The BEST Form Of Creatine

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 янв 2025

Комментарии • 2 тыс.

  • @SeanNalewanyjShorts
    @SeanNalewanyjShorts  2 года назад +415

    💪 FOLLOW THESE 2 STEPS TO MAXIMIZE YOUR RESULTS:
    1️⃣ Get your FREE training and nutrition plan from me by pressing the yellow profile icon above then clicking the link in bio.
    2️⃣ Check out my no B.S supplement line over at RealScienceAthletics.com (link also in bio) and use code YT10 to save 10% on your first order.
    ✅ Follow on IG for more daily tips: @sean_nalewanyj
    P.S. If you signed up for a free plan and didn't receive it, check your junk/bulk folder. If it's not there then contact info[at]seannal[dot]com to have it re-sent.

    • @rondoespsych5901
      @rondoespsych5901 2 года назад +2

      Hey Sean, great content man! Would you do a video on "fortetropin?" Im hearing it has promising results, is all natural, cheap and derived from eggs. I was wondering your take and if you think it's worth it.
      Thanks man!

    • @OokamiKageGinGetsu
      @OokamiKageGinGetsu 2 года назад +1

      The only problem I have with creatine monohydrate is that it gives me gas. I still use it though. I get on the leg press and fart like a steam engine locomotive picking up speed.

    • @Brian_Tabor
      @Brian_Tabor 2 года назад

      Seems like something that would only be useful if you were having digestive problems had extra money and wanted to cut the volume going into your body. I think they're conflating bloating. With feeling overly full.

    • @humblemally
      @humblemally 2 года назад

      Tips on being natural and trying losing your gut

    • @doomguyPk3
      @doomguyPk3 2 года назад

      This might be a wired question, but does it matter what age you are in order to take creatine?🤨

  • @p0k3mn1
    @p0k3mn1 6 месяцев назад +2631

    “Causes less water retention”
    That like is the entire point of creatine.

    • @jonathanwilliams7920
      @jonathanwilliams7920 5 месяцев назад +18

      I think its loading phase is easier on the gut and body.

    • @Vlek
      @Vlek 5 месяцев назад +28

      Nah it isnt, its nice but you take it for the extra peak energy and muscle growth and mental buffs
      If you just take it for water retention there are much better things for that lol

    • @jonathanwilliams7920
      @jonathanwilliams7920 5 месяцев назад +36

      @@Vlek what energy? What mental buffs?

    • @Vlek
      @Vlek 5 месяцев назад

      @@jonathanwilliams7920 look up the effects of creatine, i cant summarise it well

    • @Dumbbelldore
      @Dumbbelldore 4 месяца назад +50

      ​@@Vlek It's not just water retention, it's water retention on the muscles. Differente of getting water retention in the whole body

  • @raptorunhinged2400
    @raptorunhinged2400 2 года назад +16067

    This is one of the reasons why it felt so hard for me to start my fitness journey years ago. There were always so many conflicting opinions and not all of them were equal. Wish I had had Sean’s channel when I was more of a noob.

    • @raghavshukla5255
      @raghavshukla5255 2 года назад +279

      THAT's JUST AN EXCUSE ISN'T IT?I STARTED WORKING OUT WITH WRONG INFORMATION TOO,ALL YOU NEED IS EXPERIENCE AND SOME EFFORTS.

    • @jacob6068
      @jacob6068 2 года назад +959

      @@raghavshukla5255 OK DUDE THANK YOU VERY MUCH

    • @RGV2300
      @RGV2300 2 года назад +47

      In that case, just take advice from limited resources as taking info from many can be overwhelming. Same with anything to be honest.

    • @insertname6521
      @insertname6521 2 года назад +65

      This is probably the worst excuse I’ve ever heard just stick to the basics and you’ll figure it out on your own

    • @nadine2185
      @nadine2185 2 года назад +65

      @@raghavshukla5255 ok grandpa.

  • @bruhmane1944
    @bruhmane1944 2 года назад +7196

    *Sees Gymshark clothes*
    -Yeah say no more 😑

    • @cristianpuiu2327
      @cristianpuiu2327 2 года назад +276

      That dude was making pretty funny videos in the past last time I checked his channel. I don't know what he does now. Hope he doesn't only do this.

    • @tdot33367
      @tdot33367 2 года назад +62

      @@cristianpuiu2327 exactly, i watched him like 4-5 months ago and he was alright. I remembered him bcs i thought he looked like Aaron Gordon

    • @AD-ui6sk
      @AD-ui6sk 2 года назад +125

      @@cristianpuiu2327 started getting sponsored money offers and switched up

    • @keilinx
      @keilinx 2 года назад +52

      I once bought Gymshark briefs. It turned into a parachute after washing lol

    • @internetdude1233
      @internetdude1233 2 года назад +1

      They have a bad reputation? My brother has some

  • @christopherduncan6630
    @christopherduncan6630 Год назад +828

    And as a general rule, never trust anyone who dry-scoops anything.

    • @juju958
      @juju958 Год назад +21

      No, don’t trust anyone trying to sell you something.

    • @Cassius-m5v
      @Cassius-m5v Год назад +69

      @@juju958 never trust a dry scooper either my friend, it’s literally less effective than just mixing it up to drink, it doesn’t kick in quicker like most say

    • @rb0460
      @rb0460 11 месяцев назад +5

      Anyone that needs to take a scoop of powder before they hit the gym ain't natural lol

    • @geoffkaminski
      @geoffkaminski 11 месяцев назад +32

      ​@9DIME nah dry scooping is the way to go bc the shit doesn't dissolve in water, it's like drinking water with sand in it

    • @SonGoku5363
      @SonGoku5363 11 месяцев назад +16

      would you rather eat sand directly or drink water with sand in it?@@geoffkaminski

  • @spongSyt
    @spongSyt 2 месяца назад +13

    Ah yes, the classic “make up a problem and then solve that problem with a more expensive product” business strategy. Works like a charm

  • @railgun1258
    @railgun1258 2 года назад +960

    I find it hilarious that dude literally got his points from the bottle.

