I've heard dozens of versions of this Étude, and I've never seen such grace with dynamics and technique blended together with personal impression and feeling. Also, She managed to bring it down to a more graceful and less urgent and dramatic version of it and it is so good. I wish I had the chance of learning how to improve my piano dynamics with her. She is simply amazing.
It is easily my prefered piano composition, it is so beautiful that almost makes me cry. So well composed and so well played, so much energy completely under control, letting it go and restraining it as needed. What a feeling.
by physical actual damage, exchanging of brain wave, by these both way : i've been often changed my original body feature bad by zombies to like next points {got bigger face(since 2017.9~), got yellow and pale color face(since 2022.9~), bad and ugly nose, got bigger nostril and dented side base and thinner skin and shortened length(since 2017.2~), got ugly buck tooth and inner mouth(since 2022.3~), got shortend index finger of my hand(since 2022.9~),my nails got thinner(since 2022.12~),hair quality got thick and oily(2022.8~),my good and rational function of sexual part for example,such like vagina, changed strange,loosen(especially since 2022.12~)}. stalkers, especially japanese actresses use huge amount money to make me unhappy and looks inferior than them. and they repeat crushing and decieving, they just want to show broken me. my this unhappy situation's trigger was that my little bit sexaul self-photo laying on the bed was stolen from my phone and spreaded on the internet in 2014 summer~fall. and just for absorbe my life and hide such source, they are trying to make large number of modifying datas, i knew this.
This is such a unique and beautiful interpretation of this piece. Most pianists can play it pretty standard and faster than this, but this version is really something I've never heard. Truly amazing!
Superlative interpretation of this Chopin' very difficult study and result of years and years spent to exercise and technique. Amazing!!!!! Complimentissimi a Beatrice!!!!! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Very intelligent performance with much passion for inner voices. I enjoyed all the different colours of sound that she putted into that piece. Really amazing!
Non vorrei azzardare troppo, ma credo che attualmente sia una delle più brave pianiste sulla scena! Esecuzione di un dinamismo e di un'intensità senza pari!
@@stefanomacobi7236Yuja does not show off. She is no different than the fast fingers of young Martha Argerich. Yall just love to attack her because she is hot and wears what she wants.
Virtuosité, bien sûr ! C'est sans conteste. Mais, en plus ... une sorte de puissance lyrique qui restitue à cette belle étude son caractère poétique que trop de pianistes-acrobates oublient !
A suo modo accademica, tanto da risultare monotona purtroppo. Tutto troppo equilibrato e perfetto, insomma niente a che vedere con i grandi pianisti del passato più grezzi, pazzerelli e passionali.
Beatrice Rana mi piaceva di più quando era in competizione, osava di più, forse sotto pressione veniva fuori il meglio... ora è tutto molto perfetto, ben suonato, tutto fin troppo equilibrato, ma la trovo molto monotona, non sento quella capacità di saper "cantare" che avevano/hanno i miei pianisti preferiti che erano/sono sì virtuosi, ma anche grezzi, passionali e pazzerelli (vedi Argerich, Horowitz, Elisso Virsaladze, Sviatoslav Richter, Emil Gilels). Per carità sto confrontando con mostri sacri, ma stiamo parlando di un'artista di alto livello, che ormai ha 30 anni non più 20, mi aspettavo francamente un evoluzione migliore... invece è tutto molto piatto, manca la genialità e manca una propria personalità distintiva. E' lo spartito suonato a perfezione, con facilità e basta. Anche la dinamica che usa in questo studio, non la trovo confacente a uno studio, ma più a un notturno, cioè non capisco la scelta di rallentare come per pensare... è uno studio va suonato, non occorre pensare, nei notturni si pensa. Poi per carità molto brava, tra i contemporanei non c'è paragone a mio avviso.
Very loud and annoying resonance from too much pedaling in each second half of the chromatic scale descents, especially toward the end of each sentence. One should refrain from excessive pedaling in the second half of the chromatic scale descents for two reasons: (1) over-sustaining bass notes causes excessive resonance which makes music very murky; (2) excessive resonance makes hearing/tracking long decent difficult which is bound for mistakes or even grinds to a halt.
I've heard dozens of versions of this Étude, and I've never seen such grace with dynamics and technique blended together with personal impression and feeling. Also, She managed to bring it down to a more graceful and less urgent and dramatic version of it and it is so good. I wish I had the chance of learning how to improve my piano dynamics with her. She is simply amazing.
