Wonderful, great, extremely insightful, especially the burnt hair turning into a circular shape is the metaphor for his chains, very well said. wah wah...allah karay zore tashreeh aur ziada. Do you think Ghalib is saying that even though his chains have turned so delicate that he can break them any time, yet he is hanging on in the prison instead of running away. Is he not breaking the delicate chain of his life because we are destined to stay in this world. I am thinking it refers to the life, that despite the fact us humans have power to end the misery of life, that causes the fire under our feet, we can kill ourselves to end this prison, we don't because we are waiting for the time when our lives will naturally end?
Bhai aik guzarish kerni the k agar aap bata saktain hain k Dewan e ghalib ki tashreh kahan sey mil Sakai hai jis main falsafa b byan kiya gaya ho. Koi link ya koi book agar aap rehnumai farma dain tu aap ka is khaksaar pay ahsaan hoga
Bhai ghalib g k Dewan ki pehli ghazal k Puray Ishaar ki tashreh kerdain Is main 3 ishaar Rehtay hai. Aap ka ahsaan hoga Bhai asal main mirza ghalib ka ye sehar hai is ki zad main agaya hun shayad or meri baycheni ki ye kafiyat hai k Lakh koshish k baad b askser in ishaar ki tashreh hi nahi milti kuch ka khayaal hai k inka mafhoom kisi ko b puri tarhaan nahi Malloom. So aap pay hi umeed hai. Hum muntezir hain aap k Jawab k huzore ❤
Any effort to explain perfectly Ghalib is not easy. Only Ghalib can explain his own poetry. Or perhaps maybe even he can't. Besides the meaning there are certain emotions and feelings which the genius of Ghalib invokes in his sher. How can anyone explain that ? Ghalib is a rare fragrance which one can hardly capture and hold it.
You can see the refernces at the end of video from where i have studied, and those are big names and books. And if you still think so then you have the right to disagree. 😊 Thank you
@@ZiaeAdab sure. That's the Beauty of Ghalib. There are so many different ways one can interpret. Frankly, Ghalib is beyond Big or Small names. He connects with heart, soul. Therefore, even same person in different mood, context and time - can see same poem in totally different ways. I just meant - i found it bit wrong interpretation as i was seeing it at different depth
بہت خوب
اس کلام کی تشریح کے لیے مدت سے تشنہ تھے، آپ نے نہایت سہل انداز میں ہر شعر کی عمدہ تشریح کی ہے، سلامت رہیں
beautifully explained
Sir app bar bar dil maa aik ajeeb dara pada karta hoo apna andaz saaa.
Behtreen ❤
بہت اچھی اور واضح تشریح کی آپ نے ماشاءاللہ،،، مبارکباد
پذیرائی کا بہت بہت شکریہ 🙏
Very nice 👍
بہت شاندار انداز تفہیم ہے ماشاءاللہ
کمال
نقش سے مراد یہ کل کائنات بھی تو ہو سکتی ہے جو اپنے خالق سے ہر وقت فریاد کرتی رہتی اور اس کائنات کا ہر پیکر کاغذی ہے یعنی مٹنے والا ہے گنا ہونے والا ہے
Ghajal ko aapne bahut khoobsurti se bayan kiya hai sukria
Amazing super my dear
Keep it bro
اچھی تشریح کر رہے ہیں ۔ ماشاءاللہ
Wah! Excellent explanation ❤️❤️❤️
Thank you so much sir 🙏💖🙏
واہ واہ۔ بہت آعلی
جزاک اللہ
کیا خوب تشریح کی ھے آپ نے
سلامت رھیں
واااااہ
کلامِ غالب کی توصیف کے لیے مقام کہاں ہے ہمارى شوخىِ تحریر کا❤
💯 Wakai
درست فرمایا 💖
💖
کمال کی تشریح کی ہے بہت شکریہ
جزاک اللہ
بہت شکریہ 🙂
شاندار ہے
حضور ذرہ نوازی ہے آپ کی۔۔۔ 🙏💖🙂
Ghalib to bs ghalib hn ❤
Bahut acha smjhaate hain aap.. bahut bahut shukriya
سلامت رہیں آباد رہیں
کمال است
بہہہہہہہہت خوب
wahh sir...buhut khob
buhut hi Aala perai me salees andaz me...👏❤
شکریہ حضور۔۔۔
Best explanation👌🏻
بہت عمدہ بہت خوبصورت❤😊
بہت شکریہ 🙏
Boht khoob janab
Buhat Shandar Andaz
Boht shukriya bhai 🙏💖🙏
بہت عمدہ
بہت شکریہ سر۔۔۔ 💖🙂
Mashalla booth khooob
بہت بہت شکریہ 💖🙏💖
بھائی خوبصورت کام ہے آپ جئیں
بہت شکریہ گل بھائی 💖
Bht umda
Boht shukriya 💖
Wonderful, great, extremely insightful, especially the burnt hair turning into a circular shape is the metaphor for his chains, very well said.
wah wah...allah karay zore tashreeh aur ziada.
