I disagree with Olivia’s answer as one of the “best answers”. She was asked what she regretted doing. She starts off by saying “what I regretted most...” then ended by saying “but I dont regret it”. So she technically contradicted herself. Furthermore, she talked about picking on her siblings which really was not a strong answer based on how she delivered it. Philippines, Brazil, and Australia had better answers. Philippines that year had the best answer. It’s been years, but this edition will always make pageant followers question the validity of this edition.
Absolutely right, Philippines was the real winner of that year. In fact, USA should have been the fourth runner up, and Brazil and Australia should have been the first and second runner up.
What do you mean by too rehearse? Is it because she is quick to answer? I think it is the way she answers not rehearsed. Besides the contestants do not know what questions they gonna get. So how can you say it is rehearsed? Janine answered the question genuinely and realistically. It's like giving a extemporaneous speech with little preparation. Janine is very intelligent and smart contestant.
I still dont understand how miss USA won over Miss Philippines. The question was about a thing that happened that she regret but in the end of her answer she said I dont regret it. What??
@@hideous4685 hahahaha! Ano sabi mo? What are you saying about? O baka ibig mong sabihin eh "what are you talking about? You dont understand me? Thats y u want me to speak in english? Hehehe.. Pieces of advice lang ha, construct ur grammar first before ka bumanat ng english ok, u get me? Obvious kasi na trying hard ka kuno at pretending na marunong mag-english or shall we say conyo kuno, hahaha, napaghahalata ka naman sa mga pananalita mo na u came from a ghetto area kaya wag kna mag level up at bka ka lumagapak. Hindi na rin po kita papatulan kahit mag mumura ka pa dyan kasi wla ka breeding at uneducated ka, pikon ka kasi kaya ganyan ka umasta. Learn how to accept critics and bad comments from other people, be sports lang d mo kailangan magsalita ng d maganda o mag mura in short "just shut your bad mouth when you have nothing good to say ok hijo de la chingada?
Khayne M. : They included her in the list because she gave a spontaneous answer. Surely not the best one to give if you wanna win the crown but an original one that reflects your personality. Contrary to Philippines her answer didn’t sound generic.
Olivia is definitely beautiful (above average) but Miss Philippines response was light years above Olivia's response. Miss Phillipines should've won this title.
Miss Angola is a true doll like beauty ..wow..watta face and body... but did she answer the question ... it took her so long to answer.. but actually.all she is saying was ." i have nothing to change in myself.. i thank God for giving me all the things i need and have in my life..thank you ..."
*Janine Togonon will always be the Miss Universe in 2012 rather than that red quacking gal. Janine's CROWN is so priceless that only who believes in her can see it.* *🍵: Donald Trumpolin was one of the JUDGES that time*
@Donald Trump before you bark,please compare it first.If you watch it again,you will see Ms. Philippines thinking what will she going to say so how could you say that it's rehearsed?
@Donald Trump that's barbaric :/ Philippines might not be a powerhouse but at least we fight for our community,not like your shit-ass country whom you rule that even your own people regrets your name, should've been *DONALD FUCKING TRUMP DICKHEAD*
@Donald Trump our dearest janine tugonon isn't a bloody noob :/ stop fucking us,if Olivia one,she won,but don't ever say that just because Olivia culpo won doesn't mean u have the right to say garbage things to us,we,filipinos are actually intelligent and philosophers,we sometimes can be a bit sarcastic and dramatic but don't even think of saying words that can cause Internet war
olivia should absolutely not be a part of this compilation at all if we're talking about best answers. janine has the best answer of them all by a clear mile.
I believe Pia's answer was the best of all!!! She gave historical information and also she expressed her point of View!! The best answer EVER!!! Greetings from México!!!
@@jhayvansaliwan8134 Peru did give a better answer but Andrea was the best in everything else. so when you add it all up Andrea ends up still being teh winner. dont be sore losers
@@norbisb she represented her hometown Puerto Rico back in miss universe 1994 so it means she's puerto rican. Stop being a shithole. I know her because she used to lived in the Philippines for quite a long time. period!
Ms. Colombia here is so beautiful and confident. Pia performed with confidence almost the entirety of the competition, however she looks obviously shaken during the Q&A unlike the others. Inspite that, she did answer explendidly.
