00:25 My love story 01:17 Amagami 01:40 Angel beats 02:09 Anohana 03:08 Baka test 03:25 Bunny girl senpai 03:47 Call of the night 04:29 Charlotte 04:50 Domestic Girlfriend 07:19 Dress-up Darling 08:23 I want to eat your pancreas 08:59 Garden of words 09:43 Horimiya 10:11 Infinite Stratos 11:09 Your name 11:46 Yosuga no Sora 13:22 His and her circumstances 13:50 Kokoro Connect 14:51 Your lie in April 15:23 Komi can't communicate 15:58 Bloom into you 16:12 Love Hina 17:00 To love Ru 17:53 Highschool DxD and Highschool of the Dead 19:12 Masamune kun's revenge 20:24 The world god only knows 21:15 Fruits Basket 21:25 Ouran Highschool Host Club 21:56 Nana 22:43 Tenchi Muyo! 23:18 Gamers 23:35 Don't toy with me, miss Nagatoro! 24:14 Nisekoi 24:43 Monthly Girls' Nozaki-kun 26:15 Oreimo 27:33 Rent a girlfriend 28:40 Scum's Wish 29:23 A silent voice 30:02 Tonikawa 30:38 Quintessential Quintuplets 31:39 Toradora 32:24 Sing "Yesterday" for me 32:50 Golden time 33:15 Kaguya-sama 33:38 Eromanga sensei 33:44 Monogatari
Garnt and Sydney really look like Horimiya's final destination. Sydney, being Hori's counterpart with her chaotic energy and Garnt being Miyamura's with his "Everything's FINE guys👍🏻" energy
I think both of them wouldn't like anime like Oregairu. Like... It's Sydney and Garnt. Oregairu is almost the opposite of the types of show they enjoy.
@@rumplstiltztinkerstein garnt said that if he had watched OreGairu S3 in 2020 It would've been his anime of the year but as he didn't got the time to re-watch the whole thing he picked Re:zero
@@SuyashMishra-rm1fbdamn that is what I was thinking....hyouka is one of the best LN adaptation but still it didn't have that much romance in it till the end ya know...
Naw. I actually rewatched Toradora recently. Shes actually REALLY fucking aggressive for like half the series. I dont mean like tsun tsun mean words, like physically assaulting him. Granted, for me it makes the second half of the series that much sweeter. Would put it higher on the list than they did.
Whoever doesn't get the appeal of Nagatoro probably has extremely low t, I see no other explanation. A cute sporty and extremely energetic tanned girl who teases you daily in an very sexual way is a peak fantasy of every straight man. It's so much better than all those frigid kuderes and tsunderes that need 3 seasons of courting and warming up just to hold hands.
Nah, who would have ever seen description of Domestic Girlfriend and thinking "yeah, that what I need". It didn't awake something in Garnt, it just straight up broke his anime romantic taste
Domestic Gf shouldn't even be on that list jesus, that anime is a waste of time and honestly know there are better romances to put up there rather than that.
So I had my volume up eating lunch in a workers cafe. Saw this and said, "Let's watch this" and the intro was loud. quickly turn down the volume, but a decent amount of random co-workers heard and now are looking at me weirdly. Thanks Sydney.
If you do a part 2 (and if you’ve seen them): • Maid-sama! • Hikari-san / Miss Modern • Rumbling Hearts • Clannad • ef • Yuri on Ice • O Maidens in your Savage Season
I really dont get that one tbh. Mai is such an insufferable piece of shit with how she sadistically hurts him. I get that like 90% of anime fans seem to be masochists, but she is genuinely completely nonconsensual in how she does it. Yes, he "enjoys" it, but she never stops to obtain consent or even to check his boundaries, mainly because that has literally nothing to do with why she does it. She does it because she is upset or feeling sadistic. How does someone who isnt a supreme masochist enjoy anything involving her? The fact that they put bunny girl above dress up darling, which is a healthy romance, is just appalling to me.
@@_Lumiere_ This is probably... Well, not the worst analysis I've ever seen, but definitely one of them. This take is so shallow, straightforward and dumb, one can't even make this up for trolling. I'm not saying that the majority is always correct, but the fact that this anime is so well received should at least motivate you to look a bit deeper into the characters and their interactions, idk. Or maybe rewatch the thing more thoroughly. However such arguments often set you against the anime itself, so you can't even make an objective take on this. "Nah, everything is obvious, the show is trash" is the most i expect from your response tbh. Some personal insults are also welcome (well, kinda deserved since i might've gone a bit too far but still)
@@perchatka This is a long reply, so let me just say that I dont think that anyone is wrong for liking that show. After all, we are all just voicing our opinions. If you're interested, here's why I dislike the romance in Bunny Girl Senpai. Here's the thing, I can acknowledge that there is some deep romance and otherwise interesting character development in a story. But at the same time a story may gloss over some glaring flaw like physical abuse. Perhaps there's some story with a prince who kidnaps a maiden and forces her to sleep with him, but then they fall in love and their romance ends up being the most well-written thing ever. I can acknowledge the interesting characters and the deep romance, but I would not be able to shake the terrible thing that that love was built on. Or perhaps it's a story of a master and a slave who fall in love and their romance is so deep and nice, but every now and then the master puts his foot down and beats the slave over some transgression. Then everything goes back to being lovey dovey. I would acknowledge the depth of the writing, but I would not enjoy the romance. These examples are exaggerations, but it really is as simple as that. That's how I felt about Horimiya. I didnt like how Hori would get jealous over him talking to another girl, to the point that she straight up threw heavy books in his face (while he was wearing glasses). That would hurt like a motherfucker and would personally be unforgivable for me in a real relationship. So I cant view that as a healthy romance even if it's otherwise written well. I also cant stand how she forces him to act "dominant" and abusive towards her in public without considering his own boundaries about that. That's something that's personal to me as I'm involved in such play myself. That's also what's happening here. Mai is objectively abusing him without actually checking with him that it is ok, as you would do in a bdsm relationship. It doesnt matter if he "likes it". Even if a sub says that they like something, you dont do these things unprompted. You discuss these things and regularly check in with them to see if it's truly ok and that they arent just playing along for you. Mai doesnt even approach this from that kind of standpoint, she just does it because she wants to. This stuff is very close to my heart, so when I see something being done in such an unhealthy way, that taints the entire story and the entire relationship for me. So, unless you can somehow prove to me that what I said is wrong, how exactly is this the "worst analysis you've ever seen"? Does she sit down with him and respectfully discuss his boundaries, what he is ok with and what he isnt ok with, or does she just slap him and step on his foot unprompted? Call him names? And does she do this as a well-defined "bedroom play" or does she simply slap him because she is angry? In an attempt to force him to apologize to her without respectfully considering his side? Can you truthfully answer any of these questions without it seeming like an abusive relationship? Objectively speaking? I cant think of this as some fluffy romance when this is what I'm presented with in the show. And that's as someone who actually does enjoy the whole kink thing irl. Perhaps that's why this aspect of the show ruins it for me, because I can't stand seeing it done in an unhealthy way, it's too close to home. There is a lack of basic respect in this dynamic. But if you can dismiss all these things and if you like masochistic fiction without caring for boundaries or consent (and there's nothing wrong really with liking a fantasy like that, as long as it is a fantasy), then I'm sure the show is great. I won't deny that the characters or plot may be interesting. But abusive, unbalanced relationships are a dealbreaker for me when it comes to enjoying a romance that isnt a sexual fantasy. For me, a "perfect" fictional romance is one that I would actually tolerate seeing in real life. I would never tolerate nor want to see an irl relationship like the one in Bunny Girl Senpai and so that romance will never be on top of my list, even if it may have well-written elements. In contrast, while I'm not like Gojo myself, if I were in his shoes I would be happy with a relationship with Marin. I can view that as a nice example of a romance.
