James O’Brien left astonished by Liz Truss' PMQs performance | LBC

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 окт 2022
  • In his immediate reaction to #PMQs James O’Brien delivers a compelling analogy for Liz Truss’ attempt to defend her tax cuts.
    This video clip is from an LBC show presented by James O'Brien on 12/10/22.
    Listen to the full show on Global Player: l-bc.co/ListenNow
    #JamesOBrien #LizTruss #LBC
    LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs. We let you join the conversation and hold politicians to account.
    Subscribe for more: l-bc.co/subscribe
    The latest videos from LBC: l-bc.co/Latest
    Listen live to LBC on Global Player: l-bc.co/ListenNow
    Nick Ferrari’s latest show: l-bc.co/3biHVvM
    James O’Brien’s latest show: l-bc.co/3ONyPVI
    Shelagh Fogarty’s latest show: l-bc.co/3JkNEha
    Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
    Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
    Like, follow and subscribe to LBC!
    Website: lbc.co.uk
    Facebook: lbc
    Twitter: / lbc
    Instagram: / lbc
    This is not your ordinary talk radio stream. LBC is the leading RUclips channel for live debate around the news and current affairs. We have live interviews and debates and you can even phone in to join in the conversation.

Комментарии • 1,2 тыс.

  • @Binsonhope
    @Binsonhope Год назад +318

    "Mum what are we having for tea tonight?"
    "what I can tell you is, we have taken decisive action on energy bills..."

    • @bigpants6121
      @bigpants6121 Год назад +21

      dont forget to blame Putin.

    • @paulgibbon5991
      @paulgibbon5991 Год назад +6

      @@bigpants6121 Putin did start this with energy blackmail. Hey, that happens and it's not the first time we've had a situation like this. Other countries actually took sensible measures to mitgate the impact on their citizens, but out defective government chose insider trading instead.

    • @jjseluk
      @jjseluk Год назад +12

      “Dad why did you cheat on mum?”
      “Putin would want us to be divided right now”

    • @rob5197
      @rob5197 Год назад

      @@paulgibbon5991 Putin has not blackmailed anyone how can anyone believe LIZZ and the all west propaganda, lies and pass the blame - - Putin is simply retaliating to continuous sanction imposed on Russia - - do you all expect Putin to send a thank you card ? - - in what world you all live ? -

    • @hi-ls6lt
      @hi-ls6lt Год назад

      @@jjseluk 😂

  • @diverguy3556
    @diverguy3556 Год назад +1010

    Today's PMQs was absolutely savage: Truss refused to acknowledge questions put to her by Starmer, she blatantly lied and misrepresented her opponents . This was unlike any thing I've ever seen before. The tories have nothing to go on, and they know it. This can't go on.

    • @weswheel4834
      @weswheel4834 Год назад +155

      I particularly enjoyed the bit where Blackford said, "We're supposed to be the ones asking the questions. We can swap places if you want."

    • @cowardsallaround98
      @cowardsallaround98 Год назад +3

      @@weswheel4834
      I'll live in his castle ifhe would swap with me

    • @raj_kumar0
      @raj_kumar0 Год назад +11

      Yes it can...we have a lot further to fall before we come to our collective sense

    • @patriciamcl54
      @patriciamcl54 Год назад +23

      @@cowardsallaround98 Relevance to anything?

    • @paulwilson7234
      @paulwilson7234 Год назад +4

      Unfortunately it will for the foreseeable future.

  • @kanedNunable
    @kanedNunable Год назад +753

    so, we cant afford to renationalise for 40bn but we can afford to give those companies 200bn to keep prices a bit lower than planned?! seriously? how thick do you have to be to vote tory?

    • @michaelpower4372
      @michaelpower4372 Год назад +50

      The Tories all had hands in oil companies cookie gars.

    • @stephenmills7061
      @stephenmills7061 Год назад +16

      People generally vote for the three S's, Safety , Security , Survival.
      They do this through fear.

    • @internetenjoyer1044
      @internetenjoyer1044 Год назад +5

      After renationalising the government would still have to pay the difference to keep costs lower

    • @SamoIsKing
      @SamoIsKing Год назад +71

      @@internetenjoyer1044 Costs are so high because these energy companies have profit targets to hit. If they’re being run on a non-profit basis costs would come down overnight.

    • @jwr04CFC
      @jwr04CFC Год назад +41

      @@internetenjoyer1044 nonsense. They’d be run to pay their way not make obscene profit.

  • @bikedockbicycles
    @bikedockbicycles Год назад +43

    "How are you going to pay for the Lamborghini?"
    "Don't worry I've had a pay cut!"

  • @blackenedsprite8542
    @blackenedsprite8542 Год назад +72

    It's like Porridge, where did you put the dirt? We dug another hole and put it in that

    • @veganmama2five397
      @veganmama2five397 Год назад +4

      absolutely!! :)

    • @TearTheRoof0ff
      @TearTheRoof0ff Год назад +4

      lol. That's a great line.

    • @geraldhewing2076
      @geraldhewing2076 Год назад +3

      Did that leave them with two whole holes?

    • @ennbee2051
      @ennbee2051 Год назад +3

      Finally someone with some taste in the comment section.

    • @wicksee
      @wicksee Год назад +2

      @@ennbee2051 lacking in the spelling department however.

