Metro 2033 - Original PC vs. Redux PC Graphics Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 янв 2025

Комментарии • 1,3 тыс.

  • @JamesTeune
    @JamesTeune 8 лет назад +4437

    In the original Artyom had gloves, in the Redux he doesn't. RIP hands 2cold4me

    • @Argoon1981
      @Argoon1981 8 лет назад +128

      Yep just a way they found to save some polygons, some of the characters even tho have better faces have worse "clothing" in Redux, it was just they shifting the polygon budget to here it mattered.

    • @yourmom-yv2xk
      @yourmom-yv2xk 8 лет назад +7

      Sir Skeletor I was about to make that joke...

    • @epicwarding
      @epicwarding 8 лет назад +67

      agreed , also spiders and monster "fur" in original is better, original has darker atmosphere and much more smoke used in alot of the places , shame they took alot of the gas/smoke away. i liked it

    • @theokayishgamer
      @theokayishgamer 8 лет назад +88

      Artyom gets gloves when he meets up with Andrew "The Blacksmith".

    • @AggressiveHiDef
      @AggressiveHiDef 7 лет назад +75

      He gets gloves later on in Redux.

  • @acornstairlift
    @acornstairlift 8 лет назад +2214

    I'm kind of at a loss to be honest. The original's atmosphere was more bleak (making it more appropriate) but I find that the surface sections in redux created this unique contrast between beauty and desolation.

    • @chef5estrela
      @chef5estrela 8 лет назад +71

      could not have written any better myself, cheers to that

    • @Some-person-dot-dot-dot
      @Some-person-dot-dot-dot 7 лет назад +80

      Yeah... Redux of course has more detailed character models, and better phys-x.
      Where as the original has better lightning and a....slightly different/grimmer atmosphere...
      It was... confusing to watch this.. some comparisons I couldn't help but think "What..? why did they change that?" and then other times I was like "Yeah, I guess the Redux does look a little better here..."

    • @oskarknutsson479
      @oskarknutsson479 7 лет назад +11

      Redux atmosphere is better on all levels lol

    • @oskarknutsson479
      @oskarknutsson479 7 лет назад +7

      The Redux has better Lighting effects, Have you even played the game? XD

    • @etunimi4206
      @etunimi4206 7 лет назад +22

      Redux also runs WAY better on pc than 2033 og..
      2033 og runs like shit :/

  • @AbbreviatedReviews
    @AbbreviatedReviews 8 лет назад +2819

    It's odd how it's so inconsistent. Some parts look loads better but other parts look significantly worse. Lighting in particular was much better in the original, but some textures and models are better in Redux.

    • @jonnyboi9026
      @jonnyboi9026 6 лет назад +112

      Abbreviated Reviews lol no the lighting was wayyy better in redux, I got tired of the flame changing from red to yellow to green, shit was annoying and hurt my eyes.

    • @gringoamigo8146
      @gringoamigo8146 6 лет назад +55

      Especially the creature models, they look way better in redux.

    • @gringoamigo8146
      @gringoamigo8146 6 лет назад +36

      @@courier6945 wtf? No, it doesn't. It is better in every way. The texture in the original looks blurry, it has no wetness look on its skin even around the mouth(where it should be wet).

    • @courier6945
      @courier6945 6 лет назад +34

      Gringo Amigo the texture maybe better but they fucked the models especially the librarians, they also ruined the watchers and the lurkers, i mean i used to shit my self when a lurker jump on me, now they're not even scary anymore.

    • @gringoamigo8146
      @gringoamigo8146 6 лет назад +39

      I think it has more to do with the fact that you've already played it, when the original first came out. You didn't really know what to expect then, right? Now you play redux version after the original it's not scary anymore, because you played it and you know what to expect. The creatures, in particular, especially the rail cart attack, I thought it looked much better than the original. Some of the human characters, especially their eyes, just looks plain weird.

  • @evoakaevo
    @evoakaevo 9 лет назад +1295

    redux=crazy eyes edition.

    • @FireStarJutsu
      @FireStarJutsu 5 лет назад +35

      Yeah like wtf ??? What were they thinking when they did that?

    • @Some-person-dot-dot-dot
      @Some-person-dot-dot-dot 4 года назад +79

      Original: Dark and brooding. Pure grit.
      Redux: Look into my eyes O__O

    • @FireStarJutsu
      @FireStarJutsu 4 года назад +1

      @@Some-person-dot-dot-dot 😂😂😂

    • @rodrigosebastiano789
      @rodrigosebastiano789 4 года назад

      @@Some-person-dot-dot-dot XD

    • @PentiumChronicles
      @PentiumChronicles 3 года назад +5

      Lol, they heroes of REDUX just used too much heroine before casting

  • @ADAMSDIABEL
    @ADAMSDIABEL 4 года назад +123

    Read 3 Metro books..
    Finished to play the game today.
    I'm totally in.
    Love it.

    • @fakedarkring9088
      @fakedarkring9088 4 года назад +2

      hahaha for me the original has a better setting I just finished it now I'm going to play Metro Last Light Redux
      I learn everything about the game

    • @OscarDirlwood
      @OscarDirlwood 3 года назад

      @@fakedarkring9088 shame the book is bloated and clumsy. If you took out the filler and clunky dialogue, the book would be the size of 2034

    • @LiegeMaximo
      @LiegeMaximo 3 года назад

      Is it necessary to read the books? Or can we start with redux?

    • @Mboy556
      @Mboy556 3 года назад

      @@LiegeMaximo books are just there if you wish to know more of the backstory and so on..

    • @ZachAttackO0
      @ZachAttackO0 3 года назад +1

      Metro was the only game that had me on the edge of my seat all the way through Exodus

  • @Мирич-з4е
    @Мирич-з4е 5 лет назад +612

    The graphical improvements are very minor. And in some places the original looks even better. The point of the Redux version was to optimize the game. Because the original one was very poorly optimized. And it was hard to run even with the most powerful GPU's at it's time.

    • @SellingSouls
      @SellingSouls 5 лет назад +56

      The graphical improvements are very minor... when was the last time you checked your eyes?

