Professor Khan: If ISIS and al-Qaida are not Islam, what is Islam?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 окт 2024
- University of Delaware Professor Muqtedar Khan is an expert in U.S. Foreign Policy, Islamic political thought and governance. He is the author of the book "Islam and Good Governance," an exploration of the Islamic concept of Ihsan, which means to do beautiful things. More info about Dr. Khan can be found here: www.udel.edu/f...
Islam has nothing to do with Islam.
Narrated Yusair bin `Amr:
I asked Sahl bin Hunaif, "Did you hear the Prophet (ﷺ) saying anything about Al-Khawarij?" He said, "I heard him saying while pointing his hand towards Iraq. "There will appear in it (i.e, Iraq) some people who will recite the Qur'an but it will not go beyond their throats, and they will go out from (leave) Islam as an arrow darts through the game's body.'
Tell me the Hadith i wanna read it also could you explain it?
islam is fake
Can you describe the aqidah of the Khawarij?
@@chrisconnor7934 can you?
@@defaultish1288 KHAWARIJ
"This is a name that may be applied to anyone who rebels against the RIGHTFUL RULER on whom there is consensus, whether that rebellion was during the time of the Companions, against the Rightly Guided Caliphs or after the time of the Tabi'in.
But nowadays this name is usually applied in reference to those who were the first to rebel against the caliph 'Ali ibn Abi Talib (radiAllahu anhu).
The Khawarij were among the supporters of 'Ali (radiAllahu anhu), then they split from him after the arbitration.
Ibn Hazm (rahimahullah) said:
"They were Bedouins who had some knowledge of the Qur'an but did not acquire knowledge of the Sunnah; because of that they split into many groups".
[REFERENCE: "Al-Fasl fi'l-Milal wa'n-Nihal" (Vol. 4, pag. 168)]
i think, the main problem of common muslims and including most of their Quranic scholars, are too much "legalistic," (fiqh oriented), as if ayatollah (god guidance) is only one: al Quran (holy scripture) and its derivatives (hadist, ijma, qiyas, etc). factually, God him self, in very first revelation to Muhammad, is not asking Muhammad to study (iqra) the holy Quran (cos the kitab doesn't exist at that day), instead He command Muhammad to study (iqra) other ayatullah, we called as ayat Kauniyah (universe and all of His Creations in it). That why in serious and encyclopedic Islamic traditional school, we always taught that beside al Quran, there is another god guidance (ayatullah) called ayat kauniyah (the universe and all god creation in it). and for qur'anic scholars, we also know --from al Quran it self, there are two others god guidance (ayatullah), that we as muslims should seek for God Guidances: called as ayat insaniyah (human being) and ayat tarikhiyyah (human history).
if common muslims and it scholars, uses all 4 God Guidance in balanced ways, we will not always fall into legalistic point of view when we talking or examining Islam point of view about woman/feminism, politics, evolution, LGBTQ issues, democracy, secularism, separation between religion and state, on terrorism, etc. for me, if sociology, political science, statistics, history on the rise and fall of civilizations/countries (as interpreters of ayat kauniyah and ayat tarikhiyyah) comes to the conclusion that democracy with separation between religion and state, is the best political system in the world for advancement human civilizations, then all Muslims should choose democracy with separation between religion and state, as preferable political system to practice in all Muslims majority countries.
also if expert on biology, doctors, psychiatry, etc (as interpreter of ayat kauniyah and ayat insaniyah) , said that beside man and woman (as gender), we also has intersex, hemaprodyte, woman with more testosterones, man with more X chromosome, etc, then all Muslims should choose to agree that god him self gave us guidance / ayat that beside man and woman as gender, there also another genders/pronouns that we should cherish, protect, and respect (cos if we don't respect others God Creations, are similarly with we don't respect our God as their Creator).
