everything much more complicated as it makes ever other HOH from now on have a different winner. Since it’s been a while since I’ve watched season five of BBCAN, and this comment is already extremely long, I’m not gonna goes to much into it, but I think the most likely winners are Ika, Will, Dre and Jackie, as Ika is the ringleader of the now dominant side of the house, Dre since her social game is good enough and both Ika and Will can act as shields, Will because he has a good social game and can win crucial comps and Jackie because it’s possible for her to float to the end in the middle where her being the pawn of the season I think could easily give her the win, although she loses Ika’s vote. Anyway yeah that’s my ‘what if’ that I think is interesting. Another one is if Kevin uses the veto in week 5, but yeah! Feel free to use them if you want. That’s a lot of text
Thank you for being one of the very few people to actually say my last name correctly on the shout out. Everyone wants to pronounce it with a t or with an extra l instead of the s, so special shout out to YOU for prouncing it correctly and with no hesitation!!
Same here! A lot of people pronounce mine like the guitar as opposed to the fish (the fish is the right one).
Hear me out, what if Tyler was eliminated in the hanging rope competition in 20
I like this one!
This is the most undervalued/underrated Big Brother channel in the world. Keep it up please!
It wouldn’t have surprised me if they decided to bring Nicole back for BB19 had Paul won in BB18 but that might have denied her epic eviction in BB22 from happening
What if Nathan doesn't use the POV on Alison in week 3 of BB4? This not only changes most of BB4 but it also could affect BB7 if Alison is no longer on that season and potentially no Erika either.
That’s a great one!
Thanks for the video I love these what-if scenarios! :) One that I was thinking about recently was what if there wasn't a second double eviction in BB23, and Hannah had more time to talk to Azah and possibly convince her that the guys were working together and to nominate Kyland next to Xavier instead of her. And with Kyland winning that veto it makes it interesting! Not sure how likely this is, but it could change the game outcome I think!
Although I think Hannah is unfortunately evicted in that situation still, you’re right in that it could make things a lot more interesting! Sad Hannah only had about 30 minutes to fight for her life when she may have had a better shot with a regular weeks worth of time
I’m just going to remember BB Allstars 2 with your version. So much better than the dumpster fire that we got witness.
The what if I love the most is that Dr. Will won the final five veto in All Stars.
What if the Rewind button is never put into play in BB 16?
Love these, gotta be my favorite series you do!
Yay! Love your what ifs!
I have one to really make your gears turn. Quite possibly one of the oldest what ifs possible: what if Will had NOT thrown the F4 HoH in BB2 and instead won it? Would he still have won? How would BB as a whole be affected if he didnt?
I look forward to seeing what yoi come up with!
Realistically I don't believe too much changes. I think he saves Monica and Monica votes out Hardy, and then I have to assume that Will is still able to convince Nicole that she has no chance of beating Monica in the end and Nicole still brings Will to F2 where Will wins. Will's legacy is probably *very slightly* tarnished as he no longer has that absolute GOAT statistic of never winning a single competition, but in general I don't think there would be too big of an effect long term. Maybe there's something I'm missing though
@@Ethanimale I mean, he threw the comp to keep the deal with nicole and hardy that if he won he wouldn’t put both of them up at the same time. He would’ve broken that deal with them, since no way in hell he doesn’t throw up both nicole and hardy, because then whoever he doesn’t put up votes out Monica. So he puts up Nicole and hardy, and it depends what Monica does, but either way it’s bad for will. If Monica votes out Nicole, hardy wins final HoH for sure, and boots will immediately, he wouldn’t have been able to be reasoned with. If Monica votes out Nicole, the narrative is different now, since will didn’t vote hardy out, and he didn’t save Nicole and bring her to the final 3. He actually did the opposite, broke his word to them and is the sole reason hardy left the game. Nicole would’ve been harder to reason with as we see she had quite the temper and there’s a very real chance she takes Monica just to spite will, since their relationship at this point would be so brittle nicole wouldn’t even care that she has a better chance against will and she listens to her vindictive side. Will loses, bada bing bada boom. At least from my perspective.
I think Monica can still beat him. Will typically doesnt do that well in comps even when he’s not throwing
I HAVE A GOOD ONE!!
What if America's Player wasn't a twist?