    • @solrhopalocera5704
      @solrhopalocera5704 4 года назад +17

      nope the graphical improvements are huge. this guys metro 2033 redux graphics look far inferior to mine on PS4 for some reason plus the average metro 2033 original games for most people didnt look nearly as good as this guy who was on max graphics settings with a powerful PC and most likely some mods

    • @golmomuppet583
      @golmomuppet583 4 года назад +21

      @@solrhopalocera5704 that literally makes zero sense

    • @solrhopalocera5704
      @solrhopalocera5704 4 года назад +11

      @@golmomuppet583
      my point is, this guys metro 2033 original doesnt look anything like the metro 2033 when it came out. u can see hes using a mod or someting to boost the original metro 2033 graphics

    • @solrhopalocera5704
      @solrhopalocera5704 4 года назад +36

      @Vasy
      Are you living in the previous decade?
      Everyone grew bored of these console vs PC arguments a long time ago.
      Grow up.

  • @harvey526
    @harvey526 6 лет назад +1530

    Главное - не есть желтый снег
    Dont eat yellow snow!

  • @НикитаРерих
    @НикитаРерих 8 лет назад +185

    redux has much better graphics, but doesn't have that atmosphere like in original.
    Original has fucking creepy atmosphere :o

    • @lukkkasz323
      @lukkkasz323 7 лет назад +19

      much better? slightly better, if that's even better...

    • @chuzic
      @chuzic 3 года назад +2

      @Tech Hybrid you are wrong, newbie zoomer detected

    • @failedlanparty2280
      @failedlanparty2280 3 года назад

      @@chuzic look at him I noticed it so hard when I was at the shooting range that the original looks way better then the redux
      It is a downgrade so ps4 can run it on 4k

    • @chuzic
      @chuzic 3 года назад

      @@failedlanparty2280 yes it is

    • @sO_RoNerY
      @sO_RoNerY Месяц назад

      @@chuzic even those that are not “newbies” are wrong. The newbie has his own opinion. Doesn’t make him wrong. You people are doopid. You people use newbie/noobie incorrectly. It’s actually pathetic.

  • @jonathansoko1085
    @jonathansoko1085 3 года назад +74

    The og is free on steam till the 15th, go decide for yourselves.

    • @IvanKCM
      @IvanKCM 3 года назад +2

      went here to check whats the difference and finally decided to get the two

    • @tanujrana8490
      @tanujrana8490 3 года назад +5

      Thats why im here lol

    • @tanujrana8490
      @tanujrana8490 3 года назад +17

      @@IvanKCM steam gave og free and epic game redux free

    • @plmkoo6772
      @plmkoo6772 3 года назад +1

      @@tanujrana8490 same

    • @said24rabbani
      @said24rabbani 3 года назад

      @@tanujrana8490 when?

  • @fluffyman15
    @fluffyman15 9 лет назад +643

    Its very simple:
    Original = Much better atmosphere, scary and depressing.
    Redux = Slightly more eye candy, better weapon damage and better ki.
    I will go with the original since i want to experience the dense atmosphere, already read the book a few years ago.

    • @GALuigi
      @GALuigi 9 лет назад +3

      fluffyman15 Exactly! I'll always love the original better!

    • @Dante-zd7ef
      @Dante-zd7ef 6 лет назад

      Fails

    • @Griv3836
      @Griv3836 6 лет назад +17

      fluffyman15 look dumbass its not just the graphics the gunplay stealth just gameplay in general is much better than the shitty original

    • @thanekrios5175
      @thanekrios5175 6 лет назад +32

      Redux has a shit load of gameplay enhancements so it's hard to go back. Plus the atmosphere is still the same, for the most part. Some levels are just during daylight now.

    • @bananakings5165
      @bananakings5165 6 лет назад +1

      is there much of less expirience if u played game then read book? xd

  • @prietovich402
    @prietovich402 2 года назад +29

    Not only the atmosphere was lost but also several animations and functions of the original that I would have liked to see in the Redux, it is as if they had transformed the survival of the original Metro for more mechanics of a call of duty

  • @philipplee78
    @philipplee78 10 лет назад +1581

    Original looks better ?

    • @Candyland
      @Candyland  10 лет назад +380

      In my opinion, original looks way better than Redux. Cheers, Steve

    • @philipplee78
      @philipplee78 10 лет назад +67

      Definitely

    • @AbysmalEnd
      @AbysmalEnd 9 лет назад

      Candyland whats the name of the song you used in this video

    • @Dave-ng7ee
      @Dave-ng7ee 9 лет назад +64

      Philip Lee Original graphics look more raw, more post apocalyptic like. Redux looks just too nice for such themed game.

    • @fulzorhd9450
      @fulzorhd9450 9 лет назад +39

      Redux is brighter and smoother than the original. Details look older in the original one and they are more complex in redux. Personally I prefer Redux because it's fresher than the Original. But the Original is still an amazing game

  • @FirebonE_88
    @FirebonE_88 6 лет назад +92

    The original looks darker, scarier and much more desolate, like it really should be. The redux version's ambiance looks almost cosy, at times. Also, I find the mutants much more terrifying in the original, especially nosalises and demons. For instance, when that nosalis lands on the train cart, it looks a lot scarier in the original.

    • @Lawrence_Talbot
      @Lawrence_Talbot 2 года назад +9

      Yes I agree. I just finished redux and it wasn’t nearly as scary as the original. All the improved lighting really takes away from the dark ambience of anything could get you from a shadow. The monsters are more detailed but at the same time look more animal than mutant. Like the watchers go from these leathery rotten/mutated beasts to almost cat like with all their hair and refined snout and fangs

    • @FirebonE_88
      @FirebonE_88 2 года назад

      @@Lawrence_Talbot, well said.

    • @NotEvenDeathCanSaveU
      @NotEvenDeathCanSaveU 2 года назад +2

      Some parts have better atmosphere in original, some it seems in redux. Its pretty inconsistent, and I think there is a place for cosiness mostly only in the base and in the quiet more chill parts of the gameplay. Idk I think this redux version was mostly just a cash-grab, inconsistent and it seems low effort and low quality of work is behind it. I think thats pretty much expected however from remasters or redux versions or w/e.

    • @quirkyadventures1722
      @quirkyadventures1722 Год назад +1

      I fully agree with the Demons, I honestly wish they kept that artstyle for them in all the games, they have a scary Gargoyle look to them which the other games miss entirely.

