David Bowie's "Blackstar" Is Not About Death | OVR THNKR #18

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 янв 2017
  • David Bowie's cryptic final album "Blackstar" is typically interpreted to be an exploration of death, but it's so much more. Tell me what you think in the comments!
    SUBSCRIBE for more: bit.ly/ioYTsub
    All episodes of OVR THNKR: • OVR THNKR
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 441

  • @larkstonguesinaspic4814
    @larkstonguesinaspic4814 6 лет назад +145

    I always felt like " Blackstar " is the new David Bowie stage persona. Just like Ziggy stardust and The Thin white duke. I actually thought that before his death, When I heard the song the first time. I thought in his live shows he's going to be Blackstar. After he died I thought, In a way he actually has become Blackstar. He is a star that has died, No longer has any light.

    • @JDC352
      @JDC352 3 года назад +4

      The light higher than eyesight.

    • @joeyshrum2218
      @joeyshrum2218 Год назад +2

      That is a very good personal interpretation.

    • @eracli0
      @eracli0 Год назад +2

      Blackstar: The Blind Prophet

    • @josephyearwood1179
      @josephyearwood1179 10 месяцев назад

      @@eracli0Looks alike he literally peeps through the blindfolds to my eyeballs.

    • @bansheecat3036
      @bansheecat3036 6 дней назад

      If you think about what white and black actually mean, white is reflecting light and black is absorbing it. So, it's not that he has no light, but he is absorbing all light.

  • @Scarecrow6459
    @Scarecrow6459 6 лет назад +47

    Strangely, I agree that the song isn't just about death. However, I think the Blackstar is David himself. He refrains, "I'm not a gangstar, I'm not a pornstar" which means he cannot be defined as anything that we could codifid him as. He was special, and that we could call him nothing else but a "Blackstar".

  • @darkjediorder1412
    @darkjediorder1412 2 года назад +58

    nothing lasts forever. this track is over looked by a lot of fans, some even refuse to listen to it. personally i think its one of his best pieces of work.

    • @alohajesse
      @alohajesse 2 года назад

      agreed😀

    • @larindanomikos
      @larindanomikos 2 года назад +3

      Fans refuse to listen to it? Just how many Bowie fans do you know?

    • @ZaaZoJo
      @ZaaZoJo 11 месяцев назад

      I know alot of personal friends who can't listen to his last album because its to upseting. @@larindanomikos

    • @christopheralthouse6378
      @christopheralthouse6378 10 месяцев назад +1

      I personally LOVE the song 😍❤️

    • @kenethacabiness4045
      @kenethacabiness4045 6 месяцев назад +1

      Well said! I concur!!

  • @georgesikorski9891
    @georgesikorski9891 3 года назад +44

    Don't forget Major Tom also appeared in Ashes to Ashes, leading most to believe he is a reflection of Bowie himself. The song, released soon after he rehabilitated from his drug years says "We know Major Tom's a junky, strung out on heaven's high hitting an all time low."

    • @wezzuh2482
      @wezzuh2482 3 года назад +7

      Exsactly. Space Oddity has the phrase: Planet earth is blue. Which means that the world is a fundamentally sad place. Ie. Major Tom loses contact with ground control on purpose, to escape from life.
      We later learn in ashes to ashes that his symbolic escape from earth was by way of drug use.

    • @plungy
      @plungy Год назад +1

      It's is not Major Tom but Thomas Jerome Newton in Black star

    • @josephyearwood1179
      @josephyearwood1179 10 месяцев назад +1

      all time BERNARD lowE
      ?

    • @josephyearwood1179
      @josephyearwood1179 10 месяцев назад

      @@wezzuh2482Ground Zero/Enter The Dragon

    • @josephyearwood1179
      @josephyearwood1179 10 месяцев назад +2

      @@plungy”The Man Who Fell To Earth” (aka “Brother From Another Planet”?

  • @scottd.1700
    @scottd.1700 Год назад +13

    I believe the song is about transcendence, birth, rebirth, and death. It is about David Bowie's personal journey and grasping at the meaning of it all in his final days on earth. We are all made of stars and we all die. We return to space after the death of our own star only to eventually turn to cosmic dust and form new star systems. It is neverending. The serpent is uroboros, the snake eating it's own tail. Representing this same journey.

  • @deryckostashek5852
    @deryckostashek5852 2 года назад +19

    I'm still so gutted by his passing, even to this day; that it doesn't matter what everything means, but to listen to his voice is calming, assuring that he left amazing lyrics and music to keep his legacy alive. RIP David. We miss you.