I think that my biggest what if is “what if Zach had used the veto on Jameka or Eric, splitting up the Denetos?”
What if Big Brother NEVER introduced Pandora's Box in any season it was in
britney would've had a chance to win 😭
These are my favs 😍
I always look forward to your videos every Monday. Thank you for your hard work 🖤💚. ETHANIMALE MONDAYS.....ETHANIMONDAYS???
Whichever sounds best.
I do love the sound of Ethanimondays
omg i love this series
This is one of my favorites. What if Donny never wins the week 1 veto in BB16 and instead a Bomb Squad member wins and discards?
BB2: what if the votes aren’t flipped week 1 and nicole is evicted instead of cheryl?
The biggest what if in bb8 would be what if Eric could've played his own game? There would've been 0 Donatos in the F2.
I want the break down of “What if the HOH could compete in the Veto?” (Only applies to Big Brother Canada Seasons 7 to Present).
“What if the HOH could compete in the Veto?”
Goddamn it Cody might legit just win out even harder in BB22 now lol
What if every bbcan triple evictions were double evictions instead?
Thanks for being my RUclips video every Monday at lunch 😊
I love these what ifs.
Dan would’ve DECIMATED everyone in 13
Do “What If Brendon and Rachel didn’t both get randomly drawn for Veto in Week 3 of BB12?”!
Which I believe only had a 2.7% chance of happening- 2/9 chance either get drawn first times 1/8 chance of getting the second- Figures including the HG choice where they wouldn’t be picked.
The entire house was against them and there were two pawns on the block. they can’t cover each other in the Counting comp if only one got picked, Brenchel can’t comp out for the next 4 week, Brigade is never forced to have two members on the block…does Hayden still win? Do Brenchel get enough screen time to make it into BB13?
Yo that last clip is fire lol
PLEASE do a season rankings for BB! That would be the best vid ever!!!
I think this would be interesting bc:
-you said
-U like BB4
-BB6, BB7, and BB10 are all some of ur favs
- BB9 was better than u expected
-BB11 was borderline great
-BB12 is great despite predictability
-BB14 has the best outcome ever
-BB18 is super underrated
-BB19 isn’t the worst
-BB20 saved BB
-BB21s post jury is one of the best ever
-BB23 is a mixed season
I feel like u love almost every season and I would love to see them lined up
I have plans for it at some point!
Dr. Will winning the final five veto of BB Allstars is the best What-If.
What if Nicole F never did Amazing Race so there was never bad blood between her and Janelle in All Stars 2?
I honestly don't that would change much. I think Franzel would still feel insecure and jealous around Janelle and want her out immediately.
Let’s go.
Rank every BB Comic or Memory Wall.
0:05 yes i do think that and often too
I don’t think Tiffany beats DX in that HOH comp. Dude was a beast!!!
One I've always wondered is what if just at least 1 player on BB All Stars was different? What if someone like Monica or Cowboy or Lisa or got in and how would that change the game. There's so many different opportunities that presents that I couldn't even begin to comprehend.
The amount of differences that could happen with that one is astronomical I love it
What if Production didnt screw up their first all stars competition that gave Janelle a clutch save
What if Paul didn’t receive safety in bb 19
I’m hoping for a “what if Paul didn’t come back for bb19” cause I wanna see you admit that Josh is pre-jury exit without Paul lol
YAAAAS!!! My wish has been granted, thank you Ethan for not letting your Josh bias skew the fact that he only won because Paul was there 👏👏
For next video “what if america brought back dom instead of brendan on bb13 i think it was one of the main reasons rachel ende up winning the game
Great idea, what if Amber and Eric fought at the final 10 or earlier instead of being later which should mean Eric goes home in 10th as Amber doesn’t vote to save Eric.
You should make a podcast but like a weekly episode and just talking about bb survivor and the challenge
No, I NEVER wished Josh was on all stars. He was vile on 19.
How in HELL is Josh a bright spot.I’d love to see someone clap frying pans in his mug.
thank you for being a josh fan, i am one too
What if the button reset never happens in BB16
What if William doesn’t save Kevin in BBCAN5
I have a bit of an odd what-if. What happens if BB2 was played in the same format as BB1?
