(Reaction) Pink Floyd - Time (2011 Remastered)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- (Reaction) Pink Floyd - Time (2011 Remastered)
#PinkFloyd #Time
Original Video:
• Pink Floyd - Time (201...
Twitter: / whatitdodave
$1 Patreon: / whatitdohomies
A special thank you to the Patrons below!
Cheryl Williams
Ima Catherine Maia
Darcy Ducharme
David Spivey
Archie Goodwin
marathone
Michael Matthews
This Channel Sucks
Rev Show
David Adrian
Kyle Anderson
Oleksander Kerod
Jon Appul
Mark Adams
Michael Henry
Crungus Hakooter
Rebecca Sheehan-Plotkin
Mike Cummins
David Valdez
Nicholas Bellone
Wari Wahab
Harvester of sorrow
Sinnoh ,
Tom Colling
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
![Punk Rocker's First Time Heariing Pink Floyd - Time (2011 Remastered) [Reaction & Review]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zaFC4hrVqh4/mqdefault.jpg)
![Punk Rocker's First Time Heariing Pink Floyd - Time (2011 Remastered) [Reaction & Review]](/img/tr.png)
Do yourself a favour and listen to the entire Dark Side Of The Moon album...it will change your life.
Straight up. The album you take to the grave.
Especially if you do some LSD.
Seriously, do this. Shut off your phone, no interruptions, no pauses, just take it all in at once in one stream. Go back and relisten to the details that you want to revisit afterwards. This album is a journey. There is a reason it was on the Billboard charts for over 13 years straight, from 1973 until the mid 80's, despite all the changes that happened to music over that time period. Masterpiece is an overused term, but if there was ever a case where it applies, it's Dark Side of the Moon.
@@user-gm5by6dj3d Weed is fine too
I hope everyone notices that this had 60 likes and Zero dislikes..........Hmmmmmmmmm
He's right. This album was written to be listened to as one long song. Also, that heartbeat is actually underneath every song from the beginning all the way to the end. Everytime I listen to this album I hear new shit I hadn't heard before. Finally, this album is widely considered to be one of the highest quality audio productions of all time and is a standard for testing high end audio systems.
Takes a lifetime to hear everything that's going on on Dark Side...
Listen to the 5.1 surround sound version of the album.
I really enjoy watching people listen to many of these songs, and not just Pink Floyd/Dark Side of the Moon songs, but man, I give away all my youtube enjoyment if every person would sit in a dark room, headphones on and listen to these many amazing albums from beginning to finish. Especially, since I can tell so many of the reaction posters are music people and should really experience it like all of us older people have. I'm not even 50 and I have to call myself old in this case.
Tool don't hold a candle to Pink Floyd.
seriously. Everyone who has reacted to this thinks tool is worth a shit compared to Pink Floyd. Tool is great, but pink Floyd will always be Pink Floyd.
@@katiesmith7946 Just sounds like bias banter to me. Tool is certainly on the same level with Pink Floyd. If you don't know that, it's because you don't understand music, you just hear it. Tool, by technical standards are leagues beyond almost any band in existence. Floyd is probably the only band who's better from a creative and technical view. Discrediting Tool the way you both do, proves your ignorance to greatness. To me, Floyd is number one, Tool is number two.
Facts! Tool is great, just not Pink Floyd great.
There only one pink floyd,over 250 million album, 2 albums in top 10 of all time.The band that did more for the way concert are done today,they were pioneers of there time.Tool are a good band but pink Floyd are at a different level.
Merle is better than tool
The metronome sound was a bass guitar with the strings clamped.
What is so amazing is that the intro is time itself. Dark, slowly creeping up on you and you can't do anything about it. We all are affected by time and at last it will get us. And the rest of the song is about how we should but can't really appreciate the time that was given to us. But maybe in the very end it is not that dark and horrible as we think (the iron bell)
Physics: A white light shone through a prism breaks down into all the colors you see there. Make of that what you wish.
Breaks down into “Any Colour You Like,” actually 😉
@PaulEdwards I see what you did there 😆
@@Lchristyhastings And changes reality.....