if we stubborn, only picks, one ayatullah, we called al Quran (holy scripture/ayat Qauliyah), as the one and only god guidance to follow, then muslims and it scholars, will always fall upon into legalistic point of view (fiqh oriented) when we examining what is islamic point view on everything under the sky. wahabbiyah, isis, al Qaida, etc are trapped in this narrow point of view about Islam and its believe. of course, for responsible and encyclopedic islamic teaching, all those narrow point views on Islam are wrong (at least incomplete), misguided, and disrespecting God.
umar bin khattab, as on of few sahabah (closed friend of Prophet), several times choose to disregarding some textual issues stated clearly in al Quran, and pick other decision after he choose as Muhammad successor, as leader (khalifah/amir), if there are more fairer and more justice way (socially) on making decision as Amir/Leader, rather than choose from what already state very clear in al Quran. he always choose more fairer and more justice decisions, even others sahabah question his decision. and as we know it, umar bin khattab is one of several sahabah (closed friend of Prophet) that guaranteed (informed) by the Prophet that he is going to heaven. his way of leadership decision, was a hard evidence that the closest friend to Muhammad, also not only consider holy scripture (ayat Qauliyah), but also social aspect, fairness, and justice (ayat kauniyah), when he making decision as a leader.
nobody in umar bin khattab time, dare to called umar bin khattab as heretic/bid'ah, kuffar, or infidel. but in modern era, several of loud muslims, loud muslim scholars, and most of jihadist will immediately call us heretic/bid'ah, kuffar, or infidel if we also uses 3 other God Guidance's beside ayat Qauliyah, when we speak, analyze, examining islamic point of view on everything under the sun. how strange is it, if we following completes God Guidance's, then be called as infidel, kuffar, or bid'ah. legalistic approach (fiqh oriented) on Islam has bad impact on advancement of Islamic civilization, and has backward effect on development of its peoples: the Muslims. but yes, in Islamic jurisprudence (ushul fiqh), we also has similar concept with Umar way, but unfortunately has more narrowed approach and clearly far from sufficient to be implemented in modern era, we call them: maslahah mursalah (public good principle) and maqashid syariah (ratio legal over legal specific).
if muslims also incorporate social science, biology, technology, history, political science, psychology, etc (as part of rightful interpreter all of God Guidancs/ayatullah), many problem we faced today in many part of Muslim countries, will be addressed in responsible way. Muhammad him self, in his own word (Hadits Bukhari Collection no 6015), said: muslims should follow person with specific expertise on handling matter, so let political scientist handle political matter, health matter should handle by doctors, etc. do not let everything under authority of quranic expert. in general, muslim should treat expert on other ayatullah (scientist as rightful interpreter whole universe and all of His Creations in it, as rightful interpreter human being behavior and it history) equal to expert on holy scripture (al quran). Furthermore, on all wide range of social issues, every new founding/understanding as result from responsible research by scientist, should supersede (abrogate) any old interpretation from holy scripture, cos all of new founding/understanding as result from responsible research by scientist, are also rightful interpreter of God Guidance (ayatullah). falling to do so, should be interpreted as a disqualified argument/opinion.
Many argument/opinion base on fiqh (islamic legal specific), kalam (theology) and falsafah (philosophy), factually in most areas are quite obsolete for addressing social, economic, and political problem in modern era, cos most of them are derived only from ayat Qauliyah (Quranic centric), which is an incomplete way to sorting our problem in modern era. Most of old argument/opinion already supersede/abrogated by new founding/understanding as result from responsible research by scientist. Muslims should back to the complete of God Guidance in balance way on solving problem in Muslims world, not only using holy scripture as final say. and stop kuffar/infidel calling game, cos that game from a complete, genuine, and responsible interpretation of 4 God Guidances, is simply un islamic.