That would be a very interesting one. Based on popularity, it's gotta be either Monica or Will that comes out on top
What if Enzo voted for Lane instead of Hayden to win in bb12? Does he still get cast for survivor blood vs water?
Do a Part 4
Great video as always. FYI, that pronunciation of my name wasn't correct. "Natic" is pronounced like "Fanatic", so with a short "A". Just for future reference.
Thanks for the correction!
@@Ethanimale you said the final 4 is Jody and maven. Bro did you forget about victor??? Yiu only mentioned him first. Victor would be a top dog
I’d like to see a video about your fave fast food and soda Ethanimale
Well that is certainly not the recommendation I was expecting to see. I like Five Guys (if that counts), and I don't drink soda. Wendy's is cool too
Some of these what ifs would have bigger life changing outcomes for some of them. If Dan didn't get married and him and Memphis take the place of Dick and Daniele. Then Daniele doesn't meet and marry Dominic. And then if Memphis doesn't go on to all stars he doesn't get together with and marry Christmas.
How about no returnees in Big Brother 18?
I have a few “what if” theories that all have to do with the living legend, queen Janelle Pierzina.
What If,
During the final HoH of BB6 Ivette evicts Maggie and not Janelle. Janelle is still guaranteed the votes of Howie, James, and Rachel, but the fourth vote is a toss up. Ivette gets the guaranteed votes of Jennifer and Beau, but the votes of April and Maggie are still up in the air. It is possible the Friendship alliance will support its final member in the finale giving Ivette the win. However, do April and Maggie vote for Janelle out of respect for the game she played and how she made it to the end with odds stacked against her.
OR
If Janelle wins the final HoH instead of Ivette. Does she vote out Ivette simply out of dislike, or does she realize that Maggie is the bigger threat and she course her out. Either way, the winner is kinda unclear for to April and Maggie constantly wavering.
What If,
In the first BBAllStars, Janelle wins the final HoH. If she evicts Erika, she is already guaranteed the votes of Marcellas, James, and Howie. She would not get the vote of Will and probably not Erika’s vote either. Meaning Chicken George and Danielle will determine who wins. I do however think Janelle wins due to getting Danielle’s vote out of respect for the game she played. So in this scenario, I think Janelle wins. However, if Janelle makes the logical move and evicts Mike Boogie, she still gets the guaranteed votes of Marcellas, James, and Howie, but she would also probably get the votes of Mike Boogie and Will put out respect. And most likely Danielle and Chicken George also out of respect. Meaning that if Janelle is sitting next to Erika in the final 2 of BBAllStars, she likely wins unanimously, being the first to do so. That also means Mike Boogie likely may not return for BB14 and a new coach would replace him. Likely Evel Dick or possibly a member of the Brigade.
for the first one, janelle would’ve won because the friendship made a pact that if any of them won final hoh and took someone from sov 6 to f2 instead of the other friendship member, they would all vote for the sov 6 player. ivette would still probably have beau’s vote, but maggie and april def would’ve voted for janelle just based on that pact
Heres a suggestion what if coup d'etat doesnt exist in bb11 and chima's hoh goes acording to plan
What if production of bbcan8 stepped in earlier and removed Kyle before the Jamar expulsion
Good good.
Alex and Jason were not a part of the power structure in BB19 because Jessica did not fuck with Alex like that. It’s more likely one of Alex or Jason is pre-jury, Dominique makes it deeper because she WAS one of Cody’s closest numbers, and whichever survives of Alex and Jason becomes the underdog
also Jess and Cody were much more loyal to Mark and Elena in the OG timeline,
so I would assume that applies to this alternate one and they would be F4
over Raven/Matt. Which leaves the door open for Mark to win some endgame comps and win
I think an interesting what if is “what if Danielle and Ali convinced Jase to not agree with Janelle in week one of All-Stars 1?” It’s a good question because I think it changes Janelle’s game, I know she wins that Veto but who makes that replacement nomination
But if Dan is on BB13, then who would the other coach on BB14 be?
You should do big brother canada what ifs
What if the first Allstars wasn't until after big brother 10 does Mike boogie still win? And if the winter season wasn't the til death do us part season and if it was a regular season for season 9
7:00 - 10:00 TLDR: Josh and Kaycee probably would’ve saved all stars
can u do another survivor what ifs Video please ?