  • @KilloZapit
    @KilloZapit 4 года назад +87

    Personally, I think the song is more about the legacy Bowie left behind, along with a warning. Here is my take on it:
    The line is after all "Something happened on the day he died, spirit rose a meter and stepped aside something else took his place and bravely cried: I'm a blackstar". And what is a blackstar? Could it be like a black hole? A star that has basically died and become something else, but still has the same gravity. When Bowie died, his spirit left, his light extinguished... but his work and legacy still remain. You can still feel the pull of the gravity of his legacy.
    But it isn't him in charge anymore. His spirit has stepped aside. Now... Well, you know it's always kinda funny to me how much fandom is like religion in someways. And hence the warning: His fans will venerate him. His works will become like relics, like a skull crusted with gemstones. Even notice how fandom tends to create their own little 'rituals' of sorts? David Bowie the man is gone. David Bowie the icon is still there. Maybe it will be one day thought of as David Bowie the god. That I feel is the blackstar. A shadow image of Bowie in the minds of people, without the guidance of his human spirit.
    And every time we try to say what his work was actually about or what he was trying to say, we twist that shadow image a little. We move further away from the man and closer to our own shadow image of him. Yes I am aware of the irony of saying the song is about how people can twist his legacy by interpreting what his work was about, and this probobly isn't actually what the song is actually meant to be about. But I find the idea halarious. :P

    • @Loki-pz1uk
      @Loki-pz1uk 3 года назад +6

      Ah shit I love the idea of him “stepping aside” and this vacuum opening to be filled by other people and influences 🤯

    • @ericmalmborg770
      @ericmalmborg770 3 года назад +6

      You're nearly spot on with the way I look at the song as well.. I think that's the importance of the visual opening of Major Tom on another planet.. He's still within arms reach of us at the beginning, but his physical being drifts to the black star at the end. He understands his legacy will live on, but there will be someone to fill his void, "Spirit Rose a Meter and he stepped aside, someone else took his place" Is the pivot of the song, which occurs right before Bowie takes his bible, while in light and with eager anticipation of his fans, and visually hands it off to the next person in line"

    • @Walkerbtween
      @Walkerbtween 3 года назад +8

      The anguish and joy of creating symbolic poetry/music is that the author knows what he meant, but cares more for what those symbols might invoke in others. It's a malleable, neutral chaos prone to each individual reader's/listener's internal intrepretation to take in any direction as best as they want, hope, fear or dream for. Bowie laid down the bones, we build the gollum...the man was a magus.

    • @jean-christophearsenault2104
      @jean-christophearsenault2104 2 года назад +3

      That's a much more sensible path of solution than : "IT'S ABOUT CHRIST !"

    • @larindanomikos
      @larindanomikos 2 года назад

      I prefer your interpretation of this than other than the author of the post. Very thoughtful. Thanks. I still like to think about Bowie.

  • @yvonnecampbell7036
    @yvonnecampbell7036 3 года назад +19

    There are many references to Christian believes and also occult knowledge. Is it a warning? A confession? Artistic expression? Or just to keep us guessing for the coming 30 years just for his own amusement before he died? I don't know and probably never will. Likely all of the above. The lyrics and video are full of symbolism and wordplay (which he loved to do) It is as usual multilayered. When he sang "I'm the great I AM" He could be playing the role of Lucifer/Satan mocking God. With "You're a flash in the pan" he could be referring to when he was called so in 1973. It could also be double layered meaning Pan the satyr or goat man (where the image of Satan comes from) playing his pipes. Is Satan linked with music and the music industry? David knew he was a "shy" Capricorn boy the goat with the fish tail who's planet is Saturn. "How many times does an angel fall? How many people lie instead of talking tall? He trod on sacred ground, he cried loud into the crowd (I'm a blackstar, I'm a blackstar, I'm not a gangstar)" The fallen angel is Lucifer who became Satan which is just a title meaning "the accuser" that is his role. "He is the Father of Lies." He wanted the throne of God. So maybe the line "He trod on sacred ground, he cried loud into the crowd (I'm a blackstar, I'm a blackstar, I'm not a gangstar)" is Satan standing on the holy mountain and claiming to be God trying to convince us he isn't such a bad guy (he's not a gangstar). But then again...we could all be reaching. I just focus on God and His son Jesus Christ and try my best not to F*** up too much.

    • @CarnivalofLVX
      @CarnivalofLVX 2 года назад +1

      It’s about The Black Sun. If you wanna know what’s it’s truly about read Miguel Serrano

  • @BoyWanderer1988
    @BoyWanderer1988 6 лет назад +58

    vocally Bowie is saying: "in the Villa of ALL MEN."
    He does that quite often,
    lyrics are 1 thing, & the vocals say another.

    • @wezzuh2482
      @wezzuh2482 6 лет назад +14

      yeah, kind of like the "Lennon's on sale again" where he pronounces it a bit like "Lenin".

    • @bassline5633
      @bassline5633 5 лет назад +18

      Amen, All men, Orman, all about accent isn't it? What did he really say? Orman could make sense too, just as All men...

    • @gdub2485
      @gdub2485 5 лет назад +3

      Was that Yoko singing with him?

    • @jespinosa7691
      @jespinosa7691 4 года назад +5

      I agree . . .INDAGADADEVEDAH baby

    • @Ubu987
      @Ubu987 3 года назад +4

      @@bassline5633 London accent - sounds like "In the villar of orl-men"

  • @nolachaos
    @nolachaos 2 года назад +7

    Bowie subtley admitting his fascination and connection to dark energies and magick

  • @surgeeo1406
    @surgeeo1406 6 лет назад +21

    I caught somewhere, that this song is about a philosophy book he read, about a cicle of three ages: the age of religion, the age of science, and the age of magic. The movie would be about the death of science (dead astronaut) and the birth of the earliest form of magic, fertility magic (phalic monster). This seems to be the overarching theme. The titular Blackstar... Whatever it is, it can possess a dead body, and take over our life and identity... Could be how Bowie's characters would just take over with little choice or agency... These two themes seem to be unrelated, and juxtaposed just for dissonance, I don't know...