@@_Lumiere_ oh, so this goes even deeper into the things i hate in modern society - the Abuse witnesses. I rarely talk about this shit, but i actually have something to say. First, about the relationship in the anime. Sakuta clearly showed Mai that he doesn't mind this kind of teasing and he actually kinda likes it. Also Mai (and us viewers as well) knows Sakuta's character pretty well, so if he didn't like anything about what she did he would definitely tell her. They're ok, i don't worry about how their relationships go because i know they'll be good. Then about the social aspect of abuse. If the culture doesn't let some people cope with abuse (middle east or anything like that) then we can't do anything about that, it takes a very long time to reform a culture. If you live in a more liberal environment then it's all your choice how to deal with your abusive partner and whether to keep them your partner at all. In this case it's only your fault that you're being abused. Marriage, kids? Then you've made a mistake the very moment you married, it's just the consequences of your choice. Divorce is still an option after all. People these days tend to keep yapping about their problems and disturb everyone around them instead of trying to deal with those problems. In my opinion this is a sign of mental weakness. And this is what i never want to think about while discussing anime.
I trust Syd more to give fair ratings for romance anime more because yes she has biases just like Garnt but holy shit does he upgrade too many due to personal taste.
Surprised that "Wotakoi" and "O maiden of your savage season" wasn't on the list! I quite liked both of them, despite both having a sort of lackluster ending.
Same but also wondering where Orange is at. How can you do a romance list without best bro who takes the long term L but actually gets a massive W in the end.
No love for Ichigo 100% (The Manga, the anime died at ep 2 due to changes) Lovely Complex Ai yori Aoishi School Rumble Golden Boy (Technically, travel romcom)
I was disappointed until the end because one of my favourites oregairu and dangers in my heart were missing but then grant said part 2 and now i know i will be there
I wish you added Love Chuunibyou and Other Delusions, Tamako Love Story, Kyoukai no Kanata, Hyouka, A Whisker Away, Hotarubi no Mori e, Josee the Tiger and the Fish, My Stepmom's Daughter is my Ex, Romantic Killer, Love Election and Chocolate, Bokutachi no Remake, Weathering with You, 5 Centimeters per Second, and The Place Promised in Our Early Days. Also the infamous School Days.
How did you guys even come up with this list of "romance anime" to rate? So many of them don't even have the romance tag. I was half expecting Demon Slayer to show up at some point.
Tsurezure Children is my favorite. Quite shocking its not in that list! Having multiple couples makes it easier to stay interested, its not about choosing best girl or the big drama, its about smaller situations between people. Almost like a collection of how various couples came to be together but each couple offers a different flavour of romance. Its got something for everyone, how can you not like it?
I'd recommend reading the manga if you haven't! It's completed, and actually my favourite couple in the series are only in the manga, definitely worth it.
LIST OF THE RESULTS S Grand Finale Bunny Girl Sempai Domestic Girlfriend Horimiya Your Name Sosuga no Sora Highschool DXD The World God Only Knows Fruits Basket Oran High School Club Nana Rent a Girlfriend Love Is War Monogatare A Amagami SS My Dress Up Darling Garden of Words His and Her Circumstance Kokoro Connect Bloom Into You Love Hina Masamune-kun's Revenge Tenchi Muyo Don't Toy With Me Ms Nagatoro Oremoio Tonikawa B Oremonogatari Anohana The Flower we Saw That Day Call of the Night I Want To Eat Your Pancreas Nisekoi False Love Monthly Girls Nozaki-kun A Silent Voice Quintessential Quintuplets Toradora C Angel Beats Baka and Test Your Lie In April Komi Can't Communicate Scum's Wish D Charlotte To Love Ru Gamers Sing "Yesterday" For Me Eromanga Sensei Didn't Watch Infinite Stratos So Many Colors
Not sure when this was recorded but two I really enjoyed recently are A sign of affection and The Dangers in my Heart; was wondering where those would end up but weren't on the list.
I just finish Hyouka few days ago and this show has really little romance subplot, but even this small pieces was so good and feels so natural, much better then many "official" romances))
Exactly! You can feel natural chemistry. Not enough anime do romance like that. Spice and wolf and Steins gate are two other anime that don't make the romance the focus but the chemistry is excellent.
The Angel next door spoils me rotten, tamako love story, strawberry panic, chuunibyou demo koi ga shitai, saenai heroine no sodatekata AND the dangers in my heart were missing
@@rifqimfauzan6809 Comedy was boring af, went thru whole episodes not laughing once and some annoying af characters. Watch more comedy anime, then you'll know what actually funny
@@OK-mv4ih there is difference between comedy in romance and actual comedy anime. For romance anime Kaguya comedy was top compare to other romcom anime but if you compare it to actual comedy anime like Chiyo, Asobi Asobase, Danshi Kokosei, Hinamatsuri, JK Mudazukai etc yes it was boring. For another example of top romcom is Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun or Tsurezure Children
Dear lord the rating inflation on this list was insane. Also, putting Toradora in B tier is a travesty. I watched it earlier this year for the first time ever and it's now my favorite romance anime. The abuse was admittedly tough in the beginning, but it evolved nicely over time and was explained within the context of the story, which is what I needed to accept it. Too often a tsundere is just a tsundere for no reason but to serve as an easy character trope to mask poor writing, but Taiga's background made it understandable. Also, they fell in love because they both needed each other given their family situations, it was a genuinely touching love story compared a lot of the trash littering the A and S tiers. Even with the abuse it was still a much more believable love story than the vast majority of romance anime. One last thing, the original light novel NEVER makes Taiga physically violent with Ryuji except for the home invasion scene. If that is what stops you from enjoying the anime I suggest people try reading the light novel instead.
I watched Toradora recently and In the running in the stairs scene I think Minorin Gaslight Ryuji into thinking he loves Taiga because imo he definitely loved Minorin. (This is definitely not my copium that I wanted Minorin and Ryuji to be together)
Something that most people won't pick up on watching Toradora as well, is that Taiga is a fundamentally broken character. What she says/how she acts/what she actually things never seems to line up properly. In the last few episodes, where she's actively trying to lie to herself and everyone around her really shows how far gone she is mentally into this disillusioned state where she can never be important to anyone. The characters in this show were absolute peak writing, S tier for life.
I suddenly remembered a few romances from back in the day. Anyone else remember 'Tsuredure Children' and 'I can't understand what my husband is saying'?
I love Tsuredure Children. It's like they took the high school romance things and distilled it to its purest form. Too bad it never got more anime adaption.
@@DUFFAL02It looks like it's just not up your alley bro. It's one of the best in terms romance animes. You can't claim YLIA is bad because it never was bad at all.
@@B.G_Glyphs I wasn’t claiming it was bad, I just said it was the worst I have watched. It was still a decent anime, I just wasn’t a fan of it. The melodrama is what killed it for me.
@@B.G_Glyphs is it good, yeah, but “one of the best in terms of romance” is questionable, if that's good romance then I’ll consider Demon Slayer a romance show too
Tadano did not date anyone else. Manbagi the gyaru (best girl), was in love with him and wanted to get with him but he had feelings for Komi. Also, the manga is still ongoing even after they got together. So we definitely cannot say that it's most of the series that it took for them to get together.
Also fuck yeah to The World God Only Knows -- loved that show. But ...there's two I'm not seeing so far. They're older but ...they deserve being rated (Marmalade Boy and Kimagure Orange Road)
I didn't watch the full second season because of the shift in writing but from what I remember it had basically no romance. Just comedy and pain disguised through comedy. Amazing first season though. It's one of the anime that made me laugh the emost
Surprised that Oregairu is not on this list and I think you underrated Toradora. I really thought it depicted the situation well where people spend time together and then later on down the line realise they have been hit with a case of the feels.
@@simonenoli4418 "lost my pieces" is brutal. I watched the 3 Christmas episodes every year for Christmas as kind of a tradition (stopped when I had kids, lack of time)
As Bloom Into You was robbed by having 15 seconds of spotlight, let me recommend it. It brought me into manga. Watch the only seaon, then read the remaining 5 to 8 mangas. Can be all done in one sitting, concludes the story in a nice way.
Yeah and it was also robbed of not having a second season (even though I haven't even watched the first haha) Probably the best yuri, the story isn't anything crazy but the characters are really really good and the execution is almost flawless
True, and has way different approach to the subject of love than every other romance on the list. (Slight spoilers below) I hate when romance shows just finds two characters and they like each other from the start or after one event. Instead love in real life is more active, you have to put in effort and time to fall in love, it won't just happen. Which is the main theme of the show.
