500W VS 750W E-bike Motors | Does Wattage Matter On Hills?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 95

  • @ElectricBikeReport
    @ElectricBikeReport  2 года назад +2

    E-Bike Question of the Day ⚡🚴 What matters the most to you when it comes to the motor on your e-bike? Let us know in the comments below 👇🏼👇🏼👇🏼

    • @imprial
      @imprial 2 года назад

      sped

    • @buffalomind6838
      @buffalomind6838 2 года назад +1

      Climbing & reliability. If I can get speed in there which is not difficult depending on what type of motor you choose.

    • @pedlpower
      @pedlpower 2 года назад

      Riding an e-bike is like jogging on a Segway.

  • @snip_king428
    @snip_king428 2 года назад +28

    Most people use these for hills, so its actually very important.

    • @ElectricBikeReport
      @ElectricBikeReport  2 года назад +3

      It's certainly among the larger aspects of their appeal for many riders.

    • @johnsheetz6639
      @johnsheetz6639 2 года назад

      Exactly!

    • @ten-ub4xd
      @ten-ub4xd 2 года назад

      Indeed, i live on Mt Everist been looking for a decent Ebike for where i live

  • @InfinitelyQurious
    @InfinitelyQurious 2 года назад +11

    It's very important for ebike riders to know that just because a bike has a 500 watt or 750 watt rated motor does not mean that the bike's battery or the bike's controller are actually putting out 500 or 750 watts. In order to truly know how much power is flowing to the motor, you need an independent current meter.

    • @thebravesirrobin.
      @thebravesirrobin. 2 года назад +5

      Busting out your DMM is certainly an idea but really the manufacturers should publish the microcontroller configuration and relevant electrical performance data. Info like this is almost always documented somewhere.

    • @InfinitelyQurious
      @InfinitelyQurious 2 года назад

      @@thebravesirrobin. I think manufacturers often want to boast and exaggerate, so I don't trust them. I'd like independent and objective numbers.

  • @Dang_Near_Fed_Up
    @Dang_Near_Fed_Up 2 года назад +10

    12 degrees for a 1,760ft (1/3 mile) is not too far off the peak angle and total length of my driveway to put this in perspective.
    What would really be useful is a 1 to 3 mile long 12 degree constant climb, where the motor's ability to produce power and do the climb would also be tempered and tested with the heat of the motor possibly shutting down the bike as well. Doing this with each bike and the same rider / load would give a much more standardized test and help people select the best bike for their application.
    I live in a rather hilly area and I am not a small guy (100 kilo) and an amputee to boot (above knee) so power is far more important to me than the average rider, I need more help climbing than most since I only have 1 leg to pedal with. Having a known standard for comparison on bikes would be very beneficial to me in choosing a bike (were I still looking, I chose to build my own).

    • @eideticgoone7035
      @eideticgoone7035 2 года назад +2

      Your use case is not typical. When traveling up long hills at slow speeds, initially hub motors can do quite well, their mass will absorb the heat generated sufficiently. But eventually, the heat will build up, and they they may either cut out or damage themselves. Too much heat can burn the insulation off the field coils, or even demagnetize the magnets a bit leading to reduced output.
      I think with your disability, it would benefit you to have a throttle as there will be many times when your legs are not in the position to produce torque, and this can save you.
      Since the hills you want to climb are long and steep, I would look for a bike with a mid-drive motor with a throttle as well as pedal assist. The company Bafang makes mid drive motors that fit this specification.
      They make DIY conversion kits as well as recently motors that can be used for purpose built bikes. The end result is not necessarily less expensive, but the motors have a reputation for being very powerful, which in your case I would want.
      Good luck.

    • @geraldkoth654
      @geraldkoth654 2 года назад

      Build a cyclone mid drive. build it as a single speed with a 14 tooth on the motor and 26 tooth on the wheel. Only use 1/2 x 1/8 chain and sprockets. It will tear up a 3/32 set in minutes. Get a 72 volt 30 amp hour battery. You will have all the power you can handle at roughly 20 plus mph, and it will make that speed up hills. Never a need to pedal. I have my cranks so that they both point down moped style. Much more comfortable. In your case, you can cut off the crank on your amputee side.

