Backbone, Kishi, Gamesir! Which One Should You Choose? Comparison!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024
- Which mobile handheld controller is best? In this video, we rank and discuss what we like and dislike about the Kishi, Backbone and Gamesir X2.
Get your own Gamesir X2 here: amzn.to/3lvrGMR
Gamesir X2 Iphone version: amzn.to/3o804zF
Get your own Backbone here: amzn.to/3r9B2lH
Get your own Razer Kishi here: amzn.to/3s1jk32
Razer Kishi Iphone version: amzn.to/3s1jk32
Follow Us on Twitter and Instagram at:
/ completegeektv
/ completegeektv
Gear We Use To Make Our RUclips Videos:
Main Camera: amzn.to/35d3uam
Secondary Camera: amzn.to/359ODgZ
Main Lens: amzn.to/3iDoEGD
Secondary Lens: amzn.to/3g9LLae
Cinematic lens Filter: amzn.to/3pGGmdM
Anamorphic lens Filter: amzn.to/357oIXc
Over Head Lighting: amzn.to/3pIc3TY
Creative Lighting: amzn.to/3gu98tW
Strong Product Backlight: amzn.to/3wfdwUt
LED Strip Lighting: amzn.to/357DHjN
Microphone: amzn.to/2TopFHS
Rotating Turn-Table: amzn.to/35b53pi
Camera Tripod: amzn.to/3whvGVv
Editing Computer: amzn.to/3gdtWXJ
Video Editing Software: amzn.to/3gsnzPc
Audio Interface: amzn.to/3zdoLi9
Other Equipment We love and Occasionally Use:
Small Spot lights: amzn.to/2ToRy2U
On Camera Location Mic: amzn.to/3pGpunF
Straight Edge Knife: amzn.to/3vdy3HM
The Best SSD Drives: amzn.to/3vc7l2c
Telephoto Lens 1: amzn.to/3waM4qO
Telephoto Lens 2: amzn.to/3weExal
Wide Prime lens: amzn.to/3gq4ygl
Standard Prime lens: amzn.to/3pGId2p
Our Live Stream Equipment:
Gaming Computer: amzn.to/2TNzm2T (Not Exact, this is the closest comparable option on Amazon. Our’s has custom selected components)
Camera: amzn.to/3gnRkkh
Camera 2: amzn.to/3cAuoNt
Lens: amzn.to/3cBz4Tv
Capture Card 1: amzn.to/2SqmIqk
Capture Card 2: amzn.to/3iETbUJ
Capture Card 3: amzn.to/3ivvduU
Microphone: amzn.to/2TfXZ8e
Microphone Signal Boost: amzn.to/2TZibf1
Video Upscaler: amzn.to/2SiP8Tj
Music By: AudioGold Productions
/ audiogoldproductions
A few of the product links in this description box are affiliate links. As Amazon Associates, we may earn from qualifying purchases.
Never heard of the Game Sir. I’ll definitely look into it. Instant sub to the channel since y’all look local reppin the KC gear.
i ordered the x2 on amazon, it's arriving wednesday!
Curious about the Gamesir it seem great because of the thumb sticks. Great vid guys. ❤️
Thank you and we really appreciate it. The Gamesir X2 is great. You really can't go wrong with any of these options
Just ordered the gamesir x2 for 40 bucks. My first phone controller. Hope I like it. Kishi v1 was same price but went for this one based off an ETA Prime video. Great video guys thanks
Any followup review?
Nice, appreciate the attention to the little details. I tried the kishi when it went on sale back in Dec but it didn't fit my phone (galaxy s21) with a protective case. I really want to try the gamesir, so count me in for the giveaway boys!
Hey Ruben! We hope all is well. We are happy to have you always be apart of all the giveaways and thanks for all your support. We greatly appreciate it.
If you use a case, the Gamesir is not going to fit you. For the Kishi, you can remove the rubber supports to fit the case. I have the S20 fe 5g with a case.