    • @wolvreigns
      @wolvreigns 2 года назад +28

      And this guy just says trust me. A lot of comments are actually backing the other one being easier on their stomachs so it isnt bullshit.

    • @cantthinkofnameyeah7249
      @cantthinkofnameyeah7249 Год назад

      This youtuber has no clue what he's talking about the and he believes what he's saying. He doesn't even realize monohydrate doesn't mix as well, making the powder bottom out in your blender bottle and also your kidneys (kidney stones exist). Also since you need to take more powder you are forcing your kidneys to do more filtration than with hcl. Monohydrate is just worse in every way other than the fact it is more researched. Other than being more researched monohydrate is worse in every way.

    • @jondoe4664
      @jondoe4664 7 месяцев назад +3

      It's an ad.

  • @Mr.E6969
    @Mr.E6969 2 года назад +35

    Chemistry Major Here: The HCL form of pretty much any molecule that can be crystallized is going to be stronger and more concentrated than a hydrate form of the same molecule. Hydrates are compounds that have a very small amount of water molecules that get "trapped" inside the crystallized compound as it forms, whereas the HCL form of the same molecule is extracted using Hydrochloric Acid, (hence the HCL) which is then purged and crystallized in a much higher concentration. So technically speaking the creatine HCL form is in fact more concentrated than creatine monohydrate, but the most important thing to consider in this instance is bioavailability.
    Your body is only capable of taking in a certain percentage of a specific nutrient at any given time, so if creatine monohydrate falls within your bioavailability threshold, then taking anything more is just a waste.
    Hope that helps 👍

    • @catalyst_1007
      @catalyst_1007 Год назад +3

      damn bruv was that ez to learn?

    • @Mr.E6969
      @Mr.E6969 Год назад +7

      @@catalyst_1007 A lot of calculus, a lot of BS prerequisite classes, and a lot of headaches lol but yeah, for the most part it was pretty easy to learn. I learned all of this in my first two years at community college, but I've always been passionate about chemistry so learning about it all was super exciting for me!

    • @angel-wq6mx
      @angel-wq6mx Год назад +2

      @@Mr.E6969 thanks doc

    • @randywatson341
      @randywatson341 3 месяца назад

      Thanks for that info. Is it fair to say 1.5g of creatine HCL is about the same effect at 5g of creatine? So about a 3:1 ratio give or take. If that's true, HCl's "breakeven" price should be about 3x as expensive per gram as monohydrate right? Curious if that's roughly how I should be thinking about it.

    • @davidoryiman2398
      @davidoryiman2398 9 дней назад

      Bro speak English please

  • @mayssm
    @mayssm 2 года назад +2015

    It's not just supplement companies. The entire US pharmaceutical industry is pretty much based on this concept. Tweak it a little bit, or combine two medicines into one and then pay doctors to push it on patients, even though it costs 100x more than the generic version or the two uncombined medicines it was based on.

    • @1brunner699
      @1brunner699 2 года назад +6

      Just posted something similar.

    • @ghostflame9211
      @ghostflame9211 2 года назад +55

      Facts. I used to work in a retail pharmacy, and one of the most common blood pressure meds was the losartan-hydrochlorothiazide combo. But someone could easily take a losartan tablet and an HCTZ tablet and be fine, at a fraction of the cost.

    • @EvaLasta
      @EvaLasta 2 года назад +1

      @@ghostflame9211 was it a compound pharmacy?

    • @silverfang4583
      @silverfang4583 2 года назад +2

      It's actually more commonly the reverse, they give you a combined option that is cheaper but the premium is the lure version of one of those chemicals.
      Like codeine, people pay more for pure codeine because well you can sell that shit

    • @agnidas5816
      @agnidas5816 2 года назад

      or that you could reverse the disease by spending LESS on food
      Check out Undo It by Drs Ornish.

  • @jacksonherritage2716
    @jacksonherritage2716 2 года назад +313

    Pro tip: forget the creatine and just drink undiluted hydrochloric acid

    • @FirstnameLastname-yc2mt
      @FirstnameLastname-yc2mt 7 месяцев назад +4

      .... Does that work??..

    • @71Million
      @71Million 7 месяцев назад +32

      @@FirstnameLastname-yc2mt bro it’s like double the effectiveness

    • @drakegriffith938
      @drakegriffith938 6 месяцев назад +22

      @@71Million yup, gains 700lbs of pure muscle mass after downing a whole box of Duracell AAs. Works like a charm

    • @Arty-j4t
      @Arty-j4t 5 месяцев назад +9

      Yeah you can gain mass in your next life 😂😂

    • @GodSpeed1105
      @GodSpeed1105 4 месяца назад +6

      It worked, For me my legs didn't grow too much like the rest of my body but I did start growing another 2 legs. Gonna see how it goes.

  • @redfishbluefish4973
    @redfishbluefish4973 9 месяцев назад +3

    I’m not arguing against Sean, but I will tell you what my personal experience was. I had been taking monohydrate for a long time, but GNC had a promotion where I could get a 120 serving container of HCL for free with the purchase of two protein tubs (which I was there to get anyway). So I tried it. I figured it would have the same results, but what I experienced was:
    1: Faster gains
    2: Less bloating
    3: No cramping whatsoever
    I got it again next time there was a promotion, thereby also making it cheaper. The faster gains sounds exaggerated, but I promise it was no placebo effect. I keep a daily exercise journal going back many, many years. My progression definitely sped up.

