Nikon 17-28mm F2.8 Z Lens | The One BIG Issue!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 95

  • @adrianalfordphotography
    @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад +9

    I’ll just leave this here:
    Tamron 17-28mm F2.8 Sony E mount = $1315 AUD
    Nikon 17-28mm F2.8 Z mount = $2199 AUD
    🤔

  • @VolkswagenNut1969
    @VolkswagenNut1969 11 месяцев назад +2

    Good points. Fortunately, one year on, there is the Zf full frame with articulating screen, and this lens is less than $1,000 (U.S.)
    Tough deciding between this and the 14-30 for a similar price. The 14-30 would be my #1 choice easily, but its biggest flaw to me is that cheap feeling plastic external zooming with the ridiculous “unlock to use” design which I personally think is a pain to use.
    True that the 17-28 doesn’t have VR, but with IBIS on the FF Nikons, it’s mostly a non-issue.
    So it’s a tough call.

  • @PhilThach
    @PhilThach 2 года назад +3

    In the United States the 14 to 30 is about $150 more than the new lens. But I think I would still pick the 14 to 30 even with it costing a little more. This was a great video, Adrian, I really enjoyed it!

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад +1

      Thanks Phil. It seems we always get the rough end when it comes to photography gear pricing in Australia. I was really expecting something in the $1600-$1700 range. Hoping it'll drop in price over time. It'd be good for travelling I think, but personally I'd rather have that Nikon 20mm F1.8S lens for low light situations, astro and so forth. I think that'll be my next lens purchase for the Z7. Have a great week mate, cheers 📸🙏

  • @rdphoto2
    @rdphoto2 2 года назад +1

    Love watching this video on the 17-28. I already own the 14-30 f/4 and absolutely love it. Most used lens in my bag mounted to my Z6ii.

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      That's a pretty awesome combo Ron. Big fan of the Z6II, great all rounder camera. Cheers again for watching 🙏

  •  2 года назад +1

    Another great photography video Adrian, good points made about vlogging - enjoyable video, many thanks for sharing the info - have a great weekend :)

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад +1

      Thanks for watching Shaun. Glad you enjoyed the vid. Have an awesome weekend mate, cheers 👍📸

  • @paz09
    @paz09 2 года назад +1

    I have the f/4 lens and have been very happy with it. I was tempted by this when I saw the Nikon video though concerned by losing the lower wide end--but you convinced me that there is no reason to change! Thanks!

  • @coltoncyr2283
    @coltoncyr2283 Год назад +1

    Last year I actually bought one of Tamrons older wides, the 17-35mm used, paired on my Z6ii, for $420 US. The Nikon 14-30mm is my dream wide lens but now I don't think I'll ever upgrade. It's older but it's optics are pretty dam amazing!
    If I were coming in fresh for a wide I wouldn't even consider this 17-28mm and for that price, unreal.

  • @wingsofaustralia
    @wingsofaustralia 2 года назад +1

    Thanks buddy. Enjoyed watching as always.

  • @paulcookphotography
    @paulcookphotography 2 года назад +1

    The specs do look fantastic, but aside from the astronomical price, it looks like they've got a bit of the marketing wrong, focusing on things that they probably shouldn't be focusing on ( vlogging, weather sealing). But back to that crazy price, wow! Personally I don't even look at the Sony lenses more for the same exact pricing issue. Great video as always Adrian! Hope you are doing well. Have a great week down there mate!

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад +1

      Thanks for watching Paul. Have to admit when I saw that price here in Australia I was a bit shocked. I was expecting something around maybe the $1600-$1700 mark to begin with. Maybe it'll drop in price over time? The lens maybe be good for vlogging on the Sony cameras, but that's because they have the articulated screens like the A7SIII and A7IV. As for the weather sealing, yeah well, you saw that. One section it is, then next section it isn't. Hope you enjoyed the game you were at mate, have a great week and take care 🙏📸

  • @pedrobartolomei7707
    @pedrobartolomei7707 Год назад +1

    Trying to have afordable versions of the primes is good, there's an S for that and we should know the rest will be different (lower quality). thank you for reiewing this lens.

  • @slimbirdy
    @slimbirdy 2 года назад +2

    Great run down of the lens and all good points to consider before jumping in. I loved the crazy vlogging examples - too funny and all too true. I wanted to see the hatching turkey chicks - Ha ha.

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад +1

      Thanks for watching. Glad to report the turkey babies are out and about and having fun. Enjoy your weekend 📸🙏

  • @leod1671
    @leod1671 2 года назад +3

    Good video Adrian. I think you got it right, the 14-30 is the way to go. Also, one of your fellow RUclipsrs reviewed the 28-75 2.8 and found it to be not as sharp as the 24-70 f4 & 24-120 f4 lenses. I suspect that this one will be similarly soft. Thank you.

