Going flat is EXACTLY the way it was intended!!! He was restrained in the beginning on purpose to build the song and portray a man on the verge of falling apart!!
Check out the video I just posted today, I explain my scoring system in detail. Believe it or not, a 7.8 is a REALLY good score. Anything above a 5 is o.k., so a 7.8 is borderline great! Trust me, if you watch the video where I explain my scoring system, you'll see this was actually a really good score. After this video was released, I listened to the studio version of this song. On the album they intentionally sing the "do do do do do do do's" about 5-10 cents flat...and I said in my review that if they do this intentionally, that is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!! It's a great song, well written, well recorded, well mixed, well executed. Those do do do do do do do's are SO catchy, they're still rattling around in my head even today.
Them going flat was most likely intentional, as you can hear them bend the note down at the very end of the riff. I think it was a choice to match the sad and dark tone of the songs lyrical content. IMO unplugged was the perfect setting for Black as it is one of their more delicate songs, and it highlights Eddie. His performance was nearly perfect and delivered with so much emotion. A great example of a song written with deep lyrical substance, precisely arranged, and performed with more emotion than 99% of people can emote.. I give it a 9.5. Cant ask for much more than that.
They're not so much flat but using multiple modes. And yes it's just like this on the album. In fact I like this performance much more. And as far as performance. MTV forbade them to play standing up with pissed Eddie Vedder off to no end. At one point in one song he stood on his stool so he wouldn't be off the mark but could still stand up. He wound up falling off the stool and it was AWESOME!
My opinion, this is my all time favorite version of this song. It’s an extremely personal song to Vedder. I love it because it’s raw and he is able to make you FEEL this song. Watch his body language during specific lyrics of the song. This song, this version, especially the lyrics Eddie just off the cuff added at the end of the song…damn.
Your not alone. David letterman had it stuck in his head for years. Mentioned it when he inducted them into the Rock hall of fame. And here’s a bit from the late show. ruclips.net/video/HwmlzDaRoI4/видео.html
With the exception of the improvised lyrics at the end, the song here is very similar to the studio version. As for the background vocals, the audience takes care of that at their shows 😜
You are 100 percent wrong. MTV unplugged is suppose to be subdued even the vocals. It’s live and acuity played. It’s a different feel. They are supposed to sound exactly as they are playing. Hands down the best live performance in music
7.8??????????? 🤔 No song with the lyric "I know someday you'll have a beautiful life. I know you'll be a star in somebody else's sky, but why? Why? Why? Can't it be, can't it be mine?" Should ever get less than a 9. I joke, but in all seriousness, musical taste is musical taste. You have no need to apologize for that. The background vocals sound very similar on the studio version. My ear is not sharp enough to say definitively if it's identical, but damn close. I have not perceived any of these live performances as low energy. More subdued than jumping around on stage like they did during Pink Pop? Sure. But a song like Black (one of the great break up songs of all time) is a song about mood and emotion. It would have been bizarre and out of place if it were played with that kind of energy. I suppose one area of friendly disagreement is that when I consume music I primarily do it for the music. What I mean by that is first, second, third, and fourth on my checklist is how did I like the song. Do I want to hear it again? Does it speak to me? Perhaps its because when I listen to music, 9 times out of 10 I don't have the video. I'm in my car or on an ipod, etc.. I love live concerts because they bring out the variations in songs. And when I am actually there, it gives me a chance to connect with the band in person. I agree that when a band plays the notes without trying to connect it falls flat. But I don't need the guys jumping around for the connection. The call and answers, the eye contact with people in the crowd. Changing facial expressions all do the trick. And I think one other thing to take into consideration from live clips is that PJ shows are typically well over 2 hours. Some over 3 hours. In the audience you feel the energy ebb and flow. The songs themselves have ups and downs. It's hard to evaluate the energy of a performance overall from a single song. In fact we have seen videos where you paused early and commented on something (in this video it was Eddie's subdued vocals) only to see the song pull a 180. Once again, thanks for the reaction. Good stuff.
I think they are going flat intentionaly to make the audience feel how pain and sorrow can anihilate life. It's genius and a masterpiece. I'm french so I can't understand the lyrics like an american will but anyone on this planet can feel how emotional that sound is.
I really appreciated this reaction video and I have watched many. I usually end up skipping the talking parts after a few seconds but I listened to the whole thing. Don't agree with everything but respect your perspective. Will be watching more videos you do. Thanks.
Thank you Joe for the encouraging words I appreciate them, and thank you for having an open mind in regards to what I said about this performance. I actually listened to the studio recording of this song after I posted this video, and the "do do do do do do do's" are about 5 -10 cents flat on the studio album as well.....which means they are intentionally going flat on purpose. As I said in the review, if they're doing that intentionally, then that's absolutely BRILLIANT!!! Singing that part intentionally slightly flat makes it stick out, which makes it memorable....and it worked. TRUST ME It worked...it's been over a week since I filmed that reaction and I STILL have those "do do do do do do do's" stuck in my head. So kudos to Pearl Jam for coming up with that idea and executing it so amazingly well. Just out of curiosity, if you don't mind me asking, what persuaded you to watch the whole thing? Thank you again for watching, hope you enjoyed the show. DH
You pronounced the name correctly. Thanks for doing this review. I think you’ll change your tune on a few opinions after listening to the studio version...I’m guessing you already have. In the end though, it’s all about your own musical preferences and that’s why we come to your channel. I already have my opinion and want to hear YOUR opinion. I like that you dove into the background vocals at the end of the song. It’s a signature of this song that people tend to love or hate without even knowing what it is that they love or hate. They’ll stick with you regardless. That do do do do do do will be with you all day and into tomorrow. It might even pop up next week for no reason!
Actually you're right it is just ever so slightly flat on the studio version as well...which means it is in fact intentional. And as I said in my review, if it is intentional, then that's ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT. So kudos to them for doing so, mad props.
Haha David, I think you are the first person (after David Letterman) that talks about the doodoodoo part for more than 2 minutes 😅, thats why we all like you. Keep coming man! Speaking of Jim Morrison, Eddie did a great renditions of Jim when he fronted the reunited the Doors back in 93. But since your new rules, I can't request another one until my previous get fulfilled, maybe someone else's could 😊
Eddie's voice is so colorful and attractive. I don't know about the technique, I doubt he took singing lessons, but his innate talent created an amazing and unique vocal style which catches the attention and excites.
If you wanna see energy during an acoustic show watch state of love and trust, jeremy, or porch from this same set. Nobody rocked unplugged like pearl jam. This song is just a more subdued song. The studio is electric but not exactly a rocker. Although other live versions end with the most amazing solos by mr. Mike Mccready that I'm sure you would really enjoy.
Dave Abruzesse on drums. Best move PJ ever made was hiring him. Unfortunately, their worst move was firing him only 2 albums later. His work on Vs is legendary and he brought such energy to this band live. Matt Cameron was probably the best they could do as a replacement, but Dave will always remain the best musician Eddie ever played with.
Hey buddy, I'm pretty sure you know Sepultura from Brazil, if you don't, I'd be glad to introduce you n see you making a rection video. Attitude live in Barcelona, mind freaking...
I'm pretty sure the doo doo doo doo doo doo doos sounded basically the same as they always do. Eddie does them on the studio version and the tune isn't noticeably different to my non-musician ear. This is one of my favourite songs because of the lyrics and the depth of emotion, but if that's not your thing, it's not your thing. I love a lot of PJ's slower songs and acoustic stuff but I suspect you wouldn't be into them.
They clearly drop down right at the end of that note deliberaty, its supposed to be a haunting refrain. You think they're completely in tune but randomly go flat at exactly the same point every single time?, and it just so happens its in a way that works with the song... Dude, you're wrong 100%
It was exactly as planned except for playing on rented instruments because theirs didn't get there on time. It was intentional. The audience now sings that part because this song is known worldwide. You must have been living under a rock to have missed it. It's still huge 30 years later. Buskers do it like crazy. I can't believe you overlooked the note Eddie held just to argue the flat of the chorus. Check out "State of Love and Trust" from the same show. And "Porch" is crazy too. And yes to what was said below. Manzarek hand picked Eddie to sing for The Doors when they were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. It's all on RUclips.
