STEPHEN HAWKING'S argument DESTROYED BY John Lennox
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
- "Because of the Law of Gravity, the universe can and will create itself from nothing", this was the famous statement made by Stephen Hawking , and this is completely destroyed by Dr. John Lennox in this interview with Eric Metaxas.
Watch the whole interview here:
• John Lennox: The Quest...
![KAYTRANADA - Witchy (feat. Childish Gambino) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jGK3YVmGZ3Y/mqdefault.jpg)
The greatest scientist of our time, just passed away. I just wanted to make sure that this video was no way intended to destroy his works, but to just challenge one of his argument.He will truly be remembered for his great contributions in the world of science and be a _HUGE_ inspiration for everyone.
R.I.P Stephen Hawking!
When did Hawking actually said that?
I watched a lot about Hawking, but he never put the mere existence of gravity as cause for a universe from nothing.
A universe once infinitely dense is just a universe infinitely. Everything was packed more dense.
John Lennox probably reads comic books.
@@Philotheist777 Comic books are fun to read so maybe 🤷♂️
Jesus greek name
Greatest scientist of our time? Haha, prove that, with science...
“Non sense remains non sense even if Stephen Hawkins writes it;” that’s deep.
jesus greek name
Your bible itself is a book of nonsense i have a lot of bible verses that teaches flat earth,geocentrism and the earth being older than sun
@@nickey9637 no sane Christian believes in a flat Earth, scripture does not support a flat earth
How did any of you determine what he said was nonsense?
This coming from a man that believes in a book about talking snakes and donkeys.
@@nickey9637 The irony of these apologists is baffling.
I love John Lennox he has always been my favourite
jesus greek name
@@Philotheist777 Quit spamming if u still are. Jesus being a greek name(if it is) doesn't disprove anything.
They're telling the truth
Jesus is a greek name.
Gravity is not a thing , it is a phenomena which cannot exist without mass
And the fabric as well. Mass without the fabric is just a thing surrounded by vacuum, how would a mass communicate with other masses, if the fabric was not there!
Jesus greek name
your right Albert (:
@@dianarista7391 yes,but black holes have gravity
John Lennox I have seen you in action and you are the man .....your answers make sense I am grateful to have you on this side . Thank you for all your hard work and you even find humor in some of it ...just an awesome guy
"The only way to avoid God is foolishness!" Amen! John Lennox is simply a very educated child of God. I have maximum respect for this man
If you lived in iraq you would be muslim
@@Philotheist777 dont understand your response
Your religion is dependent on your parents. I was raised Christian because white settlers converted my ancestors. I was once a child of god. Then I read native American history and realized the non Christian natives were killed
@@Philotheist777 everybody has to learn from someone. tragic that you think playing to tje gallery on such important ... u urge to seek you a partner to lead you back to God
@@skuzaposkuzapo56 I'm done with false pretenses so was hawking
"Nothing is what rocks dream about"
Aristotle
Rocks are inanimate objects and cannot dream at all. That’s a terrible analogy.
@@2l84me8 That's the whole point of the analogy.
@@BerishaFatian It doesn’t demonstrate what a “nothing” is.
@@2l84me8 No, but it gives you an idea.
@@BerishaFatian Not really. It’s just a vague metaphor. We also have no reason to believe there ever was just a literal “nothing”.
For a physicist nothing means no matter. For a philosophical meaning of nothing see Plato's 'Sophist'.
And now Hawking has come out with a new version of the "eternal universe" model by saying that before the Big Bang, time existed in a different way - he calls it "imaginary time." I laughed so hard when I heard this... Do people actually take him seriously? Wow...
Lawrence Stanley Fact: Multiverse exists.
Fuck Organized Religions fact: god is real
HONEST SWEAT Show us god.
@@dolphin3597 If we were to be able to physically 'show' God, he wouldn't be worth worshiping. The God that we believe in is a God that we can't control. If we could control God, there would be no Christians on this Earth. The fact that God is not limited in time and space proves that we can't simply 'show' God. He is too powerful to be controlled, which is exactly why we worship him.
Yes, they do, because he is actually talking about models that cannot be proven yet....trying to build a consistent model. Some ideas are very appealing regardless whether they later are proven or not.
I mean people still believe in god or Jesus without any evidence that any of those exists.....still I respect my fellow citizens and just smile that they are gullible in this point.