Miss USA is the best proof that the ability to speak english doesn't make you smarter and wiser. What's important is the message you are relaying to the people. That even though speaking english is just a piece of cake to her, her message is just so...oofff idk
The best MU q&a would be the 2 winners from India.. Sushmita Sen & Lara Dutta! And 2 from the Philippines.. Pia & Catriona❤️ Filipinos and Indians are good English speakers from Asia and smart too.
in miss universe 2012 , ms. Philippines has the most amazing answer, so all of the fans of miss universe were expecting that she'll be crowned as miss universe. I just don't know why did usa won
where is janine tugonon? shamcey supsop? whose from philippines and had the absolutely excellent answers compare to your top 5 (not including pia ofc). philippines should have been here thrice. :)
Olivia is a celebrity that explains why she got away with the crown with a dumb answer ticket.Janine worked hard for that crown only to end up being robbed.
No she's not. How come that the essence of a woman is to give birth? How about those woman who are infertile, those woman who chose to remain single for the rest of their lives? I don't her answer was the best because she neglect those woman who are not capable of giving birth.
I agree about sushmita sen although to me the answer I loved the most out of all I have seen is miss Canada; miss universe 2005 Honestly the answers before this top three procedure were better as they were impromptu but now the contestants already know the top three final question from what other contestants claim; true or false I don't know but if true doesn't hold creativity to me they have enough time to rehearse. The top five question in my opinion is what is meant to hold more substance. And Pia's answer might not make my top 10 favorite answers but one of the winners from Philippines will. The lady who was asked what she would do with a man from the moon or something like that can't really remember but I remember her answer and i loved it. My most underrated 1st runner up answer who I would have loved to win is miss India 1995 I loved her answer more than the winner; the late Chelsi Smith, miss USA and miss universe 1995 may her soul rest in peace. Her answer was equally beautiful but lacked originality, it was the same answer she gave at her local pageant. Miss India's answer was heartfelt and sadly women around the world still struggle with it along with Chelsi's answer. Miss Canada's answer was also nice but India stood out for me. It would have been a well deserved back to back win for India.
@@spoilednever5594 have u completed your studies brother? U seriously need to graduate ok. Your intellect is little short. It is ok. U will get there. *Just complete your education* 🙂 Also, since u are not a woman; u have no right to question about the essence of any woman. Just because someone is infertile does not mean she is a lesser woman or does not want to give birth. Finally, Sushmita never said about fertility related factor. U brought it up. She only mentions *the origin of a child is a woman,* which only a fool will disagree.
Olivia Culpo was not included on the TOP TEN WINNING ANSWERS in the PAGEANT HISTORY. Janine's answer was among the top even as a first runner up. So it looked like she was the MU of 2012..
Marijo Livitzky yesss she is the real winner of miss universe 2012 and that's why philippines has 5 muss universe from now but for us but for them we only have 4
When it comes to answering questions no one can touch the contestants from INDIA.Just look at Miss India 1994,1995,1999,2000 & all the other international pageants.
janine tugonon's answer is better than olivia's
peter peter so what Janine is not a miss universe runner up lang sya paki nyo ba
@@hideous4685 pindeha hater
I think so .
@@hideous4685 maligo ka muna HAHAHAHHA
new york *eww nagtatagalog ka pa man din... Nakakahiya ka kung saan ka man nanggaling.*
The best tagged line that pia made "Confidently beautiful with a heart " was still inculcate in everyone's mind. Agree? Comment below 👇 💕💕
Dayana Mendoza's Answer gives me goosebumps and Pia's answer was memorable 😁
I don’t think Olivia’s answer should be on the list. Hehhehe
I disagree, its very true to life answer
@@pacaldo5142 she contradicts her answer at the end. And it is too simple for me
Mamita's Kitchen ok... that’s your opinion... I’m just sharing mine. Cheers
Jhanna Augustina CP Yuzzzzz. Thanks! Cheers!
I agree
I disagree with Olivia’s answer as one of the “best answers”. She was asked what she regretted doing. She starts off by saying “what I regretted most...” then ended by saying “but I dont regret it”. So she technically contradicted herself. Furthermore, she talked about picking on her siblings which really was not a strong answer based on how she delivered it. Philippines, Brazil, and Australia had better answers. Philippines that year had the best answer. It’s been years, but this edition will always make pageant followers question the validity of this edition.
