Flywheel Powered Plane

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 июн 2024
  • The first 100 people to go to www.blinkist.com/tomstanton are
    going to get unlimited access for 1 week to try it out. You’ll also get 25% off
    if you want the full membership.
    Thingiverse files: www.thingiverse.com/thing:415...
    2nd channel: / @timstation
    Enjoy my videos? These are made possible due to help from my Patrons. Please consider supporting my efforts: / tomstanton
    3D Printer filament sponsored by 3D Printz UK: 3dprintz.co.uk/
    Lighting provided by Neewer: neewer.com/collections/led-pa...
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    My Other Equipment:
    Main camera - amzn.to/2vlvlC6
    Main lens - amzn.to/2gMrhru
    Main tripod - amzn.to/2tqRjBt
    Secondary Tripod - amzn.to/2t1NkMh
    Microphone - amzn.to/2uuv9n0
    Audio recorder - amzn.to/2v3mjcG
    Banggood affiliate: www.banggood.com/?p=LT0710618...
    Twitter: / tomstantonyt
    3D Printer filament sponsored by 3D Printz UK: 3dprintz.co.uk/
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 2,2 тыс.

  • @smartereveryday
    @smartereveryday 4 года назад +2923

    2:40 Safety squint

    • @moki2093
      @moki2093 4 года назад +27

      Hi Destin

    • @syber-space
      @syber-space 4 года назад +181

      100% as effective as safety glasses 50% of the time!

    • @heyitsgowcow
      @heyitsgowcow 4 года назад +8

      how hasn’t anyone noticed you yet?

    • @ogpogtane7244
      @ogpogtane7244 4 года назад +2

      hey man love ur vidoes

    • @screwsnutsandbolts
      @screwsnutsandbolts 4 года назад +19

      This plane would have flown a lot better had he incorporated a SNATCH BLOCK !

  • @guiltypixel5275
    @guiltypixel5275 3 года назад +676

    The perpetual motion ring is fueled by crushed hopes and dreams held in a suspension of tears and anguish. Good Rage/Kg ratio

    • @c.s1393
      @c.s1393 3 года назад +7

      @@jasong8501 I think a lot of charlatans have historically tried to make flywheel based perpetual motion machines?

    • @c.s1393
      @c.s1393 3 года назад +4

      @@jasong8501 Lol dude. I'm not the original poster, I was just trying to guess his POV.

    • @Roboprogs
      @Roboprogs 3 года назад

      Rubber bands don’t look so bad after seeing this.

    • @goldenretriever6440
      @goldenretriever6440 2 года назад

      THERE IS NO FREE ENERGY DEVICE

    • @florinmacarenco7547
      @florinmacarenco7547 2 года назад +1

      Remove all type of fiction.. and you have a perpetum mobile. We look 13.8 bilion years into the past (using telescope) and we find nothing stationary... everything is moving smart guy , since big ben. Voyager 1 and 2 are moving since 1978... and probably will travel a millions of years....because... no friction...

  • @Vok250
    @Vok250 4 года назад +1917

    Local engineer spends month reinventing a common children's toy.

    • @SameBasicRiff
      @SameBasicRiff 4 года назад +16

      @Franz Huber but how does the UI *feel*

    • @cocofilms5524
      @cocofilms5524 3 года назад +5

      Franz Huber As someone in middle school I can say I have learned a mix of the two.

    • @omkarvedak4321
      @omkarvedak4321 3 года назад +24

      seriously i felt the same thing. at least he could have put a flywheel on that propeller to make it store more energy if that's how it works.

    • @mickalinjezerx7104
      @mickalinjezerx7104 2 года назад

      That's how it works

    • @Nomaditis
      @Nomaditis 2 года назад

      which is the toy? pls tell me

  • @tinkerfox1663
    @tinkerfox1663 4 года назад +261

    4:13 - 4:18
    Thats how sounds of fighter planes in war movies are made.

    • @xtocy96
      @xtocy96 3 года назад +2

      Stuka jericho trumpet :)

    • @ijdtechno5980
      @ijdtechno5980 3 года назад +4

      @@xtocy96 it doesnt even sound like a stuka

    • @mansourq.689
      @mansourq.689 3 года назад +1

      that sounded straight like external wastage of a sport car

  • @MakersMuse
    @MakersMuse 4 года назад +966

    Engage safety squints! haha please follow up to figure out WHY that ring flew so far and so stable all on its own, amazing.

    • @TomStantonEngineering
      @TomStantonEngineering  4 года назад +213

      Might need to try 'flywheel' projectiles next haha

    • @daslynnter9841
      @daslynnter9841 3 года назад +7

      ruclips.net/video/n4nZPU6L4cI/видео.html

    • @aceman0000099
      @aceman0000099 3 года назад +14

      It's because of gyroscopic forces

    • @caleb186
      @caleb186 3 года назад +15

      Remember those circular paper airplanes? I'm thinking he could just print a really deep outer ring, low pitch blades to hold a hub, and build a flying propeller.

    • @mickhowie3012
      @mickhowie3012 3 года назад +11

      Ah a fellow AVE viewer I see

  • @E4STWOOD
    @E4STWOOD 4 года назад +500

    6:21 - the ring flew surprisingly far, I'd like to see a video exploring/optimising it.

