Melodifestivalen 2019: My Top 28 (with comments)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 сен 2024
  • A VERY strong year for once! There's essentially only two songs that I strongly dislike. The rest, I don't mind. I struggled with trying to find negative things to say about most of the songs (which is a good thing).
    Sorry about having to pitch/speed up some of the songs, but it was essential for the video to not be geoblocked D:
    ------
    Links to all my social medias - flow.page/titowam
    All material used in this video is used for the purpose of criticism and falls under fair use. For more information on fair use, visit www.copyright....
    Reuploading or using this video as a source is strictly prohibited unless permission has been given. If you wish to use my video in any form or way, please contact me. No profit is made out of this video on my behalf.

Комментарии • 117

  • @TheSillyPotato
    @TheSillyPotato  5 лет назад +31

    Even after putting a disclaimer at the start of my videos, people are still attacking me for my rankings.
    Commenting on my ranking is perfectly acceptable, but sending threats and personal attacks are not allowed. There's a big difference between the two. Therefore I will now start blocking people who are ignoring the heads-up at the start of the video. You're entitled to have your own opinions just like I am, but that does not give you the right to attack someone for it.
    Also, keep in mind that I'm ranking the SONGS. If I based my ranking on the vocals/artist exclusively, this ranking would be a lot different.
    Thank you.

    • @readisgooddewaterkant7890
      @readisgooddewaterkant7890 5 лет назад

      True you are a relly Good youtuber

    • @Cakeboy26
      @Cakeboy26 4 года назад

      Your're beaing attacked because you rank them so diffrently, a message at the start wont help, to be honest, you put one of the most love artist this year last, so it's pretty obouvis your getting attacked.

  • @anniejohansson6918
    @anniejohansson6918 5 лет назад +39

    John for the win!!!!!!!

    • @klara3840
      @klara3840 5 лет назад

      Annie Johansson han vann

  • @georgbergsten6050
    @georgbergsten6050 5 лет назад +36

    Haha love your comments on Bishara. Great job! Great list too

    • @falc6392
      @falc6392 5 лет назад +7

      Finally someone saying he is bad xd

    • @fredrikostenssoncardozo808
      @fredrikostenssoncardozo808 5 лет назад +1

      @@falc6392 he is not bad. His voice is incredible! But his lyrics is not Good because i higly doubt its relatable for him.

  • @LuxSingsSongs
    @LuxSingsSongs 5 лет назад +6

    Hi there! Great list, you've got some interesting opinions! Overall very enjoyable to watch. And I just want to say thank you so much for including an English translation for the songs in Swedish!! I'm still very new to learning the Swedish language, so I really appreciate the translation!!

    • @TheSillyPotato
      @TheSillyPotato  5 лет назад +2

      Kaoru Fujimaki I’m glad to be able to help! I’ve contemplated removing them multiple times but I’ll keep on putting them in that case!
      I should also give some credit to Agafyas Eurovision, since I kindof borrowed that idea when I saw that she did the same thing 😄
      Thanks for watching!

  • @TypicalSwedee
    @TypicalSwedee 5 лет назад +5

    Omg i have been waiting!!

  • @eurovisiontszai9125
    @eurovisiontszai9125 5 лет назад +27

    If John won , he would have two entries at the same time (Don't forget his "Bigger than us" in UK , it was also composed by him)!!!

    • @kabisus4631
      @kabisus4631 5 лет назад +1

      Konstantin Derevosokroshchsky Volksgeist Federation he won

    • @ostkaka3529
      @ostkaka3529 5 лет назад

      John won

  • @eduardotwist9735
    @eduardotwist9735 5 лет назад +6

    My top 3
    1. Jon Henrik
    2. Lisa Ajax
    3. John Lundvik

  • @minaadolphson9818
    @minaadolphson9818 5 лет назад +2

    1. Hello
    2. Hold you
    3. To late for love

  • @k5612
    @k5612 5 лет назад +6

    I like your top, we have a pretty similar taste, here's my top 12:
    1. Torn
    2. Not with me
    3. Too late for love
    4. Stormbringer
    5. Hello
    6. Hold you
    7. Tempo
    8. Mina Brander
    9. I Do
    10. Norrsken
    11. Habibi
    12. Ashes to ashes