  • @sylvaintaif8128
    @sylvaintaif8128 Год назад +183

    I'm home and sick with covid...
    And the husbandy Porsche analogy had me bursting into laughter...
    Followed by 2 minutes of non stop coughing 🤣

    • @JP-lz3vk
      @JP-lz3vk Год назад +10

      Get well soon. Also totally worth it to laugh at a time like this

    • @sylvaintaif8128
      @sylvaintaif8128 Год назад +10

      @@JP-lz3vk well... I'm French so I'm not a victim of those UK policies... the Johnson to Truss Tories summer saga has all but been a strange spectacle to watch 😶 (yet we have our own troubles with Macron and his neolibs, and the far right - I obviously speak from the left)
      My heart goes to the ordinary people who'll pay the brunt of the deadly consequences. Be they Tory voters or not.

    • @hi-ls6lt
      @hi-ls6lt Год назад +7

      Ugh COVID made me cough for about two weeks straight. Get well soon mate.

    • @kevinshanahan6064
      @kevinshanahan6064 Год назад

      I hope you are under a blanket and not using the heating.

    • @cliveramsbotty6077
      @cliveramsbotty6077 Год назад +2

      lol pmqs was a car crash so bad you could hear it from france

  • @michaelscarlino1590
    @michaelscarlino1590 Год назад +26

    Keeping a house warm that you no longer have, brilliant 😂🤣

  • @Draekal
    @Draekal Год назад +246

    That was an excellent metaphor from James

    • @pentz1
      @pentz1 Год назад +3

      Yup, right on the money...it got Theo tongue tied

    • @mikewhitehead50
      @mikewhitehead50 Год назад +4

      I don’t know if a penny drop moment followed or whether he was just tongue-tied.

    • @GJI77
      @GJI77 Год назад

      It was terrible and misleading analogy. A more accurate analogy would be that she SOLD the Lamborghini (cut taxes), then people complained and she the. points out that people aren’t talking about the Porsche she just bought (help with energy bills).

    • @mikewhitehead50
      @mikewhitehead50 Год назад +17

      @@GJI77 selling a Lambo would put money in your pocket though. Like taxing more, not cutting taxes.

    • @NocturnalDoom
      @NocturnalDoom Год назад

      @@mikewhitehead50 if you’re selling to yourself you can sell at a lost and then write that off, that’s how they cut taxes. There are certain ways in which you can get write offs.

  • @NotAnIlluminatiSpy
    @NotAnIlluminatiSpy Год назад +269

    I liked the part where he got halfway through his counter analogy and realised he had nothing.

    • @TehCrushinatorz
      @TehCrushinatorz Год назад +4

      He could have at least suggested that he rent out the Porsche to other drivers to subsidize the payments of the Ferrari. I think that's the complete version of the analogy he couldn't reach, which in no do I way endorse this notion with dealing with the nation's economic absolute state.

    • @paulj7997
      @paulj7997 Год назад +3

      @@TehCrushinatorz Did he buy a Ferrari as well? .... 😉😉

    • @TehCrushinatorz
      @TehCrushinatorz Год назад +3

      @@paulj7997 I think in this analogy and the Porsche is the government buying the cost of energy, and the Ferrari is the tax cuts for the rich and bankers bonuses which somehow pays for itself. As you can clearly read on this Conservative "mini budget": phase one: make rich people richer, phase two: ???, phase three: profit.

    • @Mydyingbraincell
      @Mydyingbraincell Год назад +7

      @@paulj7997 to be fair who can spell Lamborghini anyway?

    • @cowardsallaround98
      @cowardsallaround98 Год назад

      @@TehCrushinatorz go glue your hands to a pavement

  • @wanklefish
    @wanklefish Год назад +616

    She's the best the Conservative party can offer, which is a sad indictment of how far they have fallen.

    • @hayleyxyz
      @hayleyxyz Год назад +53

      Tbh Sunak would've been marginally better; he wouldn't have crashed the markets at least. It's a mix of lack of talent in parliament and the conservative membership being swivel-eyed loons.

    • @Cruddy129
      @Cruddy129 Год назад +28

      She's our best chance in seeing the tories fall flat on their faces and kicked out, because even her own government wants her out, and she's been barely 3 months as the new PM by now

    • @weswheel4834
      @weswheel4834 Год назад +23

      @@hayleyxyz ​ @Hayley I'd heard it said that Labour would have preferred Sunak because he had an existing economic record to attack. So it is quite helpful of Truss to quickly provide an even worse one to go for.

    • @troywalkertheprogressivean8433
      @troywalkertheprogressivean8433 Год назад +10

      They started at fallen

    • @kanedNunable
      @kanedNunable Год назад

      when were they not useless? they have bankrupted the country several times now. then they blame who comes in next for the mess.

  • @SprikSprak
    @SprikSprak Год назад +339

    What was even more crazy about this PMQs was her reliance on the assertion they'd taken action on energy prices. Not only does the mortgage increase wipe out any saving that families needed, and also directly threaten their homes, not just the temperature of them, but it also completely ignores the fact the market instability was caused by a lack of explaining how the budget was going to be paid for past borrowing when the option was on the table to use a windfall tax. They steadfastly refused against all logic to do so instead promising sweeping tax cuts and spends, all driven by borrowing, all unexplained because they sidestepped the procedures for vetting and oversight. This is more than amateur, it's more than incompentant, it's willfull, entitled arrogance and self delusion. The sooner she and her cabinet, indeed her party, are gone from power the absolute better for the UK.