I've been listening to this album for over 40 years and never heard that heartbeat in the background until today! You need to hear the entire album. It's amazing! Check "Wish You Were Here"...the album, not just the song. Two of my all-time favorite albums...
Actually you listened two songs: Time (ends in "tough i have more to say") and "Breathe (reprise)" , now i suggest to go on with "The great gig in the sky", of course listening to the full album is way better. Now for these three tracks, i see "time" as the realization of time running up, a mature person realizing that there si not much time left, Breathe Reprise is, in may point of view, old age, slow and contemplative and hering the distant call of "the iron bell" that marks the end of the race, and finally The grat gig in the sky, without lyrics but in a wonderful vocal arrangement marks a journey trough the stages of mourning and duel. It would be nice to know your interpretation and i guess that you may like the experience.
Tool are great but pink floyd are the masters, tool are like floyd not floyd are like tool. Great reactions
Good Review of a Classic Song.
Enjoyed it.
RONNIE
SCOTLAND 🎸🎸
Conceptually somewhere around the level of Tool, he says he's heard. Lol.
Who is he listening to???
Ford Prefect, but you do need to admit that he also said he isn't familiar with Pink Floyd. Given.. umm, time..
I've heard people compare Tool to Floyd, but never the other way around
@@johnny85er Tool is the closest thing to Floyd there is, not better, but don't discredit them.
@@destinzenoda1045 opeth is comperable imo
@@jasonmain6398 To each their own, I don't think Opeth is even close to Floyd or TOOL. I like some of their music, but.. I can't possibly compare them to two of the greats. Just my opinion.
Absolutely Loved this reaction (of one of my all time favorite pieces of music). Great deconstruction intellectually and musically.
Try to reverse your idea of the cover art. The white light coming in from the left, indicating the start of life. While the colours exiting to the right reflect the stages of your life. Showing you that there is a wide spectrum of life for you to explore.
You analysis is really good!
That guitar solo description earned a sub
I've always read the "hanging on in quiet desperation" line as being tied to the surrounding lines. "You run and you run to catch up with the sun, but it's sinking", meaning your time is running out, every year feels like it's getting shorter, it feels like you're busy every day getting things done, but you increasingly don't find the time to do the things you want to do. But rather than make any radical change to your life to fix that, you "hang on in quiet desperation", running down the clock, until "The time is gone, the song is over, Thought I'd something more to say." - i.e. you've run out of time and you haven't done all the things you hoped to do.
Excellent reaction. You have a good sense of picking up the detailed nuances and broader concepts, especially with only having just heard it for the very first time.
Sometimes I think God Himself speaks through Pink Floyd's music 😅
Seriously though, it's some of the best that has ever been written. Sincerely...
Wait until you get to the next song on the album, The Great Gig in the Sky, which is about the experience of dying. The album, release in 1973, stayed on the charts for 15 YEARS straight, and soon returned for a total of 950 weeks. The album is certified 16x Platinum in the U.K.
If you have Jazz background, check out Steely Dan and Jeff Beck. Fusion? Return To Forever.
The Dark Side of the Moon is considered by many to be the greatest album ever recorded, and I concur. It is an experience. As wonderful as it is you’re now introduced to a hint of this transformative album, I HIGHLY recommend turning off the lights, lying down with good headphones, and playing it from start to finish. There’s times when it may seem weird or unsettling, times when the groove is insanely good, and most of it will evoke some of the best imagery you’ll have listening to music. It’s food for your soul.
Also, white light is composed of all colors, and a prism separates the white beam into it's components.
PF is a really good rabbit hole. Rock On, young dude.❤️😷
“Sounds” like a metronome... I think it’s remarkable just how low-tech the recordings are for DSOTM. This is Floyd in an experimental period... trying stuff on around Abbey Road... not “goofing around” but really exploring instruments, amps, boards... everything. Collaborative. Written and put together with flair and unbridled creativity. It’s sort of fun to imagine the process.
very great react - thanks
Quite perceptive interpretation of how the lyrics and the music's structure relates to the main theme of time. The lyric about quiet desperation is from Thoreau: "The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation". And indeed, the song after this is about death: "The Great Gig in the Sky".