Well I was very distracted by the pitch, but like I said it was consistently like 10 - 15 cents flat....which isn't a lot, but it is noticeable. I just listened to the studio version yesterday, and it's flat on the studio recording as well...which leads me to believe my theory is correct. They intentionally are slightly flat on purpose....which is absolutely BRILLIANT!!! So kudos to PJ for having the foresight to break from tradition and intentionally sing just slightly off key...it actually worked and made the "do do do do do do do's" extremely memorable. I filmed this 5 days ago....and that part is STILL stuck in my head....along with "It's O.k." that I did a while back. As far as The Doors performance goes.....keeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep watching....especially over the next 3 days.....
@@THEDavidHeretic 🤣 The stuff about David Letterman getting that chorus stuck in his head is pretty funny and he brings it up at their induction into the Rock and Roll HoF so you are not the only one. This song is just so ubiquitous I'm surprised you've missed it. I've heard orchestras cover it. I've heard it in various languages. I've heard a death metal version, etc. 😁 Everywhere...
@@christianeflentie1228 I went out of my way to avoid PJ like the plague. Whenever my brother would play it in his room I would either put in headphones and blast Metallica, or I would leave the house. I was a metal snob, still am to some extent...but now I'm open to other genres.
I've seen that video several times...I'll never forget the look on Riki Rachtman's face when he introduced the video on Headbangers Ball...he looked like someone told him his dog died. It was a good video, better song honestly. Doesn't belong on Headbangers Ball, but it was a really good song.
The only thing that surprises me about this is the fact that a “rocker” has never heard this song. Seriously, you are a middle aged man that is into rock that has never heard Black by Pearl Jam. That is very sad.
I avoided bands like Pearl Jam, Nirvana, and Soundgarden in the 90's like the plague. I was really into prog and jazz during that time, and I had no interest in the "grunge" movement at all. One of the great things about doing this channel is it has forced me to check them out, and I'm glad it did.
@@THEDavidHeretic Absolutely right! And as you said it was the "🎶Do do doot do do da doo🎶" that would always stick in my head throughout the years everytime I listened to it.
They are singing the correct intentional notes. It’s a sad song so the minor/dissonant sound is purposeful. Eddie was actually sick during this show, and you’re right that in comparison his voice was slightly thin. But you try singing that well, sick. I’ll wait.
@@MsLeemills Naaaaaaah been there done that....happened in Europe while we were touring in Austria and Hungary. Luckily it started to clear up right as we got into Slovakia. The only time I ever got sick on tour...man did it suck.
Flat is not what it is, it's full of emotion from start to finish. Vocal coaches have reviewed this video and they never say they're flat so idk maybe it's a matter of taste? Not every song has to start heavy and end heavy for it to be heard or felt. This performance is absolutely beautiful. Btw new sub here! Keep up the good work
Hey David. You really need to do a reaction to the version of Black they played at Atlanta in 1994, that's the best non-unplugged version you'll find. The ad-lib at the end from 4:35 onwards is fantastic, Eddie and Mike both on fire. ruclips.net/video/_hXYzHlevvs/видео.html
This is an older upload, so you've probably already watched the studio version at some point. But, this song is meant to grow on you. Because I'm soo in tune with every note of the song, I can recognize all the subtle greatness that each note brings in this lower volume acoustic version. In the studio version each note is much more audible. There's also a piano added that added to the atmosphere. But eventhough, this is really organic feeling, it's extremely precise, delicately precise. Every note contributes to the emotion and buildup. But I gotta push back with the energy thing. There was nothing challenging about Eddie's energy. He was in a trance and was completely singing out of raw emotion. Also, this has a hook if you listen more. This is a must acquired taste. Some songs you can't just say not my taste and move on. This is one of them. The build up and crescendo of this song will grab you. The raw yet precise emotions in sync with the structure of the song will grab you. Trust me.
Nice review, saw others hit same points on the do do do parts sticking in your head like with Letterman. Funny story, one time going to the river I played this album in the truck with Dad, let’s just say he wasn’t a fan. But he would comment and the do do do’s was one that stuck, whenever I would mention PJ he would bring that up 😂. This is a sad song, ultimate break up song, think the lyrics and feeling by Eddie when he sings it is what really gets people behind this song. As far as going flat I believe it is on purpose to give that emotional sad tone to compliment the lyrics. Eddie did this song as a tribute for Chris Cornell after he passed where he breaks down crying at the we belong together part at the end. There is always a lot of emotion from Eddie and the band in this song. I know you are focusing a lot on the technical parts, but afterwards I would recommend grabbing a drink sitting back and relax, crank up the sound, and just enjoy it as well without the camera.
I intentionally avoided these guys throughout high school and beyond....just ask my brother, he's one of the biggest PJ fans around....I would put on headphones or leave the house whenever he started playing Pearl Jam in his room.
@@Metallnsanity87 No it was because Pearl Jam had been classified by the masses as grunge, and I couldn't stand grunge music. Long story short, I heard Nirvana's "Smells Like Teen Spirit", and I couldn't stand it, and I said to myself "If this is what Grunge music is gonna sound like, I don't want any part of it". I'm actually really glad I started this channel because it's forcing me to give Pearl Jam a chance, and I'm actually really glad it is.
@@THEDavidHeretic in that case, I hope you didn't do the same with Alice In Chains..? AIC is the most metal-ish of the big grunge bands.. If you haven't heard them, you definitely should
@@Metallnsanity87 I actually really dug Alice In Chains. I remember seeing the music video for "We Die Young" on Headbangers Ball and I really dug it. loved their first album Facelift, and I reeeeeally dug Dirt. They came on the scene right before the term "grunge" was a thing, so I never really considered them grunge.
Just being honest....for the record I did go listen to the studio version, and they do the "do do do do do do do's" slightly flat on the record as well. Which means my suspicions were true...they're intentionally singling flat on purpose. As I stated in the video, if that's the case (which it is) that is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT. So yes, they are brilliant for doing that....because it makes it memorable. It makes it stick in your head.....and it has...for over 2 months now...I'd like to get a decent nights sleep....and I can't....because those "do do do do do do do's" are running around in my head and WON'T STOP!!! AAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHH. No seriously in all seriousness they really are stuck in my head still to this day. So yes, mission accomplished Pearl Jam.
@@THEDavidHeretic I love the honesty because its feels sincere! So many channels just claim to love everything requested for the clicks and likes. You give a sincere take that's true to you and I honestly do commend you for that. I will be watching more videos!
Thank you for the encouraging words,, they mean a lot to me. That's been my goal since I started this channel. I want this channel to be different. No fake reactions, no begging for clicks and subs. Just real, genuine, 100% honest content. Welcome to the channel, I hope you enjoy the show.
The one guy on the internet who didn’t quite get it. This is regarded as one of the all time best live performances. I love this guy’s passion though. He just took a little too analytical view at this and missed the emotion
Yes it is, I listened to the recorded version afterwards and sure enough...they're doing it there as well. Absolutely brilliant. It's STILL stuck in my head....2 months later.
The bassist and rhythm guitarist backup vocals are based on the piano melody of producer Rick Parasher's piano part in the original production. The flat notes are by design. Pearl Jam's album "Ten" is one of the best five rock n roll albums of all time. If you are missing the point, perhaps you should reevaluate your perspective. Godspeed.
So it could be intentional then...that's brilliant if that's the case. I'm gonna have to check out the studio version and compare. Checked out the studio version. They're flat on it as well....which leads me to believe they intentionally go slightly flat on purpose....which is absolutely GENIUS!!! It made the "do do do do do do do's" extremely memorable, they've been stuck in my head since I filmed this, and that was 5 days ago. So big kudos to PJ for doing that on purpose, it worked like a charm.
I do, I'm actually involved in several musical projects and bands. Personally I would never want to go on a show like Unplugged....too many rules and restrictions, we wouldn't be able to be ourselves.
The whole show was very high energy but Black is not a high energy song. Eddie had a chest infection and they had only that day to rehearse the show before taping. If you watch the entire show in one sitting I think you’ll enjoy it. I was a little bothered by how much you were stuck on the backing vocals and seemed to completely miss the raw emotion pouring out of Eddie.