He completely forgot the whole theme of the list lmao. It’s about how good the romance is, not how much you can’t look away from the romance. And RAGF is as bad of a romance as you can get.
Okay, part 2 is DEFINITELY needed. Fuufuu Ijou, Dangers in my Heart, Tomo-Chan, Yamada-kun, Angel Next Door, Couple of Cuckoos, Spice and Wolf, Elf Bride, and the biggest slam dunk S-tier of all time, 100 Girlfriends.
Lovely Complex would be another missing. That said, if a romance story isn't finished, it really shouldn't be on the list, or just automatically dumped into a "Not finished" tier. Because, sure, some shows are trash from start to finish (Domestic Girlfriend), and even the worst possible ending (worst girl wins) won't drag it down any further, but if a show can't stick the landing, it doesn't deserve to be rated highly. And never getting to the landing part means they haven't stuck it yet.
Finally people realize the greatness of Golden Time (the 2nd opening is a banger). But there's a big missing piece in this ter liest: OreGairu, the prince of all the waifu wars.
second opening is epic, first half of the show is epic. But man, the second half of golden time REALLY killed it. Not enough to make it a terrible show but god that ending hurt me with how much bad writing was in it, felt so rushed (at least in the anime)
That second half was so bad. I still can't believe how much love some people have for it. At one point it was like the #1 or #2 rated romance anime and it should have never been there
30:07 It's more than just a feel-good story. It's the continuation of an ancient story, and the fulfillment of a promise that survived eons. Tonikaku: Fly Me to the Moon, is one of the greatest stories ever told, and part of what makes it so good is how subtle it is. You won't really realize what's actually going on, until you're like seven episodes in, and even then, you'll only have the barest hints, but once you get it, you will remember all the small details that seemed insignificant from the start of the first episode. 30:20 I can't tell if you guys are trying to avoid massive spoilers, or if you really don't know what's going on with the story.
Came for The World God Only Knows. Not disappointed. The way they showed the emotional damage caused by what the MC had to do throughout the show was S tier alone. Not to mention the hype Ending songs and crisp animation.
@@MitsuboshiHikarufor pure and innocent romance in a high school setting it is as good as you will find. If you like more "mature" or dramatic romance than it's not.
@@MitsuboshiHikaruyou just has bad attention span because this anime has a lot of subtle and little details,show u one of the most realistic romance setting in middle school with one of the best dynamic and development. Don't expect some heavy drama shit or mature theme because the setting is in middle school, u should understand the character and the setting first before watching an anime.
@@MitsuboshiHikaru People are so used to silly stereotypes, love triangles and unnecessary drama.... Dangers is undoubtedly an S+ level romance, although it doesn't bring anything new to the genre (which is impossible really), what's interesting is how realistic and meticulously well written it is, its main characters break romantic stereotypes and thanks to that they come to life, it's like watching two real teenagers interact with each other, getting to know each other, falling in love and getting over each other thanks to their partner. It perfectly understands the formation and feeling of the first love that arises in adolescence, criticizes the superficiality in relationships and gives a beautiful message about true love and the importance of a genuine bond. A romance that transmits so much without saying it beforehand and directly? Undoubtedly a masterpiece of showing and not telling, if it were to be analyzed in depth you would realize the enormous narrative potential it has and how well done it is.
If toradora isn't in here I'm not going onto youtube for a month Edit: Ok it is on the list so I don;t have to fast from youtube for a month. But it was b instead of s or a so I am sad...
It’s an SS, I love it so much. The thing is like, Taiga isn’t even a tsundere. She’s just violent (especially in the start) and how Taiga and Ryūji just grow to be dependent on each other and needing eachother aaa, I love it!
@@Vrileyeah, that’s exactly what they said. Too much tsun and no dere until the end. I feel bad for ryujin. His eyes have been poked out more times than I can count. He is called a stupid mutt on a daily basis
Tks Garnt and Sydney for the tier list. My fav rom anime was insomniac afterschool and now I just tried Golden Time and it just completely hooked me. I am happy to say GT is equally good compared to IA. Highly recommend everyone to try Golden Time. Im sure it will put a smile on your face 😊
The fact that you put Golden Time in S and had the SAME opinion as me on Sing Yesterday for me made me feel like I had finally evolved as an otaku. Despite some disagreements with this list. A Shit, but a masterpiece shit.
Missing Peaks: - Maison Ikkoku - Kimi ni Todoke - Cross Game - Dangers of my Heart - SNAFU - Lovely Complex - Skip and Loafer - Insomniacs After School - Maid Sama! - Skip Beat! - Tomo-chan Is a Girl!
How is Domestic Girlfriend, in which they are step sisters, incestuous but Yosuga no Sora in which they are blood related is good? Also, why did Garnt say no after chat told him they were? He previously said that siblings not being related in anime is chickening out.
He will contort his own prior statements and beliefs just to simp for Domestic Girlfriend. That show must have donated him a kidney. Only explanation on why he loves it so much.
I just started Tonikawa a few weeks ago and I love it. Very wholesome with a simple yet crazy idea (married upon first meet) but it's great. Hard recommend
Angel beats is easily an A level anime, but for romance? Yeah I can agree with the C, my favourite girl was Iwasawa. Her backstory kinda reminded me of my own childhood a bit.
Him putting the garden movie above I want to eat your Pancreas was EXTREMELY PAINFUL. This film was very uninteresting for me, despite being beautiful. I don't know if it's just me, but I have much more emotional attachment to the Pancreas film.
There are two things that cause them to dislike the "I Want to Eat Your Pancreas" anime: 1. They don't like anime with a sad intention can also be seen from the ratings of Your Lie in April and Angel Beats!. Especially for Your Lie in April objectively, the sad romantic execution accompanied by beautiful classical music is at least at the B-tier. 2. Their romance taste is trash. Many anime in the high tier are rated based on their fetishes such as domekano, yosuga no sora, high school dxd, rent a girlfriend, etc.
Great to see some Amagami SS representation in this video. It's such a great concept for a romance anime and I wish more anime had used its formula... and also did it right. 😁
8:10 she has a breakdown because Gojo seems to show no romantic interest in her, with her resulting breakdown being the result of a mixture of her interpreting that as an attack on her attractiveness/femininity and her feeling that she doesn't do anything for Gojo in their relationship.
I don't remember the video but Garnt put alongside Kubo-san so that's how you know that he probably doesn't know how good it got and probably thought of as the 'average romcom 6/10 of the season'
Dang he really needs to make a part 2 for gamers! A lot of people don't talk about it but this show and Nozaki should have always had a s2. Sucks that I won't be able to get sidsnaps opinion on it but when part 2 happens, because it should, I hope it rates well. Even the alternate route chapters in the light novel DLC were good wish they had finished the translations though. Also wanted best girl to win but the MC did still end up with a good partner at the end. Chiaki and Karen Tendou are great and thats an understatement. :)
Garnt and Sydney you have got my acceptance After Putting Bunny Girl Senpai in S teirfrom a fan who has watched the show 10 freaking time. Salute To You!!!!
my favorites out of this are FruBa, bunny girl senpai, horimiya, highschool DxD, kaguya sama, dress up darling, tonikawa, and quintensential quintuplets.
There was a bunch of skipped content that got haphazardly piled into the second season, so yeah, the whole story was very condensed, but the romance and development between Hori and Miyamura was what we were there for in the first place, so I still liked it. Yes, "Oh no, he's hot" - The Animated Series is definitely a favorite. Also, Sakura got done dirty, change my mind.
@@takeru3159Nagatoro (roughly 60 chapters yet to be adapted) and Komi-san (250+) are both still running. Yes you CAN absolutely judge a romance/harem just on it's early stages.
I don't cry much, but I cry when I watch Your Name. I cry in certain moments listening to the soundtrack. That movie is god tier emotional goodness. Also, Garnt.....I too love HOTD.