  • @dontmindme5163
    @dontmindme5163 5 лет назад +19

    I think this year is really strong in my opinion. Lisa, Wiktoria, Liamoo&Hanna and John is my favs. First time in many years I like more then 1 songs haha

  • @abailonescobero
    @abailonescobero 5 лет назад +2

    My top 3:
    1- John Lundvik - Too Late For Love
    2- Hannah Ferm & LIAMOO - Hold You
    3- Lisa Ajax - Torn

    • @klara3840
      @klara3840 5 лет назад

      Alex Bailon Escobero same

  • @tatyanatrubadur5837
    @tatyanatrubadur5837 5 лет назад +5

    The guy at number 28 Bishara is actually older then Malou Prytz number 19.

    • @Hjallapenos
      @Hjallapenos 3 года назад

      Difference is that girls usually enter puberty earlier and it doesn't effect their voice the same as it does to boys and this kid doesn't seem to have entered puberty yet.

  • @henriklarssoneurovisioncha6515
    @henriklarssoneurovisioncha6515 2 года назад

    I was in Friends Arena for the finals .. and when John feat The Mamas performed .. it was a party !! You did know already then he was gonna win .. and poor Wiktoria was walking pass the crowd and it felt noone was looking at her .. everyone was focused on John

  • @emexx257
    @emexx257 5 лет назад

    Nice top 2 👌

  • @yffla2444
    @yffla2444 5 лет назад

    I love how you explain everything and I Agree with you.

  • @mjdbnh
    @mjdbnh 5 лет назад +5

    I really like this year because there's a good ratio between male and female singers and the fact that it's a lot more songs in swedish.
    Normally I don't like songs in swedish but I feel like it would be quite nice to actually see a song in swedish in eurovision (not that it's going to happen this year).
    As for the quality I feel that we have a bit to go before we go back to the quality we had 3-4 years ago but it's definitely a HUGE step forward from the disaster we had last year (even though there was a few good songs ^^).
    What I also like is that every top list I've seen for this year is really different, so that also shows how good this year really is IMO ^^
    I agree with some of your choices and disagree with some others but that's kinda the point with different opinions XD

  • @escadri4407
    @escadri4407 5 лет назад +7

    THE BEST EDITION OF MELODIFESTIVALEN THAT I EVER FOLLOWED (Started 2003).
    We agree a lot actually, but not on everything. I always love to watch your videos, and if you have time to and the will to, I would be happy if you could watch my top. I love working creatively with videos like this, and I get better, but I still don't think that I ever come close to yours... or the other ones frequently uploading Melodifestivalen-videos. Maybe one day :)

    • @Kfssan
      @Kfssan 5 лет назад

      Melovifestivalen started at 1959?

    • @xenonplays_
      @xenonplays_ 2 года назад

      @@Kfssan means when they started watching melodi

    • @xenonplays_
      @xenonplays_ 2 года назад

      I have such a different opinion haha
      2003, 2006, 2008, 2011, 2012, 2014 were all better than 2019 for me, but ofc I respect your opinion :D

  • @Arena-_
    @Arena-_ 5 лет назад

    I see u like catchy songs btw this is acually a good list in my opinion the otyers i have seen have all the old att the bottom but u took some of the old that har good perfromances and put them att a reasnoble place:)

  • @ozaaraa
    @ozaaraa 5 лет назад

    Love your top :) We have exactly the same opinion about this Melfest. And finally someone who likes Arja

  • @suck634
    @suck634 5 лет назад +11

    About Bishara..everything you wrote for Malou, same goes for Bishara, and to be really honest, her song is more JESC than anything LOL but well this is your list so will not say anything...

    • @escadri4407
      @escadri4407 5 лет назад +6

      I think her song fits better because she is singing something a 15-year old could. Bishara is more "junior" because he is singing about feelings that he 99% can't relate to. That is how I see it. + I think Malou has the more mature voice.

    • @TheSillyPotato
      @TheSillyPotato  5 лет назад +2

      That's a very valid point, I did not think about it that way! Upon listening to the songs some more, I can agree to an extent with your comment. Malou's song is a bit JESC-y, which is something I had completely overlooked when I initially listened to the songs.
      Thank you for being respectful when writing your comment

    • @fudgeyeah3660
      @fudgeyeah3660 5 лет назад +1

      One more thing is that high15 is 15/16 y/o and just the lyrics "I just want to drink off, no drama"... 16 years old ugh

    • @suck634
      @suck634 5 лет назад +1

      @@fudgeyeah3660 well kids starts drinking at 12 nowadays sadly...