Ya filipinas le había ganado a USA en 1973. Dudo que dejaran que Filipinas le ganara nuevamente a USA.
Using your logic,Angola had the worst answer of the six.
Absolutely right, Philippines was the real winner of that year. In fact, USA should have been the fourth runner up, and Brazil and Australia should have been the first and second runner up.
pia rocks. polina shows intelligence. dyana was clever. miss Angola was nice. rio answer was good. love you girls from India.
U missed Olivia : dumbest answer ever.
And Olivia is dumb
Olivia’s answer, really? She started with “something I regret” and ended with “but I don’t regret it” gurl was contradicting herself
Dayana Mendoza's answer was hostorically amazing.
Everyone cannot forget the answer of Janine Tugonon of the Philippines! She should have won the crown over the seaweed brain Olivia.😂
Janine's answer was good but it's too rehearse tbh. Americans are realistic when it comes to q&a. They want genuine, realistic, and smart answer.
What do you mean by too rehearse? Is it because she is quick to answer? I think it is the way she answers not rehearsed. Besides the contestants do not know what questions they gonna get. So how can you say it is rehearsed? Janine answered the question genuinely and realistically. It's like giving a extemporaneous speech with little preparation. Janine is very intelligent and smart contestant.
@@marijolivitzky372 true!
Ernest Liongson thanks for your support.
@@marijolivitzky372 your welcome!
I still dont understand how miss USA won over Miss Philippines. The question was about a thing that happened that she regret but in the end of her answer she said I dont regret it. What??
@@hideous4685 tanga, ang importante un final q and a sa mismong coronation night.
new york hey you idiot watch ur word baho ng bunganga mo, naka drugs ka? dapat sau tinotokhang.. Utak dilis, fanget mo!
@@hideous4685 hahahaha! Ano sabi mo? What are you saying about? O baka ibig mong sabihin eh "what are you talking about? You dont understand me? Thats y u want me to speak in english? Hehehe.. Pieces of advice lang ha, construct ur grammar first before ka bumanat ng english ok, u get me?
Obvious kasi na trying hard ka kuno at pretending na marunong mag-english or shall we say conyo kuno, hahaha, napaghahalata ka naman sa mga pananalita mo na u came from a ghetto area kaya wag kna mag level up at bka ka lumagapak.
Hindi na rin po kita papatulan kahit mag mumura ka pa dyan kasi wla ka breeding at uneducated ka, pikon ka kasi kaya ganyan ka umasta. Learn how to accept critics and bad comments from other people, be sports lang d mo kailangan magsalita ng d maganda o mag mura in short "just shut your bad mouth when you have nothing good to say ok hijo de la chingada?
@@deoninalaxa1196 i cant understand you
@@deoninalaxa1196 Hey ops. You're too busy checking other person's grammar but cannot afford to correct yours.
When Steve said "nailed it" we all know that PIA is the Miss Universe 2015!!
sorry but i think the answer of miss USA is "not really" that on point.
She has the weakest answer, in my opinion. No hate.
@Neta Shm except ph
Not really on point but I think that is the most genuine and simple answer in Miss Universe history.
John Carlo Emberga : I agree.
Question for the Miss Universe 2018:
Why did Miss Universe USA 2012 win?
Winning answer:
Home-court advantage
Donald Trump as judge haha
true
Truee
Wow! What a great answer😂😂😂 anyways absolutely right
Olivia's answer ain't even worth winning. Lol
Seriously tho, Olivia shouldn’t be there. She’s just pretty but that’s it.
She’s kind of average looking only
Khayne M. : They included her in the list because she gave a spontaneous answer. Surely not the best one to give if you wanna win the crown but an original one that reflects your personality. Contrary to Philippines her answer didn’t sound generic.
Olivia is definitely beautiful (above average) but Miss Philippines response was light years above Olivia's response. Miss Phillipines should've won this title.
Pretty???
She isn't very pretty, and her question was easy
Pia wurtzbach 😚😚😚 love from India
Paulina very simple but sharp answer, I like how she slayed that question with two powerful sentences
pia got the best answer of all the rest.. im from malaysia but i damn love u girl..
Meh pa Malaysia2 ka pa! Taga Quiapo ampotah!
@@eyelashqueen0986 Judgemantal ka kaagad?
Universe loves Pia, shes our queen. Love from india.