    • @Dang_Near_Fed_Up
      @Dang_Near_Fed_Up 2 года назад

      @@eideticgoone7035 My current ride is an ICE Adventure HD recumbent trike. I have a modified Bafang mid drive Small Block motor kit from lightningrodev. I am still trying to get the rest of the unit built (battery and lights etc), presently I am looking to install a Rohloff speedhub to allow for shifting while stopped, to help me launch without burning up the motor when forced to stop without down shifting first.
      I do have both a hand throttle and pedal sensors, and if I can ever squeeze together the cash for a proper battery I should have a nice ride, even climbing the hills I have to deal with here, with 1500 watts of mid drive. Presently I am stuck til I get a new prosthetic leg, which is being held up by red tape in the VA system.

    • @CARLOSINTERSIOASOCIA
      @CARLOSINTERSIOASOCIA Год назад

      Happy to know you decided to make your own bike, i think is the best approach, would really like to know how it goes and if any help needed I know some about ebike with special needs so glad if i can help

  • @dehoedisc7247
    @dehoedisc7247 Год назад +10

    You perpetuate the mistaken theory that electric motors are commonly rated as to producing "X" amount of power in watts. Absolute Nonsense. 250 watts 500 watts 750 watts 1000 watts Controllers (CONTROLLERS) are rated for WATTS. Electric motors are rated as to how much Torque they produce TORQUE. NOT WATTS>

    • @iraklimgeladze5223
      @iraklimgeladze5223 3 месяца назад

      Mine have 43tq and 500W, but problem is sustained power. Motor after few minutes of big incline turns off

  • @lessdatesmoreonmyplates1457
    @lessdatesmoreonmyplates1457 2 года назад +6

    250w is simply not enough for steep hills. The bare minimum is 500w but for people who weight over 220lbs you will need 750w minimum.

    • @edwardcating
      @edwardcating 2 года назад +1

      I have zero problem with my Avadar C3 (250 W/ 80 Nm/16-speed) riding 11 miles a day with an 1860 ft elevation gain. Zero.

    • @edwardcating
      @edwardcating 2 года назад

      BTW, most 750 W hub motors generate approximately the same 80 Nm of torque.

    • @Kumari_44
      @Kumari_44 11 месяцев назад

      250w works just fine for steep hills unless the person is really overweight.

  • @MotorheadRedo
    @MotorheadRedo 2 года назад +6

    The hill tests are full of good information, but I wonder how reliable these hub motors are? Some guy on RUclips said he is an e-bike mechanic and sees a lot more hub motor failures than mid drive motors. I guess because its much easier to lug a hub motor and see higher motor temperatures than on a mid drive motor.

    • @eastwood111
      @eastwood111 2 года назад +9

      A direct drive hub motor requires the least amount of maintenance because there’s no moving parts. The hub motors he’s reviewing on these bikes are called geared hub motors and the gears are typically made of plastic nylon so they wear out over time. Hub motors are actually very cheap so if you do burn one up it’s very easy to swap it out. Mid drive motors require way more maintenance because you’re involving the drive train which was not intended for the power of a motor. The chain stretches the gears wear out etc. quicker.
      I’ve built several E bikes and I love direct drive hub motors but with lots of power. Most production E bikes are all geared hub motors unless they’re mid drive.

    • @buffalomind6838
      @buffalomind6838 2 года назад +2

      @@eastwood111 the direct drive is pretty much bomb proof, and if you get it with lots of power it can be a great choice. Have you heard of the all new dual motor Juggernaut XD from Biktrix XD?

  • @SuperNewKittie
    @SuperNewKittie 2 года назад +8

    I am brand new to all of this. I have been trying to put together a spreadsheet to help me decide which bike is best for me. I have zero knowledge of the difference between 250W, 500W & 750W hub motors. My intuition tells me that 750W is way better than 250W. I am looking for a video that will explain this specifically, whether it's on hills or elsewhere.

    • @SynthApprentice
      @SynthApprentice 2 года назад +5

      The higher the wattage, the more overall power. The performance is better, but you're also drawing more power from the battery, which means less range.

    • @Danktendo
      @Danktendo 2 года назад +1

      @@SynthApprentice what battery would you recommend
      For a 750 front wheel ebike I’m building?

    • @SynthApprentice
      @SynthApprentice 2 года назад +1

      @@Danktendo Um. I guess 48v or higher? My 48v/14ah battery seems to suit my 750w mid drive just fine. I don't know if a front hub motor would make any difference or not. I'm still new at all of this, I'm learning as I go along.

    • @watchmanonthewall14
      @watchmanonthewall14 2 года назад +1

      @@SynthApprentice I, too am new to this but have been researching. The bike I'm going to test ride is 48v/14ah battery with a 750w HUB motor, but it is single gear. I am trying to get a bead on whether it will be sufficient on occasional steep hills. I fear that it will lack enough torque with only a single gear. Will be test riding very soon.

