The best historical war movie I've ever seen and I dare say it was far better than the Hollywood garbage about Napoleon! The environment, the uniforms, the weapons!! Everything in the movie was incredible and I could barely tell when it was CGI, very well done and congratulations to the director!
@@astrodoops They won't accept it. Modern Russia is not the Soviet Union, when a division of soldiers was used for filming and the next Sergei Bondarchuk has not yet been born in Russia (by the way, his son, Fyodor, is a pale shadow of his father both as a person and as a director). I tell you this as a Russian living in Russia. 🤔 Like any feature film, this one also has historical inaccuracies. In Russia they say "I'm an artist, that's how I see it" - this concerns how some directors film, making changes to the picture that distort many things, including historical facts.
this move was made 2019. it is heavily fuelled by the Russian interest to rump up nationalism in younger people and was supported by the russian state with tax-payer money. A russian critic called the show "complementary to young people, idealists who are ready to give their lives for the fatherland." Non of these scenes in "ukraine" were actual in the occupied parts of Ukraine, but in Belgorod, the district with the main bases for the forces, involved in the warcrimes of the 2nd invasion of Ukraine. Some scenes, who played in Ukraine, were ladled as part of (Tsar)-Russia, explicit Charkiv, besieged and still attempted to be captured by the Russian aggressor in this invasion RIGHT NOW. 1864 is actual better and got support for their creation in denmark and germany, both sides of this war to allow less empty propaganda in it, while receiving the support of both national historic groups in it. i will add, that ToraToraTora, The Longest Day and Waterloo are war-movies too, who are obliviously better than this war movie.
A bit of history) Emperor Alexander 1, according to this film, is the emperor who died in Taganrog, was involved in the plans of the conspirators who killed his father, Paul 1. He did not want his father to die, but after learning that he was still killed, he blamed himself for what happened for the rest of his life. An interesting fact is that in the last years of his life he often spoke of his intention to abdicate and "retire from the world", which after his unexpected death in Taganrog gave rise to the legend of "elder Fyodor Kuzmich". According to this legend, it was not Alexander who died and was then buried in Taganrog, but his double. Later, in the 1830s and 1840s, a legend appeared that Alexander, allegedly tormented by remorse (as an accomplice to the murder of his father), staged his death far from the capital and began a wandering, hermit life under the name of elder Fyodor Kuzmich (died January 20, 1864 in Tomsk. This legend appeared already during the life of the Siberian elder and became widespread in the second half of the XIX century.
It’s with English subtitles! Finally. All the others are in Russian and if you choose English subtitles they don’t make sense and there is another with English and I think Chinese subtitles but the voices clearly don’t match those speaking. Thank you
@@MrEthnicCcan only imagine how long that took you. Also to find this video when I put the name of the movie in it’s so far down on the list I almost gave up looking because all of the other ones in Russian and the one with English and Chinese and the ones that show just certain scenes are higher up. I hope you can get a lot more views! Thanks again!
@@debrakleid5752 It took me 4 or 5 days of coming back from work at 4pm and translating until 3 am every day. For some reason I was REALLY determined to get that done as soon as possible. Not speaking Russian also didn't help. I didn't even realise youtube decided to not display my vid at the top even when typing the exict video title, thanks for pointing it out, I will tinker a bit more with tags to hopefully allow people find it easier.
This mutiny of young dreamers was just an iceberg top of the huge negotiations inside of Russian elite groups. You can hear in the movie that Konstantin sat in Warsaw and St.Petersburg elite was afraid he will bfing his Polish friends to the capital.
They were the bad guys, God saved Russia in 1825, not so much in 1917. The Alliance of Salvation was composed of members of the Russian elite, who wanted the power to themselves. They were irreligious/atheist, something antithetical to 99,9% of the Russian population at the time. Plus they were Freemasons. They said they wanted to abolish serfdom and reduce military terms, not realizing that they existed for a reason. Abolishing serfdom in 1825 was impossible, from both the nobles and the peasants POV. Russian peasants benefited from serfdom, since Russia's massive territory made it impossible to have many small privately owned farms. Abolishing serfdom in 1825, would have meant a demographic disaster unlike any in history, since millions would have died within a year (if it were abolished then in 1825). This would have meant a civil war, and an alliance of both nobles and peasants against the would be government made of members of the Alliance. Hope this cleared things up for you, given that you thought they were the "good guys". Cheers.
FYI: Czest’ imieju (Честь имею) = literally means “It’s been an honor”, “This is quite an honor”; “Allow me to bid farewell”, “I shall take my leave of you (Sir/Madame)”
Love that close up shot of that pistol being fired, the flint hitting the hammer, sparks hitting the pan, a bright flash followed by a concussive BOOM! This movie really made the weapons feel like characters.
Ironically many Russians seem to think that Russia is better at fighting wars then film making. Between this film and what's going on in Ukraine....evidently not.
Wow! What an amazing film! I loved the incredible cinematography and the amazing attention to detail, plus the acting was also superb. I'll be watching this one again--and again.
God i've been WAITING for the english translated version for YEARS! now it pops out on my youtube recommendation, thank you SO MUCH man! you saved my time searching on web to web for hours. THANK you again!
The movie is terrible. It justifies Tsar Nicholas 1 in every possible way, under whom slavery and oppression of peoples in Russia reached its highest point. And the revolutionaries who wanted to make Russia a modern country were exposed as idiots and utopian dreamers
all that the so-called Russian cinema did, all these thirty years after the collapse of the USSR, was what Hollywood tried to copy. The first imitator is Mikhalkov
all that the so-called Russian cinema did, all these thirty years after the collapse of the USSR, was what Hollywood tried to copy. The first imitator is Mikhalkov
all that the so-called Russian cinema did, all these thirty years after the collapse of the USSR, was what Hollywood tried to copy. The first imitator is Mikhalkov
I hope the filmmaker sees the comments and likes on this video and realize how much the international audience appreciates this movie. It was unjustly targeted by political critics of Russian government. As a piece of art this is a very well made movie and the historical portrayal is quite accurate. No overdramatization or herocentrism which in my view ruins many historical films.
so the Russian people are well versed about the events that lead up to this although they were not alive and this version is completely different to the actual history in the archives. And you’re a western clown who believes that Russians support Ukraine and hate their own country and you’re speaking on behalf of Russian. Got it.
@@noname-nd8ecwould you explain which part shares little semblance? Are you one of the 🤡 who despise Russia and think Russians support Ukraine and hate their own country? You’re one of those self proclaimed “expert” who’ve never met a Russians and has no interest in seeing Russia do well. Nobody asked for your opinion.
@@noname-nd8ecwhich part bares "little semblance" to the actual movie? from what i read this looks pretty accurate. Where do you meet these Russian audience who so "well versed" in the events leading up to the coup? You are very likely one of those sanctimonous and condesending brainwashed russophobes who thinks Russians support Ukraine over their own country.
@@noname-nd8ec the movie pretty much portrays the history as it’s recorded in the archives with some alterations in the battle scenes. I want to know where you met the “Russian audience” who are well versed on an alternate history. You don’t like Russia and you’ve no clue about Russia yet you know so much about how the “Russian audience” feels. I bet you’re one of those “Slava Ukraini” guys.