Sorry you were bothered by what you think you heard, I suggest going back and listening to what I said a little more carefully. I very clearly stated..."If these backing vocals are intentionally 5 - 10 cents flat....then that is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!! That makes them stand out....which makes them memorable." I started out being critical, but the more I heard them I started to realize they were consistently flat every single time.....which led me to wonder if it was intentional. THAT'S why the "do do do do do do do's" are the part that stick in everyones mind....and THAT'S what creates the HOOK....and THAT is what makes the song memorable. THAT right there is PURE GENIUS!
@@jamjar5525 I'm contemplating either doing a reshoot of this, or shooting a review the studio version. Call it a mulligan. Which would go over better from a viewers perspective? Redoing the Unplugged show, or a fresh look at the studio recording?
Please listen to "Jeremy" both versions uncut official video and the mtv unplugged. Will definitely give you something to talk about. It's based on a true story.
I'm actually very familiar with that song. It was in heavy rotation on MTV back in the day when MTV ACTUALLY aired music videos. Unfortunately I can't do a reaction video to that, since I have heard the song and seen the video.
LOL....all PJ songs have more energy. They are def not an “unplugged” band. You should check out Porch from Pink Pop🤣 however this was a greaaaaaaat performance. I think it was actually pretty risky for them to do this unplugged considering their usual shows back then and they nailed it. I wasn’t particularly a grunge fan back then but you gotta hand it to Eddie , Chris Cornell and Layne Staley.. what a vocal talent each of them were! Chris was just outstanding. You should check out Hunger Strike by Temple of the Dog
Heh heh....must be new to the channel. It's all good, welcome to the channel. I actually already did a reaction for both of those suggestions. Here's Porch: ruclips.net/video/UfqiYw03tuY/видео.html and here's Hunger Strike: ruclips.net/video/bh48AS6NWlg/видео.html
Good review...rating low but everyone has their own opinion. Check out Porch unplugged...Eddie with the Doors is pretty cool too. Always enjoy your reactions thanks.
I never understood who the woman was that didnt want to be the sun in Eddie Vedders sky...like what us wrong with you lady. Lol...yes they do go flat in the recording I think.
I have loved PJ since i first heard this album in 1991, i was 16 then. but also GnR UYI 1&2, Soundgarden Badmotorfinger, RHCP blood sugar sex majik, Ozzy No More tears just a few that had awesome albums that year. If you want some emotion to this song, you need to listen to his performance @ Firenze Rocks in june of 2017 just a month after his good friend Chris Cornell passed away.. its just him his electric guitar and the audience.. he almost breaks down while singing it. not asking you to react to it but maybe listen on your own time. ruclips.net/video/IfmKAkVfvgA/видео.html anyways thanks good reaction be safe cioa for now
It’s sounds a little kinda sad - a breakup song? The words were very err metaphoric (thanks pops - not real sure what that means) not really my kinda song I’m a happy person and haven’t got to the stage of havin breakups yet so it’s it’s sad 3.2 from me and that flat singin was hurtin my ears didn’t like that bit
Everyone is entitled to their opinion. My brother can vouch for the fact that I never intentionally, knowingly, or willingly heard these songs. If I recognize the songs from some other form of media, such as movies or television, them I make sure to mention that during the video.
Yeah he hated PJ because I was obsessed, and it wasn’t his style of music. Of course I used to hate his stuff too till I got older. It’s actually pretty awesome that he created this channel because he is having to listen from the requests, and I am feeling vilified from all those years telling him to give PJ a try 😂
Too long with pauses, especially since you weren't familiar with the song. You failed to really get the meaning of the song. Hey is this flat on purpose let me know in the comments and hit play. Unfortunately one of the few reactions for this song that didn't do it proper justice.
How can I do an HONEST reaction to a song if I'm already familiar with it? That makes absolutely no sense. I made it very clear, I had never heard this song before, so of course I wasn't familiar with it.
Love your videos. Not to be a jerk or anything, but could you please don't use that kind of background, don't know how many share my phobia about clusters of small black holes. Excerpt from wiki: "Trypophobia is an aversion to the sight of irregular patterns or clusters of small holes or bumps." That background is freaking me out.
Worst review ever this is one of the best live vocal performances from any 90s band you are literally the only channel I’ve heard with any criticism just saying Talking about the Guitarist singing flat meanwhile you have an epic live performance from Eddie Vedder going on in the background talk about dropping the ball LOL I am literally shaking my head I don’t understand your reaction have you seen other people react to this video night and day
I'm guessing you didn't watch the entire video, especially the part where I very clearly stated "it sounds like they're 5 - 10 cents flat EVERY SINGLE TIME"...followed up with "I wonder if they're doing that ON PURPOSE"...followed up with "If they are intentionally going 5 - 10 cents flat every single time, then that is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!!"...followed by "If they're going flat on purpose that is BEYOND BRILIANT...because that will make that part MEMORABLE, due to the fact that it will STAND OUT!!!" Later, on my own, I listened to the studio recorded version of this same song. I discovered that they do, in fact, go intentionally flat on the studio recording....thus proving my theory correct. They are BRILLIANT for going intentionally flat on those parts, because it DID make it stand out...thus making it memorable. To this day I STILL have that part rattling around in my head. So kudos to Pearl Jam for having the foresight to do something absolutely brilliant, and make it work. You say I'm "literally the only channel I’ve heard with any criticism just saying" Have you ever asked yourself...why every other "reactor" out there "loves" this song? Better yet, why every other "reactor" seems to "love" every single song they hear, or video they watch? It's very simple...because all they care about is getting their numbers up. They don't care if they're honest, they don't care about their integrity, all they care about is getting as many subscribers as possible so they can get monetized. They do this by making sure they "love" everything they hear and see...thus making all the people who watch their reaction video happy...thus getting another subscriber based completely on a lie. I refuse to be like that. I will never give a fake reaction and say that I love something, when I actually don't like it, just so I can get more subscribers. I'm not in this to get monetized, I'm not here to lie to the people. I'm hear to give the viewers, especially The Fanbase, something different: a reaction channel that is ACTUALLY honest and genuine in it's reactions. As I have always said, I would much rather have 500 Fanbase members who actually love what I do, than 500,000 subscribers who joined up based on a lie, and who honestly don't care about what I said...as long as they were happy with the lie. Just saying... I know every other "reactor" "loves" this song, and offer absolutely no insight into their reactions....mainly because they have no insight or knowledge to be able to delve into anything musical. As a professional musician of over 30 years, who has studied music since the age of 3, I choose to do the opposite. I choose to use my 40+ years of knowledge in music, and my 30+ experience in the music industry, and put them to good use. I choose to be objective, and look at music and performances from a musicians and performers standpoint. I choose to give credit where credit is due, and to point out where it's not due...in the realms of theory, musicianship, execution, pitch, tone, chordal structure, use of time signatures, tempo, and dynamics. I have seen other "reactors" do this video...the same "reactors" that "love" every single thing they watch. Sorry I'm just not going to be like that. I have said from the beginning of this channel that I will ALWAYS be honest in my reactions, and I will never give fake reactions or opinions about what I watch and hear, just so I get my subscriber numbers up. What I will offer is genuine, honest reactions...as well as some insight as to why I made the decisions. In closing, allow me to apologize for hurting your feelings. I know the truth sometimes can be quite painful to hear, and I'm sorry that I insulted your emotional status by being honest about what I saw and heard. I can only imagine how traumatizing it must have been to hear someone actually give an honest opinion about a band you love, as well as a song you love. I recommend enjoying those other channels, who "love" every single thing they see and hear, and are willing to lie to their viewers just so they can get another subscriber. I will not change what I do, who I am, or how I react to what I see and hear. I will not insult the intelligence of the viewers with fake reactions, or lie to them just so I can boost my numbers. Lastly I will not compromise my own integrity, because in the end that's all a man is worth. DH
@@THEDavidHeretic David you didn't hurt my emotional status I'm not even a big Pearl Jam fan but I am a very talented musician like yourself........ if I'm being honest Pearl Jam completely sucks from 2000 all the way to 2020 !!!!!! 10 was great Vitalogy was a little different versus sounded like it was recorded in someone's garage with cheap equipment and in fact I think it actually was.....?????? I stopped listening after no code I also think Eddie Vedder completely fried his voice in the 90s he literally sounds like a billy goat giving birth in 2020 so I'm not a fanboy but if I was I could handle someone criticizing a band that I happen to like...... And if you would have done a little research most of the band members had a very bad cold this night they were actually filling in for Mariah Carey of all people and they had been on a very long tour but still delivered an amazing performance......... All I'm saying is I have heard you react to other recent Pearl Jam live performances and you were totally digging it ??????? but then you kind of shrug your shoulders at this incredible 90s performance....... and I've also heard other professional musicians react to this particular song in a completely positive way with little to no criticism because it was damn near Perfect by the way well I got you on the line LOL react to Masters of War at the Bob Dylan tribute just give that a listen and I also have integrity and I'm just being honest And by the way my issue with your reaction isn't the fact that you said they sounded intentionally flat and that's brilliant ........ I guess I just expected to see a seasoned musician show a little more respect to a great live performance
@@NocturnalNews Fair enough. Thank you for responding with an actual mind of your own and having reasoning behind your defense, and not just being some "fanboy" who got butthurt over some constructive criticism of their favorite song. I sincerely appreciate it. I actually did react to Masters Of War, and it got blocked worldwide by SME. I was able to put it up on my Patreon page if you would like to check it out. Again, thank you for responding with a mind of your own, and not just being some trolling fanboy, I really do appreciate it.
