Why India is more developed than Pakistan
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 июн 2024
- Download OneCard - onecard.onelink.me/High/8vw751bu and get your instant virtual card now.
#BeTeamMetal
******
You might have seen our recent video on the Pakistani economy. In the video, we discussed the various reasons that for the crisis in Pakistani economy. India, on the other hand, is doing much despite the stresses of Covid. But you might be surprised to know that there was a time when Pakistan had a better economy than India, with Pakistan’s GDP per capita significantly higher than India in the early 1980s. Today, however, India has far outpaced Pakistan’s growth. How has that happened? As we’ll see in this video, it’s a fascinating assortment of reasons, all of which we have discussed in detail.
******
Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1v...
******
Research:
Mohit Priyadarshi: / mohitprior
Editing:
Yash Vyas: / yashvyas24
Ajinkya Kawale: / ajinkya.kawale
Channel Manager :
Ajeesh Babu: / ajeesh_babu
Thumbnail :
Aanchal verma: / aanchal_creates
Subtitles:
Dhruv Bambhaniya: / dhruvkumar_2920
Want to work with us? Check this link!
tinyurl.com/22pxjjtv
******
Like the background music? I use Epidemic Sound. You can get a 30-day free trial using this referral: bit.ly/3A7bUx7
******
🗳Support on Patreon: / sochyoutube
👾Discord: / discord
🐦Twitter: / mohakmangal
📷Instagram: / mohak.mangal
👤Facebook: / sochyoutube
******
Playlists
🇮🇳Indian Society: • Hijab: Ban Right or Wr...
🗺Geopolitics and Foreign Affairs: • Will China Invade Taiwan?
🧍🏽♀️Issues of a Young Indian: • Are Indian Girls Bad a...
💰Economy: • How Kerala Changed its...
🗳Indian Politics: • UP Elections: Why Are ...
🇮🇳 Discoveries of India: • How Goa Joined India
📈Money, Stocks, and Crypto: • Why Indian Youth is NO...
******
Creative commons:
Unsplash
Flaticon
Freepik
Videvo
******
Markers
00:00 Introduction
01:58 New Nations, New Dreams
03:40 What was Happening in Pakistan?
04:23 A) Agricultural and Industrial Growth
06:10 B) Foreign Aid
07:05 India's Model
08:09 What Changed? 1) Bangladesh Liberation
12:02 2) Political and Security Risks
14:27 Military control and elite capture
15:28 3) Liberalization of India's Economy
17:00 Conclusion
Download OneCard - onecard.onelink.me/High/8vw751bu and get your instant virtual card now.
#BeTeamMetal
1st
1st
Pakistan geography is its biggest asset
Fun fact : 85 percent of people who killed on genocide were bengali hindus 🕉
Bro make a video on failure of Indian judicial system in delivering justice.
Our former PM Manmohan Singh ji, has been very underappreciated as a finance minister*❤️
It was IMF who imposed those LPG
But bhakt nahi Manenge
Kass lpg aur pehle ho pata like in China 🇨🇳
He was good as a finance minister but the growth during his tenure as prime minister was very unsustainable. Slow development of infrastructure and manufacturing, only growth in services which is unsustainable.
@@kimjong-un1217 He was a great finance minister but not Prime minister, maybe he could have been if not for the Gandhi family.
Things to learn : Never mix religion in politics. 🇮🇳
And Never Appease a particular community on pretext of Other community.. Just like Manmohan Singh said that Muslims have first right on Resources...
In India , All parties do religious appeasement !! Congress , AAP , TMC and other do muslim appeasement on the other hand BJP , Shivsena do Hindu appeasement simple !!
Even Manmohan singh had muslim appeasement policy
@@AbhishekKumar-cd2tm And never learn anything from WhatsApp University 🤣🤣
@@AbhishekKumar-cd2tm source?
This has nothing to do with religion. 1991 economic liberalization is the greatest thing to happen to post-independent India.
We need to ditch our socialist mentality anf liberalize our economy more.
Being a Pakistani i am really thankful to you for bringing this topic in eyes without any biased opinions.
You have said facts and yes we destroyed Pakistan and still doing the same.. hope one day we Indians and Pakistani can live peacefully
India wants to subjugate us.
You are converted your ancestors was Hindu😊😊
Jai shri ram🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
He is nobody special Paaji, just a normal human being with a youtube channel. Je me wrong hu, pher us great aadmi ko bolo ke me ra ka tapapa kar de. He's no more importan than you or me or all the people who have commented to his youtube video. He's flesh n bone like you and me. Atoms and molecules brother 🙂
Stand tall. he is a youtube video creator. You can also be the same , i can also be the same. I am sure he will admit he is nobody more important than you or I or anybody here. 🙂
Salam Ul Aikum Paaji
@@SN1638And everyone's ancestors were religionless once😊
As a Pakistani, I have found your research on a basis of fact and figures and whatever you said apart from political differences, are right. Military coup and bad policies have been major enemy of Pakistan's economy.
The military personnel and their undertaking should be brought out to see what ? And where the funds go ?!?
The Pakistani Military owns most of the national economy and evades a lot of taxes which can go into nation building. Bahria Town and Fauji foundation are prime examples. These are considered charitable foundations and pay less taxes and have monopoly in business.
Being a Pakistani we are really ashamed of what we have done and why our politicians are just destroying our beloved country 😭😭
Your surname is sus🤨📸
Not your politician but your Army control
@@krishvyas9953 Lmao
@@krishvyas9953 It may have been derived from Bhatt as Hinduism was prevalent till Afghanistan in ancient times before desert tribe invaded and converted all
@@TheConfirmist 😂😂
Another reason for their economic boom in the 60's was Bangladesh or the erstwhile East Pakistan. They took our wealth and fed their people. East Bengal or East Pakistan contributed to 62% of the government revenue of Pakistan and got roughly 25% in return. After 1971, there was no 'East Pakistan' to exploit.