Do you think Ghalib is saying that even though his chains have turned so delicate that he can break them any time, yet he is hanging on in the prison instead of running away. Is he not breaking the delicate chain of his life because we are destined to stay in this world. I am thinking it refers to the life, that despite the fact us humans have power to end the misery of life, that causes the fire under our feet, we can kill ourselves to end this prison, we don't because we are waiting for the time when our lives will naturally end?
शुक्रिया आपका
Excellent
Bohat khoob…maza aya apki explanation sey.
بہت شکریہ بھائی 💖🙏🙂
Appreciable
Wah Kia tashreeh ki he aapney ❤
Boht shukriya bhai 🙏💖🙏
Amazing ❤
Wah beta bahot hi khoob appropriate tashrih ki hai. Khuda tumhe umar daraz kare. You. Are master of Urdu. Keep it up
اس درجہ پذیرائی کا بہت بہت شکریہ۔۔۔🙏😊
سلامت رہیں 💖
Hassan kozagar ki tashree hojai to bohat acha hoga
السلام علیکم سر
دیوان غالب میں کل کتنے غزلیات یا نظمیں ہیں ؟
Bhai jetey rahiye aap b huzore nayab ho gay hain kya Khob tashreh ki hai.
بھائی بہت بہت شکریہ پذیرائی کا 💖🙏💖
Bhai aik guzarish kerni the k agar aap bata saktain hain k Dewan e ghalib ki tashreh kahan sey mil Sakai hai jis main falsafa b byan kiya gaya ho. Koi link ya koi book agar aap rehnumai farma dain tu aap ka is khaksaar pay ahsaan hoga
Bhai ghalib g k Dewan ki pehli ghazal k Puray Ishaar ki tashreh kerdain Is main 3 ishaar Rehtay hai. Aap ka ahsaan hoga Bhai asal main mirza ghalib ka ye sehar hai is ki zad main agaya hun shayad or meri baycheni ki ye kafiyat hai k Lakh koshish k baad b askser in ishaar ki tashreh hi nahi milti kuch ka khayaal hai k inka mafhoom kisi ko b puri tarhaan nahi Malloom. So aap pay hi umeed hai. Hum muntezir hain aap k Jawab k huzore ❤
Any effort to explain perfectly Ghalib is not easy. Only Ghalib can explain his own poetry. Or perhaps maybe even he can't. Besides the meaning there are certain emotions and feelings which the genius of Ghalib invokes in his sher. How can anyone explain that ? Ghalib is a rare fragrance which one can hardly capture and hold it.
True !
شرح کلام غالب پر مزید ویڈیوز نہیں بنائیں گے ؟
انشاءاللہ جلد۔۔۔ 😊
Behar bataye is ghazal ka please sir..
غالب شناسی کا سلسلہ جاری رکھیں ۔۔ بہت خوب
Send me your whatsapp number...
Bhai yeh quata bhi is hi ghazal kaa hai , is ke maayne batayen to badi meharbani ho
شوخیٔ نیرنگ صید وحشت طاؤس ہے
دام سبزہ میں ہے پرواز چمن تسخیر کا
جناب والا آپ نے پہلے مصرع کا بہت ہی اچھا کیا ہے لیکن دوسرے مصرع کا بیڑا غرق کر دیا ہے ۔
ناراض نا ہونا اگر آپ خود غور کریں گے تو پتہ چل جائے گا۔
Needs improvement.
wrong interpretation
You can see the refernces at the end of video from where i have studied, and those are big names and books.
And if you still think so then you have the right to disagree. 😊
Thank you
@@ZiaeAdab sure. That's the Beauty of Ghalib. There are so many different ways one can interpret. Frankly, Ghalib is beyond Big or Small names. He connects with heart, soul. Therefore, even same person in different mood, context and time - can see same poem in totally different ways.
I just meant - i found it bit wrong interpretation as i was seeing it at different depth
بہت خوب
بہت شکریہ 💖🙏