(Reaction) Pink Floyd - Another Brick in the Wall parts 1, 2, 3 (goodbye cruel world)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 авг 2020
- (Reaction) Pink Floyd - Another Brick in the Wall parts 1, 2, 3 (goodbye cruel world)
#PinkFloyd #AnotherBrickInTheWall
Original Video:
• Pink Floyd - Another B...
Twitter: / whatitdodave
$1 Patreon: / whatitdohomies
A special thank you to the Patrons below!
Cheryl Williams
Ima Catherine Maia
Darcy Ducharme
David Spivey
Archie Goodwin
marathone
Michael Matthews
This Channel Sucks
Rev Show
David Adrian
Kyle Anderson
Oleksander Kerod
Jon Appul
Mark Adams
Michael Henry
Crungus Hakooter
Rebecca Sheehan-Plotkin
Mike Cummins
David Valdez
Nicholas Bellone
Wari Wahab
Harvester of sorrow
Sinnoh ,
Tom Colling
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS 
Развлечения
You really didn't hear it all the way through. There are 26 interconnected tracks in the album; it is one long story line. The English education system is just one brick among the many bricks he sings about through the first 13 tracks of the album. The smashing of the TVs at the end signal his complete isolation from the world, the source of all his problems. The last 13 tracks are about the world he creates in his head. You will have to listen to see how that turns out and then the twist at the end to see how close you listen.
The best way to understand the story is to listen to the whole album.
100% This, "The Wall" is an album that has to be taken as a whole. you cant pull singles, or hits out of the album and fully appreciate them. This entire album is a single experience.
The album is a story and thats why they made a film on it.
I agree
The wall refers to an emotional wall hes building around him to block off reality, and each of the people from his father to the teachers to his wife, his mother, and band managers and so on are all adding to his slipping put of reality and behind his emotional wall, they are all just bricks in his wall.
You almost have to hear the album as a whole to understand the depth of the story.
Another Brick in the Wall (part 2) was a huge hit, went to #1.
You mentioned a teacher's perspective.
My daughter's third grade teacher was at our house with her daughter for a girl scout meeting years ago. My daughter was in the basement with Another Brick in the Wall part 2 blasting. Her teacher went down and talked with her. It was one of her favorite songs. With the song calling out all of the flaws in the school system, she thought it was great.
You really have to listen to this masterpiece in one go...from beginning to end. It's a work of art.
Album sold 22 million copies, 1979. Roger who wrote the album (again) lead vocals, and "if you don't eat your meat, you can't have any pudding."
Loving your thoughtful reception of the music. You’re hitting on the emotions the band intended for this narrative (concept album/film) really fast. Love love love a new person discovering Floyd. I see them as the Beethoven of the 20th century.
Pink Floyd will remain in your head now that you have opened the door!! One of the best bands out of Britain🎉 This song was very popular when it first came out & remains up there for PF fans & those now discovering this fantastic band . Please listen from beginning to end, watch the video to get the full meaning of the song 💎💜☮️ sending greetings from 🇨🇦
'The Wall' differs a little from other Pink Floyd albums in that it is fictional theater. Some say 'Rock Opera', and while an apt description, that label never sounds right to my ear.
'The Wall' is a story of a man's descent into madness.
Roger Waters drew heavily from his own life giving 'Pink', the protagonist, a similar start in life as his own... losing his father to war when he was an infant.
Apartheid South Africa banned 'Part 2'. Apparently they didn't appreciate the anti-establishment themes.
Great reaction! Send more!
Yes pink Floyd are a English group and the kids singing in the song were from a school in London hence their London accents and this was from the seventies, the music from the album was from the film The Wall to understand it a bit more watch the film it's very good and strange, the lead actor in it is Bob Geldof the lead singer of boomtown rats.
Another Brick In the Wall part 2 is my favorite. I love it when those kids start singing.
The Wall refers to a psychological barrier "Pink" creates as a safe place and shield from the forced conformity.
But as many other comments point out, the entire album is Pinks life story so picking out a few tracks is tricky.
It's a double album so might be a major project to do videos for the entire thing.
As an alternative Dark Side of the Moon (another concept album) is a single album where again each track transitions from one into the next.
