G#4: Kelly nice tone A4: Beyonce (her resonance sounded better) Bb4: kelly (more resonant) B4: Kelly (more power) C5: Beyonce was very quiet while Kelly's was loud quality (not gonna count this one) C#5: Beyonce more resonant D5: Kelly very nice Eb5: Kelly (more powerful) E5: Kelly (ease and pleasant) F5: Both sounded off key and struggled (But Kelly was less bad) F#5: Kelly Winner: Kelly (7) - Beyonce (2)
So hard to choose since they are both top notch star rated vocalists....But Kelly Clarkson is the queen of emotions! what emotive way of singing! So I choose with Kelly Clarkson
Kelly clarkson all day!!! Tremendous technique power and soul. I feel she gets better every year. Beyonce is also very talented but Kelly sends chills up my spine
I'll go for Kelly...because most of her entries here were off stage and still kill it...whereas for Beyonce all were during concert and expected to give it all...sooo KELLY all the way. Tho i think Beyonce is great too.
G#4: Tie G#4: Tie A4: Bey A4: Bey Bb4: Tie Bb4: Bey B4: Bey, but they have different approaches there B4: Tie C5: Bey C5::Bey C#5: Bey C#5: Beyonce's clarity D5: Bey D5: Tie Eb5: Tie Eb5: Kelly E5: Tie, didnt like both E5: Kelly F5: Bey F5: Some were good from Bey, some not, overall tie, leaning to Kelly F#5: Bey F#5: Tie, Beyonce too aggressive, Kelly too thin
Wait are y'all trying to say that Kelly Clarkson can't "sang"? For a White girl Kelly Clarkson can Blow. That's like saying Carrie Underwood can't "sang" cause for a White girl Carrie Underwood can "Sang" STOP trying to compare White artist to Beyonce or any female artist at that NONE of them can come close. Beyonce is ALWAYS fine tuning her instrument.
Even being a mezzo, from Eb5 and up Beyoncé is supirior. Kelly’s belts are quite strained. This had a quite poor choice of notes for Beyoncé tho. But good job anyway.
I MP - that’s a stylistic choice. She’s demonstrated this in many occasions. Still my point holds true. It’s due to good technique and proper care for the voice that her voice’s been able to sustain for nearly two decades
ohhh hhh Tell me when Beyonce stops overusing echos and reverbs during her performances and compare their acoustic performances alone. Naturally, Beyonce is a Coloratura Light Lyric Mezzo Soprano, while Kelly is Full Lyric Soprano. Tell me who naturally has fuller tone.
ohhh hhh Yeah tell me when Beyonce stops overusing echo & reverbs during her performances to imitate “big resonance & thick voice”. Thin small tone means nothing in vocals LMAO. Sorry you cant carry microphone during your acoustics performance. If they would sing together w/out microphone, you wont be able to hear a thing from Beyonce since Kelly would overpower her voice. 🤣🤣🤣
@@yureino you're so dumb, reverb doesn't make the voice thicker or bigger it just gives that echo effect like your singing in a big room but it doesn't change the tone or anything like that
People who say Kelly above Beyoncé probably don’t know nothing about music 😂. Beyoncé has a better technique and soul when we talk about singing. She is also an actress, choreographer and a producer. Beyoncé is just like Mariah, Whitney or Barbra Streisand. She is a Diva ! By the way I love Kelly
Soul/Emotion is entirely subjective so you cannot say that Beyoncé has more soul than Kelly or vice versa because it depends on different people's perspective. I personally find more emotion/soul in Kelly's voice but then again, that's just my opinion. For this particular video, Kelly outdoes Beyoncé. She's a slightly better belter than Bey, but Beyoncé definitely has her beat in lows and head voice (putting Kelly against Beyoncé for low notes is a waste of time because obviously Beyoncé would win).
The higher Kelly goes from D5 and up the more tense she gets and the more resonance she loses. Beyoncé even though she's been growling a lot more still manages to produce the maximum amount of control and resonance up to F5 as a mezzo.