Gamesir sucks...i tried using for stadia...and after a short while the usb c port on the gamesir would disconnect...and cause massive issues... something like holding a in red dead wouldn't work...the buttons stuck...and id have to constantly undock and redock my phone in it
Thanks for posting the video, thanks for the review. Great to c u again guys!
Hey Ranchorelax! Awesome to hear from you and we hope all is well.
I’ve tested a Kishi(feels cheap to me ) and the gamesir(feels pretty good ) but I really want a backbone but I wish it worked with phone cases attached
We completely agree. If you could use a Backbone with a case, or any of these, that would make things way more convenient and protective
Bro same the kishi feels bad I wish I never got it the first time the belt broke for me and the game sir x2 lighting I bought it twice and for
Both the dpad broke for after 3 weeks and got my money
Back so I count the back bone can’t wait
The kishi is cheaply made pile of rubbish imo only good thing on the controller are the sticks
Backbones stop working and begin to glitch out after 2 months. I bought 2 of them both happened and the buttons stop working immediately after
@@beauchnicherubin455 on the kishi the left side with the d pad randomly died about 3 months after having it . The kishi v2 looks like it was made in partnership with backbone hopefully they last longer than a few months especially given the price (still don't understand why these little mobile controllers cost more than a tech feature packed ps5 , joycon or Xbox controller)
Just got the Kishi V2 purely based on availability. Tons at most retail stores. Got it at Walmart. It's been pretty impressive playing the cloud Xbox gaming with a controller plugged in as opposed to using a Bluetooth controller. Night and day difference. Plus passthrough charging does still do RAPID CHARGING!! I was surprised honestly. I'd be very curious if the new Backbone Android version and Gamesir one can do rapid charging. Super curious. Btw, I'm using a Pixel 7 pro. Was playing Metal Gear Snake eater with the PS2 emulator, worked like a charm- with vulken enabled and 2x native resolution enabled. But now I think I'll mainly use it for cloud gaming. And I can't believe I'm actually saying that. I'm done rambling
Great to see you guys back from the Holiday break.
Those are all nice options for xcloud and mobile gaming.
Count me in for the draw. I know which one I’m picking 😎
Thanks Jaime and we're happy to have you be a part of it. We appreciate the support
@@CompleteGeekTV I choose the gamesir
Thanks for the review. Count me in for the giveaway!
Was wondering when you guys were putting up a new video. Glad to see ya.
Glad to see you my friend. We need to catch up soon. Have you or your son played any new games lately?
Those comparisons of good sponge and bad sponge were hilarious but perfect!
Lol. Glad you liked it dude. We were getting a kick out of filming it. What games have you been playing lately?
@@CompleteGeekTV I've been playing the Uncharted Legacy of Thieves lately. and replaying thru Spiderman again but the remstered version for PS5. I can't wait for Horizon, GT7, WWE 2k22 and Elden Ring.
Those are pretty cool! I would be into the Backbone or the Gamesir! 🎮
Yeah they are. All of them are very good options.
Great video keep it going already can't wait for your future uploads and the set up is looking clean 🔥
Thanks as always. How many hours of Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba - The Hinokami Chronicles have you played?
The backbone seems the best based off my feel preferences. Love the energy! I love these controllers that are for full size humans. Lol. Great review.
Ha thank you. Do you want to get in on this giveaway? It's free so you might as well.
Problem with the backbone is that unless you’re an early adopter there is a $50/year in-app subscription to use the backbone app and even to have it work on your other devices like iPad and Mac. Kishi v2 is the same but doesn’t require a subscription. …needing a subscription for a controller…
@@gabrield4892 is this subscription necessary for regular use? or just for additional features?
Thanks so much guys for covering these all.
I really want to get a backbone but they all seem to be pretty good quality.
That would be awesome to see you win one of these. We hope all is well and keep up the awesome work. Btw, your Earthworm Jim painting is incredible!
@@CompleteGeekTV I would not be upset by that at all!
Thanks so much! I’m enjoying it on the wall until it gets shipped off to its new home tomorrow.