  • @Mr_NB628
    @Mr_NB628 2 года назад +103

    For me, personally, creatine monohydrate causes stomach issues. I have taken it apart from anything else and about 30 minutes later there are stomach issues. Creatine HCl, while crazy bitter, does not give me those issues. I wish monohydrate didn’t either. I will be trying monohydrate again to confirm because I haven’t had mono hydrate in 10 years

    • @BogdanPW641
      @BogdanPW641 2 года назад

      try some other creaitne monohydrate.You need to find one who is good for u

    • @Mr_NB628
      @Mr_NB628 2 года назад +5

      @@BogdanPW641 Yes, once I am through my HCl I’m going to try regular monohydrate again because I would absolutely love to be able to use that over HCl just because it’s way cheaper and it doesn’t make a drink more sour

    • @skellybonz5467
      @skellybonz5467 2 года назад +1

      try and drink more water

    • @juwo7569
      @juwo7569 Год назад

      fix your gut with probiotics. stop taking antibiotics, stop eating GMO food, stop eating transfats (high omega 6 inflammitory garbage vegetable oils like they use at mcdonalds canola oil , soybean oil etc) stop eating conventional sugar , stop eating conventional chicken breast (they are fed antibiotics same goes for other meat that comes from unhealthy animals) , stop eating farmed fish (fed antibiotics go wild caught always) stop eating agrochemical pesticide garbage its bad for the gut and irritates the gut alot. if you fix your gut you could handle the creatine which is naturally found in meat. sauerkraut, water kefir, milk kefir would be very good to consume on a regular basis with ongoing gut issues.

    • @kingcreed348
      @kingcreed348 Год назад

      If you're a regular person, and take it either with pwo or protein powder, it's because it's just adding to the overall content of the drink. I used to mix it with my pwo but it was just too heavy on my stomach, so now, I just dry scoop creatine.

  • @Deusaga
    @Deusaga 2 года назад +43

    Bloating and cramping is not made up. Creatine Mono can cause bloating because it sits in the digestive tract for some time while the system struggles to digest it.
    You can completely bypass this issue by putting your creatine in something warm, like a tea, coffee, hot chocolate etc. Don't spend extra money on some other scrappy creatine. Just chuck it in your coffee.

    • @juwo7569
      @juwo7569 Год назад

      or fix your gut issues with probiotics and stop eating so much processed food full of agrochemicals that stresses the gut. alot of people with IBS nowadays because of themself its all the transfat vegetable oils, GMO's , antibiotics from foods causing it.

    • @Bigbiceps301
      @Bigbiceps301 4 месяца назад

      I’ve been getting so many cramps taking creatine monohydrate but don’t want to lose strength if i stop taking it what do i do

    • @badgaming921
      @badgaming921 3 месяца назад +4

      I dissolve my (generous) 5g scoop into a full liter of water. Haven't had any GI issues since I started doing that.

    • @Passypass4
      @Passypass4 3 месяца назад +3

      Everyones body reacts differently. I have been using creatine mono for about 26 yrs and have never had any issues of bloating and at times I have taken more then the normal 5 MG dose.

    • @nathanclaspell6003
      @nathanclaspell6003 3 месяца назад +2

      Occasionally I'll get a little bloat, but I think that it's just a full tummy from chugging water. It also helps to not drink it on a totally empty stomach.

  • @pj9241
    @pj9241 Год назад +16

    Sometimes HCL is cheaper now. I like mono but I just get what’s on sale

  • @ArmanGT
    @ArmanGT 9 месяцев назад +7

    i wish the popular fitness youtubers would address a lot of people who try creatine monohydrate and get bloated and not shrug it off
    ive been maintained at 185 for 12 years and as soon as i start creatine monohydrate, i shot up to 190 in a week and a half on only 5g/day and most of it going to my abdomen. there are a shit load of stories from ppl saying this..if its so well studied then why arent there a lot of studies on the bloating?

  • @bobyg6365
    @bobyg6365 2 года назад +152

    I really appreciate what this man is doing, and I prioritize many of the things he says, I've liked so many of his videos to keep the information in mind
    I appreciate the No BS Tips my guy

    • @cantthinkofnameyeah7249
      @cantthinkofnameyeah7249 Год назад

      Hcl does cause bloating for people, thats a long proven fact. Hes spoon feeding you bs

  • @Taylaw21
    @Taylaw21 2 года назад +52

    From my experience hcl is much easier on my stomach, while having same level of results.

    • @FirstnameLastname-yc2mt
      @FirstnameLastname-yc2mt 7 месяцев назад +1

      How do you know how well it's working???

    • @lukasbirkmann3240
      @lukasbirkmann3240 6 месяцев назад

      Tecnically HCl is Hydrochloric acid and shouldn’t be consumend but if your stomach is fine go ahead😂

    • @NicolasMorus
      @NicolasMorus 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@lukasbirkmann3240what do you think the acid in the stomach is made of?

    • @unnamedunbekannt1691
      @unnamedunbekannt1691 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@lukasbirkmann3240 your stomach acid is HCl, it is all a matter of concentration. Of course consuming highly concentrated acid is bad, but creatine HCl isn't that.

    • @NCSSoundScapes
      @NCSSoundScapes 4 месяца назад

      Easier on your stomach? If water with creatine in it messes up your stomach you must have the the weakest stomach known to man

  • @VikingSloth
    @VikingSloth 2 года назад +218

    Creatine monohydrate does actually bloat me though and HCL doesn't. I'm not taking any creatine for the moment, but it's the main reason why if I was using creatine, it would be HCL and not monohydrate, regardless of the cost increase per serving

    • @blackhammerftw1960
      @blackhammerftw1960 2 года назад +19

      Ik that’s what I was gonna say I retained like 5 - 7 pounds of water weight on creatine

    • @isaac.schultz
      @isaac.schultz 2 года назад +30

      Yeah monohydrate gave me intense pain. Like it was terrible. HCL was much much better for me

    • @cxg101
      @cxg101 2 года назад +11

      I basically get a balloon for a face on monohydrate so I use creapure instead, maybe I’ll check out HCL next time

    • @macd1327
      @macd1327 2 года назад +9

      @@cxg101 fuck I notice my face too I stopped man not worth it I’d rather a cut face looks better

    • @jamesbaka1206
      @jamesbaka1206 2 года назад +10

      Exactly that’s what I’m saying. In my personal experience the difference between HCL and Mono was very noticeable. I’d never go back to mono personally

  • @theresaferreira8485
    @theresaferreira8485 2 года назад +1

    Mono hydrate effects my stomach negatively and I’m sensitive with absorption issues and specific protein allergens, so hcl doesn’t do that it’s legit a great option for people like me

  • @curtiskelly6553
    @curtiskelly6553 10 месяцев назад +2

    We'll hcl works great for me. It doesn't leave me looking fat. I look shredded on the hcl💪

    • @Baker19911
      @Baker19911 10 месяцев назад

      So it doesn’t prevent the bloating?