Quintessential Quintuplets basically set itself up for a disappointing ending. Since the author was so determined to make the winner a surprise that meant he couldn't actually build up a natural romantic plotline. You never get any sense that the male protagonist has a real romantic connection with the chosen girl in the end beyond "she's attracted to him and he's gotta pick somebody or the story doesn't end".
One of the things I think QQ did really well is hide the main character perspective from us. And I think that was done really well since if we started to notice from his perspective which girl started to become more special to him as the arcs went by there wouldn't be too much of a mystery or surprise. I think that is the biggest problem and I can understand the argument that the romance of QQ suffers because of that, since I think the main focus was the mystery and not the romance - at least from Fuutarou perspective. So I can understand if it feels out of nowhere at first, like the main guy just chose someone just because. I agree the ending was rushed but I don't think it ruins what came before, since if you really paid attention to the signs given the only real option for the winner was only between 2 choices out of the 5 and only one of those would have felt out of nowhere - which thankfully it wasn't the winner (Itsuki). The fact that people were able to make a 40+ doc page theory of the winner waaaay before the decision was made and was right is a bit of proof of that.
I was thinking if you'd put golden time in anything other than S tier, then I'd exit out immediately, but I'm glad that your opinion about Golden time is literally the same as mine, about Kouko being the best girl and ghost banri just non existant. Ofc the top 1 part as well, instant sub with that
What the fuck was that intro
Just normal Sydney
@@Kongaii are u fr
Just Sydney being Sydney
Have you... seen Sydney EXIST before?
@@izumitodoroki-editzyeah I don’t know how to tell you this but Sydney is just kinda like that
00:25 My love story
01:17 Amagami
01:40 Angel beats
02:09 Anohana
03:08 Baka test
03:25 Bunny girl senpai
03:47 Call of the night
04:29 Charlotte
04:50 Domestic Girlfriend
07:19 Dress-up Darling
08:23 I want to eat your pancreas
08:59 Garden of words
09:43 Horimiya
10:11 Infinite Stratos
11:09 Your name
11:46 Yosuga no Sora
13:22 His and her circumstances
13:50 Kokoro Connect
14:51 Your lie in April
15:23 Komi can't communicate
15:58 Bloom into you
16:12 Love Hina
17:00 To love Ru
17:53 Highschool DxD and Highschool of the Dead
19:12 Masamune kun's revenge
20:24 The world god only knows
21:15 Fruits Basket
21:25 Ouran Highschool Host Club
21:56 Nana
22:43 Tenchi Muyo!
23:18 Gamers
23:35 Don't toy with me, miss Nagatoro!
24:14 Nisekoi
24:43 Monthly Girls' Nozaki-kun
26:15 Oreimo
27:33 Rent a girlfriend
28:40 Scum's Wish
29:23 A silent voice
30:02 Tonikawa
30:38 Quintessential Quintuplets
31:39 Toradora
32:24 Sing "Yesterday" for me
32:50 Golden time
33:15 Kaguya-sama
33:38 Eromanga sensei
33:44 Monogatari
Bros really out here doing gods work 🙏
Wtf no Clannad? Mid list
@@OK-mv4ih No chuunibyou? F tier list.
No clannaf or oregairu just sad haha
W
Garnt and Sydney really look like Horimiya's final destination. Sydney, being Hori's counterpart with her chaotic energy and Garnt being Miyamura's with his "Everything's FINE guys👍🏻" energy
No way Golden Time was actually Placed at S-tier. I saw the thumbnail and prayed to god that it was a clickbait. GOLDEN TIME IN S-TIER?! C'mon Garnt
@@jke680 why not?
@@jke680TF is you talking about?? It's one of the best romance, my favourite even
@@jke680Haven't seen Golden Time but I'm pretty sure than both Domestic Girlfriend and Rent a Girlfriend being S tier are more debatable lmao
Shut tf up we dont wanna hear brainrot peoples opinion@@jke680
Oregairu not even being in the conversation is criminal
part 2
I think both of them wouldn't like anime like Oregairu. Like... It's Sydney and Garnt. Oregairu is almost the opposite of the types of show they enjoy.
Or even hyouka that show was the best Ln adaptation I have seen
@@rumplstiltztinkerstein garnt said that if he had watched OreGairu S3 in 2020 It would've been his anime of the year but as he didn't got the time to re-watch the whole thing he picked Re:zero
@@SuyashMishra-rm1fbdamn that is what I was thinking....hyouka is one of the best LN adaptation but still it didn't have that much romance in it till the end ya know...
Toradora: "too aggressive"
Nagatoro: "wholesome"
Naw. I actually rewatched Toradora recently. Shes actually REALLY fucking aggressive for like half the series.
I dont mean like tsun tsun mean words, like physically assaulting him. Granted, for me it makes the second half of the series that much sweeter.
Would put it higher on the list than they did.
Whoever doesn't get the appeal of Nagatoro probably has extremely low t, I see no other explanation.
A cute sporty and extremely energetic tanned girl who teases you daily in an very sexual way is a peak fantasy of every straight man. It's so much better than all those frigid kuderes and tsunderes that need 3 seasons of courting and warming up just to hold hands.
Correct, at least Nagatoro going out with mc is so cute in the manga ^^
I think the worst Nagatoro isnt even close to normal Taiga.
Initial Taiga tough? Serial killer, psycho and totally crazy
nah man rewatch toradora, the female mc actually throws hands
Nah, who would have ever seen description of Domestic Girlfriend and thinking "yeah, that what I need". It didn't awake something in Garnt, it just straight up broke his anime romantic taste
It broke mine.
I watched it recently and I gotta say, it's trash, but it's the good kind
@@Bronimin agreed
that isnt a joke?
Domestic Gf shouldn't even be on that list jesus, that anime is a waste of time and honestly know there are better romances to put up there rather than that.
everyone's too focused on the intro to notice the rickroll in the outro
I was like
Hey, cool outro cover song, sounds familiar, I wonder what is the original
*looking in the comments*
Ain't no way!
I was just coming down here to comment that. I was like "did Garnt just...rickroll us in Jpop?"
It’s an absolute banger cover by Caitlin Myers et al.
Some supreme harmonies in there.
it was just meh tbh
Yeah, He has actually used in a vidoe before this, on of his seasonal anime vids I think
So I had my volume up eating lunch in a workers cafe. Saw this and said, "Let's watch this" and the intro was loud. quickly turn down the volume, but a decent amount of random co-workers heard and now are looking at me weirdly. Thanks Sydney.
You should have known what was coming if Sydney is on the screen.
Yeah. Rookie error.
You should always be prepared when Sydney is in the thumbnail
wear earbuds dude wtf
Cool pfp bro
Never seen it before
If you do a part 2 (and if you’ve seen them):
• Maid-sama!
• Hikari-san / Miss Modern
• Rumbling Hearts
• Clannad
• ef
• Yuri on Ice
• O Maidens in your Savage Season
Also my favorite chuunibyou de koi shintai
- The Dangers in my Heart
- More Than a Married Couple, But Not Lovers
- Hokkaido Gals are Super Adorable
ReLife
White album 2
boarding school juliet too
0:01 Just started and emediatly WTF
Garnt: Mai and Sakuta have great chemistry
Editor: shows a clip between Sakuta and Mai's little sister metamorphosised into Mai.
Lol😂
I really dont get that one tbh. Mai is such an insufferable piece of shit with how she sadistically hurts him. I get that like 90% of anime fans seem to be masochists, but she is genuinely completely nonconsensual in how she does it. Yes, he "enjoys" it, but she never stops to obtain consent or even to check his boundaries, mainly because that has literally nothing to do with why she does it. She does it because she is upset or feeling sadistic. How does someone who isnt a supreme masochist enjoy anything involving her?
The fact that they put bunny girl above dress up darling, which is a healthy romance, is just appalling to me.
@@_Lumiere_ This is probably... Well, not the worst analysis I've ever seen, but definitely one of them. This take is so shallow, straightforward and dumb, one can't even make this up for trolling. I'm not saying that the majority is always correct, but the fact that this anime is so well received should at least motivate you to look a bit deeper into the characters and their interactions, idk. Or maybe rewatch the thing more thoroughly. However such arguments often set you against the anime itself, so you can't even make an objective take on this.