That backbone and kishi really seem tempting. Great review, guys! Keep up the good work.
Thank you and we greatly appreciate it. They are all great and you really can't go wrong with any of these.
Don’t go Kisha had one when they first came out it feels kinda flimsy and the left side quit working afyer minimal use in about 3 months
@@gcforreal I had the same exact issue. It worked great for maybe 4 or 5 months of use and all of sudden left side stopped working. Waste of money. I'm going with gamesir this time around.
@@MrSmegmasteve gamesir is good it feels you're playing a Nintendo switch
@@CompleteGeekTV on the software side, ohhh yes you can
Great video! Even if I don’t win, I now feel well informed about each of these products. Who knows, down the line I may buy one for myself. Anyways keep up the good work you guys!
We appreciate that and thanks for watching. We would love to see you win. Out of all options, which one do you think you'll like the most?
It was a hard choice but I’d like the Gamesir X2. Their all great. It’s just that Gamesir seems more up my alley in terms of satisfaction.
You guys are back!!
Yes we are! Feels good to be back and hope all is well.
I've had brought two razer kishi and the durability on it is a problem but I will say it's a good controller other than that I switch over to a mg-x controller and it thr best controller I've uses so far
Good feedback and we're glad to hear you're enjoying the mg-x. We may need to get that one in. We do have the Gamesir X3 coming in soon so we're excited to try it out. That's for watching and we appreciate the support
I like gamesir, it seemed to have a lot of detail built into it joystick and, durability Bluetooth update and clickyness
Also it's half the price of the others.
Thank you for the thorough review. Are any of these controllers case friendly?
Thanks you! This was our first big comparison and there have been some new controllers come out since.
We reviewed the Gamevice Flex last year and really like it. It’s also made to work with cases and has inserts to help. But they are hard to get now. Sadly they are almost always out of stock. I kind of wonder Inc the company went out of business and just kept the site up but aren’t making more stock.
I’d like to be entered into the contest.
I bought the Razer Kishi a few months back, and while I have had fun using it I noticed that there’s a little bit of flex or wiggle and both ends where it comes into contact with my iPhone 12Pro and occasionally looses connection. I have to unplug it and re-plug it back in during gameplay. I’m really looking forward to getting a Backbone some day. Never tried the Gamesir but it looks pretty cool too.
We appreciate that feedback on your Kishi experience. It's good for others to hear that feedback as well to help them make a decision. We apologize as the giveaway has already passed but we appreciate you wanting to be a part of it. Thanks for watching and we appreciate your support.
Nice vid boys, aren't the a,b, x,y buttons flipped on the gamesir wired model like the switch? That's a big no no for me, the Bluetooth model the buttons are same as the xbox style,
just thought I'd throw it out there.
Missed you guys since the last stream 👍
We appreciate that and have more videos on the way. Another video and giveaway should post Tuesday.
Welcome back, Game SIRS!!
Lol. Thank you and feels good to getting more content out
Hey great video guys! I’m a fan, can’t wait for more content. This controller sounds like a solution for me with having a kid lol I would like to enter!
Been a minute, boys! Good to see your handsome faces again. Great video as always 😄
Thanks for watching Taylor and we hope all is well. We need to catch up soon and keep up the amazing work
Fantastic comparison! The real question is, which one works best on the mobile version of Final Fantasy IV 3D? 🤔
I guess we’ll need to test that out! My first thought would be Gamesir since it is automatically in “Nintendo Configuration” which would make it most true to the original game
Sounds like it's time for Jordan to give it a test run
@@CompleteGeekTV it sounds like the perfect opportunity for Jordan. And Jorgan too!!
LOOK WHO'S BACK! BACK AGAIN!!
Ha. What is up Adam. How have you been doing? Have you been playing any new games lately?
I have a Kishi and have always thought the Backbone might be better, but just haven’t gotten around to getting one. I would love to be able to win one from you guys
Glad to see you guys
Alexis!! Always good to hear from you my friend. I think some mystery jelly beans need to make a comeback on a future giveaway.
