Caste based census is absolutely necessary! This is a country where the monster of caste is standing on every turn influencing the lives of people, benefitting some and discriminating against others. An objective statistically based study is the least that can be done to even begin to root out this problem. For example, the so called general castes are always harassing the SCSTOBC people saying that they are hogging all the government jobs at the peril of the former. A caste based census will bring that claim and its veracity to the light. The only people who can oppose this are the ones who know that they are actually hogging all the premium positions in this country due to their own vedic reservation system ( e.g. collegium in Judiciary) and are afraid that this truth will become openly known.
A newborn baby never knows it's caste, race or religion. It's us adults who repeatedly expose their minds to such classifications and it becomes etched in their mind by the time they are adults
My parents used to talk about Quota seats(reading newspaper) but i was not intersted in them. For me Quota in those time meant Rashan Quota.(we belonged to BPL family in 90s). When i was in 12th class i came to know how it worked. I suffered first time...but still considered it as something sort of government rule which had to be followed. I gave exams for jobs...that was first time i felt betrayed and provoked. Prepared for civils...left me undecided about the issue once again. Thus my journey from being in oblivion to being undecided. But this journey itself says that although in principle the system might not be uncalled for but it with certitude is questionable over uneven resource distribution.
Thank you Apoorva ji The way you connect current happenings with constitution and bring in historical aspect it seems like you were a UPSC CSE aspirant. But this was very helpful as always. God Bless you
Hahaha thank you so much, Rohit! I have definitely been told this before but for now, I'm just happy being a journalist and simplifying the law for you :)
Caste census is very needed to provide representation to all castes in our society because caste is the fundamental social unit in Indian Subcontinent. If Caste census is not done then India will clearly go into civil war led by the Under-represented groups.
@@Peacefulmusic111 When caste is fundamental identity.. give representation caste wise. Inside caste quota for a community.. give quota to half women half men. And inside that quota give quota to Economically weaker sections of that caste. This should be the Ideal representation matrix.
@@royalmauryanknowledgenetwo3743 Do you feel that OBC and ST can not gain any thing in life without reservation....they don't have telent.... They need exposer I agree with you... So in all university and colleges and gov jobs there is reservation..... But cremy layer eat most of that.. Tell me one thing how you will make scientist, doctor, army without merit....... A bania guy can say we don't have proper reserpentation in army... We need quota as per our population...... Bro society cannot run in this way 😼
@@Peacefulmusic111 Reservation was implemented to ensure a level playing field for all.. but in reality it was only token implemented. That is why caste census is needed as a measure of revaluation.. samiksha of reservation. But the opposition from the upper caste is only proving that reservation was implemented only in token not in totality. Otherwise why would uppercaste oppose caste census? If they are at receiving end of reservation policy.. it is them who should be demanding caste census. So upper castes must understand that opposition to caste census... It will only further the doubts about your intention toward the Nation and society in the minds of working classes. It will be beneficial to all if you also support caste census. Not conducting caste census will only bring anarchy into the social order.
@@royalmauryanknowledgenetwo3743 bro lot of imization are going on in your mind........ Cast cencus is only to do more divide...and only for the use of politician....Rather I will tell those poliician who never made any changes in reservation for votes...... Knowing clearly that its benefiting few people and not that reserved society..... Now I know what 80% people who give vote will say that will happen in India...... Not that 1.5%.....
@@yash-lu7qp Because we are hypocritic and we want all our resource investments to remain intact with our community that includes the genetic resources. Moreover we want to chose things according to our convenience. So cast should only be removed in terms of benefits that lower casts are receiving but there is no need to remove cast system in the society. 😂
In ideal society nobody wants caste based reservation but still it's a compulsion to have a caste based census so that everyone can be aware about the actual ground reality of the society. Caste monopoly must be abolished first for the sake of equality to all. When there'll be no monopoly or hierarchy of so called caste system then there'll be no need of reservation. But in today's India , caste based census is must!!!
Constitution did not mention Castes in any Article . Constitution mentioned ' Backward Classes ' and Weaker Sections in Articles 16 (4) and 340 . AND , Article 46 . * Nowhere Constitution mentioned Castes AS CASTES CREATE Jealousy Antipathy and Rivalry as declared by Dr Ambedkar .