A great movie!!!! a Bit difficult to follow due many participans. Photography is very well done, good oversight in storyline, and the militairy aspect; the effect of grapeshot is impressive. The Hollywoon movie Napoleon is childplay in comparisson with this movie.
This movie is well done but it's hard to follow due to its plot not matching the reality. This movie was funded by the money from the state so the plot tries to follow the agenda that makes the Tzar's action more merciful and understandable while the Decembrists' motives seem vague and kind of chaotic, which is a shame considering how well this movie is made in technical terms.
@@NameNik223 Decembrists's motives were really chaotic and the revolt factually stopped the reforms. If you read the "Pestel's pravda", you will see it.
How is it "weak in terms of plot"? I found it complex and thrilling. It is subtle and pervasive and therefore deeply convincing in terms of motive and character. The plot is the first attempted Color Revolution and attempted Regime Change Op by the West of its natural superior and only global super-power, Russia. That is something that cannot be told in soundbites and therefore has not been dumbed down in the slightest for a slothful and ignorant audience.
@@franzkafka293it is not weak in terms of plot. It’s an excellent movie, nothing overdramatic. Russians have a habit of putting their own down. If this movie was made by Hollywood he would be raving about it. Look at the English comments which praise the movie and Russian comments which demean the film.
This film is particularly fascinating to me, my ancestors were white Russian nobility from the Chernihiv region of Ukraine. Mikhail Lvovich Slezkin my great-great-great-grandfather 1819 - 1877 and his son Lev Mikailovich Slezkin 1855 - 1928, my great-great-grandfather ended their careers with the rank of lieutenant general in the Imperial Army. I came upon it accidentally, and funnily enough they also spent their early formative years in France before attending a military academy in St. Petersburg. My great-great aunt was a lady-in-waiting for the last Tsarina.
@@gregorydesleskine3413 Don't embarrass yourself. You're just a liar and a regular country fool with nothing to do with Russia. Because if you had even a drop of Russian officer blood in you, you wouldn't have put that flag on your profile picture, at the very least.
There are the orchestral versions of famous Russian modern songs. At least Баста - Сансара ruclips.net/video/aiCL0-U9WxI/видео.htmlsi=BxAXR6D8R0gWKsbU and Наутилус Помпилиус - Прогулки на воде. ruclips.net/video/o-Mrbt_QHd8/видео.htmlsi=IeRRqB4JQzG0YoU1
Technically it is well done by any measure: camera POV, panoramic sweeps, close ups, lightings, shadows and mis-en-scene. It is a visual feast as well as an audio delight.
I don't know if you'd do any requests but another russian gem we can't watch for similar reasons as this movie is the sovereign servant, do you have any ideas on where to find an english subbed version or a have a way to upload one here? No problems if the answer is a no
Russia is such an interesting nation with a very interesting history. I'm glad such a well-made movie could shine some light on a lesser known(to me and possibly 'the west') historical event of such drama and importance.
The one that surprised me in all this was Col. Prince Trubekskoy. He seemed to just give up after hearing the Imperial Senate swore loyalty to Tsar Nicholas and suffered some kind of mental break down. His exemplary military record and his noted oratory and leadership skills makes his behavior hard to explain that day.
Finnaly, the film with English subtitles. I wanted to watch this film for a long time, but I didn't undferstand the weird english subtitles, and now I can watch the film in all its glory
Our people wouldn't quite agree with you. We can make good films that can be enjoyed abroad like this one. But there are also not so many. Some people like it, and some don't
success at the box office was only in those countries that translate films from other countries. The fucking monopoly of the West. For some reason, I can watch English-language movies, Chinese, Hindi with any Russian dubbing. And in the West, this turns out to be a problem.
@@teltos6817why do you watch? Dubbing must be banned in Russia. Dubbing is what’s destroying Russian move industry. And I hate dubbing, how do you guys watched dubbed films? Doesn’t it bother you when the lips don’t match the words?
@@prodigiii712 What about freedom of speech? Or is banning culture from other countries a democracy? You can watch dubbed news, but politics does not allow movies. This is medieval savagery. Even after watching this film, you can understand that Russians studied French and German at that time.
Those people who are against, but do not have an idea, but simply oppose someone, will never succeed. These people had no idea, they were just against the government. They didn't have a plan for what they would do when they achieved their goal. It was stupid.
What are you talking about? The Decemberists had drafted several versions of the future Constitution and had a plan of liberal reforms. Pestel, in particular, was a prolific writer and thinker whose thought later influenced Russian anarchists and socialists, including Lenin. The movie doesn't cover this but you could at least check Wiki before commenting.
@@jasont4206 It's one thing to write, but a whole other thing to implement. Serfdom in Russia benefited the Russian peasants,(don't get me wrong, ofc it wasn't perfect) Russia's geography did not (and to this day) didn't allow for many small privately owned farms to develop, instead, multiple peasants (or even villages) worked under one landowner, and thus they had a secure market for their products( and for the landowner as well), and a stable constant income. That's as far as serfdom is concerned, as far as constitution, it was irrelevant, since all the conspirators were from rich landowning families and only wanted the power to themselves, the constitution drafts were just a ruse to attract liberals in Saint Petersburg.
Maybe it was fortune or luck on the House of Romanov that no one knew who the new Emperor was following Alexander's death. The entire Imperial Family knew Alexander wanted Nicholas to secede him, but the upper echolons of the Military and the Imperial Senate had no idea and still thought Konstantin was Emperor. Nicholas allegedly wrote to Konstantin to come too St. Petersburg to renounce the throne from Warsaw where he was acting as Commander-in-Chief of the Army of Poland but Konstantin refused fearful of being strangeled in bed as their father had been. This confusion I think muddled the Decemberists plot.
Better watch the series "Union of Salvation. The time of anger." Basically, people didn't like the movie. You just can't fit that much information into 2 hours. Even 8 episodes of one hour is not enough for this topic.
1:57:37 Why would you bring a child to an interogation? There was said a moment (The Romanov Documentary) where Nikoolai asked his son, the future Alexander II, what would he have done to the Decembrist? Alexander said to have replied that he would forgive them
Amazing work. Putting subtitles to Russia shows. One request would you be able to get Saladin The Conquer series from trt with English subtitles apart from episode 1 it's unavailable with English subtitles. Ill look at rest of your videos soon. You need a thanks option $
Has anyone noticed that scene where they are drinking and the rock like music is playing and "The Union of Salvation" gets recognized. It is out of historical frame but works really well somehow??? I have noticed this style of directing in a few Russian films but also In Wolfenstein 2: New Colosses with the American communist revolutionary. Just something I noticed
@1:49:22 -- When Trubetsky is questioned, "Why did you lead a revolt?" he answered as if he had led, 90 years later, the Easter Rebellion in Dublin. You know, the mere effort to establish a republic against autocracy, even if it fails, will light the way to the future. The leaders of the Easter Rebellion held out for a week, and were summarily executed, without trial, by the English. Here, the revolt was dispersed by the first use of force, and the trials and investigations lasted for the better part of a year. The Decembrists led the way to the assassination of Alexander II, who freed the serfs, and that of Nicholas II, to clear the way for the Bolshevik dictatorship and terror, which lasted until 1991. Martyrs do not always get what they hope for.