    • @fudgeyeah3660
      @fudgeyeah3660 5 лет назад +1

      @@suck634 I know...Where is society going :(

  • @leaovebring2442
    @leaovebring2442 5 лет назад +2

    Two things:
    First, Bishara and Malou are both 15 so I dont understand why you didn't had a problem with Malou.
    Second, FINALLY SOMEONE PUTS JOHN AT FIRST PLACE!!!!❤️

  • @saxaren1133
    @saxaren1133 5 лет назад

    This was a good list!

  • @xenonplays_
    @xenonplays_ 2 года назад

    Gonna admit, Lina with Victorious was more played in the UK than John, and she came 11th I think?
    I have heard Victorious many times on British radios, whereas John I've never heard.
    My top 5:
    5. Lisa
    4. John
    3. Ann-Louise (guilty pleasure)
    2. Lina
    1. Anna

  • @nielsreviewsmusic3055
    @nielsreviewsmusic3055 5 лет назад +2

    Here is my list:
    BEST SONGS:
    #01. Malou Prytz - I Do Me (BEST SONG IN THE SELECTION!(TIE) - 10/10
    #01. Anna Bergendahl - Ashes To Ashes (BEST SONG IN THE SELECTION!(TIE) - 10/10
    #03. Wiktoria - Not With Me - 10/10
    #04. Mohombi - Hello - 10/10
    #05. Oscar Enestad - I Love It - 10/10
    #06. Nano - Chasing Rivers - 10/10
    #07. Lisa Ajax - Torn - 10/10
    #08. Ann-Louise Hanson - Kärleken finns kvar - 10/10
    #09. Arvingarna - I Do - 10/10
    #10. High15 - No Drama - 10/10
    #11. Pagan Fury - Stormbringer - 9/10
    #12. Hanna Ferm & LIAMOO - Hold You - 8/10
    #13. Jan Malmsjö - Leva livet - 7/10
    #14. Rebecka Karlsson - Who I Am - 7/10
    #15. Jon Henrik Fjällgren - Norrsken (Goeksegh) - 7/10
    DECENT SONGS:
    #16. The Lovers of Valdaro - Somebody Wants - 6/10
    #17. John Lundvik - Too Late For Love - 6/10
    #18. Arja Saijonmaa - Mina fyra årstider - 6/10
    #19. Andreas Johnson - Army of Us - 6/10
    Meh...
    #20. Lina Hedlund - Victorious - 5/10
    #21. Martin Stenmarck - Låt skiten brinna - 5/10
    WORST SONGS:
    #22. Anton Hagman - Känner dig - 4/10
    #23. Zeana ft. Anis Don Demina - Mina bränder - 2/10
    #24. Margaret - Tempo - 2/10
    #25. Bishara - On My Own - 2/10
    #26. Omar Rudberg - Om om och om igen - 1/10
    #27. Dolly Style - Habibi - 1/10
    #28. Vlad Reiser - Nakna i regnet (WORST SONG IN THE SELECTION!) - 1/10

