Pigs by Pink Floyd (School of Rock Lynnwood, WA cover)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- The Lynnwood, Washington School of Rock covering the song Pigs by Pink Floyd at Tony V's Garage in Everett, Washington.
NOTE - tasteful critiques, comments, and opinions are welcome, but here are a few disclaimers to consider before making an overly critical or snide remark:
1) All performers on stage were age 16 or under at the time of performance (I added approximate ages to their names below). THINK ABOUT THAT. What were YOU doing when you were 12-16?
2) As part of their curriculum at the School of Rock, they are typically taught about the bands and songs that they play and a bit about what was going on in the world at the time, why it was written, etc. They often perform generational or honored musician-themed music shows (some examples of past shows: 50th Anniversary of Woodstock, 80's Rock, Tribute to Rush, Women of Rock, Best of Bowie, Classic Metal, Prog Rock, etc) and most of them are fans of (or at least have a respectful appreciation for) the most influential rock music of past and present generations. They actually LIKE a lot of the music they play. Compare that to most common 12-16-year-olds and the music and culture they're talking about at that age (if they even care about either).
3) There are several other performers in the group than what you see on stage and they switch out most of them on EVERY song. Imagine how challenging this is to coordinate on each song: having to quickly get in/out of a drum kit, unplug/plug-in individual guitars/bass/effects/microphones, etc., having to make sure the last person didn't accidentally leave on the tuner pedal (why is there no sound from the amp?) or didn't push in the microphone plug quite enough (why is my microphone not working?) or raise/lower the seat height (why can't I reach the cymbals?). These kids (and their directors) handle all that chaos so incredibly well, really.
4) This was recorded using my cell phone only (no special recording equipment) so the picture and sound quality are not great. But keep in mind that the overall WAY the music is played and whether it should sound EXACTLY the same as the original is subjective. When was the last time you went to see a concert and the band played their songs EXACTLY like the album? Pretty boring if they did that every time, if you ask me. Their music director attempts to arrange each song to do it justice, for sure, but sometimes it's truly a unique variation of the original. No, the keyboard does not sound EXACTLY like the way it sounds on the album (they didn't have a 1970's Hammond organ), the guitar could have been louder (she was having technical difficulties with the amp), the bass player could have stepped up to the front more (she's really talented and did especially great on this one, but it's a pretty small stage), the cymbals were a bit sharp sounding (when do drums ever sound right when recording from a phone?), etc., etc., etc. All accurate. more or less. Bottom line should really be: did they at least do the song justice? With about three months of once-a-week band practices before performance (some of the kids have never even HEARD of the songs before they're assigned), I'd say they kicked some serious booty.
Vox: Olive (13)
Lead: Ava Llew (14)
Rhythm: Madeline (12)
Bass: Marissa (16)
Keys: Lief (14)
Drums: Gretchen (16)
For those of you who care to know, I added some more details about the performers, the school they attend, and other general info to the description.
They inspired me to go learn this song!
Your bass player has that magic when she plays, You know it if you've ever felt it and watching her play has reminded me that I haven't felt that feeling in far loo long. Keep up the good work!
Why the negative comments? I don’t think the bassist is claiming to be Roger Waters or the guitarist is claiming to be be David Gilmour. Just some school kids doing what they love and having a blast. Better than I could so well done 👍
Incidentally the bass in this song was played by Gilmour not waters.
Some people are just negative
And c'mon. These kids know Pigs. Just that alone deserves our full respect!
Because people suck.
Because they’re jealous that they or their kids can’t do that
To the young lady with the bass: you have a job for life, there; really good skill-set.
It’s great to see young people performing live music, the fact that it’s Pink Floyd!
Keep rocking.
The bassist is the best member of this band
Just like the real deal
Good 👍🏼 one Dad!
The Kids Are Alright.
It's damn sure not the singer
They're all talented but that bassist is otherworldly. To play like that at 16 years old, holy damn.
It's not a hard bass line.
@@user-lj3tg4nk3e Getting the melodic feel is hard. She did a top job.
If I walked into a venue and saw this I would be soooo excited! Great to see the next gen musicians playing Floyd!
I know right? Definitely a holy shit moment, id go right up front.
This is really terrific!
The bassist is obviously playing great but the way they all work together to pull this off is fantastic.
A talkbox guitar solo, are you kidding me?!
Being a hardcore Pink Floyd fan, this was impressive. Great job kids! Great song choice.
Its impossible to negatively comment on this performance...just the fact alone that these kids picked this song and pulled it off is giving me faith in the humanity...lol
Tru dat. Anyone who feels the need to post a critical comment about this performance is a tool in need of therapy!
Just happy to see the young one listening and loving Floys
Great band, but the bassist, oh man, she is awesome!!
I am literally crying. The bass girl rocks.
thanks Dad!
Awesome Bass 👍👍
As a Pink Floyd fan SINCE -1971....THAT IS VERY IMPRESSIVE!!!!!
This is awesome. I've never seen a band go for this one, ballsy.
My favorite album of all-time. That was awesome.
Yeah, this album has sooo much meaning and sooo many memories tied to it for me. What's even crazier for me is that my daughter Ava is the lead guitarist in this video. She's so talented, IMO, and I'm so stinkin proud of her. First time using a talkbox with her guitar. All of these kids are crazy talented. All under 18 years old. Blows my mind how talented they are.