  • @hushamfusion
    @hushamfusion 6 лет назад +49

    Honestly, it feels like you're watching 2 different games based on the same scenario. They both do the job very greatly, and sometimes I feel like even if the original looked a lot better in certain aspects, that just makes it more cozy, and takes away from the uncomfortable atmosphere of the game. Although to compensate for that, the outside seemed to be way more dark, in a way contrasting it.

  • @russel7766
    @russel7766 5 лет назад +30

    While I appreciate all the work that went into Redux I find myself loving the original far more.

  • @allisknu11
    @allisknu11 4 года назад +17

    Very mixed feelings. While some things such as monster enemies looking far better in Redux, some characters look worse in the newer version. Just look at this character 2:08 that looks much better in the original. Redux pig is all "pimply" and hairless, while the original pig looked better with fur, as pigs should have. Not that it matters. It's a very mixed bag with some unreasonable changes. Redux is mostly blurry. That ugly FXAA/TAA anti-aliasing. Lighting and shadows were better in the original. For me that's a deal-breaker.

    • @God_gundam36
      @God_gundam36 3 года назад

      They' mixed up which side of the screen They're on

  • @doggoonxbox2894
    @doggoonxbox2894 7 лет назад +106

    both of these versions of the game are absolutely amazing

    • @Majin_buu_u
      @Majin_buu_u 3 года назад +2

      Reading in roshi's voice

    • @siscovrcgt3
      @siscovrcgt3 2 года назад

      👍👍👍

    • @BreakTheCycle106
      @BreakTheCycle106 20 дней назад

      One is great on atmosphere and art style
      Other is great at improving combat and other stuff.

  • @alex_6911
    @alex_6911 Год назад +1

    4:33 Not Original Metro 2033 here, it's the Redux version. If you look closely, it pops up the "bullet icon" also known as "buy" icon when he got close to the merchant, which it is the same icon feature that was introduced in Metro Last Light.

  • @minihalkoja590
    @minihalkoja590 8 лет назад +203

    They should have made Metro: 2033 Redux with LL graphics, but with the same atmosphere and lighting from the original.

    • @Scoelho83
      @Scoelho83 6 лет назад +11

      @Jonathan Soko are u crazy man? lights and smokes and atmosphere is better then REdux they mod gamma to much

    • @SellingSouls
      @SellingSouls 5 лет назад +3

      @@Scoelho83 No, they are not. It looks ugly as shit. Redux fixed it, thankfully. So you better check your eyes, and also learn to type in english.

    • @michaelgordon982
      @michaelgordon982 4 года назад +5

      @@Scoelho83 lower the gamma and you'll get that og 2033 vibe

    • @Scoelho83
      @Scoelho83 4 года назад

      @@SellingSouls how about stopping be so idiot!! You can under if you want

    • @damnyejustgotbewitchedbyth2802
      @damnyejustgotbewitchedbyth2802 4 года назад

      @@Scoelho83 You can under?

  • @jorisd6584
    @jorisd6584 4 года назад +15

    5:50 I really like how the original had a lot more recoil than the redux version. Idk why they changed this, because Artyom is supposed to be an average 20 year old, imo it would be more realistic he has a bit more recoil.

    • @realtrisk
      @realtrisk 3 года назад +8

      Gotta disagree. He's an average 20 something living in a post apocalyptic setting. He's no stranger to guns as he's been on guard duty against the horrors living in the tunnels and the Dark Ones many times.

    • @christinesulyvahn6043
      @christinesulyvahn6043 Год назад

      When i was 17 year old i hold an AKS74-U, and i could shot it in fully automatic, i got to say, the recoil isn't something big, is just the feeling of the gun shaking a lot amd the weight on your arms, and i am really skinny so, doesn't made much difference to me

  • @GaMeON159753456
    @GaMeON159753456 6 лет назад +25

    I love the smoke and dust particles in the original so it makes me kind of sad to see it all go away in the Redux version. Overall I think that Redux looks much better than the original on the surface and the original looks much better underground in the metro or in the library.

  • @noisyjames8651
    @noisyjames8651 9 лет назад +243

    original more true post apocalyptic....IMHO

    • @Мирич-з4е
      @Мирич-з4е 6 лет назад +48

      You're saying that only because his opinion is different than yours. I HATE when people can't exept the others opinion, because you're maybe grown up physically, but not mentally. You've been stuck at age 12!

    • @coolguitar2010
      @coolguitar2010 6 лет назад

      stupid

    • @anarcxh8502
      @anarcxh8502 6 лет назад +13

      @Tech Hybrid ah yes the sunny bright apocalyptic word where people look like their eyes will pop off what a vastly surperiour opinion

    • @idontthink9383
      @idontthink9383 5 лет назад +2

      @ lmao

    • @SellingSouls
      @SellingSouls 5 лет назад

      @ Ok incel

  • @DeiGmz
    @DeiGmz 3 года назад +13

    One of the problems of remakes its that developers never get the lighting properly set and in most cases the game looks worst in that area.

  • @indy3130
    @indy3130 7 лет назад +6

    What makes metro so awesome is the level design, the environment, and how they made the metro look, feel, and sound like the factions also feel like they fit the environment very well but overall the level design and the environment are probably my favorites

  • @SuperFaceStomp
    @SuperFaceStomp 7 лет назад +78

    Why did they change the humans so much. And why make the iris so pronounced.,.,.,.,fnggg

  • @МаксимАшихмин-я8щ
    @МаксимАшихмин-я8щ 6 лет назад +40

    По моему мнению в оригинальном Метро 2033 картинка более натуралистическая , и преобладает в ней гнетущая атмосфера постапокалипсиса . А когда играешь в переиздание , то думаешь не о атмосфере , а о том , что за окном такая-же картина как и в игре .

    • @ПожилойскаутСелуса
      @ПожилойскаутСелуса 6 лет назад +1

      Так и есть.