    • @curtiskelly6553
      @curtiskelly6553 10 месяцев назад

      @@Baker19911 I Don't get bloated on it if I'm working out at least 3 days a week.

  • @energy_sword4560
    @energy_sword4560 2 года назад +405

    Even if hcl gives you better results, i would still stick with monohydrate because it's the most researched suplement in the world.

    • @naufalilyasa1607
      @naufalilyasa1607 2 года назад +22

      yeah me too, and it's cheaper. doesn't cost lot of money

    • @hoesseinh8346
      @hoesseinh8346 2 года назад +5

      There's also the fact that HCL is literally hydrochloric acid. DO NOT consume hydrochloric acid

    • @newuser689
      @newuser689 2 года назад +22

      @@hoesseinh8346 if that mattered people would notice brah

    • @invertexyz
      @invertexyz 2 года назад +44

      It's still the same supplement, you're promoting a bit of scientific ignorance here. This is just a difference in what the creatine itself is bound to. Monohydrates are simply bulkier but a cheaper stabilization and anti-clumping method. Both forms still break down in your digestive system to pure creatine and then absorbed into the bloodstream.

    • @onionman8160
      @onionman8160 2 года назад +22

      @@hoesseinh8346 No, it's creatine bonded to hydrogen chloride. Hydrochloric acid is pure HCL dissolved in water.

  • @StruggleEndure
    @StruggleEndure 7 месяцев назад +3

    Monohydrate makes me bloated and constipated

  • @daexmachinus
    @daexmachinus 2 года назад +7

    One reason to pay the premium is that since the dosage is less, it’s pretty good for travel since most creatine HCL packaging comes in a small jar. Would rather pay extra to lug that around than than a large tub of monohydrate that TSA is gonna pull me outta line for

    • @maddiebear7166
      @maddiebear7166 Год назад

      Majority aren’t traveling with their supplements. Even if you are you could put some in a small bag wow. Whatever works.

    • @randywatson341
      @randywatson341 3 месяца назад +1

      Agree, that's the only reason I use HCl. I use monohydrate when not traveling. Is there any case for HCl when not traveling? It's a lot more expensive for an equivalent dose, I find.

  • @Zion7HS
    @Zion7HS Год назад +2

    I mean to be honest though regular mono definitely causes bloating for many people (including myself). So it's not fair to say it's just a "made up" problem with an imaginary fix, it's a real thing and HCL does fix it :/

  • @Liza.Wharton
    @Liza.Wharton 10 месяцев назад

    you are truly a beacon of light in the business of conning people

  • @hoobertoober1655
    @hoobertoober1655 2 года назад +100

    So I can attest to regular creatine monohydrate giving me an upset stomach. Now I could normally get around it by always eating something with it, but I did find that HCL didn't mess my stomach up. It's literally a personal preference for me, and at the end of the day, supplements are just that. To supplement what you should already be getting from food.

    • @d1rt_baggg
      @d1rt_baggg 2 года назад +2

      How much water are you drinking?

    • @skellybonz5467
      @skellybonz5467 2 года назад

      drink more water bro.

    • @hoobertoober1655
      @hoobertoober1655 2 года назад +2

      @@d1rt_baggg I drink a lot of water, I know that's not my issue. Especially when I have my camel back, I would have about 2 a day minimum, sometimes more if I'm out and about in the heat. But because regular monohydrate isn't water soluble it can cause issues for some people. I'm just unlucky in that group is all. If it doesn't give you issues then hey more power to you, but for me and others it just sucks is all.

    • @johankaruyan5536
      @johankaruyan5536 Год назад

      ​@@hoobertoober1655u drink 2 cups of water, a day ? Bruh

    • @juwo7569
      @juwo7569 Год назад

      must be gut inflammation in general , too many people nowadays have messed up guts and they lack probiotics and they take antibiotics which destroys the gut or they eat terrible processed food full of pesticides, toxic transfats, GMO's , bad hormones , and even antibiotics from unhealthy animals that were fed antibiotics because they were too sick from not eating their organic diet and being caged up . take alot more probiotic food and go organic on as much as you can to avoid agrochemicals because they stress the gut . too much people are vitamin and mineral deficient nowadays thats why they have insulin resistance and all these gut problems for no reason its their own fault the IBS and stuff@@hoobertoober1655

  • @mr.knewyork5843
    @mr.knewyork5843 2 года назад +11

    Sean I just wanna say you're doing good work here, I'm a new gym dude and I appreciate you looking out for us, keep up the good work

  • @escoffeepot
    @escoffeepot 2 года назад +222

    I love how he said being more water soluble helps digestion. U could eat dirt and your stomach acid would dissolve it not saying, u should, but there's tons of medication that's not well dissolvable in water but that doesn't matter because water has barely anything to do with digestion.

    • @Velzizar
      @Velzizar 2 года назад +20

      medication is almost always in the form of salts to give it better bioavailability tho. just because you have stomach acid and what not doesn't mean you dissolve everything and anything. And water solubility is actually important, as is pH. Still, you can't compare solubility of medication and solubility of supplements, because medication(usually) is needed as quickly as possible and in higher % of the consumed quantity in your blood, because of pharmacokinetics, while even if you take a supplement with 10% bioavailability you could take like 10 tablets to reach the dose of a 100% bioavailable supplement and there wouldn't be any problem, because you don't really need it asap and the "therapeutic" window in most supplements is much wider than the therapeutic window in medicine

    • @ChristAcolyte
      @ChristAcolyte 2 года назад +18

      Solubility has a lot to do with the absorption of WATER SOLUBLE NUTRIENTS. It's in the name. Just take your creatine with hot water.

    • @bobert8125
      @bobert8125 2 года назад +3

      @@ChristAcolyte you don't get that that just means your cup of water will absorb it better right? not that your body absorbs it better because of the water. like dude said water isn't what helps you digest.

