È Fantastica! Mai sentita una tale sintonia con l'orchestra in un brano tanto impegnativo, sembra che suoni tutto Lei... E alla fine sembra che abbia fatto due passi in giardino, è perfino riposata. Beatrice, Ti amo!
Suono e fraseggio molto interessanti !!! Da tempo non sentivo questo concerto suonato in modo così nitido e chiaro... brava davvero!!! Orgoglio italiano !!! Continuo a fare il tifo per te !!!
Meravigliosa Beatrice! Letteralmente i brividi! Ti auguro che la tua carriera già così ai vertici del pianismo nell mondo ti porti ancora tantissimi successi, noi possiamo parlare di te orgogliosi di conoscerti da piccola, quando già eri speciale!
Brava Beatrice..... Fai battere il cuore della Puglia nel Mondo.. E' un onore poterti fare i complimenti.. non vedo l'ora di ascoltarti dal vivo.. sei unica!
Fantastica già da bambina quando ebbi l'onore di conoscere lei e la sua splendida famiglia. Ormai una grande stella del firmamento musicale. Questi sono i personaggi che danno lustro a questo magnifico paese. Grande artista
Beatrice, te lo dico ogni volta su Instagram, te lo ripeto anche qui, sei un grande orgoglio italiano e pugliese nel mondo. Interpretazione fantastica, straordinaria tanto più intima e naturale, fluisce con grandissima leggerezza. Grazie!
Che brava che sei Beatrice, fantastica: il grande Spirito di Robert Schumann aleggia dappertutto, la sua e la tua musica prendono il sopravvento su tutto. Grazie di cuore!
Una salentina a livelli internazionali..che orgoglio!!non posso immaginare quante ore di studio...tutto a memoria...sei una meraviglia!!quando farai un concerto nella tua zona saro' in prima fila per ascoltarti..sei una GRANDE!
Thank you, Beatrice. I just disovered you playing Bach's concerto in D-minor, one of my favorites. Your presentations, virtuosity Is fantastic. Yes, Bach seems to be the most un your soul. AND now this greatly performed Schumann. Thank you for sharing your gift, your work with us, showing the World these fantastic composers, orchestra, lifting you all, our spirits in difficult Times AND even More in good times.then the Soul goes into the immortal dimension where the music comes from.
Mi piace tantissimo come Beatrice Rana suona Schumann. Molto partecipe emozionalmente, rende questo concerto cameristico, come era nelle intenzioni di Schumann. Dialoga con naturalezza con gli altri strumenti, non si pone al centro. Il suono è equilibratissimo, molto intimo, eppure non si perde mai. Si sente che Beatrice ha studiato Bach a fondo. Bellissimo il rubato, molto emozionanti i momenti in accelerando.
Magnificient! So sensible, clever, emotionaly powerful and smart! You play this concerto as if it would have been composed for you! As if you had met Clara Schumann! Bravissimo!
so gloriously unpretentious, she plays non-technical perfect, as it is the most normal thing in the world, she is the best i remember the brahms concerto in bolzano........
And now this Schumann? I know her as a Bach Interpreter, can she play romantic music? As you can already understand my answer is yes! I never heard this piano concerto played with a more gentle touch than hers.
This reminds me of hearing Katia Buniatishvilli perform with the LA Philharmonic two years ago (Mozart A major concerto) . Her sound was not quite as bright as it is on iTunes but is was fuller and warmer with incredibly detailed dynamics. I'm really starting to appreciate world class piano playing. Thanks for your video on the Goldberg Variations. I watched another video on PianoTV about the Goldberg and I had to buy the music and look at it.
It's great that you are discovering classical music. Keep on listening and re-listening to different interpretations of the same piece. Eventually you'll find out there's tasteful, imaginative interpreters - and vulgar and tacky ones. I've got an idea into which category Rana belongs - and into which Buniatishvili. But up to you find out... 😉
Performance meravigliosa, emozionante, eseguita con "cuore caldo e mente fredda": suono controllato e timbro molto personale; mi ha colpito in particolare l'esecuzione da 12:38 a 14:58.