Sari textile tu West Pakistan mai thi bruh... Yes our politicians had rude behavior but many things were exaggerated by your politicians for their own personal benefits... Khair acha hoa alag ho gy.. At least ab hmmarri wjha sai ap ko tqleef tu nhi ho gi.. Khoosh rahayn
basically it was like British rule season -2
Jhoot mat bolo
Love from Darjeeling dada
@@saifali-qj2hs don’t confine your knowledge to what your country wants you to know. Look beyond that and you'll be able to know the truth.
Hi. I'm from Pakistan 🇵🇰 and I must appreciate your video because you were completely focused on the topic without being biased towards Pakistan. Haven't seen even a little hate but totally facts without being bitter and insulting which mostly Indians done. Keep doing nice work man. Awesome 👌 👏 👍
Because for you people religion comes first not country, that's why I hate most about pakistan.
agreed
Ooy ptwari
@@umarfarooqgujjar8176 dudu pi
Well it's an educational channel not an geopolitical channel
I don't know why Indians just simply credit Mr.Manmohan Singh for all the things ( which of course he had his role)..but no body talks about the great and the most underrated prime minister of india Dr.PV Narasimha Rao..if u just read about him (best book is "the half lion" ) u will understand what sort freaking genius that man was..he was a visionary and action oriented personality..just because he lacks charisma doesn't mean he don't deserve any credits..all due respect to the spine behind all the 1991 reforms..🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🏻
Dr. PV Narashimha is for India is what M. Khan Junejo is for Pakistan
FInally some sensible comment. They dont appreciate because most want Congress to look good. MMS represents Congress for them, not PVNR.
Dude it was manmohan Singh brain behind PV Narasimha raos decision. He was just a prime minister.
@@surajkumarshetty4810 dude..as I said just read the book "the half lion" u will understand what am talking about..🙏🏻
Why anyone can't see growth at that time why everyone saying that india is now growing better I know it's bitter for you but it's truth
As a Pakistani, I (and many others) appreciate you making this video.
*You want Kashmir.?* 🤔
@@mogleesh-22 is it Free?
@@HelpfulHarry Nope. You won't be getting any.
@@mogleesh-22 bhai tu ne Ladai jarur shuru Karni hoti hai
@@HelpfulHarry Laure tera desh isme chal jayega
Soviet invasion of Afghanistan played a pivotal role in terror factories in Pakistan,
while Soviet collapse played a pivotal role in making india to move into to a market economy.
Both the South Asian economies were influenced by the West vs Communist geopolitics, even till this date.
Yeah man
Soviet union and USA was like to poles of the earth
Very well said
I wish the soviets would won, then socialist Afghanistan could be preserved when they were seeing hdi growth. In 1975 Afghanistan was richer than India.
Yes , Bcoz Porkias are radical people .. They don't want development & mehnat ... They only want Muft ka maal Or formal word Maal-e-ganimat just like M & reservation lovers here in India .
Pakistan is addicted to freebies. Got a country without struggle. And donation from usa and China.
Thank you my Indian brother for such a crystal clear explanation. Take love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩.
Bangladesh is doing super good for last decade especially taking over textile export , congratulations on great performance economically
Kangludesh
@@PrashadKaPrasad Thanks for showing your illiterate background
@@MirMahmud2003 ingore it bro , lot of trolls online
@@jaintango But not doing good in science and technology.
Let’s appreciate this for explaining such a controversial topic in simple words without any hatred against pakistan 👏 love from pakistan
Ak to religion extremity or dusra anti India nature is the reason. Anti India stand forcing Pakistan to spend more on army instead of education and health. India forcing Pakistan to spend more and more on army. Bangladesh choose different path they naturally doing better in education, health and economy.
@@vickkeevickkee2043 Your explanation is much easier. Hahaha
@@vickkeevickkee2043 all of south asia would be a better place if we stop hating each other
As a Pakistani Student we must work hard like indian students.
Love from Pakistan.
Basically, you're are Indian but saying Pakistani 🤣🤣🤣
@@zoyapayeng9743 you are a classic example why Pakistan will never development always pulling your own kin
*You want Kashmir?* 🤔
@@ritwikmandal1928 Mera Pakistani hone me Nehru ji ki galti😁
@@mogleesh-22 Bhai, Kashmir humara hai, humara hi rehega...
As a Sri Lankan and Buddhist. Same thing our Sri Lanka. Buddhism is not the state religion of our country. But Buddhism has been given great priority in Sri Lanka. Religion (Buddhism) and politics are mixed in our country. Most Buddhist monks have forgotten the role of the monk. Doing politics. Some Buddhist monks have become radicalized. Very sad to say. This is the reason for the economic crisis in our country.😭😭
I don't think buddhism has any role to play in SriLanka's downfall , it has got to do with dynastic politics of Rajpaksha's and screwed up policies like big infrastructure airport projects and 100% organic farming.
Love from Pakistan brother ❤️ don't worry our countries will hopefully become great once again. After every dark night their is a pleasant morning.
Have buddhist monks have also formed terrorist organizations like Pakistans jaesh e mohammed or lashkar e toiba?
@@mustafaahmed4410 Nahh, we Indians don't hope any good for you
@@defenderofjustice3435 yes we know 🤣🤣
10:46 So true. The growth engine was Bangladesh 🇧🇩💪
What now?