Reservation can never be a solution for cast discrimination It will be there until there is the hindu religion .Reservation is most undemocratic thing in a democracy . In modern capitalistic world whosoever ever had the money he has the power . If they have to keep reservations keep it on economic basis it will also stop injustice and dirty politics
@@Vjlabel143 Shia, Sunni and Ahmadiyas are divided by difference in religious beliefs. There difference is like Vaishnav and Shaiv traditions. The caste system is altogether a different beast.
thats division of labour - varna system....not caste! caste is a colonial construct. educate yourself... also shree krishna said that your varna is not determined by your birth...
Hi Apoorva, I just want to know whether Christians can contest polls from Reserved Seats. Because there are two reserved seats in Andhra Pradesh where Christians got elected from those seats. Would you be able to shed light on this please.
Where are those who opposed CAA? Can you advise how many peace loving (Muslims OF COURSE) frightened people have lost their citizenship with CAA so far?
@Gymtim Tim Although, this is really sad. Unfortunately, I do agree with you on this. Liberals would be the ones who would happily convert, the rest, would suffer the worst.
@Gymtim Tim you are either deluded or just larping. The growth of the peaceful community has drastically slowed down over the years just as all of india has we are very close to a replacement rate birth rate. India's population will plateau around 2040 and then go on decreasing. For the current 20% Brahma samaj and arya samaj are already working hard I would suggest you to worry about your own country which might not be around by 2040
@Gymtim Tim seems like the history classes in Pakistan is just as bad as all the other things in that hellhole Let me remind you buddy there have been 4 wars between India and Pakistan. In these wars, You have lost more than half of your country and all the dignity your nation had. Soon Balochistan will be free as Pakistan slips into anarchy and finally the army with a country will lose both the army and the country But before that you have a few days left as a chinese colony and terrorist hot bed I wish you a peaceful life and please say hi to the Chinese side of your family for me😉
जातिगणना बहुत जरूरी है..विदेशी मूल के सवर्ण या तो आबादी के अनुपात मे लेकर मूलनिवासी जाति मे मिक्स हो जाए.. या फिर कुछ नही मिलेगा. यह देश सबका है.. सबको हिस्सा मिलना चाहिए. कुछ लोग खेले और बाकी लोग ताली बचाए ये अब नही चलेगा.
@@vaibhavsingh6108 एक समान शिक्षा व्यवस्था लागू करो फिर.. और डोनेशन कोटा से तुम्हारा क्या संबंध है.. खत्म करो डोनेशन कोटा? और मेरिट चेक करना हो तो सबको पहले बराबर कराओ फिर कंपटीट करो.. फिर देखो किसमे कितना है दम. समाज को गैर-बराबरी वाली व्यवस्था मे बांटकर योग्यता-मेरिट की बात करते हो. 🤣🤣🤣
@@royalmauryanknowledgenetwo3743 bhai konsi si donation di kisne di kisko mili mere engineering College main log obc scholarship ki daaru pete hai...bade aye merit pe gyan dene wale... 😂😂
@@vaibhavsingh6108 स्कालरसिप की दारू सब पीते है.. सवर्ण.. ओबीसी.. एससी.. एसटी सब. और डोनेशन कोटे का पता नही होना यही आपकी मेरिट जगजाहिर कर देता है. 🤣🤣🤣
If there are reservations based on caste, how do you justice the number of candidates recruited with a census? Either give up reservation based on caste or give up census
The problem of this country is people who are absolutely mum on the root problem of caste system in India, but jump up against Reservations. brahmin, baniya, vaishya, shudra , i.e. brahmin dharma's varna system itself is a reservation system working since a long time! Look at Collegium system of Judiciary. It is not merit based but contact based. And thus see the abysmal condition of Judiciary. The Constitutional Reservation is supposed to remedy this caste discrimination, not add to it. People should curse the disease, not curse its medicine.
@@blastard5539 Reservation SHOULD increase until there is equality. Since the problem is casteism and the accompanied discrimination on its basis, Reservation i.e. representation should be given on the same basis.
Totally ridiculous observation. If anyone wants to donate, they shouldn't go for castes based donations. Donations must go to needy people not to a particular caste. If anyone thinks that caste base census is necessary, either they are politician or people with the mind living in 19th century.
How much money you get for this video just because you manipulating the truth that cast based data is used for development I'm agree with you but correcting the point that this data is useful for development of political parties not for public...😡
#जातीय जनगणना पिछले 15 साल में बिहार के विकास और विनाश दोनों में किस जाति की कितनी हिस्सेदारी रही इसकी जातीय जनगणना हो और सरकार इसपर श्वेत पत्र जारी करे और फिर जातीय जनगणना करा के सामाजिक विकाश करे । ruclips.net/video/dZOvq8464OM/видео.html
Very good decision. We cannot go back 30 years from now. Countries are moving forward but in India, people want to be backward.