  • @user619tlsdca5
    @user619tlsdca5 2 года назад +2

    When you look at specs of faster speed of the higher watt motors to see it is only a few extra mph from 22 to 24. You assume it should be faster but it is your weight and extra cargo you thinking of using bike that fits the RIGHT TYPE OF WATT. If you weigh 200 .lbs it is best to get a 500watt or higher. If ya weight is A BUCK TWENTY fit is 250 to 350 watt unless you want fast because you will go faster at that weight on 500, 750 and up. The lighter people will take 500 and up motors top speed by 5 notches of MPH. The higher the WATT means the higher the torque NM or the stronger it will pull off weight, especially use of constant hill climbing/

  • @TimBee100
    @TimBee100 2 года назад +1

    The speed is restricted by the fact that it is going uphill so probably won't reach the lower class 2 limit let alone the higher class 3 limit.
    I would test the difference between class 2 and class 3 on level ground.

  • @anunakizz
    @anunakizz 2 года назад

    on a hill it is difficult to help the hub motor, what a tilt sensor would do would be good, I don't know if this would be possible

  • @spacegazette4781
    @spacegazette4781 Год назад +3

    So, even though I can probably get by with a 500watt engine - At around 270lbs - I would probably be better off with a 750 even though they weigh more.

  • @aeestep77
    @aeestep77 Год назад

    How do I find out what my controller is for my ebike? It has dual hub 500 watt bafangs. I was wondering if I could upgrade to 750 watt bafangs for more hill climbing power.

    • @ElectricBikeReport
      @ElectricBikeReport  Год назад

      You can check out the specs page from the bike manufacturer, but you may need to contact them directly. Depending on the brand, it's usually about 50/50 whether or not it's included.

    • @aeestep77
      @aeestep77 Год назад

      @@ElectricBikeReport from the specs on their website it’s kinda vague about some of the parts. I do know it’s a 48 volt 20 amp battery. So I may just call them and ask on the controller part

    • @aeestep77
      @aeestep77 11 месяцев назад

      My bike is a krusader dual 500 watt bafangs. Can I swap out for 750?

  • @nguyentrananhnguyen7900
    @nguyentrananhnguyen7900 Год назад

    which one consume more energy?

    • @ElectricBikeReport
      @ElectricBikeReport  Год назад

      A 750W motor can consume more energy, but the programming of the bike's controller and what PAS setting you use are also contributing factors.

  • @bhig3
    @bhig3 5 месяцев назад +2

    These hills were so flat... I have steep ass hills here.

  • @Random-ed2xf
    @Random-ed2xf Год назад

    Voltage as well since some bikes come with 36v even on 500w motors.

  • @clerissonmesquita
    @clerissonmesquita 2 года назад +3

    Thank you so much for your invaluable information, highly appreciate it, keep it up the outstanding job, have a great day.

  • @user619tlsdca5
    @user619tlsdca5 2 года назад +1

    I made a DIY 350watt Gear( gear ⚙️ can go long distance( 20mph) all the way to battery use but very slow on hills) with a 2000 watt Gearless ⚙️ Turbo Hyper Drive Booster( power speed of 40 and up but can't go full throttle of a 4 to 5 miles trip of motor cutting off for a bit to cool down , great on hills of going over 34mph and higher) with this set up I can go long distance of a very high speed of 40mph without the Gearless cut off cool down. This set up should be the standard set up for not only novice e bikers but also for pro builds or factory made. A lot of practical positives and minimum cons as most DIY Duals ppl make are overkill of not being practical of more being obstacles of the weight, energy consumption, brake system and frame wear and abuse.

  • @nikolasb9990
    @nikolasb9990 2 года назад

    Hi I have a question ? My battery hailong 15.5 ah max current 20 a What happens if I connect a 22 a controller?

    • @eideticgoone7035
      @eideticgoone7035 2 года назад +1

      Its possible that you will exceed the BMS current limits when riding full out and the BMS will cut off the battery output when the controller asks for more than 20a. If you have an LCD display that allows to limit the current from the controller, then just set this to be less than 20 amps. You could replace the BMS with a 25 or 30 amp BMS. Open the hailong case, and see what cells you have. Look up the max and steady current ratings on the cells, by googling the cells and looking at a "data sheet" for the cells. Multiply this rating by the number of cells in parallel to determine what current your batteries will tolerate comfortably.
      The 20 a BMS may be under the capabilities of the cells because the battery maker want's to prevent warranty issues, and/or to save a few bucks on the BMS.