and, as an open end conclusion, there is a deeper question: why common muslims and its scholars dare to disregarding 3 other God Guidance's? why muslims and its scholars become legalistic (only focus on 1 ayatullah / 1 God Gudance (ayat Qauliyah) called alquran, as if salvation of a civilization fate can be and must be depend on 1 cause only? as brief answer is: corruption and abuse of power by people in high power, it cronies, and big business that closed to muslim countries rulers at that time. all of them, almost single handedly creates and propagate common muslims and its scholars into disregarding 3 other God Guidance's.
peoples in power, it cronies, and big business that closed to muslim countries rulers push and push relentlessly to narrow interpretation on morals and public interest thru perverted interpretation on the holy scripture. even, they dare to appoint unqualified islamic scholar as qadi for them to uses as fatwa producers in favors to their vested interest. since then, islamic civilization goes down spiral into inevitable decline from it's greatness. many fatwa produced in their regime will makes serious, genuine, and responsible islamic scholar scratching their head and shocked. fatwa on mihnah policy, on banning printing technology, banning radio, tv, google, youtube, etc, are among of perverted interpretation on holy scripture. it lead to tradition/repetition/reinforcement on using narrow interpretation islamic law for beating and punishing dissent and discontent on social injustice in islamic society.
furthermore, it lead islamic society to become close minded, anti science, and trapped in textual approach tradition on just 1 god guidance called al quran (ayat Qauliyah) only, with narrow and more narrow interpretation. common muslim today and it scholar today are the real victims of bad fatwa born from dark alliance between high power, it cronies, big business that closed to muslim rulers before them. lets wake them up, by spreading the real genuine of God Guidance's and it's rightful interpreters that we called: sciences. amen.
Are you Muslim ?
Being islam like indonesian🇮🇩
Tepok jidatt, hadehh.. biasa aee
@@yourexcused2261 you will see extremism in Indonesia now, they have invested enough to spread wahabism in indonasia zakir naik is choosen for the job
@@merohit121 Yeaa, so truee.., lots of them here. Scary, Bruh..
It's amazing how some tendencies insist on accusing Islam in individual ways.
Narrated Yusair bin `Amr:
I asked Sahl bin Hunaif, "Did you hear the Prophet (ﷺ) saying anything about Al-Khawarij?" He said, "I heard him saying while pointing his hand towards Iraq. "There will appear in it (i.e, Iraq) some people who will recite the Qur'an but it will not go beyond their throats, and they will go out from (leave) Islam as an arrow darts through the game's body.'
I'm a muslim and I was taught in school that Islam prioritize peace. TERRORISM is not a part of Islam. How can we as muslims assure you that??
We told yall too many times that terrrorism is the opposite of Islam. You refused to listen to our voices.
These terrorists, they claimed that they followed Islam but actually they are not!! Why are you listening to them, instead of listening to other muslims voices?
Majority of muslims hate them, cuz they give bad image of muslims to the world.
Then, why are you hating the majority of muslim that are against terrorism? The world is unfair.
Please do not blame the WHOLE religion if only minority of them did wrong.
If anyone wants to know Islam, do not learn from the media.
Read the Holy Quran and STRONG Hadiths.
Be careful with hadiths though cuz some of them may be made up by morons.
Because they are killing us and chanting "allah hu akbar "
So peace they destroyed the Constantinople wall with cannon.
This man had never read Qur'an with meaning
IS stand for islamic state and they practice the quote of Quran very well.
How do they practice it very well? Which practice?
No , we have 2 billions Muslims doesn’t agree with isis , why ?!!!!!
The holy Quran never commanded people to kill innocent people, and I challenge you to reflect
@Wasim Akram Mondal there is huge difference between u terror organization al qaida nd rss understood
@@sultanaldhaheri6194 why Taliban killing inconcent people
Bruh...why did people make a fuss about it? Just follow what Al-Quran and Hadists said. EZ
@ Mate, most people mistaken when Al-Quran said that kafaru(non-muslims) will be punished as if we're the one that giving punishments to them.
Was your religion not told you that people who wasn't part of your religion will face the consequenses?