"Nah, everything is obvious, the show is trash" is the most i expect from your response tbh. Some personal insults are also welcome (well, kinda deserved since i might've gone a bit too far but still)
@@perchatka This is a long reply, so let me just say that I dont think that anyone is wrong for liking that show. After all, we are all just voicing our opinions. If you're interested, here's why I dislike the romance in Bunny Girl Senpai.
Here's the thing, I can acknowledge that there is some deep romance and otherwise interesting character development in a story. But at the same time a story may gloss over some glaring flaw like physical abuse. Perhaps there's some story with a prince who kidnaps a maiden and forces her to sleep with him, but then they fall in love and their romance ends up being the most well-written thing ever. I can acknowledge the interesting characters and the deep romance, but I would not be able to shake the terrible thing that that love was built on. Or perhaps it's a story of a master and a slave who fall in love and their romance is so deep and nice, but every now and then the master puts his foot down and beats the slave over some transgression. Then everything goes back to being lovey dovey. I would acknowledge the depth of the writing, but I would not enjoy the romance. These examples are exaggerations, but it really is as simple as that.
That's how I felt about Horimiya. I didnt like how Hori would get jealous over him talking to another girl, to the point that she straight up threw heavy books in his face (while he was wearing glasses). That would hurt like a motherfucker and would personally be unforgivable for me in a real relationship. So I cant view that as a healthy romance even if it's otherwise written well. I also cant stand how she forces him to act "dominant" and abusive towards her in public without considering his own boundaries about that. That's something that's personal to me as I'm involved in such play myself.
That's also what's happening here. Mai is objectively abusing him without actually checking with him that it is ok, as you would do in a bdsm relationship. It doesnt matter if he "likes it". Even if a sub says that they like something, you dont do these things unprompted. You discuss these things and regularly check in with them to see if it's truly ok and that they arent just playing along for you. Mai doesnt even approach this from that kind of standpoint, she just does it because she wants to. This stuff is very close to my heart, so when I see something being done in such an unhealthy way, that taints the entire story and the entire relationship for me.
So, unless you can somehow prove to me that what I said is wrong, how exactly is this the "worst analysis you've ever seen"? Does she sit down with him and respectfully discuss his boundaries, what he is ok with and what he isnt ok with, or does she just slap him and step on his foot unprompted? Call him names? And does she do this as a well-defined "bedroom play" or does she simply slap him because she is angry? In an attempt to force him to apologize to her without respectfully considering his side?
Can you truthfully answer any of these questions without it seeming like an abusive relationship? Objectively speaking? I cant think of this as some fluffy romance when this is what I'm presented with in the show. And that's as someone who actually does enjoy the whole kink thing irl. Perhaps that's why this aspect of the show ruins it for me, because I can't stand seeing it done in an unhealthy way, it's too close to home. There is a lack of basic respect in this dynamic.
But if you can dismiss all these things and if you like masochistic fiction without caring for boundaries or consent (and there's nothing wrong really with liking a fantasy like that, as long as it is a fantasy), then I'm sure the show is great. I won't deny that the characters or plot may be interesting. But abusive, unbalanced relationships are a dealbreaker for me when it comes to enjoying a romance that isnt a sexual fantasy.
For me, a "perfect" fictional romance is one that I would actually tolerate seeing in real life. I would never tolerate nor want to see an irl relationship like the one in Bunny Girl Senpai and so that romance will never be on top of my list, even if it may have well-written elements. In contrast, while I'm not like Gojo myself, if I were in his shoes I would be happy with a relationship with Marin. I can view that as a nice example of a romance.
@@_Lumiere_ oh, so this goes even deeper into the things i hate in modern society - the Abuse witnesses. I rarely talk about this shit, but i actually have something to say.
First, about the relationship in the anime. Sakuta clearly showed Mai that he doesn't mind this kind of teasing and he actually kinda likes it. Also Mai (and us viewers as well) knows Sakuta's character pretty well, so if he didn't like anything about what she did he would definitely tell her. They're ok, i don't worry about how their relationships go because i know they'll be good.
Then about the social aspect of abuse. If the culture doesn't let some people cope with abuse (middle east or anything like that) then we can't do anything about that, it takes a very long time to reform a culture. If you live in a more liberal environment then it's all your choice how to deal with your abusive partner and whether to keep them your partner at all. In this case it's only your fault that you're being abused. Marriage, kids? Then you've made a mistake the very moment you married, it's just the consequences of your choice. Divorce is still an option after all.
People these days tend to keep yapping about their problems and disturb everyone around them instead of trying to deal with those problems. In my opinion this is a sign of mental weakness. And this is what i never want to think about while discussing anime.
I trust Syd more to give fair ratings for romance anime more because yes she has biases just like Garnt but holy shit does he upgrade too many due to personal taste.
Yeah the sheer amount of trash that made it to S-A without any justification was nuts.
she's biased af who's surprised
@@Hawk7886can you get your incel ass out of here?
Garnt is always like this. He purposefully didn't put Clannad on the list, such a spiteful guy
@@OK-mv4ih He didn't finish Clannad
Surprised that "Wotakoi" and "O maiden of your savage season" wasn't on the list! I quite liked both of them, despite both having a sort of lackluster ending.
I was more shocked there was no oregairu🤷♂️
Ikr? Wotakoi went under the radar for Garnt and sydney i guess
Same but also wondering where Orange is at. How can you do a romance list without best bro who takes the long term L but actually gets a massive W in the end.
True
No love for Ichigo 100% (The Manga, the anime died at ep 2 due to changes)
Lovely Complex
Ai yori Aoishi
School Rumble
Golden Boy (Technically, travel romcom)
I was disappointed until the end because one of my favourites oregairu and dangers in my heart were missing but then grant said part 2 and now i know i will be there
I wish you added Love Chuunibyou and Other Delusions, Tamako Love Story, Kyoukai no Kanata, Hyouka, A Whisker Away, Hotarubi no Mori e, Josee the Tiger and the Fish, My Stepmom's Daughter is my Ex, Romantic Killer, Love Election and Chocolate, Bokutachi no Remake, Weathering with You, 5 Centimeters per Second, and The Place Promised in Our Early Days. Also the infamous School Days.
How did you guys even come up with this list of "romance anime" to rate? So many of them don't even have the romance tag. I was half expecting Demon Slayer to show up at some point.
Don't give Crunchyroll any ideas, damn it.
Demon Slayer is siscon romance
Reminds me of last year when they just gave up and put JJK S2 in literally every single category lol
@@pointyheadYTtho it did fit the description for every category
Tsurezure Children is my favorite. Quite shocking its not in that list! Having multiple couples makes it easier to stay interested, its not about choosing best girl or the big drama, its about smaller situations between people. Almost like a collection of how various couples came to be together but each couple offers a different flavour of romance. Its got something for everyone, how can you not like it?
Tsurezure Children was one of the best cute romance anime ever. Takano and Sugawara was my favorite couple.
I'd recommend reading the manga if you haven't! It's completed, and actually my favourite couple in the series are only in the manga, definitely worth it.
Same! Best romance ever
@@cedricmichaud552 yeah agreed, Takano x Sugawara is the most interesting couple 👍🏼
It's really nice, I would put it up high but it's also really short.
If I remember correctly the episodes were 5 minutes
LIST OF THE RESULTS
S
Grand Finale
Bunny Girl Sempai
Domestic Girlfriend
Horimiya
Your Name
Sosuga no Sora
Highschool DXD
The World God Only Knows
Fruits Basket
Oran High School Club
Nana
Rent a Girlfriend
Love Is War
Monogatare
A
Amagami SS
My Dress Up Darling
Garden of Words
His and Her Circumstance
Kokoro Connect
Bloom Into You
Love Hina
Masamune-kun's Revenge
Tenchi Muyo
Don't Toy With Me Ms Nagatoro
Oremoio
Tonikawa
B
Oremonogatari
Anohana The Flower we Saw That Day
Call of the Night
I Want To Eat Your Pancreas
Nisekoi False Love
Monthly Girls Nozaki-kun
A Silent Voice
Quintessential Quintuplets
Toradora
C
Angel Beats
Baka and Test
Your Lie In April
Komi Can't Communicate
Scum's Wish
D
Charlotte
To Love Ru
Gamers
Sing "Yesterday" For Me
Eromanga Sensei
Didn't Watch
Infinite Stratos
So Many Colors
Gotta comment so people see this
Where is golden time
Thank you
Yo u know if garnt has an imdb/letterbox or something like this ranking all anime? I dont wanna watch 20 vídeos separating anime by genre or whatnot
Nana not getting S is crazy to me. I have straight up never seen better writing in a romance.