@@THEDavidHeretic cool no problem and by the way love the channel I've watched damn near every video sorry to hear about masters of War that was one of my favorites And I will check out the patreon And as I mentioned they were filling in for Mariah Carey so this was thrown together last minute and they still did a pretty good job this was their first real live acoustic performance other than the bridge benefit concert
What the actual fuck..You rave about KISS..and the say that one of the best performances of MTV unplugged is, flat, held back and the two other band members are off pitch. And KISS is great I guess..WTF, I don't get this world anymore.
Not quite what I said. I actually said I was disappointed in the KISS Unplugged show. There was no energy in that show, no stage presence. It was boring, other than when Ace and Peter came out. Yes I did say it was held back...as is every other acoustic show. Due to the fact that they are all sitting, playing acoustic instruments, in a small intimate setting...of course it's going to be held back. This is why I've never been a fan of the Unplugged series, it's just not my thing. I prefer live shows with lots of energy, crowd interaction, and intensity. Yes, the guys singing the "do do do do do do do's" were flat by about 5 - 10 cents. That is undeniable. I also stated that since it was consistent and constant, it MAY be intentional...meaning they are singing 5 - 10 cents flat on purpose. I also stated that if they are in fact sing flat like that intentionally, then that is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT! That made the "do do do do do do do's" stick out, which in turn made them extremely memorable. I still have that part stuck in my head, and it's been well over a week since I filmed that reaction. So I listened to the studio version of this song, turns out my suspicions were correct they do sing those "do do do do do do do's" intentionally flat. Not to the point that it sounds bad, only 5 - 10 cents flat...just enough to stick out and be noticeable, thus making it MEMORABLE. For the record, I NEVER said the performance was bad, or poor, or that it sucked. I understand you want to defend a band you absolutely love, but please understand I never put them down. Quite the opposite actually, I paid them a number of compliments...just as I have in all my other Pearl Jam reaction videos. In closing I hope this clears up any confusion you may have had, in regards to anything you may have misunderstood. In the future, before you decide to jump on anyone, please make sure you actually heard what you think you heard, and not what you wanted to hear. DH
I'm in the definite minority, but I don't really like this version. Eddie's voice is shot, he messes up the lyrics... the emotion and delivery is great, but not a fan of most of the rest.
First off, how is what I'm saying negative? You must have missed the part where I said "If this is intentional, then that's ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!" That's right, I called them brilliant, because I did listen to the studio version, and they are intentionally doing the "do do do do do do do's" about 5-10 cents flat. Like I said, that makes it stick out, which makes it MEMORABLE. Absolutely Brilliant. I always make sure to mention the aspects that I enjoy, as well as the parts I wasn't a fan of. Secondly, I would be more than happy to say exactly what I said in the video to Eddie in person. I've never been one to shy away from speaking my mind and voicing my opinion, especially in person. That way the person hears it directly from me, which would eliminate hearsay. Lastly, it's clear to me that you have not watched all the videos of Pearl Jam that I have done so far. If you had, you would see that I have given them WAY more compliments than criticisms. I estimate a 4:1 ratio of compliments to criticisms, so they have absolutely earned my respect as musicians, songwriters, and performers. You're probably not used to reactors on RUclips actually being honest and giving their honest opinions and thoughts on what they watch. Sorry, but I'm not going to be one of those fake reactors who love every single thing they see and hear. I'm going to give my honest opinion and thoughts about everything I watch and hear. The good news is, if you don't like what I do, there are literally hundreds of fake reactors you can watch and enjoy, who are all more than happy to lie to you to make you happy so you'll subscribe to their channel...because that's all they care about. Feel free to enjoy them, and please be happy. DH
Going flat is EXACTLY the way it was intended!!! He was restrained in the beginning on purpose to build the song and portray a man on the verge of falling apart!!
Well said. ❤
I was gonna say the same thing, very clever music.
Well said
This song is sheer artistic poetry put to beautiful, yet gut wrenching melodic rock music
Eddie's singing in a nutshell: Imperfect Perfection
That sounds about right
spot one.. exactly what i love about his unique style
Last comment - State of Love and Trust from same performance is worth a look too. Great uptempo unplugged performance.
It sounds better live (to me) than it does on the studio version. I think it IS intentional.
Eddie actually had the flu when they were on unplugged and still sounds amazing
So wild, he had the flu this past Wednesday when I saw them live in FT Worth Tx and even still this day sounds amazing live
This song is so perfect. Everyone is entitled to their opinion I guess 🤷♀️
Check out the video I just posted today, I explain my scoring system in detail. Believe it or not, a 7.8 is a REALLY good score. Anything above a 5 is o.k., so a 7.8 is borderline great! Trust me, if you watch the video where I explain my scoring system, you'll see this was actually a really good score.
After this video was released, I listened to the studio version of this song. On the album they intentionally sing the "do do do do do do do's" about 5-10 cents flat...and I said in my review that if they do this intentionally, that is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!! It's a great song, well written, well recorded, well mixed, well executed. Those do do do do do do do's are SO catchy, they're still rattling around in my head even today.
I agree, the pure emotion he shows is perfect!!
This song kills me every time I hear it.💔
Them going flat was most likely intentional, as you can hear them bend the note down at the very end of the riff. I think it was a choice to match the sad and dark tone of the songs lyrical content. IMO unplugged was the perfect setting for Black as it is one of their more delicate songs, and it highlights Eddie. His performance was nearly perfect and delivered with so much emotion. A great example of a song written with deep lyrical substance, precisely arranged, and performed with more emotion than 99% of people can emote.. I give it a 9.5. Cant ask for much more than that.
My favorite song ♥️
They're not so much flat but using multiple modes. And yes it's just like this on the album. In fact I like this performance much more. And as far as performance. MTV forbade them to play standing up with pissed Eddie Vedder off to no end. At one point in one song he stood on his stool so he wouldn't be off the mark but could still stand up. He wound up falling off the stool and it was AWESOME!
Eddie is one of the greatest frontman ever.
hell yes!
My opinion, this is my all time favorite version of this song. It’s an extremely personal song to Vedder. I love it because it’s raw and he is able to make you FEEL this song. Watch his body language during specific lyrics of the song. This song, this version, especially the lyrics Eddie just off the cuff added at the end of the song…damn.