    • @mixbykodi
      @mixbykodi 6 лет назад +8

      Оригинал намного лучше,чем переиздание,там лучше атмосфера,там нет тупорылого стелса,где враги тебя в притык не видят,там все намного лучше,переиграл раз 6 это точно)

    • @АлексСолкин-г2п
      @АлексСолкин-г2п 6 лет назад +1

      Наверно соглашусь

  • @mastertochi101
    @mastertochi101 6 лет назад +19

    I always love the original since it was the first metro i got that got me into the books as well. The first felt a lot like how the books described the metro, dark and everyone living like rats.

  • @Globbified
    @Globbified 9 лет назад +37

    Payday 2 needs a redux, so they can fix fucking everything

    • @tylerboy565
      @tylerboy565 9 лет назад +3

      +Globbified Just the stealth needs to be fixed imo. The fucking pager system is honestly so stupid.

    • @Globbified
      @Globbified 8 лет назад

      Preach it man!

    • @Bloodhurl67
      @Bloodhurl67 7 лет назад

      Nikephor Well I didn't have this problem with the dlc since the huge sale that occured on spring break but I see your point. Btw don't forget how absolutely RETARDED the AI is. There are a few things I'll disagree with. The mods for your weapons. You do know that you can buy it with continental coins correct, you don't just have to use the gamble system. The skill system I would not at all say is broken at all. I can understand that it's repetitive but ya gotta understand that this game is about "heists" where you steal shit such as diamonds, money, and even break Hoxton out of prison. Every thing else I agree with, although I love the progression system in this game as it is fair and forgivable unlike games such as Bf1 where it takes fucking more than a goddamn month to get to maximum level.

  • @cCFANATIK61Cc
    @cCFANATIK61Cc 10 лет назад +1

    Super Vergleiche, macht weiter so !
    lg

  • @AggressiveHiDef
    @AggressiveHiDef 7 лет назад +13

    I have both. I played & cleared the original 1st, and fell in love with the Metro Series. Then I played and cleared Metro Last Light. Then years later I played the Redux version. I like both. There is ups and downs on both versions.
    My Comparison:
    Original to Redux:
    - Monsters look more Scarier, finer detailed and a bit darker over Redux.
    - Characters sort of look the same, and most look younger over Redux.
    - Game overall looks darker & grainier versus Redux.
    Which version do I prefer? BOTH. Play the original then play the Redux. They both have there unique characteristics. Though you have to play the ORIGINAL if you want the TRUE to LIFE experience METRO is suppose to give you.
    Last Light is a great improvement in Character movement, graphics, mask looks, like seeing smoke coming out of your filter, cleaning the mast etc., details and so on. I can't wait for a METRO 2034 Expansion Pack and a METRO 2035. Though I would prefer it be about 10-15 years in the future. Such as METRO 2055. For example.

  • @danielchernook8445
    @danielchernook8445 Год назад +2

    Honestly the sparta character look alot better in the original. Atmosphere was way better in the original aswell

  • @jUppers
    @jUppers 7 лет назад +30

    3:31 omg really?

    • @jacobmulligan5962
      @jacobmulligan5962 4 года назад +1

      I believe they just changed that section from day time to night time

    • @zxccursed5379
      @zxccursed5379 4 месяца назад

      @@jacobmulligan5962 nope. Just sun is overcast

  •  4 месяца назад +1

    I played redux first and then the original, but the gameplay feels so different, they did a really good job with the gameplay. It feels more smooth, weapons, controls, menus, everything is more like a modern game, original is just awful even when in some scenes might look a it better. Play redux is a waaayyy better experience

  • @Handler9
    @Handler9 8 лет назад +255

    why is Redux so bright? Sadly, original looks better - more atmospheric and models look better..

    • @kingzfire8937
      @kingzfire8937 7 лет назад +35

      lol redux is way better original is only darker and have some more details

    • @tastycookiechip
      @tastycookiechip 7 лет назад +12

      Nah the original is more atmospheric

    • @coolguitar2010
      @coolguitar2010 6 лет назад +1

      sadly u r an idiot

    • @Griv3836
      @Griv3836 6 лет назад

      Michelangelo00001 u need to get ur eyes checked dumbass

    • @chza1181
      @chza1181 6 лет назад

      Ur boi Jacob Hey now, hey now
      Don't dream it's over
      Hey now, hey now
      When the world comes in
      They come, they come
      To build a wall between us
      We know they won't win

  • @Sunnykr275
    @Sunnykr275 2 года назад

    Always use to love watching your graphics comparisons man. Hope you doing better :)

  • @JustinRM20
    @JustinRM20 9 лет назад +29

    I just finished the Last Light redux. Now doing the 2033 Redux. I finished 2033 on xbox already, but I had to try it on pc, so I got the redux version. The improved textures, higher polygon models are better, but I just like the more grim and gloomy atmosphere the original Metro 2033 has. The city for example looks way darker in the original than in the Redux, which is kinda sad since the game is supposed to be gritty, not full of lights. That made venturing in the city scary. Nonetheless a good job, but I like some things of the old one better.

    • @Rob712
      @Rob712 7 лет назад +10

      ProjectRealityBf2 In the novel, stalkers only venture to the surface during a night. When its daytime, the sun would be too bright, blinding them, and would burn them due to UV radiation. So I think in the original game it's nightime but in the redux version they changed the story.

    • @etunimi4206
      @etunimi4206 7 лет назад

      @Rob
      It is a Redux afterall..

    • @Scoelho83
      @Scoelho83 6 лет назад

      @@etunimi4206 Redux FAIL

    • @ryanbrown4053
      @ryanbrown4053 5 лет назад

      Literally turn down your brightness setting.

    • @michaelgordon982
      @michaelgordon982 4 года назад

      lower the brightness, simple as that

  • @Z7Sakari
    @Z7Sakari 2 года назад +2

    It's strange how they completely changed the facial appearances of most of the characters. If you played the original game and got to know those characters on sight, you would never recognize them moving to the redux.

  • @chugg159
    @chugg159 8 лет назад +108

    Alright guys, I understand that some of you don't like change, and in most cases I would agree, and this is coming from someone who hates the Last Light redux. The 2033 redux is just overall better than the original. The textures are much higher resolution, the character models look more true to Russia, and look more like real people than clean cut ass holes. The lighting is in most places far better. The changes to the environments make the game look far more true to real life, one good example of that would be the comparison between the hot water underground.
    The brighter overworld environment in this video helps better reveal what the torn apart Russia looks like in this universe instead of the constant dark underground sequences. The game runs leagues better than the original. Lastly, the particle effects, anti-aliasing, and bloom effects added in the redux greatly improve the atmosphere. And you guys are saying that this is shit?
    The only design changes I have a problem with are a select few models (only two of those models in this video) who just overall look dumber than the ones in the original. Other than that, this is the better version.