Not sure when this was recorded but two I really enjoyed recently are A sign of affection and The Dangers in my Heart; was wondering where those would end up but weren't on the list.
Maybe the list was made years ago, it had alot of old shows and none of shows from 2022 onwards are on there
This is just Garnt defending Domestic Girlfriend at all costs.
Lmaoooo... He looks so uncomfortable when she starts bashing on it.
I just finish Hyouka few days ago and this show has really little romance subplot, but even this small pieces was so good and feels so natural, much better then many "official" romances))
Exactly!
You can feel natural chemistry.
Not enough anime do romance like that.
Spice and wolf and Steins gate are two other anime that don't make the romance the focus but the chemistry is excellent.
Good chemistry tends to stems from the characters not coming together, and that isn't what “romance” is to me
Dangers of my heart not on the list is criminal...
They're really sleeping on the best romance anime, period.
confirmed
there are a TON more anime that could be on this list, but Dangers of my heart is the most criminal for sure
The Angel next door spoils me rotten, tamako love story, strawberry panic, chuunibyou demo koi ga shitai, saenai heroine no sodatekata AND the dangers in my heart were missing
Man I was on my way to comment this as well. Same 100 girlfriends.
well now I know both of you have awful taste in romance anime, but in different ways. Basically you're perfect for each other
atleast they're both right in immediately putting Love is War and the Monogatari series in S
@@vosamul Kaguya sama nowhere near S tier for the romane, the comedy is top tier though
@@rifqimfauzan6809 Comedy was boring af, went thru whole episodes not laughing once and some annoying af characters. Watch more comedy anime, then you'll know what actually funny
@@OK-mv4ih there is difference between comedy in romance and actual comedy anime. For romance anime Kaguya comedy was top compare to other romcom anime but if you compare it to actual comedy anime like Chiyo, Asobi Asobase, Danshi Kokosei, Hinamatsuri, JK Mudazukai etc yes it was boring.
For another example of top romcom is Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun or Tsurezure Children
only someone as equally insufferable deserves to be with another lol
The World God Only Knows is one of the 3 anime that got me into anime, the others being Gosick and Hikaru no Go.
Dear lord the rating inflation on this list was insane.
Also, putting Toradora in B tier is a travesty. I watched it earlier this year for the first time ever and it's now my favorite romance anime. The abuse was admittedly tough in the beginning, but it evolved nicely over time and was explained within the context of the story, which is what I needed to accept it. Too often a tsundere is just a tsundere for no reason but to serve as an easy character trope to mask poor writing, but Taiga's background made it understandable. Also, they fell in love because they both needed each other given their family situations, it was a genuinely touching love story compared a lot of the trash littering the A and S tiers. Even with the abuse it was still a much more believable love story than the vast majority of romance anime.
One last thing, the original light novel NEVER makes Taiga physically violent with Ryuji except for the home invasion scene. If that is what stops you from enjoying the anime I suggest people try reading the light novel instead.
I watched Toradora recently and In the running in the stairs scene I think Minorin Gaslight Ryuji into thinking he loves Taiga because imo he definitely loved Minorin. (This is definitely not my copium that I wanted Minorin and Ryuji to be together)
@@pranavbatra6286 it takes more than just one breaf interaction to properly convince someone
Something that most people won't pick up on watching Toradora as well, is that Taiga is a fundamentally broken character. What she says/how she acts/what she actually things never seems to line up properly. In the last few episodes, where she's actively trying to lie to herself and everyone around her really shows how far gone she is mentally into this disillusioned state where she can never be important to anyone. The characters in this show were absolute peak writing, S tier for life.
It's definitely better on a first watch. On rewatching I didn't really like some of the way they let things play out.
Yeah putting Tora Dora in B tier and then Rent a G in S tier is literally criminal. How am I supposed to believe his other ratings now?! Insane
I suddenly remembered a few romances from back in the day. Anyone else remember 'Tsuredure Children' and 'I can't understand what my husband is saying'?
I love Tsuredure Children. It's like they took the high school romance things and distilled it to its purest form. Too bad it never got more anime adaption.
Tsuredure children shouldve definitely been given a second season tbh
So many romances I’m surprised weren’t on this list! Given, Wotakoi, Kimi ni Todoke, Say I Love You, just to name a few.
ReLife
Grant's hate for Your Lie in April can rival Joey's hate for Bocchi
it's funny how different his opinion is 10 years ago lmao
YLIA was the worst anime I have watched so far (I’ve watched Cowboy Bebop, Samurai Champloo, My Dress Up Darling, Steins;Gate, Naruto, and Toradora)
@@DUFFAL02It looks like it's just not up your alley bro. It's one of the best in terms romance animes. You can't claim YLIA is bad because it never was bad at all.
@@B.G_Glyphs I wasn’t claiming it was bad, I just said it was the worst I have watched. It was still a decent anime, I just wasn’t a fan of it. The melodrama is what killed it for me.
@@B.G_Glyphs is it good, yeah, but “one of the best in terms of romance” is questionable, if that's good romance then I’ll consider Demon Slayer a romance show too
Tadano did not date anyone else. Manbagi the gyaru (best girl), was in love with him and wanted to get with him but he had feelings for Komi. Also, the manga is still ongoing even after they got together. So we definitely cannot say that it's most of the series that it took for them to get together.
Also fuck yeah to The World God Only Knows -- loved that show. But ...there's two I'm not seeing so far. They're older but ...they deserve being rated (Marmalade Boy and Kimagure Orange Road)
Was waiting for maid sama, and it was never mentioned 🥺🥺🥺
Kaichu was goood
And Kimi ni todoke
Because all shoujo series are garbage
I’m waiting for Re:LIFE 🗿
One of the best romance anime the manga ending is perfect
Also My Little Monster
Mako and gamagori having sex is probably the funniest and scariest mental image you can conjure, thanks sidney for reminding us of that relationship
Let's not forget that at a panel Patrick seitz while using gamagori's voice made a love confession to mako. And yelled out it's Canon bitches
Gamagori's a good guy. Fiercely loyal and has a strong code of conduct.
Just makes me think of that jpeg of a hamster eating a banana.
Nana in S tier is a huge W, top 3 for me🤝🏾 the character writing is so good.
Definitely need to add School Rumble to the Pt 2 list! Easy S-tier!
I didn't watch the full second season because of the shift in writing but from what I remember it had basically no romance. Just comedy and pain disguised through comedy.
Amazing first season though.
It's one of the anime that made me laugh the emost
Yesss! Monthly Girls Nozaki-kun. One of my favorite Manga and anime of all time. It's S tier for me baby.
Sexist garbage
Surprised that Oregairu is not on this list and I think you underrated Toradora. I really thought it depicted the situation well where people spend time together and then later on down the line realise they have been hit with a case of the feels.
I have seen the "taiga realizes she's in love" scene a million times and I still love it
@@dadaucha It still fking breaks me every single time.
i can't listen to "lost my pieces" without tearing up like im a fking pavlovian dog.
@@simonenoli4418 "lost my pieces" is brutal. I watched the 3 Christmas episodes every year for Christmas as kind of a tradition (stopped when I had kids, lack of time)
Surprised that Toradora is in the list, because that anime is anything, but romance, lol.
@@Dar-El_Akai if you fail to see tje rom of the romcom you missed 50% of the anime.
As Bloom Into You was robbed by having 15 seconds of spotlight, let me recommend it. It brought me into manga. Watch the only seaon, then read the remaining 5 to 8 mangas. Can be all done in one sitting, concludes the story in a nice way.