    • @SirDella
      @SirDella 4 года назад +16

      Discovered by accident

    • @fritz1990
      @fritz1990 4 года назад +18

      There used to be a toy frisbee like device that used a thin cardboard tube, with a heavier leading edge, that used a form of the Magnus effect to fly. Sorry for the run on sentence.

    • @JMMC1005
      @JMMC1005 4 года назад +15

      It looks like the little stub of propellor blade left was enough to propel the ring, but didn't have very much drag and so the ring kept its speed up for much longer.
      I think with more optimisation (maybe a non-printed ring that could spin a lot faster) and a shallow-pitch, optimised set of short blades, you could probably get a pretty impressive flight out of one.

    • @clonkex
      @clonkex 4 года назад +4

      You can do the same thing with an empty toilet roll. Just cut it in half, wrap a layer or two of tape around it at one end and spin it forwards out of your hand (which takes some practice). Quite a fun toy if you can get it working.

    • @osten_petersson
      @osten_petersson 4 года назад +3

      We made freesbies like that when i was a kid by cutting a coke can in half and remove the top by filing the fold so it get a bit heavier in front. Throw like a american football and it flies really well, u can even do loops

  • @craigriglin
    @craigriglin 4 года назад +123

    Running a fly wheel latterly along the fuselage would really make the plane extremely stable acting like a gyroscope. If this was utilized on an ultralight the landings might be so stable that you could technically just land with only one wheel . You may well accomplish a most perfect safe landing. It’s good to see someone toying with these kind of ideas.

    • @danielpapp5901
      @danielpapp5901 4 года назад +5

      No, it actually gets instable when decelerates!

    • @Doctor_Subtilis
      @Doctor_Subtilis 2 года назад +1

      You seem like you know what you're talking about. I'm the furthest thing from an engineer but I've been imagining a fanciful glider that has flywheel powered propeller(s) which is why I found this video. what are your thoughts on the feasibility of placing turbines posterior to the propellers that rewind the flywheels using drag while cruising or when needed for air braking? It's only natural that fly wheels be used for flying and I want lowtech environmentally friendly and safe ways for normal poor people to fly.

    • @hornetIIkite3
      @hornetIIkite3 2 года назад +7

      Good luck steering. The wheel wants to keep going straight. You will never get the plane turning

    • @Doctor_Subtilis
      @Doctor_Subtilis 2 года назад +1

      @@hornetIIkite3 what about two on the wingtips with brakes

    • @Doctor_Subtilis
      @Doctor_Subtilis 2 года назад +1

      The brakes engage the propellers

  • @kurukuru4120
    @kurukuru4120 3 года назад +151

    6:19 can you imagine walking down the park and see a flying circle like that.

  • @oscarrobinsonteddy9847
    @oscarrobinsonteddy9847 4 года назад +896

    4:15 That sounded like an actual plane crash

    • @somekid8311
      @somekid8311 4 года назад +31

      this comment is gonna get stolen or many many likes

    • @marcus_w0
      @marcus_w0 4 года назад +40

      It also looked like an actual plane crash

    • @AbhishekThakur-wl1pl
      @AbhishekThakur-wl1pl 4 года назад +3

      Lmao, i thought the same.

    • @Pillowcase
      @Pillowcase 4 года назад +11

      2:43 putting on the safety squints

    • @somekid8311
      @somekid8311 4 года назад

      @@marcus_w0 wow here comes onther one

  • @keu5951
    @keu5951 4 года назад +311

    idk why, but the flying hoola hoop gets me everytime!
    6:20

    • @bicross87
      @bicross87 4 года назад +15

      I laughed so hard I look down on the comment to see if i was the only one !

    • @m4d0s
      @m4d0s 4 года назад +2

      @@bicross87 same

    • @timehunter9467
      @timehunter9467 4 года назад +1

      I thought it was awesome.

    • @sriharivaila7276
      @sriharivaila7276 4 года назад +1

      😂😂 fly amazing. that g force broken it.

    • @aNOMaly_..
      @aNOMaly_.. 4 года назад +1

      It's hilarious, isn't it? 😂

  • @shailesh_rajpurohit
    @shailesh_rajpurohit 3 года назад +33

    This guy motivates me that if he can make so much fail attempts to achieve one successful attempt then why should i stop

  • @SSphotos_edits
    @SSphotos_edits 4 года назад +356

    I love how when the plane crashed it sounded like an actual plane crashing

    • @gfries4906
      @gfries4906 4 года назад +38

      Not the actual sound of a plane crashing. Movies just use that sound for planes crashing so it has become very familiar. The sound is actually the WW2 Stuka siren.

    • @johnmarcelo7848
      @johnmarcelo7848 4 года назад +2

      9/11

    • @Starjumper2821
      @Starjumper2821 4 года назад +13

      @@gfries4906 While many movies for increased drama use a sound like the Jericho trumpet fitted on some Ju 87, props can create a similar sound when rotating beyond their spec, or rather when dragging the engine with them, due to the high airspeed. The Jericho was after all pretty much just a small prop fixed to the undercarriage. The difference is just in the pitch and loudness. Easier to record in a studio too.

