Why was Bombay SPLIT into Maharashtra and Gujarat?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 июн 2024
- Download Link - kukufm.sng.link/Apksi/bw9n/wwmx
Coupon code - MOHAK50
(Coupon valid for first 250 users)
******
The states of Maharashtra and Gujarat were once a single state known as the state of Bombay under the British. Upon independence, there were demands to create separate states of Gujarat and Maharashtra on the basis of language. The centre didn't want this but appointed several commissions to look into this matter. Finally, when protests grew from both the Marathi and Gujarati sides, the centre divided the state of Bombay into Maharashtra and Gujarat on May 1,1960.
Formation of Telangana - • The Birth of Telangana
Srilankan Civil war - • How Tamils Fought in S...
******
Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1R...
******
Research:
Vishwa Thakkar: / vishwathakkar5
Editing:
Yash Vyas: / yashvyas24
Ajinkya Kawale: / ajinkya.kawale
Editing Support :
ButWhy: / butwhy
Ajeesh Babu: / ajeesh_babu
******
🗳Support on Patreon: / sochyoutube
👾Discord: / discord
🐦Twitter: / mohakmangal
📷Instagram: / mohak.mangal
👤Facebook: / sochyoutube
Liked the background music? I use Epidemic Sound. You can get a 30-day free trial using this referral: bit.ly/3A7bUx7
******
Playlists
🇮🇳Indian Society: • Hijab: Ban Right or Wr...
🗺Geopolitics and Foreign Affairs: • Will China Invade Taiwan?
🧍🏽♀️Issues of a Young Indian: • Are Indian Girls Bad a...
💰Economy: • How Kerala Changed its...
🗳Indian Politics: • UP Elections: Why Are ...
🇮🇳 Discoveries of India: • How Goa Joined India
📈Money, Stocks, and Crypto: • Why Indian Youth is NO...
******
Markers
00:00 Introduction
01:00 History of the Bombay State
02:35 Social Landscape of Bombay
03:34 The Dar Commission
06:18 The State Reorganisation Committee
10:30 The Bifurcation of the state
11:55 Conclusion
******
Creative commons:
Unsplash
Flaticon
Freepik
Videvo
******
As a gujrati living in Mumbai, happy that Mumbai is a part of Maharashtra. Can't imagine a liquor free Mumbai.
😂😂😂
🤣🤣
Lmao
@@power3433 Thanks for inviting me to your house. But sorry I wouldn't be coming.
@@pinakm1311 gujju it is your house in gujrat 🤣
one more important point Marathi were not mainly labourers but land owners. The AAGRI - KOLI Marathi community are the real Mumbaikars amd actually Mumbai is their land and culture
Right
Not only labourers
Many intellectual social reformers of maharashtra like lokmanya tillak , rg bhandarkar , gopal Krishna gokhle , gopal ganesh agarkar and Many were associated with either of the two cities
Mumbai (bombay) and pune ( poona) .
They contribited to the city intellectually .
Archtects of many buildings in mumbai were maharashtrians .
Ho bhau 🚩🚩
True bro
आगरी कोळी समाज हा मुंबईचा मूळ रहिवाशी आहे. 🚩
Agreed. Tho I still kinda struggle to find out what were the aagri's occupation at that time since we know Kolis are basically fishermen
As a Gujarati, I find this quite informative. I knew about the separation but never the reasons and stuff. Wonder why they didn’t teach about this in school. Thanks for bringing light to this, Mohak.
Anyways, Much love to my Marathi brothers and sisters.
Jai Garvi Gujarat ~ Jai Maharashtra
Bhai sab toh tumhe school mai janna hai. Lekin phir school mai masti bhi karna hai. Bhai har jagah ye school wala rant lagana band karo yaar.
@@subhamsatyaprakash96 Abe kya bol raha hai? School mai masti?? Baat to ese kar raha hai jese personally janta ho mujhe
No love to marathi brothers, will surpass them again in future 🎉
@@affinix887 Bhai chill maro koi competition thodi chal raha h lol sab ek hi country ke hai
@@aryansarc aej to aa thoda Gujarati ego batade che ane pachi badhane gado sambhadvi pade che
जय महाराष्ट्र and love for Gujrati brothers!
Maharashtra has largest migrant population in India not only in Mumbai but in the whole state. Respect to all the people who called this state home and made it one of the if not the best to live in. 😊😊
And yet Hindi is more important than Marathi
More than the people who migrated respect should be to the people who accepted the ones who migrated and made them feel like hone
@@adastra3192 saare boards mein compulsory hein
@@EliasRoy ......and the reason is bollywood industry.
@@EliasRoy In dreams 😂
Divided by states
United by bharat mata's aashirwad 😎😎🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@Noname-ny9if chal nikal to fir
@@titfortatt-regionalist bhai united by money
As Gujarati, we love Marathis, But we also support Mumbai as a part of Maharashtra, we are happy with our Ahmedabad, Surat and Vadodara cities which come in the top 10 developed cities list of India
❤
Bewda
Marathis and Gujratis should not forget the struggle of their forefathers in preserving their regional languages and cultural values .
It's called national language not regional language. Language, culture and history form a nation. Country and nation are two different things. Google the difference.
India is not a nation. It is union of nations like European union. The difference is that this union is much more centralised and grabbed all the powers in the federal govnt
@@SatpalVerma000 your vision is absolutely right....i am ideologically a federalist.
Too late, I'm from Maharashtra but I definitely know better English than Marathi and although most of my classmates don't it's not like they're reading classic Marathi literature/consuming Marathi content over Hindi
@@SatpalVerma000 Didn't expect I'd meet someone who knows the difference under yt comment section. India is a nation the way China is communist and North Korea is democratic.
@@FirstNameLastName-tm4tg Communism and capitalism is a ecomonic system which have impact on political and social sysyem too. But Nation is different. You got zero idea what Im on about. Read few books on communism, read online on formation of nation states and empires
I'm glad mumbai is in Maharashtra. I love Gujarat, but it is better to see how the marathis have welcomed us with open arms. Yeah sure there were some issues in the past, but mumbai is THE idea of India for me, inclusion and diversity. Navratri and Ganesh Chaturthi is a good example of positive cultural exchange in mumbai, because many gujarati families (except us jains because we have our paryushan at that time) have started adopting that festival and the dandiya raas functions all over mumbai probably have more maharashtrians than gujaratis lmao.