    • @tnxfgt2087
      @tnxfgt2087 8 лет назад +15

      Nah man, people in redux might look better, but the clothes on (most of) them look kinda standartized and boring. And too shiny. In fact, most of the scenery looks too bright and shiny, especially surface at day.

    • @tnxfgt2087
      @tnxfgt2087 8 лет назад +9

      Interesting, yeah, but imho it's just doesn't belongs in such setting. Surface should be terrifying to the player, or at least more depressing. Maybe, letting player go to the surface at night-time should do the trick?

    • @jojolafrite90
      @jojolafrite90 6 лет назад +1

      Morons don't like change. Intelligent people think that IF change should occur somewhere it HAS to do a better job at what it replaces.Assuming people are judging some new version of something (judging, not in good or bad terms, just judging) and that some that judged it not worth it or whatever, did it because they "don't like change" is over reducing and quite a rash and bad opinion.

    • @jojolafrite90
      @jojolafrite90 6 лет назад +1

      Glossy shader everywhere because it catches the eye of low IQ people. They don't realize it's just a shader applied everywhere. Plus its very ugly and shitty.

    • @LP-PADICIA
      @LP-PADICIA 6 лет назад +13

      +jojolafrite90 To be fair, you have to have a very high IQ to understand Metro 2033.

  • @CrazedBird
    @CrazedBird 7 лет назад +4

    Am I one of the few who thinks the redux is a proper remaster? Absolutely makes everything look better.

  • @szepiz
    @szepiz 7 лет назад +388

    shitty lightning and graphics does not mean better atmosphere
    is everyone blind? xd

    • @frankyv8584
      @frankyv8584 7 лет назад +55

      szepiz i agree. i think redux looks a lot better. except for some of the charaters faces.

    • @nomadikmind3979
      @nomadikmind3979 7 лет назад +39

      are you? its not just an atmosphere thing, the original looks better 90% of the time

    • @Jimmy-ls5nt
      @Jimmy-ls5nt 7 лет назад +15

      When I play the original sometimes I can't make out what's in front of me. Especially in a gas mask. That's what makes it even more terrifying. I'm not exactly sure what I'm walking into when I crawl into a tunnel or a dark room. Even with some light it's hard to make out the silhouettes and shadows of an enemy compared to say a table. Death stalks every corner, and I'm on the edge of me seat. Every. Single. Minute. It's amazing.

    • @ChazMcClure
      @ChazMcClure 7 лет назад +4

      well it has some good fog in some places but thats it

    • @CloverBnuy
      @CloverBnuy 7 лет назад

      On max settings the Redux looks pretty rough, however turn off all the post processing and you're left with a great experience

  • @DicasdaNet
    @DicasdaNet 3 года назад +2

    2:44
    Metro 2033: he has 132 pounds
    Metro 2033 Redux: he has 450 pounds

  • @lornilula4213
    @lornilula4213 5 лет назад +81

    I play redux in low setting so still the same for me.

    • @Al3x10_
      @Al3x10_ 4 года назад +2

      *laughs in console gamer*

    • @christopherdiaz1622
      @christopherdiaz1622 4 года назад +1

      @@Al3x10_ laughs in 120 fps pc gamer

    • @zoiuduu
      @zoiuduu 4 года назад +2

      @@christopherdiaz1622 what the fuck is ur nme?? it bugged my youtube,, the line goes beyhond the video tiles lol

    • @mingithemango
      @mingithemango 4 года назад

      @@zoiuduu it's a morsecode

    • @blck0ut572
      @blck0ut572 3 года назад

      @@Al3x10_ laughs in 200 fps pc gamer

  • @Grainsauce
    @Grainsauce 4 года назад +1

    Lighting is the main difference pause at 0:55

  • @hihithisisalex
    @hihithisisalex 5 лет назад +11

    3:04 Teddy bear!

  • @benireges
    @benireges 5 лет назад +10

    Original indeed looks better in general, but that's due to the gamma-settings, which-by the way-can be adjusted. Original also stutters a lot more. Redux stutters a lot less, and has a load of gameplay enhancements. Atmosphere is mostly about the same, and some levels are during daylight in Redux.
    There's more to Redux's advantages than what I just stated.

  • @orangypteco8858
    @orangypteco8858 6 лет назад +21

    It triggers me so much that Artyom lacks his tattered gloves at the beginning of Metro 2033 redux.

  • @vesselinkrastev
    @vesselinkrastev 5 лет назад +11

    The video doesn't do the Redux version justice. The upgrade in terms of assets, lightning and effects like smoke and fog is much more apparent when you have it running in real time. I played them back to back some couple of weeks ago.
    That said, the art direction has definitely changed. I can understand people liking the look of certain areas better in the original. I personally think that both versions are worth playing if you like the series. It's a shame that the original game was removed from Steam.
    Another thing was that the original was too dark for me in many places. Like to the point I could barely see where I was going during stealth sections. It was virtually impossible to find out where some of the traps were without bumping into them first and reloading a checkpoint. The gamma setting did little to alleviate that. The Redux was much matter in that regard. I could actually see where I was going and it was still plenty dark where it was appropriate. The gamma setting actually perceptibly changes things and has reference images which help you to adjust it.

    • @K3zster
      @K3zster 5 лет назад

      You have a torch and night vision though..

    • @v-trigger6137
      @v-trigger6137 5 лет назад

      this is the only valid comment in this whole video

    • @v-trigger6137
      @v-trigger6137 5 лет назад

      @@K3zster still it's looks very dark even on nightvision too I remember how it giving me headache I was having problem in focusing

    • @Scoelho83
      @Scoelho83 5 лет назад

      @@v-trigger6137 change the brighness xD Original is much better in Terror, still the Redux is more fun and i love catch the secret keys and pages.... is Real terror vs Pure fun

  • @IamTheGreatCornholioo
    @IamTheGreatCornholioo 5 лет назад +7

    2:13 this must be trolling, look at the nose lmao

  • @GeraAbi
    @GeraAbi 8 месяцев назад

    2024 and I just now finished Metro2033 redux on console, tomorrow starts Last light, after that, Exodus.
    I played the series like 3x by now, always with like a 2 year break.
    I will play it in a few years again, the series is timeless and really holds up even up today.
    The redux versions really are a blessing.