Olivia's answer was like a kid being asked by another kid. Janine's answer was way better.
Yes and Janine was more beautiful than Olivia. She should have won Miss Universe !
since all of the comments are about miss olivia’s answer here is the timestamp 3:29
Wow smart lady, the one wearing blue gown.
you ment pls?
pia
Philippines
That's Philippines pride.. Pia Alonzo Wurtsback
@@johnninopunay7408 Pia and Paulina the best!!!
Loved Miss Universe 2014 Paulina Vega.❤️❤️. Her answer to that “what can women learn from men?”was amazing.
Paulina Vega is the prettiest Miss Universe ever.
Miss Angola is a true doll like beauty ..wow..watta face and body... but did she answer the question ... it took her so long to answer.. but actually.all she is saying was ." i have nothing to change in myself.. i thank God for giving me all the things i need and have in my life..thank you ..."
I love Dayana's answer. 😍
*Janine Togonon will always be the Miss Universe in 2012 rather than that red quacking gal. Janine's CROWN is so priceless that only who believes in her can see it.*
*🍵: Donald Trumpolin was one of the JUDGES that time*
Stop. USA already won. You cant change the time anymore.
@Donald Trump wtf?? did yoy hear SA answer
@Donald Trump before you bark,please compare it first.If you watch it again,you will see Ms. Philippines thinking what will she going to say so how could you say that it's rehearsed?
@Donald Trump that's barbaric :/ Philippines might not be a powerhouse but at least we fight for our community,not like your shit-ass country whom you rule that even your own people regrets your name, should've been *DONALD FUCKING TRUMP DICKHEAD*
@Donald Trump our dearest janine tugonon isn't a bloody noob :/ stop fucking us,if Olivia one,she won,but don't ever say that just because Olivia culpo won doesn't mean u have the right to say garbage things to us,we,filipinos are actually intelligent and philosophers,we sometimes can be a bit sarcastic and dramatic but don't even think of saying words that can cause Internet war
olivia should absolutely not be a part of this compilation at all if we're talking about best answers. janine has the best answer of them all by a clear mile.
Janine was not Miss Universe
Well, the one compiled this crass video is another dumbest!
@@jeromehiralall3962 Thanks to Ms Universe that time. They turned a pageant to a cooking show.
Dayana Mendoza is one of the best 😘🇻🇳🇻🇳
What is something you regret doing?
Miss USA: I regret picking on my siblings.. blah blah blah.. but i don't regret it.
What something you have done, and you Will never do again?
I believe Pia's answer was the best of all!!! She gave historical information and also she expressed her point of View!! The best answer EVER!!! Greetings from México!!!
exactly 💯
But miss Mexico 2020 is not deserve for the crown 👑 because all in all it should be miss Peru cause she gave the best answer
@@jhayvansaliwan8134 It's not just about QNA there are so many other factors too and Andrea deserved it
@@jhayvansaliwan8134 Peru did give a better answer but Andrea was the best in everything else. so when you add it all up Andrea ends up still being teh winner. dont be sore losers
Para mi la mejor es la de Dayana mendoza una resuesta inteligente y precisas
Janine Tugonon (PHILIPPINES) should be the Miss Universe 2012!!!
No te extrañes de que cosas como estas pasen. Recuerda que a Colombia le pasó 3 veces. En 1992, 1993 y la peor de todas en 1994.
Very clear answer is PIA OF PHILIPPINES! MORE POWER! "CONFIDENTLY BEAUTIFUL!"
best answer of all time is from pia(philippines, dayanara(puerto rico) and sushmita shen (india).
Leo Pret Dayanara is from Venezuela
@@norbisb no. She's Puerto Riconian charing
Nobita Go Dayana Mendoza sorry... she is Venezuelan
@@norbisb she represented her hometown Puerto Rico back in miss universe 1994 so it means she's puerto rican. Stop being a shithole. I know her because she used to lived in the Philippines for quite a long time. period!
Nobita Go omg Dayana Mendoza is Venezuelan, Dayanara TORRES is Puerto Rican
Miss Universe 2008 miss Venezuela has the best answer among them..her answers were spontaneous and deep,her confidence even made her true queen....
Ms. Colombia here is so beautiful and confident. Pia performed with confidence almost the entirety of the competition, however she looks obviously shaken during the Q&A unlike the others. Inspite that, she did answer explendidly.