Pakistan railways is a good example of the rise and downfall of Pakistani economy. Most of the railway tracks in Pakistan were laid during the British era and upto the 60s, later very little expansion has been done.
Also in early 2000s Pakistan had to shutdown the Karachi Circular Railway due to bankruptcy
1991 economic liberalization is the greatest thing to happen to post-independent India.
We need to ditch our socialist mentality anf liberalize our economy more.
@@TheRishijoesanu
And some legends still say that Socialism is the best, it just has never been implemented properly.
After dividing the world into two parts, they still say that it has never been implemented properly.
कौन हैं ये लोग? कहाँ से आते हैं ये?
@@TheRishijoesanu inc and leftists dosen't want that
@@TheRishijoesanu we can't be that much liberal in economy lest capitalists will buy our whole nation like it is happening today
Amazing
If there were internet users in 1991 then lot of people would be saying "MMS ne desh bech diya"
But we were too late
But I'm against privatisation of LIC tbh although I'm fully supportive of privatisation of air India also I would like if indian postal services is privatised
@@SQUID12 you are right. Petroleum companies banks, LiC should not be private
@@SQUID12 Lic has been made public only just all other PSUs which were made public decades ago, How it can be said selling or even how can it be said privatised??
@@atulchaubey2826 they should
Proud to be Indian
Great Effort...as a Pakistani i appriciate your effort you summarized the whole thing...in a very good way..without insulting anyone.
Thank you from.Bangladesh, well wishes for India.🇮🇳🇧🇩🇳🇵
U did great research but missed a point that Manmohan Singh did not liberalise the economy on his own will. India was forced to open its economy in order to take help from IMF in BOP crisis of 1991.
That was the sole reason for economy to open up to the world. India was never ready for that because britishers came as traders and ruled over us, which made Indian government fearful of foreign companies.
Sadly political influence has led to hiding of facts. I also read how government implemented reforms but never it was forced by imf
@@ShubhamMishrabro exactly so, political leanings have made people stop thinking rationally
And rao was the real hero not mms
you forgot the cold war , Russia USSR was a very powerful nation and influenced many countries and allys to follow socialist model. ( Like a trend )
Economic transformation was not a MCQ question in which one of 4 options is the right answer
Thank god MMS was there to execute this mega complex revolution without any blunders. If sanghis were in power they would have drowned us. E.g. they viciously opposed computerization of govt offices.
Well, I am pursuing economics and I'm in 12th, this video touched new economic policies and India, China, Pakistan chapters of ncert, with detailed explanation. I just gave mcqs test of those questions whose answers I have got from here. So informational, keep it up!!
despite being indian you are anlaysis is very appreciated
respect you from 🇵🇰🕊️🕊️🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
He is American not indian
We are educated people. Unlike what your media shows.
@@buzztube1738 than he should make video on US not india
@@rakshas7219 For sure
What does it mean by Indians here..dude we speak on facts and research 🙏
If indian economy would have been opened up in 1960 our economy would have been triple the size of today's
Yeah, because many countries were still growing that time
But today many have become too overpowered to compete eith
If India opened up in 1960 then our economy would be 70% larger than American economy today.
Free markets are an extremely powerful tool
but that period of time socialism was in rise
We could also have been looted and destroyed like the several South American and African economies that were destroyed by NATO nations, mainly USA. Capitalism and globalisation are not ethical, they are often accompanied by forced WTO trade deals that can take away a lot of civic freedoms, economic protections for the masses and tamper with the sovereignty of any country.
True
India is doing great now thanks to the leader like Manmohan Singh now Narender Modi sir ❤❤❤
Though we are doing better than Pakistan, we shouldn't limit ourselves there. China is dominating the world and we should try to reach there.
China is a great country. All Indian comrades love China 😊
China is nowhere dominating the “whole world”.😂
@@ghs89 that’s why Gobi ji didn’t blame China even after they killed our 20 soldiers in Galwan😢
China liberalised it's economy in 1970's meanwhile India opened up in 90's China got first's mover advantage that's the reason China is way ahead of India
@@vipulkanojiya2588 I think you are politically biased, who said age of expansionism is over? Isn't it PM? It mean china right?
Manmohan Ji is an example of true Gem of modern India! India is India because of him. India is growing, learning, leaping & dominating because of him ☺️❤️❤️❤️
Wasnt he a khalistani?
@@lampart6950 Are you living in the 1980s??
Khalistani Movement was at it's Peak back in the 1980s and that Movement Died by the 1990s.
This is 2022 bro.
@@gouthamsudheer2080 yes we lived that 80's on our chest,
You are talking about 2022 then what happened at kisaan agitation? Why they were called khalistani? Police and admin yet again opened fire,
@@lampart6950 They were all BJP supporters who were Calling the Kissan from Punjab Khalistanis because they need Something to Counter their Movement.
Afterall, at the End, the Kissans Won against the Farm Laws, right?
@@gouthamsudheer2080 its not about winning or losing, its about the thoughts, sikhs look different thats why no one like us,
I am not talking about all but majority
I am your regular viewer from Pakistan and the reasons that Pakistan is lagging behind in most of economical indicators are 1. Pakistan involving itself in the Afghan wars in the 70s , 80s and 2000s ( War on terror) . 2. No expansion of the tax network 3. Subsidies given to the elite and rich e.g Sugar and Real Estate sectors. There is no incentive for the investor to set up a factory that can export and it is easier for them to invest in a plot of land and earn more which is not benefitting anyone and doesn't increase productivity and employment. 4. No FDI because of the wars that Pakistan fought on the western front and that created a security issue which we are still facing today. There are many more reasons aswell for example not spending on education and agticulture sectors. Pakistan has the lowest literacy rate in all of south aisa.
