[Documentary/다큐멘터리] Kumari: The Sacred Anchor (Eng, 한국자막)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 авг 2024
- Bournemouth University Graduate Project 2017. Documentary 'The Sacred Anchor: Kumari'.
Director: Solip Im
Camera: Serafina Pang
PM: Abigail Thurston
Editor: Solip Im
*Working on making the Japanese subtitle. Thank you for your patience.
Most of the people are complaining about the animal's sacrifice in this footage.
I wanna ask them "have you ever thought about these sentiments while putting non-veg items on the corner of your plate in the meal time? Are all these chickens, muttons, beef, porks are grown in the trees? "
We never complain about your traditions like 'burn soul in hell' or " Burkas" then why are you?
Enjoy your own traditions and lets us do our own.
I do worship her as a god and always forever.
Just ignore those hypocrites, they complain about animals being killed but at the same time they eat the meat without thinking twice.
You are right...
👌👌👌
"Burkhas" is not even comparable to animal sacrifice. No one is being harmed when people wear burkha, but the cruelty against animal is in no way justifiable. Our tradition, on the contrary, HARMS defenseless animals. How can you compare killing animals to simply covering oneself( I am not even going to start on "burn the soul in hell" which makes no sense). I agree traditions should be respected, but the ones that are outright inhumane and merciless for petty selfish reasons should be called out. Traditions doesn't justify thousands of animal's life taken.
very true.....agreed
Say Whatever... but when the mature Kumari spoke... she oozed so much of positivity... I felt like I was watching a Goddess in human form following her regular life as a human
I would like to request to the Government of Nepal & Kumari selection committee, Kumari must get scholarship in their education. ( Higher education) even after her retirement from Kumari house.
Yes
But if someone will stay whole life kumari or she spend her life for those kind of education then her life will be damage
@@ChonzeTaraa first of all you should know about Kumari. Kumari starts from age of 4- to age of late 11 yrs old, before her menstruation. Before her menstruation she had been replaced by new Kumari. Old Kumari will stay with their parents after retirement from Kumari House. She got the huge respect from the country,while she was as Kumari Goddess, after her retirement from Kumari she was treated as a normal person. So if the Government or Kumari Selection Committee provide scholarship, it will be the best... as a respect of Kumari.
Yeah
@@JamesBond-eh6xz just giving you an information because you told that being Kumari is from age 4 to late 11. actually there is a Kumari till now who has not got her menstruation till now but she was given the option to choose being a normal person but she told that she is gonna live the life of being goddess. And she is now about 65 years old 🗝️.
Thank you all the viewers for the comments and interest in this video.
It was my graduation project in 2017 so it would be grateful if you’d be generous about any mistakes found from the film! And I can see some are not enjoying the music. I didn’t have much knowledge of Nepalese copyright at that time. So I asked a fixer in Kathmandu to humming one of the famous songs in Nepal on location. I didn’t want to get in trouble in copyright issue (I cannot just download any songs from RUclips!). I am sorry if the music might disturb you but still hope you enjoy the story itself. Thank you!!
The music is lovely. I enjoy her singing. It’s very relaxing & soothing. 😊
The music was very beautiful and fit the subject of the film very well. Very good work for a graduation project. You did a good job of showing both the positive and negative aspects of the tradition and its impact on the girls.
@@cincocats320 Thank you for your comment :)
@@Keiri12 Thank you for your comment! :)
Man! who choose this background music?
I was a bit scared at first 😅😅😅
Am I the only one who liked the music and found it peaceful??!!
We worship kumari as a goddess which is much better than girls who are being raped and abused in other part of the world. I have visited kumari myself and she is like any other girl;she plays, laughs, smiles however when she changes into her sacred attire and sits on her sacred throne, she changes to a goddess. Completely different personality. And no she is not deprived of her education, she gets education not in school but in kumari house.
Patan has been in so many documentaries! Only five days to adapt to the real world is a tall order. I pray her mental state is a calm and accepting her role is over.
I loved and enjoyed the humming.... It made me to feel something on my mind...
you can listen the original song "Timi jun raharle mamaa bhulna aayau sabai khushi harai sadhai dukha paayau...." by late Narayan Gopal Gurubachaya too in youtube.