Miss USA is the best proof that the ability to speak english doesn't make you smarter and wiser. What's important is the message you are relaying to the people. That even though speaking english is just a piece of cake to her, her message is just so...oofff idk
That question in 5:21 is a bad question to ask in Miss Universe. 🤮🤮
Janine Tugonon's answer is better than Culpo 🙄
Okay now let's add Catriona and Ms. South Africa ❤️❤️
I love Venezuela's answer!
what! USA.. shit answer... Should be Miss Philippines who is the 1st Runner up won...
monefloje29 I agree
agree
agree and she is even included in this list!!
its a homecountry what do we expect.#janine tugonon missuniverse
Ok
Best ans by Sushmita Sen, miss universe 1994.. 😍
Dayana, Paulina, and Pia💗💪💯
woooo Pia...was wonderful...so smart and beautiful...congratulations...
Janine Tugonon must be Miss Universe not Olivia Culpo!!! I dont even understand her answer!!!
Maria Loves I agree she should have been the Miss Universe not Culpo.
hometown decision
Miss U Philippines 2015 which is Pia is exactly so smart.
We will never forget the moment when Olivia won over Janine istg justice will prevail! JUSTICE WILL PREVAIL!
I cant forget about janine she deserve more
She been robbed
Sry for my bd eng
2006, Japan (Kurara Chibana)
2012, Philippines (Janine Tugonon)
Both were robbed
2012 really a bad year for miss Philippines because miss USA answers is far from the tittle of being Miss Universe
Sabotage at its finest by trump!
Miss Philippines, very smart confidently beautiful with a heart
I fell in love with Rio Mori after that answer
Oh my god miss USA is not the miss universe and i think miss philippines is the miss universe oh my god very bad mistake haha
Pauline Vega is sooooo beautiful and stunning shoulders really
Angola's answer had more substance. Janine had a very good response to her question as well.
i helieve miss india sushmita and miss trinidad and tobago and miss phillippines catriona has the bedt winning answer.
isa sinisigurado ko ayaw ni trump ke janine doon sya sa me branding.uknow wat i min? business.ganun lng un.
@@gerliemondalo5561 English please!
I'll go with Pia. Truly a Queen!!! ❤
always she will be my favorite ❤️❤️ miss universe 💖
I speak Portuguese fluently so hearing the one from Angola was just beautiful
🇧🇷🇵🇹
I am from Eastern part of Indonesia. We were colonized by portugeese so love portugese
Now it’s time to update this list , add Catriona’s Final QA 😻
Absolutely...the best miss universe for all times..
the best answer so far 👌
and remove olivia's
@@rizzaquiatchon3375 ir she's the best why she was not invited in Latin country during her reign. After her reign what is she doing now singing?
Dayana still the best... And pia alsoo.. 😊😍
Paulina Vega is an example of Classic beauty.......her beauty is sooo classic n sofisticated
Dayana Mendoza gave an outstanding answer! 😍
Why tf is Olivia the crown robber Culpo is here lol
Miss Angola is the most beauty queen ever seen as miss universe winner😍😍😍
I like angola's answer because of portugeese. It sounds unique. I Know some of portugeese. Good job. Love from Eastern part of Indonesia
The best MU q&a would be the 2 winners from India.. Sushmita Sen & Lara Dutta! And 2 from the Philippines.. Pia & Catriona❤️ Filipinos and Indians are good English speakers from Asia and smart too.
Demi 's answer on first Question was on point(Mis Universe 2017) 💕
Wow so proud of Queen Pia from Philippines
loved miss Angola.... beautiful attitude...
in miss universe 2012 , ms. Philippines has the most amazing answer, so all of the fans of miss universe were expecting that she'll be crowned as miss universe. I just don't know why did usa won
Olivia culpo.. Worst answer how come she include on the best answer.. Lol
Janine should have been the MU rather than Olivia
Ms Angola has the prettiest face of all of them
@dean and deanbear for me it’s Paulina Vega
All had really good answers except for Miss USA in 2012 tbh. Loved 2011 and 2015 (Leila and Pia) had the best answers in my opinion.
Pia, smartest of them all!!!
👍
Over dayana? Keep on dreaming :*
She looked so nervous.
she the only one who got a very serious question. thats why it sounded smart . all the lady’s had good and true answer no one is better then no one.