  • @Max-sh6zu
    @Max-sh6zu 2 года назад +18

    I love seeing all these different interpretations of it. I think it might have been made to be open to interpretation on purpose, but I mean, the only man who knows for sure is dead.

    • @plungy
      @plungy Год назад

      He left the final answers in the Musical Lazarus

    • @thestorytimekitchen9706
      @thestorytimekitchen9706 8 месяцев назад +1

      He can’t give everything away, and the fact is, maybe the whole point is, he didn’t know himself, much of the time. The man channeled stuff, his gift was cultivation of the hospitality to allow, rather than to interrogate till it loses all its internal integrity, which is its power.

  • @caseywilson7768
    @caseywilson7768 7 лет назад +89

    this song is about rebirth

    • @chara4rmsj
      @chara4rmsj 6 лет назад +8

      Casey Wilson demonic rebirth

    • @PortrayAlteam
      @PortrayAlteam 3 года назад +9

      I like how succinct you are. I just started reading the human's interpretations of his work, and all I see are ridiculous, Puritanical assumptions. These are projections. People are describing their own minds in the face of mystery, and I think I'll just savor the mystery without the annoying compulsion to place brass tacks on something so perfect.

    • @crunchiethepig3885
      @crunchiethepig3885 3 года назад +2

      Birth is the same as Death

    • @benjaminbermiller3709
      @benjaminbermiller3709 3 года назад +2

      This is my favourite part of the comment section. I agree with you guys.

    • @sawyerboy13
      @sawyerboy13 3 года назад +1

      @@crunchiethepig3885 birth is the opposite of death

  • @antonizielinski9401
    @antonizielinski9401 4 года назад +4

    Wooow, beautiful explanation and EXTREMELY specific, your really great at exploring all these meanings, well done and please continue making these!

  • @blakecollins6933
    @blakecollins6933 6 лет назад +20

    there are so many theories and i am just shitting myself trying to decode it using my own intuition plus other opinions and its just overloading me and I am starting to think maybe its just a plain mind fuck and that he just left it behind with a theme but no real meaning that all ties into everything throughout his life because tbh i would do that just so my legacy lived on as long as humans are curious but honestly what a fucking legend hes just a god

    • @solcutta3661
      @solcutta3661 3 года назад

      That's what I've commented ,it's the pinnacle of his career,all of his music led to this song which is a product if evolving from the very first thru to now.

    • @alohajesse
      @alohajesse 2 года назад

      anything is possible right. after all every person will interpret all things purely based on their own life experiences.

  • @toddsmemory1499
    @toddsmemory1499 5 лет назад +12

    Well you gave me a whole new perspective on Bowie. A depth and appreciation that was almost written off too soon by seeing black star as demonic. But as you very plainly said the guilt has to be removed from our humanity, which is so much about living in a fallen world and realizing the possibility of an afterlife.
    Nice post. Scary song.

  • @DirtworshipperMusic
    @DirtworshipperMusic 3 года назад +27

    I've always thought it might have to do with wormwood/nemesis/nibiru.... alot of black star songs out there for sure..

    • @hybrid6692
      @hybrid6692 3 года назад +1

      Hmm i tried to make the nibiru thing fit but came out more confused than at the start, its just out there thats all you can say

    • @iam33iamgod35
      @iam33iamgod35 2 года назад +3

      It's nothing to do with external apocalyptic events or anything external!! The revealing of ormen,, or in hebrew means light and the solitary candle is the spine (7 chakras) the 7 seals of revelation!! It's not evil

    • @iam33iamgod35
      @iam33iamgod35 2 года назад +6

      Light the candle (pineal gland) it's esoteric

    • @MarcLowe
      @MarcLowe 6 месяцев назад

      @@iam33iamgod35The mention of Kabbalah here reminds one of DB c. 1976, wearing the outfit we again see him wearing in the “Lazarus” video as he backs himself into the closet in the final shot…
      Click.
      Makes sense, as he was interested not only in esotericism, but specifically at one point in the Kabbalistic Tree of Life (Sephirot - “Kether to Malkuth”…).

  • @gdub2485
    @gdub2485 5 лет назад +1

    Wow, good interpretation. I found myself listening to it today, been awhile. Each time I see something new, more meaning. Thanks for your vid.

  • @Thereal_prettyinblack
    @Thereal_prettyinblack 3 года назад +8

    doesn't matter what is it about- it is the most magnificent piece ever written for popular music. Masterpiece on the very top of my list, high above clouds.

    • @gr.vo.3058
      @gr.vo.3058 4 дня назад

      May I suggest another absolutely wonderful piece of music. The epic tune. "Supper's Ready". A dream about two lovers, in very apocalyptic times. It will take you on a musical adventure.

  • @laprpnl
    @laprpnl 3 года назад +2

    wow, it make so much sense ! mainly knowing that bowie always had a great search for spiritual growing and knowledge. one of his friends told that in the last days he was so peacefull about the death and I really believe that he found the way he looked for. great video !

  • @jakelopez3181
    @jakelopez3181 4 года назад +5

    Really good analysis. Mind blown at the major tom connection !