So called "Bolshevik terror" or "Red terror" was period of time in 1918-1922, it's an official naming, as a responce of Bolsheviks to multiple violent actions of various opposition groups in summer 1918, which led to Civil war. Only in western propaganda all period up until 1991 is called that way:)
Ваше мнение основано на заблуждении, что властьимущие добровольно отдадут все что было ими захвачено на протяжении веков. НАСТОЯТЕЛЬНО РЕКОМЕНДУЮ проследить причинно следственную связь
@@EvgeniiKrupenin Do you think that England gave up power in Ireland voluntarily? The Easter Rebellion's martyrdom initiated a widespread revolt in Ireland. The martyrdom of the the Decembrists did not. It lead to a model of assassination of emperors.
Hate to break it to You but I don't actually speak Russian, I might try to force myself to translate it like I did with this one at some point but as of now I'm too busy. Also where can i find the series? I was looking for it a while ago but couldn't find anything and gave up.
@@MrEthnicC Yandex. Put Rutracker in the search box along with the name if you can't find it. The Rutracker post also has some useful discussion to read.
@@elfi-z8n I translated from a version with Polish lyrics, it wasn't perfect but definitely more understandable than english versions online. First version I made had some mistakes but I had a Russian friend who helped me and corrected them.
@19:05 --"By what law have we been sentenced?" The answer Prince Nikolai gave was, The Word of the Emperor is Law. That was the crucial contradiction, in the many pronouncements of Aleksandr Pervyi -- he wanted a constitutional regime, but intended to retain un-constitutional power in his hands. It sounds strange to us today to have someone say, "The highest will" and mean the Word of the Emperor, but "All-highest" was the standard term to refer to the tsar.
Until the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution of the USA, Kings were anointed by God to rule. It was by God's will, and God is infallible, that a person was born a King, a peasant (serf, different than a peasant), or a criminal. The USA declared forever that ALL MEN ARE CREATED EQUAL and that ended thousands of years of Royal Rules. What would Russia have become if the Decembrists had succeeded??? Would the revolution that changed Rusia and the World have happened? Would Lenin have succeeded in his communist goals???
@@sjb3460 Yep instead the USA made billionaires their kings and made people even less equal and then started wars all around the world and putting their military bases in almost every country. They also then overthrew a bunch of governments and facilitated coups. Resulting in millions of innocent deaths around the world. USA USA USA
@sjb3460 1. Good that you mention that USA told only about MEN (nowadays it is somehow forgotten). But you also forgot, that they meant actually not even all men… no, not even all white men (hello Irish) :D They told only about small bunch of very specific group of men. From this point of view, in most kingdoms people had more right than in USA. Actually even in 20 century people in US had less rights than most people in Europe in 19, 18 and 17 centuries. 2. De facto first communist is Gracchus Babeuf, in is late 18 century, France. So, it is complicated to discuss what would happens. From one side revolution of 1917 directly have roots in this events. 1825 not gone, arrived several waves of revolutionists (main wave is 1860s) which in result born Lenin. But this is only one side, from my opinion not important. Who really cares about constitution and some "rights"? It is fiction which is irrelevant for life of 99,99% of people. Give nothing. From another side, Lenin build communism. And communism it is mainly about different things: economical system, real equality of people (don’t tell me fairy tales, that me and Bill Gates are equal, I’m dust, while he is God from Olympus), about property. So, even if revolution happened in 1825, unlikely it could cancel attempts of communistic revolution. Like nobody canceled it nowadays. If someone will propose it to me now, I’m will support, why not. But if you ask me, what I prefer: constitution with parliament/president or monarchy without any constitution or main law - I don’t care, anything, it is literally irrelevant.
@@juliap.5375 yes, but the idea has to start somewhere. you're overlaying the culture of today with the concept of 200 years ago. And now, we're "woke" and down some rabbit hole. "all men" was the first step away from King's divine Right of Rule. Then, more steps.
J'aime beaucoup cette forme de scénario avec d'impressionnantes performance des acteurs 16.20.minute. J'apprends a écouter le russe a lire l'anglais car je suis Canadien français d'Amérique du Nord côté Est. Autre chose. En 1825 l'Alaska était russe et en 1863, St Petersbourg l'empereur a tenté de vendre l'Alaska pour 7 millions de dollars. Après discussion le congrès ne voulait pas cette terre aride désertique et froide , oui le congrès américain a signé l'achat de Alaska.
@@СтаниславШнайдер-ъ3н В чем пропаганда?В том что декабристы дров наломали,и загубили столько жизней?По какому праву Николай должен был уступить,просто потому что какой то Вася захотел?
In my personal opinion, this movie is a good one. The acting, the choreography, the music, it's all well-rounded. However, I think the pace of the plot is a bit too fast and the duration is too short; maybe if they make it into a 4-hour movie, the plot could've been deeper and more detailed, at the same time allowing us who aren't exactly familiar with the December revolt history to chew and digest the story better. If I'm to make an analogy, it's like being served a prime, medium rare ribeye steak and told to eat it under 10 minutes. It's doable, and the steak will be delicious nonetheless, but I sure would like to savor it a little longer.
This movie has later been remade into an 8-episode series "Union of Salvation: Time of Anger", which is more well-paced (but I don't think there are English subtitles for it)
Декабристы не планировали отмену крепостного права. Эту легенду позже придумали большевики. Они планировали свержение царя и установление оллигархической республики.
Если я посчитаю, что мое предназначение отобрать вашу хату и жену, ваша свобода в том, чтобы это защитить. Стало быть, было бы справедливо, если бы меня после не преследовали 😏
This is an excellent movie even though it’s not accurate I love it surely better than the new Napoleon because atleast it a realistic, entertaining, based on actual true events, and has great action. The grapeshot scene is excellent as it correctly portrays how cannons work rather than exploding which is not what roundshot does the men sound like they are actually getting hit again this movie is great
@@yurikropotov3135 zdes ne filologicheskyi kruzhok. lutshe, chem nichego. bolee obidno, chto istoriya povtorayetsa. vse v krovi budet. russia budet v krovi skoro. na urovne srednem.
@alexejgorodnicenko7295 Вообще ничего не повторяется. Ну и с чего это Россия будет в крови? Мы вообще-то стоим на пороге того, что вероятно Европа будет превращена в радиоактивную пустыню. Вот это более вероятно. Ну или даже весь мир. А в России всё спокойно.
This looks good and all. But there's something missing. Just like western modern media the acting feels hollow. They play their characters like they are robots without feeling, just following a program. Look to the english tv series (Hornblower) for an example in what acting should look like in my opinion.
I cannot fathom what their plan was. It seems absurdist in execution. What is also weird is how sympathetic the Tsars are portrayed as. Good music and brilliant cinematography. The time-cuts were an interesting device certainly.
