Punch Brothers - "New York City" (Live at WFUV)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- wfuv.org • Follow @wfuv: ow.ly/flLAg
Punch Brothers perform "New York City" live in Studio A. Recorded 2/21/12.
Host: Claudia Marshall
Engineer: Joe Grimaldi
Cameras: Claire Donovan, Erica Talbott, and Patrick Moore
Editor: Claire Donovan
Hard to say what sticks most in this tune. Noam’s pretty much on a shredding banjo solo the entire tune (reminds me of Carter’s drums on some DMB tunes). Chris playing drum fills on the mando at about 2:15. There is so much friggin rhythm in that right hand of his!! Fiddle solo is crazy! Gifted dudes, every one of them! Well done guys!
Noam's percolatin'!
Fantastic version. The work of Paul Kowert in this band is overlooked. He is the glue and the soul of the Punch Brothers.
+Colorado Paul Not overlooked by me! Anyone with Edgar Meyer as a mentor is someone to keep an eye on. Totally agree.
This song is the most technical display of *yearning* ever. Absolutely magical.
Well said. It's breathtaking.
Love, love, love this song.
Agreed! There is something to be said for the engineer here too, getting it to sound so great with just a few mics (granted they're 3K each!) but yes, this is way too rare today!
oh my god Noam
Very cool Mic arrangement here. And of course an amazing performance by the Punch Brothers.
Very impressive.
Amazing - just love these guys.
Crank up the banjo!
Cuudoo ,ta kapela ,to jebaneee cudooo !!! Awesome 🙈
Wow! Excellent dynamics on the condenser mics, and everybody sings!
It's real magic when you 'grow a band' like this......
I keep seeing all these amazing things from WFUV but it was all before I came to this school! Very sad haha but it's cool to know at least that they were once on campus :)
is it just me or are all of these guys insanely good musicians ...
in a tight as hell band .... ?
its very hard to be this good and they make it all look so easy
Chris plays the mandolin like a guitar. His rhythm playing is just fantastic and it has such a wonderful effect on the music. If you watch him, he, with the guitar are the rhythm section. That is by far his greatest strength. He builds melody through harmony. I really enjoy his playing.
now that is a top comment and needed saying. It makes you wonder if people realise half the time whats going on with production and trickery etc.. Thankfully I do actually believe more and more people are developing a taste for 'real' live, feel, music with no frills except talent, and boy oh boy thats what you get here
2:09 is one of the sexiest moments in music history
I think the thing I love most about Noam Pikelny is that at the end of every song he looks totally, completely and absolutely bored.
Bored resting face haha
the punch brothers show that you dont need all that post production studio crap to sound good. this video is just as tight and just a clear as the album. true examples of how a band should sound and that you should listen to the other members and blend with them instead of recording everything separate and smashing it together. true musicians
good stuff...
Indeed.. though I have to say from standing in that room - these guys are so good, the mics might as well be 57s. They know how work together, use a space and blend! A rare skill these days, to be sure
There’s more reverb on the album and that’s…basically the only difference. Unbelievable musicians.
Man you don't realize how fast this song is til you try to play (guitar) along with these guys, they are beasts! noticed Critter always makes it look so easy but you gotta have a loose wrist or something to keep up!
That’s the irony-to be this precise you have to be relaxed! Always a challenge for me 😂😅🤦♂️
@@Ravelle17 True, that must be the secret! Man this song is so good.
the one the only
Love the PB, and a tip of the cap to the sound engineers for this fine recording. Doncha just love those Neumann mics? Great artists behind the gear as well as in front. Thanks!
New Yawk, New Yawk......snow on the Hudson indeed.
Isn't it cool? They really know how to work their arrangements into any acoustic environment
hearing this for the first time in years and so many emotions are flowing through me. so much love
I love this. I can't believe they manage to repeat it.
over and over
it all depends on the engineer and the style of music being played. Certain styles of music are compressed and many fx are used but just because of this does not mean all work done in studios is crap. Most engineers don't like using fx when they don't need to, and it is shown in their recordings.