Riyo mori is suchh an adorable queen
La seguridad de Dayana al responder en perfecto ingles a pesar de no ser su idioma natal no la tuvo ninguna otra. Salve reina.
isabella licia de acuerdo contigo no como otras brutas que no saben ni su idioma natal
where is janine tugonon? shamcey supsop? whose from philippines and had the absolutely excellent answers compare to your top 5 (not including pia ofc). philippines should have been here thrice. :)
this is only winners here
@@---ct2hj fuck you hahahaha
- - lol his name is Vietnamese so shut up
@@---ct2hj how dare you are the annoying one
Pia’s Anwsers was the best.
Love Dayana, not only what she said but also the way she showed her opinion
Olivia is a celebrity that explains why she got away with the crown with a dumb answer ticket.Janine worked hard for that crown only to end up being robbed.
I love Pia and Liela..from Thailand.
.
I like Leila too
Why is Olivia Culpo even here? Her answer cannot change lives
For me sushmita sen miss universe 1994 is the best answer ever
George Jacildo for the past 10 years...for the past 10 years 😉
No she's not. How come that the essence of a woman is to give birth? How about those woman who are infertile, those woman who chose to remain single for the rest of their lives? I don't her answer was the best because she neglect those woman who are not capable of giving birth.
@@hitbhatt1100 but Pia gives the answer that were never forget!Pia is Unforgattable Sushimita sen is like Pia in 20's
I agree about sushmita sen although to me the answer I loved the most out of all I have seen is miss Canada; miss universe 2005
Honestly the answers before this top three procedure were better as they were impromptu but now the contestants already know the top three final question from what other contestants claim; true or false I don't know but if true doesn't hold creativity to me they have enough time to rehearse. The top five question in my opinion is what is meant to hold more substance. And Pia's answer might not make my top 10 favorite answers but one of the winners from Philippines will. The lady who was asked what she would do with a man from the moon or something like that can't really remember but I remember her answer and i loved it.
My most underrated 1st runner up answer who I would have loved to win is miss India 1995 I loved her answer more than the winner; the late Chelsi Smith, miss USA and miss universe 1995 may her soul rest in peace. Her answer was equally beautiful but lacked originality, it was the same answer she gave at her local pageant. Miss India's answer was heartfelt and sadly women around the world still struggle with it along with Chelsi's answer. Miss Canada's answer was also nice but India stood out for me. It would have been a well deserved back to back win for India.
@@spoilednever5594 have u completed your studies brother? U seriously need to graduate ok. Your intellect is little short. It is ok. U will get there. *Just complete your education* 🙂
Also, since u are not a woman; u have no right to question about the essence of any woman. Just because someone is infertile does not mean she is a lesser woman or does not want to give birth. Finally, Sushmita never said about fertility related factor. U brought it up. She only mentions *the origin of a child is a woman,* which only a fool will disagree.
For me India and Philippine always best ❤
Angola has very good answer too
How disgusting Olivia Culpo included in the best answer 😂😂
Olivia Culpo was not included on the TOP TEN WINNING ANSWERS in the PAGEANT HISTORY. Janine's answer was among the top even as a first runner up. So it looked like she was the MU of 2012..
Marijo Livitzky yesss she is the real winner of miss universe 2012 and that's why philippines has 5 muss universe from now but for us but for them we only have 4
Catriona Gray has the best answer ❤️
Philippines (Miss,Pia 👑) yass❤️
When it comes to answering questions no one can touch the contestants from INDIA.Just look at Miss India 1994,1995,1999,2000 & all the other international pageants.
Philippines 🇵🇭
Loved all the answers....❤❤
Pia🔥🔥🔥🔥
The best answer for me will forever be miss universe 2000 Lara Dutta.
I love susmita sens answer 😁
USA 2012, dafuq?
Miss Colombia is the coolest. See what she did during the choatic crowning moment in 2015.
And when is Miss Peru's Answer going to be added on to the List? as she had the best answers for Miss U 2020
dude the title of this video should be "miss universe winners from the past 10 years."
i admire paulina vega so much😘😘😍
Angola is very pretty and her answer is excellent ...i love her ...love from India
Love her too
The appropriate title should be "6 Best Miss Universe Answers for the past 10 Years"