    • @sheldondebellotte2045
      @sheldondebellotte2045 3 года назад +1

      Hollmarkmonve

    • @sheldondebellotte2045
      @sheldondebellotte2045 3 года назад

      Hollemorkmoive

  • @lightningslim
    @lightningslim 4 года назад +844

    "Flying Hula Hoop" must be your next project!

    • @calebsherman886
      @calebsherman886 4 года назад +41

      Please, that was really cool.

    • @JustJackOnYoutube
      @JustJackOnYoutube 4 года назад +9

      @@calebsherman886 yes

    • @filipmatyja
      @filipmatyja 4 года назад +21

      Use Magnus effect to generate some lift and off we go!
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnus_effect

    • @sed8me69
      @sed8me69 4 года назад +1

      LoL, googling that would likely end in a faptrap.....!

    • @grazianoturbogas
      @grazianoturbogas 4 года назад

      Tom Stanton give an eye to X-Zylo it's something for your super powers

  • @JoelCreates
    @JoelCreates 4 года назад +2114

    This is great, but I'm going to build a plane powered only by Tom Stanton's accent

    • @funylee547
      @funylee547 4 года назад +9

      Get this comment more likes!!!

    • @jerry3790
      @jerry3790 4 года назад +32

      Tbh I don’t think his accent is very strong compared to some other British people

    • @leifvejby8023
      @leifvejby8023 4 года назад +34

      Accent?!? Which accent?

    • @bruhdabones
      @bruhdabones 4 года назад +2

      Joel Creates it will be stronger than vibranium

    • @Mrbobinge
      @Mrbobinge 4 года назад +3

      The accent is on curiosity and sheer determination. Meanwhile, he makes the full movie as well!

  • @gonun69
    @gonun69 3 года назад +64

    I remember reading about a German (I think) early unmanned helicopter project where they basically built one of those propellers with a flywheel in big. The idea was that you could launch it near the frontlines. The helicopter would go up, shoot some pictures, and slowly come down as the rpm decrease.
    I looked for it a while now but can't find it again. If someone knows what I mean, please let me know.

  • @TheSliderW
    @TheSliderW 3 года назад +15

    Have you tried mounting the flywheel on other axis ? Like maybe parallel to the ground or facing sideways like the toy ?Also the rotation direction might be important. The fact the toy's ring continues flying by itself when the propeller exploded is also interesting.
    Did you know some planes attempt using rotating cylindrical wings using the magnus effect to create lift.

  • @Peterscraps
    @Peterscraps 4 года назад +293

    4:15 okay that cut back to wide when it crashed had me hollering.

  • @SuicideNeil
    @SuicideNeil 4 года назад +154

    This definitely needs a part two, considering how well the simplified design worked. Also, see how high you can make the flying hoola-hoop go ( straight up, like the toy ) with a high rpm motor and more robust hoop....

    • @trif55
      @trif55 4 года назад +5

      bolt a wider thinner alu ring to a standard CF prop (maybe 3 or 4 blade) that'd be insane!

    • @SuicideNeil
      @SuicideNeil 4 года назад +7

      @@trif55 Yep, make the prop itself the flywheel essentially. This definitely needs more investigation...

    • @KirbyZhang
      @KirbyZhang 4 года назад +2

      you can't reach the incredible rpm's with the blades on them. flywheel works but requires really high tech electrically transmission and superconducting nano materials. if you have all that tech it's better than li-ion battery

    • @SuicideNeil
      @SuicideNeil 4 года назад +2

      @@KirbyZhang The blades don't need to reach the same rpms as the separate flywheel- the idea is just to reinforce the ring around the blades and add a *little* bit of weight to help them act like a flywheel for long flights. The real failure point was the where the blades attach to the hub- reinforce that area with some more beefy blades and away you go, literally...

    • @KirbyZhang
      @KirbyZhang 4 года назад +2

      @@SuicideNeil the fly wheel didn't work because there was too much transmission loss. the simplified design got rid of transmission, but you'll never spin those blades to 20k rpm

  • @simonm.456
    @simonm.456 2 года назад +2

    My friend, you will make a lot of kids happy with that.

  • @DrBe-zn5fv
    @DrBe-zn5fv 3 года назад

    great quality high detail crystal clear communication, no pissing about, and.. ZERO FKN MUZAK .. this guy's a stone genius ---- subscribed big time

  • @mikeslaserstuff4018
    @mikeslaserstuff4018 4 года назад +169

    4:57 The flywheel is creating a massive amount of torque relative to the weight of the plane. with the flywheel perpendicular to the plane, and the rotation twisting toward the nose, it puts it in the FDAU position, perfect for a broken propeller. adding a few grams to the tail may do the trick... or re-gearing to have the opposite effect, pulling the nose up and adding weight to that, but with the wings being the vertices, it would be a much larger weight increase due to proximity alone. OR you could orient the flywheel and gear for a perpendicular rotation opposite that of the propeller, using carbon fiber spindles instead of a disc to reduce drag, possibly shaped to increase thrust? I think adding weight to the tail would still be your best option with the current configuration.
    5:46 I should have just kept watching lmao

    • @ELEGANTFOX
      @ELEGANTFOX 4 года назад +6

      Were you watching the video while typing? You didn't edited it

    • @mikeslaserstuff4018
      @mikeslaserstuff4018 4 года назад +1

      This was 2 months ago, I don't know how to answer your question.