👍
you forget to mention islamic radicalisation and its support by public and military.
are tum log jashan manao ki hamne india ka 3 billion investment afghanistan me duba diya
Most of the points you said must be true.. a stable, prosperous, sanely religious (not religiously fanatic), educated pakistan is good for india too... as india have always got well with civilian democratic governments in pakistan.. during nawaz sheriffs time with vajpayye. And even in modi-nawaz sheriff times too... but pakistan military derailed the peace talks with kargil war and pathankot-uri attacks... now india-pakistan relations is back to square one .. and india have kindf learned to avoid /ignore pakistan too in recent times... may be once a moderate democratic stable govt with less military intervention in pakistan happens.. india -pakistan relationship will improve and solutions for the issues could be findout too
@@sunilsabat-0483 Aisi baaton pe jashan trolls manatay hain bhai
So these are clear lessons for us indians also if we don't want to repeat same mistakes either our's Or pakistan's
1) Socialism doesn't work. Countless examples and our own experience suggests same so we should continue and improve our current path of capitalist economic reforms and infrastructure building
2) We should strengthen our institutions so as to resist any authoritarian and religious extremism that would destroy the peace and prosperity of country
3) we must focus on human development because even a country with 5 million people who are well educated, free spirited, entrepreneurial and innovative can do better than a country of 500 million with less human development
I take issue with 2 & 3:
1. The idea of Pakistan's extremist path is not applicable to India. Pakistan's political and military elite deliberately chose the anti economic path as they had realised by the 70's and even more so by the 90's (failure of Stan bloc) they don't want the economic path because their society and country would be consumed under it.
2. Human development is a second order effect of economic progress. A country that overproduces it's elite will be ruled from the outside.
When the population of ab-duls increases in a country, reli-gious extremism automatically increases. Nothing much can be done about it
When industry were infant in late 1800 even America was protecting its infant industry. Today opening up works because
1. Industry of west comes to east for cheap labour.
2. Consumers get better products at lesser price.
But before independence our industry was crushed by uk as they sold cheap saree bangle agarbatti etc to us and not let us develop heavy industry. Jl nehru was clear foundation needs to be strong so instead of Consumer goods we sacrificed to produce heavy industry. 1990s this power steel engineering industry was used to make industrial machine which produced Consumer goods. So socialism was not an ideology , it was a curtain under ussr to grow at home. U dnt let your infant roam around. Once same infant grows up you dnt stop or protect.
@@gyatak200 Nehru laid the foundation of India's incompetence. Today, India lags in almost every high-tech industry. We don't make our processors, electronic parts, machines used for making tools, etc. Everything is imported from China, EU or USA
@@SapiensHaiHum inequality is increased. Not poverty. That is why it's a necessary evil.
Your research is truely wholesome!Your are definitely going to grow by leaps.Subscribed!
Beautiful presentation n explanation ...love it...i rarely comment but cldnt stop myself from appreciating the research n hard work you have put in this video
Irrespective of your Left-wing, Right-wing, or Centrist identity, listen to the video carefully and keep aside the India-Pakistan part for a moment. Lots of crucial topics are talked about regarding India and its people's past trends and future scope accidentally which should be discussed in prime time debates.
1991 economic liberalization is the greatest thing to happen to post-independent India.
We need to ditch our socialist mentality anf liberalize our economy more.
Name one developed country where this is debated in prime time. (Answer: there are none. This is a self imposition guided by self hatred just like "you did not get the girl because you don't have eight pack abs)
Mao Zedong and Pol Pot should be the icons of all Indians. This is how we can develop India.
@@ghs89 Ah yes, develop India by starving millions! Surely a good idea!
@@ghs89 Chinese bot I've seen him multiple times don't mind him
Love you Bhai from Pakistan 🇵🇰 . Kia research ki hy kabil e tareef hy totally unbiased
I don’t know why are you surprised. He never hates any country, he is a sensible person
@@mdazeem2114 generally we don't hate the people of Pakistan. Indian & Pakistani r always good friends in a third country due to similar ethnicity.
@@vasoolee I agree with you, many friends who lives in abroad told me the same.
@@vasooleenot ethnicity, but you can say language, way of making food, songs, etc. otherwise pak and India are a lot different
Awesome knowledge bro... Keep the good work
Bhai aapke andar bilkul bhi doglapan nhi h or aap fact k sath har chij clear krte, kisi ek party ko support nhi krte bas knowledge share ho. This is really good thing ❤
1991 was game changer 🔥
Ye bolna sahi hai bhakto ko samajh hi nahi ayega iss saal kya hua
@@Tuniyatv Sayad aap Bhakto ko Liberals ka confuse kr rhe h 😋
1991 economic liberalization is the greatest thing to happen to post-independent India. The current generation is losing the cultural memory of 1991
We need to ditch our socialist mentality anf liberalize our economy more.
@@Tuniyatv achha and 1991 ke bad manufacturing pe focus kyu nahi kiya fir 😏 , sorry pappu ne to bola tha ham manufacturing kar hi nahi skte , and logistics pe kam kyu nahi kiya? Ab tu itne bhi talwe nahi chant
@@Tuniyatv tell me one unique policy MMS presented outside of the Bretten Woods system aur log Maan jayenge. This is the reason BJP respects Narasimha Rao and not MMS. Bande ne existing system jo thopa gaya (as a condition for the loan) tha usko partially implement Kiya.