If you want to see the guys "back in the day" then as an "older" Brit who grew up listening to PK I would suggest taking a peek at Echoes - Live at Pompeii where the guys play in an empty Roman Amphitheater with no audience apart from maybe a bunch of ghosts.
Anyway it's a trip, so if you want to risk it, buckle up Dorethy Kansas is about to go bye bye! 😂
Beautiful guitar solo by Dave Gilmour.
Idk if part 2 will apply to an American teacher since pink floyd is a British band but feel free to ask
Man, if you have a Jazz / Sax background Pink Floyd has some killer songs with Sax.
Shine on You Crazy Diamond, Money, and Us and Them.
Shine on You Crazy Diamond is one of the greatest pieces of modern music IMHO
You should watch the movie the wall it all go's together. It's amazing.
Pt 1... Young boy who is trying to understand why his dad isn't around.
Pt 2... Older boy who is building his defenses to the world in the wrong way, just from not knowing any better.
Pt 3... Young adult who has isolated himself; anger and resentment incorporated, as he's never known any different way to be.
If you watch the film version, it may offer a bit of context for all of the stuff heard in the background. The movie is basically an album length music video.
It was fascinating listening to your reaction to this, especially when you're trying to figure out what Another brick in the Wall meant, and seemingly thinking about the teachers as the subjects of the songs.
It was fascinating because I remember when I first heard this album and I was trying to figure it out for the first time, and I listened to the end tire album in one sitting, so it seemed to make a lot more sense to me than it did to you.
I would definitely say that you listened to these songs the wrong way.
This album should to be listened to from the first track to the last track in order to be understood. It is a story song. If you start watching a movie 10 minutes in, then jump in another 5 minutes, then jump in another 20 minutes, and turn the movie off, you will be confused as hell! That's the same thing with this album.
I hope by now you've listened to the entire album all the way through without pauses and learned that the album is following a man named Pink.
In my opinion, Pink Floyd is one of the most brilliant bands that have ever existed, and their way to produce music, while being innovative, has never really been copied.
I'm hoping you will listen to all of their music to get a better idea of who they are. Definitely listen to the Piper's at the Gates of Dawn, their first album, with many of the songs written by Syd Barrett, the inspiration of Pink Floyd.
And read his story.
Maaaaan, you need to hear Dogs, Shine on You Crazy Diamond and ECHOES!
Watch the whole movie (wide screen); you'll understand the meaning of the songs. Listening of the songs after that you'll find out that this music has nested in your mind for ever.
He builds a metaphorical wall around him and disconnects from the world and any problem or suffering in his life becomes more brick in the wall
That's not purposeful distortion, it's a bad reproduction.
True. It’s actually supposed be almost a whisper. I don’t know how or Goodbye Cruel World is so loud and distorted here.
Watching the rock opera on film has a great deal artistic symbolism and should be appreciated in its entirety☮️❤️
This song is a commentary on the British education system of the 1970's. The kids are processed by the schools to produce kids that fit the system. Individuality was discouraged. Uniformity was everything. Hence the title Just Another Brick in the Wall.
I like that interpretation of the teacher imposing their viewpoint on students as an example of the teachers "building a wall" using the students as bricks. Never thought of it that way.
You HAVE to listen to this album all the way through. You'd love it.
You're right on both theories
Negative things that happen to us throughout our lives are bricks. We sometimes build a wall between ourselves and others.
Great Reaction to a Great Band and a Deep Song... makes you think 🤔
The distortion at the end was not intentional, it was bad audio version. The original is extremely clear with an almost empty echo behind it which to signifies the emptiness he’s feeling at that point of the story
Great!
You received some good points in the comments. Take the suggestions to watch the movie. You will enjoy it
Part 2 is capturing the essence of British education 50 years ago. However, the theme is still important: It is the purpose of the education system beat individuality out of kids so that they can be good submissive adults.
Another Brick In The Wall part 2 was the last number 1 hit of the 1970’s and the 1st of the 1980’s.
Love watching guitar players on you-tube cover the solo to ABITW-2 - it’s so intricate.
The wall is a wall that blocks out how he truly feels and acts.