A day before the start of the uprising, the gendarmerie arrested the head of the Southern Society, Pavel Pestel. The Decembrists decided to prevent the troops and the Senate from taking the oath of office to the new emperor. The rebellious troops were to occupy the Winter Palace and the Peter and Paul Fortress, the royal family was planned to be arrested and, under certain circumstances, killed. Prince Sergei Trubetskoy was elected to lead the uprising. After that, it was planned to demand that the Senate publish a nationwide Manifesto proclaiming the "destruction of the former government" and the establishment of a provisional revolutionary government. It was supposed to make Count M. M. Speransky and Admiral N. S. Mordvinov its members (later they became members of the Decembrist trial). The deputies had to approve a new basic law - the constitution. If the Senate had not agreed to publish the people's manifesto, it was decided to force him to do so. The manifesto contained several points: the establishment of provisional revolutionary governments
But their slowness allowed the emperor to gather enough strength and close them in a ring. I personally was in St. Petersburg and I can say for myself if they had started acting immediately, seized fortresses and set up barricades in the streets. Then the battle would have turned into many battles of 300 Spartans. The streets are narrow and the blocks are square. Plus, the Peter and Paul Fortress has an ideal view of the winter palace. They would have lasted at least a day. And at night, riots might have started and everything would have gone downhill.
Ваши ощущения вас не обманули. У них действительно не было четкой программы и плана реализации. Сплошной сумбур и романтические бредни. Никто из них НЕ МОГ научно разработать концепцию. При этом они пытались решить свои шкурные интересы. 😊
It’s true. The punishment for what did was quartering but they were hanged which is much less painful and many of them were either imprisoned or exiled. The “dictator” in the group was eventually pardoned by Nicholas’s son and even got back his title. I don’t think the Romanovs were overtly cruel esp when compared to the Bolsheviks.
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
The best historical war movie I've ever seen and I dare say it was far better than the Hollywood garbage about Napoleon!
The environment, the uniforms, the weapons!!
Everything in the movie was incredible and I could barely tell when it was CGI, very well done and congratulations to the director!
Napoleon is horrible, but Waterloo is amazing. And if it helps, features thousands of trained Russian extras in the battles.
@astrodoops Napoleon was a fine French fellow, from everything I've read and heard about him.👍
@@astrodoops They won't accept it. Modern Russia is not the Soviet Union, when a division of soldiers was used for filming and the next Sergei Bondarchuk has not yet been born in Russia (by the way, his son, Fyodor, is a pale shadow of his father both as a person and as a director). I tell you this as a Russian living in Russia. 🤔 Like any feature film, this one also has historical inaccuracies. In Russia they say "I'm an artist, that's how I see it" - this concerns how some directors film, making changes to the picture that distort many things, including historical facts.
@@nicolasoltonactually he was Corsican. All his bodyguards were also Corsicans
this move was made 2019.
it is heavily fuelled by the Russian interest to rump up nationalism in younger people and was supported by the russian state with tax-payer money.
A russian critic called the show "complementary to young people, idealists who are ready to give their lives for the fatherland."
Non of these scenes in "ukraine" were actual in the occupied parts of Ukraine, but in Belgorod, the district with the main bases for the forces, involved in the warcrimes of the 2nd invasion of Ukraine. Some scenes, who played in Ukraine, were ladled as part of (Tsar)-Russia, explicit Charkiv, besieged and still attempted to be captured by the Russian aggressor in this invasion RIGHT NOW.
1864 is actual better and got support for their creation in denmark and germany, both sides of this war to allow less empty propaganda in it, while receiving the support of both national historic groups in it.
i will add, that ToraToraTora, The Longest Day and Waterloo are war-movies too, who are obliviously better than this war movie.
Thanks,I’ve been searching the film with English subtitles for a long time now,thank you!
Same
congrats soup boy
yeah same.
Ayyyyy bloodandiron player. I play bloodandiron too
A bit of history) Emperor Alexander 1, according to this film, is the emperor who died in Taganrog, was involved in the plans of the conspirators who killed his father, Paul 1. He did not want his father to die, but after learning that he was still killed, he blamed himself for what happened for the rest of his life. An interesting fact is that in the last years of his life he often spoke of his intention to abdicate and "retire from the world", which after his unexpected death in Taganrog gave rise to the legend of "elder Fyodor Kuzmich". According to this legend, it was not Alexander who died and was then buried in Taganrog, but his double.
Later, in the 1830s and 1840s, a legend appeared that Alexander, allegedly tormented by remorse (as an accomplice to the murder of his father), staged his death far from the capital and began a wandering, hermit life under the name of elder Fyodor Kuzmich (died January 20, 1864 in Tomsk. This legend appeared already during the life of the Siberian elder and became widespread in the second half of the XIX century.
Alexander was buried in St.Petersburg
It’s with English subtitles! Finally. All the others are in Russian and if you choose English subtitles they don’t make sense and there is another with English and I think Chinese subtitles but the voices clearly don’t match those speaking. Thank you
Yeah that annoyed me so much that I decided to make the translation myself
@@MrEthnicC You did it? Well, I cannot thank you enough!!
@@MrEthnicCcan only imagine how long that took you. Also to find this video when I put the name of the movie in it’s so far down on the list I almost gave up looking because all of the other ones in Russian and the one with English and Chinese and the ones that show just certain scenes are higher up. I hope you can get a lot more views! Thanks again!
@@debrakleid5752 he had been translating it for 3 days straight (+/-8 hours per day) and got assistance from a real life russian
@@debrakleid5752 It took me 4 or 5 days of coming back from work at 4pm and translating until 3 am every day. For some reason I was REALLY determined to get that done as soon as possible. Not speaking Russian also didn't help.
I didn't even realise youtube decided to not display my vid at the top even when typing the exict video title, thanks for pointing it out, I will tinker a bit more with tags to hopefully allow people find it easier.
bad timing, bad planning, bad leadership and bad luck is all that I can say about this revolution
This mutiny of young dreamers was just an iceberg top of the huge negotiations inside of Russian elite groups.
You can hear in the movie that Konstantin sat in Warsaw and St.Petersburg elite was afraid he will bfing his Polish friends to the capital.
Бог помог России. Ура Николай!
They were the bad guys, God saved Russia in 1825, not so much in 1917. The Alliance of Salvation was composed of members of the Russian elite, who wanted the power to themselves. They were irreligious/atheist, something antithetical to 99,9% of the Russian population at the time. Plus they were Freemasons. They said they wanted to abolish serfdom and reduce military terms, not realizing that they existed for a reason. Abolishing serfdom in 1825 was impossible, from both the nobles and the peasants POV. Russian peasants benefited from serfdom, since Russia's massive territory made it impossible to have many small privately owned farms. Abolishing serfdom in 1825, would have meant a demographic disaster unlike any in history, since millions would have died within a year (if it were abolished then in 1825). This would have meant a civil war, and an alliance of both nobles and peasants against the would be government made of members of the Alliance. Hope this cleared things up for you, given that you thought they were the "good guys". Cheers.
FYI: Czest’ imieju (Честь имею) = literally means “It’s been an honor”, “This is quite an honor”; “Allow me to bid farewell”, “I shall take my leave of you (Sir/Madame)”
thank you
Pehaps "I have the honor" or "The honor is mine (of addressing you)".
@@franzkafka293no
@@lounflexmachine87 yes, Честь имею means in literal translation I have the honor.