Who wants to go backwards ?
Back to Vedas?
@@blastard5539 hahaha...lets go to Sultante times..back to build better.
@@blastard5539 nice reply 😂😂
Caste based census is absolutely necessary!
This is a country where the monster of caste is standing on every turn influencing the lives of people, benefitting some and discriminating against others.
An objective statistically based study is the least that can be done to even begin to root out this problem.
For example, the so called general castes are always harassing the SCSTOBC people saying that they are hogging all the government jobs at the peril of the former.
A caste based census will bring that claim and its veracity to the light.
The only people who can oppose this are the ones who know that they are actually hogging all the premium positions in this country due to their own vedic reservation system ( e.g. collegium in Judiciary) and are afraid that this truth will become openly known.
What a joke! Caste census will just ignite caste violence across the country cuz policies based on caste generally tend to be zero sum in nature.
A newborn baby never knows it's caste, race or religion. It's us adults who repeatedly expose their minds to such classifications and it becomes etched in their mind by the time they are adults
My parents used to talk about Quota seats(reading newspaper) but i was not intersted in them. For me Quota in those time meant Rashan Quota.(we belonged to BPL family in 90s).
When i was in 12th class i came to know how it worked.
I suffered first time...but still considered it as something sort of government rule which had to be followed.
I gave exams for jobs...that was first time i felt betrayed and provoked.
Prepared for civils...left me undecided about the issue once again.
Thus my journey from being in oblivion to being undecided.
But this journey itself says that although in principle the system might not be uncalled for but it with certitude is questionable over uneven resource distribution.
But a new born baby should know that his parents were forced to live like animals for 2000 years
@@Navneetkumar-uv8uz his parents? For two thousand years ?
Thank you Apoorva ji
The way you connect current happenings with constitution and bring in historical aspect it seems like you were a UPSC CSE aspirant.
But this was very helpful as always.
God Bless you
Hahaha thank you so much, Rohit! I have definitely been told this before but for now, I'm just happy being a journalist and simplifying the law for you :)
@@apoorvamandhani1181 oh yes please continue with what you are doing, you are awesome in this
Thank You!
@@apoorvamandhani1181 thanks didi...u reduced a competition a bit (kidding). Happy carrier ahead didi :-D
Thank you again, Rohit! :)
Hahahaha Peeri! Thank you so much :D
Caste census is very needed to provide representation to all castes in our society because caste is the fundamental social unit in Indian Subcontinent. If Caste census is not done then India will clearly go into civil war led by the Under-represented groups.
I think... Representation in Indian democracy is as per cast....as in Indian people vote as per there cast...... So why to do census asper cast 🤔
@@Peacefulmusic111 When caste is fundamental identity.. give representation caste wise. Inside caste quota for a community.. give quota to half women half men. And inside that quota give quota to Economically weaker sections of that caste. This should be the Ideal representation matrix.
@@royalmauryanknowledgenetwo3743 Do you feel that OBC and ST can not gain any thing in life without reservation....they don't have telent.... They need exposer I agree with you... So in all university and colleges and gov jobs there is reservation..... But cremy layer eat most of that.. Tell me one thing how you will make scientist, doctor, army without merit....... A bania guy can say we don't have proper reserpentation in army... We need quota as per our population...... Bro society cannot run in this way 😼
@@Peacefulmusic111 Reservation was implemented to ensure a level playing field for all.. but in reality it was only token implemented. That is why caste census is needed as a measure of revaluation.. samiksha of reservation. But the opposition from the upper caste is only proving that reservation was implemented only in token not in totality. Otherwise why would uppercaste oppose caste census? If they are at receiving end of reservation policy.. it is them who should be demanding caste census. So upper castes must understand that opposition to caste census... It will only further the doubts about your intention toward the Nation and society in the minds of working classes. It will be beneficial to all if you also support caste census. Not conducting caste census will only bring anarchy into the social order.
@@royalmauryanknowledgenetwo3743 bro lot of imization are going on in your mind........ Cast cencus is only to do more divide...and only for the use of politician....Rather I will tell those poliician who never made any changes in reservation for votes...... Knowing clearly that its benefiting few people and not that reserved society.....
Now I know what 80% people who give vote will say that will happen in India...... Not that 1.5%.....
जाति से मिला आरक्षण तो सबको दिखता है, लेकिन जाति से मिला शोषण, भेदभाव, ऊंच-नीच, जाति के नाम पर अत्याचार किसी को नही दिखता ..??