    • @georgec7899
      @georgec7899 Год назад +9

      100%CORRECT

    • @jonjames7328
      @jonjames7328 Год назад +3

      I’m afraid we’ll need the Tories in power until one of the other parties reaches some form of maturity.

    • @badbooks476
      @badbooks476 Год назад +35

      @@jonjames7328 The other parties have been way more mature than the Tories for a long time

    • @BigHenFor
      @BigHenFor Год назад +3

      They can't understand why you're not grateful, especially as that mini budget probably cut your Defined Contribution Pension fund value by 50% as well.

    • @janewright2800
      @janewright2800 Год назад +4

      Agreed! We have had more than enough!!!

  • @punkywozza4330
    @punkywozza4330 Год назад +277

    But the money they borrowed to help us pay our energy bill went straight to the enegry companies who were already in massive amounts of profit anyway.

    • @manic2360
      @manic2360 Год назад +26

      Another massive transference of wealth from the public to the private sector....again.

    • @roisinmalone3015
      @roisinmalone3015 Год назад +10

      It's still borrowed money that has to be paid back.

    • @julezpanda14
      @julezpanda14 Год назад

      The penny dropped!! Never believe a Tory when their lips move because you just know they're messing with the working class and feeding the fat cat's!!!

    • @FlyingKeo045
      @FlyingKeo045 Год назад +6

      Exactly. Any sane PM, HAD to implement energy price mitigation, otherwise, put out the lights and close the door on the UK. The energy companies still get their excess profits from the consumers whatever.way it is paid.

    • @georgec7899
      @georgec7899 Год назад +6

      Totally OBSCENE whatever you kook at it

  • @steffen1405
    @steffen1405 Год назад +20

    The worst part about this (analogy) is that the Porsche was actually free (windfall tax) but she insisted on paying for 2 supercars instead of none, and the whole enterprise will force us to sell our mortgaged mansion at time of rampant inflation and destroy our credit rating, so we'll be homeless and bankrupt from now on.

  • @royrcf
    @royrcf Год назад +62

    If you borrow money to help pay energy bills because the enrgy companies are charging excessive amounts, but you don't tax their profits, aren't the taxpayers paying twice. Once with their bills and again when the government raise taxes to pay the loan.

    • @wayneford2481
      @wayneford2481 Год назад +6

      I totally agree I have tried to say the same but you said it better thank you.

    • @marcogiuliocamurri
      @marcogiuliocamurri Год назад

      That's entirely the Tory's plan. Make a massive hole in public finances and force the next government, clearly Labour, to raise taxes to fill the hole, then blame them for being the "tax party", and then win the following elections.

    • @NoHeartAnthony
      @NoHeartAnthony Год назад

      They’re not necessarily raising taxes they’re just going to collect them for decades to pay off this debt and the spiralling interest. How anyone could vote Tory I don’t know

    • @sisternum9022
      @sisternum9022 Год назад

      We have been double paying for years however many of us didn’t realise it until recently.

  • @neilpemberton5523
    @neilpemberton5523 Год назад +105

    I had to laugh at the end, when James' voice is cracking from disbelief and he looks incredulously around the studio. 🙂

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад

      ....playing to his gullible audience and they lap it up....painful to behold....😊....

    • @dannylad1600
      @dannylad1600 Год назад +3

      @@chatham43, he had a point though.

    • @Sou1defiler
      @Sou1defiler Год назад +4

      @@chatham43 So where is he wrong?

  • @Rosbif06600
    @Rosbif06600 Год назад +156

    She gave the same 'answer' to every question; pretending the energy bill cap is a Tory gift and avoiding talk of how it is to be repayed or that mortgages are skyrocketing and the BoE is struggling to find ways to prop up the economy.

    • @chrissilver7719
      @chrissilver7719 Год назад +14

      it was a gift .... to energy company share holders

    • @mharbinson8952
      @mharbinson8952 Год назад +6

      Absolutely; if I hear her say about the cap of 2,500 again as that's again misleading; it has been the only thing semi justifiable so it's the only thing she can turn to again and again.

    • @begoneblue6295
      @begoneblue6295 Год назад +11

      @@mharbinson8952 it's the boris equivalent of "fastest vaccine rollout" to every question

    • @mharbinson8952
      @mharbinson8952 Год назад +6

      @@begoneblue6295 yeah you're right or "await the findings of the sue gray report" until it came out and then it was let's move on 🙄

    • @martinsolomon5500
      @martinsolomon5500 Год назад

      It’s the same as “education education education” will lead to better jobs. Privatization of railways will stop “strikes” “masks stop Covid” “Covid killed millions of people” “vaccinations one and done” “vaccines safe and effective” “Putin’s appalling war has caused food shortages” “Putin’s war has caused energy crisis” “warfare creates democracy” “they have weapons of mass destruction” “joining the EU in 1993 created jobs” “leaving the EU will reduce random immigration by dinghy’s across the channel” “leaving the EU means we UK law means we don’t have to contribute money to the EU or come under European High court rulings” it must be true because a politician said it

  • @mattg2861
    @mattg2861 Год назад +17

    Even the experts are speechless. Can it get any worse.

  • @abumstead1219
    @abumstead1219 Год назад +31

    Love your analogy of buying Two cars. So simple but Thick Liz wouldn’t understand it !

    • @wicksee
      @wicksee Год назад +2

      So simple it's not an analogy at all. Simple enough for the Lefties to understand though so that's the main thing.