  • @randomizer368
    @randomizer368 2 года назад

    3:51 this jump is what it felt like when i saw metro exodus for the first time

  • @yunglean4838
    @yunglean4838 6 лет назад +124

    Оц тоц перевертоц бабушка здорова!)

  • @PuppiKatts
    @PuppiKatts 5 месяцев назад +1

    The Redux models and detail work is superior to the original, but the lighting in the original’s is so good.

  • @alljust2120
    @alljust2120 6 лет назад +224

    Мне кажется или оригинал более мрачный и страшный ?

    • @ПожилойскаутСелуса
      @ПожилойскаутСелуса 6 лет назад +6

      Да.

    • @javansfeb3746
      @javansfeb3746 6 лет назад +21

      В некоторых да , в особенности тот момент когда упырь на дрезину запрыгивает ! Но буря на пути к Останкинской башне гораздо страшнее и опаснее выглядит в редакс версии .

    • @wasabiwell
      @wasabiwell 6 лет назад +12

      По-моему это сравнение х*уя с пальцем . Тогда технологии не позволяли такое выдавать , поэтому и вышло , что игра такая мрачноватая . А так да , оригинал лучше .

    • @andreyzvonnik1918
      @andreyzvonnik1918 5 лет назад

      Так и есть.

    • @КлёпаХокаге
      @КлёпаХокаге 5 лет назад +6

      В ориге больше резкости и контраста, но в редаксе почти нет повторяющихся скинов и мыла нежели в ориге.

  • @Promethium666
    @Promethium666 5 лет назад

    Nice comparison thanks!

  • @elpatrico2562
    @elpatrico2562 4 года назад +5

    I just recently started to play the game, I haven't play the older version, but I wish we had that darker stormier outside lighting than the blinding new one.

    • @BurakTaban
      @BurakTaban Год назад +1

      I feel the same. Now that I see the older version, I'm not eager to play the redux version.

    • @afufu-b5k
      @afufu-b5k Год назад

      @@BurakTaban I played first 10 min and uninstalled.

  • @Z7Sakari
    @Z7Sakari 2 года назад +2

    Wild. If you didn't have the clips labeled I would have been fooled into thinking the better looking one was the remaster.
    After seeing this I'll stick with the original, in almost all regards it looks superior to me.

  • @w_atso_n
    @w_atso_n 10 лет назад +4

    They added some more effects, lens flares and made better textures.
    The Redux looks very good.

  • @mynameiskranz
    @mynameiskranz 3 года назад +1

    0:37 original is more detail

  • @stavroskoul119
    @stavroskoul119 5 лет назад +21

    Redux looks SOOOO MUCH BETTER. Except for the character details. It also has fewer frame dropw and improved optimisation. Redux is the way to go.

  • @DiegoAlanTorres96
    @DiegoAlanTorres96 8 лет назад +2

    The 2010 release didn't work in my celeron N2806 with Intel HD but this one did splendidly. I welcome the addition of more difficulties and a "playstyle" option, plus there is more exploration in some areas where you have to search keys for safes that contain military ammo and stuff, and also there's more customization for weapons. However, the shinier graphics affects the overall theme of the game and may scare off some players from the original title.

  • @KuroNekoIX
    @KuroNekoIX 5 лет назад +6

    the redux version looks great, but wtf happened at 1:10 :)))

    • @ottokaiser_
      @ottokaiser_ 4 года назад +1

      Maybe sleepy effect

    • @jorisd6584
      @jorisd6584 4 года назад

      He just woke up so they added a sleepy blur

  • @LeviAckerman-ln8kt
    @LeviAckerman-ln8kt 10 лет назад +1

    Bilde ich mir das nur ein oder sieht das Original besser aus? Wenn man mal bei dem Vieh guckt was auf den Wagen springt, ist die Haut doch beim Original deutlich detaillierter als bei der Redux Version. Auch der Boden sieht beim original finde ich iwie besser aus als in der Reduxversion und der Typ der da bei 44 Sekunden rumballert hat beim beim original auch iwie schärfere Texturen. ich kann mir nicht helfen aber ich finde das Original sieht sogar besser aus, dazu ist es düsterer als die Reduxversion was die Atmosphäre verstärkt.

  • @AlbinoJedi
    @AlbinoJedi 9 лет назад +3

    Personally I think the only thing the Redux improves on visually is some shadows and outside effects. The original has much better human models and has a dingier atmosphere about it probably due to choices of lighting and particles. The Redux messed up peoples faces. I have heard that the redux did improve on the controls though.

  • @Griftercash
    @Griftercash 8 лет назад

    Great video!

  • @FoxrainFuture
    @FoxrainFuture 10 лет назад +10

    Also rein vom grafischen her ist die Redux version natürlich besser aber stilistisch gefällt mir das original besser. Die Redux version ist teilweise sehr aufgehellt und ich finde die metro muss einfach düster sein^^

  • @baalyoz
    @baalyoz 4 года назад +1

    03:51 original is very good

  • @Powerbasti
    @Powerbasti 10 лет назад +59

    Unglaublich.. ich finde die Originale Version viel besser und stimmiger :D

    • @Candyland
      @Candyland  10 лет назад +11

      Mir persönlich - und da spreche ich rein als Privatperson - gefällt die Originalversion auch viel besser als die Redux. Ich finde die Atmosphäre im Originalen stimmiger. BG, Steve

    • @DerKnochensturm
      @DerKnochensturm 10 лет назад +2

      Die "alte" Version kommt viel authentischer rüber, die Szene mit dem kleinen Teddybären z.B. Der Teddy sieht in der alten Version viel ranziger aus.
      Für die Konsoleros isses halt okay das die auch mal in schön und flüssig spielen können und nicht in 30 Frames Pixelbrei xD

    • @dicktracy2720
      @dicktracy2720 8 лет назад +4

      Naja also die Redux Version sieht um längen besser aus, die Texturen sind höher aufgelöst, es liegt eher an RUclips das man es nicht so sieht, wie groß der Unterscheid ist.
      Besonders das Motion Blur macht einiges an Unterschied aus wenn man es spielt, doch bei RUclips lässt einiges an Motion Blur das Video schlecht aussehend wirken

    • @dicktracy2720
      @dicktracy2720 8 лет назад +1

      Und es sind viel mehr LIchtquellen in der Redux Version, was die Komplette Atmossphäre weit aus besser wirken lässt

  • @jojolafrite90
    @jojolafrite90 6 лет назад

    5:28. NOT "particles effect". Simple animated texture with alpha blend (transparent).