I have one question,why people ain't go for ending caste system inspite of reservation
Absolutely right
For the answer, just ask all your friends and family members why do they still practice arranged marriages which are essentially same caste marriages.
@@yash-lu7qp Because we are hypocritic and we want all our resource investments to remain intact with our community that includes the genetic resources. Moreover we want to chose things according to our convenience. So cast should only be removed in terms of benefits that lower casts are receiving but there is no need to remove cast system in the society. 😂
@@amreshsingh3079 we all can contribute to the demise of this system by deciding to marry someone for their individuality and not their caste.
Sir,your question is right discussed , how to make quickly Level every people in India,. Who it
Good explanation. No junk and full substance. Exactly what is needed. TQ Apoorva Mandhani ji.
Caste based census jaaruri hai 🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿
It helps to bring equality in country 🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿
😂lol
@@TanmoyDeb merit walo ki jarurat nahi hai comment karne ki 😂😂😂😂
The main purpose is to strategies the caste vote bank for 2024 elections. Rest of the reasons is just a eye wash.
2:53 Also 🇲🇲Burma (now Myanmar)!
Cast based reservation is ok then cast based census ..why not?
Cuz it will ignite caste violence
Very informative video.
Thank you, Alok! :)
I always make it a point to listen to what you present, Apoorva, not to speak of your colleagues.
Thanks for the informative video 🙏. Great stuff as always
Thank you, Ayush! :D
Actually 97% Brahmin are in powe.that's why BJP will not published census data😁😁😁
Very informative 👍🏾
Please see 🙏🏿🙏🏿
Dr. Laxman Yadav viedo on RUclips on caste based census.
Then talk on caste based census.🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿
Thank you
The good initiative, however, please add data in form of graphics and charts.
In ideal society nobody wants caste based reservation but still it's a compulsion to have a caste based census so that everyone can be aware about the actual ground reality of the society.
Caste monopoly must be abolished first for the sake of equality to all. When there'll be no monopoly or hierarchy of so called caste system then there'll be no need of reservation.
But in today's India , caste based census is must!!!
Caste census will ignite caste violence
Constitution did not mention Castes in any Article .
Constitution mentioned ' Backward Classes ' and Weaker Sections in Articles 16 (4) and 340 . AND , Article 46 .
* Nowhere Constitution mentioned Castes AS CASTES CREATE Jealousy Antipathy and Rivalry as declared by Dr Ambedkar .
This may be a dumb question but if they have the data, can it not be demanded through rti?
No, bcs it's not released under Census of India act.
Reservation can never be a solution for cast discrimination
It will be there until there is the hindu religion .Reservation is
most undemocratic thing in a democracy . In modern capitalistic world whosoever
ever had the money he has the power . If they have to keep reservations keep it on economic basis it will also stop injustice and dirty politics
shia sunni ahamadhiya. will be there until there is in the islam religion.
Ye dekho shia sunni doosra namoona
@@Vjlabel143 Shia, Sunni and Ahmadiyas are divided by difference in religious beliefs. There difference is like Vaishnav and Shaiv traditions. The caste system is altogether a different beast.
Bhat were Brahmins converted into Islam.
Your Brahmanical mentality still works inspite of your conversion😁😁😁😁😁
@Saira Shamsi 😂 pislam is a disease
I am general but identify as Schedule Caste ...
जब तक जाति जनगणना नहीं तब तक कोई ढिलाई नहीं
Hinduism created caste based society....check our bhagavad gita...
thats division of labour - varna system....not caste!
caste is a colonial construct.
educate yourself...
also shree krishna said that your varna is not determined by your birth...
@@shubhamshukla5572 oh yeah. date someone on a lower caste. then the society around you will teach you.
@@kuttalu society is not a homogenous entity.
I can date anyone in a city, but in rural areas you cant date anyone let alone someone not frm yr caste.
@@shubhamshukla5572 no, manusmriti specifically refers to birth based varna, not occupation based. Birth is priori, not posteriori.
Hi Apoorva, I just want to know whether Christians can contest polls from Reserved Seats. Because there are two reserved seats in Andhra Pradesh where Christians got elected from those seats. Would you be able to shed light on this please.
I also want to ask same question
Where are those who opposed CAA? Can you advise how many peace loving (Muslims OF COURSE) frightened people have lost their citizenship with CAA so far?
@Gymtim Tim Although, this is really sad. Unfortunately, I do agree with you on this. Liberals would be the ones who would happily convert, the rest, would suffer the worst.