Pink Floyd albums, especially this one, are a testament to sequencing. One bleeds into one, into the next.
It's why I hate hearing them on the radio.
Please react to massive attack “ angel”, “ inertia creeps”, “group four” or any other. And to tricky, any of his songs. Idk why nobody reacts to the british trip hop, its amazing.
I've wondered the same thing. I suspect they are 'blockers'. But I agree. Massive Attack are an untapped reactionary goldmine (though not quite on the level of PF).
great job bro. u gotta do Dogs by Pink Floyd!!!
In part 2 Pinks overprotective mother and abusive teachers became bricks in the wall in part 3 Pink dismisses everyone he knows as just bricks in the wall.
Good reaction unlike the majority of people reacting you have an interest in music and an insight to what it's about plus a vocabulary..
Can I introduce the frames or the lead singer Glen hansard ( once ) film
I dont know what's wrong with your sound setup dude, but the original version doesn't have distorted vocals on Goodbye Cruel World!
It’s not me. It’s who ever uploaded the video I listened too. But some people are saying the original do have distorted vocals. Idk.
Try to find the wall movie.
Yes its a very English band.
Could see you struggle to understand the scottish teacher lol, if you dont eat your meat you cant have any pudding lol
Part 2 was a massive single worldwide and was banned some places. Difficult to get the context without listening to the whole album. Like opening a book half way and expecting to know the plot. Cool reaction
Finally someone doing is at least partially right...
Yep, must listen to the full album or even watch the movie (think of it as a long video clip), the final distortion is not purposeful, the compiler of the video you reviewed increased the volume of the last track, originally the voice is very low (because he is suposedly singing from behind the wall he just built to seal himself from the world)
It's great that you listened to a block of songs, although you missed some context by skipping some.
Most of their albums were first released on vinyl, not CD. I'd suggest googling the albums to get the track order on each side, then listen to them one side at a time. The Wall was a double album. So 4 sides.
I had a very hard time digesting and adapting to the monotony of Swedish school system from 1970-1979, and that was before a lot of weird names were invented on my so-called symptoms because I had a hard time sitting still and concentrating on the teachers' monotony lesson.
The political school system can never be wrong so let's find the flaws in the kids instead.
In the school's to day, they had pointed me out as a kind of letter child you know as ADHD but in fact I was just a child with too much energy to sit still and listen to something so monotonous and boring like most of the old teacher's presented the lessons, most of them should have changed professions a long time ago instead of just wait for retirement.
Listening to several parts of this album and coming up with the meaning is like reading three random chapters in a book and deciding you know what the story is. You really need to see the movie or at least listen to the whole album. Thanks for the review.
Also listen to dark side of the moon
Roger Waters lost his father in WW2. A lot of Pink Floyd music speaks to loss.
Watch the movie. Shed a tear. Change your life.
By the way, the children's choir was not paid. There was a scandal.
Hope you watch the movie. Context is everything with The Wall. 🤘
Skip the movie. Listen to the album all the way through - several times.
very perceptive observation-wait until you see the movie
purposely-the movie will explain it all.
ABITW got the radio play but now has become trite by overplaying. “Nobody Home” never gets the love (lol) but it’s such a sweet tribute to all the members in PF. If you look around you’ll find a pic of Syd wearing his yellow Gohill boots. Wright, Gilmour, and even Waters get “sideways” referenced, poetically. Fun fact: Waters said it was last song written for the album... sort of “for filler.”
1979.
Check out the movie it is really deep.
Pink Floyd siempre te hará pensar . se refiere a ciertos educadores en los años 50 y 60 eso ocurría en casi toda Europa,
Couldn't do it without the video. Sorry.
It's the sound track to THE MOVIE...
Your levels are too quiet. lost all the dynamics of the sound.
This is an old video when I was still figuring out details. I recorded this a few months back on my old channel before it was hacked. I've grown a lot as a content creator since then.
@@whatitdodave I'll check out your newer stuff.
You should start at the beginning of the album and not skip over tracks. You're missing huge parts of the story listening to it your way and it probably won't make much sense to you. A lot happens between parts 2 and 3 that you missed. The sound of that phone ringing is important!
Absolute rubbish! Get on with your work.