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      Thanks for watching Leo and I think you're spot on in your comment. Hope you have a great weekend, cheers 📸🙏

    • @coltoncyr2283
      @coltoncyr2283 Год назад

      That 24-120mm is freakin amazing. I don't own one yet, but I've seen many reviews and for $1000 it's unbelievable. Perfect for group photos, city and landscape, and travel.

  • @bazwahh7124
    @bazwahh7124 2 года назад +1

    G'day Adrian, I just found this video today as I am looking to purchase a wide-angle zoom for landscape work, but can't quite justify paying the same price for a lens as I paid for my Z5. Thanks for this honest and informative look at the new player on the field. I also note that the prices for the 14-30mm have jumped by about A$500 since the 17-28mm was released so they are basically the same, which is nuts. Cheers.

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      Thanks for watching mate. If ya can hang on for a month the Black Friday sales will be on. That’s when to pounce. Prices are always higher just before the sale 🤙🙏

    • @bazwahh7124
      @bazwahh7124 2 года назад

      @@adrianalfordphotography Yep; I bought my Z5 during the Black Friday sales last year and my plan is to come out of the weekend this year with either one of those two or the "affordable" Laowa 12-24mm 5.6, but that feels like a poor compromise.

  • @vinhsanity
    @vinhsanity Год назад

    At 17mm you can totally vlog, I’ve done it at 16mm on the Fuji XH2s which is like a 24mm FOV, you just have to use a Joby or alike and can’t hand hold it. But I agree about the price. Even though Nikon outsources to Tamron for the assembly, it’s still Nikon glass and electronics - however the price savings is not enough.

  • @rahult4614
    @rahult4614 Год назад +1

    Hii Adrian, presently the 17-28 f2.8 on B&H is 1196$ and 14-30 f4 is 1346$, so given the price range, which one i should take my first priority is image quality second priority is f2.8 please suggest me. Thank you

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  Год назад

      Thank you for watching. I'm wondering why the price is so cheap? Is there a reason why they're not selling and have to drop the price so drastically to get sales? As I said in the video, do you really need that F2.8 aperture? If so, then maybe look at the 17-28mm. I do know the image quality from the 14-30mm F4 is pretty amazing and sharp.

  • @straight-out-of-camera
    @straight-out-of-camera Год назад

    Been using the tamron e version with the techart v2 adapter. Works perfectly, same as native.

  • @JohnHPettigrewFujishooter67
    @JohnHPettigrewFujishooter67 2 года назад +1

    Adrian, thanks for sharing, I watched the entire video even though I am now shooting Fuji, I was thinking of going back to Nikon, I am shocked at those prices, but I must say that is probably true of most brands, from what I understand sometimes the 3rd party lenses are actually better than the name brand, but are they really? Would you buy a high end camera say the Fuji XH2 and stick on a Tamron lens, to be honest I probably would, but then I think it is like buying a Porsche and sticking on cheap wheels. Thanks for sharing mate, I missed a couple of vids but hope to catch up.

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      Thanks for watching John I really appreciate it. I agreed with everything you said. Your average Joe/Jill photographer will more often than not just buy a lens that is cheaper as long as it takes “photos”. In terms of chromatic errors, corner sharpness etc, people don’t even know what that is. Have a great week mate cheers 🍻 📸🙏

  • @g00nther
    @g00nther 2 года назад +2

    I was thinking that I'd get this lens, but didn't realise it was so expensive! The 14-30 F4 would be a better option for most given the pricing, and I'm assuming the weather sealing is also better. I'll wait to see some reviews to see how this lens compares optically.
    My only quibble with this review is regarding the blogging aspect. That's a function of the current line up of Nikon's bodies and not the lens itself. Admittedly the lens shouldn't be promoted as such given the lack of genuine blogging bodies.

  • @christian.irmler
    @christian.irmler 2 года назад +1

    Hi Adrian, really a great video! And oh yes, vlogging gear is generally - let's say at least: a bit difficult. I'm waiting for three years now that I would get an affordable but also not too heavy vlogging camera from Sony, which fulfills my requirements. When it was Sony, it would allow me to have (with my vlogging camera) a 2nd body with me, just for the case. At the moment I would need to have 3 cameras with me when we count the vlogging camera as well. The vlogging market is definitely growing, but I think it is anyway too small to get that consideration we would wish. Till that I will have to be satisfied with using action cameras, instead.
    Interesting that you mentioned the flip screen. Many say it would not be necessary. For me it is. Same reasons you mentioned, but sometimes it is also good to use the front screen to adjust the video composition when there is a drop-off going down behind the camera :)
    Thanks a lot for this video and enjoy your weekend,
    Christian

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      Thanks for watching Christian. I do like vlogging with my Osmo Action as it is super light and has the front screen to see myself. My other camera the Sony ZV-1 is also very good and again has the fully articulated screen and is light weight, but not the widest lens unfortunately. Have an awesome weekend buddy, cheers 📸🙏

  • @eddiecarrascojr
    @eddiecarrascojr 2 года назад +1

    There are a few good options out there. Personally I'd love to use my 14-24mm f/2.8 on my Z9 as a vlogging lens. The only problem, i can't put VND filters on it. Great video though.