It is easily my prefered piano composition, it is so beautiful that almost makes me cry. So well composed and so well played, so much energy completely under control, letting it go and restraining it as needed. What a feeling.
Absolutely mesmerizing!! Phenomenal technique always at the service of the most expressive and dynamic interpretation
This is a really great performance. The recording is exquisite. She is playing this piece w fire and energy. Well done!!!!! Thank you
I think whoever prepared the piano got it just right, as well. Great all round.
by physical actual damage, exchanging of brain wave, by these both way :
i've been often changed my original body feature bad by zombies to like next points {got bigger face(since 2017.9~), got yellow and pale color face(since 2022.9~), bad and ugly nose, got bigger nostril and dented side base and thinner skin and shortened length(since 2017.2~), got ugly buck tooth and inner mouth(since 2022.3~), got shortend index finger of my hand(since 2022.9~),my nails got thinner(since 2022.12~),hair quality got thick and oily(2022.8~),my good and rational function of sexual part for example,such like vagina, changed strange,loosen(especially since 2022.12~)}.
stalkers, especially japanese actresses use huge amount money to make me unhappy and looks inferior than them.
and they repeat crushing and decieving, they just want to show broken me.
my this unhappy situation's trigger was that my little bit sexaul self-photo laying on the bed was stolen from my phone and spreaded on the internet in 2014 summer~fall. and just for absorbe my life and hide such source, they are trying to make large number of modifying datas, i knew this.
It's not so good((((
This is such a unique and beautiful interpretation of this piece. Most pianists can play it pretty standard and faster than this, but this version is really something I've never heard. Truly amazing!
Wonderful piece and Beatrice !! 🙏❤🎶🎹🎶❤👌🌨 🌬 🤗 Congratulations and thank you so much, Beatrice Rana and Warner Classics. 💕💕🌹💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹💐😊🌹❤
Superlative interpretation of this Chopin' very difficult study and result of years and years spent to exercise and technique.
Amazing!!!!!
Complimentissimi a Beatrice!!!!! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Wow the dynamics. The title “winter wind” was given justice.
Wow absolutely masterful performance. 🌬🌪 SO enjoyed a perfect interpretation thank you Beatrice Very well done. 👏👏👏💐💐💐💐
Very intelligent performance with much passion for inner voices. I enjoyed all the different colours of sound that she putted into that piece. Really amazing!
Bravo, magnifique performance!
Una de mis pianistas preferidas, ¡gracias Beatrice! Es un estudio muy difícil como muchos de los de Chopin, Bravo
Absolutely outstanding. Both the pianist and the sound engineers.
Wow, the winter wind is so strong 😮
That was Epic ❤❤❤ B. Rana is Unique, she'll top Argerich in a near future 👌👌👌⭐⭐⭐🌹🌹
Bravissima Pianista. Mi dispiace che Lei non risponda mai ad un solo commento. Credo sia bello sentire Il Maestro.... Grazie
extraordinaire, parfait. Un plaisir immense.
Meravigliosa Beatrice. Sei straordinaria!!
Perfect playing
Non vorrei azzardare troppo, ma credo che attualmente sia una delle più brave pianiste sulla scena! Esecuzione di un dinamismo e di un'intensità senza pari!
...эмоции есть .. но много лажи ...и педали!(
Non azzardi nulla!
BRAVO!!!
Bravo!
Grandissima esecuzione , personalità e carattere , lascia con il fiato sospeso
Beautiful Beatrice!
Crisp playing and Great piano too!
BRAVO !!!!!
Una delle migliori interpretazioni. Complimenti!😄
Speaking as a pianist, the only thing I don't like about Beatrice Rana's playing is that she makes it look much easier than it is.
Yes, pretty much everything is easy for her
Because she doesn't show off, like other female pianists, i.e. Buniatishivili or Wang
@@stefanomacobi7236 She learned music, not theatrics.
In fact, it should be more daring, otherwise it's too monotonous.
@@stefanomacobi7236Yuja does not show off. She is no different than the fast fingers of young Martha Argerich. Yall just love to attack her because she is hot and wears what she wants.
I find some pauses quite abrupt, but other than that really loved the passage at 0:48
Piękne 💐👏
Sublime
wooowww what a power! cool
Virtuosité, bien sûr ! C'est sans conteste.
Mais, en plus ... une sorte de puissance lyrique qui restitue à cette belle étude son caractère poétique que trop de pianistes-acrobates oublient !