@@franzkafka293 By the way, I advise you to watch a Russian film about the war in Chechnya. It is called "I have the honor". You will like it.
Love that close up shot of that pistol being fired, the flint hitting the hammer, sparks hitting the pan, a bright flash followed by a concussive BOOM! This movie really made the weapons feel like characters.
You just have to be a Yenghi.
You have done well for thousands of historical fans on this topic. You are the one we needed, I am glad you made this video!
😂 вы называете этот фильм историческим, не удивлюсь если вы учителя историю Турции по сериала великолепный век😂
@@Кто-то-у8х8г Have you any further information on this claim of yours or are you simply enjoying insulting people?
@@Кто-то-у8х8г хах, товарищ)
Originally it is series (8 episodes, 6+ hours).
While this is just short complication (2 hours).
@@juliap.5375That's awesome to hear, there was much work put to it indeed. Maybe I'll get to the series entire once.
The Russians have certainly mastered the art of film making, bravo and thanks so much!
@@StokedToker most of their film are lame
@@mimorisenpai8540 САМ ТЫ УБОГИЙ
@@mimorisenpai8540 depends
@@mimorisenpai8540 but many people think that anime is shit
Ironically many Russians seem to think that Russia is better at fighting wars then film making. Between this film and what's going on in Ukraine....evidently not.
Wow! What an amazing film! I loved the incredible cinematography and the amazing attention to detail, plus the acting was also superb. I'll be watching this one again--and again.
God i've been WAITING for the english translated version for YEARS! now it pops out on my youtube recommendation, thank you SO MUCH man! you saved my time searching on web to web for hours. THANK you again!
A brilliant movie. I am so glad to have seen a version with English translation.
Thank you, I've been waiting for this with English subtitles for so long. Excellent!
Good Niche film. Russians know how to make napoleonic era movies!
The "niche" is lot bigger than you think. You probably live in the West.
@@franzkafka293 1820s set historical dramas are a niche.
Эпоха была России!
@@g.mtorsten3564 Exactly. Not enough films get made about the early 19th century, and that's such a bummer!
...historically accurate films, that is.
They’re very good at it especially the flim Waterloo
It's so much better than the Napoleon film
Dude, anything is better than Napoleon.
That's was a truly awful movie.
Hollywood should learn again from this movie.
The movie is terrible. It justifies Tsar Nicholas 1 in every possible way, under whom slavery and oppression of peoples in Russia reached its highest point. And the revolutionaries who wanted to make Russia a modern country were exposed as idiots and utopian dreamers
What do you mean "again"? Hollywood could have never and never have made such a magnificent film.
all that the so-called Russian cinema did, all these thirty years after the collapse of the USSR, was what Hollywood tried to copy. The first imitator is Mikhalkov
all that the so-called Russian cinema did, all these thirty years after the collapse of the USSR, was what Hollywood tried to copy. The first imitator is Mikhalkov
all that the so-called Russian cinema did, all these thirty years after the collapse of the USSR, was what Hollywood tried to copy. The first imitator is Mikhalkov
No one makes movies with such mastery, depth and knowledge, technical, historical and cinematographic, than the Russians! Urrah!
I hope the filmmaker sees the comments and likes on this video and realize how much the international audience appreciates this movie. It was unjustly targeted by political critics of Russian government. As a piece of art this is a very well made movie and the historical portrayal is quite accurate. No overdramatization or herocentrism which in my view ruins many historical films.
the international audience sees this as nothing but russian propaganda. so go f k yours3lf, orc
so the Russian people are well versed about the events that lead up to this although they were not alive and this version is completely different to the actual history in the archives. And you’re a western clown who believes that Russians support Ukraine and hate their own country and you’re speaking on behalf of Russian. Got it.
@@noname-nd8ecwould you explain which part shares little semblance? Are you one of the 🤡 who despise Russia and think Russians support Ukraine and hate their own country? You’re one of those self proclaimed “expert” who’ve never met a Russians and has no interest in seeing Russia do well. Nobody asked for your opinion.
@@noname-nd8ecwhich part bares "little semblance" to the actual movie? from what i read this looks pretty accurate. Where do you meet these Russian audience who so "well versed" in the events leading up to the coup? You are very likely one of those sanctimonous and condesending brainwashed russophobes who thinks Russians support Ukraine over their own country.
@@noname-nd8ec the movie pretty much portrays the history as it’s recorded in the archives with some alterations in the battle scenes. I want to know where you met the “Russian audience” who are well versed on an alternate history. You don’t like Russia and you’ve no clue about Russia yet you know so much about how the “Russian audience” feels. I bet you’re one of those “Slava Ukraini” guys.
Strange as it sounds, thank you Ethnic Buttstabber!
Beautiful movie, i finished it with in two day with englsh subtitle.
The uniforms are fantastic wants to go in this era in 1925.
1825
Thank you for the wonderful upload. Been searching for years download with good English subtitle.
A great movie!!!! a Bit difficult to follow due many participans. Photography is very well done, good oversight in storyline, and the militairy aspect; the effect of grapeshot is impressive.
The Hollywoon movie Napoleon is childplay in comparisson with this movie.
Bollywood version coming next, G
Insh'Allah. ❤👍🙏
This movie is well done but it's hard to follow due to its plot not matching the reality. This movie was funded by the money from the state so the plot tries to follow the agenda that makes the Tzar's action more merciful and understandable while the Decembrists' motives seem vague and kind of chaotic, which is a shame considering how well this movie is made in technical terms.
@@NameNik223 Decembrists's motives were really chaotic and the revolt factually stopped the reforms. If you read the "Pestel's pravda", you will see it.
Спасибо за залив! Сам фильм сюжетно слабый, но эффекты, саундтрек и общая атмосфера наряду с отличными костюмами на высоте.
How is it "weak in terms of plot"? I found it complex and thrilling. It is subtle and pervasive and therefore deeply convincing in terms of motive and character. The plot is the first attempted Color Revolution and attempted Regime Change Op by the West of its natural superior and only global super-power, Russia. That is something that cannot be told in soundbites and therefore has not been dumbed down in the slightest for a slothful and ignorant audience.
МУЖИКИ В ФОРМЕ!!!
если бы именно этот фильм был снят Голливудом, вы бы были в восторге от него. мы знаем, что русские - самые ненавидящие себя существа в мире.
@@franzkafka293it is not weak in terms of plot. It’s an excellent movie, nothing overdramatic. Russians have a habit of putting their own down. If this movie was made by Hollywood he would be raving about it. Look at the English comments which praise the movie and Russian comments which demean the film.
В головушке кака
This film is particularly fascinating to me, my ancestors were white Russian nobility from the Chernihiv region of Ukraine. Mikhail Lvovich Slezkin my great-great-great-grandfather 1819 - 1877 and his son Lev Mikailovich Slezkin 1855 - 1928, my great-great-grandfather ended their careers with the rank of lieutenant general in the Imperial Army. I came upon it accidentally, and funnily enough they also spent their early formative years in France before attending a military academy in St. Petersburg. My great-great aunt was a lady-in-waiting for the last Tsarina.
Its spelt Chernogov in English
человек с этими данными был не в армии а в жандармерии и сыновья тоже генералы так что ты просто лжешь
@@поварлиза I can prove it.