  • @olivermcintyre8403
    @olivermcintyre8403 5 лет назад +1

    Same Winner

  • @leahlol9544
    @leahlol9544 5 лет назад +1

    My top 28
    28: Habibi (0/10) (No hate to Dolly Style but damn this song was f*cking terrible, honestly one of the worst songs I’ve heard in a REALLY long time. Still can’t believe this finished higher than Valdaro Lovers and Omar) (Heat 3)
    27: No Drama (2/10) (Not my type of music) (Heat 1)
    26: Hold You (2,5/10) (They sing well but the song sounds more like a remix of popular radio hits (Dusk Till Dawn, Don’t Let Me Down etc) than an actual song, can't give any points for it) (Heat 2)
    25: Känner Dig (4/10) (I find the song ok and it is performed well! Well done!) (Heat 4)
    24: Not With Me (5,5/10) (I personally like the song but her voice is as annoying to listen to as ever) (Heat 1)
    23: Mina Fyra Årstider (6/10) (I don't think there's anything wrong with the song but it isn't enough for a higher place in my top) (Heat 1)
    22: I Love It (6/10) (The song isn't that bad but for some reason the lyrics really bugs me) (Heat 2)
    21: Låt Skiten Brinna (6/10) (I like the song overall but the chorus is really boring and nothing really happens. His voice is amazing though) (Heat 3)
    20: Who I Am (7/10) (The song is great but as with Wiktoria, her voice is pretty annoying live. Unlike from Wiktoria though she can’t hit all the notes in the song, but it is a pretty hard song to sing though. It would be a great soundtrack for Frozen 2 xD) (Heat 3)
    19: Ashes To Ashes (7/10) (I don't find the song that good until the last chorus, that part is amazing! Never really liked the staging either to be honest) (Heat 1)
    18: On My Own (7/10) (I expected more from him but it ain’t bad! Love his voice too! But I’m questioning the lyrics too. He’s 15, he’s singing about someone he loves that he wants in his bed… (Taken from the actual lyrics) Yeah, they’re creepy. What did the songwriters think with??) (Heat 4)
    17: Mina Bränder (7/10) (This is gonna get raped on the Swedish radio... Don't wanna listen to it too much so I won't get bored of it) (Heat 1)
    16: Tempo (7/10) (This is 100 times better than ''In My Cabana'' but I understand why it didn't go through) (Heat 2)
    15: Leva Livet (7/10) (The song is great but his performance was messed up) (Heat 2)
    14: Victorious (8/10) (It’s too up-tempo for me but it’s not bad) (Heat 3)
    13: : Om Om Och Om Igen (8/10) (The song is great and the performance was amazing, I don’t understand how it didn’t go through)
    12: Army Of Us (8/10) (This is one of those songs that I just like for no reason) (Heat 2)
    11: Kärleken Finns Kvar (8/10) (This is so relaxing… Perfect song to fall asleep to. (Not in a bad way) The performance was great as well!) (Heat 4)
    10: I Do (8,5/10) (Such a fun song! Love it!)
    9: Stormbringer (9/10) (ROBBED!! LAST IN HEAT, W T F!!) (Heat 4)
    8: Too Late For Love (9/10) (What a bop! Love it!)
    7: Norrsken (9,5/10) (I feel like his mic broke in the last chorus, I couldn’t hear his voice at all. I personally think it’s his second best attempt, Jag Är Fri was better) (Heat 3)
    6: Nakna I Regnet (9,5/10) (The song is amazing and the choreographic performance too, but he needs to work on his vocals a lot. Btw älskar dina videor, stay awesome!) (Heat 2)
    5: I Do Me (9,5/10) (I could listen to this forever just because of how pleasant it is) (Heat 2)
    4: Chasing Rivers (10/10) (In my opinion this is better than ''Hold On,” what a fantastic song!) (Heat 1)
    3: Somebody Wants (10/10) (I don’t know why but I really thought they were gonna be my favourites from the heat even before I listened to the snippet, I’m not disappointed) (Heat 3)
    2: Hello (10/10) (Such a nice soundtrack, and he’s as great as ever!)
    1: Torn (10/10) (Beautiful… I don’t understand what the voters thought of when putting this into AC. I voted like crazy for her… At least she isn’t battling against Nano…)

  • @ellibod1
    @ellibod1 5 лет назад +3

    You actually improved the songs you pitched and sped up

  • @Cakeboy26
    @Cakeboy26 5 лет назад

    Finaly some one like the lovers of valdaro

  • @cxnfusionspxll870
    @cxnfusionspxll870 5 лет назад

    Filip Åström
    My favorites are Jon Henrik, Nano, Wiktoria, Pagan fury, Margaret, Malou, the lovers of valdaro
    They are Amazing
    I hate mohombi, Jan Malmsjö, Arja Saijonmaa, Ann-Louise Hanson, Martin Stenmarck, lina Hedlund, dolly style, Andreas Johnson
    Overall i want Jon Henrik Fjällgren or Wiktoria to represent my country

  • @Blubblib
    @Blubblib 5 лет назад

    John Lundvik är min favorit.

  • @naedot.9779
    @naedot.9779 5 лет назад

    Im from Finland, and i think Sweden should send Hanna&Liamoo to Tel Aviv, their voices is good, they have chemistry and the song is amazing.