You need to listen to"The great gig in the sky" right after " Time" uninterrupted and your explanation of this song will come full circle ✌️
The idea of "quite desperation" comes from the philosopher Henry David Thoreau:
“The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation. What is called resignation is confirmed desperation. From the desperate city you go into the desperate country, and have to console yourself with the bravery of minks and muskrats. A stereotyped but unconscious despair is concealed even under what are called the games and amusements of mankind. There is no play in them, for this comes after work. But it is a characteristic of wisdom not to do desperate things..”
Its darkly, very darkly sad about what Syd Barrett did to himself with LSD. He really, mentally zombified himself as NOBODY knew anything about what that garbage does to the MIND! :.|
The 'hanging on in quiet desperation' line....realize that the English musicians of that era were born and raised during and in the aftermath of the Germans bombings of London and many cities in WWII. It affected their music in a profound way.
DSotM sold over 45,000,000 units and charted for somewhere over 15 years, so that might give you a hint about the work as a whole.
Each track transitions into the next so def best listened to in order to avoid weird breaks / cuts. For example the last section of Time is actually a repris of a track before.
Having lyrics to hand is helpful to start, and Floyd always have something to say in the poetry.
There are quite a few references to Syd Barret a founding band member who suffered from mental illness and the effects of drugs.
DSotM is a great way in, but Floyd is a deep deep rabbit whole, if you go down it, then buckle up Dorethy, Kansas is about to go bye bye! 😉
I read online that Dark side of the Moon has sold 200 million's album's, it was a 5-6 years ago but i do not remember on which site it was and Michael Jackson album Thriller is the only one that sold more with 400 million's but it's more like meanstrem music to me so it does not count.
But to day i read on one site D.S.o.t.M.sold over 45-50 millions and a another site says over 100 millions so how to interpret right?, considering that it is 50 years soon they released the album and I think they have not had any correct album statistics the last 20 years, so to me, 45 million's sounds like 20-30 year old statistics.
I remember Pink Floyd's appearing at Live 8 -2005-, and the week after that gig, P.F. album sale increased with 700% so to me 200 is more truthful today.
ABBA has sold 30-40 million's and i do not think they are that close to P.F.- D.S.o.t.M.
@@gurra63able the figure of 45 million just comes from RollingStone Magazine 2018
So I'm sure it's much higher than that figure, so to avoid getting told I've over played it, I just put "over 45M"
In any case it's at least amongst the top selling of all time😊
@@philshorten3221 I wonder where R.S. magazin got ther information and how old it was then. There was never any criticism of you Phil Shorten I like what you texted but I'm frustrated at how hard it is to get something similar to the true number's in today's information world.
45-50-millions is what i read in the mid. 1990's.
Put on some quality headphones, lay back, maybe catch a buzz and listen to this whole album from beginning to end. You'll thank me.
I have listened to this song (and the rest of the album) HUNDREDS of times. I was 19 when it was released. My interpretation is, it tells the story of a typical life. The clock chimes seem to be conception to birth. The rhythmic intro makes me think of childhood. The first verse is the thoughts of the young adult time. The guitar solo makes me thing of midlife and the time of getting lost in the work-a-day world of living. The last verse is going through old age and then inevitable death. The song titled "Time" ends with "thought I'd something more to say". You mentioned the line "Hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way", I think that is the person in the final days still trying to cling to what life (time) is left. Notice that they transition to another, different, tune. The reprise, which is the final verse of the song, "Breath In The Air". I think it is intentionally added to the "track" to mean, the "afterlife". "Home, home again, I like to be here when I can". "It's good to warm my bones beside the fire", the warmth of pure love. In the last line it sounds like, in the distance, you hear the songs of angelic prayer. I like to remember that songs of that era was more forms of poetry that was put to music.
You need to do yourself a favour and have a listen to Pink Floyd - Echoes. It has been my favourite song of Floyd ever since I saved up enough and bought the LP back in 1972. For all the haters I know the album came out in 71 but I couldn’t afford it then just being a young kid
Should add it’s brilliant watching them perform it in Pompeii back in the 70s
Some call that horror "existential dread" ... The organ chords following the chimes that open the song remind me of both 2001: A Space Odyssey and Close Encounters of the Third Kind -- two movies you ought to see if you haven't already. You're the second YT reactor I've watched listen to this song to detect a hint of bluegrass in it. I don't hear it myself. Quiet desperation might be summed up by the British expression "keep a stiff upper lip" or perhaps Thoreau "The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation. What is called resignation is confirmed desperation."