1991 budget was really game changing for us.
It was by a accident prime minister Manmohan Singh
@@davinderkaur4418 but bhakt nahi Manenge
@@kimjong-un1217 yes right . how you came here kim
@@kimjong-un1217 tumlog nhi sudhorgye har chiz mai andbhakth aur chamche kartai ho congress ke samaye 10 saal mai 1 trillion dollar economy mai contribute huwa while today all know proof is reality
@@kimjong-un1217 sir Manmohan singh did very good as finance minister but not that good as pm because of congress.
Congress is very much into family politics.
Whereas bjp proved that they are good in foreign policy and internal security.
Thoroughly researched and well presented!
So Nyc Message Passed Mohawk Broh ❤❤❤
Pakistan was doing good before due to Bangladesh. Most of its income used to come from East Pakistan(Bangladesh). But used to spend very less in that region. And when they lost Bangladesh, their downfall started and still falling.
THAT'S NOT COMPLETELY TRUE.
THE CONDITION OF BANGLADESH WAS VERY BAD.
Partially correct
But you should remember that while Bangladesh/East Pakistan was great for agriculture and textile industries
West Pakistan was performing good in IT, Electronics, Automobile, Logistics and also agriculture sector that time.
But they were too baised and partial. So, they focussed on only one side.
It's similar to how Maharashtra pays most of it's attention to west only🙃
Nope bruh.. It is correct that East Pakistan played a very crucial role in Pakistan's economy but west Pakistan also had taxtile industry.. East Pakistan was important for agriculture but taxtile industry was completely based in west Pakistan.. As a Pakistani, i will say our rude behavior towards East Pakistanis was not good especially of our politicians...On the other hand our politicians have no problem to divide pakistan for their persoal benefits.. That's the reason Bhutto and Mujib ur Reham took the benefit of it.. While our army always take everything on its ego.. Army could control the situation but they did'nt.. Rather they become the part of politicians' politica
@@anujkumarmishra8284 Bangladeshi gdp growth is one of the top in world. From the rootless basket now Bangladesh is one of the fastest growing economy in world. A lot of social and economical indicators Bangladeshi condition is comparatively better then most of the South asian countries.
Nahi sari textile to thi hi west pakistan mein agricultural land bhi Bangladesh se bhi achi amdan hoti thi
So basically Pakistan said goodbye to East Pakistan and it's economic growth along with it💀
Nope bruh.. Even Bhutto k time mai economy boht achi thi. Problem tb hoi jb Arab Israel ki war ki wjha sai oil prices peak pr challgy aur Pakistan mai history ka khofnaaq Sailaab aya.. Us sai Pakistan ki economy ko boht nouqsaan hoa aur phr economy smbhl nhi sakki
@@MUHAMMADASLAM-bt7df terrorism was the reason
It's always well known fact that don't mix religion with politics there's a reason west understood it earlier and now are waaaay ahead of whether it's Pakistan or other Asian countries
Pakistan mein aaj bhi textile buhut zyada hai faislabad ko Manchester kaha jata hai
@@saifali-qj2hs sure buddy😂😂😂
Hi Mohak, I'm from Pakistan. I've seen tons of videos made by Indian RUclipsrs taking current situations of Pakistan as a boost to their Channels. All of them have used a harsh language and slang words for their neighboring and were seen happy for what its been going through these days, like if jese unpr to kudh sada bahar rhy gi. I really appreciate the way you've conveyed the knowledge in your video keeping both countries equal.
Paying back with the same coins…that’s all. ✌🏽
Bete tum iske video me gaali dhundte reh gaye aur isne Islam ko pakistan ke badhaali ka zimmedar bana diya 🤡
he literally said it is due to Islamization.
Filhal to tu yahi samajh le ...yahan se India sada Bahar hi rahega ...kyunki yahan ki India ko aaagy hi Jana h ....tu 5 saaal or ruk ....tujhe India or pak me difference or bhi zyada clear dikhne lagega !!!!
@@realsrvbhtngr Abay Kaalay keerday, mene video ki postiviity ki baat ki hai. Pakistan is not doubt has been controlled by Military Coup since its beginning aur bahoot si ghaltiya ki hain jis ki waja se aj woh is stage pr agya hai, aur humai is cheez se agree krna chye.
We have to compare India with China not with Pakistan. 🤔
No one thinks India and Pakistan on same place not even Pakistan ~ Dr. S. Jaishankar. 🙄
We should compare ourself with usa but I think Indians know that they have no chance of beating america so they are happy to be a second fiddle.
@@mranonymous9141 Yes because USA is like dominate the world. US will treat India as like china and Russia, when we become 2nd/3rd largest economy. 🤔
@@mranonymous9141 we're behind china as well
He just wanted to shed light on how we overcame poverty when literally Pakistan was richer than us back in the days..... People like me are interested in such history
@@mranonymous9141 usa is beatable but china isnt
Most of the credit should go to our president Abdul Kalam Sir and prime ministers Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Manmohan Singh .....We need to thank them for what India has achieved today at the world stage 🔥🔥❤️❤️
You forgot to mention former PM P. V. Narasimha Rao. The main architect of the reforms.
@@kaptantomar9928
Exactly. He was the one taking the risk. MMS was only his finance Minister but as PM he would be the one to take the blame. NR had to fight the critics in his party, because he was going against Nehruvian socialism to rescue India.
For going against the Congressi idol Nehru, his own party virtually disowned him and even now won't give him the credit which is his due.