What if McCrae caught Andy's bluff and send him packing instead of Elissa
What a dream that would be
“What if” the jury isn’t bitter in BB19 and actually votes for who played the best game and gives Paul his money?
Bitter juries are a result of bad gameplay. Josh outplayed Paul in jury management while staying afloat in the strategic and social
Game. That was enough.
What if Danielle won season 3? Would the jury start being sequestered? Would the cookout have been as big a deal last season?
What if Christmas' injury in BB19 was so bad that she had no choice but to be pulled from the game?
Idk what's in this video yet, but an interesting what if to me is What If Jessica saved Ramses with veto? Josh gets evicted next to Paul and/or Christmas, leading to a tiebreak with Cody and Christmas (at least, depending on what Ramses scores?) If Cody wins the final 12 HoH, I think the season changes drastically
Woah that’s actually super good
What if the mvp twist didn’t happen in bb15
What, if? Lane won the final for HOH instead of final five who do you take with them to the end? What does he do?
Did you ever cover what would happen if Nicole went against the alliance and didn’t vote out Ian in All Stars 2? I feel like you might have but I don’t remember
I never did that would be interesting for the next one!
What if Christmas never broke her leg
Another good one is what if the clique twist didn’t exist in bb11? Jeff would be gone first and probably wouldn’t have married jordan
You could do bbcan what ifs
biggest travesty ever I wanted to see josh play so bad I was salivating I needed him and even paul to come back so bad smh absolute travesty tbh thats woulda been a great season I think tyler and josh woulda worked together so well it woullda been so lit smh
Here’s a couple of ‘what if’ scenarios to touch on:
What if America voted to evict Memphis over Jessie in BB10?
What if Paul never got the Pendant of Protection in BB19?
How about in your next “What if’s” you work out what would've happened on BB17 if the Goblins sided with Becky in week 7 and voted out Vanessa instead.
So, in BB23 Sarah Beth and Derek X both end up sending each other home that week depending on who wins the HOH - unless SB somehow gets enough BB Bucks to play in the roulette comp, which I doubt she does. lol
it kinda makes sense that the original cast for AS2 would make it a better season
I love josh too omg
Ehh I got one, what if ... Bb17 Steve F4 HoH tiebreaker, Steve does NOT forget a digit so he goes over and John wins F4 HoH. Then Steve is likely in a must win Pov days competition versus Vanessa that imo would likely lose. I think that would become John-Vanessa Final HoH Part 3. Possibly Johnny Mac Bb17 winner.
Josh doesn’t have a “small” effect, he has no effect on the Challenge other than being a BB number affecting the vets, even then, it’s a small BB alliance that Kacey keeps him in and he provides very little, if anything to it. I like him more now than I did in WotW1 but he’s filler, every season he’s in, he’s not a great challenger, got an awful elim record, only wins by default, Michy wasn’t even finishing his slide puzzle and Josh struggled, to throw a ball, not great at the social aspect, he’s just there. Got Fessy sent home, which is great but he wasn’t winning that season anyway and it was his own alliance member. I want to see him back, I’m just never excited for his chances, would love to see him take a Devon turn, but I’m not optimistic. 🤷♀️ The only thing I will give him credit for is at least trying to bring Amber into the alliance, she’s a doll and doesn’t deserve any of what the BB players do to her. 🙄😒
Really wish Paul would've won 18 and KC would've replaced Nicole. Nicole was annoying in all stars 2.
What if Jodi stayed night one? 😲😲
I can’t possibly imagine dan on bb13
One of my biggest "What ifs"
What if
In big brother all-stars during the first hoh Jase goes with the house and disagrees with janelle and they go on the block. In this scenario let's say janelle doesn't win veto or get saved.
Now will doesn't have janelle to win comps how much does the legacy of janelle change if she doesn't dominate the challenges of bb all stars
What if Frankie Lost the BOTB
What if James beat Nicole in BB18s hoh
What if David doesn't take the $50,000 in Otev
According to one of your scenarios for BB8, if Jamika had already won would there have been as much of a push by the cookout
To stick together as they went on?
I hope Casey and Josh only ever come back during an all winners season of Big Brother. Otherwise, just let them enjoy their time on MTV with The Challenge