When you listen to Pink Floyd's Comfortably Numb, make sure you use the Live Pulse Performance!
Yes! He MUST hear the Live Pulse version! OMG! It’s at a whole new level! ❤️
The song slows at the end because it is the next song., "Breathe (Reprise)" Since the album is about the stress and pressures of life, "Time" is the irrevocability of time lost and the constant pressure to make use of it the older one gets. Quiet desperation is reflective. Hindsight being 20/20 different choices could have been made, but it doesn't really help to change the future or does it? If there is one central theme in all the lyrics written by Roger Waters it is that it takes work just to get up and out of bed and go out the front door and make the best use of life in spite of the constant impediments. Sitting at home thinking of great things doesn't get it done. This is explored more deeply in the album, "The Wall".
They arent on the level of Tool...but Tool might be close to the Pink Floyd level
Uhhhh Not a fucking chance in hell or anywhere else
Listening to random Pink Floyd songs is like coming into a conversation halfway through a sentence. You can be easily confused and miss the point as many tie into the preceding and following songs. There are about 5 albums whose songs are best listened to at the very least in order, if not in one sitting. This is due to the songs blending into each other as well as telling a story. This will provide you the best understanding.
I enjoyed this reaction. 👍. A comment I read I quite liked, "Pink Floyd is the sound of feelings". Enjoy !
Amazing song also by live PULSE
Progressive Rock*
But yea, Floyd describe the human experience, recognisable and resonant to all.
'the English way' - just grin and bear it, stiff upper-lip, quiet desperation, but never show it in case it makes someone else uncomfortable, etc.
Just realized that I've been watching your videos for months and somehow had failed to subscribe. Problem corrected, my brother. Thank you for being real and doing your thing.
The line about the English way, I believe, is in reference to the English being very stoic, and reserved..Much time spent on being reserved and proper, and not exactly free-spirited...I do believe a lot of the great music that came out of Britain in the 60's/70's was in spite of that reserved way of life. They (English youth) were rejecting, and rebelling against those norms.
The rest of the album is just as good, depending on your taste. Time is my favorite track but just barely. If you have a jazz background, the guitar solo is pretty simple but his composition is perfect up to the crescendo, then it relaxes and loses its intensity. Most of the album is diatonic but a few songs modulate keys, a lot. Really, if you liked this, there's more stuff on there you will like. Oh, the first song on side 2, Money, is in an odd time signature 7/4. "Hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way" is Roger Waters' blending of two rather famous expressions you can Google, "The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation (an American)" and the British government motivational poster saying prior and during the ominous time of World War II, "Keep calm and carry on". I've never considered the Pink Floyd lyrics to be especially awesome. They're good enough, and that's good enough for me. Sometimes lyrics are less about some awesome truth, and more about saying something cool that just sounds good in the song :)
Sup Dave! After 30+ years of resonating to this album, i had yet to imagine that point of view. Thanks for the perspective.
Music, a never ending well of wonder.
David Giloure guitarist for Pink Floyd. Comfortably Numb live at Pompei!
On the same level as Pink Floyd ??? That is almost laughable. Nobody is on the dame level as Pink Floyd, as you are about to find out. You have yet to scratch the surface of their talent. The messages will blow your mind and the music will amaze you. Enjoy my friend, you are in for one hell of a journey.
The best description I've heard about Pink Floyd's music is that it is soul penetrating.
Anyway, about the lines, you asked about:
The line quiet desperation. Was penned by the prolific author Henry David Thoreau. The quote is “The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation. ".
My interpretation is that "quiet desperation" is desperation on the inside and doesn't look to be such. You can tell when someone is overtly desperate. The quiet type would be the desperation that is internal to the person. The person sees their life slipping away and realizes they may not ever reach their goals or even what their goals "should" be.
The last part of the song where he refers to coming home and warming himself by the fire I think refers to someone getting older. You have fallen into a routine and give up on the big dreams. Just coming home and warming yourself by the fire is what works for you at this point.