@@MattiavonSigmund No, Chernihiv, learn how to spell it correctly.
@@gregorydesleskine3413 Don't embarrass yourself. You're just a liar and a regular country fool with nothing to do with Russia. Because if you had even a drop of Russian officer blood in you, you wouldn't have put that flag on your profile picture, at the very least.
The scenography of this movie is just amazing.
Excellent idea to post this ,,, wonderful movie, subtitles help to appreciate it. Thanks
this movie has a good soundtrack :)
There are the orchestral versions of famous Russian modern songs. At least Баста - Сансара
ruclips.net/video/aiCL0-U9WxI/видео.htmlsi=BxAXR6D8R0gWKsbU
and Наутилус Помпилиус - Прогулки на воде.
ruclips.net/video/o-Mrbt_QHd8/видео.htmlsi=IeRRqB4JQzG0YoU1
Technically it is well done by any measure: camera POV, panoramic sweeps, close ups, lightings, shadows and mis-en-scene. It is a visual feast as well as an audio delight.
@@Ewan_Gamingand Victor Zoi’s “Try to sing along with me”: ruclips.net/video/U940ebIkP9U/видео.htmlsi=-uaN5qHP9uFl9t9J
A high quality film. Thanks for uploading. Superb casting, photography, amazing scenes.
Well done! Great movie. It's good to see that the Russian tradition of making real good historical movies is still alive and kicking.
When did the communists in Russia ever make any truthful historical movies? The Americans or British never made any.
I've only seen little clips of this. So glad you posted it!
I LoVE YOU SOOO MUCH FOR POSTING THIS MOVIE !!! THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU !
Great film, thanks for such great work bringing to an English speaking audience
:O Ive been Looking for this movie!! THANX BRO MAN UR THE GREATEST ! ITS VERY HARD TO FIND WITH NO LUCK , and you got the subtitles
Thank you so much, I've been looking for this since i saw the decemberist grapeshot video years ago! 🙇🏼♂️🙇🏼♂️
I don't know if you'd do any requests but another russian gem we can't watch for similar reasons as this movie is the sovereign servant, do you have any ideas on where to find an english subbed version or a have a way to upload one here? No problems if the answer is a no
Same!
Russia is such an interesting nation with a very interesting history. I'm glad such a well-made movie could shine some light on a lesser known(to me and possibly 'the west') historical event of such drama and importance.
Russian history started in 1721. before that it was Muscovy, the father-murdering orphan-child of Mongolian Kaganate.
1:18:47 what marching song it this?
Izmailovsky
Thx
OH MY GOD, ENGLISH SUBTITLES, GOD BLESS YOU
The one that surprised me in all this was Col. Prince Trubekskoy. He seemed to just give up after hearing the Imperial Senate swore loyalty to Tsar Nicholas and suffered some kind of mental break down. His exemplary military record and his noted oratory and leadership skills makes his behavior hard to explain that day.
We finally got this actual good movie before gta 6
Better then Napoleon
@@JacquetValiantyep.
@@JacquetValiant that movie was a disgrace to napoleons name.
Occasionally I lost sight of the plot, who was who, stopping to read the text. The CGI was very good and the uniforms impeccable.
What a tale and so well told. Bravo.
Finnaly, the film with English subtitles. I wanted to watch this film for a long time, but I didn't undferstand the weird english subtitles, and now I can watch the film in all its glory
Thanks for the great translation
If Konstantin had ascended the throne then, we would now remember Poland in the same way as the Crimean Khanate
Wow, at last I'll be able to watch this movie!
Thanks 🙏
From France 🇨🇵
Actually it is TV series (8 episodes by 50 mins) compiled in short movie.
Two minutes in, and already a better Napoleon than that turd Scott shat out.
Rosjanie zawsze robili piękne filmy
Our people wouldn't quite agree with you. We can make good films that can be enjoyed abroad like this one. But there are also not so many. Some people like it, and some don't
I appreciate the work you put into giving us this, sir. Thank you.
The Battle scenes are really fucking impressive in this movie
realy nice film imo. Shame that it didnt do well at its box office. thx for uploading with english subs and good quality
success at the box office was only in those countries that translate films from other countries. The fucking monopoly of the West. For some reason, I can watch English-language movies, Chinese, Hindi with any Russian dubbing. And in the West, this turns out to be a problem.
@@teltos6817why do you watch? Dubbing must be banned in Russia. Dubbing is what’s destroying Russian move industry. And I hate dubbing, how do you guys watched dubbed films? Doesn’t it bother you when the lips don’t match the words?
@@prodigiii712 What about freedom of speech? Or is banning culture from other countries a democracy? You can watch dubbed news, but politics does not allow movies. This is medieval savagery. Even after watching this film, you can understand that Russians studied French and German at that time.
Love this movie, thanks for posting.
Thank you so much! I have been looking for this movie, but nothing so far in English
Those people who are against, but do not have an idea, but simply oppose someone, will never succeed. These people had no idea, they were just against the government. They didn't have a plan for what they would do when they achieved their goal. It was stupid.
Согласен это было глупо. Русские либералы сегодня ФБК Навального.
Your remark is only true in relation to the plot of this film. It contains too many historical inaccuracies to judge the real Decembrists by them.
Они не ставили цели свергнуть царя. Они принуждали к реформам @@kanakubatov5508
What are you talking about? The Decemberists had drafted several versions of the future Constitution and had a plan of liberal reforms. Pestel, in particular, was a prolific writer and thinker whose thought later influenced Russian anarchists and socialists, including Lenin. The movie doesn't cover this but you could at least check Wiki before commenting.
@@jasont4206 It's one thing to write, but a whole other thing to implement. Serfdom in Russia benefited the Russian peasants,(don't get me wrong, ofc it wasn't perfect) Russia's geography did not (and to this day) didn't allow for many small privately owned farms to develop, instead, multiple peasants (or even villages) worked under one landowner, and thus they had a secure market for their products( and for the landowner as well), and a stable constant income. That's as far as serfdom is concerned, as far as constitution, it was irrelevant, since all the conspirators were from rich landowning families and only wanted the power to themselves, the constitution drafts were just a ruse to attract liberals in Saint Petersburg.
yessss tysm im gonna share this with my friends
Great movie 🙂👌🏼🇷🇺
THERE IS ALSO A DIRECTOR'S SERIAL VERSION, IT'S MORE DETAILED AND MORE INTERESTING
What is it called?
@@prodigiii712 It is called Союз Спасения. Время гнева
Ong lmk if you find out
@@prodigiii712 Союз Спасения. Время гнева. I hope someone does English subtitles for it
I just combined Russian version and the subtitle I found myself four months ago😂.
Anyways thanks man
Maybe it was fortune or luck on the House of Romanov that no one knew who the new Emperor was following Alexander's death. The entire Imperial Family knew Alexander wanted Nicholas to secede him, but the upper echolons of the Military and the Imperial Senate had no idea and still thought Konstantin was Emperor.
Nicholas allegedly wrote to Konstantin to come too St. Petersburg to renounce the throne from Warsaw where he was acting as Commander-in-Chief of the Army of Poland but Konstantin refused fearful of being strangeled in bed as their father had been. This confusion I think muddled the Decemberists plot.