"Ms. Rana is adversely an 8th wonder, a sagestly claiuraudent necromity of likened listening essentially perturbed gifted young talent," Just what isn't there that she hasn't done, I have the privilege of her performing can't wait. Think I've waited long enough for her dayview.
I gave the same opinion to a Sir asking what the piece in the Four minutes movie's final was, posting this link and telling him that this is comparabile to Martha Argerich's performance only... Great to meet someone with the same feeling.
DENNY T I urge you to skip to the last movement if you couldn’t stand the first 2, in all honestly I don’t prefer the first two movements much either but I am not lying when I say that the finale is one of the most beautiful pieces of music I’ve ever heard. At least give it a try, id like to know your thoughts about it!
@@lukeehrkepiano5061 Thank you for your effort to bring your appreciation of this Schumann piece to my attention. I did listen to the last movement, but it still leaves me cold. I found it to have, at its best parts, touches of Chopin and Brahms. When I listened, I didn't have any awareness of his fondness for both composers. I never felt that he reached a lyrical beauty I find in both of those composers. But, thank you again for trying. Perhaps when I'm old, I'll like him more. I'm only 77 now.
Very poor performance of this fine concerto. She rushed through sections that required much more expression and generally rushed through it. A perfunctory performance throughout. Lipatti is my favorite recorded performance and his live one as well with Ansermet. I wonder if Rana has ever heard Lipatti's performances or has taken note of other fine performances. This is not to say that she should have followed other pianists' interpretations but she could had gained greater insight into the piece had she done so and might have changed the way she approached this work. A few other great pianists have given fine live and recorded performances of this work. Rana does well when performing the Prokofiev concertos but is out of her element when it comes to the Schumann piano concerto.
"Very poor"? I disagree. Technically imperfect, yes, as others have noted. But she breathes life and feeling into pieces like this that I'd stopped listening to because they are so boring. I'll listen to the gentleman you mention, looking forward to it.
Your very subjective opinion. I love this performance for precisely the reasons you dislike it. It's a piece I used to hate, because of grandiose, overindulgent performances. Now, at last, I understand it.
The flowers are for you Miss Beatrice Rana, grazie for your lovely performance. 🌷🌷🌷 (Hollanda)
Beatrice Rana is the greatest pianist of our time. When she plays the music floats in the air directly from the composer's heart to your heart.
I believe, you will end up being one of the great piano legends, Beatrice Rana.
She already is, and already was as young girl ! ❤
The greatest Rach 2 I have ever witnessed and one of the best concerts ever!
È Fantastica! Mai sentita una tale sintonia con l'orchestra in un brano tanto impegnativo, sembra che suoni tutto Lei... E alla fine sembra che abbia fatto due passi in giardino, è perfino riposata. Beatrice, Ti amo!
Suono e fraseggio molto interessanti !!! Da tempo non sentivo questo concerto suonato in modo così nitido e chiaro... brava davvero!!! Orgoglio italiano !!! Continuo a fare il tifo per te !!!
Meravigliosa Beatrice! Letteralmente i brividi! Ti auguro che la tua carriera già così ai vertici del pianismo nell mondo ti porti ancora tantissimi successi, noi possiamo parlare di te orgogliosi di conoscerti da piccola, quando già eri speciale!
She is indeed a wonderful pianist and a beautiful young woman.
Che suono meraviglioso! E' che interpretazione... che emozione
Brava Beatrice..... Fai battere il cuore della Puglia nel Mondo.. E' un onore poterti fare i complimenti.. non vedo l'ora di ascoltarti dal vivo.. sei unica!
Il miglior Concerto di Schumann che abbia mai sentito!
She is marvelous. A long, healthy life to her!
Letteralmente incantata dalla bravura, dalla semplicità e dalla simpatia che emana fra chi la osserva.
I remember this concert very well. It was electrifying even in the vast hall.