  • @geraldrutledge1183
    @geraldrutledge1183 3 года назад +5

    Has anyone else noticed the set in Blackstar resembling an old attic has an uncanny resemblance to the set in the "Look Back in Anger" video? The theme of "Look Back" is pretty obvious. Also note that at the end of that video, he crawls under his bed. This under-the-bed image, as well as the beginning of both videos where he starts out in bed (uncomfortably) before his "death" is repeated in "Lazarus", yet another death/rebirth/transformation theme.

  • @joelhenry5489
    @joelhenry5489 6 лет назад +122

    In some pagan belief systems the black sun represents bad knowledge. Like a regular sun it casts rays but the rays do not illuminate. A spreader of bad knowledge is a false prophet. When Bowie says he is a black star that is what he is saying about himself. He was a false prophet. He was among the very small group of music stars that ascended to unnatural heights to the point of almost being worshipped. And he did not deserve it. Blackstar is Bowie's judgment on his legacy.
    Evidence:
    Corrupted dancing - throughout the video there is a lot of dancing and all of it seems trance-like, spastic and hideous. But if you look closely at the dance moves they are corrupted versions of choreography used by Michael Jackson, Elvis, Mick Jagger and many others. This is to show that the effect of the blackstar (pop star) is hypnotic and negative.
    Buttons for eyes - Four characters in the video have buttons over bandaged faces where the eyes should be. This means not only are they blind but they are pretending to have sight. Falsehood.
    The button-eyed - who are these button-eyed pretenders? One is Bowie himself. The other three, on crosses like Jesus, are dressed like Michael Jackson, Elvis and Frank Sinatra. These are all Blackstars, the false prophets.

    • @albertarthurandre9213
      @albertarthurandre9213 6 лет назад +4

      it is beautifully put even if it tells that knowing it doesn't make you utterly responsible for it

    • @DocFumeur
      @DocFumeur 6 лет назад +6

      Very interresting. Thanks for sharing your view on that.
      Now why would Bowie talk of that on the verge of death, wouldn't he like to keep on spreading the good image he had on most of his fans' mind, guaranting him some kind of immortality in all his fans' hearts?

    • @BoyWanderer1988
      @BoyWanderer1988 6 лет назад +2

      Bowie wants you all to think stupid interpretations.
      LONDON BYE TA TA (Elijah)
      DANCING WITH THE BIG BOYS (Cincinnati)
      DRIVE-IN SATURDAY ("feels like Kings Island, teardrop")
      NEW YORK'S IN LOVE (the Go-Go Boys)
      PLEASE MR. GRAVEDIGGER ( ha-choo! )
      CYGNET COMMITTE ( I bless you madly )
      UNWASHED & SOMEWHAT SLIGHTLY DAZED (the whole song)
      ATOMICA (+ all of his songs; he is "Elijah" ~ my little babies) lol
      (I'm Enoch)...
      you all will think we are the devil himself, not many years hence.
      Just a couple of "fire-breathers" ~ momma poppa's coming for yews.
      yes, "in THIS MANNER" our enemies MUST be killed.
      I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR YOU (you didn't see us coming).
      "Suspicious minds, it was always TIME."

    • @benjones5439
      @benjones5439 6 лет назад +2

      Very interesting...i like this interpretation

    • @wezzuh2482
      @wezzuh2482 6 лет назад +16

      He always expressed sentiments about pop-culture being a form of false idol-worship (life on mars, for example). Maybe this is him regretting becoming one of those false heroes. The women worship the skull of Major Tom, right?

  • @RobertMonroeMusic
    @RobertMonroeMusic 5 лет назад +19

    I think however you cut it it is a thought provoking song that was an amazing parting gift from a total genius

  • @bassline5633
    @bassline5633 5 лет назад +11

    Blackstar is mentioned among many Occulted, and Esoteric Artists in the Music industry. Celldweller- blackstar, David Bowie- Black Star, Apparently Elvis, keep looking, it is all over.

    • @liamwalpole9415
      @liamwalpole9415 3 года назад +4

      Its an admission of something far darker behind the man

    • @bassline5633
      @bassline5633 3 года назад

      @@liamwalpole9415 nah

    • @treeoftreason6564
      @treeoftreason6564 3 года назад

      He is androgynous meaning (FTM) NO ADAMS APPLE....
      THE BANDAGES ARE HIM AFTER TAKING ON A MALE VESSEL....OCCULT MAKES THEM LIVE AS BOTH JUST LIKE THE BAPHOMET THAT THEY ALL WORSHIP...BLACKSTAR IS THE STAR BEHIND THE SUN COMES CLOSE EVER 3600 YEARS HENNCE ALL THESE DEATHS IN THE INDUSTRY BECAUSE THERE PLANET IS HERE & TIME TO HARVEST US HUMANS....ruclips.net/video/ojChlHtW3zM/видео.html....ITS HERE

    • @bassline5633
      @bassline5633 3 года назад

      @@treeoftreason6564 I don't feel that way. Obviously the star is the sun and the moon is the black foreshadow. We call that a solar eclipse. To indigenous cultures when the moon is swallowed by the earth's shadow it is a grave thing, what does that say about the sun? Or the earth in the moon's shadow?