Every one of those punishments will be given to kafaru if they're not a Muslim(That's what we believe in) but that doesn't mean that people with sins won't be forgiven(unless if they didn't ask for forgiveness). And those punishments will be given by *God* , i repeat *by God.*
Us humans can't just torture other humans just because they're not a Muslim. That's also stated in Al-Quran. Basicaly it stated that us Muslims can't declare war against kafaru unless they declare it first. We're not allowed to harm kafaru unless they harm us first.
"Oh...but what ISIS?"
I don't know if they really counted as Muslims because what they did was against what Al-Quran said(what i just explained above).
"Oh but they called themself Muslims therefore all Muslims are violent right?" Well now let me ask you this: If people from your religion bombed innocent people, does that mean that all of your kind was the same? That they're violance and like to do harm?
Therefore when people said that we like to do harm just because who we "harmed" was not a Muslim, *they're wrong.*
Indeed allahu akbar 💣💣💣
@@chell6022 Say it but without the bombs...
@@chell6022 what's going on with the bomb???
@@delicatewallflower He thought it was funny to make a joke about a holy word being used as a word to start something v*olent by a misguided group of Muslims.
The Muslim community is the first in the world in behavior and integration - Islam leads to the best in reality and behavior - the increasing turnout from celebrities and the public from the West and their refusal to abandon Islam despite the deliberate linking of terrorism to Islam from time to time - to confirm that Islam leads to a better reality - this
Facts that lead you to learn about Islam from your reality or on the Internet. Thank you
Dear Islam? Shia or Sunni? If Shia, which shia, Khoja, Bhora, Memon, Ismaily. If Sunni, Bareilvi, Deoband, Alehhadees, wahabi etc, etc, etc.etc.?
@@satyajitray5889those are man-made (bida'a) a lot of people are just Muslims which are majority.
When will we wake up from this never ending nightmare.
دل ناامید تو نہیں ناکام ہی تو ہے
لمبی ہے غم کی شام مگر شام ہی تو ہے
How did Mohd the founder lead his life, was it similar to isis or not? That is the best way to determine what is and isn’t islam
you never heard ??
@@jamilumagaji582 heard what?
@Kalle Andersson lol maybe u should examine the life of mohd and judge for yourself if he warned u about isis or he led a life that inspired isis then we talk again :)
@Kalle Andersson all u need to do is read the quran and the hadiths :) that is where i get my info from. same place isis gets their info from
let me ask u a few simple questions, did mohd go to war with his neighbors, did he take sex slaves?
yes or no will do
@Kalle Andersson let me ask u a few simple questions, did mohd go to war with his neighbors, did he take sex slaves?
yes or no will do
Islam is a whole approach with books and scholars deciding what's right and what's wrong, so you look at what the consensus of the nation decides, not what people do.
Do mufti have natural desire for wealth or are they another perfect Allah creation?
Read "The Wahhabi Myth" by Haneef James Oliver.
I would strongly advise against this Professor, as many of the things he says---including a yearning for position in a political system that is antithetical to the laws of the Deen are against the orthodox teachings of Islam. If anyone is serious and sincere, always beg Allah for guidance and really study the Qu'ran and Sunnah and the Ulama Haqq and beware of wicked scholars trying to water down/distort the Deen.
Are you sure? Didn't sultan's prince kill each other for the throne all the fucking time?
@@blockedinchina6015 your names fits why you stated this comment. Blame the people not Islam. The Quran is a clear and perfect book. But people look at it in the wrong way.
@@ZinnCuh can’t be a perfect book if so many people are able to read it ‘incorrectly’
I am islam☝️. But isis is not Islam
Every muslim who does what Mohammed did is, - according to islam itself, a true muslim! Check Koran and Hadith to see if ISIS did what Mohammad did.
As long as Isis and Islamic terrorism exists it is the true form of Islam for us. Everything else seems watered down. You guys first figure it out among yourselves before preaching half baked truthsto the world.