    • @smokeypillow
      @smokeypillow 4 года назад

      @@ELEGANTFOX Probably just had the comment editor open during the whole video

    • @raelik777
      @raelik777 4 года назад +12

      Not only that, but with as much angular momentum as a flywheel has, the precession force will be absurd. So even if you manage to put enough weight on the back to counteract the momentum of the flywheel (which is also only going to work momentarily as the flywheel loses momentum to the propeller), any torque applied by the frame of the plane to the flywheel will cause a precession according to the right-hand rule (so 90-degrees deflection from the direction of angular momentum). So, if the flywheel is spinning forward, and a breeze blows the tail to the left (applying clockwise torque perpendicular to the spinning of the flywheel and parallel to the ground), the flywheel will precess counterclockwise perpendicular to the ground, causing the plane to roll to the left while it yaws to the right... and it will crash pretty much immediately. A similar effect will happen if something makes the plane roll, though if it rolls to the right, the flywheel will cause it to yaw to the right, not the left. This behavior will reverse if the flywheel is spinning backwards: a roll to the right will cause a yaw to the left, and a yaw to the right will cause a roll to the right. The only way to stop this from happening is to decouple the flywheel from the frame, like the 3-axis gimbal mount of an avionics gyroscope. You would only be able to extract energy from that type of flywheel electromagnetically.

    • @mikeslaserstuff4018
      @mikeslaserstuff4018 4 года назад +5

      @SmokeyPillow I rarely comment on videos, so no need to have the editor open all the time. @ELEGANTFOX, thinking more carefully about it now, I believe I typed the first part, played the video for more reference, and saw that everything I said was a moot point... So instead of removing all logical thinking, I simply added humor.

  • @niki123489
    @niki123489 4 года назад +164

    6:14 That propeller flew far away when it broke ...wow.

    • @KagaminaraShikatsu
      @KagaminaraShikatsu 4 года назад

      Weeeeeeeee !

    • @Co-km6cl
      @Co-km6cl 4 года назад +1

      Flew

    • @Sawer
      @Sawer 4 года назад +5

      Like a plastic vortex ring or something :p

    • @rud9599
      @rud9599 4 года назад +5

      The MAGNUS effect

    • @Zwettekop
      @Zwettekop 4 года назад

      Yeah that surprised me as well

  • @miketuzyk7530
    @miketuzyk7530 4 года назад +8

    Commercial pilot signing in, and I’d love to see your idea fly!
    By the way your first design constantly wants to fly nose down indicates that the centre of gravity may be too far forward. As well, the wing dihedral is a bit a mute point, as it helps create stability in unstable air. Having a straight wing with winglets would be more efficient at drag reduction. And a basic tail dragger landing gear forward of the CG would save the output gear overhaul every flight.
    Good luck!!

    • @tracywarren7332
      @tracywarren7332 2 года назад +1

      I notice the plane nosing down and was thinking the same thing about the weight being to far forward. It would be interesting to see if moving the weight backwards would have lead to a more successful attempt.

  • @dilip3333
    @dilip3333 4 года назад +4

    You explore different concepts that is really great. Never imagined using compressed air , gyro based pitch control, flywheel powered plane, elastic powered plane. Awesome

  • @Lozoot2
    @Lozoot2 4 года назад +261

    6:20
    Hula hoop must return to his home planet. His people need him.

    • @omerfeyyazselcuk7325
      @omerfeyyazselcuk7325 4 года назад +4

      This one got me so hard

    • @DigitalJedi
      @DigitalJedi 4 года назад +1

      r/mypeopleneedme

    • @Shareezz
      @Shareezz 3 года назад

      Yeah the gyro effect keeping it straight and flying in the same direction it was propelled was a real surprise.

  • @MushVPeets
    @MushVPeets 4 года назад +90

    6:21 Next project, Magnus effect aeroplane with a spinning outer fuselage and no wings?

  • @hypocritehenry4619
    @hypocritehenry4619 3 года назад +29

    When the title said, “flywheel powered plane”
    Then i saw the first part, I immediately went,
    “So you’re gonna fly a plane using a bike?”

  • @skeletonfunfair
    @skeletonfunfair 3 года назад +3

    Love the slow mo shots! Amazing to see how the whole airframe moves with the spinning prop

  • @JaviRP97
    @JaviRP97 4 года назад +53

    The flying hoop has stolen my heart ❤️

  • @StopChangingUsernamesYouTube
    @StopChangingUsernamesYouTube 4 года назад +123

    3:18 Me getting out of bed, ready to take on the world.

  • @Justwantahover
    @Justwantahover 4 года назад +2

    Extremely precious footage of a flywheel propeller breaking up.

  • @nicholaskelly6375
    @nicholaskelly6375 3 года назад +1

    Flywheel powered locomotives are still used in mining in the former Soviet Union. The "Gyroz" HUNOSA the Spanish coal combine used them as well.