    • @treeoftreason6564
      @treeoftreason6564 3 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/pizCPSXwu-8/видео.html explain this i caught it yesterday

  • @lorio5003
    @lorio5003 Год назад

    i really enjoyed hearing these thoughts. i just started to delve into david bowie's songs and movies now. i'm not sure why it took this long. but i think i will find what i am looking for and why i am suddenly drawn to it now. and this helped, thanks!

  • @invisi-bullexploration2374
    @invisi-bullexploration2374 4 месяца назад

    I always interpreted it as a legacy left for future generations to discover and enjoy.
    Many of Bowie's fans aren't even born yet!
    No Plan really hits that home. Bowie is effectively 'immortal' with pieces of the universe projecting his image to would be fans for decades if not centuries.

  • @Nalot56
    @Nalot56 2 года назад

    Amazing analysis. You made my year

  • @godfree6292
    @godfree6292 10 месяцев назад

    video I really needed to see. wish it went longer.

  • @andrewlassman9755
    @andrewlassman9755 6 лет назад

    I think you have the best interpretation that I have seen yet. Thanks for your thoughts!

  • @plungy
    @plungy Год назад +2

    David Bowie his final persona is Thomas Jerome Newton, And his last work was the musical Lazarus. You can find al the final answers in that piece. I've seen Lazarus 150 times since i worked on the show.

  • @andrewholt2425
    @andrewholt2425 Год назад +1

    It's a perceptual awareness,. The eyes showing you what you want, and acceptance of wrong path because of the things we want. Willingly searching for the selfs wants and fulfilling them . And finding out that it's the wrong way after you get to the end of your journey. Realization of the fact you wanted it, and what you are.

  • @theother1406
    @theother1406 6 месяцев назад +1

    Someone finally said it, first time I saw it I said, "That's the girl with the mousey hair"

  • @aslavetomybones
    @aslavetomybones 6 лет назад +4

    Thanks. Very insightful, and the most “understandable” explanation of “Blackstar” so far, your review stands out as the sanest out of all the crazed, kooks spouting absolute coddswallap.....although. It is only a song, and it’s themes have have been visited many times before throughout his career. Blackstar’s ideas remind me of “Station to Station” where Germanic/Nordic and the Kabbalah are interwoven throughout its 10 minutes length , similar to Blackstar’s time. What “Blackstar” has a achieved is a confirmation of Bowie’s art, and your theory of transcendence, rings true. Bowie( I feel) set out to make a final statement of art, and he nailed it with Blackstar.

  • @Nalot56
    @Nalot56 2 года назад +1

    This is one of the best reviews/reactions I’ve ever seen on RUclips. Why did you stop?

  • @KnoxBronson
    @KnoxBronson 7 месяцев назад

    Excellent! Thanks for your insight.

  • @anthonyrogers6429
    @anthonyrogers6429 Год назад +1

    Although heavily layered, I still think this was Bowie dealing with his very eminent mortality. We saw the young naive astronaut begin his lifelong trip by leaving Ormen in Space Oddity. We then saw the jaded drug addicted Major Tom in Ashes to Ashes. Then we see Major Tom dying on what may or may not be Ormen.
    OR, the unicode for Black Star is 2605. Mick Ronson's birthday. Ormen is also a town in Norway, where he "lost" Hermoine Farthingale. I'm sure there's a lot more symbolism of lost lives.
    As usual, with Bowie, there are 1000 ways to interpret this, and every single one could be right, or none.

  • @TheIfey07
    @TheIfey07 5 лет назад

    Man...... I don’t know where you got all this information but your the only one that makes correct sense

  • @mialia15104
    @mialia15104 Год назад

    First off, you have nice skin. Also great video! I've been listening to Blackstar over and over trying to figure it out, this makes a lot of sense.

  • @plungy
    @plungy Год назад +1

    In the Musical Lazarus David Bowie changed some of the texts of his old songs, they make they key in understanding the greater mystery.

  • @fizzingwhizbeee
    @fizzingwhizbeee 3 месяца назад

    I see this as an attempt to answer the question "Who Am I?" more than "Why do we die?." I see this as an exploration of the self and the metamorphasis in your understanding that occurs on death. In near-death experiences "something happened on the day he died, spirit rose a meter then stepped aside", some people witness the phenomenon of everything that you thought you were becoming no more real than a dream and who you are becoming abundantly clear. Who you really are cannot be seen (Like a black star), but is always there, you are the perceiver. "At the center of it all, your eyes." He repeats "I am not a" ((insert human trait)) "I'm the great I AM". Then returning to his person's life "Somebody else took his place and bravely cried, 'I'm a black star" acknowledging the human named Bowie declaring he is the great "I Am" is not him, because he is a great, black star, not this human. Don't ask me why I think this. "I can't answer why, just go with me"

  • @ikehelly
    @ikehelly 3 года назад +9

    On my Christmas break and have time to actually listen and watch David Bowie. I have no idea what it is about. For me there is a lot of religious imagery. I thought he was singing 'In the City of All Men' so that took me in a completely different direction. It is dark and appear to have an occult resonance. Leaving aside my intellect it can be enjoyed without knowing what it means. Must revisit the album. Good for opening a discussion on it. Subscribed to your channel

    • @andalltheangelssay212
      @andalltheangelssay212 3 года назад +2

      I have seen on the internet an early draft of David’s handwritten lyrics , I’m assuming they’re genuine, where he had written in the villa of all men. He had also written Lucy in brackets, and I wonder if the lyrics are about St. Lucy, look her up and you will see where I’m coming from, also maybe look up St. lucy in Dante’s inferno. Inferno by Dante was on David’s top 100 books, it’s worth looking into.