No, andersingram, it's not just you! Chris has surrounded himself with four absolute virtuosos!
Just saw them last night at the El Rey in Hollywood....Great show!
They recorded the album Punch like that. It was literally just them in front of the mic and when one was meant to be heard more than others, he would step forward. They are tight as butholes!
Yes i agree, i saw Him when he was still with nickel creek, very talented bluegrass musicians, then again most are
Exactly. Too many bands these days are only good because of things like auto tune. This is just plain, raw skill and talent that just can't be matched by the best auto tuning and post production frills!
Does anyone know where I could find the chords for this?! I need them so badly!
intro G-, verse II: G-, C-, Ebmaj7, G- :II C-, Ebmaj7, F, G-, II: G-, C-, Ebmaj7, G- :II C-, Ebmaj7, F, chorus II: Bb, D-7, C7, Ebmaj7 :II (this will get you to the middle instrumental which has more chords and subtleties than I can express in quickie chords)
Any luck? Lol
the Music fan in me is shocked how amazing they are, but the woman in me is watching the speed of their fingers:s
Greatest band ever! nuf said. Your a sharp dresser too Chris. I toned it down from what my mom said. I didn't notice til she said something. actual lol.
Wow, musicians with actual talent and skill. That's unusal to find these days.
Great song, makes me smile, goes with my sunny sunny day
post production audio (mixing and mastering) is meant to clean up a recording session that was not at it's fullest potential. I've always treated it as such. a great live engineer these guys have. kudos
Reminds me of the Genesis album - trick of the tail. I love this!...and I confess that country, especially bluegrass, really bothers me.
This was dated Mar 6, 2012. If this was dated Sept 28, 2021, the song title would be "New York City Sucks".....just sayin'............
Literal perfection.
Crazy..it sounds just like the album. There are probably a handful of artists out there who can replicate their sound so perfectly and effortlessly. Raw talent right here
god bless y'all...beautiful..I can't help of think of the towers...what a tribute..
Yes twitchie, it be Chris.
wow!...these guys are amazing...not long discovered them...loved Clara so much thought I'd hear more...This track is awesome too!
Clara is such a heartbreaker! “Your eyes are not a window, they’re a one-way mirror to my soul” 😭
Joan, I think Clara is about a grown woman who as a child witnessed her father assault her mother, and her father is still living in her head. Is that how you interpret it? The tune is so beautiful, and the lyrics so fraught.
@@Ravelle17 Nick, same question as I asked Joan above. What story do you hear in Clara?
aahh one of the greatest bands ever!
This is how it is done
These guys are geniouses!
Love it!
I still love Nickelcreek
Absolutely Braw!
Totally diggin' on this band right now.
2:06…”my band kicks ass”
And 3:07 to the end, maybe best outro EVER!
“If I knew would you”…what’s the final lyric in that line at :47?
sounds like York. You York makes no sense anywhere except in this context, so I'm good with that.
looks like his right hand is hardly moving!
so good.
2:08 awesome! Love that part
Sweet!
Fuuuuuck that Banjo riffing at 1:45. Holy shit.
Amazing!
DELICIOUS!!! Yum yum yummy yum.
Haha yeah I think the same thing!
Can I just like marry Christ Thile? PLEASE?
this is so Dope!!
badass
JESUS CHRIST said: Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest. Seek JESUS CHRIST, seek Salvation, turn to Him !
Who let him in here?
Is the Singer/mandolinist Chris Thile?
yes
Ugh, Chris Thile! ;D 3
Fat? Lolwut
riptrippers?
Where can I find a tab for the guitar part?
I wrote out some chords about 15 posts above
@@norfitz lol thanks man
you realize those microphones are worth more than a used car lol
But they only needed one!
Good mics, bad placement.. this could sound quite a bit better than it does. There's all sorts of phase cancellation happening here, especially on vox.
Critter kinda looks like a younger, thinner Stephen Fry...
just can't get into their music--tried--but it just ain't there
I admire them so much