졸업작픔이라곤 믿기지 않는 퀄리티네요! 방송사 다큐멘터리인줄 알았습니다
덕분에 좋은 다큐멘터리 한 편 알고 가요!
하민지 감사합니다!
यो हाम्रो परम्परा हो जिउँदो देउता कसैले पनि नराम्रो नसोच्नु र नराम्रो कमेन्ट नगर्दीनु होला
"for the sake of Sita"
read that webtoon if you're interested in this
the art is one of the best
edit: um...incase y'all didn't know, I'm a nepali myself lol
Yuss !! It's awesome !!
A must read webtoon.
Yes it's good, but be careful it had lots of misinformation .
I'm Nepali
It was amazing now the anime is on it is comin soon
@@palzomlama4761 ikr i'm so excited to finally see it. I seriously hope they get a nepali to write the parts in nepali instead of something that sounds like google translate lol
that ha ha ha ha sound sucks great song but that ha ha ha sound makes it horror
Thats one of the songs sang by our Late Narayan Gopal. Shut ur fking gob ! Asshole !
Alone Exploer hahahha😂😂
아버지 살짝 눈가가 촉촉해지셨어 그래두 딸이 저렇게 멀어져서 지내야한다는게 슬플것같기두하공
Its a ritual,I understand...but to be honest to say, its like crippling a child deliberately...not letting a child to live a normal life for 5-7 years and then just asking her to grow all of a sudden like the others.....similar ritual is also there in Hinduism, but its only for 1 day,Durga astami,nd only for few hours, when 'kumari puja' is performed...
The child chooses it. It's like saying to a young Christian child, you are too young to be saved and baptized. No, they aren't they can consent to that spiritual ritual. Likewise, the Kumari can consent to this spiritual ritual.
Did your ears stopped working when the previous Kumaris were speaking?
And then 2 days after the kumari of Kathmandu .. retires
Kamari doesn't retired until she have her first period and the chossen in a very small age
What's up with the music? It's so disturbing 😥😥
Tshesang Tamang exactly like its some sort of disappointing,vicious video, kasto creepy background music haldira
@@nehashrestha3894 that's what💀
Music name?
3:50 in nepali he doesnot even mention slender body but the comment "........slender body,etc"
Diwa Ghimire it was mentioned but it was cut in edit... sorry i could not check properly thank you for your comment.
I feel bad for father😭❤
I don't think Kumari's father is happy .He is little sad bout the daughter .😢😢😢
저 딸이 망가지고 그녀의 아버지는 우실까?
Sound choice chahi milena jasto lagyo.... weak combination
We ll be bringing 9 young girls to our home this asthami to worship them as kumari for one day and offer food , gifts etc .
The mûsíç is wonderful
Very true! ❤️
also the words of the lyrics.
love this video love from Nepal. now, i would request you to make a video about the god indraJatra
02:45 - 03:03 was my favorite
This is what we are, proud of being nepali 🇳🇵
와 이게 졸업작품인가요....?정말 대단하네요.
Proud to be newar
For the Caucasian women that spoke. Was really rude as if its up to them. Not your religion, faith, tradition or country. I felt it was not needed for the video.
It's heart touching music...
The song is called “timi jun raharle ma maa ayau” by legendary late singer Narayan Gopal
I am from nepal 🇳🇵
Most of the people complaining about the footage where. They killed the animal like Bro don’t act like act like y’all see animal got kill and this festival only comes 1 a year so ... and y’all never eat animal , it’s our culture and please reap our culture 🙏🏼❤️
Do you mean every culture is right? Don't do what the people do we need to think before doing anything is it right or wrong if you are hindu then the bhagwat gita say don't harm other
Gelong Tara yea but I can’t stop them from doing that Iam not some kind of big person of Nepal to stop it that culture has been going through a long period of time so I can’t do anything to stop it 😭 if I could I will stop ....
@@ChonzeTaraa
Hinduism isnt only about Bhagwat geeta!
It is really diverse in itself!
And kathmandu or ancient Nepal is based on Tantricism so sacrifice and alcohol cant be missed in those rituals!
Can kumari marry the person they want ?? Or they are left alone for their lifetime??