I suspect that the ending lines about far away across the field The tolling of the iron bell… and the faithful kneeling is a reference to religion. The older you get, knowing you don’t have much time left, the more you become interested in the afterlife.
Please please please do more Floyd. Comfortably Numb (live at Pulse) for the insane guitar solo. Album version of Echoes (23 minutes) to hear the most beautiful underwater journey in music history. You really seem to get them just from this one song, and I bet you’ll fall in love.
Wow, absolute interesting and comprehensible Interpretation 👍
Thanks for your reactions friend.. Coming Back to Life pretty please :)) The whole song is an eargasm ✌
That is a prism and it breaks the light into its distinct wavelengths. 😂😂 One thing going in and a bunch of different comes out of that one thing. Like a reaction to a bunch of comments. 😂😂
You're hitting it. Time is a track that focuses on time going by from childhood all the way through to where you're at the point of looking back when you reach an older age. The line "time is getting shorter" at the 3rd set of lyrics spells it out. The entire album is interconnected songs leading from birth to the end of the game
The ethereal crystalline guitar of David Gilmour is from another planet
Wow buddy I absolutely LOVE your interpretation of Pink Floyds ""Time"" we've all got pretty much the same meaning from it but when you elaborated about the triangle it really got me to thinking about it and YEAH ...... I see what you are saying!!! Awesome take on this legendary tune! Thanks so much!!
I love your interpratations. That is David Gilmour on the guitar solo. It's mostly his voice, too. When he does the solos in concerts he takes it up a notch.
Great video man! You should check out The Skatalites
yeah cover art is just a prism. now i dont know precisely if that has additional meaning, just pointing out what it is.
the triangle is a prism, if you shine a beam of light into a prism it will create a rainbow on the other side. You got it just the other way.
Pink Floyd.........te hará pensar
Pink Floyd's "Comfortably Numb" Live Pulse Performance= Best thing i have ever heard.
You need to watch the 2016 Live at Pompeii Version....So much better
Definitely!
It's a prism one light create all colours your trying too hard to sound philosophical.
This is progressive rock. Not metal.
P.S. Congrats on your wee boy! God bless!
Divine light is what we start with and the choices we make in life are the rainbow
I enjoyed your reaction.
I saw this when it was first released in 1973 performed in West London in Earls Court with 18,000 others and the ticket cost £1 or $1.34 ...lol
Since then 47 years have passed and I got so involved in playing and watching Sports, including Professionally that suddenly in 2017 if was if I came out of a Four Decades-long Coma and now I am an OLD AGE Pensioner which for me seems insane as a Single Guy in London so take every opportunity as they do NOT always come round again :)
Isleofskye you lucky man, would have loved to see the original line up live. Must have been incredible :)
Thanks, Malcolm.
It was great and somehow overhead in the Indoor Arena they got a plane flying over as I recall...:)
Expensive though £1 ....Led Zeppelin were only 75 Pence @ Wembley Arena and " Up In The Gods" for both Deep Purple one week and Creedence Clearwater Revival the next week @ The Royal Albert Hall were both only 25 Pence rather than send us away. Happy Days , my friend :)
Try Obscured by Clouds
I really love your perception on the intro. Ill here it differently now!
Without knowing what the underlying theme of all of PINK FLOYD music is, you will never understand the meanings of the words or the songs. Many folks have no clue about the meaning of their songs... truly Mind-Blowing when you piece it all together.
Watch THE WALL. The Movie. It will explain to you about the former band member Sid Barrett that lost his mind via the needle. Animals, Dark Side, Wish u Were Here... all about Sid Barrett and their way to tell his story by speaking to him in Musical terms. Asking him to abandon the world he created in his mind, and come back to reality. All the albums talk about the evil of Money and Lawyers, and how they prey on the innocent. (Pigs from Animals)
PS: Must listen to Animals.... It is by far their best album from a true fan viewpoint.
PS:PS: Pink Floyd's had hidden secret backwards messages on "The Wall Album" First pressing to win concert tickets to the first NY City Show. My friend got 2 which included a limo ride to NYC. Song was Young Lust right before the vocals start.