I have lived in Mumbai and my experience says that Mumbai shouldn't be in Maharashtra ever it should be like Delhi. Marathi wants that companies having headquarters in Mumbai should employ Marathi more.
@@sudhirkumarshahu6146 matlab kuch bhi
@@sudhirkumarshahu6146 ganja ganja
@@sudhirkumarshahu6146 Girls are safer in Mumbai than Delhi.
@@sudhirkumarshahu6146 bhaiyya konsa nasha kiya hai
Sanskar Nagari Vadodara of Gujarat was also Developed by Marathis just like Gujaratis did for Mumbai. 💓🇮🇳
@@dhavalrajapara King of Vadodara was Marathi.
@@Batman099 saiyaji Rao gaikwad
@Ramesh shinde yes abhi ke time me dekha jaye toh up,bihari labour ne develop Kiya h Mumbai ko. But jis time ki baat ki h video me us time Gujarati merchants ki wajah se hi prosper huva tha aur marathis mostly labour force thy usme. So Jo sach h use accept kar lena chahiye Hume ,I'm saying this being a maharashtrian
@@pratik8678 gujrati business main aagey hain mumbai main.
Baki sab bohot piche hain .
But gujrati britisho ke saath bohot they mumbai main.
@Ramesh shinde bhai teri baat sahi hai mein ye bhi samajh , ki baat pride ki nahi facts ki hai google pe top 10 india k amir ki list dekh le I bet shart laga le adhe se jyada gujarati log hai , and tumhe pata nahi hoga to bata du ki jo parsi community hai wo mostly gujarati speakars hai , like tata group k founder ke gujarati origin se hai , ratan Tata too...ye baat sach hai aur ye bhi sach hai ki Gujarati log bussiness me achha karte hai bhai , hope u understand 🙏❤️👍
Huge respect to 105 people who lost their lives for Bombay.....which you even not mentioned in your video
Jai Maharashtra
Exactly 💯
I found this video very much biased towards Gujarat. Quite selectively ignored the importance of the region in pre British era during the Mughal vs Maratha period
@@shreyasjamdade8549 Yes...Maratha pigs always find fault with Gujarat
@@shreyasjamdade8549 indeed. This guy has soften the then issue moreover, the sacrifices of 105 Marathis not given importance.
Video is good informative. .magar Morarji Desai ne 105 marathi young ladko per goliya chalvai thi es baat ko taal diya.
Marathi and Gujrati people are brothers. Both cultures are so closely related. Marathi and Gujrati people can get along easily within minutes because there's a unique vibe and a some sense of belongingness and mutual respect.
Jay Hind Jay Maharashtra Jay Garvi Gujarat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
I am Marathi,I can speak fluent Gujarati and this only shows the historic connection between marathis and gujaratis.
@@ATMmm62 we're brothers man my city is Vadodara and our king was Maharaja Sayajirao Gaekwad he was a lion and pride of Vadodara he established schools and universities promoted education we are always thankfull to all the Gujaratis and Marathis to help each other and to develop our states
@@heisenberg9595 ❤️
@Ramesh shinde kuch bhi
that's false, Gujarati and marathi are actually distantly related. Konkani and marathi are actually sister cultures whereas Gujarati and Marwadi are another sibling pair of cultures.
The far-sight that the leaders of the nation must have considering the past, current and future is no easy task. For every rise that we see for any field there is always a downside but the long term goal must not deter. If I was living in 1950-60s I would not have understood the benefit for the decision but seeing now how far we have come is astounding.
Ambedkar was way ahead in terms of everything sadly he is criticised for reservation
Now we have leaders who cares more about power and money.
@@driggster116 he said reservation is necessary for like 10 years but every govt keeps on extending it every 10 year :(
@@driggster116 He was literally an ocean of knowledge, a man who could truly foresee. But today's constitution is just a shadow of his committee's views after all those amendments.
@@driggster116 his thoughts on China, Islamic extremism, current politics are so much relevant
Similar to Mumbai city of Vadodara was developed by Marathi rulers. And you will find lots of Marathi speaking people in Vadodara
But Mumbai was not developed by Marathi rulers so there is no similarity per se.
@@pawanugalmugale7446 what language does Bohris and Parsis speak? Did anyone stop you from taking pride in your people's contribution to anything? Gujaratis have to speak for their contribution because a section of the population with selective amnesia have been targeting Gujaratis as outsiders when the only difference between them and marathi people is that during Bombay state bifurcation the city went within map of one state.
@@pawanugalmugale7446 bro just information that mostly all parsi are Gujarati speakers 🙄😆yes , and now one is first in taking pride ok all are proud Indian that's it
@@pawanugalmugale7446 all parsi are gujarati, Tatas are from navsari, even today most expensive areas belong to gujarati traders of Surat and big gujarati business house like tata ambani adani
@@pawanugalmugale7446 if no it isn't it made from Marathi labor and gujarati capital, why Maharashtra don't have single big trade City other than Mumbai then? Becoz Marathi people aren't a trader why it's so hard to accept it. I proudly accept gujarati aren't great warriors or we don't have big kings. We are good at working with the brain and not the body!
Both Maharashtra and Gujarat are powerhouse of Bharat.
Jai Garvi Gujarat
Jai Maharashtra
Jai Hind.🇮🇳 Vande Mataram.
Love from Uttar Pradesh.
Bruh. Marathi Power ? Where ? To kick out UP Bihar people ?
@@Max6850 you better don't divide... Jai maratha Jai gujrat from Bihar
Tatakae xD
@@ShadowMonarxh7 no tatakae Only JAI SHREE RAM🚩🚩
@@erenyadav3580 Jai shree ram 🙏🙏
As a Gujarati I'm happy to witness our two most developed states much love to marathi brothers and sisters
I hope everyone thinks like you. It is important to stay united to make our country great again.
But you guys lift your alcohol prohibition and should focus on your English education. Gujarat need more software engineering colleges otherwise in the era of 4th industrial revolution Gujarat future is very dark.