Fantastica già da bambina quando ebbi l'onore di conoscere lei e la sua splendida famiglia. Ormai una grande stella del firmamento musicale. Questi sono i personaggi che danno lustro a questo magnifico paese. Grande artista
Sono impressionato, straordinaria, immensa!
Beatrice, te lo dico ogni volta su Instagram, te lo ripeto anche qui, sei un grande orgoglio italiano e pugliese nel mondo. Interpretazione fantastica, straordinaria tanto più intima e naturale, fluisce con grandissima leggerezza. Grazie!
Che brava che sei Beatrice, fantastica: il grande Spirito di Robert Schumann aleggia dappertutto, la sua e la tua musica prendono il sopravvento su tutto. Grazie di cuore!
Una salentina a livelli internazionali..che orgoglio!!non posso immaginare quante ore di studio...tutto a memoria...sei una meraviglia!!quando farai un concerto nella tua zona saro' in prima fila per ascoltarti..sei una GRANDE!
Thank you, Beatrice.
I just disovered you playing Bach's concerto in D-minor, one of my favorites.
Your presentations, virtuosity Is fantastic.
Yes, Bach seems to be the most un your soul.
AND now this greatly performed Schumann.
Thank you for sharing your gift, your work with us, showing the World these fantastic composers, orchestra, lifting you all, our spirits in difficult Times AND even More in good times.then the Soul goes into the immortal dimension where the music comes from.
Mi piace tantissimo come Beatrice Rana suona Schumann. Molto partecipe emozionalmente, rende questo concerto cameristico, come era nelle intenzioni di Schumann. Dialoga con naturalezza con gli altri strumenti, non si pone al centro. Il suono è equilibratissimo, molto intimo, eppure non si perde mai. Si sente che Beatrice ha studiato Bach a fondo. Bellissimo il rubato, molto emozionanti i momenti in accelerando.
Royalty at the piano. Very well done!
Grazie x aver suonato Schumann
Superb playing: matter-of-fact elegance without calling attention to self, genuine, with feet firmly on the ground throughout.
Magnificient! So sensible, clever, emotionaly powerful and smart! You play this concerto as if it would have been composed for you! As if you had met Clara Schumann! Bravissimo!
so gloriously unpretentious, she plays non-technical perfect, as it is the most normal thing in the world, she is the best
i remember the brahms concerto in bolzano........
absolutely amazing performance! yes it is Schumanesque indeed. thank you for sharing.
The Best❤❤❤
🥰🥰🥰 saw her last week, Brahms piano concerto n. 1, an angel’s touch 🥰🥰🥰
So glad this is available. Joyous inspiring playing from soloist and orchestra
What a wonderful musician and pianist
Wonderful rendition!
Beatrice sei fantastica!❤❤❤
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Felicitaciones, una pianista exquisita. Gracias.
🌷👸Sua interpretação é de tirar o fôlego. Belíssimo!
Scoperta stanotte in Bach BWV 1052 e Prokofiev k per pf 2 e 3. Cioè nel top del top. Straordinaria, incantevole pianista salentina!
Bellissima interpretazione
Fantastica!!!!
Wonderful legato playing! Full harmonics
Wonderful, questo è Schumann
And now this Schumann? I know her as a Bach Interpreter, can she play romantic music? As you can already understand my answer is yes! I never heard this piano concerto played with a more gentle touch than hers.
Bravissima e concentratissima!!
Amazing
Un dono del cielo
Intensa. Immensa.
FANTASTICA !!!!!!
This reminds me of hearing Katia Buniatishvilli perform with the LA Philharmonic two years ago (Mozart A major concerto) . Her sound was not quite as bright as it is on iTunes but is was fuller and warmer with incredibly detailed dynamics. I'm really starting to appreciate world class piano playing. Thanks for your video on the Goldberg Variations. I watched another video on PianoTV about the Goldberg and I had to buy the music and look at it.
