You three. Your amazing. But Kel is just amazing. Innocence, reveled, realized. It's pure. It's real. I'm touched. I feel it, for the first time again.
A girl introduced me to Porcupine Tree's music about 12 years ago, I am still gobsmacked, in a good and grateful way, and my life just changed! I hardly listen to anything else no-more! Steven Wilson solo of course, have you done "Luminol?" Live in Mexico! GREAT! And I also followed Harrison over to The Pineapple Thief. Song to do from them must be "Tear you up " also the accoustic, gitar, Song, version. I do not think I ever will find a band that dethrones P.T and SW. EVER!
Don't know if anyone's mentioned this, but Steven Wilson is also a legendary re-mixer of albums made during the heyday of prog. Bands he's worked on include Yes, Jethro Tull, King Crimson, Emerson Lake and Palmer, and Gentle Giant. (He's also done some non-prog bands, as well.) The man has a fantastic ear for rebalancing sound and bringing out all the buried goodness in old recordings.
I have a live version of this song where Steven makes a little speech at the beginning about what this song means. To paraphrase, it's basically their answer/response to stupid little boy bands and their love songs. So instead of a love song, they wrote a Hate Song.
I paused at 13:28 to write that if Larry plays drums it makes sense he would pick pretty much anything and everything from the two live Porcupine Tree shows, because of how brilliant Gavin Harrison is. Then I unpause and he goes on about him. Fitting :) I've had this dvd for over a decade and still go back to it every now and then, such a great show. I know one of the first reactions you guys ever did was the studio version of Arriving Somewhere, but I feel like you guys should now check out the live version from this dvd if you still haven't. It's just bliss.
Three songs by Porcupine tree. I know what I'll be doing for the next hour. Been a fan for a long time. Steven Wilson is a brilliant composer. Gavin Harrison is a great drummer. He took over for Mike Portnoy for OSI, a Jim Matheos and Kevin Moore side project.
Thank you for returning to the wonders that are Steven Wilson and Porcupine Tree! Larry obviously knows what it means to be entrapped in the complex musical web that is PT! Much love to you all!
Gavin Harrison is the only drummer that I really notice in song. I can appreciate other drummers too but noone does these incredible fills while still playing for the song.
So Porcupine tree or Dream Theater ? I never connected with D.T but P.T is one of my favorites modern rock bands and i say band because is no only about Steven Wilson or Gavin Harrison is about the Chemestry of all there ,Collin is great bass player very groovie and Barbieri is a master of soundscapes and ambient atmospheres , can you imagine P.T with out that sounds... Hate song need to be listening 2/3 times and you gonna love It !
Since you guys love Dream Theater and Porcupine Tree, I'll recommend you check out the band OSI. I requested them back when your channel was really new 😁 the song Radiologue is right up your alley. Kevin Moore (former keyboardist from Dream Theater), Jim Matheos (guitarist from Fates Warning) and Gavin Harrison (drummer from Porcupine Tree) make up the band in that song. It's awesome stuff.
Love the OSI stuff. Mike Portnoy was the drummer on their first 2 albums. Kevin Moore is such a unique vocalist. When it comes to composers I think there is Jim Matheos, then Steven Wilson, then every one else. OSI stands for Office of Strategic Influence. Their first album is their best, an anti-war, concept album. Sadly, according to Jim, there are no plans for any more OSI.
Gotta add #UmphreysMcgee to your playlist. Such a tight rock band filled with virtuosos that's been around for about 20 years .They have a shit ton of music to choose from. Maybe the track Plunger is a good start. You will be thanking me later, I promise.
longingbydesign What u talkin bout friend, zats what make em special, Wilson is a Genius like no other in the Rock Metal genre, now you want him to be a screamer
You three. Your amazing. But Kel is just amazing. Innocence, reveled, realized. It's pure. It's real. I'm touched. I feel it, for the first time again.
This is a great song, its very good in the album, but this performance is mind blowing. Very good choice Larry.
I love seeing musicians/bands that can just jam, play off each other and just stay in the groove.
A girl introduced me to Porcupine Tree's music about 12 years ago, I am still gobsmacked, in a good and grateful way, and my life just changed! I hardly listen to anything else no-more! Steven Wilson solo of course, have you done "Luminol?" Live in Mexico! GREAT! And I also followed Harrison over to The Pineapple Thief. Song to do from them must be "Tear you up " also the accoustic, gitar, Song, version. I do not think I ever will find a band that dethrones P.T and SW. EVER!
I just discovered a gem. The coolest Porcupine Tree song I've heard yet. "The Start of Something Beautiful", live from the Chicago 2005 show.
Incredibly powerful track indeed
Don't know if anyone's mentioned this, but Steven Wilson is also a legendary re-mixer of albums made during the heyday of prog. Bands he's worked on include Yes, Jethro Tull, King Crimson, Emerson Lake and Palmer, and Gentle Giant. (He's also done some non-prog bands, as well.) The man has a fantastic ear for rebalancing sound and bringing out all the buried goodness in old recordings.