@@DannycageGhostrider I know bro I'm happy that guys like you are giving constructive criticism and focusing on weak points
And yeah this was a problem but know I can see that people are working on it quite a bit people are trying to improve on their English communication and students are taking IT lines rather than just business
I myself has taken Computer Engineering 😁so yeah It's improving but thanks 😊
@@heisenberg9595 but in a business minded state like Gujarat why you guys are not still protesting against liquor prohibition because there is no benefit and huge revenue loss. even in women safety Gujarat in 16th position where Maharashtra in 9th position?
@@DannycageGhostrider I think liquor ban is a good thing
I don't like alcohol so encouraging it is something I'm against of it and about women safety you're right our state is not putting more efforts in women safety I'm shocked to see Gujarat is in 16th position😐hope state government is doing something about it
Proud to be a Gujarati 😍😍...
And love for Maharashtrian ❤️
Jai Maharashtra Jai Garvi Gujrat
Same Man! Proud to be Gujrati
@@prakharganodwale1739 Jay Maharashtra Jay Gujarat
Gujarat Maharashtra Day is celebrated on one day and Saint Gora Kumbhar Maharashtra is prevalent in Gujarat.I am Ashutosh Kumbhar and live in Odisha.
105 ppl
Died for Mumbai aamchi mumbai Jay Maharashtra
jai maharashtra
bro usne mentioned tak nhi kiyaa
@@59-onkarkhedekar33 sad
All over mh we have memorials buit to rem them.
106*
I live in a Gujarati colony in Maharashtra.
Gujrati and Marathi communities are like sugar in a milk, we know how to coexist and flourish.
I am not a Maharashtrian but Mumbai is my home...I can't imagine myself living anywhere else.Mumbai meri Jaan..
mumbai overhyped doesn't even have basic facilities
@@JustAPokemonCommentingOnVideos
As per recenly published global livability index 2022 among Indian cities Mumbai was second most livable city ranking 141 just behind Delhi, third was chennai(142) than ahemdabad (143) and than bengluru(146).
So atleast as per Indian standards indeed it's good city.
@@SAMARTHSAMANT I have lived in Mumbai and recently from past 9 year I am living in Surat. Living standard, facility, cleanliness and affordability is far better than mumbai in Surat
@@GaneshYadav-cb5hn mumbai just has more cultural diversity no strixt rules on non veg and liquor? more freedom of choice.
@Ramesh shinde my god. Pune ki itni jalti hai na mumbai se ki comments me bhi dikhane ajate hai🤣🤣jali na. Teri bhi jali na🤣
No Doubt We Marathis owe a lot to our Gujrati Brothers who brought in the Massive Development in terms of Trade, Buisness and Education.
But what is important to say here is that much of the Present Day India owes alot to Marathas. If it were not the Heroic Military Conquests under Peshaws, Holkars, Shindes, Gaikwads, Puars and Dabhade a great Part of India would've been Under Mughal/Durrani Clutches.
• It were Gaikwads who helped Dadabhai Nawroji and many others
• Scholarship to Dr Ambedkar was Provided by Karveer Shrimant and Baroda Naresh.
• Holkars carried out Large Scale renovation of Temples.
But marathas still lost to the british
@@ashwinvk4124 yeh but cuz they have advanced weapons and technology and that also help India in industrialization
@@Krishna0660 back then the weapons what they had was not drastically superior to indian weapons we also had rocket projectile and gun powder weapons infact many british soldiers used to dismount from thier horses in the middle of the war and use Indian swords of an injured soldier .
We lost to the british because of our lack of unity and also had a lot of backstabbers and traitors
Also the industries what they bought were more beneficial to them , they built textile, iron and steel industries along with the railway so that they can suck the resources from our country and sell to their country at a much cheaper cost in the mean time destroying our very own muslin textile and other handloom industries
@@ashwinvk4124 true. Lack of unity is what made us suffer back then and is still making us suffer
@@adityasharma2935 "naval blockade " do you know how long is our cost line
This was a good video on the Gujrat and Maharashtran history and how both these groups are so related
*gujarat
@@Shark0_0 that was just a small typing error
@@jackshukla9772 understandable👍🏽
@@Shark0_0 first letter of a name should be capital
*Gujarat
@@dayyanahmad117 *First letter of the sentence should be capital.
As an Odia, I have come to love all the different languages and cultures of my country, it's difficult not to once you start to explore their characteristic rich but intertwined histories.
For the Gujratis, a heartiest જય અંબે મા.
I just love your splendid flowy language, characteristic temple architecture, the playful Gujrati script and the unique dishes, plus the highly jovial nature of Gujratis, who have come to be passive in their own state, regarding languages. ગુજરાત બા has graced us with gems like Sardarji patel, the Tatas, Adanis, our national father and our beloved PM. I just hope, more Gujratis pay attention to their sweet language and adore it in the future.
Ah the Marathis, छत्रपति शिवाजी माहाराजांचा जयजयकार , we won't find a more patriotic community like them, towards the country as well as to their glorious resplendent language. Y'all are so accommodating to many linguistic groups, your architecture is beautiful, the dishes so full of चाव and ho, the fighter spirit in your people woes anyone who comes to your state. महाराष्ट्र आई has bestowed Shivaji Maharaj, Tilakji, Ambedkarji, Thackeray sahib graciously to all of India, the marathi language is ever glorious, although at the very least, Marathis themselves ought to know about their cultural Modi script( vast majority is ignorant inspite of having tonnes of ancestral letters in the aforesaid script) and give it a co-official status with Balbodh script.
Learning both the languages was fun for me, in some matters one language was closer to Odia and vice-versa. The endings in Gujrati are numerous and you sometimes find it so hard to distinguish between gha and dha; cha and ya, but nevertheless worth rewarding. Marathi pronounciation is aptly peculiar to imbibe, the nuances of dialects, conjugations at the end, but it has been a wonderful experience. The biggest problem was gender in both languages, which was opposite in many cases and hard to remember, since Odia doesn't have gender at all.
I agree with you bro❤
Well written 👏
As a marathi i think odia are very similar in temperament to marathis. Straight forward, non vulgar, simple people
Nice 👍
Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj*
We Marathi and Gujrati still love peacefully together in both Maharashtra and Gujrat. Maratha Kings contributed in Gujrat progress and Gujrati merchant contributed in Maharashtra progress.