  • @MikeBSc
    @MikeBSc 4 года назад +12

    That hoop sailing off into the horizon was beautiful.

  • @tubularap
    @tubularap 4 года назад +4

    I followed most of your plane propulsion designs, and the flywheel is my favorite.
    Thanks for taking us along on your thought processes and trials. Amazing slow-mo shots. Great production !!

  • @jeremiah._.hamman9255
    @jeremiah._.hamman9255 3 года назад +6

    6:19 the propeller taking off into the distance made me lose my shit, I was laughing so hard.

    • @C.Sharpe
      @C.Sharpe 3 года назад

      "Later, Gator!"

  • @timearly5226
    @timearly5226 4 года назад

    Toy companies are often very good at finding simple, yet effective (and cost effective) engineering solutions.

  • @Tclans
    @Tclans 4 года назад +35

    6:02 that could very well be an amazing toy. Toy makers should carry that 😍

  • @zilym
    @zilym 4 года назад +14

    This video was really great! I loved the super simplified version of the design at the end. Very ingenious! Was also really happy to see you using real safety glasses at @4:08 instead of the "safety squints" like @2:08. Stay safe Tom!

  • @MeriaDuck
    @MeriaDuck 3 года назад

    4:17 I instinctly dove away at this point in the video.
    4:22 The engineer mantra.
    Was re-watching this after your bike flywheel adventure. So the second thumbs up must be stored here as the official one was already given: 👍

  • @danielbaldoni6725
    @danielbaldoni6725 2 года назад +1

    I’m pretty sure Tom could solve world hunger with a large enough flywheel

  • @pafnutiytheartist
    @pafnutiytheartist 4 года назад +188

    Hey Tom! I wounder if your original design would have problems anyways due to gyroscopic effects.

    • @user-mr6ui4fy5h
      @user-mr6ui4fy5h 4 года назад +9

      At more than 20k rpm the whole plane has such a vibration that gyroscopic effect is not that important ;)

    • @iteerrex8166
      @iteerrex8166 4 года назад +6

      Good point, going up or down would cause left or right turns. But it would be fun piloting hahaha

    • @ka-50withsaams36
      @ka-50withsaams36 4 года назад +13

      That is what I was thinking. At 4:40 it looks really odd. I don't know if that is gyroscopic force or just weird stalling.

    • @Jonay1990
      @Jonay1990 4 года назад +13

      @@ka-50withsaams36 click on that timestamp it sounds like a burp! :') but it's just the tail end of Tom saying "propeller"

    • @luelou8464
      @luelou8464 4 года назад +14

      @@iteerrex8166 It rotates on the pitch axis, so that should be unaffected. Roll will cause yaw torque, and vise versa, and they're be a slight pitch torque due to the flywheel decelerating.

  • @1.618_Murphy
    @1.618_Murphy 4 года назад +14

    4:53
    You can clearly see and feel the frustration, disappointment and hopelessness on Tom's face!!! That's the exact moment I remember myself from 2 years ago wandering in my thoughts about my project, failing again and again!! ☹️

    • @joewoodchuck3824
      @joewoodchuck3824 4 года назад +1

      Albert Einstein once said that there aren't any failures. It's just a collection of experiments of how not to do something.

  • @tuomassyrjaniemi
    @tuomassyrjaniemi 4 года назад +8

    For a tip I’d recommend to make a test throw first without power to see which glides better, flatiron or actual plane 😄

  • @__Mr.Long__
    @__Mr.Long__ 4 года назад

    I love it how you make this super complicated and expensive plane out of carbon fiber and aluminium and stuff and it's almost a total letdown and then a 5€ plane with a 10 € launching station illustrates perfectly the point you were trying to make and also WORKS :))

  • @roesm
    @roesm 4 года назад +9

    That sure gave me a good laugh when that prop assembly came apart in slo-mo, accompanied by your droll commentary! Nice work, sir.

  • @johnthomas7040
    @johnthomas7040 4 года назад +143

    the flywheel is spinning in a way that's forcing the plane to go down nose 1st probable solution 2 flywheels spinning in counter-rotation ?

    • @gregoetker1389
      @gregoetker1389 4 года назад +27

      The issue is the Center of Gravity is off aka the flywheel is to far forward causing it to be nose heavy. The centrifugal force of the flywheel can cause issue once you Roll the plane left or right.

    • @Mansare94
      @Mansare94 4 года назад +14

      @@gregoetker1389 This guy has built a plane before, I'm sure he's got the centre of mass right...

    • @melcrose
      @melcrose 4 года назад +4

      @@Mansare94 You spelled "center" wrong. (lol)

    • @gregoetker1389
      @gregoetker1389 4 года назад +15

      @@Mansare94, I've watched Tom for years and know about his projects.
      My statement is still true. The plane nose dived into the ground. That is caused by incorrect CG and/or not enough wing surface to substain flight.
      The cord of that wing was narrow (but was the wing span enough?) and with the normal CG approx 25% back of the leading edge of the wing, the boom length and tail weight might not been enough to offset the weight of the flywheel.
      RPM can be adjusted if needed.
      The real test is do a glide test without the use of flywheel. It should float down not arc down.
      Some some food for thought.