Aadarsha kuinkel they can Rashmila the former kumari in the film has got married
They can but there is a saying where they say that if anyone marries a former kumari they would die within 6 months yet others have gotten married and their partners never died
I believe after they get there menstrual cycle they are no longer kumari
Yes
@@notyourhun6295 that's just rumor. They die they do but not because they are married to Kumari. Its because Kumari has more strong aura(something like that, I couldn't find the words) so if her spouse has aura weak than her then that might cause some problems
정말 잘봤습니다!
Animals are also a part of nature
True!
Offering god what he created is neither a sin! Being a Nepali is sin to u..such shame
KFC Khako Bela buff momos khako Bela sausages haru khako Bela tw animals are also part of nature wala khyal tw dimag ma tw aaudaina hola tw 🙄
@Yudhisthir Sharma oh mister Sharma tmy li chai k ko nakh thussa dukheko ni.
@Yudhisthir Sharma abo hunxa hola hoina veg KFC, and veg sausage .. ki taha xoina sausage vanneko
안녕하세요. Full 영상은 어떻게 볼 수 있을까요? 영상 구입처 링크가 있다면 알려주시면 감사합니다:)
늦게 연락 드려서 죄송합니다. 죄송하지만 이 영상은 이게 풀버전입니다 ㅠㅠ학교 졸업작품으로 만든 다큐멘터리라 15분 제한이 있었거든요.. 관심 가져주셔서 감사합니다!
풀버전을 만드려고 더 인터뷰 해놓은게 있는데 풀버전이 완성되면 이 채널에 업로드 하겠습니다! ㅎㅎ
@@solipim1010 와우... 졸업작품이라고 하기엔 퀄리티가 정말 좋네요.. 사실 BBC 이런 곳에서 찍은 다큐같아요... 졸업후 어느쪽으로 가실지는 모르겠지만 정말 기대가 되는 인물이라 생각해요 굿굿입니다! 댓글 고맙습니다ㅎㅎ
저야말로 이렇게 큰칭찬 해주셔서 감사합니다!! ㅎㅎ
네팔 놀러와요
WOW!
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I totally respect the culture but idk why i dont feel positivity in it . I m so sorry for keeping my opinion if it offended anyone .
I feel the same
Banseng namshum apparently the king also had sex with an underage girl and killed her. Its my sinister than u think symbolically
Jay kumari mata
11:45 truth
👌🤧🤘
Every westerner should listen this
Can i use this to explore about kumari....?
Ashok Puri absolutely! It’s my pleasure! But i would like you to research about this culture more by yourself, not just believing all information from this film.or visiting Nepal could be suggested :) thank you for the comment!
How is a person known in India as Kumari?!
Did you know?
I know. What kumari whoy not kumar puja
My father don't let me to be kumari
Rofl Frost he won’t cause there are many conditions to be kumari that only few girls have I also don’t have that feature being kumari is considered as the most luckiest thing in newari community no offense
I wish I could also be kumari
😆😆being Nepali i didn't knew there were two Kumari 😅😅
Haha same ...ani hindu Buddhist dubai ko vanera ni thathena. Hinduko culture jasto lagthyo!
Not just 2.but if you research you'll find that most of the traditional newar community/place have this tradition of kumari.but due to lack of media coverage and other reason we are not unaware of these tradition that are happening on other part of same community...
There are more than 8 kumari in the valley where basantapur patan and bhaktapur are considered royal with ganesh and bhairav as living god
If only this interview was conduct in her native language, later translated, it would not have been as contradictory as it is!
Mao ra. Afi you are god .
Thik you like tussinet taugami.
Afi you are god. Respect zen.
다음 작품 기다릴께요?
Woww
why is it cutted?
Name of background music please??😍😍😍👌
The song is called “timi jun raharle ma maa ayau” by legendary late singer Narayan Gopal
Is animal sacrifice good ???
Go ask that same question at your local McDonald's.
Save mother earth
Just because it's a tradition, it doesn't make it right. Education is knowledge and knowledge is power.
A bad fruit it's like a dead tree, it's only good to be cut down and thrown in the fire, so is a bad tradition.
When a bad habit isn't stopped at it's root, the bad cycle of stupidity and ignorance will produce nothing but poverty, problems and lots more likewise.
I pray in the name of Jesus, that many repent and come to accept only Jesus Christ as their Lord and Savior, the true Messiah of the whole world.