@H J Even Gujrati merchants were limited to Mumbai development
@H J Whole gujarat was under maratha empire
I really want a video where its shown how India's map has transformed into what it has become now with the 28 States from the start of early 20th century
He has made a lot of video already but not all. But you can check the videos on hi channel.
29 states
odisha jharkand from bihar, gujrat from maharashtra, telangana from AP, chattisgarh from MP, UK from UP, haryana n HP from punjab. Thats it.
@@iambhushan418 about NE States
@@batman3490 28 states J&K has become a UT now
My mother tongue is Marathi but this is what I like about Gujaratis. Most Gujaratis care about financial growth and improving standard of living instead of getting too much involved in this kind of dumb prides.
“Pride should be reserved for something that you achieve on your own; not for something that happens by the accident of birth” - George Carlin
There's this slogan in Gujarat, "Jay Jay Garvi Gujarat" that means, "We Proud of our Gujarat." Or "Proud to be Gujarati". which means Gujarati people proud on their state but they didn't take that as granted. that is why they always update themselves and their businesses
True bro. I'm marathi but I don't understand the obsession of my community with themselves. It's highly politically motivated and they are innocent enough not to understand it.
@@pawanugalmugale7446 what’s even more sad is, even some educated Marathi people have got all their priorities wrong. They’re too busy feeling proud of Marathi language and the glory of Maratha empire 🤦🏻♂️
@@Sach973 i don't see anything wrong with that
@@Sach973 Nothing wrong in pride if use it to feel good about oneself instead of bring other down.
Gujarat has been considered as Business hub since Indus Valley Civilization.
Marathi people were workers not because of illiteracy but because of the huge population,
Mumbai is surrounded by Marathi people who were the land owners and Have a powerful history.
In school, we learned that the Britishers build Mumbai city or build the first railway but the thing is Shankar Seth Murkute sir was the first person who convinced the Britishers and funded the first railway project. started the first trading and political organization at his House with Britishers. Helped the marine trade to grow, Most of Mumbai's land is donated by him. He used to give loans to Britishers, today's Mumbai police headquarters was built by Britishers but the funding was given by Surat Maratha Sardar named Gaikwad ji, And so on...
The trading capital of Britishers was Surat but Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj looted it so many times, that Britishers were scared of Marathas. British had no choice but to move to Mumbai
They came here to trade and had not enough to build the entire land capital Marathi, Gujrati, and Parsi are the ones who provided funds.
It's not that the literacy rate was less among the Marathi people but they had no trading history as they belong to the warrior background.
If you google who built the Gateway of India you'll find that George wittet built it, but the thing He was the architect and the civil engineer who built it was Mr. Ravbahadur Desai sir who was a local. even has a name of him to the chowk near the Gateway of India.
And the main this is there is a Gateway of India model at is resident in Gaondevi.
Our History is hidden ...
If you see the Geographical location Within a 100km radius there are 80% Marathi people.
There are so many things which could be considered in this video....
This video really felt biased.
Towny? Anyway, Perfect info. 👍
@@tejas9231 Exctaly also parsi where British Agent British had hate for Maratha as Nation of warriors unlkike gujrati who never had any martial
One of बाळासाहेब ठाकरे 's dialogue:
"मुंबई ही आपली आहे आणि इथे आवाज ही आपलाच हवा"
rakho ham dusra mumbai bana lenge
@@arthn8605 bhavaa dum lagto tya sathi tujyat nahi toh mumbai sarkha dusra shahar nahi kon banvu shakat🥵😂😎
@@arthn8605 Amdavad kai ochu che enathi 😉 aato Mumbai ma bollywood che etle hawa ma fare che marathao😜 south movie thi bollywood bandh thava do etle khbr Maharashtra ni kimmat 🌝
@@poojan5262 aej to bollywood ane mumbai na hoi to amna pradesh ne to koi gadhedu pan na puche
@@arthn8605 next new mumbai is already created
It's the navi mumbai
Pune will be next another mumbai
proud to be Marathi. Maharashtra might have flaws but it's best state for opportunities. good economy and India's best city Mumbai located here.
On what parameters mumbai is the best city just because its popular.
@@desage4766 it's economy
Delhi>Mumbai imo
The only thing it edges is that Mumbai is a port city while Delhi is landlocked
@@adityasharma2935 Riot,r@pe,Lynching op bolte
As a Gujarati I love Marathi brosis. Respect to both states. Both states are powerhouse for India.
Jay Hind 🇮🇳
Jay jay garvi Gujarat
Jay Maharashtra
Proud To Be Marathi🧡
proud To be hindu 🚩
What a coincidence! 🤩 i just study this chapter in my political science book and you just uploaded this video ☺😌
Class 12th political science 😅
@@beenachaudhary6388 yess😁
Lucky kids! 🙂
@@iamjust1normalgirlfromindi446 🙃🙂
i am from songadh, the gujarat side of station ,here we have more marathis then gujaratis.
Same dispute was between Assam and Meghalaya when both the states were demanding Shillong as their capital. Finally, Meghalaya was awarded Shillong and Assam had to choose a new capital near Guwahati. Even today, Punjab & Haryana fight for Chandigarh.
Punjab have mohali and haryana have panchkula . They can resolve this diapute
@@faizanhashmi389 yes bro... But for that, both the state govts should come to a conclusion.. But unfortunately, they both are playing tug of war with chandigarh
@@samarthasaha32 Chandigarh should be ruled by centre only. If it is given to any state govt, the resources of Chandigarh will be used to provide subsidy to farmers of both state which will ultimately be a disaster for the city
@@samarthasaha32 this happens everytime , not sure why they just can't stop this political bs
@@samarthasaha32 both are doing nothing , but used chandigarh for vote
Could you make how Moraji Desai betrayed India during his PM position and disclosed to Pakistan about India's mission of sabotaging the nuclear test in Pakistan, because of which many Indian spys got martyred in Pakistan. Infact he is the only PM of India to get highest honoured award from Pakistan.
British was firstly relying on Surat for trades then due to some instability they shifted all trades to Bombay/Mumbai. That was already very established from the time of chatrapati shivaji maharaj. In earlier time Gujarat had it's own Bombay - surat and after that Maharashtra has it's own Bombay - Mumbai. (& *Chatrapati Shivaji Park)
Surat port started to become unsable due silt deposition
Mumbai was just a very small village during shivaji.