    • @lbbk6
      @lbbk6 2 года назад +1

      @@andalltheangelssay212 I just looked her up..wow. Her eyes removed for speaking against the powers that were.. in the video.. those button eyes 👀. ..wow. and I think Bowie says "in the center of it all, in the center of it all, your eyes" ..also, the solitary candle might make ref to the saint wearing candles on her head to keep both her hands free while feeding the hungry. Thanks very much for this info.. im now going to go look at the Dante's illustrations. ...

  • @sallymae6090
    @sallymae6090 2 года назад +1

    one man once took our blackstar for us

  • @acar7421
    @acar7421 8 месяцев назад

    Wow this was deep. Thank you for this.

  • @josephyearwood1179
    @josephyearwood1179 10 месяцев назад +1

    EVERY MAN HAS A BLACK STAR
    =
    EVER MAN HAS A BLACK STAR (SOUL)

  • @lindsayobrien7950
    @lindsayobrien7950 Год назад

    Wow, interesting thoughts, I think you are right. Could you expand more please?

  • @SomeGuyNamedRobb
    @SomeGuyNamedRobb 2 года назад

    dude, i Love this, man. I'd love to hear your thoughts on the rest of this album.

  • @tysonprice
    @tysonprice 2 года назад

    thank you for this video

  • @bryantwhittaker4163
    @bryantwhittaker4163 2 года назад

    And I like David Bowie's music to this day he mixes a lot of artistry and symbolism and meaning in his music

  • @richardbeverley1426
    @richardbeverley1426 5 месяцев назад

    I read somewhere at the time of his death that blackstar was a name given to a type of cancer. I also think the song is a distant recalling of his dalliance with Hermoine Farthingale who left him and went to Norway to make a film. His songs can be described at best as a smoke and mirrors thing, so much is there and it depends on your personal preference of circumstance

  • @DJXLX
    @DJXLX 3 года назад +2

    Still turns upsidedown mind emotions and passion

  • @joycekoch5746
    @joycekoch5746 2 года назад +5

    Brilliant. I don't know if people know this but Bowie had been coming around
    toward a more and more Christian world view since the 90's. In the 70's he
    discovered the reality of Lucifer but by the 80's he concluded he was no
    light bringing but a cheat and the world of Lucifer was a maze to keep people
    wandering, searching and wasting time like in the film Labyrinth until their time
    was up. In other words, the Goblin King isn't so nice at all - he wants to possess
    but can't really love and is filled with rage even in his own kingdom.
    I think Bowie was so far out in Blackstar that it didn't get more traction as people
    just didn't understand it.

  • @bodylan11
    @bodylan11 4 года назад +1

    Theres the connection to his son's Duncan Jones film Moon, the main character discovers he is imprisoned on the moon as a clone, as countless Clones.
    That image of major tom on the moon and the general obscurity tells me there's more to this piece than just death.
    I've been thinking (if) the Dali Lama reincarnations are real, perhaps the souls of musicians, and other geniuses of their craft are too... it can explain why some musicians are born with natural gift, many who are have parents in high ranks in the military/government and were likely groomed to become Frank zappas, jim Morrisons, Brian Wilson, thom yorke, Beatles, marilyn Manson, elvis, bowie...etc.

  • @kraz007
    @kraz007 28 дней назад

    Black star is tabula rasa, a blank canvas. It defies labels and underlies existence. It's the eternal dao that gives way to a myriad things (musically in our case).

  • @chickenswampable
    @chickenswampable Год назад

    When I first heard this I thought the lyric was "in the fear of all men,burns a solitary candle". It made sense.

  • @kenkayvoice
    @kenkayvoice 8 месяцев назад

    Pls correct me if I'm wrong but, no one noticed that Elvis and Bowie have the same birthdays (January 8)? That is what made this song a little more spooky (and cool) for me. Now I'm listening to Elvis' version daily!

  • @corinneclaes5792
    @corinneclaes5792 2 года назад

    I'm glad to have an explanation, thanks à lot for your vidéo.

  • @xbird532
    @xbird532 6 лет назад +2

    I don’t get how the black star represents guilt and how guilt is the cause of death. I agreed with what you were saying before that, then you just made a huge leap.

  • @indigrace6584
    @indigrace6584 3 года назад

    As old as this is, you sir are on the money!👍🇦🇺

  • @QUINT34577
    @QUINT34577 5 лет назад +9

    you cannot define a piece of poetry

    • @Rtd22375
      @Rtd22375 3 года назад

      Even the person who wrote it doesn't know what it means sometimes

  • @howedelamitri
    @howedelamitri 6 лет назад +9

    Just a theory: a 'dark star' =eclipse=supernova. A cosmic magic trick by The Master

  • @mahatmacubensis2657
    @mahatmacubensis2657 4 года назад

    Great analysis

  • @andalltheangelssay212
    @andalltheangelssay212 3 года назад +1

    Have you ever thought Blackstar could be about St. Lucy? And St Lucy’s role as protector in Dante’s Inferno?