This is a ten in my humble opinion. Just like the name of the album
Your not alone. David letterman had it stuck in his head for years. Mentioned it when he inducted them into the Rock hall of fame. And here’s a bit from the late show.
ruclips.net/video/HwmlzDaRoI4/видео.html
With the exception of the improvised lyrics at the end, the song here is very similar to the studio version. As for the background vocals, the audience takes care of that at their shows 😜
You are 100 percent wrong. MTV unplugged is suppose to be subdued even the vocals. It’s live and acuity played. It’s a different feel. They are supposed to sound exactly as they are playing. Hands down the best live performance in music
Subscribers going strong!! 2k in two days salute David!!
This is actually better than the album version.
7.8??????????? 🤔
No song with the lyric "I know someday you'll have a beautiful life. I know you'll be a star in somebody else's sky, but why? Why? Why? Can't it be, can't it be mine?" Should ever get less than a 9.
I joke, but in all seriousness, musical taste is musical taste. You have no need to apologize for that.
The background vocals sound very similar on the studio version. My ear is not sharp enough to say definitively if it's identical, but damn close.
I have not perceived any of these live performances as low energy. More subdued than jumping around on stage like they did during Pink Pop? Sure. But a song like Black (one of the great break up songs of all time) is a song about mood and emotion. It would have been bizarre and out of place if it were played with that kind of energy.
I suppose one area of friendly disagreement is that when I consume music I primarily do it for the music. What I mean by that is first, second, third, and fourth on my checklist is how did I like the song. Do I want to hear it again? Does it speak to me? Perhaps its because when I listen to music, 9 times out of 10 I don't have the video. I'm in my car or on an ipod, etc..
I love live concerts because they bring out the variations in songs. And when I am actually there, it gives me a chance to connect with the band in person. I agree that when a band plays the notes without trying to connect it falls flat. But I don't need the guys jumping around for the connection. The call and answers, the eye contact with people in the crowd. Changing facial expressions all do the trick.
And I think one other thing to take into consideration from live clips is that PJ shows are typically well over 2 hours. Some over 3 hours. In the audience you feel the energy ebb and flow. The songs themselves have ups and downs. It's hard to evaluate the energy of a performance overall from a single song. In fact we have seen videos where you paused early and commented on something (in this video it was Eddie's subdued vocals) only to see the song pull a 180.
Once again, thanks for the reaction. Good stuff.
I think they are going flat intentionaly to make the audience feel how pain and sorrow can anihilate life. It's genius and a masterpiece. I'm french so I can't understand the lyrics like an american will but anyone on this planet can feel how emotional that sound is.
I really appreciated this reaction video and I have watched many. I usually end up skipping the talking parts after a few seconds but I listened to the whole thing. Don't agree with everything but respect your perspective. Will be watching more videos you do. Thanks.
Thank you Joe for the encouraging words I appreciate them, and thank you for having an open mind in regards to what I said about this performance.
I actually listened to the studio recording of this song after I posted this video, and the "do do do do do do do's" are about 5 -10 cents flat on the studio album as well.....which means they are intentionally going flat on purpose. As I said in the review, if they're doing that intentionally, then that's absolutely BRILLIANT!!! Singing that part intentionally slightly flat makes it stick out, which makes it memorable....and it worked. TRUST ME It worked...it's been over a week since I filmed that reaction and I STILL have those "do do do do do do do's" stuck in my head. So kudos to Pearl Jam for coming up with that idea and executing it so amazingly well.
Just out of curiosity, if you don't mind me asking, what persuaded you to watch the whole thing? Thank you again for watching, hope you enjoyed the show.
DH
You pronounced the name correctly. Thanks for doing this review. I think you’ll change your tune on a few opinions after listening to the studio version...I’m guessing you already have. In the end though, it’s all about your own musical preferences and that’s why we come to your channel. I already have my opinion and want to hear YOUR opinion. I like that you dove into the background vocals at the end of the song. It’s a signature of this song that people tend to love or hate without even knowing what it is that they love or hate. They’ll stick with you regardless. That do do do do do do will be with you all day and into tomorrow. It might even pop up next week for no reason!
It's been with me since filming....that was 5 days ago. Also "It's o.k." is stuck in my head as well.
flat is on purpose. There are many flat notes in music. You can tell it is intentional when Eddie joins them. He hits the same notes. Intentionally.
RAW ORGANIC TALENT💚
It is intentional my friend. That is the way it is on the album version.
Actually you're right it is just ever so slightly flat on the studio version as well...which means it is in fact intentional. And as I said in my review, if it is intentional, then that's ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT. So kudos to them for doing so, mad props.
I did not like you at first. But now you are my bro. Keep up the work. Dude you are great.
Pearl Jam ❤❤❤❤
Haha David, I think you are the first person (after David Letterman) that talks about the doodoodoo part for more than 2 minutes 😅, thats why we all like you. Keep coming man! Speaking of Jim Morrison, Eddie did a great renditions of Jim when he fronted the reunited the Doors back in 93. But since your new rules, I can't request another one until my previous get fulfilled, maybe someone else's could 😊
Ohhhhhhhhh.....I have a feeling you're gonna be pretty happy in the next couple of days.....
Eddie's voice is so colorful and attractive. I don't know about the technique, I doubt he took singing lessons, but his innate talent created an amazing and unique vocal style which catches the attention and excites.
If you wanna see energy during an acoustic show watch state of love and trust, jeremy, or porch from this same set. Nobody rocked unplugged like pearl jam. This song is just a more subdued song. The studio is electric but not exactly a rocker. Although other live versions end with the most amazing solos by mr. Mike Mccready that I'm sure you would really enjoy.
This song is intense AF
Great reaction.I love this version because I think it portrays the heartbreak Eddie is experiencing in the video
Watch the whole video. They bring it on everything they do ❤️🔥
Dave Abruzesse on drums. Best move PJ ever made was hiring him. Unfortunately, their worst move was firing him only 2 albums later. His work on Vs is legendary and he brought such energy to this band live. Matt Cameron was probably the best they could do as a replacement, but Dave will always remain the best musician Eddie ever played with.
my favorite song has already turned 30 and Eddie is amazing!!! 🖤
He had a really bad cold that night aswell
Disagree with that rating - lowballed it. But enjoyed the review
I am NOT a huge Pearl Jam fan. This song is f#cking AMAZING, and for me easily their best.
Hey buddy, I'm pretty sure you know Sepultura from Brazil, if you don't, I'd be glad to introduce you n see you making a rection video. Attitude live in Barcelona, mind freaking...
I'm pretty sure the doo doo doo doo doo doo doos sounded basically the same as they always do. Eddie does them on the studio version and the tune isn't noticeably different to my non-musician ear. This is one of my favourite songs because of the lyrics and the depth of emotion, but if that's not your thing, it's not your thing. I love a lot of PJ's slower songs and acoustic stuff but I suspect you wouldn't be into them.
Yes, that's how it sounds on the record.
They clearly drop down right at the end of that note deliberaty, its supposed to be a haunting refrain. You think they're completely in tune but randomly go flat at exactly the same point every single time?, and it just so happens its in a way that works with the song... Dude, you're wrong 100%
Just do a little experiment, sing that bit to yourself and don't drop down at the end, it doesn't work at all.
It was exactly as planned except for playing on rented instruments because theirs didn't get there on time. It was intentional. The audience now sings that part because this song is known worldwide. You must have been living under a rock to have missed it. It's still huge 30 years later. Buskers do it like crazy. I can't believe you overlooked the note Eddie held just to argue the flat of the chorus.
Check out "State of Love and Trust" from the same show. And "Porch" is crazy too.
And yes to what was said below. Manzarek hand picked Eddie to sing for The Doors when they were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. It's all on RUclips.
Well I was very distracted by the pitch, but like I said it was consistently like 10 - 15 cents flat....which isn't a lot, but it is noticeable. I just listened to the studio version yesterday, and it's flat on the studio recording as well...which leads me to believe my theory is correct. They intentionally are slightly flat on purpose....which is absolutely BRILLIANT!!! So kudos to PJ for having the foresight to break from tradition and intentionally sing just slightly off key...it actually worked and made the "do do do do do do do's" extremely memorable. I filmed this 5 days ago....and that part is STILL stuck in my head....along with "It's O.k." that I did a while back.
As far as The Doors performance goes.....keeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep watching....especially over the next 3 days.....