Yeah and it was also robbed of not having a second season (even though I haven't even watched the first haha)
Probably the best yuri, the story isn't anything crazy but the characters are really really good and the execution is almost flawless
Yeah, it's one of the few adaptation where you can just continue in the manga where the anime left off with how loyal it is to the source material.
Still hoping for S2...
But we only got one Yuri this year so far, with this pace it ain't gonna happen..
True, and has way different approach to the subject of love than every other romance on the list. (Slight spoilers below) I hate when romance shows just finds two characters and they like each other from the start or after one event. Instead love in real life is more active, you have to put in effort and time to fall in love, it won't just happen. Which is the main theme of the show.
Yeah, Bloom Into You continues its streak of being robbed in this video.
been reading yamada kun and its def on my top romance list of all time. it feels like im watching a real tv show when i read
DAMN SYD COMING IN WITH THE GREAT TAKES
No kamisama hajimemashita?
Clannad?
Sankarea?
Lovely Complex?
Planetarian and other robot girl stories are also missing. It's not meant to be complete.
@@NoidoDev Chobits and Plastic Memories
school rumble ?
Grant: Dome kano S tier
Sydney: Yogusa no sora S tier
- what a lovely couple 😊
I loved how it went from "it felt all icky and incestuous" to "TWINCEST IS WINCEST AMIRITE!" with Syd.
Sydney being BASED
And they're both over Bloom Into You, somehow.
Rent a girlfriend in S? Jesus save him....
Literally I cant.
He is beyond saving man
He completely forgot the whole theme of the list lmao. It’s about how good the romance is, not how much you can’t look away from the romance. And RAGF is as bad of a romance as you can get.
it's prob. the goat in romance genre.. btw am serious
Hahaha yeah. That's crazy LMAO
Okay, part 2 is DEFINITELY needed. Fuufuu Ijou, Dangers in my Heart, Tomo-Chan, Yamada-kun, Angel Next Door, Couple of Cuckoos, Spice and Wolf, Elf Bride, and the biggest slam dunk S-tier of all time, 100 Girlfriends.
Clanned also
dangers in my heart is so overhype, its not a terrible romance at any means but its not one of the best
Lovely Complex would be another missing.
That said, if a romance story isn't finished, it really shouldn't be on the list, or just automatically dumped into a "Not finished" tier. Because, sure, some shows are trash from start to finish (Domestic Girlfriend), and even the worst possible ending (worst girl wins) won't drag it down any further, but if a show can't stick the landing, it doesn't deserve to be rated highly. And never getting to the landing part means they haven't stuck it yet.
Clannad bro CLANNAD. The peak of romance and it's not even there
Thats what I was thinking
18:07 Based. DXD and HOTD are classics and peak at what they do.
His and Her Circumstances is why I even give romance anime a chance. I freaking loved that show.
ayoo that intro
I literally just watched Joey, Emi, and Daidus’s vid on ranking romance anime yesterday. Impeccable timing. Lol
Bunny Girl Senpai ❤
Yes sir cried in one episode TWICE deserves S tier
Overrated mid show with cringe romance and bad character design
@@kingdoom5022 ok ur opinion 👍
I like the character design but it is a mid show.
@@kingdoom5022watched Vinland Saga I have no haters, I love you 😀
Part 2 pls, so many good ones that have been missed so far
The thing I always remember from Kokoro Connect is the kick to the nuts scene
I guess the intro was the meaning behind Garnt's opinion on love.
Finally people realize the greatness of Golden Time (the 2nd opening is a banger). But there's a big missing piece in this ter liest: OreGairu, the prince of all the waifu wars.
second opening is epic, first half of the show is epic. But man, the second half of golden time REALLY killed it. Not enough to make it a terrible show but god that ending hurt me with how much bad writing was in it, felt so rushed (at least in the anime)
@@nebula8893 It's true that it's rushed, but it was a great emotional rollercoaster (and I don't even know why I liked it so much)
@@nebula8893 The only rushed segment I remember was the amnesia episode. Can you elaborate on that?
Have finished the video yet.. Oregairu is not on here !???? What
That second half was so bad.
I still can't believe how much love some people have for it.
At one point it was like the #1 or #2 rated romance anime and it should have never been there
That monogatari meme is 10/10
Oh they was some birds
30:07 It's more than just a feel-good story. It's the continuation of an ancient story, and the fulfillment of a promise that survived eons. Tonikaku: Fly Me to the Moon, is one of the greatest stories ever told, and part of what makes it so good is how subtle it is. You won't really realize what's actually going on, until you're like seven episodes in, and even then, you'll only have the barest hints, but once you get it, you will remember all the small details that seemed insignificant from the start of the first episode.
30:20 I can't tell if you guys are trying to avoid massive spoilers, or if you really don't know what's going on with the story.
Came for The World God Only Knows. Not disappointed. The way they showed the emotional damage caused by what the MC had to do throughout the show was S tier alone. Not to mention the hype Ending songs and crisp animation.
Its a new anime but dangers in my heart is definitely S tier romance , its have amazing writing and peak romance
its not, dont get me wrong its not a bad romance, its really good, but theres no way its peak romance
@@MitsuboshiHikarufor pure and innocent romance in a high school setting it is as good as you will find.
If you like more "mature" or dramatic romance than it's not.
@@MitsuboshiHikaruyou just has bad attention span because this anime has a lot of subtle and little details,show u one of the most realistic romance setting in middle school with one of the best dynamic and development. Don't expect some heavy drama shit or mature theme because the setting is in middle school, u should understand the character and the setting first before watching an anime.
@@MitsuboshiHikaru People are so used to silly stereotypes, love triangles and unnecessary drama.... Dangers is undoubtedly an S+ level romance, although it doesn't bring anything new to the genre (which is impossible really), what's interesting is how realistic and meticulously well written it is, its main characters break romantic stereotypes and thanks to that they come to life, it's like watching two real teenagers interact with each other, getting to know each other, falling in love and getting over each other thanks to their partner.
It perfectly understands the formation and feeling of the first love that arises in adolescence, criticizes the superficiality in relationships and gives a beautiful message about true love and the importance of a genuine bond. A romance that transmits so much without saying it beforehand and directly? Undoubtedly a masterpiece of showing and not telling, if it were to be analyzed in depth you would realize the enormous narrative potential it has and how well done it is.
If toradora isn't in here I'm not going onto youtube for a month
Edit: Ok it is on the list so I don;t have to fast from youtube for a month. But it was b instead of s or a so I am sad...
It’s an SS, I love it so much.
The thing is like, Taiga isn’t even a tsundere. She’s just violent (especially in the start) and how Taiga and Ryūji just grow to be dependent on each other and needing eachother aaa, I love it!
@@Vrileyeah, that’s exactly what they said. Too much tsun and no dere until the end. I feel bad for ryujin. His eyes have been poked out more times than I can count. He is called a stupid mutt on a daily basis
Garnt sold his soul and fell for the I'm an adult so I must conform meme sadly.
bro, me either. Toradora is a freaking masterpiece
@@Vrile yeah, for people who have only senn romance in anime, lol.
was hoping to see "From me to you" on the list... maybe next time :')
Tks Garnt and Sydney for the tier list. My fav rom anime was insomniac afterschool and now I just tried Golden Time and it just completely hooked me. I am happy to say GT is equally good compared to IA.
Highly recommend everyone to try Golden Time. Im sure it will put a smile on your face 😊
The anime/movie of Pancreas didn't do it justice. The novel was so so good.
The fact that you put Golden Time in S and had the SAME opinion as me on Sing Yesterday for me made me feel like I had finally evolved as an otaku.
Despite some disagreements with this list.
A Shit, but a masterpiece shit.
Garnt hating the miscomunication in Gamers is like... missing the point. The show was comedic as hell. That was the point!
Miscommunication was the most fun part of the show. It was so entertaining to watch. Give me MORE miscommunication situations please.
I'd wager he's of the opinion that that makes it a good *comedy* but a painfully slow *romance*.
@@gregoryfolsom7882 Now THAT does make some sense yeah.
the comedy is A tier prob S, but the romance meh
Thank you! Someone gets it!