  • @alohajesse
    @alohajesse 2 года назад +1

    Yeah WOW, I really thought this was going to be shit, how wrong could I have been. If anything you really gave me a whole new dimension/s for this album to mull over. Not that I had thought it was about anything in particular beforehand......I had already realised one thing though, this is possibly one of the best songs ever written.

  • @tennisbum3686
    @tennisbum3686 Год назад

    We live behind a mask throughout our lives, making efforts to play a part as in a play, pursuing approval from others to be accepted in an ever-changing role playing. We make adjustments to figure life out before death finally takes us into the void.

  • @EmilyKresl
    @EmilyKresl 5 лет назад

    What can you tell me about the next day Album and the whole oak king parallel.

  • @bowiesaid
    @bowiesaid 7 лет назад +1

    Bless your heart. Very well thought out

  • @hankpicard160
    @hankpicard160 4 года назад +2

    I don't care if he's a BLACK STAR or a
    STAR MAN,,,
    He is my STAR 🌠
    and he is missed,,,,😥

  • @freesolo5856
    @freesolo5856 Месяц назад

    Well apparently he wasn't terminal when he wrote this and others from the Black star album and my understanding is the terminal diagnosis was only about 3 months before the end. Nevertheless, I can't help thinking that he was deeply contemplating his own mortality at this point. He had been unwell and he did indeed have cancer. I kind of want blackstar to be about death because then for me, he becomes a true hero through his final artistic acts.

  • @titekubo3836
    @titekubo3836 2 года назад

    This is a really interesting interpretation

  • @michaelmichaels138
    @michaelmichaels138 4 года назад +7

    my PawPaw says the song is about smoking weed.

  • @midnightmosesuk
    @midnightmosesuk 6 месяцев назад

    If I may suggest, if you want a deeper interpretation of this song, you should read the poem The Hollow Men by T S Eliot. I think that a lot of imagery from that poem was used by Bowie in his art. It also gives context to the three scarecrows in the field. Yes, they probably symbolise the crucifixion but they symbolise much more.

  • @gr.vo.3058
    @gr.vo.3058 4 дня назад

    The Black Star is Sirius. Or the second sun. The Black sun. The SS had a symbol for it. It was supposed to give energy, vitality, and power to those who believed in it. BTW. My avatar/ symbol is of our beautiful Milky way Galaxy. Not to be confused with the aforementioned.

  • @oaktree2406
    @oaktree2406 3 года назад +1

    Holy shit yah got it son. Here's a cookie.

  • @punkestmofo
    @punkestmofo 3 года назад

    guys You still did not get it. David Brother's went out of his head on acid watching Kubrick's Odyssey. The smile sign You see on major tom was the most common blotter stamp at David's time. Than he speaks about Hermione Forthingale showing the inspiration (the girl that drives him) and the knowledge of death through the loss of his father and brother, major tom, died and rescued as the golden skull now that he is approaching the end. The transformation is there, he did alchemy, he transcended the poor faith of humanity "life goes against itself" "life gives what he takes away from You". He knows how the exasperate usage of drugs destroyed his life but gave him the false illusion to be guided in the long "trip" of his life, from Ziggy to all the expressions of his Psychosis, the gift to the world of a man that was touched by Genius, Charm, extreme intelligence, beauty, wit, and the capacity of revolutionizing the music and art during the second half of the 20th century. thanks David

  • @MitaLupa
    @MitaLupa 2 года назад

    None of the analysis videos I've seen so far of this video/these videos (from Blackstar, the LP) include the fact that the astronaut's costume is the same (or strongly references, see smiley face) as used in his son, Duncan Jones', movie 'Moon'. Now, I don't wish to spoil the great film for anyone who hasn't seen it, but I think it's worth considering what might connect the two (video/song story & movie/story) with the facts of: 1) referencing his progeny & 2) the possible common themes/symbolism/emotional exposition between David's life/death/music, & Duncan's film.

  • @TheGinger5678
    @TheGinger5678 7 лет назад +2

    Fascinating !!...tend to think of his take on humanity, reincarnation and cycle of life--all good...what great about Bowie is there is no one right interpretation.

    • @ioLanche
      @ioLanche  7 лет назад +2

      Well, if there is, he certainly didn't tell us ;-)

  • @creatifetudes8553
    @creatifetudes8553 3 года назад

    Very nice interpretation

  • @halasztothcsilladenes415
    @halasztothcsilladenes415 10 месяцев назад

    The song Blackstar is not about death but about dying which is our masterpiece of life for all of us.

  • @LioraLand1
    @LioraLand1 Год назад

    So open-heart it’s pain.

  • @michaux6000
    @michaux6000 5 лет назад +1

    we play and we see.

  • @plungy
    @plungy Год назад +1

    The Astronaut in Blackstar is not Major Tom but Thomas Jerome Newton, The man Who Fell to Earth. who left again in the Musical Lazarus, all the secrets are revealed in that musical.