@Gymtim Tim OH really? hahahah And the 80% will keep quiet?
GROW UP IDIOT
@Gymtim Tim you are either deluded or just larping.
The growth of the peaceful community has drastically slowed down over the years just as all of india has we are very close to a replacement rate birth rate.
India's population will plateau around 2040 and then go on decreasing.
For the current 20% Brahma samaj and arya samaj are already working hard
I would suggest you to worry about your own country which might not be around by 2040
@Gymtim Tim seems like the history classes in Pakistan is just as bad as all the other things in that hellhole
Let me remind you buddy there have been 4 wars between India and Pakistan. In these wars, You have lost more than half of your country and all the dignity your nation had.
Soon Balochistan will be free as Pakistan slips into anarchy and finally the army with a country will lose both the army and the country
But before that you have a few days left as a chinese colony and terrorist hot bed
I wish you a peaceful life and please say hi to the Chinese side of your family for me😉
@Gymtim Tim Ayessha was 6 years old
जातिगणना बहुत जरूरी है..विदेशी मूल के सवर्ण या तो आबादी के अनुपात मे लेकर मूलनिवासी जाति मे मिक्स हो जाए.. या फिर कुछ नही मिलेगा. यह देश सबका है.. सबको हिस्सा मिलना चाहिए. कुछ लोग खेले और बाकी लोग ताली बचाए ये अब नही चलेगा.
Kaunsa hissa humme bhi batao. Kaunsi duniya main je rahe ho. Tum mat pado yeh tumhara problem hai.
@@aj126052 पाकिस्तानी जाये लाहौर समझौते की पैदाईशे. 🤣🤣🤣
@@vaibhavsingh6108 एक समान शिक्षा व्यवस्था लागू करो फिर.. और डोनेशन कोटा से तुम्हारा क्या संबंध है.. खत्म करो डोनेशन कोटा? और मेरिट चेक करना हो तो सबको पहले बराबर कराओ फिर कंपटीट करो.. फिर देखो किसमे कितना है दम. समाज को गैर-बराबरी वाली व्यवस्था मे बांटकर योग्यता-मेरिट की बात करते हो. 🤣🤣🤣
@@royalmauryanknowledgenetwo3743 bhai konsi si donation di kisne di kisko mili mere engineering College main log obc scholarship ki daaru pete hai...bade aye merit pe gyan dene wale... 😂😂
@@vaibhavsingh6108 स्कालरसिप की दारू सब पीते है.. सवर्ण.. ओबीसी.. एससी.. एसटी सब. और डोनेशन कोटे का पता नही होना यही आपकी मेरिट जगजाहिर कर देता है. 🤣🤣🤣
If there are reservations based on caste, how do you justice the number of candidates recruited with a census? Either give up reservation based on caste or give up census
True
Reservation will increase.
The problem of this country is people who are absolutely mum on the root problem of caste system in India, but jump up against Reservations.
brahmin, baniya, vaishya, shudra , i.e. brahmin dharma's varna system itself is a reservation system working since a long time!
Look at Collegium system of Judiciary. It is not merit based but contact based. And thus see the abysmal condition of Judiciary.
The Constitutional Reservation is supposed to remedy this caste discrimination, not add to it.
People should curse the disease, not curse its medicine.
@@blastard5539 Reservation SHOULD increase until there is equality.
Since the problem is casteism and the accompanied discrimination on its basis, Reservation i.e. representation should be given on the same basis.
@@Masterofmultiverse how much should be 67% percent where would i go mate?
Good
Totally ridiculous observation. If anyone wants to donate, they shouldn't go for castes based donations. Donations must go to needy people not to a particular caste. If anyone thinks that caste base census is necessary, either they are politician or people with the mind living in 19th century.
Religion and cast based both can be stopped
Religion based census is also need of the hour.
Use some more graphics
Good morning
How much money you get for this video just because you manipulating the truth that cast based data is used for development I'm agree with you but correcting the point that this data is useful for development of political parties not for public...😡
Right banty ji
Left propaganda band karo
Apporva plz marry me
Why does this bhumi Pednekar look-alike always talk about caste.?
Ask vedas form were the caste bullshit emerged
#जातीय जनगणना
पिछले 15 साल में बिहार के विकास और विनाश दोनों में किस जाति की कितनी हिस्सेदारी रही इसकी जातीय जनगणना हो और सरकार इसपर श्वेत पत्र जारी करे और फिर जातीय जनगणना करा के सामाजिक विकाश करे ।
ruclips.net/video/dZOvq8464OM/видео.html