  • @lazzi9465
    @lazzi9465 6 лет назад +24

    Вернуть-бы старую атмосферу но оставить графику..Было-бы хорошо . Но когда мертвый Московский город выглядит не так мрачно как тогда..... Печально . А РАНЬШЕ-ТО Я УСИРАЛСЯ МЕЛКИМ ИГРАТЬ В МЕТРО

    • @Anonguy7
      @Anonguy7 6 лет назад

      Bleeding Pain в октябре оригинальную раздавали бесплатно ) теперь я вот думаю Редукс или оригинал проходить) обе проходил раньше ) но уже не помню)

    • @lazzi9465
      @lazzi9465 6 лет назад +1

      @Bleeding Pain P/s метро забрал :D
      Прикол в том, что на два стула не сядешь, ибо атмосфера метро осталась в старой версии, а как ни крути графен и остальные фишки нового метро остались в редакс...

    • @ZAVA_DEN
      @ZAVA_DEN 6 лет назад +2

      Дада срался и играл, снова срался выключал на часик и снова в библиотеку

    • @barsdkd6859
      @barsdkd6859 6 лет назад +2

      мелким? метро вышла не так уж и давно, так что ты и сейчас не особо взрослый

    • @axelsmul6889
      @axelsmul6889 6 лет назад

      Да хз, такое себе. Вот в сталкера я ссался играть

  • @bloodySunday77
    @bloodySunday77 5 лет назад +1

    Lots of different opinions here, and it just goes to show that a decision for a game/movie/music album remaster will never be recognized as a successful one by default. Sometimes everything just clicks at the 1st attempt when the creators just get their inspiration out of their system.
    The way I see it: Redux has some significant improvements in graphics, but they are sporadic & the newer artistic choices of the creators rarely look as good & successful as the original. In 70% of the scenes of this video I would definitely choose the original. I think the choice between polished and atmospheric is an easy one. I would be more than willing to sacrifice some fidelity in graphics to get a better atmosphere that remains close to the original artistic vision. (As far as gameplay, I can't be sure.)

  • @chunlee8827
    @chunlee8827 7 лет назад +8

    i absolutely love the metro series, cant wait for exodus

    • @gdgd5194
      @gdgd5194 3 года назад +1

      It was pretty good, the exodus :D

  • @galy0
    @galy0 2 года назад

    Thank you for the video.

  • @chza1181
    @chza1181 6 лет назад +9

    It’s too bright, in the book they would go blind if they went out with the sun blazing.

  • @DoctorObviously
    @DoctorObviously 2 года назад +1

    While I do like the Redux more, it's a very close call. The original is much, much more darker, which makes sense, but the Redux then has changed the graphics in such a way that certain scenes looks much better. I think the monsters look a lot better in the Redux, but then it lights them up way too much. I prefer the UI a lot more in Redux as well.

  • @ChicoAzevedo
    @ChicoAzevedo 5 лет назад +3

    I need to play this game again.

  • @lukie80de
    @lukie80de 9 лет назад +1

    What I found by very close inspection of the video:
    - Textures seem to have the same resolution as in the original :)
    - New textures are less crispy because they have less specularity and bumpiness :(
    Criticism: Sometimes it is very difficult to compare texture quality here because of:
    - AA is OFF in the original version
    - Motion blur is ON in the redux version
    - Recording resolution is not always 1920 × 1080 but sometimes lower
    Nevertheless, thanks for the comparison.

  • @MegaGuver
    @MegaGuver 9 лет назад +16

    redux has better lightning yes but the original has a better atmosphere i think

    • @zolta8445
      @zolta8445 6 лет назад +1

      The original have a better lighting and better atmosphere.

    • @ryanbrown4053
      @ryanbrown4053 5 лет назад +1

      @@zolta8445 just turn down your brightness

    • @michaelgordon982
      @michaelgordon982 4 года назад +2

      @@zolta8445 lower your gamma and you'll get that original 2033 with much improved gameplay

  • @traploli2214
    @traploli2214 2 года назад +1

    The only things that bothered me in redux where the character models and how some of them always looked surprised with wide open eyes as well as some off putting lighting but that’s about it.

  • @RogVanek
    @RogVanek 5 лет назад +4

    Очень приятно, что западные игроки играют в метро и им она нравится)

  • @BrokkoliSchleuder
    @BrokkoliSchleuder 9 лет назад +1

    eigentlich tragen nur die lichteffekt zu einer "besseren" grafik bei. Personen sehen zT definitiv bescheuerter aus. Ansonsten passt finde ich der etwas verwaschenere (und auch unscharfe!) Look der alten Version durchaus besser. In Games ohne düsteres Endzeitszenario wahrscheinlich anders..

  • @SteveL11
    @SteveL11 5 лет назад +4

    It's 2019 and I just played both Redux prior to Exodus and got to say, it's hold up REALLY well. 2033 Redux & Last Light Redux still have more details than other games released in 2018. Such a great franchise.

    • @camo5567
      @camo5567 5 лет назад +2

      Yeh I downloaded ark survival evolved and the graphics are so bad it's a joke,then I downloaded metro which is an older game and it looks pretty good in my opinion.

    • @siscovrcgt3
      @siscovrcgt3 2 года назад

      👍👍👍💙

  • @Roebuck325
    @Roebuck325 5 лет назад +2

    All these years, and artyom has now become hunter.