@@CompleteGeekTV yea man for sure 😂😂
Dang Super Bowl weekend. Noice. I want in
Oh you're in!
Yooo these things are sick! One of my friends has something similar, these types of things are definitely worth it for those looking to enter in this giveaway.
Armyboy!!! What is up my friend? How are things going?
@@CompleteGeekTV Things are going great! Playin' video games and livin' life!
That's good to hear! What have you been playing lately?
@@CompleteGeekTV I've been playing a lot of Breath of the Wild and Wind Waker as of late. Having a lot of fun with Wind Waker. I had always been hesitant to play the game just because of how different it was from the rest of the Zelda games, but I actually really enjoyed it.
Finally new video!
Hey Pedro! Yes it took a while but we are back in full swing
I like the Backbone as it has the headphone jack. I'm not sure what time the live video will be, but if I won't sleep that time, I'll enter.😅
Yeah we like that it has a headphone jack. If you can't make it live you still have a chance to win so we'll definitely have you be a part of it. Thanks for joining
@@CompleteGeekTV that's fantastic, thank you!
It would really help for my streaming
We are happy to have you be apart of it. They are all great and think you'll be happy with either one.
There is an item that can out before all of them that fits ANY phone! The only thing you need is a Bluetooth controller.
Found out that kishi v2 don't pass music with it's usb C output so there's no choice other than using Bluetooth with hectic latency. Any android controller without a 3.5mm earphone hole doesn't make sense because even if your device has a 3.5mm jack you won't be able to use that when you pack your device into the controller. So make your choice with accordingly.
I can't use the kishi since I have a Galaxy Zfold , so I went with the gamesirx2 because it fits and the only controller that can ran switch games on eggns .
Nice! Have you received it yet and if so, what are your thoughts? We are fans and especially like the sticks
@@CompleteGeekTV yeah been using it for days playing Xbox gamepass and running the eggns switch emulator to play breathe of the wild . The razer kishi was nice on my pixel6 but the gamesirx2 can fit all devics.. I had a hard time using the s22ultra on the kishi and had to remove the foam to fit it .
@@kdubspencer3390 We are glad that you're enjoying it. That is definitely part of what makes the Gamesir X2 such a good option. We think a lot of people write it off or don't know about it but it's a great device.
Tbh I think the backbone is the best one because it feels comfortable playing with it.
Enter me in the giveaway please
Thanks for joining Spooky and we are happy to have you be apart of it
The picture caught my full attention
I need that Ralph Wiggum plush!
Ha dude we won him at Universal. That was a great win. He will be making a lot of guest appearances
Another amazing giveaway guys ❤️
Thank you and we appreciate all the support.
Hi friend please I need one suggestion I’m using iPhone 14 plus can I use gamesir or any other for COD
I have the backbone
Qual modelos vcs endica pra jogar no remote play da Sony?qual funcionou melhor?
Can we get a phone size comparison because no one mention this I have a 6.82 size phone and the gamesir barley fit my phone without a case. Now I'm looking to get the backbone one but. Afraid it won't fit either. I love the gamesir thou
Really wish the Gamesir had an option for an analog trigger. Otherwise it seems ideal, but no analog triggers is a no-go for racing games.
Yeah that would be nice! It would be awesome to have mix of each controller! So far the closest we’ve found to that is the Moga XP7-X Plus. It is Bluetooth and not direct connection though, but in our testing it didn’t seem to add any noticeable lag we could find.
We made a video about it if you’re interested!
ruclips.net/video/PZpszClRS7g/видео.html
@@CompleteGeekTV like you guys say in that video - all these controllers are great but they also all have a drawback. In this case for me it's that it doesn't support iPhone. Appreciate the recommendation though!
@@AriaLaurel gotcha! Yeah I understand! I (Jordan) have an iPhone as well so I personally use the backbone the most. Adam has an android phone and loves the Moga (I do as well but can’t use it) it’s nice having both phonebrands between us though because it allows us to try more devices for the channel. It would be awesome if they made something like the Moga for iPhone though
@@AriaLaurel Nobody cares about iPhone. No emulators. Bad locked in ecosystem.