    • @vanyel_etc8695
      @vanyel_etc8695 2 года назад +1

      @@ChristAcolyte or take your creatine with food like a protein shake, so your body is actually breaking down real macros and micros alongside the creatine.

    • @evh3811
      @evh3811 2 года назад

      @@bobert8125 but that is what causes some people gastric distress when powder is being broken down in the stomach vs liquid

  • @Sahxocnsba
    @Sahxocnsba Год назад

    I appreciate your honesty Sean. You literally have a stake in this market, and you're making sure people DONT get ripped off, when you could join them and make more money just to get richer, faster. I so very much appreciate you being honest and doing good for the community. You do what's right and tell it like it is. I fuckin dig it!

  • @GrimwoodHorror
    @GrimwoodHorror 2 месяца назад

    One of the few helpful guys on the web

  • @FirstLast-us6hi
    @FirstLast-us6hi 2 года назад +29

    You should do one of these but let him finish. Then at the end just say “It’s the same fucking thing” and end the video.

    • @onionman8160
      @onionman8160 2 года назад +7

      Or actually explain why you shouldn't listen to him. Just saying "no" isn't an argument.

    • @vanyel_etc8695
      @vanyel_etc8695 2 года назад +2

      @@onionman8160 it is when it comes to people lying. This isn't a debate, creatine monohydrate does not cause water retention and bloating. This has been proven in multiple studies. Leave the well formed arguments for debates, not for responding to anti-science.

    • @Gripdoctor
      @Gripdoctor 2 года назад

      @@onionman8160 cool name

    • @onionman8160
      @onionman8160 2 года назад

      @@Gripdoctor Bro wtf

    • @liamnicholson9464
      @liamnicholson9464 2 года назад

      @@Gripdoctor 🧅

  • @1brunner699
    @1brunner699 2 года назад +145

    I am a pharmacist and see this all the time. Pharmaceutical companies play similar tricks with prescription drugs. For example the medication Wellbutrin initially came out decades ago as an immediate release tablet that needed to be dosed three times per day due to having a short half-life. Then before the patent expires the drug company releases it as an SR (sustained-release) tablet that can be dosed twice daily. Then a few years later they do it again and call it Wellbutrin XL which is now dosed once daily. One way to take the same exact same drug and extend their patent to continue making a profit on it. Sure it does improve compliance when the patient only needs to take one dose per day instead of three but why not develop that formulation initially? Answer: $$$

    • @orangecat5036
      @orangecat5036 2 года назад +5

      They experiment with patients with out the patients even knowing I'was on psychotic med's for year's and caught onto the trick's doctor's play with patients. they pressure the patient to switch med's then they ask questions later.

    • @johnmorgan2619
      @johnmorgan2619 2 года назад

      @@orangecat5036 💥👍

    • @invertexyz
      @invertexyz 2 года назад +2

      At least extended release has some usage. Another even dirtier tactic they'll use is bind something inert or digestible to the drug that gets cleaved off in digestion. They can patent this as a new drug because the chemical structure has technically changed, but the drug itself is actually still the same shit once it gets to your blood stream.

    • @dee_petrik
      @dee_petrik 2 года назад +2

      Oh you’re a pharmacist??? Name every drug

    • @Melvin_499
      @Melvin_499 2 года назад

      @@dee_petrik lol

  • @hugechimp
    @hugechimp 3 месяца назад +3

    CON-CRET is Bad Ass. Used for years. More $ but if you can afford, the way to go..Based on my personal experience, you got this wrong.

  • @dfh291
    @dfh291 2 года назад +1

    Pharmaceutical chemist here, the HCl formulation does bypass a lot of the negative effects because you have to take less, so it means it is absorbed better, meaning it has higher bioavailability. Besides supplementary creatine is not needed to build muscle mass.

  • @jerrysartain2539
    @jerrysartain2539 Год назад +2

    Thanks for all your great advice, much appreciated.....Jerry,London

  • @RancidRiki
    @RancidRiki 2 года назад +9

    Creatine hcl was actually cheaper per serving in the place where i bought it

    • @RancidRiki
      @RancidRiki 2 года назад +2

      @@mareanie5998 i mean in my local supplement store, mono was 30CAD at 60 servings and hcl was 40CAD at 250 servings. Hcl was basically a bargain price and with a smaller tub top

    • @km-kx3te
      @km-kx3te 2 года назад

      @@RancidRiki damn must be nice to have that. You won't be able to find any hcl for that price and servings in my country

  • @EvaLasta
    @EvaLasta 2 года назад +778

    Monohydrate actually gives me insane stomach problems so I have to take hydrochloride so its definitely not BS

  • @v.567
    @v.567 2 года назад +22

    POV: You've never taken a Chemistry class.
    Creatine monohydrate and creatine HCl is pretty much the same as long as gym people are concerned.

    • @yerpster
      @yerpster Год назад

      Never did🤪🇨🇳

    • @Smoshylife
      @Smoshylife 7 месяцев назад +1

      Who are you arguing with? No ones denying that.

  • @InfinityGrappling
    @InfinityGrappling Год назад

    Sean’s channel = no bs fitness tips.
    Thanks again

  • @Uprising771
    @Uprising771 2 года назад +1

    Sean you are awesome. ive been reading your articles since 2010. you are one of the only people in fitness who doesnt scam people

  • @bransonaverett3817
    @bransonaverett3817 2 года назад +20

    I personally like HCL the best. It cost the same as monohydrate for the same amount of servings. I felt noticeably more energetic during my workouts and also did notice less cramping. Some may argue bs but I personally felt a difference when taking HCL and think it’s worth trying. I’m currently on monohydrate but will be trying HCL once it’s back in stock at my local sporting goods store.

    • @julianjimenez4051
      @julianjimenez4051 2 года назад

      Just picked some up don't forget to price match! Got mine for 50% off

    • @juwo7569
      @juwo7569 Год назад

      cramping comes from magnesium, potassium deficiency youre low on electrolytes is what it means.