@@kaptantomar9928 agreed forgot to include him .... Thanks for reminding though 🙂🙂
@@kaptantomar9928 Give credit to Pakistan who helped USA in breaking of USSR and communism or else 90% of Indians wouldn't have shoes to wear in 2022 just like it didn't in 50's 60's 70' 80 and early 90's. India is till poorer than Pakistan with 66 crore people making under $3 a day. what UN can't calculate is the superior land fertility, seasons and culture of Pak. Poor of Pak have crops to grow and farm animals to eat. Pak never faced a famine. While over 40% Indian population go through famine every other year. No one ever pulled a riksha in Pakistan. No one ever committed hunger suicide in Pak but almost 33 poor of India commit hunger suicide on daily basis. Subscribe to western news and get rid of godee liar media. I
@@sabrinakhan8217 lol.....konsa ganja fhukta hai pakistan ki do kaudi ki awaam...ek kuch nhi waha pe chai khareedne ke paise nhi aur dusro ko jhuut bol ke nicha dikhaenge😂😂😂😂😂.....ek acha educational institution bhi nhi waha pe aur yaha ki bat karoge compare karoge😂😂😂😂😂😂......jo bhi tu ne bola ye sab clear jhoot hai aur aise same bat maine ditto dekhi hai...figure change kar ke bola tha kisi aur ne......Proof de tera...Nhi milega guaranteed.....par point blank full known bat hai ki tumlog ke pas chai ke paise nhi aur jute ki bat kar rahe ho ironically😂😂😂😂.....FATF ke terror list meh ho😂😂😂.....Yaha pe tumlog daily medical tourism ya apna ilaaj karwane aate ho😂😂😂😂....IMF meh daily jate ho😂😂😂😂koi industries,companies nahi hai tumlog ka aur agar hai bhi toh itna ghatiya hai ki pucho mat😂😂😂😂😂😂😂...koi softpower nhi hai tumlog ka😂😂😂😂😂😂......apni identity chupate ho hamesha😂😂😂😂😂....Pura debt meh ho aur china ke mercy pe jee rahe ho😂😂😂😂😂cpec ke nam pe tumhara pura desh wo log control karte hai😂😂😂....Russia ne discount meh tel dene se mana kar diya😂😂😂😂😂....aur koi tumlog ko pasand nhi karta...😂😂😂😂ghatiya foreign relations hai tumhare😂😂😂😂
Very detailed analysis. Yeah, Pakistan was once fastest growing economy. It averaged 6% from 1960 to 75. It was ahead of India in terms of growth rate, and per Capita. But even at that time indian GDP was 5.8 times bigger than pak. It the pak growth would have continued the difference would have been same today (5.8), not 10 times like today. Unfortunately, I didn't happen. But hopefully they will recover.
You didn't account for the size difference in terms of population and physical size. That's why per capita is a better measure
@@midorimashintaro2092Hmm. You could be right, but if you see Japan and Germany with even 1/3 size of pak in population and size. They had high nominal gdp than that of India. Even if India gdp becomes equivalent to USA. It per capita would be 1/7 of us because of massive population size.
@@harshsharma9898 yes, but they are the exceptions. Most countries are not that rich and are in India's range.
We have gone through a lot 😔
But we survived and recovered 💪
I am from 🇵🇰 I really liked the video.. no hate, no biasness.. just pure facts & information
An unbiased research
Honestly speaking learnt a lot.
Hat's off from 🇵🇰
vlog?
@@akashpaul4143 sorry 😞 informative or fact finding research
🇮🇳🤝🇵🇰
@@Adolf_Rizzler__ 😘🥰🥰🤝🤝
That's what common Indian and Pakistani want but unfortunately that is what Pakistani establishment and Indian politician don't want.
@@mistermmister8487 I am sure one day there will be peace and no religious fight ❤️
Well articulated video :)
Nice video , this video has a great message 📖👏🏼
I never like Manomohan Sing as a PM but his 1991 FM term was revolutionary. With the economic liberation, we would never could have become the same.
that liberation policy is because of imf that imposes condition to get pakage bailout.
China did that 20 years ago in 1970's
IMF forced him to open economy. He didn't do shiz.
Yes pm singh is underrated
He was only acting as a PM. The REAL PM was behind the scenes taking orders from the pope and mullahs
Great 👍 I'm Pakistani totally agree with you our Corrupt government destroys us government based on Religion so ......... 🥺 I'm Minority
Present indian govt is also based more on religion
Minority what's your religion? Girl
@@helix7203 christian
@@helix7203 hona bhi chahiye
@@helix7203 accha, religion pe based h toh madarse banae ke liye paise kyu baat ti h?
the current govt put indian culture and indian religiosn forward
thats it
I love how instead of criticizing Pakistan on its current state like others, Mohak presented the reasons and wrongdoings which lead Pakistan to be where it is now. As a Pakistani, Thank you. I wish you a very successful career in educating everyone that watches your content.
Great video! Loved it.
As Pakistani I 👍💯 Agree You
As a "pakistan begger"
@@sb7109 Any Problem
*You want Kashmir?* 🤔
@@mogleesh-22 I Just Want A Brother Relationship
That Hindustan motors advertisement's tagline hits me hard....that tagline gives a sense of realisation that how much risk, time and money does it take to invest in a complete state controlled/planning based economy.....
How so? Please elaborate.
@@ArmageddonIsHere The tagline was"Takes on Anything"literally anything even the government 😂....I viewed this tagline in a political and economical sense....
Great research bro
Pakistani here.
This is an excellent video. Extremely well researched and without any political bias.
Thank you mohak my pre - boards are starting from tomorrow and my first subject is economics, you helped me with highlighting Indian economy 😂❤️
1991 economic liberalization is the greatest thing to happen to post-independent India.