So John Lennox and Eric Metaxas two men who have never studied astrophysics in their lives both clearly understand the complicated mathematics and science more that Hawking who was a real scientist and who has created scientific work that has helped advance astrophysics and cosmology!
Hawking will be remembered as a great scientist revered by millions whereas Lennox and Metaxas will never be remembered for advancing our scientific understanding!
The cuts to the fireworks are a rather adolescent touch.
What's really funny is the thumbnail of this video. Damn I'm going to heck.
Btw it has meme potential, for example
*When u don't listen so teacher asks you but u know the answer anyways*
@@Necrodzentelmenel1 Jesus the greek god with a greek name.
Holy shit , how can someone misunderstand the basics of physics and mathematics to such an extent! Its a pity
And he is a very brilliant scientist.
I would not trust anything from Lennox.
9:06 nothing must be physical. But how can it be when it's not there? At this point i feel sorry for whoever wasted time on Mr. Hawking (?) and those other men with senseless statements. A man may have a degree but that doesn't make senseless statements correct. Thanks so much for posting this.
nothing = no matter.
I would suggest that he mas either misrepresented what Hawking said, or misunderstood it. To simply say he was stupid (or his idea was stupid) is not a useful argument.
He didn’t misrepresent Hawking’s argument, it relied upon assuming what we know about quantum mechanics would hold true in a state of nothingness. Lennox argues that nothing means the absence of absolutely anything physical, quantum particles included.
@@stevenw350 If nothing means nothing, then presumably there is no god, because that would be something. I know that you said 'physical', and that is his (and your?) get-out clause. But we know of nothing other than particles and fields. To postulate and all-powerful, all-knowing something that has always existed and had the ability to create a universe is, you have to admit, a bit of a stretch.
@@steveknight878 I ask you to find me a theory on this topic that isn’t “a bit of a stretch”, that’s where *faith* comes in.
What if... No Thing created the Universe, and it has always been there and will always be? And that Matter/Energy is a Living Entity?
1:50 in other words, gravity itself is something.
Laws of physics don't oblige any rules to make sense to John Lennox. Stop making fun of people with a real contribution to science, just cause he tried to explain it in a way any stupid would understand. What's your contribution to science? A ton of books religion oriented? Religiously related? Like many aspects of science anything is debatable until proven not by one, but by peer review, therefore I ask what's your proof of god that any person can review it or test it?.
Failing to understand abstract concepts makes me think you fail mathematics. Did you?
Hahahahahaha Stephen Hawking
My johnson created itself out of nothing
Lennox should have had the chair at uni..he was only fit.for black holes
12:50 thanks Dr. Lennox. Can academic institutions cancel the degrees of those learned men? 😂
Physicists are terrible philosophers.
Refute Stephen Hawkins after his death.....brave
Ο μονος τροπος να αποφυγεις τον Θεο ειναι η ανοησεια
"Something can't come from nothing, God is something, and he made something" but....okay.
@@graceelliepage6898 how do you know that the universe or rather the cosmos is not eternal. the evidence suggests that our current universe and our understanding of space-time had a beginning about 13.8 bil years ago. as of right now we don't know anything about the before or if a before even makes sense, because the evidence seems to show that time didn't exist "before". we still "see" the big bang happening that's the reason how we have proven this theory. but the big bang theory does not describe the beginning. it describes the expansion of the universe after our understanding of a "beginning". as of right now we know nothing about the "beginning" or if there even was a beginning. if you now say yeah that's where you need god then you obviously don't understand physics and it would be a perfect example of the god of the gaps.
and your claim about god, space and time has not been demonstrated to be true. it's as if I would say 10 fairies created time and space and that's why they can't be effected by time if they made it. it's just fallacious.
I hope that helps you to understand where you 're wrong.