@@SafavidAfsharid3197 Mumbai was a group of 7 islands. British reclaimed land from the sea and merged it into one peninsula
@P write in the comments. Its not this guy is friends with mangal
@@SafavidAfsharid3197 SHIVAJI MAHARAJ bolo.....
Bhagwan he vo
Jay jay Maharashtra mazha
Garja Maharashtra mazha ...
The land of great leaders , dynasties and social reformers ... Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Jai maharashtra
Bharat jaude khddyat barobar?
Jay Jay garvi Gujarat ❤️
@@buzztube1738 maharashtra cha jay jay kar kelyane bharatacha apman kasa kay hoto barr?? Maharashtra bhartat ch ahe ki.. mg maharashtra cha jay jay kar ha bhartiyancha ch jaykaar zala na.
we also had first feminist of india - savitribai phule, who along with fathima sheikh opened first women's school of india
This story sounds so similar to what my parents think about Telangana State Formation.
Hyderabad city was developed a lot by the then AP govt, but when Telangana was formed, they got Hyderabad and AP lost it.
And now AP is screwed coz of a terrible CM
How is AP is screwed? AP is getting lot of investments, reforms in education sector etc. But huge mistake after state bifurcation was making useless amaravati as capital instead of already reasonably well developed vizag. I hope vizag becomes capital in future as current state govt is planning
Well, I agree with the govt part, but dude Telangana was independent before AP joined to form a single state.. historically and geographically Hyderabad belongs to Telangana but CBN developed Hyderabad instead..
ap got coast and also they got 10 year time to build new capital but your politicians ruined it all.
@@riderchallenge4250 it took 70 years to built the current hyd not just 10 yrs
@@arshad1647 800 years not 70 years
Many don't know about "NANA SHANKAR SHETH " he was Marathi man who is known as the father of Modern Mumbai
And Jamsetjee Jeejeebhoy is not? Lovji Wadia is not? Gerald Aungier is not? All these people are city fathers.
@@milaanvigraham8664 i am telling about Marathis only
@@sanketvelhal9536 Just saying that Marathi and non Marathis were both fathers of Mumbai. And if one had to pick a single father of Mumbai it would be Gerald Aungier.
but according to bollywood Bombay ki history mein bus Bhailog, Gundagardi, Smuggling, crime hi hota tha 🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂
Bollywood ko seriously lene vale log maha ch*tiya hai 💀
its parallel ....on ground history is diff .
jaise new york base movies mai bhi gangsyer type
12:34
The last part of this video will be my Answer in UPSC mains when the question of Dividing India on the basis of language will be asked
Jai Telugurasthra
My great grand Father, Mr Indulal Yagnik was the leader of MahaGujarat moment.
And before the Portuguese, Bombay was the part of Gujarat Sultanate and it was taken away by the Portuguese from the Badshah of Gujarat Sultanate
The original inhabitants of Mumbai are Marathi Koli fishermen, Mumbai belongs to them before anyone else.
Maratha Empire ruled whole india then also include Whole Gujarat 60 years
@@AA-pb8us
Maratha emerged in the late 17th century and the Portuguese acquired Bombay from the Gujarat sultanate in the first half of the 16th century. So between these two, there is a gap of 170 years.
And Before The Maratha, Gujarat is an independent state from the 4th century AD.
@@harshyagnik5334 achi baate hei bro isme Zafar Khan tha Gujarat sultanate ka banayi thi
@@AA-pb8us
उससे पहेले राजपूत रजाओ का साम्राज्य था चौथी सदी से बारहवीं सदी तक जिस्म सबसे महानतम शासक हुए सम्राट भीमदेव सोलंकी और सिद्धराज जयसिंह
Bealgaon and karvar district people's are our family...
Tribute to 106 martyrs.
💐💐💐💐💐
Thank you, Karnataka & Maharashtra 🤝
@@Albetroz1415 Belgaon is maharashtra
@@TheFutureWeWant Mumbai is Karnataka
@@TheFutureWeWant pune is karnataka
@@Albetroz1415 Whole Karnataka is ours😂
Maharashtra is lucky to have leaders like BR Ambedkar Ji and BabaSaheb Ji. Meanwhile, Bihar and UP have Akhilesh, Lalu and Nitish as prominent leaders
Babasaheb was born in Mhow in MP and got his education from Mumbai. Also, he was never in favour of a united Maharashtra, he only advocated including Mumbai in it, but was of the view to make Marathwada and vidarbha its own entity. So be proud of that fact too.
Babasaheb and Ambedkar Ji both refer to the same person.
we have gandhi sardar modi. world level
Bihar have Gautam Buddha mahaveer Swami Chanakya, Ashoka chandragupt Maurya samudragupt etc.
@@JeetuKumarYadav-ow8jq i think he meant in terms of modern era
*Samyukta Maharashtra Movement*
During the period from 16 to 22nd January 1957, 90 people died. 15 died in November in same year during protest. Around 10,000 satyagrahis were arrested. Overall 106 people sacrificed their life.
RIP🙏
🚩JAI HIND, JAI MAHARASHTRA 🚩
Still belgaum is not under Maharashtra....
@@Sanskar-1705 neither we're interested I think there should not be any changes in map now
@@Sanskar-1705 No use Belgaum is still largely Kannada-spoken region
I am born Maharashtrian , currently residing in Gujarat, Kutch from last 10 years. Little did I knew about the separation of Gujarat and Maharashtra but never thought and learnt about this side of story ! One thing is for sure and that is I have observed so many of Gujarati people and community are fluent in speaking marathi ! Moreover many of the wordings of two languages are same like for example safarchand(apple), phatakde(fireworks) etc. Beyond the complex past I still admire how beautiful and cultured both side of people are! 🙌🥰
Safarchand nahi sapharjan h gujrati mein. fa sound sanskrit mein nahi h gujrati sanskrit se aayi h means gujrati mein nahi h vese marathi gujrati se bhi purani bhasha h
Vese bade log ka kiya dhara samnya logo ko bhugtna padta h aur log apas mein hi ladte h aur bolte h bharat mein vividhta hote huye bhi ek sath rehte h bas apna state apna state yahin sochte h are sabhi state apne h sab state develop hone chahiye tabhi apna desh develop hoga
@@prachidesai786 acha sapharjan hota h 👍 vaise sahi kaha kyuki pichle 9 saal sai Gujarat mai reh tha hu isliye bhaut kuch similarity mili h
@@harshalgaikwad2678swaminarayan right
Being a Marathi I can say that we love Gujjus and I find guratis & Marathis to be very similar culturally , linguistically , similar cuisine just the clothing is not similar while even we look alike...I can fluently speak both the languages.