    • @User_92020
      @User_92020 Год назад +1

      I just checked online right now and I have to agreed with you!
      Hcl and monohydrate cost the same!!
      Sean give Bullshit advice once again.

  • @jonchippure52
    @jonchippure52 2 года назад +36

    If you find that creatine monohydrate worsens acne, creatine HCl could be a decent alternative. It is similar effectiveness to normal creatine and not that much more expensive.
    Id recommend trying to wash your bedsheets and pillowcases before you blame creatine but it could be a factor!

    • @puppieslovies
      @puppieslovies 2 года назад +2

      Yeah and if you're pushing a new diet really heavily then it could also be that
      Look at every change you make and try to figure out what helps and what doesn't

    • @jimbo9661
      @jimbo9661 2 года назад +3

      And wash your hair after every gym session

    • @juwo7569
      @juwo7569 Год назад

      its the conventional chicken breast and conventional garbage protein powders giving them acne its inflammitory and toxic. zinc deficiency causes acne breakouts. people that get alot of acne better avoid bad dairy that comes from unhealthy animals and avoid high omega 6 vegetable oils like canola oil and soybean oil this will defiently create acne instantly

    • @Lapinettepetitbébé
      @Lapinettepetitbébé 9 месяцев назад

      ​@@jimbo9661i am a woman, i can't wash my hair every day...

  • @joebrutocao9748
    @joebrutocao9748 2 года назад +5

    I actually agree with the no bloating part. I started on HCL and then switched to monohydrate and couldn’t take it. I have a sensitive gut so maybe it doesn’t matter for most people.

    • @1Jack1daniels
      @1Jack1daniels Год назад

      Hi man, I have a similar problem too with stomach bloating which is why I’ve been afraid to take creatine. Would you say that the HCL creatine caused no side effects compared to the mono? Including things like diarrhoea and cramping?

  • @JDucks77
    @JDucks77 2 года назад

    You saving lives

  • @jeremyp6161
    @jeremyp6161 Месяц назад

    I love your no BS content. Just a note, totally anecdotal but I know a bunch of folks with stomach issues who had trouble with monohydrate but not HCl, myself included. I realize this wasn't shown in studies but just worth noting.

  • @epic_troll_3418
    @epic_troll_3418 2 года назад +6

    You only need to take a teaspoon of creatine daily. That dude literally had a tablespoon in his hand

    • @temporarymonk4022
      @temporarymonk4022 2 года назад

      This has very recently been proven otherwise.
      Height, weight and metabolism has a big effect on needs.
      It's now been recommended to take 10g for the average person.
      This is as a result of someone who is 6'4 200lbs actually needing as much as 15g for optimal effects.

    • @epic_troll_3418
      @epic_troll_3418 2 года назад +2

      @@temporarymonk4022 show me the facts

  • @StabyMcStabsFace
    @StabyMcStabsFace 2 года назад +1

    Solving fake problems is 90% of modern marketing and engineering.

  • @slither7152
    @slither7152 Год назад +4

    I think people don’t truly understand what creatine is and how it works creatine is a natural thing your body already makes and is used in the production of atp when a muscle contracts a neuron fires causing many steps I don’t want to explain and towards the end it releases calcium which attaches to your muscle and the old atp pulls your muscle causing it to contract and new atp let’s you release which is why when you have low calcium water potassium you are prone to cramps because your body isn’t able to let go so you stay cramped I don’t understand this notion of creatine makes you look bigger it just helps you make more atp which in turn helps you work out for longer which makes you build more muscle

  • @StrengthOfADragon13
    @StrengthOfADragon13 2 года назад +21

    I switched to creatine HCL because it dissolves easier, monohydrate kept giving me the feeling of having sand in my teeth for the whole day

    • @badcrysis1349
      @badcrysis1349 Год назад

      Probably used to much, it's like sugar and water the more sugar you put in a glass of water the more you gotta stir it and will take longer to dissolve
      This happened to me years ago I mixed to much protein in my water and hours later still could feel powder in my mouth

  • @15.tom_74
    @15.tom_74 6 месяцев назад

    I like this guy he knows what he talks about keep up the good work 👍🏻

  • @monkeyboy018
    @monkeyboy018 2 года назад +1

    Want to reduce stomach discomfort with creatine? Disolve if fully in warm water (not hot), and don't mix it in cold water. If you want to drink it cold you can add ice and it won't fall out of solution. If it's not disolving add more water. If you want to drink it with Gatorade then it'll take longer, but the time to dissolve can be decreased by drinking room temperature Gatorade (yuck). Also make sure it's micronized creatine monohydrate. It disolves quicker.
    I mix mine with my morning water bottle. I add 5g to 1L of room temperature water. It takes about an hour and a half to disolve completely. It doesn't actually matter when you take your creatine, just that you take it.
    *Skip this next part if you aren't interested in learning about the physiology and pharmacology*
    Creatine monohydrate is available as a granulated powder. It's crystals are white and slightly translucent. When added to water it disolves very slowly.
    Creatine isn't very soluble or stable in water. At 8H you've lost 5% and at 24H you've lost 20% of the creatine just by it breaking down in the water.
    Here's the life of creatine when you injest this power when dispersed (not disolved) in water and why it causes GI discomfort. Creatine hits the stomach where its nitrogen components are protonated. This doesn't really have much of an effect on the actual protein as it is too small to fold anyway. It is then moved along the GI tract. The undisolved crystals are completely happy remaining undisolved, but their presence alone draws water from inside your body into the intestinal tract. Your body doesn't like this. This increased water content in your gut causes that uncomfortable bloated feeling. After the creatine is disolved in your gut it can then be absorbed by your body. You don't end up losing any water because it is reabsorbed in the large intestine. Disolving the creatine completely before consumption reduces this bloated feeling.
    *End physiology and pharmacology*
    Another option is to try not loading. You don't need to load at like 10g/day to see the full benefit of creatine, it just makes you reach full saturation quicker. That excessively high dose is what's causing the discomfort. You're going to be taking it forever anyway, so it's better to just take it at a normal dose of 3-5g/day than to deal with the GI upset imo. It'll take about a month to reach full saturation vs. 2-3 weeks when you load, and loading doesn't provide any added benefits in strength or performance. Basically you'll see improvement in strength and performance in roughly 2-4 weeks regardless if you've achieved full saturation or not. If you're not seeing results with creatine it's for any of 3 reasons:
    1) you're not applying the concept of progressive overload appropriately. Increase the weights, and buckle down on your form. You want keep tension on the muscle for the entire lift and make sure you do not use momentum.
    2) you're a creatine non responder. Unfortunately you lost the genetic lottery. The great news is after around 6 months to 1 year you'll be in the same place as people who started with creatine anyway so all is not lost. Keep up with your program, apply the concepts of progressive overload properly, and trust the process. Keep on the grind.
    3) you got scammed and didn't actually buy creatine. Creatine is just a protein made of L-arginine, glycine, and L-methionine. You only want to see "Creatine Monohydrate" on the label with no other ingredients. If they break it down into those amino acids then it's not creatine. Change your supply. Only go for reputable brands with proven track records for honest labelling. If it's suspiciously cheep then chances are it's cut with something. Creatine has been going up in price substantially lately, so the risk of this happening is getting higher.