May God have mercy on us.
A mind is a terrible thing to waste.
"Take the plank out of your own eye first," sayeth The Lord.
@@joerobinette5397 Do you even believe in the Lord or His word? You are quick to preach but you don't practice it. Nice try hypocrite.
@@gloryhalleluiah4787
Of course I believe it. I was just pointing out that you are the hypocrite, and you should probably come down off your high horse, but that is between you and The Lord. Enjoy your afternoon in repentance and self reflection.
Hey youtube: this "Glory" person is a complete Islamaphobic BIGOT.
Funny how we rarely, or never, see Hindus or Buddhists invading the comments of some Christian video and running through the litany of what Lot and his two teenage daughters in that cave... Funny how Christians never talk about that either...
It's such a beautiful custom.
नमन🙏
will the goddess get me real wealthy caring female to save my physical life?please.
जहां करुणा दया अहिंसा नहीं वहा परमात्मा और उसका स्नैह कृपा नहीं जीव की जगह बली प्रथा को मानने वाले हिंसक क्रुर अपनी बलि क्यों नहीं देते धर्म के नाम पर अधर्म हाय हाय
아니...노래가 으흐흐으응 으흐흐으흐으흐으응
Kkkkkkk
앜ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
3:10 bish gave me karen vibes from what she said.😀🙄😐🤚
For kumary we no need to harm aninals
God gave one small jolt for them understand what they r doing is wrong still they dont understand another jolt will happen n this time it will be final
Bichara 😔I fell very sad for buffalo’s child
And what about buff momo??
Restro ma gayera buff momo tw khan xau tw kanxi.🤔
You also feel sad for buffalo ko bacha while eating momo.?
I know this is our culture for our culture we no need to harm other animal😥😥😥😥😥😥😥😥😥😥😥😥🐴🦌🐮🐂
### I am very........... sorry😐😐😐😐
.
They forgot to specify that it was result of the kings guilt of having killed a underage girl while having sex with her.
Rupak Dev wow
Source??
I can't understand what are you saying please can you explaine please 🙏
That's a different story about different king which isn't related to Kumari. If you don't have full information then don't speak.
Astagfirullah
Stop killing endangered animals
무식한 사람들이 이 영상을 많이 좀 보면 좋겠네..네팔인들에게 쿠마리가 되는건 교황이 되는거같은 영광일텐데.. 꼭 서양 문화는 찬양하고 동남아나 중동쪽 문화는 까내리는거보면 정말 역겹다.무슨 소녀의 삶이 어쩌고 저쩌고 까내리는 서민들 보면 토악질나옴. 신으로서 살아본다는 경험자체가 영광일텐데
교황이랑 이거랑은 좀 결이 다른듯... 교황은 자기가 신부 되기로 선택했고 거절도 할수있고 그런데 쿠마리는 자기 의지로 뭔가 고민해서 결정할 수 있는 나이가 되기 전에 타인의 뜻에 의해서 결정되는거고 또 교황은 삶이 다할때까지 하던가 사임하더라도 무슨 심각한 죄를 짓지 않은이상 존경받으면서 사는데 쿠마리는 초경이라는 자연스러운 육체의 변화 현상에 의해 내쫓겨지고 그 이후의 삶은 망가져버린다는게 좋아보이지 않는다는거임..
임솔잎 감독님. 메일 보냈습니다. 확인 부탁드려요. 개인정보 워드 파일도 다시 부탁드렸습니다. 감사합니다.
네 확인했습니다! 감사합니다!
KUMARI IS CHOSEN FROM NEWARI COMMUNITY
But that what most of people told and newari community contain sakhya, bhramachari and newar is also related to bhudisam
and "Shakya" to be particular.
Annoying background music
I just wanna do the same thing they did with the animal....
R u a vegetarian? If not then u should probably STFU..
@@Nikesh977 dont wanna
Why did they treat animals like that?
Maznah Mohamed It’s a part of the religious ceremony. They sacrifice the animals to God.
They sacrifice to a deity. Not The Most High God.
Really woman its sacrifice
You should know better being a Muslim that too.