    • @MrRailjunkie
      @MrRailjunkie Год назад

      @@wicksee No it's simple for idiots who put Thick Lizzy in the wrong job.

    • @mergendy
      @mergendy Год назад +2

      @@wicksee having fun up there on your entirely imaginary pedestal?

  • @mrjikes60
    @mrjikes60 Год назад +36

    2:43 mins - The moment that the main suspect realises their cover story has unravellied and they have inadvertently confessed their crimes to Columbo due to his clever questioning technique.

    • @DesL488
      @DesL488 Год назад +5

      And just one more thing.......

  • @janetgough6585
    @janetgough6585 Год назад +49

    I love the utter incredulity in James's voice. I felt exactly the same

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад +1

      ....yup...RADA would be proud....but stop gurning James.....😊..

    • @Ipdex
      @Ipdex Год назад

      Have you lost your mind love?

    • @johnwalters5131
      @johnwalters5131 Год назад

      yeah he's a ham actor , that's true .

  • @billcampbell6857
    @billcampbell6857 Год назад +48

    And the light came on. Well done for perseverance Mr O'Brien.

  • @ieaston5418
    @ieaston5418 Год назад +42

    Well done, James. You got him there in the end.

  • @Oliver-gj7bz
    @Oliver-gj7bz Год назад +53

    an incredible analogy :)

    • @wicksee
      @wicksee Год назад

      no a terrible one.

    • @bodricthered
      @bodricthered Год назад +2

      A terribly accurate and clear one...

    • @funoff3207
      @funoff3207 Год назад +2

      @@wicksee go on...

    • @wicksee
      @wicksee Год назад

      @@funoff3207 go on what? you want me to expand on what a stupidly inaccurate, irrelevant and infantile analogy it was?

    • @weswheel4834
      @weswheel4834 Год назад +2

      @@wicksee Did it hurt your feelings? Go on, tell us why it is inaccurate and irrelevant?

  • @monty6491
    @monty6491 Год назад +45

    James is entirely right, they could absolutely have announced the energy support package completely separately from the tax cuts and to pretend they are linked is ridiculous

    • @gingersteve
      @gingersteve Год назад +5

      Not disagreeing with anything you are saying at all (its all ridiculous), but I seem to remember that the energy support package was unveiled before the "mini-budget" - which surely makes it even more ridiculous to link the two,

    • @imaginalfoto2729
      @imaginalfoto2729 Год назад

      It's like they want to brainwash people by constantly repeating and try to associate the two things togheter (which in fact and in a certain perspective are quite the opposite , for one side and this one was done relutanctly there is the support with the energy bills, for the other side the big cut of taxation,for a minority of very rich people which it is in her own words the priority. This is a complete insult to ordinary people, already struggling...

    • @hb1338
      @hb1338 Год назад +1

      It is a deflection tactic. Truss is trying to soften the news that she wishes to make her wealthy friends even more wealthy by giving us poor people some help with our bills. What total nonsense. I resent being treated like a numpty. Where is Guy Fawkes when he is needed ?

  • @monty6491
    @monty6491 Год назад +59

    Like Andrew Marr said, it's hard to give them much credit for the energy price cap when they literally don't have a choice, they have to do it or many people will die

    • @wayneford2481
      @wayneford2481 Год назад

      And the people will continue to becouse they and their children and their children will have to payoff the lone and high interest, the TORYS kicking the can down the road for other's to repair.

    • @NoHeartAnthony
      @NoHeartAnthony Год назад +2

      The kick in the teeth is how they’ve chosen to fund it

  • @adam346
    @adam346 Год назад +66

    don't worry, before they have to consider repaying the "bill" as it were they will hand off the country to the Labor party and then blame them for the sorry state they left it in.

    • @Detector1977
      @Detector1977 Год назад +16

      That is the tory mo....

    • @danmayberry1185
      @danmayberry1185 Год назад +2

      We've seen some rough handovers to be fair, but yes - would Sir Keir & Co look forward to inheriting No. 10?

    • @cowardsallaround98
      @cowardsallaround98 Год назад

      @@Detector1977 complete your comment sad sack

    • @michaelpower4372
      @michaelpower4372 Год назад +5

      @@danmayberry1185 That's the torie plan.

    • @pablosaintmarr3223
      @pablosaintmarr3223 Год назад

      That Adam, has been the plane for quite a wee while, feather the nest hand gov money over to shady characters and businesses and make sure "I'm alright Jack" prior to the Tory press barons "allowing" Labour or a coalition to remove the Tories from power.
      Then sit back and blame them [Labour/coalition]for the mess created by the Tories and all the while enabled and exaggerated by said press/media barons.
      Its as plain as the nose on your face and why folk fail to see this is quite incredulous .

  • @Paul-eb4jp
    @Paul-eb4jp Год назад +9

    She only has one answer and it's the energy bills cap. it doesn't matter what the question is.

  • @MrPoodlekiller
    @MrPoodlekiller Год назад +32

    These people are so far removed from the real world that they have so much control over. I really hope Scotland goes Independent, as they are the only ones who seem to be making sense in Parliment at the moment.. If Scotland become Independent, I can see Wales follow suit.

    • @kayew5492
      @kayew5492 Год назад

      I do hope so! If England insists on following this self-destructive path the other countries in this English-imposed ''Union'' will have no choice but to dissolve the Declarations of Union and leave them to it. I'm tired of them exploiting our people and resources, hoarding wealth for themselves and ignoring the needs of communities North and West of Westminster and looking down on us as second class citizens while they do it.