Total Jam !
Gavin Bloody Harrison ! Godlike
This Band is a Treat indeed!, Pure Godlike! No hype No overrated stuff! Pure Class Act Performers!
I have a live version of this song where Steven makes a little speech at the beginning about what this song means. To paraphrase, it's basically their answer/response to stupid little boy bands and their love songs. So instead of a love song, they wrote a Hate Song.
I paused at 13:28 to write that if Larry plays drums it makes sense he would pick pretty much anything and everything from the two live Porcupine Tree shows, because of how brilliant Gavin Harrison is. Then I unpause and he goes on about him. Fitting :) I've had this dvd for over a decade and still go back to it every now and then, such a great show. I know one of the first reactions you guys ever did was the studio version of Arriving Somewhere, but I feel like you guys should now check out the live version from this dvd if you still haven't. It's just bliss.
Oh , you should really check out Polish prog band ,Riverside . They are superb ! Egoist hedonist live is a great track 👍
With SW and PT's recent rubbish releases bands like Riverside, Soen and Airbag have more than filled the gap left
Unbelievable musicians! Top notch! Anthesitize is amazing too!
Three songs by Porcupine tree. I know what I'll be doing for the next hour. Been a fan for a long time. Steven Wilson is a brilliant composer. Gavin Harrison is a great drummer. He took over for Mike Portnoy for OSI, a Jim Matheos and Kevin Moore side project.
The best wahwah solo i ever heard.
Thank you for returning to the wonders that are Steven Wilson and Porcupine Tree! Larry obviously knows what it means to be entrapped in the complex musical web that is PT! Much love to you all!
Drumgasm.
Gavin Harrison is the only drummer that I really notice in song. I can appreciate other drummers too but noone does these incredible fills while still playing for the song.
The Pineapple Thief ♪
they suck, a fantastic drummer can't help them @@howardjohny
Great song from a great dvd/live show.
I got to see Steven Wilson at this same venue on his 'Raven' tour :)
So Porcupine tree or Dream Theater ? I never connected with D.T but P.T is one of my favorites modern rock bands and i say band because is no only about Steven Wilson or Gavin Harrison is about the Chemestry of all there ,Collin is great bass player very groovie and Barbieri is a master of soundscapes and ambient atmospheres , can you imagine P.T with out that sounds...
Hate song need to be listening 2/3 times and you gonna love It !
I was at that show. The guitar work on this song is awesome but not to hard to do. He did play it in a framework, to perfection.
Yes. Truly a shame that they disbanded. Gavin is truly an awesome drummer. I was so glad to hear King Crimson gave him a job :D #
steven wilson is my hero , and Gavin!!!!! Love the addition to King Crimson
There a comment on that video that sums it all up: God was on drums.
Just love PT thanks.🎧👍
LOVE HATE SONG ;-)
Gavin fucking Harrison. Enough said.
Since you guys love Dream Theater and Porcupine Tree, I'll recommend you check out the band OSI. I requested them back when your channel was really new 😁 the song Radiologue is right up your alley. Kevin Moore (former keyboardist from Dream Theater), Jim Matheos (guitarist from Fates Warning) and Gavin Harrison (drummer from Porcupine Tree) make up the band in that song. It's awesome stuff.
Love the OSI stuff. Mike Portnoy was the drummer on their first 2 albums. Kevin Moore is such a unique vocalist. When it comes to composers I think there is Jim Matheos, then Steven Wilson, then every one else. OSI stands for Office of Strategic Influence. Their first album is their best, an anti-war, concept album. Sadly, according to Jim, there are no plans for any more OSI.
@@williambevins Yeah, all 4 of their albums are solid. And Sean Malone on bass too, is great. That man is a wizard.
I really enjoyed listening to Porcupine Tree. ZEN!
YES Kel, "Please Sir, I would like more." :-)
Hey! It's Larry!
Please do "Mellotron Scratch" from Porcupine Tree's "Deadwing" Album.
Last part of the guitar is largely influenced by adrian belew's style from king crimson in 80's
Thats insane, ill be dipped in shit and rolled in breadcrumbs ha ha ;-) i love Trains and Anesthestize live
Hallo Sorry i Love the grummer🤗😀a this Calvin Harrison?
Gavin Harrison
For us, hardcore prog rock fans Steven Wilson is god and we workship him :d
Gotta add #UmphreysMcgee to your playlist. Such a tight rock band filled with virtuosos that's been around for about 20 years .They have a shit ton of music to choose from. Maybe the track Plunger is a good start. You will be thanking me later, I promise.
John Fogerty ????
If you like this you will like King Crimson Starless same sort of mood
Can’t load up KC. Blocked instantly
First😀👍
Great song by a great band. I just wish they had a talented singer.
longingbydesign What u talkin bout friend, zats what make em special, Wilson is a Genius like no other in the Rock Metal genre, now you want him to be a screamer
He's an incredible singer.