  • @shawnfuller5544
    @shawnfuller5544 5 лет назад +10

    I think this has to do with your graphic and screen settings with the right settings redux's lighting is amazing as good or better than the original

    • @OnlyNeedJuan
      @OnlyNeedJuan 4 года назад +1

      Yeah gamma feels a little high in the redux version. But even then, color palette in redux is generally more pleasing. I don't really get the "oh it's post apocalyptic, everything ought to be grey and dark otherwise it's not moody enough, when redux definitely gives you dark and gloomy when it needs to.
      I think the first step onto the surface is far better in redux, it feels frozen in time, almost alien with tranquility. In the original it's just a slightly brighter metro.

  • @flatterkatz
    @flatterkatz 3 года назад

    at 1:12 - yeah no. the original wasn't that blurry.

  • @Artur960426
    @Artur960426 8 лет назад +9

    After playing both I can say, that Original has better atmosphere in visuals.
    Also sounds are better, for example, when you have silent moments in Original you hear only surroundings, while in Redux you hear some stupid music. It ruins whole tension and immersion.
    If you have platform to play Metro 2033 (X360 or PC), bypass Redux version and get Original.

    • @tastycookiechip
      @tastycookiechip 7 лет назад

      The atmosphere and gameplay immersion suffers however

    • @chza1181
      @chza1181 6 лет назад

      Tech Hybrid I thought the original had a better atmosphere as well, It’s just an opinion dude no need to be a baby.

    • @ryanbrown4053
      @ryanbrown4053 5 лет назад

      What? Lol literally turn off the music and turn the brightness down. This is such an easy fix that it's a non-issue, but no one seems to be able to figure that out.

  • @senku2768
    @senku2768 4 года назад +1

    Increiblemente el remastered esta mejor optimizado para las pc papatas, gente si tienen integradas con 4 de ram descarguen el redux, 30 fps es lo minimo que me tira cuando dispara, cosa que en el original bajaba hasta 15 o 20

  • @harrierdubois975
    @harrierdubois975 6 лет назад +15

    Оригинал лучше, по крайней мере атмосферой.

    • @NONAME-pl8up
      @NONAME-pl8up 4 года назад +2

      Оригинал проработанее вглядись в детали, а ремейк он более красивее но все же мне по душе оригинал

  • @JoschNo1
    @JoschNo1 10 лет назад +1

    Dieser Vergleich zeigt doch einfach nur wie gut das Original ist xD

  • @Masterwar15
    @Masterwar15 5 лет назад +3

    If I recall correctly Redux also changes the gameplay, and as you can see it also enhances the frames A LOT. I'm telling you, it's the better experience imo. Stealth is better too.

  • @SpartanOli
    @SpartanOli 6 лет назад +2

    Is it just me that find that most of the textures from the old one is better? For example, outside (during the first cinematic), in the old it's way darker, which is more scary and have more mood imo

    • @ryanbrown4053
      @ryanbrown4053 5 лет назад

      Literally turn down the brightness

    • @ryanbrown4053
      @ryanbrown4053 5 лет назад

      @BillyTheSillyWilly Thank you, I'm not sure how half the commenters haven't figured this out. All complaining about the atmosphere not being dark enough in redux, when it's SO easily remedied.

  • @brenanonberenstein5548
    @brenanonberenstein5548 4 года назад +3

    YO THEY ADDED MY BOY PRAPOR??? MAD RESPECT! THAT NIGGA OWES ME 7.62X39MM AMMO!

  • @DeiGmz
    @DeiGmz 3 года назад +1

    I played both and for me the original had better atmosphere and it was more difficult to survive, without a doubt the best experience is the original, in my opinion.

  • @UltraSolarGod
    @UltraSolarGod 6 лет назад +20

    am i the only one who bough all 4 of them Because i cant tell which one i liked the mosted

  • @vencerfennec417
    @vencerfennec417 3 года назад

    Great vid :D

  • @Fero1998
    @Fero1998 6 лет назад +13

    Мне одному оригинал больше нравится? Цвет более насыщенный, мрачная атмосфера - действительно мрачна, а не тусклая как в редокс, а у костров насыщенный жёлтый теплый цвет создаёт уют и покой. Да и озвучка в оригинале лучше, в редокс взяли щегла на роль - вс испортили

    • @erielgrower7820
      @erielgrower7820 5 лет назад +1

      Потому что Артем и есть щегол на время игры. У него явно в 24 года не будет голос обкуренного дядьки. Плюс редукса в том,что там оптимизацию завезли.

  • @EldarKillToz
    @EldarKillToz 6 лет назад +1

    1:42 - Why original looks more sharp and better? Why in original version, we have better textures? Why in redus version sooo much soap like blur, bloom, lensflare and more shity staff? C'mon guys. Redus version is killing atmosfear and graphics style, but adding better light and shadows + better models and I think, original version is much better if you like dark atmosfear and graphics without soap.

  • @GnomeKr
    @GnomeKr 6 лет назад +18

    Watch in 140p for true slavic experience

  • @nickwillard4471
    @nickwillard4471 5 лет назад +1

    Except for how some of the character's eyes look I pretty much think that redux looks better. It has superior lighting, the stealth is better, higher quality models, and the environment detail just isn't really even comparable. Hands down the redux version is the way to go. The only things the original really have over it are the fact that there isn't a limit to how much ammo you can carry, and the eyeballs look ever so slightly better on some characters.

  • @tomrabbani
    @tomrabbani 5 лет назад +82

    Who else is here because it's free on Epic Games lol

    • @killthatbeast4392
      @killthatbeast4392 5 лет назад +2

      Me

    • @whyarewestillhere1073
      @whyarewestillhere1073 5 лет назад +6

      I bought the redux when it came out...so...

    • @freakingamerspoint7424
      @freakingamerspoint7424 5 лет назад

      Me lol and it's a fun game and now I gotta buy last light and exodus

    • @theonewhoknocks1412
      @theonewhoknocks1412 5 лет назад +2

      I just finished originall 2033 and then went to epic to download because i tought redux is second part but i just realized it’s remastered version of it lmao im disapointed

    • @watchman260386
      @watchman260386 5 лет назад

      $7 steam 2033 and LL

  • @SheffAlex
    @SheffAlex 9 лет назад +1

    Anyone know the song that plays at 4:25? Thanks in advance