Mala pan Gujarati yete Chan.
Gujarati don't love Marathis btw
Oh bruh my name is also Prakhar much love to marathis from a Gujarati jay Maharashtra
@@xaviball2911 kuch bhi
@@rudrajani2485 it's true. They treat Marathi people as their workers
जय महाराष्ट्र 🚩🚩🔥
@@CodexArchivist jali na 😂😂😂
Shayad isi liye tere jaise idhar tatti chatane ate hai😂😂😂😂
@@CodexArchivist Jai Hind bro 🔥❤
@@CodexArchivist same like your house....bas darwaza accha hai baaki pura Ghar toilet hae
Although... Maharashtra besides Mumbai has Pune, nashik, Aurangabad, Nagpur....
Well you r mad, illiterate and shameless
I hope these word aren't enough to describe your nature and life
@@CodexArchivist jalte raho tum bhikhari
@@CodexArchivist india acha hai 🙂
Again Balasaheb Thackeray was not mentioned. He had a significant contribution
Doesn't suit propaganda🙃
not at all, it was not balasaheb but his father prabodhankar thakare who was a staunch supporter of sanyukt maharashtra movement
@@adityasharma2935 exactly soft leftist this channel is
Being a Gujarati kid living in Mumbai I didn't new this. Thanks brother for this information 🔥🔥
As a Marathi, I have a lot Gujurati friends here in Mumbai. Can't imagine not having them in my lives. ❤
The Navapur talukathat you talked about is in Nandurbar district, and Dang district it is a tribal area which was divided into the areas of Gujarat and Maharashtra, and the tribals there are demanding a separate state, "Satpura Pradesh/Bilpradesh", and this demand is very very old, but even after creating Gujarat and Maharashtra, they were divided into different states, which had an effect on their development. It is happening, and the new state demanded is formed by combining the areas of the Satpura hills of Maharashtra, Gujarat, Rajasthan, and Madhya Pradesh. And it's called "bhilpradesh" or "Satpuda pradesh."
Major Correction to your video: "Riots was Not Happened between Marathis and Gujaratis.🙄 It happened against Government from both side."🇮🇳💓🇮🇳
Obviously Marathi side protest is more aggressive. 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
खर आहे
Marathi killed Gujarati and that will never forget by us gujrati.
Nothing more than Gujarat.
@Ramesh shinde Mast reply bhau Love from Vidharbha..
@@chaudhary978 Gujarati CM Morarji Desai ordered to open fire on Marathi Protesters resulted in 105 deaths. Acchha hua Maratho ne yeh sab bhula diya, nahi to aaj Ek gujarati nahi hota aaj Mumbai me.
@@chaudhary978 nahi riot nahi hua but sarkar ke against violence hua thaan.
Agri Koli Bhandaris are the natives of Mumbai, and Mumbai grew because of Jagannath Nana Shankarsheth, a educationist, philanthropist and reformer, he was the one because of whom Indians have access to railways, he's the one who funded construction works in Mumbai.
Chalo man ko sukun mil gaya hoga tumhare 🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣
Railways was funded by a board which had mostly British and 2 Indians. Shankarsheth was one. The other was Jamsetjee Jeejeebhoy, a Parsi. So please enough with your racism
@@milaanvigraham8664 Gonna Cry??
@@billusanda5568 Predictable, it's not like you guys care about the truth anyway
Isliye bhide aur jethalal ki nahi jamti hai😂😂
Maharashtra runs country 🧡
@@Shashank_ssm WE ALL ARE DIVIDED INTO STATES!!!
MAHARASHTRA GIVES 38% OF REVENUE TO UNION
MAHARASHTRA GETS 13% FROM CENTER
MAHARASHTRA RUNS COUNTRY 🧡
@@atharvkadam8301 if the governing party is different from centre then 13% pan nahi milat
@@94.darshanugalepatil51 teech tr bhavaaa
@@dhavalrajapara 😂😂
@@dhavalrajapara stop fighting bro
Shivaji park bhai boht anokhi jaga hai pure desh ke iconic moments Jude hue hai usse 🧡🧡
I was born in Mumbai and I have lived my whole life here. I must say that the contributions of both the Marathi and Gujarati people has brought Mumbai to the heights it has reached today. Love and peace to all the communities who live in harmony in this wonderful city 😊😊😊😊
Historically Maharashtra belongs to Swarajya, The Great Maratha Empire and Bombay was part of it. There was only Koli tribal community exited on islands of Bombay even before Portuguese and East India Company. Gujaratis and Parsees came much later into the business. Kolis were part of Swarajya and Bombay was protected by Marathas. So basically Marathis were not only labours but also warriors who fought for the soul. That’s why Sanyukta Maharashtra movement was run successfully. You should’ve mention all that in detail.
marathis and gujaratis are brothers and sisters
Never had any issues with marathi people. They're friendly people🙌😌
No we aren't.
I had Gujarati girlfriend 😜😜😜
@@omkarkamble2445 and i have mumbaiker gf😜
@@omkarkamble2445 mere pass marathi ex thi bhai 🙃
Our leaders were initially sceptical about linguistic reorganization of states
But in the end they proved VERY successful
The state formed in 1953 after Potti Sriramulu's death was Andhra State. And Andhra pradesh is a different entity formed in 1956 after the language reorganization act through which many other states were also formed. So please don't confuse them!
Woah thanks for the input
We Maharashtra has large contribution from Gujrati people, whether it's from running sweet shop or running big businesses.
Idk , but I cried and I'm proud for being a gujarati and having and amazing rich history with india 🇮🇳 ♥️, but I still miss indian 😢 and love india 🇮🇳
Thay thay
Both are richest states of India 🚩
Jay Maharashtra
Jay gujrat 🚩
why the saffron flag ? .....aren't you Indian ? don't you believe in Indian flag ?