  • @markymark7531
    @markymark7531 2 года назад +6

    Whenever something works and isn't broken, just break it and charge more.

  • @monwhopperdopy1973
    @monwhopperdopy1973 2 года назад +4

    He couldn’t keep a straight face when the guy said HCL lol. Fr tho, I’m still not sure about taking creatine because of the digestive issues that may come with it as well as hair loss.

    • @9.5.9.5
      @9.5.9.5 2 года назад +6

      Misconceptions.

    • @ginseng2005
      @ginseng2005 2 года назад +5

      There is no digestion issues nor hair loss, its just a nutrient, and we find it in foods we eat.

    • @Dnite13
      @Dnite13 2 года назад +1

      I wouldn't worry

    • @triple_octopus
      @triple_octopus 2 года назад +1

      It only accelerates hair loss if you already have genetic hair loss but anything other than that is bs, best supplement ever

    • @Dnite13
      @Dnite13 2 года назад +2

      @@triple_octopus right lol, im already going bald so its no issue for me, plus bald people look great too

  • @Chris-ux7xb
    @Chris-ux7xb 2 года назад +4

    Just because he’s wearing gym shark doesn’t mean he’s wrong. Myself and many others in this comment section have also switched from monohydrate to HCL because of negative side effects that come from using monohydrate. I have never had any negative effects from HCL, I will never try monohydrate again

  • @BillySmith-np5zn
    @BillySmith-np5zn 2 месяца назад +1

    Me personally my stomach cramps up way more on monohydrate than hcl

  • @yvonnecasaus9925
    @yvonnecasaus9925 2 года назад +7

    Lol. “This is one common strategy that supplement companies do to increase their profits….”
    uh, that’s EXACTLY what our pharmaceutical companies does as well…AND our government!

    • @yvonnecasaus9925
      @yvonnecasaus9925 2 года назад

      @@TheJackOfAllTrades777 It’s still wrong. Even if everybody is doing it. But you’re right, people need to start thinking for themselves on all matter of things, instead of blindly believing the people trying to sell you something.

    • @mohammadmeu
      @mohammadmeu 2 года назад

      @@yvonnecasaus9925 I wonder if people are becoming more and more aware of these strategies that such corporates do, or are becoming easier to target..

    • @yvonnecasaus9925
      @yvonnecasaus9925 2 года назад

      @@mohammadmeu I think both are happening simultaneously

    • @marvin9860
      @marvin9860 2 года назад

      Go home Karin. This isn't Facebook

    • @dontgranme
      @dontgranme 2 года назад

      Yvonne you're drunk go home

  • @LoPan1985
    @LoPan1985 2 года назад +4

    I fell for it once! Never again! 🤦🏼

  • @bigphil9714
    @bigphil9714 2 года назад +5

    Was that geezer eating it dry???

  • @kingzeus129
    @kingzeus129 Год назад

    This man is looking out for all of us ❤ thank you.

  • @fernandoulate3975
    @fernandoulate3975 Год назад

    just hopped on💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿

  • @habbaticchio2468
    @habbaticchio2468 2 года назад +13

    Creatine mono hydrate does bloat you and cause water retention…. From my experience.

    • @michaelyocum7082
      @michaelyocum7082 2 года назад +1

      I need that water retention 💯

    • @joshuafeirreira4233
      @joshuafeirreira4233 2 года назад +2

      Monohydrate works very well but when I took it, my face blew up like a puffer fish! I’ve had chubby cheeks since I was a kid, I could be 4% body fat and would still have chubby cheeks but I noticed my cheeks got even bigger on mono. Don’t know why it affected me so much but after that I’ve just not taken any creatine since. HCL really is 2/3x more expensive, kinda crazy

  • @casualartist4202
    @casualartist4202 2 года назад +16

    “less bloating and water retention” bro the purpose of creatine is to hold more water in your muscles so they’re fuller and harder
    edit: also better performance

    • @benitocamela174
      @benitocamela174 2 года назад +1

      That is not at all the purpose of creatine, only the side effect..... unless you are solely taking creatine for that reason lol

    • @casualartist4202
      @casualartist4202 2 года назад

      @@benitocamela174 huh, i thought that was one of the uses of creatine besides the performance enhancing. don’t they increase muscle volume, strength, and rigidity? i may be wrong

    • @benitocamela174
      @benitocamela174 2 года назад

      @@casualartist4202 sure, but i haven't met anyone taking creatine for that reason, just the performance enhancing

    • @casualartist4202
      @casualartist4202 2 года назад +1

      @@benitocamela174 makes sense. i pay attention to more bodybuilding than powerlifting, so i look at it from an aesthetics standpoint more so than performance.

  • @MorethanGUNZ
    @MorethanGUNZ Год назад

    Sean is one of the best influencers out there 🔥🔥🔥

  • @jonathanwilliams7920
    @jonathanwilliams7920 5 месяцев назад +1

    Creatine HCL does help people who are sensitive to creatine. I know a few people that get upset stomachs from monohydrate but not HCL

  • @nauroticdax
    @nauroticdax Год назад +1

    "HCL gives you less water retention" ...isn't part of the point of taking creatine to make your muscles retain water better?