    • @grimfpv292
      @grimfpv292 4 года назад +9

      @@gregoetker1389 You're not taking into account the flywheel slowing down, and with the rotation direction, that creates a force pivoting the plane down.

  • @divyajnana
    @divyajnana 4 года назад

    Tenacity pays off, great work! The "hula hoop" all by itself, flew beautifully.......speaking of simplicity.

  • @SpikeReid
    @SpikeReid 3 года назад +1

    Great outtakes Tom. Superb video and congrats on succeeding with flywheel flight.

  • @hyperhektor7733
    @hyperhektor7733 4 года назад +24

    6:20 these flying loops would made a real exotic plane or at least exotic propellant system.

    • @Bengs402
      @Bengs402 4 года назад +1

      Look up marvel q-ship mate. It'd be awsum if its real

  • @tomw9078
    @tomw9078 4 года назад +78

    His style of video is progressively becoming more like that of veritasium's. Pretty cool

  • @jasepellerin3350
    @jasepellerin3350 3 года назад

    The brief clip of you picking up the broken outer ring was a great touch! I had just wondered whether those bits tend to get lost after they fly off. Great video!

  • @sghering1
    @sghering1 4 года назад +2

    As an avid and long time pilot of R/C aircraft, this was rather enjoyable to watch. Kinda taking it back to the basics. Have you thought about having the pitch of the blade change as it approaches the hub of the prop itself? Not sure if 3D printers can do that or not as I have never owned one. 4 Blade props are also real good with low RPM, if you can handle the xtra weight.

  • @houstonhelicoptertours1006
    @houstonhelicoptertours1006 4 года назад +34

    6:15 that was incredibly satisfying...for some odd reason.

    • @UltraBadass
      @UltraBadass 4 года назад

      I must go my people need me

  • @BagheeraTube
    @BagheeraTube 4 года назад +6

    That hula hoop slowmotion footage is priceless! 😂😁😁😃😂😁😃😂

  • @sticky59
    @sticky59 4 года назад

    Love your back yard mate ....looks like a winner for the summer.

  • @jamesanderson6882
    @jamesanderson6882 3 года назад +1

    its great to see all the failures and problem solving.

  • @Mk12dexxa6
    @Mk12dexxa6 4 года назад +17

    Well, that flying hoop looks rather awesome too

  • @CaseyFinSF
    @CaseyFinSF 4 года назад +5

    *_"Unless you want a flying Hula-Loop"_* .... perfect comment for the fabulous slo-mo action on the screen.
    Well done.
    You do know that your channel is an inspiration for all the young inquisitive scientific minds out across the globe, and that you make it okay to fail, and then learn from those mistakes. It is an admirable thing that you do, and a wonderful legacy that you are leaving behind you.
    Even I, at age 62, enjoy your content and the way you approach your projects and present them to the world.
    Thank you for what you do because you do it so well and so honestly.
    Keep it up Tom, the world needs more minds like yours out their making it okay to be creative thru trial and error, with a reward at the end *_either way it turns out._*
    And for that you have earned my admiration towards excellence.
    So, Tally ho, and all that sort of rot! (stupid thing to say...)
    (Oh darn, I revealed myself as one of those damn Yankees from across the Pond... well, not all of us are full blown idiots like the one in the White House.... 🥴🤪🤑😎🤫)

  • @RmxManOfficial
    @RmxManOfficial 4 года назад +1

    Don't give up, try to set up the propeller in front of the aluminum wheel. You want to make a perpetual motion device? You need more. Find ways to put capacitors in the scheme so one wheel will recharge the capacitor to give you a perpetual motion device.

  • @rowgler1
    @rowgler1 3 года назад

    I bought a futuristic toy plane that used a similar concept and worked really well maybe about 15 years ago. It most closely resembled the Project Zero Electric Tilt Rotor plane except it had a single central rotor. It was string pull release, when it rose off the spindle the rotor would tilt 45 degrees and it would fly forward. I did a search but I can't find it or who made it. It flew very well with that configuration. I guess now that I think about it, it didn't have much to do with storing energy in a fly wheel. They work best when they are heavy and that is best ground based. Probably some gyroscopic forces and direction of rotation that have to be taken into consideration. Good effort, really interesting experiment, seems like you get through it pretty straight forward and quick.

  • @mnshp7548
    @mnshp7548 4 года назад +5

    the flying ring interests me the most, as it took off and was able to fly really far although been so simple

  • @MotoRideswJohn
    @MotoRideswJohn 4 года назад +29

    Engineering 101: K.I.S.S. Keep it simple Stanton. Well done mate.

    • @kennyg1358
      @kennyg1358 4 года назад +2

      Fortunately for the Allies the Germans had trouble with that concept in WW2.

    • @xSchattenfluchx
      @xSchattenfluchx 4 года назад +4

      @@kennyg1358 German guy here.
      We still haven't figured that out

  • @user-im9xq7fp5r
    @user-im9xq7fp5r 2 года назад

    admire your unwaning enthusiasm!! ...and the analytical mind !!

  • @megatronmike1334
    @megatronmike1334 4 года назад

    I dont know why but watching the red prop plane made me smile especially during the high RPM explosion lol. Great work my dude!!

