@The Dark Knight yeah these random names are amazing. Imagine someone is beating the shit out of Arthur and asks his name,and the first name that comes to his mind is leviticus cornwall😂😂
@@fernandovelazquezgonzalez4169 goes to the blackwater bank: umm hey uhh we heard that you gave a mortgage to a feller who looks a lot like rip van winkle Oh you mean Jim John marston Milton Yesnt
Rip van Winkle, protagonist of a short tale by Washington Irving, became the literary archetype of the "hen pecked husband", also some sort of "Jon Doe" if I remember properly. Which, John Marston calling that to himself makes it just hilarious. Assuming he knows this, which is rather improbable given he's not precisely a cultivated man, he's making fun of himself as being not man enough to handle Abigail's temper at the same time as saying "I'm nobody of your concern"
I mean, they're not the most educated, but Hosea and Dutch taught both Arthur and John how to read and could've showed him this short tale. It would be less weird than Arthur knowing greek and celtic cultures, at least partially. But yeah, the joke is way too "Hmm, educated humor, yes".
It could be something to do with John abandoning the gang for a year and the Pinkertons potentially didn't know he'd re-entered the gang. It seems that they don't have accurate descriptions of the gang members, that's why Milton says "Mr Matthews, I presume". He wasn't %100 sure that was Hosea and made an educated guess
@@OGJohnMarston you're right. The mod I got looks like shit with some hats like his main one. They could have worked on it to make it better though. Rather have that, than horse balls shriveling up in the cold
One of the best lines even if it's just saying a name but the first time i saw this i thought it is "Wrinkle" instead of "Winkle" and it made laugh really hard,Rip like R.I.P "van" like van der Linde and "van" also being seen a lot in peoples names from Netherlands/Dutch,Wrinkle doesn't need an explanation.Hell, even Dutch's name itself is funny to me,his name being the name of a nationality and using the same surname that a lot people from Netherlands have in their names.Whoever came up with the name Dutch Van Der Linde is a genius
Rip Van Winkle is the protagonist of a book published in 1819. John just didn't want to say his real name so he used the name of a random book character. Rip Van Winkle was probably a well known character in those times, so I think yeah, it was probably just a joke that Milton and everyone else understood.
*Rip Van Winkle*
Huh, good day sir.
Dutch can you still take us to Tahiti to farm mangoes ???
R.I.P Rip Van Winkle
Imposter!
Hey thats my dialogue
Arthur: Don’t be two people at once. John: Ok, I’ll be three
Lmao
Gotta love John Jim Milton, Jim Milton, Rip Van Kinkle, and John Marston
Wolfman
Scarface
Rip Van Winkle
Jim Milton
John Marston
jim marston van winkle
jim milton scarface rip van winkle john marston
That sounds a lot like Jim milton
I thought so too
you know, we’ve never actually seen john marston and jim milton in a cutscene together 🤷🏻♀️
Yo tf? I thought he sounded similar to the outlaw John Marston, weird 🤔
nah man he sounds like John Jim.
Dumb ass it’s John Jim and rip van wrinkle
The name was randomly came across his mind, that's for sure
Right 🤣
Rip was an actual name of a celebrity from a long time ago
The name is a reference to someone from rdr1
It’s a reference to a Dutch children’s book back in the 19th century. John must’ve been reading it to Jack, and it crossed his mind
It's from a story that exists in real life. The fun part is that in the story Rip is a Dutchman.
Arthur is the only one with a normal fake name
“Arthur Callahan”
wht about tacitus kilgore
@@iroquoisv you got me, I forgot about that one
@@iroquoisv That's a fake name for the whole gang, so they can send and receive mail, which makes it even more weird lol.
Jim milton
@The Dark Knight yeah these random names are amazing. Imagine someone is beating the shit out of Arthur and asks his name,and the first name that comes to his mind is leviticus cornwall😂😂
Edger Ross when he sees John again : it’s Rip van winkle.
I imagine Ross asking about Rip Van Winkle in the credits scenes 😂😂😂
@@fernandovelazquezgonzalez4169 goes to the blackwater bank: umm hey uhh we heard that you gave a mortgage to a feller who looks a lot like rip van winkle
Oh you mean Jim John marston Milton
Yesnt
@@BiggsTheOwl *Flashback of John saying Rip Van Winkle*
Ross: ._.
@@fernandovelazquezgonzalez4169 Ross milton:
He played us like a damn fiddle
LOOOOL 💀💀💀
I like how Dutch is the goat at making up fake names, John is decent but forgets sometimes, and Arthur is basically calls himself Bill Gates
god no, John basically just call himself harry potter
Arthur Callahan, Leviticus Cornwall, killgore,
arthur callahan
Tacitus Kilgore
Yeah Arthur sucked at fake names lmao
Love how he doesn’t even hesitate😭
Rip van Winkle, protagonist of a short tale by Washington Irving, became the literary archetype of the "hen pecked husband", also some sort of "Jon Doe" if I remember properly. Which, John Marston calling that to himself makes it just hilarious. Assuming he knows this, which is rather improbable given he's not precisely a cultivated man, he's making fun of himself as being not man enough to handle Abigail's temper at the same time as saying "I'm nobody of your concern"
I mean, they're not the most educated, but Hosea and Dutch taught both Arthur and John how to read and could've showed him this short tale. It would be less weird than Arthur knowing greek and celtic cultures, at least partially. But yeah, the joke is way too "Hmm, educated humor, yes".
game has better writing than most movies
@@carmendemairena6972 Yes, they could very well have been thaught this. By the way, long live Carmen de Mairena
You're an idiot.