@@graceelliepage6898 wow it's like you didn't even read my answer... I even predicted you'd use the god of the gaps and you don't even seem to realise it. and I already said that our current understanding of space time seems to had a beginning but that doesn't tell us anything about the beginning or the "time" or physics "before". I don't want to repeat ms but it seems like your understanding of cosmology is very limited. you didn't answer my question and made again already disputed claims.
but let's go there anyways. first there aren't even close to a thousend prophecies in the bible and the fulfilled once are not even close to impressive. mainly because they don't give a accurate or detailed description of the events and they are not timely limited. not a single one says for example on january 12th 2121 at 12 a.m. the earth stops to rotate for 2 min. if that would happen at that exact time that would be impressive but nothing in the bible comes even close to this.
there are no witnesses that saw jesus there are only reports about witnesses in the bible but thats about it. you have to look outside the bible for evidence. a starting point would be the Roman empire which existed before, during and after Jesus. fun fact: there is not a single piece of evidence that suggest that a rabbi named jesus performed any miracles. there is more evidence that Buddha existed then Jesus and Buddha lived 500 years before Jesus. read into that!!!!
and these scientific facts about there order of our universe are objectively wrong. the order in genesis is wrong and has been proven to be different.
i hope that helps
@Caleb Xantho I am not a hypocrite. you 're just like grace you don't really read my awnsers... I never once said that the universe is eternal I was just stating the obvious that we don't know. just read again and you 'll see that I never once claimed that the universe is eternal. I just said that we (humans) have no knowledge about the "before" or if a "before" even makes sense.
and now to your probability claim of god. generally speaking there is a rule to this kind of claims. it's: "probability needs to be demonstrated". if you can't demonstrate your probability then there is no probability that could be demonstrated and your argument is flawed.
but now I really do expect a probability and if you don't come up with any numbers you 're admitting that you never really calculated a probability. and the main reason why I want numbers is because you said: "mathematically you have a higher probability of having a god..."
I hope you read my comments again to see that I never once made a positive claim I was just stating the obvious flaws in graces and now in your arguments.
I hope that helps.
@Caleb Xantho The question of who made God can be answered by simply looking at space and asking, "Does space have an end?" Obviously, it doesn’t. If there is a brick wall with "The End" written on it, the question arises, "What is behind the brick wall?" Strain the mind though it may, we have to believe (have faith) that space has no beginning and no end. The same applies with God. He has no beginning and no end. He is eternal.
The Bible also informs us that time is a dimension that God created, into which man was subjected. It even tells us that one day time will no longer exist. That will be called "eternity." God Himself dwells outside of the dimension He created (2 Timothy 1:9, Titus 1:2). He dwells in eternity and is not subject to time. God spoke history before it came into being. He can move through time as a man flips through a history book.
So What if God is something?He is a supernatural being
Jezeus the greek god.
Jesus the great god.
His name was Yeshuah but ok 👀
He brings forth the living from the dead and brings forth the dead from the living, and gives life to the earth after its death, and thus shall you be brought forth.
And of His signs is this: He created you of dust, and behold you human beings, ranging widely!
And one of His signs is that He created mates for you from yourselves that you may find rest in them, and He put between you love and compassion; most surely there are signs in this for a people who reflect
And one of His signs is the creation of the heavens and the earth and the diversity of your tongues and colors; most surely there are signs in this for the learned.
And one of His signs is your sleeping and your seeking of His grace by night and (by) day; most surely there are signs in this for a people who would hear.
And one of His signs is that He shows you the lightning for fear and for hope, and sends down water from the clouds then gives life therewith to the earth after its death; most surely there are signs in this for a people who understand
And one of His signs is that the heaven and the earth subsist by His command, then when He calls you with a (single) call from out of the earth, lo! you come forth.
And His is whosoever is in the heavens and the earth; all are obedient to Him.
And He it is Who originates the creation, then reproduces it, and it is easy to Him; and His are the most exalted attributes in the heavens and the earth, and He is the Mighty, the Wise.
Al-Room verse 30 chapter 10 - 27
13:08 brilliant.
It takes guts to refute Stephen Hawking ❤❤❤❤❤❤
no. it takes to have a religious faith.
Hawking was media created "genius." He thought about black holes is whole life. A plumber adds more value to society.
Let me guess - You're a plumber...
Stephen hawking s arguments never go destroyed by john lennox
Haha, I've heard John Lennox misquote Stephan Hawking to prove his point. This was so intentionally done that it can only be interpreted as an intentional lie and deception. He doesn't deserve to talk about this great man.
10:38 😂
Right
Does Metaxas ever prepare himself properly?
If all things were in one singularity back in time 13,8 billion years ago, that does not mean nothing, that is all was superdense, and started expanding.
jesus greek name
Ok and where did that come from?Big Bang Theory is just creation.