  • @barriewilliams4526
    @barriewilliams4526 4 года назад +4

    Nice that you show the failures as well the successes :)

  • @lumiinescence5957
    @lumiinescence5957 4 года назад +51

    Love the plane at the end based on the toy, will we be seeing a giant version with radio control?

    • @Jokl92
      @Jokl92 4 года назад

      Peter Sripol wants your number!

  • @benmcreynolds8581
    @benmcreynolds8581 2 года назад

    That was satisfying to see that thing take off so well once the right concept was put into use 🤘

  • @skogpekka
    @skogpekka 2 года назад

    Had my coffee coming out my nose when I saw the ring separating from the propeller - and it even flew better than the glider it was intended for! xD

  • @BPSspace
    @BPSspace 4 года назад +53

    @ 6:22 "I must go, my people need me"

  • @grimfpv292
    @grimfpv292 4 года назад +3

    6:12 The flying hoolahoop looked really cool actually!

  • @jackevans2386
    @jackevans2386 4 года назад

    I admire your never give up attitude.

  • @Thecracktroll999
    @Thecracktroll999 4 года назад +17

    5:14 duuuuuude that was teh toy of my childhood, you really maked up my day ;D

    • @axel9291
      @axel9291 3 года назад +2

      Thecracktroll999 Productions, You play Roblox you are still a kid no adult plays roblox.

    • @ijdtechno5980
      @ijdtechno5980 3 года назад +1

      @@axel9291 kids can still get those

  • @OpreanMircea
    @OpreanMircea 4 года назад +8

    "FLYwheel Plane" you got my like before I even played the first second of the video, would you stop reading my mind please?
    edit after I've seen it: I loved the video, I love seeing how you adapt your concepts.

  • @AnimilesYT
    @AnimilesYT 4 года назад +4

    6:21 The way it just flew off like that had me burst out in laughter xD
    FYI, it takes a LOT to make me burst out in laughter when I'm watching a video on my own.

  • @jarenhudson9794
    @jarenhudson9794 4 года назад

    One of the VERY few youtubers I may consider actually paying money to. You do an incredible job Mr. Stanton.
    Is there a RUclips reward competition for best engineering channels and things of that nature? - I want to go put my vote in.

  • @waylonk2453
    @waylonk2453 4 года назад

    Beautiful chassis and machining!

  • @FirstnameLastname77777
    @FirstnameLastname77777 4 года назад +5

    Ive said it before ill say it again this is the most underated science channel on RUclips

  • @PKMartin
    @PKMartin 4 года назад +9

    Oh man I'd love to see a flywheel-as-prop plane like the second one, with a machined and balanced metal flywheel like the first.

    • @MichaelThompson94
      @MichaelThompson94 4 года назад

      That will bring the centre of gravity too far forward

    • @MushVPeets
      @MushVPeets 4 года назад

      @@MichaelThompson94 Could always have some ballast, electronics, or other stuff in a fairing ahead of the propeller...

    • @MichaelThompson94
      @MichaelThompson94 4 года назад +1

      @@MushVPeets could do, but ideally you want the weight to be minimal... It would be better to do a mid prop mount or something.

  • @oswaldoriginal7587
    @oswaldoriginal7587 2 года назад

    flywheel as storage of energy for any purpose will forever be RIDICULOUS

  • @adriansalter9358
    @adriansalter9358 8 месяцев назад

    I’m really enjoying your videos now 🤩 A friend and I got a patent more than 20 years ago for a magnetic bearing that can be used for flywheel storage systems so we understand the challenges you face.
    Please keep making cool videos 👍🏽

  • @92393jackpot
    @92393jackpot 4 года назад +5

    Hi Tom! Have you thought about the gyroscopic effect of the fly wheel on the stability of the plane? In the new design you switched the rotation axes of the flywheel to be the direction the plane is pointed in, so it's possible that could be stabilizing it. I'd be interested in seeing how it works with the heavy flywheel but rotated 90 so the rotation axis of rotation points in the forward direction.

  • @coryman125
    @coryman125 3 года назад +6

    I was thinking of other weird energy storage methods, and I was about to recommend a gravity powered plane, but..... that's just a glider isn't it.
    Maybe put a tank of water in the plane and have it drip through a tiny hydroelectric dam to power the propeller? ;)

    • @C.Sharpe
      @C.Sharpe 3 года назад +1

      My favorite thing is when I come up with a brilliant idea for a new way of doing something but realize after spending some time on it that it's already been done... 😂
      As a kid I drew up a revolutionary new design for a "flying squirrel suit" only to later realize skydivers have been using something similar for decades...

    • @coryman125
      @coryman125 3 года назад

      @@C.Sharpe Ahh, that's always fun! But at least, it shows that your ideas are feasible, which is reassuring :P

    • @endorsedbryce
      @endorsedbryce 3 года назад

      solid fuel rocket plane.