    • @paulgibbon5991
      @paulgibbon5991 Год назад +5

      How about everyone outside of Londongrad has a referendum, and makes our own UK?

    • @kayew5492
      @kayew5492 Год назад +3

      @@paulgibbon5991 Isolate them instead of breaking away from them? Could work, it has to be worth a try.

    • @MrPoodlekiller
      @MrPoodlekiller Год назад +7

      @@kayew5492 I think you are spot on... The country needs to be run locally, as those in power are now so far removed from everyday living. Oh, hang on.. they need our taxes to fund their Corperate Mates...

    • @hypatia4754
      @hypatia4754 Год назад +1

      At this point if I was British I'd be voting for the SNP in the next elections. They're the only sensible people in the room.

  • @quintoblanco8746
    @quintoblanco8746 Год назад +14

    "Yes."
    That was my favorite part of this video.

  • @Nevakonaza.
    @Nevakonaza. Год назад +36

    James O’Brien is a legend, I love how he straight up just asks the questions we are all thinking and when he knows what they are saying is a load of donkey droppings he calls them up on it, This government is purely milking our country dry before they are thrown out...by then its too late, They'll be okay though.

  • @JustMe-ks8qc
    @JustMe-ks8qc Год назад +2

    I think his brain froze a little after that half-arsed proposal from James.

  • @Richard_Turner
    @Richard_Turner Год назад +8

    To give her 1 bit of credit she was honest once and did repeat it... I am genuinely unclear.... 🤣

  • @davidhooper1767
    @davidhooper1767 Год назад +51

    Did she claim that anyone asking tough questions is an enemy of growth?

    • @paulgibbon5991
      @paulgibbon5991 Год назад

      Anyone the Tories want to stir up hate against at any given point is an enemy of growth. It's quite a Trumpian approach to toxic, corrosive nonsense.

    • @weswheel4834
      @weswheel4834 Год назад +6

      Yup, it is a whole new level of: "You're either with us, or against us".

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад

      ....probably not Davy boy but don't let that stop you...😂.....

    • @ray9628
      @ray9628 Год назад

      Up there with 'fake news' as an answer to every question.

    • @TalesOfWar
      @TalesOfWar Год назад

      Get rid of "tough" and you're on to something.

  • @weswheel4834
    @weswheel4834 Год назад +88

    She said that she wouldn't decrease public spending. But seemed to imply that she considers the "help" with energy bills to be part of that public spending (in which case presumably she could decrease the rest of public spending by £150bn).

    • @wayneford2481
      @wayneford2481 Год назад +1

      I wouldn't bet on it you have to take profit out of it.

    • @badbooks476
      @badbooks476 Год назад

      @Wes Wheel. That is exactly what I thought, crash the markets even further, she will not be satisfied till she has bankrupted the UK

    • @Adam-zd2bk
      @Adam-zd2bk Год назад +1

      "help" which is a loan from the tax payer....

  • @odhranmcbride3781
    @odhranmcbride3781 Год назад +5

    Absolutely brilliant James. Tragic, but brilliant.

  • @Toothache42
    @Toothache42 Год назад +12

    You can lead a Tory to water but you can't make them think

    • @PeteH0121
      @PeteH0121 Год назад

      Love it.
      It should probably be "lead a politician" though. They are all as bad as each other.

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад

      ....thanks for taking the time to articulate that hilarious gag.....!

  • @rozb554
    @rozb554 Год назад +7

    "If we were married"
    I'm dead.

  • @steve1340
    @steve1340 Год назад +30

    This had me cracking up

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад

      ....thanks for sharing that...

  • @julezpanda14
    @julezpanda14 Год назад +8

    James looking around the Studio in disbelief!!! 😂😂 Ive done that every single day that Tories have been in power!! Lol..

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад

      .....got your own studio.....in North London...?

    • @julezpanda14
      @julezpanda14 Год назад +1

      @@chatham43 Nope, but it has the same effect!!😂

  • @neontv6605
    @neontv6605 Год назад +6

    Don't give her your credit card 😂

  • @Traceva
    @Traceva Год назад +3

    The Porsche and Lamborghini analogy is SPOT ON!

  • @michaelbooth2890
    @michaelbooth2890 Год назад +1

    That moment of realisation is golden.

  • @JamesEChapman
    @JamesEChapman Год назад +8

    My thoughts exactly 👌

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад

      ....we are all glad to hear it....cheers from planet earth......

  • @transcendtravel
    @transcendtravel Год назад +10

    If Truss had an original sentient thought she immediately would have an brain aneurysm.

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад

      .....a thought provoking comment meticulously articulated...thanks....

  • @AustenMerritt
    @AustenMerritt Год назад +5

    Nice analogy James!

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад

      ....yep.. James burning the midnight oil putting that rant together....😊...

  • @Luniverspin
    @Luniverspin Год назад +11

    I think her point is that the tax cut will somehow pay the energy bill by magically trickling down. She hopes that riches will invest in businesses rather than buy Lambos and Porsche. Of course she is wrong but that is another debate…

  • @Alex-cw3rz
    @Alex-cw3rz Год назад +108

    Starmer : "how are we to afford the tax cuts"
    Truss : "Well I instituted an energy bill plan that will also add £150 billion on the debt as well instead of a windfall tax"
    Edit : silly commenter still talking about the joke note 12 years ago if we had nothing, how has our debt doubled since then...