    • @Kfssan
      @Kfssan 5 лет назад +1

      I Agree with you. Thats my favourite this year

  • @neaochnell8788
    @neaochnell8788 5 лет назад +3

    Tänkte jättelänge hur jag skulle skriva detta på engelska (är inte så bra på engelska) sen kom jag på att du - och dem flesta andra som kollar på det här är svenskar men aja.😅 Vi tippade väldigt likt, jag älskar också ashes to ashes och hatar bishara haha. Men jag gillar mohombi lite mer än du men ändå💓

  • @wassinmuangprom4763
    @wassinmuangprom4763 5 лет назад +3

    Great top, i agree with most of them. But you didn't like Bishara because he is too young for the lyrics?, but you liked High15 who is the same age as him and is singning about drinking

  • @nicolemwuah
    @nicolemwuah 5 лет назад +2

    If Sweden send John’s song do u think Sweden will win Eurovision?

    • @TheSillyPotato
      @TheSillyPotato  5 лет назад +5

      I don't think we'll win, but I also don't think we have any Eurovision winners in the line-up this year. I can see a top 10 placement with John, but I can also see a top 10 placement with Hanna Ferm & LIAMOO. Those two are probably our best bets.

    • @watching.everything
      @watching.everything 5 лет назад +1

      ofc

  • @Sundish_
    @Sundish_ 5 лет назад

    I don't really like John that much, i dont know why honestly.
    By the way i whould say that my top three songs is
    1. Hold you
    2. Hello
    3. Torn

  • @arvidasklid7172
    @arvidasklid7172 5 лет назад

    Too late for love
    Chasing Rivers
    Hold you

  • @lrnzmarco
    @lrnzmarco 5 лет назад

    Please Sweden, do the right choice and send Wiktoria to Tel Aviv, she deserves it completely!!!
    Besides, considering how weak this year is so far, it would do really well in my opinion

  • @katarinaisey
    @katarinaisey 5 лет назад

    BISHIS!!!

  • @Cape-tf2iw
    @Cape-tf2iw 5 лет назад

    I must say that I was a bit let down by pagan fury since I was looking forward to a bit of rock but the song sounded more like pop to me. But you’re allowed to have your opinon I just wanted to share mine

  • @nyaversioner6381
    @nyaversioner6381 5 лет назад

    I liked your nr 1 but there are many of these songs that I would have put at the opposite place. In my opinion you should switch Bishara with Margaret. But that is my personal opinion. And I respect yours.

  • @EmVee.
    @EmVee. 5 лет назад

    As a Dutchie who would love to vote for Sverige again in the semi and final in May, PLS GIVE ALL YOU APP VOTES TO HOLD YOU

    • @klara3840
      @klara3840 5 лет назад

      Mitchel van Eijk I did but it lost

  • @fygamer391
    @fygamer391 5 лет назад +1

    Bishara its best

  • @tobiasmilne
    @tobiasmilne 5 лет назад +1

    Margaret 2019 wearing a fully body showercap ?

  • @sfc_editzs5540
    @sfc_editzs5540 3 года назад

    The lovers of valdaro could win

    • @V530-15ICR
      @V530-15ICR 2 года назад

      Didn't even go to Andra Chansen if I remember correctly

  • @dontmindme5163
    @dontmindme5163 5 лет назад +5

    I think Lisa Will win mello and ESC

  • @watching.everything
    @watching.everything 5 лет назад

    We have the same favourite!!! :)

  • @vilmerberggren6696
    @vilmerberggren6696 5 лет назад

    You have a swedish boy right here!!!!

  • @rtv7510
    @rtv7510 5 лет назад

    I just want to say that Malou is younger than Bishara, just so you know, Bishara is born in January and Malou in Mars. Cause you wrote that you didn't like when young kids are singing in melodifestivalen. (sorry for my bad english)

    • @teakmelissa
      @teakmelissa 5 лет назад

      Ja och hon mimade till en inspelning av någon annan som sjöng texten för hon sjöng falskt!

  • @Athixe
    @Athixe 5 лет назад

    28.
    HIGH 15!!!! WHOA lol

  • @carlmanol
    @carlmanol 5 лет назад

    I’m won!🤑(my name i’s John)

    • @klara3840
      @klara3840 5 лет назад

      Syskonen Olsson jag tror han kan stava....