@MUHAMMAD HAZIM BIN ZAMRI Moe
an also
When you make a peace agreement with your enemy, then, if you found out that enemy has left the * the peace agreement *. Islam commands you not to betray your enemy, and send a message telling them before war, that you found out; "that the peace agreement has been broken".
"And you(the enemy) must know the war is possible everytime"
إِمَّا تَخَافَنَّ مِن قَوْمٍ خِيَانَةً فَٱنۢبِذْ إِلَيْهِمْ عَلَىٰ سَوَآءٍ ۚ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ لَا يُحِبُّ ٱلْخَآئِنِينَ
@@infinitydude7305 the big reasons that small terrorists claim ("that they are Islam") because of; they found out that muslim peoples are heros ando don't fear the death like Israel soldiers😂😀.
The isreal soldiers entred and hide in cans of rubbish to keep their lives from rockets of Palestinians 😂😁😀🤣 because they are cowards
Allllahuuu akbarrrrrr 💣💣💣
SONIC.EXE is like isis
sonic is like real islam.
Is Islam "just a political ideology"? - ruclips.net/video/EBtAVzhw4gs/видео.html
Sir I'm a hindu, I am very touched by the message you gave in this video, I had a wrong thought about, Islam and had a very wrong mind set, but in this span of 1 min 24 sec you just changed the whole incorrect idea of mine. Thank you sir thanks a lot, the whole idea of islam, I thought islam was nothing but violence, but its just the stupid society, that has done injustice to this very beautiful religion, Anyone who is reading this comment I would want to say that, all religions are created for a very good reason and all of the books of teaching say the same thing but in different ways, I really liked this video,Professor khan got a little emotional there, but it was needed to make my heart melt and understand the wrong thought that I possessed.
Bhai aisa kya keh diya isne XD XD
bhai sacchi bhai
You become brainwashed in just 2 min video.
Based hindu
@@nandirenukumar3972 ankhe mat band karo😂😂
Al-lâh = The god = Lâh = In Egyptian mythology, Lâh is a god linked to the lunar star.
Sura 36.1 Ya-Sîn = Sîn is the deity personifying the Moon in ancient Mesopotamia.
Lâh / Sîn is ONE, the same Lunar God ............... Lâh was honored by the Idolaters in Egypt and Sìn in Mesapothania (Iraq).
sura 36 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
36.1 Ya-Sin = Oh, Lunar God
36.2 By the wise Koran.
Muslims hear a Lunar God, behind the Lunar God hides the Saytan. Allah is Satan!
My friend I wish you happiness - here are some concepts about Islam to remove the bad image
Drawn by the suspicious media - Islam came with the Holy Qur'an, the word of God. When you listen to it or read it, you will find serenity and spiritual peace that you have never found before - filling the spiritual void of the soul by answering all of its questions, including - Why was it created? What after death? It gives the soul hope and removes anxiety
and fear of the future
Is hell eternal ?
Islam has elevated women through the right of inheritance, kinship, property and work that does not affect their dignity - Islam has criminalized the exploitation of their beauty and neglect in old age, despite these rights being deliberately distorted to limit Western women’s turn to Islam due to their feeling of safety and respect, especially in old age (by comparison.. )
Muhammad, may God’s prayers and peace be upon him, is the seal of the Messenger, Jesus and Moses, peace be upon them, the good news of Muhammad
Just ideal and hypothetical talk. It says actions speak louder than words. So called Muslims like you trumpet 🎺 so many statements but full of hypocrisy 🙄
Islam sets a purpose for
life
It is a comprehensive lifestyle - based on justice and equality - it carries solutions to all life's problems - suitable for every time and place, free of contradictions and myths - it rejects all forms of religious and class distinction
- He holds the scientific lead (the stages of fetal development - the ascent into space ... and) supported by logic. Reason - enable yourself to hear it to realize the truth - by comparing it with other holy books, will you find the true religion?