It's great that you are discovering classical music. Keep on listening and re-listening to different interpretations of the same piece. Eventually you'll find out there's tasteful, imaginative interpreters - and vulgar and tacky ones. I've got an idea into which category Rana belongs - and into which Buniatishvili. But up to you find out... 😉
“This is music.” Martin Scorcese
E viva Italia !!!!😘😘😘😘
eccellenza italiana
Eccezionale!
Brava Beatrice
Ein sehr schöner Anschlag, sowohl bei Bach, wie auch bei Schumann´s Klavierkonzert.
Performance meravigliosa, emozionante, eseguita con "cuore caldo e mente fredda": suono controllato e timbro molto personale; mi ha colpito in particolare l'esecuzione da 12:38 a 14:58.
bravo Beatrice !
大好きです。
頑張ってください。応援しています！
ショパンもラフマニノフも大好きです！
いつもありがとう！
Quanto mi piace b.r
🇮🇹👍🥂
Much better than Buniatishvili... Great job, Beatrice!
30:30
Wow! The last coda...
"Ms. Rana is adversely an 8th wonder, a sagestly claiuraudent necromity of likened listening essentially perturbed gifted young talent," Just what isn't there that she hasn't done, I have the privilege of her performing can't wait. Think I've waited long enough for her dayview.
She plays beautifully, without artifice.
Excellent Goldberg at El Camino College, Los Angeles! Next time you should play at Walt Disney Concert Hall.
ruclips.net/video/ftP8tyui27g/видео.html. This the link for to see her
++
Bravoooooo Beatrice... better then Martha .....
Are you kidding me? Martha is Martha.Nobody like her.
Da notare che è l'unica senza spartito
Schu-MERN?
Peccato l'orchestra.e il suo direttore che riesce ad appiattire perfino Schumann!!
she plays like martha argerich, i think...
beter.....I 'm sure
I gave the same opinion to a Sir asking what the piece in the Four minutes movie's final was, posting this link and telling him that this is comparabile to Martha Argerich's performance only... Great to meet someone with the same feeling.
😅
🤦sorry
Schumann does nothing for me.
Sorry to hear that.
I have doubts that anyone who has listened to the last movement of this concerto could say such a thing...
@@lukeehrkepiano5061 Couldn't get to the last movement.
DENNY T I urge you to skip to the last movement if you couldn’t stand the first 2, in all honestly I don’t prefer the first two movements much either but I am not lying when I say that the finale is one of the most beautiful pieces of music I’ve ever heard. At least give it a try, id like to know your thoughts about it!
@@lukeehrkepiano5061 Thank you for your effort to bring your appreciation of this Schumann piece to my attention. I did listen to the last movement, but it still leaves me cold. I found it to have, at its best parts, touches of Chopin and Brahms. When I listened, I didn't have any awareness of his fondness for both composers. I never felt that he reached a lyrical beauty I find in both of those composers. But, thank you again for trying. Perhaps when I'm old, I'll like him more. I'm only 77 now.
Very poor performance of this fine concerto. She rushed through sections that required much more expression and generally rushed through it. A perfunctory performance throughout. Lipatti is my favorite recorded performance and his live one as well with Ansermet. I wonder if Rana has ever heard Lipatti's performances or has taken note of other fine performances. This is not to say that she should have followed other pianists' interpretations but she could had gained greater insight into the piece had she done so and might have changed the way she approached this work. A few other great pianists have given fine live and recorded performances of this work. Rana does well when performing the Prokofiev concertos but is out of her element when it comes to the Schumann piano concerto.
"Very poor"? I disagree. Technically imperfect, yes, as others have noted. But she breathes life and feeling into pieces like this that I'd stopped listening to because they are so boring. I'll listen to the gentleman you mention, looking forward to it.
@@quincykim1 What technical imperfections are you referring to?
Your very subjective opinion. I love this performance for precisely the reasons you dislike it. It's a piece I used to hate, because of grandiose, overindulgent performances. Now, at last, I understand it.
@@juliansymes3994 The nearly imperceptible ones that make it a human performance, not sterile like pretty much all prior recordings I've heard.
I'd like to see you and listen to you playing this concert! I am sure you do better than anyone else!