Those ratings can't be trusted. Kelly is at around the same level as P!nk and Lady Gaga vocally so if these "ratings" could be trusted, I'd say an A at the very least.
@@renanchaves3834 listen to kelly doing Whitney's I will always love you, and run to you, and queen of the night.. no B Rated singer could would dare to sing those tough songs
The lower belts Kelly cause she has better tone, but higher notes Beyoncé because she aces them, hits them better, growls better, and has more resonance
Love both, but Kelly.
Beyoncé slayed me yet again 😍😍😍😍
Kelly. Her tone and richness, for me, is miles ahead but that's a personal taste thing I guess. Both are talented on an inhuman level. Great video 😊
Beyoncé is sooooo resonant!
Both tremendous vocalists! But Kelly makes you feel the songs so hard! So soulful and emotive!!
Kelly is for me here!
Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
Angel Frost I would love to!
Without a doubt,Kelly Clarkson all the way!!!
Kelly all the way!
G#4: Kelly nice tone
A4: Beyonce (her resonance sounded better)
Bb4: kelly (more resonant)
B4: Kelly (more power)
C5: Beyonce was very quiet while Kelly's was loud quality (not gonna count this one)
C#5: Beyonce more resonant
D5: Kelly very nice
Eb5: Kelly (more powerful)
E5: Kelly (ease and pleasant)
F5: Both sounded off key and struggled (But Kelly was less bad)
F#5: Kelly
Winner: Kelly (7) - Beyonce (2)
Beyoncé off key and struggling at F5's???? Lmaooo you wish
@@everton7361 both of them did not even struggle..... Beyonce sounds so good at F5, kelly too!
I like people that emote when they sing..Kelly is exactly that and she wins in my openion.
So hard to choose since they are both top notch star rated vocalists....But Kelly Clarkson is the queen of emotions! what emotive way of singing!
So I choose with Kelly Clarkson
Kelly clarkson all day!!! Tremendous technique power and soul. I feel she gets better every year. Beyonce is also very talented but Kelly sends chills up my spine
I'll go for Kelly...because most of her entries here were off stage and still kill it...whereas for Beyonce all were during concert and expected to give it all...sooo KELLY all the way. Tho i think Beyonce is great too.
Yes Because in the commodity of home way harder to sing lol.
Of course I have to go with my girl Kelly
+High Notes Are My Drug Of course dear! the tone and power of Kelly Slays! Did you like the notes I added in this video from her?
Angel Frost we did!!!
Could you see my cover and tell me your opinion please? Here I leave the link ruclips.net/video/zesB0V_P_Bw/видео.html
Beyonce's belts after E5 are not evern worthy of being called belts, its too exclamative, i can fucking do that 🤣
Beyonce for the win to be honest.
my gosh, kelly ate that
I'm gonna have to go with kelly
Beyonce
Beyonce -mezzo all the way.
Kelly
G#4: Tie
G#4: Tie
A4: Bey
A4: Bey
Bb4: Tie
Bb4: Bey
B4: Bey, but they have different approaches there
B4: Tie
C5: Bey
C5::Bey
C#5: Bey
C#5: Beyonce's clarity
D5: Bey
D5: Tie
Eb5: Tie
Eb5: Kelly
E5: Tie, didnt like both
E5: Kelly
F5: Bey
F5: Some were good from Bey, some not, overall tie, leaning to Kelly
F#5: Bey
F#5: Tie, Beyonce too aggressive, Kelly too thin
Kellegend
Wait are y'all trying to say that Kelly Clarkson can't "sang"? For a White girl Kelly Clarkson can Blow. That's like saying Carrie Underwood can't "sang" cause for a White girl Carrie Underwood can "Sang" STOP trying to compare White artist to Beyonce or any female artist at that NONE of them can come close. Beyonce is ALWAYS fine tuning her instrument.
Kelly can go up to Bb5
Kelly Clarkson range is Eb3-G5-E6 and Beyoncé's is F2-G#5-G6.
@@wouldyoulikesomesugainthat3173 Kelly has belted an A5! Search for this note before talking fake things !