    • @nick1065
      @nick1065 Год назад +4

      From the Labour Government whose parting gift was a ‘no more money left’ note!

    • @napoleonreed3309
      @napoleonreed3309 Год назад +2

      @@nick1065 Exactly

    • @spikeannoyed
      @spikeannoyed Год назад +11

      @@nick1065 ah yes … that makes it ok then…

    • @MF-zh4ig
      @MF-zh4ig Год назад +13

      @@nick1065 it’s been 12 years. The Tories have had ample time to make significant change for the benefit of the population as well as to predict energy stability required and implement measures to ensure stability. They have not done this to an adequate level.
      What they have done is essentially written a cheque of £150 billion to energy companies rather than focusing on a viable windfall tax (which Labour had to keep pushing the issue on) and reinvestment of that money to ensure mid to long term stability. This payment is secondary to the energy payment already received a few months ago. It’s a plaster that isn’t helping the ‘wound’ to heal.

    • @paulgibbon5991
      @paulgibbon5991 Год назад +15

      @@nick1065 It's been twelve years. That excuse has thoroughly run dry. Find a new one.

  • @jjseluk
    @jjseluk Год назад +29

    I love how uncomfortable Theo is in every exchange with James

    • @patchso
      @patchso Год назад +1

      I think he’s scared that he had to be JOBs husband :-)

    • @Ipdex
      @Ipdex Год назад

      Laurel & Hardy. Don't you see that you mug?

    • @paulweller84
      @paulweller84 Год назад +1

      It’s the difference between someone who can say pretty much what they’re thinking (James) and someone who has to stay politically neutral and offer no opinions (Theo). I love listening to them together, it’s great radio 😂

    • @jjseluk
      @jjseluk Год назад

      @@paulweller84 yes! That discomfort is always when James drops an opinion and asks Theo to comment on that. Squirms ensue. It’s quite cute really

  • @kenabiss1
    @kenabiss1 Год назад +3

    Best analogy ever!!🤣🤣

  • @havingalook2
    @havingalook2 Год назад +1

    I say! Who could have imagined it went from dumb to dumber!!!!

  • @cazwalden1497
    @cazwalden1497 Год назад +5

    The governments generosity has overwhelmed me, i dont know about anyone else!

    • @MontyCantsin5
      @MontyCantsin5 Год назад +3

      Oh definitely! The sheer generosity and their ability to look out for the most vulnerable has been a sight to behold.

    • @weswheel4834
      @weswheel4834 Год назад +2

      Indeed. Their efforts to look after those poor energy companies with their massive profits in the middle of a crisis is beyond comparison.

  • @tonythomas8409
    @tonythomas8409 Год назад +3

    Brilliant James …!

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад

      ....is there no limit to his super powers..?

  • @jeb-zf4un
    @jeb-zf4un Год назад +8

    yep when you put it like that I can see why the financial markets might be upset.

  • @nazzanuk
    @nazzanuk Год назад +1

    Haha this was pure comedy

  • @L77yma
    @L77yma Год назад +1

    Moral of the story is don’t buy a Lamborghini and a Porsche! 🤣

  • @cpuuk
    @cpuuk Год назад +3

    Right at the end, that analogy is perfect.

  • @karenchristinewise7833
    @karenchristinewise7833 Год назад +5

    In Ireland, our budget 2023, will have given my household €1,000 extra payments for electricity bills made up of €400 next week, €200 each in 3 payments, 100% extra payment next week for people with disabilities, €500 extra cost of living payment in November for people with disabilities and carers and a 100% Christmas Bonus in December. This is in addition to an special assistance payments recently added for hardship. All these payments do not have to be paid back. Social Welfare payments in Ireland are never loans.

  • @drose311
    @drose311 Год назад +2

    The analogy should be. Darling I have bought a Lamborghini. Wife asked how will you pay for it. Well I have reduce my hours at work to enjoy driving it more. How will you pay for it? I am optimistic it will all work out. Drive! Drive! Drive!🤣

  • @petyrkowalski9887
    @petyrkowalski9887 Год назад +1

    Every time Starmer asked her a question..she questioned him. As Ian blackford said…. They should have swapped chairs.

  • @peterc2248
    @peterc2248 Год назад +6

    Our local council set up a Trading Company (with Councillors and senior public servants on the board), flogged public assets at a cheap rate to this new company who were using money lent to them by the Council in the first place! Guess what, the only people making anything are the board members. And they wonder why people don't trust them!

    • @howler6490
      @howler6490 Год назад

      Are most of them tory?...you should pass on the bare bones info to private eye...they'll name names

    • @wayneford2481
      @wayneford2481 Год назад

      YES I heard that was Bournemouth Council (sorry BPC BOUNEMOUTH POOLE AND CHRISTCHURCH) AFTER THEY OVER RAN Poole and Christchurch Council,. The same Council that has dodgy finance accounts, who also said no to a wind farm in Poole bay.

    • @georgec7899
      @georgec7899 Год назад

      @@howler6490 Look under Corruption in Councils ??

  • @Greenpoloboy3
    @Greenpoloboy3 Год назад +3

    At least we can laugh about this... all the way to the mad house 🤪

  • @w0033944
    @w0033944 Год назад +1

    Thanks for asking this, James!