  • @nathanplumb3782
    @nathanplumb3782 3 месяца назад +1

    I like the hcl better actually. It’s nice only taking a gram or two, and mono hydrate does seem to cause some gastrointestinal discomfort for me. It might just be because of the lower dosage but hcl seems like it may cause less discomfort for me as far as bloating goes. But I tend to get kind of bloated either whether I’m taking Creatine or not.

  • @tacobeartaco7140
    @tacobeartaco7140 2 года назад

    The obvious “so tired of this sh**” face! Love it! Appreciate your videos man!!

  • @RNB_ZAE
    @RNB_ZAE Год назад

    Monohydrate doesn’t even dissolve well and hcl honestly does feel better I just starting taking it and feels way cleaner

  • @epickiller30
    @epickiller30 2 года назад +1

    The hcl component is also helpful for digestion and stopping the burps I get while working out

  • @XenIsWhen
    @XenIsWhen 4 месяца назад

    This has to be the most clever idea for fitness videos I've ever seen. So much material with these lunkheads. 😂

  • @rooinmaggot1892
    @rooinmaggot1892 2 года назад

    As someone new to this whole fitness journey, I appreciate the hell out of your content and your knowledge. 👐 So thank you.

  • @moneymitch2k
    @moneymitch2k Год назад +1

    Sean I know this is an old vid by now but this is the one thing I'd disagree with you on tbh. Creatine Monohydrate destroys my stomach and I regularly get painful and sleepless nights on it, and with a fuckton of trial and error I made sure it was monohydrate that caused it.
    I swear by hcl since it doesn't cause any stomach pain nor any ridiculous constipations that'd last for weeks on end.

  • @wakawaka1976
    @wakawaka1976 2 месяца назад +1

    Just started taking the HCL and it hasn’t caused any stomach pains like the regular stuff did… yet at least.

  • @SD-op2ue
    @SD-op2ue Год назад

    tbh they both have pros and cons I recommend trying both for yourself to determine which is better for you and your goals I see value in using both on and off

  • @JshDav
    @JshDav 3 месяца назад

    I used HCL for a little bit, the one thing I did like about it was how it doesnt require loading to get the full result as I always end up forgetting to have my daily creatine with my super busy lifestyle these days

  • @brokenlegend1179
    @brokenlegend1179 3 месяца назад

    Good looking out bro

  • @dariangossman
    @dariangossman Год назад +1

    I explosively shit my brains out with monohydrate. I have to disove it in small quantities in something acidic like soda or citrus juice. I haven't tried HCL yet so i don't know if it digests any better.

  • @KieranSpears
    @KieranSpears 6 месяцев назад +2

    I use HCL because I have IBS and it’s wayyyyyy easier on the stomach than monohydrate

  • @arathsg9824
    @arathsg9824 6 месяцев назад

    Business 101: create a problem and sell a solution

  • @Juan_LopezMorales
    @Juan_LopezMorales Год назад

    Damn that sucks. Never really knew that. Thanks for always been upfront with this kind of information! Love the channel!

  • @magalahi6seventy284
    @magalahi6seventy284 2 года назад +2

    Everytime he makes a dissapointed look i die a bit more

  • @milesperez4627
    @milesperez4627 Год назад

    Earlier today I went to a new supplement store, I ended up getting hcl over monohydrate but only because it was cheaper per serving at this particular place. As long as it does the same thing I'm happy.

  • @IraDyer-j1k
    @IraDyer-j1k Год назад

    My man👏🏽

  • @lolk4530
    @lolk4530 3 месяца назад

    The water weight is literally the cool part. It makes your muscles look bigger and way more defined.

  • @lavvvf
    @lavvvf 4 месяца назад

    Bro is carrying him on his shoulders 😂

  • @beboysub
    @beboysub Год назад +1

    Thank You kind Sir ❤

  • @_Paul_N
    @_Paul_N Год назад

    HCL is much better on the stomach compared to mono for me at least.

  • @Lamborafa
    @Lamborafa Год назад +1

    When he took it without mixing it in water I knew not to listen cuz that’s bad for the liver

  • @Osprey1994
    @Osprey1994 Год назад

    There was a sale going on so I started with HCl. Might switch to mono when I run out of HCL.

  • @GlorifiedGremlin
    @GlorifiedGremlin 3 месяца назад +1

    Water retention is the fcking goal 😂

  • @santiagocalderon4700
    @santiagocalderon4700 Месяц назад

    I was literally just thinking about that, thank you 🙏

  • @tinorjack719
    @tinorjack719 2 года назад

    I'm just happy i found you before i saw other b.s content creators

  • @MartintheworldChampion
    @MartintheworldChampion 4 месяца назад +1

    When a Gym shark athlete promotes Coach Greg's htlt supplements

  • @giovanni540
    @giovanni540 Год назад

    HCL is a necessary acid to help with your stomach acid production to break down protein and other nutrients.

  • @bo49685
    @bo49685 Год назад

    Great channel Sean!! Just found your channel the other day, love your content 💪💪💪

  • @aayushjain8381
    @aayushjain8381 2 года назад

    His face when he throws creatine box away🤣🤣🤣

  • @Vincent-RS09
    @Vincent-RS09 4 месяца назад

    I could’ve sworn I heard bro say “with 1/5 the circumcise-“

  • @The_real_JulieKelsea
    @The_real_JulieKelsea 2 месяца назад

    Love your content! Thank you 🙏🏼

  • @chickenmanicmrt1705
    @chickenmanicmrt1705 2 года назад +1

    I get bloating from protein powders, but there's many types so I changed to isolate and bam no bloating

  • @lilchavo
    @lilchavo Год назад

    I seen on other videos people had commented saying they’ve noticed hair loss/ hair thinning. Was wondering if any else noticed these changes while taking creatine. I want to take creatine but also concerned with this hair loss 😅