  • @estebanarroyave4993
    @estebanarroyave4993 2 года назад +1

    Is it better to have a higher voltage or wattage? Where should I focus more when it comes to hills? Like would it be enough with a 48v 750w? Or is it just too much and I'd be save with a 36v 500w?
    Thank you

    • @tihomirrasperic
      @tihomirrasperic 2 года назад +1

      N(power) = I (Amps) x U (volts)
      so
      for power you watch Watt number
      but it is all relative
      the motor is one component
      battery other
      and the bike itself third
      how many speed the bike has
      how big (small) wheels it has
      road bikes have an advantage on flat roads
      mountain bikes, on the other hand, have advantages on macadam and steep slopes
      motor power is important, but not the most important
      whether the bike fits your height and weight?

  • @buffalomind6838
    @buffalomind6838 2 года назад +1

    Will you guys be testing out the Dual Drive Juggernaut XD from Biktrix?

  • @ctx_12
    @ctx_12 Год назад

    Random question, but what is the name of this song that plays during the testing?

    • @chrisragnar1
      @chrisragnar1 4 месяца назад

      Generic angry American shit nr5336

  • @LINUXGRATISYMEJOR
    @LINUXGRATISYMEJOR 2 года назад +2

    Se han fijado que todos los vídeos, de bicicletas eléctricas de fábricas o hechas en casa, Nunca los muestran en subidas muy empinadas, solo en terrenos planos (Llanos), o en bajadas, y de forma de subidas muy empinadas, se puede ver la potencia y el rendimiento real de esos motores eléctricos,🤔🙄🙄❓❓❓.

  • @edwardcating
    @edwardcating 2 года назад +1

    PLEASE let's see a test of the Avadar C3 250 Watt mid-drive that produces 80 Nm torque and sports a 16 speed Alevio drive train.

    • @rocketassistedgoat1079
      @rocketassistedgoat1079 Год назад

      That's exactly what I want to see too. A small 250watt mid mounted motor with long endurance, that can take advantage of the bike's gears: thus produce 80-90nm of torque like you say, way more than the usual 50 or 60 of most hub motors.

  • @WeileWorld
    @WeileWorld Год назад

    Isn't it more exciting to focus on Nm?

  • @weedsintherain
    @weedsintherain 2 года назад

    What motor do they have?

  • @haliaeetus8221
    @haliaeetus8221 2 года назад +6

    Get some acoustic music in the future. I'm a metal head but get a headache from this generic distorted trash.

    • @ElectricBikeReport
      @ElectricBikeReport  2 года назад +2

      Noted!

    • @haliaeetus8221
      @haliaeetus8221 2 года назад +1

      @@ElectricBikeReport Awesome production of content btw. Much apprechiated. 🙏

    • @dennisluz6453
      @dennisluz6453 Год назад +1

      No music is best. Want to be able to hear bike noise from working parts

  • @johnsheetz6639
    @johnsheetz6639 7 месяцев назад

    I go up some pretty gnarly hills on a 500. I just don't like it to strain like like they do. Top speed is less important I just don't want to feel like I'm heating up the motor by strain.

  • @justinmckey4320
    @justinmckey4320 2 года назад

    Love selling ebikes at work haha

  • @britkasablja007
    @britkasablja007 11 месяцев назад

    500w is it geared hub or direct drive? you cannot compare 2 different types of motor 750w is 100% geared hub and geared hub motor are superior with hill climbing and have great torque compared to DD... Direct drive last longer because less moving parts and are great for higher constant speed but sucks accelerating from 0 eating battery like crazy if you don't at least give some pedal boost... if rear wheel is free and go easy it is geared hub... if rear wheel is hard to pedal without electricity then it is direct drive... one more thing DD charge battery back GH not.

    • @sandsleeper3124
      @sandsleeper3124 5 месяцев назад

      It's about time someone brought up the geared vs direct drive hub motors. I need an ebike to get through the up and down hills from my house to town, so I prefer a lower max speed geared motor over a higher speed direct drive. I just ordered a bike with a 500W 20mph max speed hub motor. Hopefully it is geared and not a direct drive limited by the controller. I don't know because the information that is available for ebikes is pathetic. When you buy a non-ebike, like a Trek, they provide detailed specs. Ebikes should do the same with details like the manufacturer and model numbers of the battery and motor.