@@THEDavidHeretic 🤣 The stuff about David Letterman getting that chorus stuck in his head is pretty funny and he brings it up at their induction into the Rock and Roll HoF so you are not the only one. This song is just so ubiquitous I'm surprised you've missed it. I've heard orchestras cover it. I've heard it in various languages. I've heard a death metal version, etc. 😁 Everywhere...
@@christianeflentie1228 I went out of my way to avoid PJ like the plague. Whenever my brother would play it in his room I would either put in headphones and blast Metallica, or I would leave the house. I was a metal snob, still am to some extent...but now I'm open to other genres.
❤❤❤
I expect you’ll change your tone in the second part :) it gets intense. Amazing performance.
Solid!
Also "evenflow" official video is high energy you will like it. It is also on the MTV unplugged set.
I've seen that video several times...I'll never forget the look on Riki Rachtman's face when he introduced the video on Headbangers Ball...he looked like someone told him his dog died. It was a good video, better song honestly. Doesn't belong on Headbangers Ball, but it was a really good song.
The only thing that surprises me about this is the fact that a “rocker” has never heard this song. Seriously, you are a middle aged man that is into rock that has never heard Black by Pearl Jam. That is very sad.
I avoided bands like Pearl Jam, Nirvana, and Soundgarden in the 90's like the plague. I was really into prog and jazz during that time, and I had no interest in the "grunge" movement at all. One of the great things about doing this channel is it has forced me to check them out, and I'm glad it did.
Yes the flat is on purpose.
Yes it is, I heard it on the studio recording too. That's ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!! What an ingenious way to make those stand out and be memorable.
@@THEDavidHeretic Absolutely right! And as you said it was the "🎶Do do doot do do da doo🎶" that would always stick in my head throughout the years everytime I listened to it.
They are singing the correct intentional notes. It’s a sad song so the minor/dissonant sound is purposeful. Eddie was actually sick during this show, and you’re right that in comparison his voice was slightly thin. But you try singing that well, sick. I’ll wait.
@@MsLeemills Naaaaaaah been there done that....happened in Europe while we were touring in Austria and Hungary. Luckily it started to clear up right as we got into Slovakia. The only time I ever got sick on tour...man did it suck.
Flat is not what it is, it's full of emotion from start to finish. Vocal coaches have reviewed this video and they never say they're flat so idk maybe it's a matter of taste? Not every song has to start heavy and end heavy for it to be heard or felt. This performance is absolutely beautiful. Btw new sub here! Keep up the good work
Awesome Elyse, welcome to The Fanbase, glad to have you among us.
Hey David. You really need to do a reaction to the version of Black they played at Atlanta in 1994, that's the best non-unplugged version you'll find.
The ad-lib at the end from 4:35 onwards is fantastic, Eddie and Mike both on fire.
ruclips.net/video/_hXYzHlevvs/видео.html
This is an older upload, so you've probably already watched the studio version at some point. But, this song is meant to grow on you. Because I'm soo in tune with every note of the song, I can recognize all the subtle greatness that each note brings in this lower volume acoustic version. In the studio version each note is much more audible. There's also a piano added that added to the atmosphere. But eventhough, this is really organic feeling, it's extremely precise, delicately precise. Every note contributes to the emotion and buildup.
But I gotta push back with the energy thing. There was nothing challenging about Eddie's energy. He was in a trance and was completely singing out of raw emotion.
Also, this has a hook if you listen more. This is a must acquired taste. Some songs you can't just say not my taste and move on. This is one of them. The build up and crescendo of this song will grab you. The raw yet precise emotions in sync with the structure of the song will grab you. Trust me.
Check out the doors induction to RRHOF Vedder plays with living member of Doors, 91 or 92.
.....keeeeeeeeeeeeep watching.....all I can say....
Nice review, saw others hit same points on the do do do parts sticking in your head like with Letterman. Funny story, one time going to the river I played this album in the truck with Dad, let’s just say he wasn’t a fan. But he would comment and the do do do’s was one that stuck, whenever I would mention PJ he would bring that up 😂. This is a sad song, ultimate break up song, think the lyrics and feeling by Eddie when he sings it is what really gets people behind this song. As far as going flat I believe it is on purpose to give that emotional sad tone to compliment the lyrics. Eddie did this song as a tribute for Chris Cornell after he passed where he breaks down crying at the we belong together part at the end. There is always a lot of emotion from Eddie and the band in this song. I know you are focusing a lot on the technical parts, but afterwards I would recommend grabbing a drink sitting back and relax, crank up the sound, and just enjoy it as well without the camera.
Yes they sound the same in recording 👍
Yes they do, so brilliant. That made them memorable...I still have those "do do do do do do do's" stuck in my head
Can’t believe you’ve never heard this.? Wtf?
I intentionally avoided these guys throughout high school and beyond....just ask my brother, he's one of the biggest PJ fans around....I would put on headphones or leave the house whenever he started playing Pearl Jam in his room.
@@THEDavidHeretic why? To avoid something that might have been too mainstream?
@@Metallnsanity87 No it was because Pearl Jam had been classified by the masses as grunge, and I couldn't stand grunge music. Long story short, I heard Nirvana's "Smells Like Teen Spirit", and I couldn't stand it, and I said to myself "If this is what Grunge music is gonna sound like, I don't want any part of it". I'm actually really glad I started this channel because it's forcing me to give Pearl Jam a chance, and I'm actually really glad it is.
@@THEDavidHeretic in that case, I hope you didn't do the same with Alice In Chains..? AIC is the most metal-ish of the big grunge bands.. If you haven't heard them, you definitely should
@@Metallnsanity87 I actually really dug Alice In Chains. I remember seeing the music video for "We Die Young" on Headbangers Ball and I really dug it. loved their first album Facelift, and I reeeeeally dug Dirt. They came on the scene right before the term "grunge" was a thing, so I never really considered them grunge.
You got guts for being critical of Pearl Jam with they're hardcore fan base but I commend you lol even if I'm in part of the Jamly
Just being honest....for the record I did go listen to the studio version, and they do the "do do do do do do do's" slightly flat on the record as well. Which means my suspicions were true...they're intentionally singling flat on purpose. As I stated in the video, if that's the case (which it is) that is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT. So yes, they are brilliant for doing that....because it makes it memorable. It makes it stick in your head.....and it has...for over 2 months now...I'd like to get a decent nights sleep....and I can't....because those "do do do do do do do's" are running around in my head and WON'T STOP!!! AAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHH. No seriously in all seriousness they really are stuck in my head still to this day. So yes, mission accomplished Pearl Jam.
The more I listen to them, the more I'm appreciating them and what they do.
@@THEDavidHeretic I love the honesty because its feels sincere! So many channels just claim to love everything requested for the clicks and likes. You give a sincere take that's true to you and I honestly do commend you for that. I will be watching more videos!
Thank you for the encouraging words,, they mean a lot to me. That's been my goal since I started this channel. I want this channel to be different. No fake reactions, no begging for clicks and subs. Just real, genuine, 100% honest content. Welcome to the channel, I hope you enjoy the show.
The time to REWIND it is during the :kids" part
Eddie could forget all of the words to every song and he'd still sound great.
The one guy on the internet who didn’t quite get it. This is regarded as one of the all time best live performances. I love this guy’s passion though. He just took a little too analytical view at this and missed the emotion
Listen to him sang whit the doors at 1993, the doors induction into Hall of rock, it's really interesting, he made 3 Doors songs with them
Oh I know, I did a reaction to the performance of Roadhouse Blues. Here's the link so you can check it out: ruclips.net/video/ZZ6zaTBfJLM/видео.html
I'll check it out
I have heard the discussion before about the background guys being exactly flat every time and yes it was purposeful and I agree brilliant
I’m sure this has been answered, but I am pretty sure it is intentional and the same on the recorded version.
Yes it is, I listened to the recorded version afterwards and sure enough...they're doing it there as well. Absolutely brilliant. It's STILL stuck in my head....2 months later.
@@THEDavidHeretic It's one of my favorites from Pearl Jam, just a beautiful tune.