@@u4usuf that flag is a representation of marathas
Marathas used those flags
Hence it is representing Maharashtra
Using that flag is no different than Indias flag...because marathas were and will always be Indians
@@u4usuf bihari🤣🤣
@@Abhishek-xt9sl what is ur problem bro?
People like you always want to create disharmony between state. I think you should rethink about ur behaviour.
Love Bihar and Maharashtra from Bengal 🧡
@@TD-pm3vr We don't love you guys, Specially Bihari. According to police data Majority of criminals in Maharashtra are from UP Bihar. We hate These people, They can't make their own state beautiful that's why they come here ruin my state.
Your video editors are so good to understand the whole concept easly.. thanks for give us that type of content
According to Ambedkar , gujratis and parsis were brought to Mumbai for doing business they were never locals over there .. British offered them free warehouses and lands to do business like opium etc geographically Mumbai should be part of mh. Gujaratis cannot claim Mumbai .. Ambedkar also pointed out that Gujaratis never ruled over mh but maratha ruled Gujarat . If just bcause they were brought for doing business then Marathas can claim whole Gujarat as they were ruler over there .
पहेले इतिहास पढ़ ले भाई
बॉम्बे ऐतिहासिक रूप से गुजरात का हिस्सा रहा है। सन 1448 तक बॉम्बे, गुजरात सल्तनत का हिस्सा हुआ करता था और तब मराठा साम्राज्य पैदा भी नहि हुआ था
1448 के अंदर, गुजरात सल्तनत में बादशाह से पुर्तगालीओ ने लिया और उसके बाद पुर्तगाली लोगो से बॉम्बे ब्रिटिश ने लिया
अतः बॉम्बे पर गुजरात सल्तनत का तो सीधा प्रभाव था लेकिन मराठा साम्राज्य का नहि
रही बात मराठाओं के गुजरात में शासन की तो वह हम ही थे जिंहौने छत्रपति शिवाजी को सामने से बुलाया था अपना धन लूँटने के लिये ताकि औरंगज़ेब के हाथ ना लगे हमारा धन
@@harshyagnik5334 I believe in Dr Ambedkar not you ... Who are you ?
There has been lot of sultanates since so many years across India ..even mh was part of another sultanate ... But the fact is Gujarati never ruled mh but vice versa is true.
Britishers used people according to their requirement and shifted from one place to another .. tamilians were shifted to Malaysia / Singapore , south Africa for doing labour work ...
According to 1941 population date 51% of locals were marathis and rest migrated and some other religion settled long ago.
Gujaratis got free warehouses and lands by Britishers that's why they grown up in business .. Marathas were busy fighting for swarajya and saved not only Gujarat but also almost whole India ... 1857 revolt by tatya tope , manikarnika tambe , peshwa ,angal landey etc etc and then gokhale and lokmanya tilak , savarkar , Subhash Chandra Bose etc who continued the fight against British
Finally mahatma Gandhi followed teaching from gokhle and helped for freedom
So inspite having so many freedom fighters Gandhi is well known and called father of nation why ? Cause he was the last well know person alive during freedom.
You can't jump the guns .. now Mumbai is part of mh that's the truth . So don't jump the guns .... My comment was according to Ambedkar what he said to Gujaratis on 9 points after freedom to desai and his Gujarati team and has logic in it .
If you have given space to do some business does not mean you can claim it. That's why Ambedkar give lots of details in his book.
@@santoshkhade1257 in 1951 census marathi was minority in mumbai
About 43.6 percent of population .
The last time I saw marathis were majority in mumbai was in 1911 where 53 percent of mumbai spoke marathi.
@@harshyagnik5334 jo tu bolraha Hai vo aadha sach Hai.
Khali naam mein gujarath hone ka Matlab ye nahi ki sultanate gujarath ki huyi .
Itihas padho . Gujarath sultanate pahile delhi sultanate ka hissa Hua karta tha fir jab delhi sultanate kamzor huyi tab gujarath region ke governer ne khud ko independent rural ghoshit Kiya aur uske baad gujarath sultanate aayi lekin sultante ke Raja urdu farsi aur persian ka hi zyada use karte the gujarathi ka nahin
Main south bombay par nahin lekin suburban mumbai par marathonka Prabhav Padha tha . British ne bombay ke saath taaku( which today form south bombay) Portuguesonse liye lekin salesetti islands ( which today form suburban mumbai) Portuguese rakhe. 1739 ke battle of bassein mein peshwa bajirao aur chimaji aapa ne Vaha se portuguesonko bhagaya aur use maratha empire mein milaya . Fir 1784cmein treaty of salbai mein vo areas marathas ne British ki diya bombay ke expansion keliye .
Mumbai gujarath sultanate se pahile devgiri yadavon ke Raja bimbideva ka capital tha . Raja bimbideva culture se maharashtra ke konkan region ka tha aur unhonee bahut saare maharasjtrian communities vaha llaye the Jaise ki panchlakshi vrahmins , vadvals , agris , bhors etc.
Agreed
गर्जा महाराष्ट्र माझा जय जय महाराष्ट्र माझा🚩🚩🚩
Always jay jay jay Maharashtra 🧡🧡🧡🧡
Jai kokan
As a sindhi i heard stories of partitions from my grandparents for both like partition of india & Pakistan
And also as we lives in Gujarat i am hearing stories of Gujarat and Maharashtra partition 😇 hope Gujarat and Maharashtra even whole India keep developing ❤️❤️
U migrated from Pakistan ?
@@blacksheep6174 no my grandparents were migrated to India from Pakistan
@@LHA12 which part of India ! You guys still speak Sindhi ?
@@blacksheep6174every sindhis speak sindhi my friend.
Damn you guys REALLY stepped up the video production quality! Very smooth.
Great topic. Being an Uttrakhandi, I would definitely love to see how Uttrakhand got created.
Government just want to seprate the hilly region of up, cuz up was a big state, and state was not providing much facility and development in hilly region, hence uk got created, tho I would also love to see a whole video out of it.
Up and Bihar should learn many things from these two developed states but we should not forget that from Gujarat only we got a govt like this we have today
"although"
What?
I think there should be a separate state for bhojpuri
@@nknkannadiga9742 bhojpuri, magahi and awadhi speaking areas from UP, Bihar and MP should be separated into a single state.