U are asking us first see your culture u kill thousand of animal just for godallah Maznah Mohamed
what type of music is this. This is not horror documentary this about god
Isn't this child abuse no offense but opinion I'm not questioning the tradition but that girl can't enjoy her childhood and she's not allowed to show expressions and her education is gone and her childhood innocence is only gone
We worship kumari as a goddess which is better than small girls who are being raped and abused in India and other part of the world. There are rules which she has to follow only when she is in her goddess attire and her sacred seat. And no they are not deprived of their education, they get education not in school but in kumari house. I have visited kumari myself and she is like any other child with special privileges. She plays, runs, laughs, smiles BUT ONCE she sits on her sacred throne with her attire she becomes goddess, completely different personality.
@@anjilanakarmi3973
Why do you always write your first sentence the way you do?? It's like you are obsessed about that subject... What gives??
@@joerobinette5397 i write the way I do because its a fact. I am not obsessed but sick and tired of horrible events happening like that to a kids as small as few months old. Can you even imagine?So is it not good to worship than to abuse? What do you think?
Apa cuma gua yg org indo?
Putri Ramadani thank you for your reply. I am sorry but I can’t read your language!
I saw some devils don't like the Holi Kumari tradition .
Hola, con todo respeto a sus creencias, que yo desconozco, pero no hay dioses ni diosas vivientes, sólo humanos tal cuáles, la ignorancia de muchos es aprovechada para el poder de pocos, que han implementado algunas costumbres para benefició propio.
Gracias por el comentario. Yo no creo en esta religión. Este video es un documental sobre las personas que creen en este video y su cultura. Hice este documental para no juzgar sus creencias y cultura como 'malas'.
Belive or not...
Kumari is known as protector of Nepal 'kul devi'
If something huge change is going to happen in the nation...kumari will start to show her behaviour
In the past 2001, Kumari started crying for 3 days..everybody were afraid...then on the night of 1st June, royal massacre happened in Nepal...after that she stopped crying and said, 'Okay, now it's over.'
Ya she is a kid... like us normal people...but don't forget that soul is like a 'conversion of energy'
It can transform from one place to another
This is just disguting me.
Really??
watch the full video then u wil get
Always criticize without knowing
@@palzomlama4761
The ppl who judge this must have very sad lives...
I think it is a beautiful and noble custom.
Hey British you must not talk about Cruality see what you have done to world KARMA is Coming for you
Bikki Chettri
You meant cruelty? In what aspect? Can you be more specific?
😂ok I'm kumar ...
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
You look bhogoban dasi. All time re????????thakur.muslim marige 2 3,4 5 all time panis women
I don't believe this😒😒
That is not good for society and all worldwide
fuck u and ur world. I am Chamling Rai, belong to a Kirat so do u. But i support Newars whole heartedly.
Look at the kumari after retirement how happy she is.
@@krishnamandal4820 You are an Indian you have lots of issues to solve in your own country. First stop dowry system, child marriage and shitting on streets ok ? This is Nepals affair and not yours. There are thousands to problems in the world to deal with. FInd one ! Thank u !
I'm also from limbu community and tell me why it is not good for society??respecting child as God is bad. in kumari ghar she is treated as God with facilities and it is hard to get such facilities for normal neplese child.Everything said by Westerner isn't true lunga bichar choge .
@@machindrakhapung6039 There are billions of problem in the world why dont u start tackling with one? This is a part of newari tradition which i respect though i am a Kirat. I am sure you are too facing as many problems in your family and life too, deal with that first brother. There is nothing bad to respect and worship a child as a goddess. In other parts of the world llike in India / Bangladesh girls are raped and trafficed. We Nepalese worship and respect a girl so whats harm in it ? Most of all this tradition didnt happen over night. Look at the bigger picture and think out of the box its a coalition of 2 big religions HIndu and Buddhists creating a religious harmony. Nothing is fair in this world brother, look back and turn the pages of history you ll find your answers.
Ummmmm
Child abuse ! Time to abolish this.
How it is child abuse?
@@dibinashakya7678 You tell me why it is not child abuse ? You jolly well know more than me about this backward practice so why not you lay out some points to support your claim it is not child abuse.
@@conanabang1515 it's not backward practice. What is this word "backward practice "? It's culture. And don't worry the child is healthy, educated, respected and happy for being well treated. She gets whatever she wants. Understand the essence of the creation of kumari. DisRespecting and raping and cat calling female may be you backward practice which you still follow not ours
@@conanabang1515 and you tell me why it is child abuse?