That Bb5 i wouldn't consider a belt.More like a heady mix exclamation
Same for the A5
Tales Zuckermann well the A5 was good so i'll give to her as a belt.But anyway G#5 is only half note off an A5
Even being a mezzo, from Eb5 and up Beyoncé is supirior. Kelly’s belts are quite strained.
This had a quite poor choice of notes for Beyoncé tho. But good job anyway.
Kelly;s notes are not strained stupid Beyoncé fan
@@sandatotten552 Kelly's belting technique has never been the best.
@@Ignasimp You don't belt live for 17 years without having decent technique.
@@omelette429 decent yes, but that's it. She has a great voice. But she pushes her high belts.
I MP - that’s a stylistic choice. She’s demonstrated this in many occasions. Still my point holds true. It’s due to good technique and proper care for the voice that her voice’s been able to sustain for nearly two decades
wait.....was that Demi Lovato at the end??? Queen Demi?
0:57 is everything..
Kelly all the way. Beyonce is just using lotsa echo to sound bigger and more resonant. Her technique is overrated. Next
Songsource nah..
ohhh hhh Tell me when Beyonce stops overusing echos and reverbs during her performances and compare their acoustic performances alone.
Naturally, Beyonce is a Coloratura Light Lyric Mezzo Soprano, while Kelly is Full Lyric Soprano. Tell me who naturally has fuller tone.
ohhh hhh Yeah tell me when Beyonce stops overusing echo & reverbs during her performances to imitate “big resonance & thick voice”. Thin small tone means nothing in vocals LMAO. Sorry you cant carry microphone during your acoustics performance. If they would sing together w/out microphone, you wont be able to hear a thing from Beyonce since Kelly would overpower her voice. 🤣🤣🤣
@@yureino you're so dumb, reverb doesn't make the voice thicker or bigger it just gives that echo effect like your singing in a big room but it doesn't change the tone or anything like that
@@everton7361 the fact that you are replying to a 2years old comment shows that you’re even more dumb and have no brain. Next.
Beyoncé. Her technique is unmatched
Beyoncé is better. Boice is more developed and she voice services the music better than Kelly.
People who say Kelly above Beyoncé probably don’t know nothing about music 😂. Beyoncé has a better technique and soul when we talk about singing.
She is also an actress, choreographer and a producer. Beyoncé is just like Mariah, Whitney or Barbra Streisand. She is a Diva !
By the way I love Kelly
Soul/Emotion is entirely subjective so you cannot say that Beyoncé has more soul than Kelly or vice versa because it depends on different people's perspective. I personally find more emotion/soul in Kelly's voice but then again, that's just my opinion.
For this particular video, Kelly outdoes Beyoncé. She's a slightly better belter than Bey, but Beyoncé definitely has her beat in lows and head voice (putting Kelly against Beyoncé for low notes is a waste of time because obviously Beyoncé would win).
You’re delusional 😂
why Kelly's notes so tensed and strident, despite the fact that she has great ease and facility above E5.. it's soo strange
Devonte Lampkin that’s a lot of sopranos nowadays
Because the clips that were used were from performances after her pregnancy.
The higher Kelly goes from D5 and up the more tense she gets and the more resonance she loses. Beyoncé even though she's been growling a lot more still manages to produce the maximum amount of control and resonance up to F5 as a mezzo.
Yes, that's what i noticed as well, she doesnt thin out up there, Kelly does
is Kelly Clarkson a star rated vocalist??? just curious .. she's so good omg
B or B+
Those ratings mean nothing. It's literally made by some Mariah fan on social media. Its not credible at all.
Those ratings can't be trusted. Kelly is at around the same level as P!nk and Lady Gaga vocally so if these "ratings" could be trusted, I'd say an A at the very least.
@@renanchaves3834 whoever gave that rating to Kelly Clarkson is delusional. She's wayyy above.
@@renanchaves3834 listen to kelly doing Whitney's I will always love you, and run to you, and queen of the night.. no B Rated singer could would dare to sing those tough songs
The lower belts Kelly cause she has better tone, but higher notes Beyoncé because she aces them, hits them better, growls better, and has more resonance