Better watch the series "Union of Salvation. The time of anger." Basically, people didn't like the movie. You just can't fit that much information into 2 hours. Even 8 episodes of one hour is not enough for this topic.
Are there subtitles for the series ?
@ probably
1:57:37 Why would you bring a child to an interogation? There was said a moment (The Romanov Documentary) where Nikoolai asked his son, the future Alexander II, what would he have done to the Decembrist?
Alexander said to have replied that he would forgive them
Maybe that sad experience was one of the reasons the Crown Prince rejected his father's tyrannical ways and eventually became Alexander the Liberator.
@@f-14btomcatand that’s what killed him. Imagine freeing almost one third of population from serfdom with a stroke of a pen.
@@f-14btomcat Didn't he end up getting killed by extremists though? The irony there is kind of heartbreaking...
@@darthmeta6445 Yes his horse wagon got blown up in 1881
Amazing work. Putting subtitles to Russia shows. One request would you be able to get Saladin The Conquer series from trt with English subtitles apart from episode 1 it's unavailable with English subtitles. Ill look at rest of your videos soon. You need a thanks option $
Has anyone noticed that scene where they are drinking and the rock like music is playing and "The Union of Salvation" gets recognized. It is out of historical frame but works really well somehow??? I have noticed this style of directing in a few Russian films but also In Wolfenstein 2: New Colosses with the American communist revolutionary. Just something I noticed
@1:49:22 -- When Trubetsky is questioned, "Why did you lead a revolt?" he answered as if he had led, 90 years later, the Easter Rebellion in Dublin.
You know, the mere effort to establish a republic against autocracy, even if it fails, will light the way to the future.
The leaders of the Easter Rebellion held out for a week, and were summarily executed, without trial, by the English.
Here, the revolt was dispersed by the first use of force, and the trials and investigations lasted for the better part of a year.
The Decembrists led the way to the assassination of Alexander II, who freed the serfs, and that of Nicholas II, to clear the way for the Bolshevik dictatorship and terror, which lasted until 1991.
Martyrs do not always get what they hope for.
So called "Bolshevik terror" or "Red terror" was period of time in 1918-1922, it's an official naming, as a responce of Bolsheviks to multiple violent actions of various opposition groups in summer 1918, which led to Civil war. Only in western propaganda all period up until 1991 is called that way:)
Ваше мнение основано на заблуждении, что властьимущие добровольно отдадут все что было ими захвачено на протяжении веков.
НАСТОЯТЕЛЬНО РЕКОМЕНДУЮ проследить причинно следственную связь
@@EvgeniiKrupenin Do you think that England gave up power in Ireland voluntarily? The Easter Rebellion's martyrdom initiated a widespread revolt in Ireland. The martyrdom of the the Decembrists did not. It lead to a model of assassination of emperors.
emperors do notget it either but eventually common folk do but all pay with blood except the bankers
Большевики захватили власть извне. Просто бандиты с наемниками уничтожили государство, и поставили культуру на грань исхода.
Im happy to understand most of it even without the subtitles its just better to be a part of the slavic people
This is amazing! Any chance you might to Время Гнева in the future?
Hate to break it to You but I don't actually speak Russian, I might try to force myself to translate it like I did with this one at some point but as of now I'm too busy. Also where can i find the series? I was looking for it a while ago but couldn't find anything and gave up.
@@MrEthnicC ruclips.net/video/xiNBU9lUj18/видео.html
@@MrEthnicC Yandex. Put Rutracker in the search box along with the name if you can't find it. The Rutracker post also has some useful discussion to read.
@@MrEthnicC How in the world did you translate it so well then?
@@elfi-z8n I translated from a version with Polish lyrics, it wasn't perfect but definitely more understandable than english versions online. First version I made had some mistakes but I had a Russian friend who helped me and corrected them.
Actually their grave was uncovered at the site of Almaz Marine Yard on Golodai island. There is a small obelisk now.
@@konstantinkanev6287 discovered not uncovered… unless they were dug up.
Great video!
(condensed version)
1:03:46 1:16:29 1:38:26
(extended version)
1:02:05 - 1.11.29 | 1:13:10 - 1.22.16 | 1:23:49 - 1.29.55 | 1:35:39 - 1.55.42 | 2:01:40 - fin
10/10 movie
fr
Thank you for the upload
@19:05 --"By what law have we been sentenced?"
The answer Prince Nikolai gave was, The Word of the Emperor is Law. That was the crucial contradiction, in the many pronouncements of Aleksandr Pervyi -- he wanted a constitutional regime, but intended to retain un-constitutional power in his hands. It sounds strange to us today to have someone say, "The highest will" and mean the Word of the Emperor, but "All-highest" was the standard term to refer to the tsar.
Until the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution of the USA, Kings were anointed by God to rule. It was by God's will, and God is infallible, that a person was born a King, a peasant (serf, different than a peasant), or a criminal. The USA declared forever that ALL MEN ARE CREATED EQUAL and that ended thousands of years of Royal Rules.
What would Russia have become if the Decembrists had succeeded??? Would the revolution that changed Rusia and the World have happened? Would Lenin have succeeded in his communist goals???
Это Особенности построения романо- германской (континентальной) системы права.
@@sjb3460 Yep instead the USA made billionaires their kings and made people even less equal and then started wars all around the world and putting their military bases in almost every country. They also then overthrew a bunch of governments and facilitated coups. Resulting in millions of innocent deaths around the world. USA USA USA
@sjb3460
1. Good that you mention that USA told only about MEN (nowadays it is somehow forgotten). But you also forgot, that they meant actually not even all men… no, not even all white men (hello Irish) :D They told only about small bunch of very specific group of men. From this point of view, in most kingdoms people had more right than in USA. Actually even in 20 century people in US had less rights than most people in Europe in 19, 18 and 17 centuries.
2. De facto first communist is Gracchus Babeuf, in is late 18 century, France. So, it is complicated to discuss what would happens. From one side revolution of 1917 directly have roots in this events. 1825 not gone, arrived several waves of revolutionists (main wave is 1860s) which in result born Lenin. But this is only one side, from my opinion not important. Who really cares about constitution and some "rights"? It is fiction which is irrelevant for life of 99,99% of people. Give nothing.
From another side, Lenin build communism. And communism it is mainly about different things: economical system, real equality of people (don’t tell me fairy tales, that me and Bill Gates are equal, I’m dust, while he is God from Olympus), about property. So, even if revolution happened in 1825, unlikely it could cancel attempts of communistic revolution. Like nobody canceled it nowadays. If someone will propose it to me now, I’m will support, why not. But if you ask me, what I prefer: constitution with parliament/president or monarchy without any constitution or main law - I don’t care, anything, it is literally irrelevant.
@@juliap.5375 yes, but the idea has to start somewhere. you're overlaying the culture of today with the concept of 200 years ago. And now, we're "woke" and down some rabbit hole. "all men" was the first step away from King's divine Right of Rule. Then, more steps.
Excellent movie!
thanks, great movie
6:05 name of the opera?