@@_nom_ webrcade
Imma need one of these so I can play the final fantasy battle royal game
Good point. You also need to get your black PS5 controller
🎶I need it🎶 🎶I need it🎶
Backbone type c I heard is coming in november but, by then Backbone V2 will probably be out.
I want that kishi. Gonna order the v2 i think
New to this channel , the back bone convinced me! Tbh.
Also I would like to enter the giveaway (:
Welcome to the channel and we're happy to have you be a part of it. It would be awesome to see you win!
Planning to get one for my bday and i still can't decide which one but i guess the pricing will xD
Also which controller do you prefer for GameSir? Is it the USB plug or Bluetooth?
That's a good birthday gift and we're excited for you to receive it! I think it really comes down to the user and which phone they are using. If you have a phone that has a USB C then the USB model is a good option and the one we have but, the Bluetooth one gives more flexibility because it doesn't matter where the USB port is and it doesn't have to be a phone that uses USB C
Is there any controller for mediatek devices? 🥺
Love the video but that majoras mask thooooooo
10:07 not gonna lie my brain had a stroke for a sec
Lol. I just had to watch the 10:07 mark. The old switcheroo
@@CompleteGeekTV hahaha
Good Day, thanks for the video. I always game on console and recently downloaded COD Mobile and was looking at a few mobile controller options. But I’m located in the Bahamas 🇧🇸 and these types of technology aren’t as available here. But would like to be entered for the controller giveaway. 🤞🏾
We would love to have you be a part of it. You might have issues using these with COD mobile but you may consider the Gamesir X2 Bluetooth version. We aren't positive but we believe that works with it and we would gladly send you that if you won unless you wanted one of the others.
Gamesire is the best. I had to go through two razer kishi they break east too many moving parts and from collapsed them multiple times, parts in the inside start to break. And start to rattle. My second kishi still works but it’s useless because the right trigger and buttons are sticking that sponge feeling gets sticky
The backbone does look the coolest, and sound the best, unfortunately I don't have an iPhone. Im one of those peasants. The Gamesir seems legit tho!
I’m actually very surprised they haven’t made an android version of backbone yet! Their website actually claims they have had a lot of requests and taking into consideration when you look on the FAQ page so hopefully they do!
now they are available
Can you review the Mocute 060 gamepad? i just wanna know if it can be use for cloud gaming with a smartphone
We will certainly look into it. We are always looking for new ones to test
I like this video
😎 coolest thing ever
What one is the best for play FPS games on iPhone
That's a tough one. The Gamevice Flex would be a good option. It has nice sticks and there is little to complain about. The Naxon MG-X pro is also an amazing controller that will be available for ios in February but it is Bluetooth instead of plug connection so that's something to consider. We do recommend giving the Gamevice Flex a look.
Josh and who?
I’m interested in the giveaway ✋
Thanks for your comment and we appreciate the support. We unfortunately have already had the giveaway but we have several more SSD videos planned and more giveaways. Please keep an eye out as we would love for you to have a chance to win
Thanks for the review!
No problem and thanks for watching!
Will the backbone work with remote play for ps4/5 without subscription?
As far as we know it does still work but it's missing some features through the app. We have discussed doing a video on this showing the differences now with or without the subscription. Thank you for your comment and for watching.
Yep
For the backbone.. does the PS4 have to be on in order for me to play?
The reason I wanted to get this was because my PS4 doesn’t work no more and I didn’t want to get a new one.
Yes it does. Sadly PlayStation does not support Cloud play yet like Xbox does. Meaning it just plays your games off the cloud instead of your device. The way PlayStation remote play works is by playing the game on your primary PS4 (or PS5) system and then streaming the video feed to your phone while sending the controller inputs back to the console. Hopefully one day PS will add actually cloud gaming because I’ve been using it a lot for Xbox Game Pass and it’s pretty awesome being able to play any of my games anywhere!