We need to ditch our socialist mentality anf liberalize our economy more.
All the best for your pre-boards and boards.
Question 1 ....what is LPG reforms..
@@bhagatsinghfans8735 kya bhai 10wi ka question
@Abhijeet Agrawal economics ka paper hai 12 me hoga
Bro, you missed another factor. After 1971, a percentage of Pakistan's money was diverted towards radicalisation to cause disturbances in India, which increased in later years...
Why do Indians think this is a problem when it's quite an ingenious solution Pakistan came up with? If they play the economic game they lose my friend.
It is small in percentage. It is used just to divert the mind of Pakistani people from Economy to an Imaginary War.
What about hindu radicalisation
@@amishsurani4765when and where?
@@premgosain2733 exactly they would just do it to gain majority votes in pak. Things we can see these days in our own country
Nice content andc
presentation thanks👍🙏
Amazing Work, hats off to you.
We need to acknowledge the role of Ch Ajit Singh in LPG reforms. Ch Ajit Singh ji prepared the draft of LPG reforms way before Dr Manmohan Singh ji but couldn't pass te bill because of the backlash from public and trade unions.
Dr Manmohan Singh ji brought this because India needed IMF bailout and IMF had put this condition infront of Indian govt.
Wow
Where can I know more about it?
@@amritaparida3992read class 12th economics
@@amritaparida3992 There is an article on Print and Indian Express. Any UPSC aspirant will tell you this fact
Ch. Ajit Singh was great personality , IIT-ian and a US trained computer engineer but got bogged down in dirty politics of those decades.
Wasn't expecting this to be so good. Well researched ! I like your apolitical commentary. Well done !
Really awesome informative video.
Can u make detailed analysis on impact from note ban.
The reason India grew after economic liberalization is because the untapped potential was realized. Its not the fruit of some wise policy maker but of the people themselves. Keep in mind we were literally forced to accept thise policies for getting an imf loan, just imagine how far we could've been if such policies and educational levels were maintained.
It gets even worse if you dig into the details. I am yet to come across a person who can cite details while praising MMS. His tenure as PM demonstrated his lack of input in implementation or even his personal convictions. Our growth story paid the price between 2010-2020 for selecting a skilled operator as a visionary
@@ok9yrago834 isn't that already the case? Someone I know called him "father of reforms"
[Quran 20:14]:-
Indeed, I am Allah. There is no God except Me, so worship Me and establish prayer for My remembrance.
[Quran 31:33]:-
O humanity ! Be mindful of your Lord, and beware of a Day when no parent will be of any benefit to their child, nor will a child be of any benefit to their parent. Surely Allah promise is true. So do not let the life of this world deceive you, nor let the Chief Deceiver, deceive you about Allah !
[Quran 24:22]:-
Do you not love to be forgiven by Allah ? And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful !
It's the diligent and hard working nature of Indians. They are always on their A game.
@@HasanUnknown sahi he.
But I'm sure this is not what you learned from this video or is it?
Mark mohan's words : As long as India focuses on its economy and development , not only our government but also us. The first and most dangerous step Pakistan went for was Islamisation which not only degraded their economy but also created chaos , increase terrorism and violence in their country.
And you were lucky that a modi govt was not in power in 1991. Otherwise they would’ve given priority to religion over development. It’s easy point out faults in others because wrong things happened at right times for them. While as right things with right people happened at the right time.
Just consider yourself luck that such a govt came into power when india was already a $2 trillion Economy.
@@9Rehankhan19 bhai dudu pi
@@9Rehankhan19 kuch bhi bole ja raha
@@9Rehankhan19 well said
@@9Rehankhan19India has seen a lot of economic development under the Modi government. Even our current projected gdp growth rate is the highest in the world. Be objective, not biased due to your own prejudices.
Extremely knowledgeable video. All the best 💞 buddy.
Allahumdulilah proud be indian 😎😎😎
Accha hai fir ummah ke chumma ke bbbare me sochna baand krdo
We as an indian aren't proud of you.
All Thanks to Manmohan Singh and Pv narsmiha rao for their economic reforms🙏🙏🙏
Also atal bihari vajpayee ji's 1990s economic reforms placed a huge amount of economic independence for India
Actually we need to thank IMF. They forced us. IMF actually tried to help west, but it helped us.
@@train_xc ikr 😂
@@kanamenoname210 exactly 💯 percent correct
All thanks to modi ji
15:32 seeing India's past videos always saddens me...What a time that was...we came a long way... through culture science and technology
Informative❤
Religion is one of the prominent reason behind what happened to pakistan 🇵🇰. To much extremist thoughts on religion is dangerous , it could harm india 🇮🇳 to we have to be aware.
Between Islamism and war on Terror, Pakistan had found a sweet spot which it milked for 50 years. How on earth can you continue thinking this applies to India?
Yes, u are right. India will have to eliminate is-lamist extremism from its soil. Banning pfi was a good step
@@rutvikrs Why is religious extremism and radical religious politics only unique to Pakistan?
@@chethanshajan9047 religious extremism is not unique but the identitarian politics causes it to be. Unlike conservatives in other countries, Pakistani elite does not have a history, foundation myth, theological mandate or continuing tradition. This causes them to essentially treat Pakistan as a temporary state of being. To some they are waiting for capture and conversion of the entire subcontinent, to most people it is the subsumation into the global ummah under the Caliphate.
This causes their identity crisis on who they really are. When a Pakistani salutes to their flag, they are honouring Islam which is unlike any other nation. Their political elites realise this either through ideology(Liaqat Ali, Zia ul Haq, Yahya Khan) or experience (liberals like Bhutto family, Gilani, Shaukat Ali and even Imran Khan who are liberals outside and conservatives inside the country).