  • @deldridg
    @deldridg 3 года назад +1

    Great fun vid and in a beautiful back yard too! Cheers from Sydney, Oz - Dave

  • @Edwinthebreadwin
    @Edwinthebreadwin 4 года назад

    The slow mo in this is really good

  • @kafigoto
    @kafigoto 4 года назад +25

    4:15 That sounds like plane crashing in movies

  • @maartendj2724
    @maartendj2724 4 года назад +4

    Awesome content! Would love to see more experimentation with flywheel energy storage :)

    • @somekid8311
      @somekid8311 4 года назад +2

      i was exactly trying to build this kinda stuff on www.algodoo.com/

  • @Eatsgrease69
    @Eatsgrease69 4 года назад

    This man is just a pure joy to watch! Great work and keep up the fantastic content!

  • @stelleratorsuprise8185
    @stelleratorsuprise8185 4 года назад

    You are trying a lot of things and very often with limited success, but I respect all this efforts. No one knows if thing work if there is not someone who tried them.

  • @Davide21570
    @Davide21570 4 года назад +13

    What about the conservation of angular momentum? Shouldn't the plane tend to pitch one way while the flywheel is slowing down?

    • @KelticStingray
      @KelticStingray 4 года назад +1

      Like the spitfire's radial engine. Actually gave it an advantage in dog fights.

  • @haulngrassracing
    @haulngrassracing 4 года назад +31

    Could you used the flywheel technique at the beginning of the video but make the carbon fiber into a propeller shape and use that at the front of the plane?

    • @gajbooks
      @gajbooks 4 года назад +2

      You definitely could make one like he made later but out of carbon fiber and steel. It sounds pretty dangerous though.

    • @haulngrassracing
      @haulngrassracing 4 года назад +1

      gajbooks all in the name of Science 🤣

    • @Ultrazaubererger
      @Ultrazaubererger 4 года назад +2

      Might be hard to get the cg right with all that mass in the front.
      Maybe put the propeller in the middle of the plane?

    • @trif55
      @trif55 4 года назад +1

      I just posted suggesting this but giving you the up-doot so hopefully tom sees this! :-)

  • @lovehope5126
    @lovehope5126 3 года назад

    This was awesome
    I thoroughly enjoyed just about everything in this video, which is kind of rare treat for me. Thanks so much for putting it together ☺️

  • @joewoodchuck3824
    @joewoodchuck3824 3 года назад +1

    I remember years ago that flywheels running in a vacuum were thought of as viable future energy storage. There were even air bearings being developed to help further reduce losses. I never heard any more about it.

    • @chaotickreg7024
      @chaotickreg7024 3 года назад +1

      I remember seeing a video in my Recommended called "The Mechanical Battery" I wonder if that's about the same thing

    • @joewoodchuck3824
      @joewoodchuck3824 3 года назад +1

      @@chaotickreg7024 Could very well be. The big parameters to compare are cost, weight (not in every application though), and recharge efficiency.

    • @chaotickreg7024
      @chaotickreg7024 3 года назад

      @@joewoodchuck3824 The thing I find interesting about storing energy in its kenetic form is that humans create kenetic energy all the time, sometimes for fun. It's interesting to think about a scenario where large batteries cant be produced so instead you have a couple people riding stationary bikes to power up a flywheel "battery" for a factory to keep the mechanical machines operating until lunchtime. Imagine a windmill charging a flywheel so that a farmer could do their wheat milling at any point of the day they wanted? Ok now I see why people are into stuff like steampunk.

    • @joewoodchuck3824
      @joewoodchuck3824 3 года назад

      @@chaotickreg7024 Human peak power is around 1.2 hp with 0.1 hp sustained. Athletes can do somewhat better, but most people aren't athletes.

  • @Hirosjimma
    @Hirosjimma 4 года назад +7

    4:16 has some meme potential with that amazing sound

  • @letsbuildit6954
    @letsbuildit6954 4 года назад +4

    This is exactly how some WWII carrier aircraft were started. Crank the flywheel, drop the clutch, and start the engine with no electricity.

    • @frackcha
      @frackcha 4 года назад +4

      I believe a tiger tank is also started with a hand cranked flywheel.

    • @Shortsircut1
      @Shortsircut1 4 года назад +1

      @@frackcha Ever seen the original Flight of the Phoenix with jimmy Stewart? The radial engine used in that flying box car used a shot gun shell blast to spin a fly wheel that cranked the engine over. Really a unique and fascinating idea!

    • @MichaelThompson94
      @MichaelThompson94 4 года назад

      How I start my car when people are asleep lol (Hill roll start)

    • @generalharness8266
      @generalharness8266 4 года назад

      @@frackcha it was.

  • @XeonXR6
    @XeonXR6 Год назад

    The spinning hoop had me burst out in laugher. Well done! :D

  • @snowsnow4231
    @snowsnow4231 4 года назад

    Man you need to make an RC model business, you make some money. RC paramotor is a real thing.

  • @ethoslogospathos
    @ethoslogospathos 3 года назад +6

    6:19 And she said, "Daddy, I want a hula-hoop flyer now!" (Charlie and the Chocolate Factory quote).

  • @GoExperimental
    @GoExperimental 4 года назад +191

    What slow-mo camera are you using brother?

  • @bennib91
    @bennib91 4 года назад

    I really hope, that you will give the first version another go, I'd love to see it fly!

  • @MrSpasticdancer
    @MrSpasticdancer 3 года назад

    i learn a lot about engineering from you and i see now why simpler solutions are usually better