    • @robbrown9619
      @robbrown9619 Год назад

      could Thomas Newton be Major Tom though, as he fell to earth

    • @plungy
      @plungy Год назад

      ​@@robbrown9619 David Robert Jones Became David Bowie, who became the Thin White Duke, Who Became Ziggy Stardust, and in the end became Thomas Jerome Newton. Newton Tries to get back into space, to Mars ttps://ruclips.net/video/hqT2hu3WrrA/видео.html

  • @gemstar5511
    @gemstar5511 3 года назад +2

    The woman has a tail because shes a witch born the 7th girl in a line, they were supposedly born with a tail

  • @komoriaimi
    @komoriaimi 5 лет назад +5

    Not very comforting that my very first email address, quite a while ago was... Black_star013 haha

  • @DWKThedogbreaths
    @DWKThedogbreaths 6 лет назад +39

    Hmm, nice theory but I'm not convinced. Bowie did not recognise Satan or any other symbol related to Christianity, he was closer to Buddha in the end and consequently had no archetypes worth singing about. I have no alternative theory to foster and appreciate the song for what it is; an enigmatic talking point.

    • @griffineagle7
      @griffineagle7 4 года назад +2

      disagree ..he incompassed all occult knowledge what you call christian and buddaha he would call esoteric wisdom ..the Gnostic christian belief of re-born he says in the lyric " we were born upside down ..the wrong way around " and the LUCIER not satan is a yes for the same reason ..your putting your belief and imaging it on bowie has am i and its a fair comment D.W.K.... ..lOLANCHE ..the the girl with the mousey hair and cat tail is also a referene to his CAT PEOPLE SONG ( cat ..mouse ) ..the video black star has all the qualitys of esoteric wisdom of his writings beyond doubt

  • @danielmackeigan9710
    @danielmackeigan9710 3 месяца назад +1

    Perhaps the only way to transcend is to sacrifice the ego-the false self. Spirit over matter.

  • @michaux6000
    @michaux6000 3 года назад +2

    David bowie rocks.

  • @lisapryce
    @lisapryce 6 лет назад

    Major Thom's disconnection from Ground Control represents state of 'the majority.'
    Unless the severed connection is repaired Humanity will remain lost st sea (or i n space...)

  • @operationnocontrol551
    @operationnocontrol551 6 месяцев назад

    In occultism, a black star is the other energy, representing mystery and the unknown energy of magic ( he was obsessed with occultism his whole life)

  • @xfire7
    @xfire7 Год назад

    Interesting that he said someone took his place . Would make the rebirth a whole lot easier to explain .

  • @photonjiagu
    @photonjiagu 3 года назад

    I don't know if the Elvis song meant anything to him but what I do know and what everyone else in the world missed is that the album art (I presume painted by Bowie) refers to the painting by JO BAER (1929) "White Star".
    krollermuller.nl/en/jo-baer-untitled-white-star

  • @andreabrambati4285
    @andreabrambati4285 2 месяца назад +1

    It sounds like "The process" by Kafka

  • @electronics3000
    @electronics3000 6 лет назад

    I like what you said here. I am also interested in what you might say about Blacksar today.

  • @maureenrosol-short2392
    @maureenrosol-short2392 3 года назад

    I like your interpretation.

  • @jobes4525
    @jobes4525 Год назад

    ELvis and David shared the same Birthday as well! Jan 8th.

  • @ManergoTones
    @ManergoTones 13 дней назад

    I’d love to hear more about his marriage to Iman, who is Muslim. It’s uncommon for a Muslim woman to marry a non-Muslim, so I’m curious about how that came to be.

  • @GALILEAClaudiaCeaCruz
    @GALILEAClaudiaCeaCruz 2 года назад

    El album BLACKSTAR, son las confesiones antes de morir de BOWIE... que es la ESTRELLA NEGRA, por supuesto ... EL ASTRO/DIVO PERVERSO
    The BLACKSTAR album, is BOWIE's confessions before he died ... which is the BLACK STAR, of course ... THE PERVERSE ASTRO / DIVO.

  • @skrtoplmrnqs5561
    @skrtoplmrnqs5561 2 года назад

    There’s an interview of Bowie and Mos Def from years ago where Bowie talks about the lyrics from the Black Star album. Black star is Mos Def and Talib Kweli duo, it could have inspired Bowie’s album title.

    • @ivankaramasov
      @ivankaramasov 2 года назад +2

      Bowie never talked about Blackstar in any interview. He gave no interview the last 10 years of his life.

  • @marcgoldstein2957
    @marcgoldstein2957 4 года назад

    His Major Tom alter-ego has been long established. Maybe we can think of Bowie - who as an iconoclast embodied so many different personas - proclaiming "I'm a Blackstar", that only he truly knew who he was at the end, leaving us with a perplexing mystery, as his skeletal remains are committed to the void. What is not often discussed, are the women manifesting a "demon" through their ritual, who goes after patriarchal scarecrow figures. There is a lot in there as well.

  • @cathyfitzpatrick9384
    @cathyfitzpatrick9384 5 лет назад +1

    Davids legacys in his music he began singing as no one would sing his songs …. What about Lulu and Mott the Hoople who he gave a song which saved the group from splitting up 'All the young Dudes but David is heard on the song with guys .David has helped so many people and so many musicians have also in return helped David as music styles were changes for instance 'Niles Roger's with 'Let's Dance' that became one of the best Albums of the 1980's We will never have another David Bowie for this guy has left some people guessing over Black Star it is a wonderful Album in reality David thought he had months to live . there is 5 years of Bowie songs under Visconti's arms . to be released the next is said to be the re release 'Space Oddity' but on Vinyl but since there were a few versions of Space Oddity we wait with baited breath.