The kumaris grow up to become a aducated citizen of the country. I believe an educated person can certainly tell if its a child abuse.. Guess what, none have said so. If fact they are proud of have been Kumari. Who can judge about Kumari culture better than Kumari herself?
Hinduisim and buddhism are different if you know about buddhism you will never accept hindus god or goddess
😆😆😆well..... Many of us don't discriminate... We pray every god....
Put your ideology in your pocket. We regard buddha as a 9th incarnation of The Supreme Lord of Creation. We know what is buddhism and hinduism. its not a religion is a culture ....... Go get yourself learn. I don't like animal sacrifice too but some people raise against animal sacrifice after having meat and chicken ...
I am a Hindu, I am aware of Buddhism. I am not converting.
Though born in nepal, I honestly felt we had one of the worst culture in the world yet ignorantly proud of it. Felt too ashamed watching this shit
Then, its time you packed your bags and moved elsewhere where you will feel proud.
Says the one who comes from a culture that damns their women to cowsheds during mentruation, leaving them in unhygienic condition, some even get sexually abused.
Then you people are killing kid childhood and earning money .
How are killing childhood? Oh by not allowing her stare at mobile whole day?
@@dibinashakya7678 it comes under all like education, outside playing, talking with others, even not keeping her legs on the ground.
@@upendrachary6663 should do your homework or listen to this interview of kumari carefully.
@@upendrachary6663
And you believed that you can keep a child from touching the ground. I mean-
@@yghhgy2547 how come it is. What the rights you have to grab her childhood and attached stickers like ... goddess
Jiw jantu marnu paap ho.. That s why nepal aile pni bikashit na vako ho.
Lol hasauxa Vai le Vai this is our culture belief...mula world wide each and every kill Garixa China hos USA hos Ani teha Chai sap vegetarian ho ta mula 🤣 🤣
@@Mr.BADDA91 to nai ho mula bhai...!!! Teri cultural ma marxa hola... hamro ma hoina..
@@urgenlama4390 dashain ma pork khaney gareko xoina ki kya ho?😂😂😂aajha khaja ma buff momos sausages . ?
@@_aneeba_smu7533 timro ma pork khanxa hola mo lama vko nata ma esto kai khadina pni ani na marnu vnxu.. yo maar Kat garera puja garnu sb naramro ho....
@@Mr.BADDA91 dharma ko nam ma esto maar Kat garera rmro hoina. Manche le world mai masu khanxa bt na khane pni manche xa.. devi devta le kaile masu khadaina manche le nai chadau xa. I have to learn budhist philosophy... La bhai.
Attention Attention. Please do not think that all Nepalese worship Kumari and believe in the so called living goddess Kumari. There is more than 100 ethnicity in Nepal. Only the brahmin chettris and some newars believe in this living goddess kumari. The creator of this kumari are the brahmins and the followers are chettris and newars who have been hindunized by the brahmins. We Tharu people, one of the ethnicities of Nepal have no relations to kumari. so do not blame all Nepalese for this heinous crime of making such small girl into kumari.
Worshipping Kumari is a newar tradition. Only newar girls can become Kumari.
@@nimkati5627 this is why we must stop this tradition. this brings bad image to Nepal.
@@lordbuddhatharu3731 Stop this tradition? Do you even know why this tradition was started?
@@sonimayonjan1046 this tradition was started by the Brahmins(bahun) from India.
@@lordbuddhatharu3731 lol!! who told you that it was started by brahmins of india?😂😂 it was started by malla king in 17th century! 😏 aafnai desh ko culture kasari start vako pani tha xaina kasto manxe ho!
00:44 haram!! Gk dibacakan doa dulu main sembelih aja sapinya kasihan tau sapinya!! DISLIKE😡😡
Fuck you and your Mohammed and you fucking fake allah
Jadi gini...,kan budaya nepal dan indonesia berbeda kalo indonesia biasanya dibacakan doa dulu kan gak tau kalo nepal bisa dibacakan atau nggak tapi tapi dan tapi itu kan divideo sapinya di sembelih untuk ritual bukan untuk dimakan kayaknya hehe:v SEKEDAR MENGINGATKAN HEHE:V
Disliked just because of the song