  • @victorlim5077
    @victorlim5077 2 года назад +1

    You hit the nail on the head, Adrian. Nikon launches the Z30 but the 12-28mm lens on the roadmap is nowhere to be seen. Now apparently it's a power zoom lens but still nowhere to be seen.

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      Thanks for watching Victor. Glad you enjoyed the video. Have a greet weekend 📸🙏

  • @tonytfuntek3262
    @tonytfuntek3262 2 года назад +1

    Hello Adrian, thank you for all the work you put into your videos. I was wondering if you ever did a comparison between the Nikkor 16-35mm f4 and the 14-30mm f4 S lens on the Z7 ? I can pick up the 16-35mm used for about 1/3 of the cost of the newer 14-30. Thanks again.

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад +1

      Hi Tony - I haven’t had the chance to do a test on the Z7 together. However I did do the test with the 16-35mm on the D850 and 14-30mm on the Z7 side by side. I would dare say the image quality on the 16-35mm would have been pretty much the same if I had it adapted to the Z7 via the FTZII adapter. Video link is here > ruclips.net/video/-JPyaHXdmII/видео.html I have also done a long term review on the 16-35mm on my channel not too long ago 🙏

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      Here’s is the video on the long term review on the 16-35mm as well. Hope it helps > ruclips.net/video/enxBDU32tto/видео.html 🙏

    • @tonytfuntek3262
      @tonytfuntek3262 2 года назад

      @@adrianalfordphotography Thank you

  • @rdphoto2
    @rdphoto2 2 года назад +1

    Vlogging with a non articulating screen looks like this.......LMAO. Nice clip on that Adrian. Made me laugh

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      Thanks for watching Ron. Glad you got a giggle. Have a great weekend 📸🙏

  • @ronspi
    @ronspi 2 года назад +1

    LOL. Great review. When I heard about the lens first, the price described as "affordable" was enough to stop looking at it. Interestingly, none of those who introduced the lens on YooooToooob mentioned the cost of this "affordable" lens. I liked your review. It was very entertaining. Thank you.

  • @rupeshagarwal2837
    @rupeshagarwal2837 5 месяцев назад

    Do we need to rebalance the gimbal in inner zoom lenses.

  • @joekugelblitz4144
    @joekugelblitz4144 2 года назад +5

    It´s an option... and that´s the point: Nikon gives you this option, Canon does not. They´ve got the RF 15-35/2.8 L (big, heavy, expensive), the RF 14-35/4 (small, black corners, expensive) and the new RF 15-30 (small, lightweight, small max aperture, not so expensive)... if you want/need f2.8, you´re forced to buy the L-lens.

  • @macromicro9541
    @macromicro9541 2 года назад +1

    Very informative~

  • @tonyh4266
    @tonyh4266 7 месяцев назад +1

    Good info, naughty Nikon. I don’t like zooms and really buy them, but someone at Nikon needs to look into this. Not good practice! Thanks for being so objective. TonyH

  • @urosjovanovic3142
    @urosjovanovic3142 Год назад

    Well, the first two issues are not about the lens, are they? :D The pricing is a bit strange, comparing Australia, USA and Serbia (where I'm from). Still, nice video! :)

  • @lukaszklopotek
    @lukaszklopotek 2 года назад +1

    An excellent review. I got cought by the clickbait title and I don't regret. ;-)

  • @DrNick8002
    @DrNick8002 2 года назад +1

    Its a good lens by Nikon, but I just bought Nikkor 24-120mm f4 Z lens and this lens just suits my hobby requirements

  • @peterviragphoto
    @peterviragphoto 2 года назад +1

    Stop it Adrian, that “ big issue” is perfect when it cuts your head off😂😂😂 great overview of the other alternatives as well! P.s. That price is a bit brutal considering it’s not an S-line lens😩

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад +1

      Thanks for watching Peter. I think you know exactly how hard it is to vlog without a front facing screen. But maybe Nikon know something we don't? Is there a full frame Z camera with a fully articulating screen coming? Yeah, that price!? Have to admit I was a bit shocked when I first saw that. Have a great weekend mate, cheers 📸🙏

    • @dafyddthomas7299
      @dafyddthomas7299 2 года назад

      on price par with the 'S' 14-30 F4 Lens, the 'S' version is better optically and sells for same price as the Canon equivalent.

  • @georgeb6466
    @georgeb6466 2 года назад +1

    I checked the price for the nikkor z 17-28mm f2.8 at my local camera store and when converted to Australian $ is $1,424.00

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      The prices in this video are in Australian dollars and you can very clearly see the prices on all the websites visited.