Gujarat and Maha are not landlocked like Bihar and UP, this gives them a big advantage
Wow growing up in Mumbai, I did not know all these.. Thanks Mohak for the awesome research that you have put in and presented this to us... keep on rocking my friend
11:23 Ironically majority of the Gujratis target Marathis and Muslims by not allowing them in their society's and prohibiting their dietary choices. Who is doing the discrimination on linguistic basis now?
Bro Gujaratis don't target muslims and marathis, the fact that they do not allow them is because they are non- vegetarian people, otherwise we dont hate anyone on the basis of their language and its the owners wish, who they want to allow in their society
जय जय महाराष्ट्र माझा 🔥🔥❤️
Jai kokan majha
@@buzztube1738 jai Pashchim Maharashtr
@@TheFutureWeWant Te ek mahinya purwi bhava ata fakt jai hind
These 2 legendary states take care of entire BIMARU state
Stop calling Northern states bimaru, that just shows who's mentality is really bimar.
@@himanshusingh3167 he isn't wrong tho , Bihar is a burden on entire india
😂😂😂😂😂
Parsis have more contribution to economy than 230million peaceful
You and the team should be really proud of this one, Mohak. This is so well made.
So at that time Marathi people were fighting for Bombay city because they felt that the city was built by Marathi work force and they ignored Gujarati capital but in early 2000 they were throwing bihari and UP labour outside. at that time they forgot that these labours are also responsible in making of Mumbai City stange Haan 🤔🙄
They are not fighting because they were just labors or work force they are fighting because local marathi people like agri,koli are land owners of mumbai .
There are multiple angles to this. Do not base your opinion on one video. The land (except the area near Gujarat) was mostly owned by the original Maharashtrians.
And about throwing UP, Bihar workers out of Maharashtra, that was a whole political thing to get votes. And I agree, it was wrong.
@@ShivamSharma-5622 taang kheech rha hoon bhai bura mat maano 😝
@@vishveshkhanzode9342 bhai Punjab , kashmir, Maharashtra, tamilnadu aise india ko dekhenge toh bas ladenge ..unite rahe and desh ko aage badhaye 🙏
@@sarveshjadhav9617 this is land bro no one owns this you own untill you are alive after that tum bhi isi mitti me mil jaoge 🙏 desh hai sabka hai milke raho aage badho🙏
It is so important to know the correct history of everything. Very informative video. Thank you very much.
I learned about this when I got curious why 1st May is a holiday.
How😂
Agree
My sister can't celebrate her birthday coz both of my parents are teachers and
They return home late at 1st of May.
But may 1st is a holiday worldwide because of international labour day
There is no holiday in gujarat for gujarat day🙃
1st May is Labours day 🤣🤣
I was in Dang district for 4 years. It's completely a different world. Dense forest and Humble people. Gujarat government has done wonders in that area.
I think this is might be reason Gujaratis can easily catch up with Marathis or Maharashtra than other states same goes with marathi or Maharashtra people they can easily catch up with Gujarati or gujrat than other states
Being Gujarati i will definitely prefer Maharashtra over other states as so much similarities in food, climate, thinking, education, language, etc 😇
I used to study in Dang district, let me tell you it is a very backward district but geographically very beautiful
Are you still there
@@shivamramani2579 no, I did my 11 and 12th there
Dominant language there?
@@utkarshxo9039 mostly gujrati but many can understand marathi too.
Hey...I'm from Dang District. In which school you studied?🤸🔥
जय जिजाऊ
जय शिवराय
जय शंभूराजे
जय महाराष्ट्र
Jai hind jai Maharashtra
I am from gujrat, jai shivaji maharaj and jai hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🚩🚩🚩
And now both Gujarat and Maharashtra are economic hub of Bharat
i wanted to learn about this topic for such for such a long time! thanks Mohak you always bring such intersting topics for us
PROUD TO BE A GUJARATI..
favorite sentence for all wankers: "Proud to be "
💓👍
not related to the topic but Mohak could you do a video on the booming fast fashion industry, its a big problem and no one really talks about it, really appreciate your work and effort put into it! and as usual amazing video!!😊
I think an open letter/comment waale bhaiya ne iss topic par video banaya tha
@@Karan-te9yi aaj kal unhe ke hi topic churaye jaa rhe hai😁
As a GPSC (Gujarat public service Commission) aspirant I read so many book for this topic but could not understand. Until I found this video. Great research and content.
I'm cocktail .... Half gujju & half Marathi 😂😂😂 love both languages ! And culture !
Good
Suryawanshi means marathi sirname
@Nike Jagirdar 🤣🤣🤣 marathi gujarati bhai bhai hai kuch chtya log bhi hai zagade ke liye 🤣 tum kha rehate ho
Now you represent the two cultures well!
@Nike Jagirdar Kesa combo hai ye 🙄
I had always wondered how so many Gujarati people, also especially Parsis ended up in Mumbai... Informative.... Although Mumbai is geographically included in Maharashtra, it is mostly a city that was developed as a trade capital and still a place of opportunities... It is in Mumbai's air....
U skipped no. of deaths 107(marathi) on that day when moraji desai announced open firing in Mumbai.
"Marathi Labour" This shou;ld be reminded to Marathis when they discriminate with UP Bihar People.
Marathis were not labours they were land owners Agri-koli(Marathi) community.
Shivsena ke base pr har ek marathi ko mat generalize kro
Want to add something in it... chatrapati shivaji maharaj raided Surat 2 times it resulted in way that Surat became a difficult place to trade. And shivaji maharaj started giving protection to Mumbai's traders and thats when most of traders moved to Bombay from surat. More credits to ch. Shivaji maharaj 🙌🙌🙌
He did not raid Surat, he attacked the Mughal Empire in Surat, he wanted to bring it under Bhagwa (saffron) flag from Islamic occupation.
That's how important to respect every Regionals Languages in their States.
Jai Maharashtra 🔥🔥
Jai Garvi Gujarat!
Jai hind!
Vande matram jay hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@lokeshrathod4541 jai hind!
Yeah it is burning, let's try to chill it out
Bombay state itself was carved out Maratha empire. Comprising Parts of Gujarat, maharashtra and karnatak.
Hi Mohak, do you think the way Indian federal system works is the best that India can do? Or would it have been better to give every state more power or less power than they already have? Like should things in state list, centre list or concurrent list increase or decrease? Would love to see a video on this topic