    • @jjm380t8
      @jjm380t8 4 месяца назад

      @@sandsleeper3124 geared are small in diameter and similar sizes to eachother, direct drives are huge in diameter and stand out, hope this helps

  • @stavman8536
    @stavman8536 6 месяцев назад

    The big secret is to use your legs !!! If you do so like i do then with a 29inch 750 hub motor can climb 20% or even more ...uphill !

  • @felixonrails
    @felixonrails 2 года назад +2

    Crying in european where almost only 250w motors are available...

    • @plumetheum7017
      @plumetheum7017 2 года назад

      You know you can buy a separate kit, and battery right?

    • @felixonrails
      @felixonrails 2 года назад +1

      @@plumetheum7017 sure, but it's way more convenient just to buy a ready bicycle...

    • @plumetheum7017
      @plumetheum7017 2 года назад +1

      @@felixonrails Is spending an extra 3000+ Euros really worth saving an hour of wrenching?

    • @rocker-barrel4786
      @rocker-barrel4786 2 года назад

      Yeah im in uk all the same BUT eb sre much cheaper than in the u.s.

  • @rocker-barrel4786
    @rocker-barrel4786 2 года назад

    ELECTRIC EVs are the future!
    Stupid laws here in the uk. 25kmh is fastests allowed on public roads.

    • @benoito.1451
      @benoito.1451 Год назад

      Yes for (now) and future transportation . (Depend where you live on earth...) 25 km/h was not stupid, it need à registration, regulation for who doesn't care of the law. A little bit slower but safer was better for everyone... ;)

  • @jimwortham8634
    @jimwortham8634 2 года назад +3

    Let's show me nothing

  • @Daehawk
    @Daehawk 8 месяцев назад

    Wonder if you can hack a ebike and make it go faster

  • @garymaya1767
    @garymaya1767 6 месяцев назад

    does the cost matter? LOL, 500w vs 750w is a big chunk of change. maybe pedal faster and bring an extra gatorade.

  • @dimitristripakis7364
    @dimitristripakis7364 3 месяца назад

    Nice job hiding the crawling by using fast forward editing. 😂

  • @dalecarpenter8828
    @dalecarpenter8828 Год назад

    Is the loud annoying repitious noise a youtube requirement?

  • @wakawaka1976
    @wakawaka1976 2 года назад

    I’m constantly hearing twerk

  • @HackHunter1835
    @HackHunter1835 2 года назад +4

    Why wouldnt you call it Hell HILL. Hell Hole? Come on guys, its a hill not a "hole" A 500 watt motor is plenty, just pedal more and stop using it like a scooter?

    • @ElectricBikeReport
      @ElectricBikeReport  2 года назад +11

      The trailhead is actually called Hell Hole haha 🤷

    • @HackHunter1835
      @HackHunter1835 2 года назад

      @@ElectricBikeReport Fair enough. Off topic, but are you guys going to be doing a review on the new ADDMOTOR City Pro?! I havnt seen one youtuber review on it yet.

  • @ĒriksEmerbergs
    @ĒriksEmerbergs 4 месяца назад

    750W is very good, but 1000W is better...

    • @ElectricBikeReport
      @ElectricBikeReport  4 месяца назад

      Watts aren't everything! We've tested a few 1000W motors that didn't perform as well as many 750Ws.

    • @ĒriksEmerbergs
      @ĒriksEmerbergs 4 месяца назад

      @@ElectricBikeReport if you need max torque on mountains, you must have your 1000W in normal 26inch x 2,3inch, or even 20inch x 3inch wheels, but if you need horizontal max speed, then you need only 750W in 29inch x 2,1 inch in country, or 26 inch x 2,3inch wheels- in city...

  • @doggyman1202
    @doggyman1202 2 года назад

    Interesting and thoughtful analysis guys, as always.
    Somewhat off topic, but Tower builds and promotes this step thru as a women's bike, so the appeal is limited to half the potential market.

    • @ElectricBikeReport
      @ElectricBikeReport  2 года назад +2

      We don't love the "step-thrus are for girls" narative that still lingers in the industry. The EBR staff typically prefers ST models to the high step counterpart. STs are for everybody!

    • @doggyman1202
      @doggyman1202 2 года назад

      @@ElectricBikeReport Amen!

  • @donkydo5020
    @donkydo5020 Год назад

    Why why every 1 plays music how you know i like your music cant watch sry