Мощно, сильно, впечатляет. Там в степи глухой замёрзал ямщик....
Veramente superlativa. Passione, grazia e perfezione tecnica. Straordinaria.
Levels are good.
Orgoglio italiano !!
Grandissima, credo che Chopin sarebbe strafelice di questa Sua lettura. La saluto signorina, è sempre una grande emozione ascoltarLa
Super
ショパンの木枯らしのエチュードの難易度は、最高レベルらしい
神曲紹介してるから再生リスト見てちょ
完美的诠释🎉
I love this piece 🥰
Increible 😍😍😍
wonderful!
J’adore le 5 ème en karaté 🥋 à 3:38 ❤️
Wonderful.
Tutto con lei è come deve essere! Olimpica.
🙏
👏👏🥰
so well played!
This should have a trillion views
Beautifully done! I just love ‘Winter Wind.’ I actually recorded my own version recently, and I’d be thrilled if you could give it a listen!
I like her tempo
Incredible
Winter wind? More like a winter hurricane
WOW!
Müthiş
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
🇦🇷😍🇦🇷😍
Bellissimo
Glänzend... aber Pollini nimmt weniger Pedal, dadurch klingt manches deutlicher!
3:37
Není co řešit super krasavice
.....mamma mia!!!!!!......è un mostro sacro. !!!!! Emozionante..come governa il piano, e come lo rispetta!!! SUPER
Chopin ❤️
0:28
Anyone else noticed she just kinda looks like Janice?
Molto accademica,brava ma riguardo all interpretazione c è molto ancora da lavorare
A suo modo accademica, tanto da risultare monotona purtroppo.
Tutto troppo equilibrato e perfetto, insomma niente a che vedere con i grandi pianisti del passato più grezzi, pazzerelli e passionali.
This is really very hard to play
Anche Leonora Armellini se la "cava bene" con Chopin.
se va beh! non basta cavarsela a questi livelli.... avremmo bisogno di altro, da entrambe le artiste.
Beatrice Rana mi piaceva di più quando era in competizione, osava di più, forse sotto pressione veniva fuori il meglio... ora è tutto molto perfetto, ben suonato, tutto fin troppo equilibrato, ma la trovo molto monotona, non sento quella capacità di saper "cantare" che avevano/hanno i miei pianisti preferiti che erano/sono sì virtuosi, ma anche grezzi, passionali e pazzerelli (vedi Argerich, Horowitz, Elisso Virsaladze, Sviatoslav Richter, Emil Gilels). Per carità sto confrontando con mostri sacri, ma stiamo parlando di un'artista di alto livello, che ormai ha 30 anni non più 20, mi aspettavo francamente un evoluzione migliore... invece è tutto molto piatto, manca la genialità e manca una propria personalità distintiva. E' lo spartito suonato a perfezione, con facilità e basta.
Anche la dinamica che usa in questo studio, non la trovo confacente a uno studio, ma più a un notturno, cioè non capisco la scelta di rallentare come per pensare... è uno studio va suonato, non occorre pensare, nei notturni si pensa.
Poi per carità molto brava, tra i contemporanei non c'è paragone a mio avviso.
It's magic. I believe that Chopin must like to be played by you
I think not. Romanticists of the past was not so dramatic.
Pretty good but I miss Richter beating the hell out of those final chords
How to prove you’re ambidextrous.
beautiful piano playing, narcissist camera man.
Hyvin soitettu mutta jäin odottamaan lumimyrskyä
We want to see her play not the piano ...
THAT PIANO SOUNDS HORRIBLE, ESPECIALLY IN THE LOW END......MUDDY IN GENERAL, BUT ESPECIALLY THE BIG BASS NOTES AT 3:36 !!!
Let’s see you play it 😭😭
@@eleneingorokva I WASN'T CRITICIZING HER PLAYING, ONLY THAT OLD BEAT DOWN STEINWAY...
i thought i was the only one
Very loud and annoying resonance from too much pedaling in each second half of the chromatic scale descents, especially toward the end of each sentence. One should refrain from excessive pedaling in the second half of the chromatic scale descents for two reasons: (1) over-sustaining bass notes causes excessive resonance which makes music very murky; (2) excessive resonance makes hearing/tracking long decent difficult which is bound for mistakes or even grinds to a halt.
Peccato quel rallentamento troppo evidente
E' tutto troppo evidente e accademico.
Che pianista......le dita corrono come il vento