Animals was more about politics (unfortunately) than Syd. Syd didn't have a needle dope problem, he overdosed on LSD. I love PF. Dark Side and Wish You Were Here with the exception of "Hava A Cigar" are all about Syd. The Wall was also about Roger Water's self loathing about his past. Not a big fan of the Wall.
Love the harmonics at the beginning
Dude, you're over-analyzing the prism thing. The Prism on the album cover was just one of many options that it's creator artist Strom Thorgersen came up with for the 1973 Dark Side of the Moon album cover. He presented all of his drawings to them to choose which one they wanted for the album cover. They agreed on the prism
Although over the many years since the albums release, there have been many, MANY theories as to what the use of the Prism on the album cover really means. Actually in real life, it has no meaning at all,..... It's just the one they liked for the cover of their new album.
This explanation comes from David Gilmour in an interview with the BBC in the late 90s
I over analyze a lot. Kind of a thing with my channel lol. Thanks for the info.
Metallica- Nothing else matters
excellent perception of the message
Disappointed that you think this has any musical likeness to Tool. This isn't metal at all BTW, it's simply rock, some might say psychedelic rock 🎸
I was not relating the genre, just the fact that it’s conceptual and makes me think, like TOOL does.
Pink Floyd's level? No one.
"On the level of Tool"! LMAO! :)
Classic song. Was actually our unofficial senior song my high school senior song. 💯💯
Wish you was here is another 🙌🏻🙌🏻
Don't overthink it.
british rock at its best
dastuff is great
Hey man I've always liked your unique insight. You usually bring something intellectually distinct to the table, vs. the main stream. I thought I'd finally comment because - per the other many comments - the entire album is a stand out experience, and I would love to hear your end-to-end review of it. That would be awesome!
Way wrong!!!!
I think the prism turning a single bead of light into a rainbow is a sign of the times the album was released and a proclamation of what an impact this album would have on music. As well as a symbol of the introspection in the lyrics and soundscape.
Fair warning, if you start doing PF reactions, there'll be a group who will swoop in and try to convince you that Animals is their best album. In reality it was kinda a failed concept album that the rest of the band didn't put much effort into because Waters was becoming such an ego maniac. They brought it back around to do The Wall, but Waters was out after that album and the B-side follow up album. This album, Meddle and Wish You Were Here are their peak masterpieces. PF without Waters put out good albums too, but it wasn't quite the same.
Thats what I love about pink floyd, u hear the lyrics and sink into the song like hypnosis. No one really knows what the lyrics mean, what is important is how the listeners interpretation of them brings deep emotion which is individual with every person
I have a five year old, just turned 40, this song hits harder now that my 30’s are behind me and it starts to feel like what’s the point of what I have done the last decade. Interesting take on the album cover, may be reading way more into it than was intended, I think they probably just thought a prism looked cool.
One of my favorite songs of all time, from one of my favorite albums of all time. You made an astute observation which I have never heard before, equating the guitar solo in the middle, to the mid part of our lives, that we are basically living our guitar solos. That a beautifully profound thought.
On the album cover, you do realize this triangle is a prism. White light enters the prism and the prism produces the colors coming out.
Yep. Their music and lyrics makes one contemplate life...
👍
On the bluegrass thing, yeah, your wrong.😁
Always thought the art on the cover was light passing through a prism
That “triangle” is a prism that breaks up into the colors of the rainbow when light hits it.
Its not an album to be dissected it is to be felt the album is an experience.
Still far too quiet. consider this Dave. if the volume is too high I can turn it down. but if the levels are too low your end, i can't turn it up. listening to Pink Floyd at the levels on this and other stuff of your's that I've listened to. is a waste of my time.
Nobody else is having issues. Might be on your end. I’m listening to this with headphones and the volume is loud.
I left a comment to this video about 8 months ago. And your saying it was posted a day ago? What's up with that?
Old channel was hacked 3 months ago, since then Ive created a new channel. I just got access back to my old videos 3 days ago so I started moving them here.
“Hanging on in quiet Desperation is the English way” German invasion of Britain WWII
Tool?
Tool?
Uhhhhhh.........Tool?
Hey man
Dark side of the moon is the album that talks about life, it's a master piece