  • @MotorcyclePhaedrus
    @MotorcyclePhaedrus Год назад +1

    Nicely played

  • @BashERC
    @BashERC Год назад +8

    the look at theo's face when James said you're my husband is priceless 🤣🤣

  • @carolalisonsmith4235
    @carolalisonsmith4235 Год назад +28

    The money “to help support energy bills” is it not giving tax payers money to energy companies to maintain profits? Asking for friends 😉

    • @DidntKnowWhatToPut1
      @DidntKnowWhatToPut1 Год назад

      Also the energy companies need to pay back those loans over the next 10 years, so our bills will remain artificially high even when the market settled down to pay off the loan. Whereas if we paid for the energy freeze through windfall taxes on energy producers, energy bills could be frozen and there wouldn't be much if anything for the general taxpayer to pay back once the situation returned to normal.

  • @ASChambers
    @ASChambers Год назад +1

    The definition of politician: “Someone who just will not answer a simple question.”

  • @cezelipatrick
    @cezelipatrick Год назад +1

    I love how the guy struggled with picking which role he had in his marriage to James 😅

  • @FlyingKeo045
    @FlyingKeo045 Год назад +5

    Mad Lizzy was, like her predecessor, trying to turn PM question time into interrogation of the opposition`s alternatives.
    Ian Blackford (SNP ) tried, in vain, to remind her . The speaker should slap down ANY Prime Minister that tries this practice.

  • @ChristopherFynn001
    @ChristopherFynn001 Год назад +7

    The "help with energy bills"" is just taking public money, which we'll eventually have to pay for, and handing it over to the energy companies who already making unexpected excessive profits.
    If this help with energy bills was funded by a windfall tax on those excessive profits of the energy companies OK, but she's funding it from borrowing which will eventually have to be repaid by UK taxpayers.

    • @TalesOfWar
      @TalesOfWar Год назад

      And their genius "mini-budget" just made interest on government borrowing skyrocket.

  • @CallumRSU30
    @CallumRSU30 Год назад +2

    Suggestion: Theo Usherwood to be on Taskmaster. :D

  • @TeZXSpectrum
    @TeZXSpectrum Год назад +1

    It's like borrowing money off a mate who's knicked it out of your wallet.

  • @RazorMouth
    @RazorMouth Год назад +3

    If that really works I'm going to ask my employer for a pay cut tomorrow 🤣

  • @roypowell3450
    @roypowell3450 Год назад +3

    Well done Liz, keep getting backs up!! Give this flaming media something to keep them in work!

    • @DesL488
      @DesL488 Год назад

      Glad to see that you're enjoying yourself.
      Bet you wish you could been alive during the in Roman Empire. Just imagine all those dead bodies, you'd have been happier than a pig in the smelly stuff!

  • @JamesSBunting
    @JamesSBunting Год назад

    Our generosity!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?

  • @davidspendlove5900
    @davidspendlove5900 Год назад +1

    No point in saving energy bills if you don’t have a home to go to.

  • @philthebus733
    @philthebus733 Год назад +3

    You could hear when the penny dropped that it was the first one in the can.

  • @Bullion-Bikes-n-BabesTour2024
    @Bullion-Bikes-n-BabesTour2024 Год назад +3

    Bravo, Bravo, Bravo! The most concise takedown I've seen in over a decade!

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад

      ...leave the sarcasm to me...😂...

    • @MrRailjunkie
      @MrRailjunkie Год назад +1

      @@chatham43 Oh so you're not really a reality denying Tory sycophant, it's just sarcasm then is it?

  • @Maltloaflegrande
    @Maltloaflegrande Год назад +1

    Look mate, people aren't talking about your generosity for the same reason they're not talking about flying elephants.

  • @wiltarthebarbarian1988
    @wiltarthebarbarian1988 Год назад +178

    Conservatives: decrease taxes but maintain spending.
    Everyone else: has to raise taxes to cover deficit caused by borrowing and tax cuts.
    Conservatives: LOOK WHAT THEY DID!! THEY RAISED TAXES!

    • @troywalkertheprogressivean8433
      @troywalkertheprogressivean8433 Год назад

      Meanwhile the rich/corporations have received reduced taxes and increased subsidation, consistently, for decades now. It's funny how the rich write the laws while "complaining" about the government they own.

    • @paulb9769
      @paulb9769 Год назад

      Well this hyper inflation is happening in the USA to under Biden. It is happening in all western countries. Makes no difference who is in power the same people still call the shots.

    • @drummingtildeath
      @drummingtildeath Год назад

      It's the worst mentality - if they look like they're losing their control they'll wreck the economy just to make their opponents suffer or struggle. They're the sort of people that should should never be given responsibility. It's the opposite of patriotism.

    • @SiriusMined
      @SiriusMined Год назад

      Exactly the same as the Republicans in the United states.

    • @7ookee
      @7ookee Год назад

      Libertarians have no clue how a country works. It's just all me me me. They don't even understand why people are different. They just think me me me me it must work my way or not at all.
      Beggers belief how they got past childhood.

  • @bigpants6121
    @bigpants6121 Год назад +3

    Truss is as sharp as a marble!

  • @philipward196
    @philipward196 Год назад +5

    They could have pointed out that the support for energy bills actually amounts to paying money that we've earned to the energy companies (so that they can keep their shareholders and CEO's happy with dividends and bonuses). The government should have taken over the energy companies, not just handed them loadsamoney.