Good lord, Sydney's screeches was not something to have off earphones at work today.
you should've known better
Missing Peaks:
- Maison Ikkoku
- Kimi ni Todoke
- Cross Game
- Dangers of my Heart
- SNAFU
- Lovely Complex
- Skip and Loafer
- Insomniacs After School
- Maid Sama!
- Skip Beat!
- Tomo-chan Is a Girl!
Angel beats at C is almost criminal, that shit had me crying like a baby at the end
Same with the disrespect on Charlotte I thought it was good at least
Methinks Syd doth protests too much during the Domestic Girlfriend part lol
How is Domestic Girlfriend, in which they are step sisters, incestuous but Yosuga no Sora in which they are blood related is good? Also, why did Garnt say no after chat told him they were? He previously said that siblings not being related in anime is chickening out.
He will contort his own prior statements and beliefs just to simp for Domestic Girlfriend.
That show must have donated him a kidney. Only explanation on why he loves it so much.
1:15 Ayoo-- what the fck did I just see 💀
I just started Tonikawa a few weeks ago and I love it. Very wholesome with a simple yet crazy idea (married upon first meet) but it's great. Hard recommend
we need the second part, like, there were very few shojo here and not only
Because all shojo series
Are garbage
Angel beats is easily an A level anime, but for romance? Yeah I can agree with the C, my favourite girl was Iwasawa. Her backstory kinda reminded me of my own childhood a bit.
Is F tier bland characters
Boring story
D tier romance tbh
11:32 define vibe
Bruh
Oh no
Him putting the garden movie above I want to eat your Pancreas was EXTREMELY PAINFUL.
This film was very uninteresting for me, despite being beautiful. I don't know if it's just me, but I have much more emotional attachment to the Pancreas film.
There are two things that cause them to dislike the "I Want to Eat Your Pancreas" anime:
1. They don't like anime with a sad intention can also be seen from the ratings of Your Lie in April and Angel Beats!. Especially for Your Lie in April objectively, the sad romantic execution accompanied by beautiful classical music is at least at the B-tier.
2. Their romance taste is trash. Many anime in the high tier are rated based on their fetishes such as domekano, yosuga no sora, high school dxd, rent a girlfriend, etc.
the part 2 is badly needed for Dangers of my heart and Oregairu
Great to see some Amagami SS representation in this video. It's such a great concept for a romance anime and I wish more anime had used its formula... and also did it right. 😁
This is one of the lists of all times💀💀
To Love Ru in D is crazzzyy
World God only knows mentioned! Respect!
Me: See Grant w/Sydney
Me: What weird stuff I going to hear this time..
Video: Start
Me: WTF 🤣
Where in the hell is best romance anime ever kaguya-sama
8:10 she has a breakdown because Gojo seems to show no romantic interest in her, with her resulting breakdown being the result of a mixture of her interpreting that as an attack on her attractiveness/femininity and her feeling that she doesn't do anything for Gojo in their relationship.
Sign of Affection is S+++++
Yuki's Happy Arm waving cures all depression
Dangers in my heart? hello?
Ik right
I thought it was gonna be an immediate S tier or something turns out it ain’t there ☠️
I don't remember the video but Garnt put alongside Kubo-san so that's how you know that he probably doesn't know how good it got and probably thought of as the 'average romcom 6/10 of the season'
@@ShotterGames dayum that’s crazy ☠️
@@ShotterGames He's insane.
@@ShotterGames Damn, it's one one of my favorite animes oat, favorite romance anime for sure
OKAY BUT YOUR LIE IN APRIL IN C TIER IS ILLEGAL LIKE WHAAAAAT
Dang he really needs to make a part 2 for gamers! A lot of people don't talk about it but this show and Nozaki should have always had a s2. Sucks that I won't be able to get sidsnaps opinion on it but when part 2 happens, because it should, I hope it rates well. Even the alternate route chapters in the light novel DLC were good wish they had finished the translations though. Also wanted best girl to win but the MC did still end up with a good partner at the end. Chiaki and Karen Tendou are great and thats an understatement. :)
11:41 "Iroduku: World of Colors, didn't watch it."
Garnt 5 years ago, makes an entire video on it.......
that ghost banri cracked me up so much :D
"Toradora in B"
How fucking dare you...
It's absolutely criminal that Kaichou Wa Maid-sama wasn't on this list
when i was a teen, i watched that almost 9 times wtf
LETS GOOOO TWGOK S TIER GOOD LIST, TWGOK IS THE BEST ROMCOM ITS PEAK
Garnt and Sydney you have got my acceptance After Putting Bunny Girl Senpai in S teirfrom a fan who has watched the show 10 freaking time.
Salute To You!!!!
Don't worry, I balanced you out by dropping it 3 episodes in ;)
my favorites out of this are FruBa, bunny girl senpai, horimiya, highschool DxD, kaguya sama, dress up darling, tonikawa, and quintensential quintuplets.
Horimiya felt like we were speed running a romance.
There was a bunch of skipped content that got haphazardly piled into the second season, so yeah, the whole story was very condensed, but the romance and development between Hori and Miyamura was what we were there for in the first place, so I still liked it. Yes, "Oh no, he's hot" - The Animated Series is definitely a favorite.
Also, Sakura got done dirty, change my mind.
It skipped through fillers. It didn't need to take 3 seasons for two people to confess to each other.
Better than the slow walks in anime where you need 3 seasons just to get together 🫠
Romance, D-tier
Comedy, S-tier
@@viciousoz4188 Lmao no the "comedy" is corny af. Classic unfunny anime comedy. Watch some actually good comedy anime
WHERE THE HECK IS THE 100 GIRLFRIENDS WHO REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY LOVE YOU?
The anime is only at 6% completion. And to my understanding the manga is around 35%. You can't judge it yet.
@@takeru3159Nagatoro (roughly 60 chapters yet to be adapted) and Komi-san (250+) are both still running. Yes you CAN absolutely judge a romance/harem just on it's early stages.
Is it really a romance when it's the equivalent of completing a Pokedex?
@@TuxedoKamina the list is romance/harem, and even then, Rentarou absolutely romances every single one of his girlfriends.
Yeah... it's definitely a romance. If you think it isn't... then I guess you haven't even seen it properly
Always love when sydney and garnt make a tierlist together, I already know it’s gonna be chaotic
I don't cry much, but I cry when I watch Your Name. I cry in certain moments listening to the soundtrack. That movie is god tier emotional goodness.
Also, Garnt.....I too love HOTD.
Fuck me so glad i turn the volume down before watching anything with sydsnap in at night
Quintessential Quintuplets basically set itself up for a disappointing ending. Since the author was so determined to make the winner a surprise that meant he couldn't actually build up a natural romantic plotline. You never get any sense that the male protagonist has a real romantic connection with the chosen girl in the end beyond "she's attracted to him and he's gotta pick somebody or the story doesn't end".
🤨
Because best girl (ichika)
Didn’t win
One of the things I think QQ did really well is hide the main character perspective from us. And I think that was done really well since if we started to notice from his perspective which girl started to become more special to him as the arcs went by there wouldn't be too much of a mystery or surprise. I think that is the biggest problem and I can understand the argument that the romance of QQ suffers because of that, since I think the main focus was the mystery and not the romance - at least from Fuutarou perspective. So I can understand if it feels out of nowhere at first, like the main guy just chose someone just because.
I agree the ending was rushed but I don't think it ruins what came before, since if you really paid attention to the signs given the only real option for the winner was only between 2 choices out of the 5 and only one of those would have felt out of nowhere - which thankfully it wasn't the winner (Itsuki). The fact that people were able to make a 40+ doc page theory of the winner waaaay before the decision was made and was right is a bit of proof of that.
Dude… porn would be easier to explain than that intro.
Yes sir, Golden Time first place, its my first ever romance.
I was thinking if you'd put golden time in anything other than S tier, then I'd exit out immediately, but I'm glad that your opinion about Golden time is literally the same as mine, about Kouko being the best girl and ghost banri just non existant. Ofc the top 1 part as well, instant sub with that