The bassist and rhythm guitarist backup vocals are based on the piano melody of producer Rick Parasher's piano part in the original production. The flat notes are by design. Pearl Jam's album "Ten" is one of the best five rock n roll albums of all time. If you are missing the point, perhaps you should reevaluate your perspective. Godspeed.
....did you miss the part where I said "If that's intentional, it's BRILLIANT?"
8.3 .. that's a score!
No stopping
I have to pause now and then, otherwise it will get blocked. Trust me if I didn't have to pause I wouldn't.
Exactly lol same as recorded
I don’t think it’s going flat it’s pretty much the way the track is
So it could be intentional then...that's brilliant if that's the case. I'm gonna have to check out the studio version and compare.
Checked out the studio version. They're flat on it as well....which leads me to believe they intentionally go slightly flat on purpose....which is absolutely GENIUS!!! It made the "do do do do do do do's" extremely memorable, they've been stuck in my head since I filmed this, and that was 5 days ago. So big kudos to PJ for doing that on purpose, it worked like a charm.
Lol...he gets there, dont worry.
You go on unplugged and have a take? You must have a band?
I do, I'm actually involved in several musical projects and bands. Personally I would never want to go on a show like Unplugged....too many rules and restrictions, we wouldn't be able to be ourselves.
You want energy?
Maximum the Hormone - Alien
I'll need a link so I watch the correct video
Watch it again
The whole show was very high energy but Black is not a high energy song.
Eddie had a chest infection and they had only that day to rehearse the show before taping. If you watch the entire show in one sitting I think you’ll enjoy it.
I was a little bothered by how much you were stuck on the backing vocals and seemed to completely miss the raw emotion pouring out of Eddie.
Sorry you were bothered by what you think you heard, I suggest going back and listening to what I said a little more carefully. I very clearly stated..."If these backing vocals are intentionally 5 - 10 cents flat....then that is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!! That makes them stand out....which makes them memorable." I started out being critical, but the more I heard them I started to realize they were consistently flat every single time.....which led me to wonder if it was intentional. THAT'S why the "do do do do do do do's" are the part that stick in everyones mind....and THAT'S what creates the HOOK....and THAT is what makes the song memorable. THAT right there is PURE GENIUS!
@@THEDavidHeretic I get that and appreciate it, it’s just such an emotional performance and I felt like you missed that is all.
@@jamjar5525 Alright you seem like an intelligent human being...can I ask your honest opinion on something?
@@THEDavidHeretic please
@@jamjar5525 I'm contemplating either doing a reshoot of this, or shooting a review the studio version. Call it a mulligan. Which would go over better from a viewers perspective? Redoing the Unplugged show, or a fresh look at the studio recording?
Please listen to "Jeremy" both versions uncut official video and the mtv unplugged. Will definitely give you something to talk about.
It's based on a true story.
I'm actually very familiar with that song. It was in heavy rotation on MTV back in the day when MTV ACTUALLY aired music videos. Unfortunately I can't do a reaction video to that, since I have heard the song and seen the video.
@@THEDavidHeretic how about just breathe official. Beautiful song
@@lionesslion5863 I'll look into it. Thank you for the suggestion.
@@THEDavidHeretic you dont have to call it a "reaction" but call it a review if you listen to it?
@@nukchuu1 .....keeeeeeeeeeeeep watching...all I can say....
LOL....all PJ songs have more energy. They are def not an “unplugged” band. You should check out Porch from Pink Pop🤣
however this was a greaaaaaaat performance. I think it was actually pretty risky for them to do this unplugged considering their usual shows back then and they nailed it.
I wasn’t particularly a grunge fan back then but you gotta hand it to Eddie , Chris Cornell and Layne Staley.. what a vocal talent each of them were! Chris was just outstanding. You should check out Hunger Strike by Temple of the Dog
Heh heh....must be new to the channel. It's all good, welcome to the channel. I actually already did a reaction for both of those suggestions. Here's Porch: ruclips.net/video/UfqiYw03tuY/видео.html and here's Hunger Strike: ruclips.net/video/bh48AS6NWlg/видео.html
@@THEDavidHeretic oh dang! Sorry... I didn’t see it. I will check it out!
@@ginao8935 It's all good, enjoy the show.
I do like the studio version much better, but the raw emotions in this, seeing him preform, compensate.
Sounds like that on the album.
Really
Good review...rating low but everyone has their own opinion. Check out Porch unplugged...Eddie with the Doors is pretty cool too. Always enjoy your reactions thanks.
Its like i was watching another video...........
I never understood who the woman was that didnt want to be the sun in Eddie Vedders sky...like what us wrong with you lady. Lol...yes they do go flat in the recording I think.
Is
I have loved PJ since i first heard this album in 1991, i was 16 then. but also GnR UYI 1&2, Soundgarden Badmotorfinger, RHCP blood sugar sex majik, Ozzy No More tears just a few that had awesome albums that year. If you want some emotion to this song, you need to listen to his performance @ Firenze Rocks in june of 2017 just a month after his good friend Chris Cornell passed away.. its just him his electric guitar and the audience.. he almost breaks down while singing it. not asking you to react to it but maybe listen on your own time. ruclips.net/video/IfmKAkVfvgA/видео.html anyways thanks good reaction be safe cioa for now
Pearl jam black from pistoia 2006
It’s sounds a little kinda sad - a breakup song? The words were very err metaphoric (thanks pops - not real sure what that means) not really my kinda song I’m a happy person and haven’t got to the stage of havin breakups yet so it’s it’s sad 3.2 from me and that flat singin was hurtin my ears didn’t like that bit
It is a grunge thing, the intentionally dirty notes.
How dare you!!!
he had a sever chest cold
I think you have heard all these songs and just pretending you have never heard these PJ songs.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion. My brother can vouch for the fact that I never intentionally, knowingly, or willingly heard these songs. If I recognize the songs from some other form of media, such as movies or television, them I make sure to mention that during the video.
Yeah he hated PJ because I was obsessed, and it wasn’t his style of music. Of course I used to hate his stuff too till I got older. It’s actually pretty awesome that he created this channel because he is having to listen from the requests, and I am feeling vilified from all those years telling him to give PJ a try 😂
@@timothydavid4565 Ohhhhhhhh shaddup don't rub it in.
Too long with pauses, especially since you weren't familiar with the song. You failed to really get the meaning of the song. Hey is this flat on purpose let me know in the comments and hit play. Unfortunately one of the few reactions for this song that didn't do it proper justice.
How can I do an HONEST reaction to a song if I'm already familiar with it? That makes absolutely no sense.
I made it very clear, I had never heard this song before, so of course I wasn't familiar with it.
He actually got the lyrics wrong in this version.
It's his lyrics. He can't really get them wrong
Love your videos.
Not to be a jerk or anything, but could you please don't use that kind of background, don't know how many share my phobia about clusters of small black holes. Excerpt from wiki: "Trypophobia is an aversion to the sight of irregular patterns or clusters of small holes or bumps."
That background is freaking me out.
Yikes sorry about that. I'll do my best.
Thanks. =)
Worst review ever this is one of the best live vocal performances from any 90s band you are literally the only channel I’ve heard with any criticism just saying
Talking about the Guitarist singing flat meanwhile you have an epic live performance from Eddie Vedder going on in the background talk about dropping the ball LOL
I am literally shaking my head I don’t understand your reaction have you seen other people react to this video night and day
I'm guessing you didn't watch the entire video, especially the part where I very clearly stated "it sounds like they're 5 - 10 cents flat EVERY SINGLE TIME"...followed up with "I wonder if they're doing that ON PURPOSE"...followed up with "If they are intentionally going 5 - 10 cents flat every single time, then that is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!!"...followed by "If they're going flat on purpose that is BEYOND BRILIANT...because that will make that part MEMORABLE, due to the fact that it will STAND OUT!!!" Later, on my own, I listened to the studio recorded version of this same song. I discovered that they do, in fact, go intentionally flat on the studio recording....thus proving my theory correct. They are BRILLIANT for going intentionally flat on those parts, because it DID make it stand out...thus making it memorable. To this day I STILL have that part rattling around in my head. So kudos to Pearl Jam for having the foresight to do something absolutely brilliant, and make it work.