Joli film sur une histoire violente! Dommage, je n'ai rien comprit aux dialogues! Pas de traduction possible... Mais beau film quand même! Stéph.
What do they say in Russian between 1:02:06 and 1:02:17 ?
-Здорово, гвардейцы!
-Здравия желаю, ваше императорское величество!
J'aime beaucoup cette forme de scénario avec d'impressionnantes performance des acteurs 16.20.minute. J'apprends a écouter le russe a lire l'anglais car je suis Canadien français d'Amérique du Nord côté Est. Autre chose. En 1825 l'Alaska était russe et en 1863, St Petersbourg l'empereur a tenté de vendre l'Alaska pour 7 millions de dollars. Après discussion le congrès ne voulait pas cette terre aride désertique et froide , oui le congrès américain a signé l'achat de Alaska.
Grande film! I film russi sono meravigliosi nei costumi, nella recitazione, nei movimenti delle grandi masse.
Thank you very much for uploading!
Is it the full movie ?? Also can any one specifies if there's a series on the same subject !!
Yes it’s called Union of Salvation: Time of Wrath (Союз Спасения: Время гнева).
В этом фильме Николай просто святой какой-то..!!!😢
потому как в первые дни правления сам обкакался что его сметут и не успел наломать дров.
Еще бы,кто бы дал денег что бы снять фильм в наше время где глава государства плохой и революция это хорошо
Не грешнее остальных монархов
Шо вы хотели от прапагандистского кала
@@СтаниславШнайдер-ъ3н В чем пропаганда?В том что декабристы дров наломали,и загубили столько жизней?По какому праву Николай должен был уступить,просто потому что какой то Вася захотел?
the credits music is also amazing lmao, as much as the movie itself !
In my personal opinion, this movie is a good one. The acting, the choreography, the music, it's all well-rounded. However, I think the pace of the plot is a bit too fast and the duration is too short; maybe if they make it into a 4-hour movie, the plot could've been deeper and more detailed, at the same time allowing us who aren't exactly familiar with the December revolt history to chew and digest the story better. If I'm to make an analogy, it's like being served a prime, medium rare ribeye steak and told to eat it under 10 minutes. It's doable, and the steak will be delicious nonetheless, but I sure would like to savor it a little longer.
This movie has later been remade into an 8-episode series "Union of Salvation: Time of Anger", which is more well-paced (but I don't think there are English subtitles for it)
For a Russia of free peasants. For a constitutional monarchy to ensure the Tsardom can last.
What a loss!
Монархии место на свалке истории.
Декабристы не планировали отмену крепостного права. Эту легенду позже придумали большевики. Они планировали свержение царя и установление оллигархической республики.
I always wanted to watch this movie with English subs.
thank u all great film!!
Very well done movie!
Свобода это возможность следовать своему предназначению и тебя никто не преследует за это!!! Браво сказано и главное верно!!!
Если я посчитаю, что мое предназначение отобрать вашу хату и жену, ваша свобода в том, чтобы это защитить. Стало быть, было бы справедливо, если бы меня после не преследовали 😏
Excellent historical movie, without suoer heros, just the truth. How it shuold be.
👍 Makes you feel there. Anyone knows if the uniforms in the film are for sale ?
Se colocassem a tradução em português seria ótimo.
You know it's legit when a guy named Buttstabber helped translate it.
This is a masterpiece. Historically did that fight at the square happened ?
This movie is almost documentary
@ almost documentary my ass🤣🤣🤣 Russian lie upon a lie upon a lie as usual… nothing new from Russian liars
@@free4492 do not believe anything in Russian Federation movies about Russia… it’s almost like watching Nazi propaganda about fascist Germany
This is an excellent movie even though it’s not accurate I love it surely better than the new Napoleon because atleast it a realistic, entertaining, based on actual true events, and has great action. The grapeshot scene is excellent as it correctly portrays how cannons work rather than exploding which is not what roundshot does the men sound like they are actually getting hit again this movie is great
Спасибо за перевод!
благодаришь? перевод на уровне средней школы
@@yurikropotov3135 Вам следует перевести фильм и показать нам, как это делается.
@@yurikropotov3135 zdes ne filologicheskyi kruzhok. lutshe, chem nichego. bolee obidno, chto istoriya povtorayetsa. vse v krovi budet. russia budet v krovi skoro. na urovne srednem.
@alexejgorodnicenko7295
Вообще ничего не повторяется. Ну и с чего это Россия будет в крови? Мы вообще-то стоим на пороге того, что вероятно Европа будет превращена в радиоактивную пустыню. Вот это более вероятно. Ну или даже весь мир. А в России всё спокойно.
I wonder the opera is at 5:51
this movie is really quite glowing in its portrayal of Alexander
What elexander
@@LoadMaster-xl8dp the first; his portrayal as an enlightened despot is all enlightened and no despot lol
Thanks for sharing 👍
This looks good and all. But there's something missing. Just like western modern media the acting feels hollow.
They play their characters like they are robots without feeling, just following a program.
Look to the english tv series (Hornblower) for an example in what acting should look like in my opinion.
46:38 is a damn cool scene. Such a vibe. Miloradorvich's character was really stealing the show for me.
I cannot fathom what their plan was. It seems absurdist in execution. What is also weird is how sympathetic the Tsars are portrayed as. Good music and brilliant cinematography. The time-cuts were an interesting device certainly.
A day before the start of the uprising, the gendarmerie arrested the head of the Southern Society, Pavel Pestel. The Decembrists decided to prevent the troops and the Senate from taking the oath of office to the new emperor. The rebellious troops were to occupy the Winter Palace and the Peter and Paul Fortress, the royal family was planned to be arrested and, under certain circumstances, killed. Prince Sergei Trubetskoy was elected to lead the uprising.
After that, it was planned to demand that the Senate publish a nationwide Manifesto proclaiming the "destruction of the former government" and the establishment of a provisional revolutionary government. It was supposed to make Count M. M. Speransky and Admiral N. S. Mordvinov its members (later they became members of the Decembrist trial).
The deputies had to approve a new basic law - the constitution. If the Senate had not agreed to publish the people's manifesto, it was decided to force him to do so. The manifesto contained several points: the establishment of provisional revolutionary governments
But their slowness allowed the emperor to gather enough strength and close them in a ring. I personally was in St. Petersburg and I can say for myself if they had started acting immediately, seized fortresses and set up barricades in the streets. Then the battle would have turned into many battles of 300 Spartans. The streets are narrow and the blocks are square. Plus, the Peter and Paul Fortress has an ideal view of the winter palace. They would have lasted at least a day. And at night, riots might have started and everything would have gone downhill.
Ваши ощущения вас не обманули. У них действительно не было четкой программы и плана реализации. Сплошной сумбур и романтические бредни. Никто из них НЕ МОГ научно разработать концепцию. При этом они пытались решить свои шкурные интересы. 😊
@@Очумелыеручки-ш1ъ напоминают современных либерастов XD
It’s true. The punishment for what did was quartering but they were hanged which is much less painful and many of them were either imprisoned or exiled. The “dictator” in the group was eventually pardoned by Nicholas’s son and even got back his title. I don’t think the Romanovs were overtly cruel esp when compared to the Bolsheviks.