My opinion is better than your opinion.
more like my logic is better than your nonsense
"Something can't create itself, but God can create himself." smh 🐂💩
😂😂😂
Fuck Organized Religions but he is the highest power
Ignorance God was, is and always will be. He has always been there is no beginning to Him, blessed be He for He has put upon us His mercy and only He will be praised by every nation and every tongue will proclaim that He is Lord and King of all. I offer you Salvation as I have been saved by the Lord Jesus Christ. Accept His love and let Him into your heart and He will offer you peace and love and everlasting life. He is great and kind to forgive us for our transgressions humble yourself and kneel before Him and let Him work through you and you will feel His love, the consuming fire will burn in your soul and when you feel it you won’t be able to contain yourself and proclaim His name. Accept Jesus as your Lord and Savior and you will be saved. Blessed be His name for all eternity.
don't you listen spiritual is not physical its not bound by time or matter. God was not created he had no beginning, he created the first trinity of trinity's the is the foundation of the creation of the universe . father + son + holy spirit...the original trinity. genesis 1 "in the beginning" {time} "God created the heavens" {space} "and the earth" {matter}… {time, space , matter} the trinity of the known universe and all must co- exist simultaneously in order for balance and existence as we know it. trinity of the trinity's {time =past - present - future} … {space = length - breadth - height}… {matter = solid - liquid - gas} they then break down into even more trinity's {atom = proton - neutron - electron} GOD had no beginning he created the beginning of everything outside of time . time and the laws of science are his creation he is not bound by it. open your heart even in the darkness of suffering and know the truth that is the light of Jesus who suffered on the cross so that he might meet you.
God didn't create Himself because He didn't have to because He has always existed, God is the un-created always-existing un-caused First Cause. It's not that hard to grasp if you get off your atheistic high horse.
No body think John Lennox is smarter than HAWKING
I do
@@skuzaposkuzapo56 facts i do too
Again, your using nothing& nobody inappropriately. Nobody is defined as; no person, no one. Since three people think Lennox is smarter; your whole theory is a proven fallacy. Unless, of course you meant to use nobody as a pronoun, in that case, your statement is subjective. I think he is smarter, but then again I am "nobody".
Nothing is defined as; not anything, no single thing.
Let me get this straight; you believe "nothing" came from "nothingness" from "imaginary time" before the "big bang"& insinuate those who believe in God as intellectually inferior? Ugh I have a headache.
Jebus vs Mohammed death battle
@@charissa6648
An god could be created from nothing? Yea. yea...
Simulations with calculations from quantum mechanics prove something can come from nothing, and particles do.
A man who discovered the secrets of black holes vs a religious fundamentalist who believes in talking snakes and demons and other superstitions.
John Lennox is a professor of mathematics at oxford university
@@Metalhead98793 Steven Hawking and Richard dawkins showed using math god kills 5 million innocent Christian children. And 5 million more non Christian.
If god existed that is
Phillip Abreo And if God existed, His own creation and what He does with it, along with the purpose the death of those children serve is non of human business. Stop applying mortal morality and judgment of flawed beings to an all knowing, all powerful perfect being. And in theology, death is a product of separation from the Creator, not a product of the Creator himself.
By the way, Hawking’s black hole theory is severely flawed in many of its principles. As Lennox stated here, nonsense is nonsense even if Stephen Hawking writes it.
Now about this god.... Where is it...?....
God is not material, is spiritual, so what are you actually asking?
Man says show me and I believe u
But God says believe me and I show
He loves u just ask him he cares
@@aniquiroga1814 Oh right - in other words --Imaginary!
@@kassoberano5793 gods do not exist! just imaginations...
@@briendoyle4680 what proves that he does not
destroyed?
I don't understand aby if theoretical physics, but I can recognize religious fundamentalist when I see one.
if prof. Lennox's counter-argument is "God is eternal (sic! yeah? says who? a man- made book) he is the ultimate reality (yeah? that nobody can see, hear, touch or smell?) the ultimate fact (an fact is supposed to be based on observations, isn't it, professor?) To ask who created him is to show that one does not understand the nature of his being (it is not matter of one's understanding, it is a matter of ones atheism or theism...)...
So, if all these are professor's argument, that professor is a genuine fundamentalist. luckily this is 21st centurty, so he cannot burn alive anyone. yet...