You say I'm "literally the only channel I’ve heard with any criticism just saying" Have you ever asked yourself...why every other "reactor" out there "loves" this song? Better yet, why every other "reactor" seems to "love" every single song they hear, or video they watch? It's very simple...because all they care about is getting their numbers up. They don't care if they're honest, they don't care about their integrity, all they care about is getting as many subscribers as possible so they can get monetized. They do this by making sure they "love" everything they hear and see...thus making all the people who watch their reaction video happy...thus getting another subscriber based completely on a lie. I refuse to be like that. I will never give a fake reaction and say that I love something, when I actually don't like it, just so I can get more subscribers. I'm not in this to get monetized, I'm not here to lie to the people. I'm hear to give the viewers, especially The Fanbase, something different: a reaction channel that is ACTUALLY honest and genuine in it's reactions. As I have always said, I would much rather have 500 Fanbase members who actually love what I do, than 500,000 subscribers who joined up based on a lie, and who honestly don't care about what I said...as long as they were happy with the lie. Just saying...
I know every other "reactor" "loves" this song, and offer absolutely no insight into their reactions....mainly because they have no insight or knowledge to be able to delve into anything musical. As a professional musician of over 30 years, who has studied music since the age of 3, I choose to do the opposite. I choose to use my 40+ years of knowledge in music, and my 30+ experience in the music industry, and put them to good use. I choose to be objective, and look at music and performances from a musicians and performers standpoint. I choose to give credit where credit is due, and to point out where it's not due...in the realms of theory, musicianship, execution, pitch, tone, chordal structure, use of time signatures, tempo, and dynamics.
I have seen other "reactors" do this video...the same "reactors" that "love" every single thing they watch. Sorry I'm just not going to be like that. I have said from the beginning of this channel that I will ALWAYS be honest in my reactions, and I will never give fake reactions or opinions about what I watch and hear, just so I get my subscriber numbers up. What I will offer is genuine, honest reactions...as well as some insight as to why I made the decisions.
In closing, allow me to apologize for hurting your feelings. I know the truth sometimes can be quite painful to hear, and I'm sorry that I insulted your emotional status by being honest about what I saw and heard. I can only imagine how traumatizing it must have been to hear someone actually give an honest opinion about a band you love, as well as a song you love. I recommend enjoying those other channels, who "love" every single thing they see and hear, and are willing to lie to their viewers just so they can get another subscriber. I will not change what I do, who I am, or how I react to what I see and hear. I will not insult the intelligence of the viewers with fake reactions, or lie to them just so I can boost my numbers. Lastly I will not compromise my own integrity, because in the end that's all a man is worth.
DH
@@THEDavidHeretic David you didn't hurt my emotional status I'm not even a big Pearl Jam fan but I am a very talented musician like yourself........ if I'm being honest Pearl Jam completely sucks from 2000 all the way to 2020 !!!!!!
10 was great Vitalogy was a little different versus sounded like it was recorded in someone's garage with cheap equipment and in fact I think it actually was.....?????? I stopped listening after no code
I also think Eddie Vedder completely fried his voice in the 90s he literally sounds like a billy goat giving birth in 2020
so I'm not a fanboy but if I was I could handle someone criticizing a band that I happen to like......
And if you would have done a little research most of the band members had a very bad cold this night they were actually filling in for Mariah Carey of all people and they had been on a very long tour but still delivered an amazing performance.........
All I'm saying is I have heard you react to other recent Pearl Jam live performances and you were totally digging it ???????
but then you kind of shrug your shoulders at this incredible 90s performance....... and I've also heard other professional musicians react to this particular song in a completely positive way with little to no criticism because it was damn near Perfect by the way well I got you on the line LOL react to Masters of War at the Bob Dylan tribute just give that a listen
and I also have integrity and I'm just being honest
And by the way my issue with your reaction isn't the fact that you said they sounded intentionally flat and that's brilliant ........ I guess I just expected to see a seasoned musician show a little more respect to a great live performance
@@THEDavidHeretic ?
@@NocturnalNews Fair enough. Thank you for responding with an actual mind of your own and having reasoning behind your defense, and not just being some "fanboy" who got butthurt over some constructive criticism of their favorite song. I sincerely appreciate it.
I actually did react to Masters Of War, and it got blocked worldwide by SME. I was able to put it up on my Patreon page if you would like to check it out.
Again, thank you for responding with a mind of your own, and not just being some trolling fanboy, I really do appreciate it.
@@THEDavidHeretic cool no problem and by the way love the channel I've watched damn near every video sorry to hear about masters of War that was one of my favorites
And I will check out the patreon
And as I mentioned they were filling in for Mariah Carey so this was thrown together last minute and they still did a pretty good job this was their first real live acoustic performance other than the bridge benefit concert
What the actual fuck..You rave about KISS..and the say that one of the best performances of MTV unplugged is, flat, held back and the two other band members are off pitch. And KISS is great I guess..WTF, I don't get this world anymore.
Not quite what I said. I actually said I was disappointed in the KISS Unplugged show. There was no energy in that show, no stage presence. It was boring, other than when Ace and Peter came out.
Yes I did say it was held back...as is every other acoustic show. Due to the fact that they are all sitting, playing acoustic instruments, in a small intimate setting...of course it's going to be held back. This is why I've never been a fan of the Unplugged series, it's just not my thing. I prefer live shows with lots of energy, crowd interaction, and intensity.
Yes, the guys singing the "do do do do do do do's" were flat by about 5 - 10 cents. That is undeniable. I also stated that since it was consistent and constant, it MAY be intentional...meaning they are singing 5 - 10 cents flat on purpose. I also stated that if they are in fact sing flat like that intentionally, then that is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT! That made the "do do do do do do do's" stick out, which in turn made them extremely memorable. I still have that part stuck in my head, and it's been well over a week since I filmed that reaction. So I listened to the studio version of this song, turns out my suspicions were correct they do sing those "do do do do do do do's" intentionally flat. Not to the point that it sounds bad, only 5 - 10 cents flat...just enough to stick out and be noticeable, thus making it MEMORABLE.
For the record, I NEVER said the performance was bad, or poor, or that it sucked. I understand you want to defend a band you absolutely love, but please understand I never put them down. Quite the opposite actually, I paid them a number of compliments...just as I have in all my other Pearl Jam reaction videos.
In closing I hope this clears up any confusion you may have had, in regards to anything you may have misunderstood. In the future, before you decide to jump on anyone, please make sure you actually heard what you think you heard, and not what you wanted to hear.
DH
I'm in the definite minority, but I don't really like this version. Eddie's voice is shot, he messes up the lyrics... the emotion and delivery is great, but not a fan of most of the rest.
Lots purposely
god man what do you know these guys are awesome you are so negative bet you would not say this to Eddie
First off, how is what I'm saying negative? You must have missed the part where I said "If this is intentional, then that's ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!" That's right, I called them brilliant, because I did listen to the studio version, and they are intentionally doing the "do do do do do do do's" about 5-10 cents flat. Like I said, that makes it stick out, which makes it MEMORABLE. Absolutely Brilliant. I always make sure to mention the aspects that I enjoy, as well as the parts I wasn't a fan of.
Secondly, I would be more than happy to say exactly what I said in the video to Eddie in person. I've never been one to shy away from speaking my mind and voicing my opinion, especially in person. That way the person hears it directly from me, which would eliminate hearsay.
Lastly, it's clear to me that you have not watched all the videos of Pearl Jam that I have done so far. If you had, you would see that I have given them WAY more compliments than criticisms. I estimate a 4:1 ratio of compliments to criticisms, so they have absolutely earned my respect as musicians, songwriters, and performers.
You're probably not used to reactors on RUclips actually being honest and giving their honest opinions and thoughts on what they watch. Sorry, but I'm not going to be one of those fake reactors who love every single thing they see and hear. I'm going to give my honest opinion and thoughts about everything I watch and hear. The good news is, if you don't like what I do, there are literally hundreds of fake reactors you can watch and enjoy, who are all more than happy to lie to you to make you happy so you'll subscribe to their channel...because that's all they care about. Feel free to enjoy them, and please be happy.
DH
Pearl Jam ❤❤❤❤