    • @TalesOfWar
      @TalesOfWar Год назад +1

      And this actually causes more inflation long term because the money isn't going back into the economy, but someone's portfolio sat in a bank.

  • @J5Dev
    @J5Dev Год назад +1

    Greatest. Analogy. Ever!!

    • @chatham43
      @chatham43 Год назад

      ....best comment ....EVER....!!!!!

  • @MrMistoffelees
    @MrMistoffelees Год назад +2

    It's less "I've bought a Porsche" as "I've quit my job as well".

  • @lewismaclennan3028
    @lewismaclennan3028 Год назад +8

    Brilliant! Made my ferk'n morning. :)

    • @nick1065
      @nick1065 Год назад

      You need to get out a bit more

    • @MrRailjunkie
      @MrRailjunkie Год назад +1

      @@nick1065 Says the person who spends a lot of time commenting on someone he claims to hate & most of the time doesn't make a valid point.

  • @matthewsmith3660
    @matthewsmith3660 Год назад +3

    “Genuinely I am unclear” - Liz Truss. PMQ’s. 12/10/22

  • @nickbaby29
    @nickbaby29 Год назад +1

    A better analogy would be you bought a Lamborghini but also convinced your boss to cut your wages.

  • @Anton-ji4td
    @Anton-ji4td Год назад +11

    CEO of Shell said in the last week, Windfall tax energy companies.

    • @ajgillingham7412
      @ajgillingham7412 Год назад

      Or they could just pay extra tax voluntarily instead of making political sound bites. They don’t have to wait for the law to be changed to extra tax.

  • @qlnbd
    @qlnbd Год назад +3

    So that's what Theo looks like.😁

  • @jdavies1296
    @jdavies1296 Год назад +1

    Reamed with words.

  • @ranjanningthouja7053
    @ranjanningthouja7053 Год назад

    🤣🤣🤣. What a analogy 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @Cossieuk
    @Cossieuk Год назад +7

    It's more like she has bought a Lambo at the same time going part time

    • @regs_j
      @regs_j Год назад +2

      🤣🤣🤣

    • @CommissionerSleer
      @CommissionerSleer Год назад +6

      Yeah "Why do you keep going on about me getting fired? What about this lovely Lamborghini I've just bought on credit cards?"

  • @markdessie816
    @markdessie816 Год назад +3

    Brilliant comedy gold if I was ye guys I would seriously think about divorce.

  • @rabburns1382
    @rabburns1382 Год назад

    My head hurts

  • @radscorpion8
    @radscorpion8 Год назад

    3:05 so funny XD. James is completely flabbergasted

  • @futurememories1660
    @futurememories1660 Год назад +5

    The support package for energy bills obviously has implications on public spending but is not, in itself, representative of fiscal policy. Truss passing it off as the main component of her mini-budget is absolutely ludicrous and totally derided PMQs, enabled by a weak speaker.

    • @georgec7899
      @georgec7899 Год назад

      Weak Speaker? correction totally USELESS Speaker devoid of any semblance of authority

    • @TalesOfWar
      @TalesOfWar Год назад

      Even more ludicrous given it was announced weeks before the actual mini-budget.

  • @troywalkertheprogressivean8433
    @troywalkertheprogressivean8433 Год назад +4

    Philanthropy TO the rich? 🤔

  • @simonkimber169
    @simonkimber169 Год назад

    🤣🤣if you don't laugh you have to cry

  • @ozmosize
    @ozmosize Год назад

    Absolutely nailed it. Lovely stuff

  • @thethinkingcatakaneonormie3527
    @thethinkingcatakaneonormie3527 Год назад +9

    How can you have Low Taxes and Borrowing at the same time how are you going to pay the bill off for borrowing

    • @weswheel4834
      @weswheel4834 Год назад +3

      Because in Truss' head, reduced taxation leads to higher growth which leads to higher tax intake which then pays of the borrowing. It does seem hopelessly optimistic, and wrong, but that's the theory I think.

    • @michaelpower4372
      @michaelpower4372 Год назад +2

      Don't know why ask me I'm only the prime minster. (lis truss.)

    • @troywalkertheprogressivean8433
      @troywalkertheprogressivean8433 Год назад +2

      More cops, more fines. Reduced services elsewheres. Higher prices and higher sales taxes. If it's not paid for on the front end it'll be paid for on the back end.

    • @Me0wish
      @Me0wish Год назад

      @@weswheel4834 During a global cost of living crisis and gas shortage due to Russia
      She has certifiably got donkey brains

    • @paulgibbon5991
      @paulgibbon5991 Год назад

      Let the next government sort it out.

  • @timmyripkey2030
    @timmyripkey2030 Год назад +8

    How has james survived
    over 40 years of depression?

    • @cowardsallaround98
      @cowardsallaround98 Год назад

      He lives in side a bubble

    • @neilpemberton5523
      @neilpemberton5523 Год назад +2

      The man has fire in the belly, that's how.

    • @geraldhewing2076
      @geraldhewing2076 Год назад +2

      Rather like the majority I imagine.

    • @SirAmnesia
      @SirAmnesia Год назад +2

      we're all struggling my friend

    • @neilpemberton5523
      @neilpemberton5523 Год назад +4

      @@cowardsallaround98 He freely admits he's in a privileged bracket. But compared to nearly all of the rest of media, he earns his money, in spades.