@@auburn696 Are you calling me gay???
Its funnier because the characters knew who Rip Van Winkle was because he was a character in a popular book released in the early 1800s.
That part almost destroyed my lungs, because Van Winkle is Vanilla Ice. 80s/90s folks know that name well.
Rip Van Winkle is also the name of a protagonist in a book written by Washington Irving in 1819
@@S1L3NTBUTCH3R Didnt know. Makes more sense now.
@@DementedButtHole 💀💀💀
Bruh Rip Van Vinkle is a story
Vanilla ice is DIO’s right hand man
I once got dropped off from a stagecoach and was referred to as “mr can winkle” pretty cool little Easter egg
same, but i was arthur
"Rip Van Winke"
- John Marston
"Rip Van Winkle"
- Rip Van Winkle
"Huh. good day sir"
I am making a petition to make RDR remastered and they call John Rip Van Winkle the entire time. Like to sign.
Rip, Van Winkle 😔
R.I.P Van Winkle
My fav character in rdr2 Rip Van Winkle
quandale dingle
If ever get ask what my name is by anyone idk I’m saying this
Lmao
What’s your name?
@@briantran1468 his name is Epic Gamer420
@@Ian260m why did u run
@@Ian260m years ago? How old are you?
why didn't Ross and milton know who john was? cause he was raised by dutch alongside Arthur and im sure he would of had a bounty on him as well?
They probably knew his name but not his face
It could be something to do with John abandoning the gang for a year and the Pinkertons potentially didn't know he'd re-entered the gang. It seems that they don't have accurate descriptions of the gang members, that's why Milton says "Mr Matthews, I presume". He wasn't %100 sure that was Hosea and made an educated guess
Also Johns Scar is recent so they probably were wondering who this scar faced member was that they didn't know about
john probably never got caught and you can't have a photo on your wanted poster if you haven't been caught
Why TF couldn't Rockstar keep this same look for John in the epilogue. Giving him Arthur's hairstyle. Stupid AF
grow your hair lol
@@mrbruh2874 no. I play on PC and got a mod for his original hair. Still dumb tho
They were lazy
I think it’s because the hair clips through some hats. Like the Classic Hat from rdr1. Rockstar couldn’t be bothered to fix it though.
@@OGJohnMarston you're right. The mod I got looks like shit with some hats like his main one. They could have worked on it to make it better though. Rather have that, than horse balls shriveling up in the cold
One of the best lines even if it's just saying a name but the first time i saw this i thought it is "Wrinkle" instead of "Winkle" and it made laugh really hard,Rip like R.I.P "van" like van der Linde and "van" also being seen a lot in peoples names from Netherlands/Dutch,Wrinkle doesn't need an explanation.Hell, even Dutch's name itself is funny to me,his name being the name of a nationality and using the same surname that a lot people from Netherlands have in their names.Whoever came up with the name Dutch Van Der Linde is a genius
He woke up and became a G
Why is young Ed Ross so goddamn good looking I can’t stand it.
wait what
Wh- 😳
No he’s not
@@Only1omer just look at him standing all mysterious with that shotgun, and don’t even get me started on that mustache. Dude is a complete stud.
@@deventazz8018 well maybe in your perspective but young hosea will always be the most badass gang member
Rip Rip Van Winkle
That’s the name of my horse on Red Dead Online
Mine was called tesco
So now we got John Marston, Jim Milton, John-Jim Milton and Rip Van Winkle
this is the funniest scene in the game for me i dont know why
Bruh I was thinking about this scene like half an hour ago and came on RUclips to search it only to find it first on my recommended feed
*huuuuh.... Good day sir...*
this is so funny😭
I guess this is my reminder to replay rdr2. Oh well cya’ll in 100 hours
It's me
John Marshton years later: your last name is my property now
its marston not marshton
I heard Tahiti is nice
Avoid Guarma
Very interesting.
the people who actually know the story
At first its john and then rip van winkle and then jim milton and after that undead john
That was definitely sarcasm. I mean, why would he tell them his real name? XD
J.M, Jim Milton 😂
The one time John is funny
А он че, клоун тебе чтоль
hi erik
hello😁
@@erik3011 how are you this fine day sir erik
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
nogga
*HUH*
Why does he say winkle like that😂😂😂😂
How else would he say that?
HUHH
Huh...
Huh…
Probably could have used a more believable name
Nah Rip Van Winkle is believable enough
Better than Dutch’s “Hoagy Macintosh” 😂
y se la pela
0:08
Huh
Where this came from?☠️
Рассказ о человеке который напился и уснул на много лет - его звали Рип Ван Винкль
Рассказ о человеке который напился и уснул на много лет - его звали Рип Ван Винкль
which chapter does it happen?
What mission is this
Is rip van winkle a joke or something I can’t understand it
Rip Van Winkle is the protagonist of a book published in 1819. John just didn't want to say his real name so he used the name of a random book character. Rip Van Winkle was probably a well known character in those times, so I think yeah, it was probably just a joke that Milton and everyone else understood.
Rip Van Winkle
why did you change your name to RIP VAN WINKLE
Rip Van Winkle