Playing the welfare nation state game will cause them harm because they can never be energy surplus or keep a market economy to compete with either Asia or the Middle East. They even tried the Stan grouping which failed purely due to lack of cultural coherence.
@@rutvikrs The pakistani elite isn't the entire pakistani nation and we hv often seen that radical religious ideologies themselves (Islamic fundamentalism in this case) provides their own foundational myths and cooked up historical narratives. It's only a matter of how much radicalism the politician peddling it requires to mobilise the masses in his support and any society given the optimum conditions can be brought to this state.
Pakistan definitely has the potential and population to maintain a healthy market economy if it manages to bring major structural changes and evicts the military from its political institutions. The stan grouping failed because of the war in Afghanistan, Pakistan's affinity to the taliban, Russian and Chinese interests in Central Asia. If cultural coherence was the determinant then Pakistan is probably the only country other than Turkey in the middle East that can claim substantial turkic lineage to central Asia.
Really appreciate your efforts and hardwork sir ❤️
a well research brother❤
I like how Narasimha Rao and MMS collaborated during 1991. Although both had different views on the direction, they were pragmatic. If this would have backfired MMS would have been blamed and would have been fired. Kudos to both as Rao implemented policies proposed by MMS.
2005-2014 time period me 🇮🇳 ne sabse jyada loans liye the Manmohan Singh ke time par or kuch log yaha 1991 ke Liberalization ko game changer bata rahe h to bhai 1991 me desh ko bhikhari bhi inhi logo ki policies ne banaya tha. Ab agar aap ayashi karo or fir aapke ghar ka koi mamber aapka plot bech ke ghar ka karja utar de to isme tareef ki kya baat h, tareef to tab hoti jab ghar ko dubne hi na diya hota.
The collapse of indian economy in 89-91 was the game-changer. Basically, the government had no other option
And today when the same policy is implemented by other Government, the same MMS says that Desh ko bech diya... 😜🤣😜 I mean does he even remember that he was the first person who introduced Privatisation...
@@shaggyk369 yes bro, no one questioning that why India defaulted in 1991, who were responsible?
@@shaggyk369 There is a difference between privatisation and disinvestment 😂.... Selling (non-strategic) loss making state owned companies to private players is one thing and then selling profit making state assets to your chamchas so that they will buy your election bonds is another 😂
Goosebumps on Dr. Manmohan Singh ji speech on budget 🙏🏼 great educated PM
Sona bech ke loan lia tha😃..1991 mw twitter hota to gali khata bichara😃
@@chiranjibisahoo5408 😂😂😂
@@chiranjibisahoo5408 🤣🤣🤣🤣 fir bhi chamche chatukarita nhi chhodte
Well Explained and God Bless you
ویسے کمال کی ریسرچ ہے ذبردست مزہ آگیا ❤❤❤
15:33 brought me tears
I was looking my grandmother in same expression as rahul gandhi looking Indira Gandhi
Bro ur titles are very cleverly picked 🤣
Great Work.
Well concluded 👍🏽
bilkul bro ap ney bilkul sahi btaya hay poora video mey
Hey! Very informative and factual video, I must say.. One thing was absolutely correct that liberalisation could’ve been done earlier that would’ve boosted the Indian economy a lot.. Due to that, perhaps India would’ve been less trade deficit as compared to now and would have also established India as one of the most finest Capitalist economies, due to our capital and skill investment…
@ 6:51 Thanks for showing Kashmir in the Indian territory because that's the truth.
India was on the brink of bankruptcy during 1991. But Economic policies of Manmohan Singh led to a massive transformation in major business sectors. Or else it would’ve suffered a fate worse than one what Sri Lanka and pakistan is facing now. Even now many do not change those policies.
v nice info
Manmohan Singh gets unnecessary praise because the policies implemented were not his but it was IMF's condition before giving bailout package to India. India was going to implement these policies in 1960's under Shastri's time but he was "assassinated" and was followed by indira gandhi who followed in her father's footsteps.
IMF GOATed. I ❤️IMF
Death of Shastriji and Indira's succession is nothing but "Desh ka Durbhagya".
I was looking for this comment (･o･;)
You don't even know how to use His/Her in a sentence and talking about history. Typical WhatsApp university graduate.
@@DharmendraSingh-pj1rw leftist lol
"great mistake was late economic reform, China did much earlier" ~ jaishankar
Shastri planned to do it in 1965, but...........
You can thank the Gandhi family for that.
Well in this case South Korea has my respect.
Bro you got a new subscriber after making this great analysis video of our country
Wow your work is unbelievable 👍 great work.
Started watching the video after hitting the 👍🏻 button. As usually it is informative and simplified 👏🏻
16:38 A real hero is speaking
What did he do to achieve this status in your eyes?
@@rutvikrs LPG POLICY
@@clutchboy2963he did not come up with it. LPG was a partial implementation of the Bretten Woods Agreement that IMF imposes. Narasimha Rao took the political heat and took all the key decisions.
From Pakistan 🇵🇰 : love your content keep uploading ❤
A very good analysis bro😊
Thanks for this video, tomorrow is my Economic's exam. It's really helpful.
A day without humiliation is a day wasted.
- Imran Khan
😆
A day without humiliation is a day wasted
- paxtan
Itni achi English nahi aati pakistanis ko
A humiliation without a day is day wasted
(This looks perfect)
@@afifaafridi1159 banter
LOL
Great video thanks for the unbiased information