  • @tuvaa2948
    @tuvaa2948 4 года назад +1

    Vet att denna är ifrån förra året men asså äntligen ngn som inte gillade Bishara haha

  • @Erkgot
    @Erkgot 4 года назад +1

    Bishara win

  • @zachbrzezicki6398
    @zachbrzezicki6398 5 лет назад

    Stormbringer and Om Igen were criminally robbed.

  • @klara9983
    @klara9983 5 лет назад

    Anis don demina is fantastic on saw search on beatiful sax on spotify

  • @antelique8011
    @antelique8011 5 лет назад

    Why do you look on swedish melo?

    • @TheSillyPotato
      @TheSillyPotato  5 лет назад

      Cookie Gacha Because I’m a huge Eurovision fan, and I’m Swedish and have followed it for as long as I can remember (at least 15 years)!

  • @jmlshark5064
    @jmlshark5064 5 лет назад

    I just say that ”Hello” is better on Spotify

  • @wystxrr
    @wystxrr 4 года назад

    Norrsken sounds better when pitched

  • @ricardocasanalufre6579
    @ricardocasanalufre6579 5 лет назад

    Wiktoria

  • @lovamalm2605
    @lovamalm2605 5 лет назад +3

    (My opinion) bishara is the best ever, he is 16? Not tho young he is our new justin bieber

  • @abbecfc8373
    @abbecfc8373 5 лет назад

    I think Dolly Style has changed members (Maybe like 1 or 2)

  • @engqvistengqvist5852
    @engqvistengqvist5852 5 лет назад

    Ääääääääää noooooo!

  • @Slixix
    @Slixix 5 лет назад

    Very good rating except Jon hendrik should be nr 1

  • @rafaelbelay870
    @rafaelbelay870 5 лет назад +1

    Bishara 28 wtf

  • @adamkorsfeldt7328
    @adamkorsfeldt7328 5 лет назад +1

    Bishara on last place, you have very weird ears

  • @poepoekid4478
    @poepoekid4478 5 лет назад

    Good list but im sorry but dont agree with Ashes to ashes and Lovers of valdaro

  • @ylvabomark3971
    @ylvabomark3971 5 лет назад

    og i can really not relate to any of it except wiktoria, hanna and liamoo and john!

  •  5 лет назад

    Yes!!! Bishara ended up last, his song is worthless. ;D
    Ja!!! Bishara kom sist, hans låt är värdelös. ;D

  • @emiliskog
    @emiliskog 5 лет назад

    stormbringer got last because of the new voting system it would have gotten sixth place which I know isn't too much better but it aint last

  • @Meeeeeoooooo0w
    @Meeeeeoooooo0w Год назад

    lmao mohombi so copied mans with the staging

  • @emmaeliasson965
    @emmaeliasson965 5 лет назад

    John won😊

  • @NatalieSilvervarg
    @NatalieSilvervarg 5 лет назад

    Hi

  • @liamfridman
    @liamfridman 5 лет назад

    Nä,så får man inte tycka 🚔🚔🚓🚓

  • @jonteho4939
    @jonteho4939 5 лет назад

    Totally agree with Bishara, the song is VERY boring and the lyrics are not for kids. Hopefully he get last 👍

  • @teakmelissa
    @teakmelissa 5 лет назад

    Malou Prytz Lip synced.. I'm sorry u liked here.

  • @novineux1246
    @novineux1246 5 лет назад

    Liamoo & Hanna Ferm! Alla de är andra är BORING!!!!!!!

  • @frozenchurro8954
    @frozenchurro8954 5 лет назад

    kokl

  • @xpvsu8947
    @xpvsu8947 5 лет назад

    somebody is good and put Bishara last xD

  • @filipjonsson5819
    @filipjonsson5819 5 лет назад +1

    Bishara is 16 im pretty sure he know what love is

  • @huwh4627
    @huwh4627 5 лет назад

    its kinda ironic u set the song by high 15 super high (compared to the other young entires) since they are singing about drinking lol. The chorus itself is also awful, kinda nice build up but the rest is complete trash imo

  • @nov1bxes
    @nov1bxes 3 года назад

    This is silly

  • @Snwyfx
    @Snwyfx 5 лет назад

    Worst

  • @morrisanderssonelev5501
    @morrisanderssonelev5501 5 лет назад

    WHY BISHARA 28?