Have all 3 backbone works probably the best and has the best triggers *But* that god awful click on A,B,X,Y is terrible sitting on lunch break the kishi works so people don’t hear that god awful click there is a work around taking it apart and get rid of the metal backing to stop the click using a Nintendo gameboy advance soft pad
Hey, the video is good but it would be a lot of better if it didn't feel you were each fighting for screen time. You were constantly interrupting each other and not in a scripted, fun way.
First!
First twice now. Impressive
It bugs me how the light strips on the back don't line up. Sloppy.
Our room was and still is in pre construction. It is also a combination of the camera angles and our bodies/chairs. Thanks for the feedback though and thanks for watching
@@CompleteGeekTV Thanks for the reply. Like the show. Lights are still not level though. Not camera angles. Look at the brick mortar lines on the wall. Its all good.
Thanks John and we appreciate the comment and feedback. Thanks for the support and thanks again for checking out the video
They need to bring one out for the new iPad Mini 6!
I think a lot of people would enjoy something like that. We’ve been testing the steam deck for the past few weeks and just saying how someone should come up with more of a” “Tablet” style console. Almost line a thick iPad with really good specs but you have to Bluetooth or attach your own controller so it can be 100% screen.
Backbone: 👍
GameSir: 👍
Kishi: 👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎
I just ordered a kishi so I can dominate in Diablo immortal… iPhone 13
Ha nice! Let us know what you think once you get some hands on with it. We think you'll enjoy it.
That’s nice I had the kishi i I didn’t like it the strap is so flimsy but I had the gamesir x2 didn’t like it either but I have my backbone I love it
I'd like to enter
Gamesir all the way
The sponge 🧽😂😂😂😂
Ha. We laughed pretty hard filming that
Count me in please
We are happy to have you be a part of it and hope you're doing well
Great video! I'd like to be entered for the giveaway
Thank you and we're happy to o have to be a part of it.
Great video, id like to be in the giveaway!
Gamesirs quality is garbage...i just ordered the kishi...the gamesir connector port is terrible...constant disconnect...and its not my phone...the triggers are terrible the sticks make shooting games very difficult...the buttons stuck after 4 months with light gameplay...id use the gamesir for emulators because of the button mappimg but for true gaming on stadia/GeForce/Xcloud go with the kishi..otherwise ur controller will fall apart
We're sorry to hear about your issues with your Gamesir. That is unfortunate to hear and we hope you have much better luck with your Kishi. Thank you for your feedback as it's also helpful for others that are trying to make a buying decision. We appreciate you watching and thanks for your support.
@@CompleteGeekTV to be fair i didnt expect much of the gamesir...as someone who designs technology for a company i can tell when something is poorly constructed ..the moving type c port was a giveaway to a short lifespan...the connections on usb c ports dont support constant flexing and movement...thats why chargers have a box housing the connectors so that where the contact points meet the charger head there is zero flexibility...if u bend a wire back and forth enough it will break...it was a poor design choice opposed to the kishi
@@CompleteGeekTV plus i have a note 20 so my enormous phone didnt help either...if u have a smaller phone it will probably last longer but dont expect it to last a year 💯🤷🏻
Fun fact: I have a back bone
on my body
Just ordered my backbone one from amazon for 100 (117.00) with overnight shipping can't wait
Awesome! It’s fun little device! We hope you enjoy it!
the backbone is overprice
Yeah at current prices, it's almost double the price of the others. Thank you for your comment and sharing your feedback.
I want to be entered
backbone is trash.....kinda
Backbone is trash, buttons become unresponsive after a little while. I’ve gone through one a year so going to try the Razer and see how long that last
Very sorry to hear that. We did just get the Gamevice Flex and we are enjoying it so far. Feels like an upgrade to the original Kishi in many ways. We only mention it as another option if you haven't seen it.
Whatever you do, Don't buy the ShitSir. Over hyped.
Enter me
Might wanna reword that 🤔