  • @CRaul87
    @CRaul87 2 года назад +1

    z8 or z6 iii prob has flippy screen and nikon is giving us a heads-up. being optimistic here:)

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      Fingers crossed for that flip screen. I know other photographers don't like it, but when I had the Canon R5 for a review I used it a lot and didn't realise how much I missed it.

  • @johnpatricklim4509
    @johnpatricklim4509 2 года назад +1

    Yup....for me....price is the biggest consideration for me buying lenses....

  • @haydennettleton3272
    @haydennettleton3272 2 года назад +2

    I suspect the price will drop rather quickly on this lens just like the 28-75mm.

  • @tonytfuntek3262
    @tonytfuntek3262 2 года назад +1

    I'm with you, both the 17-28 and 14-30 are around the same price. But I feel it's worth the one stop penalty to get down to 14mm. Thanks for these videos and enjoy the weekend.

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      Thank you very much for watching and commenting Tony. Hope you have a great weekend 🙏

  • @BLAKEBLAKE-yf5po
    @BLAKEBLAKE-yf5po 2 года назад +2

    Idk how I can afford a 3000 dollar camera in my life.

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад +2

      Work hard, play hard. Pepsi Max 😜

    • @the4armedmonk
      @the4armedmonk 2 года назад +1

      @@adrianalfordphotography Thank you for these encouraging words sponsored by Pepsi.

  • @genin69
    @genin69 Год назад

    these lenses should have been the budget Nikon lens options but they are expensive af, literally just shy of the S series lenses and no special gold ring to make them stand out. no just a silly little S added. so clients who are used to look out for the gold ring know you are shooting with good optics wont know any different now.. wtf nikon.. only fly in the ointment being the new 70-180mm lens. its actually almsot half the price of the 70-200 lens and its very good, and also half the weight, not so much with the other 2

  • @konsamprincesingh7763
    @konsamprincesingh7763 2 года назад +1

    One thing I like about this lense is the internal focusing. Wish the price is a little low. Anyways a good review

  • @devilangel4655
    @devilangel4655 2 года назад +1

    Wow in Europe this lens is 1349euro’s and it is still’s expensive, but 2 grand in Australia…jeez😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      Thanks for watching. Yeah I can't work out why it is expensive here and not in other parts of the world? Maybe it'll drop in price over time? Enjoy your day 🙏

    • @siebewiersma8836
      @siebewiersma8836 2 года назад

      1349 euro’s is about 2000 aus dollars

    • @devilangel4655
      @devilangel4655 2 года назад +1

      @@siebewiersma8836
      Ah i see, but it’s more then that price of the lens😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫

  • @cliffday1183
    @cliffday1183 2 года назад +1

    as of 30 September 2022 the Tamron 17-28 re badged aka Nikon 17-28 is £1199 British pounds whereas the Tamron 17-28 for the Sony E mount is £789......its the same lens!!, I'll stick with OEM 14-30 f4,

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      Thanks for watching. Yes my point exactly. If it were more on par with the Sony E mount pricing I think a lot more people would buy.

  • @georgeb6466
    @georgeb6466 2 года назад

    B&H price $1,196.95 plus shipping

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад

      The prices in this video are in Australian dollars and you can very clearly see the prices on all the websites visited.

  • @georgeb6466
    @georgeb6466 2 года назад

    Nikon never guarantees their lenses their lenses to be weather resistant in all conditions.
    Just go to their website, even with S line lenses such as the z14-24 f2.8

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад +2

      It's obvious you are a Nikon rep or fan and no one DARE say anything bad about Nikon. So what you're saying is I can't have a voice, I'm not ALLOWED to say anything bad. I just have to accept what ever garbage Nikon throw in front of me and just pay for it! If people don't speak up and ask for more, then companies will continually dish out garbage for little expenditure and gain greater profit from people like you that bow down before the mighty Nikon! Oh and FYI I have been a long term user of Nikon gear for over 20 years!

    • @adrianalfordphotography
      @adrianalfordphotography  2 года назад +1

      Oh and how about you grow a pair and stop hiding behind anonymity. At least I have the guts to put myself out there. Put up some videos on your channel so I can troll comment on and see how you like it. A profile picture, some info on you. No? Yeah thought so.

    • @wingsofaustralia
      @wingsofaustralia 2 года назад

      @@adrianalfordphotography I agree with you Adrian on this "person". Keep up the good work, buddy, am a fan of your channel. Least you can tell ya not Nikon sponsored like a lot of other guys doing reviews on this lens.

  • @indranilguhahotography
    @indranilguhahotography Год назад

    Go buy sony 17-28mm.. ouch they don't have one.. and if you are comparing 3rd party lens price... Then compare samyung and sony😂😂