You should check out Ava's other videos and covers: ruclips.net/channel/UCKDn4PZn_wJ-TQZS-bJlaaw
@@jaysonbarretto222 Ooh yes, she's awesome! I actually checked out some of her playing before reading this, she's the real thing no joke 👍
It is a beautiful thing to watch yet another generation play and hopefully fall in love with Pink Floyd. Their instructors are to be commended. Thanks for sharing.
Being a bass player in a Pink Floyd tribute band...the bass player, in this ensemble, is excellent. True fire.
Kudos kids! You have chosen to start at the top of the totem pole of musical importance. Pink Floyd's relevance is immeasurable. What an undertaking and you all did an excellent job 👌.
Kudos for taking a complex arrangement and performing it live. All did a great job. The bass player stood out as the most comfortable. In her element. I hope they continue to grow with their talents.
Great bass work...
Amazing! ALL OF YOU!!
I just realized that I'll dissolve in tears if I had a daughter that play the bass like this. It's a dream of mine have a kid that will pick up my bass to play. And what about this lead guitar?? AWESOME!! I'll be the proudest father in the world!
Thanks for sharing!
I am definitely a proud papa 👍🏼
WoW, the bass player really stands out. Kudos on the track, really did it justice!!
I was in high school when this album came out & it's one of my all time favorites with a Waters/Mason autographed vinyl copy hanging framed above my piano. Just wanted to say that the bass player totally nails it!! Great Job! Keep on rockin'!
These kids will save the world
They all played well, singer looked disinterested, but the feisty young lady on bass absolutely knocked it out of the park and into the Stratosphere. A real rock chick!
I love it am 56 and been a floyd fan a long time ,great show ladies 🚺
Great work everyone and the bassist wow.
what a song to tackle..... an 11-minute monster tune!!!! Well Done to All !!!! ❤
Absolutely brilliant on so many levels. Firstly a pink Floyd song and an obscure on at that for average person. Secondly the guitarist with Ibanez jem with the handle no less and thirdly a bunch of teenagers (and mostly) girls enjoying 70s rock. I only highlight the girls because this is about as far aware from what you’d imagine the typical girls of this age would be listening too. And on top of that well played. Love it. Update: and then a talk box !!!!! Amazing.
Kids these days... are phenomenal. Keep up the good work!
Dam the more I watch this band (over n over ) the more I rock out!! You guys are awesome and thank you for all the feel good you bring me, you seriously are going places!! Rock on
Glad this showed up in my feed. Love seeing the next generation out there playing live :)
The bass player totally nails it. Absolutely brilliant
Bass player is in the groove :)
10000000000 love and respect to the bassist and drummer
What a tough song to take on! Wow - really impressed.
Being myself a member of a PF tribute band, only 2 words : respect and congrats !
....with talk box no less, holy crap. Way too impressive. I have played in a PF tribute show. What a great, great job they've done here. Just stumbled on this and I am forwarding it to about 20 people. Oh, I can just imagine what a few years of stage would do for you guys. I'm just freaking out.
Excellent curriculum; moreover, rendition of a masterpiece by such young musicians. Very impressive. Nice to see adolescents not glued to their phones.
The Great bass player
bass player is awesome!!!
This is no charade. Great job School of Rock. 👍👍
LOL!
What was I doing at 15? Listening to this album all the time floating like that pig wishing I could be doing what these kids are doing!
Good job!!!
BTW- page owner, do not apologize or make excuses for these young people.
They are doing a great job 👍
the bass player was working it...!! great job....
Loved this!!! These kids are already more musically talented than I will ever be. It does my old heart good to know that kids this young aren’t just listening to Pink Floyd, they’re learning how to play Pink Floyd songs. Extra kudos to the bass player. Rock on!
Great cover! Each member was holding their weight - especially the bassist! The talkbox solo is not easy to pull off, and I could tell the guitarist had some sound issues early on in the song - but she came back quite nicely and NAILED the outro solo! I think the complexity of this song, however, as well as the overall tone of the lyrics was lost on the audience. These musicians will no doubt be playing to much larger crowds very soon in their careers. Rock on🤘
Terrific effort guys. Successful in every way. Best part is the band and all their friends will discover the greatness of Floyd.
Only thing missing was the Cow Bell, other than that I really liked the performance of Pigs.
Glad to see kids this young covering Pink Floyd. Great job everyone
She rocked that bass! Not an easy song to play. We all gotta start somewhere. Well done to all of you.
It's a long song with many time changes and the drummer obviously studied the music and was able to keep everything together , rhythm section is the strength.
That bass player is busy!!!! Great upload
Wish these players all the best, thoroughly enjoyed the performance. Nice work.
Bassist flippin rocks ! Totally Pro
That was VERY COOL !
They are all better than many of the so called " Musicians " that are making negative comments . Great job to the musicians ! 👍👍👍
Wow. Good show, kick ass performance!! Love Pigs, easiest the top 5 floyd songs. 10/10
Aside from them doing a great job here, I'm thrilled beyond words to hear these younger folks playing such a great song. Just the fact they're playing real instruments gives me hope that one day, some of them will write and perform their own awesome songs. Great job to everyone on that stage!
That young lady absolutely rocked the bass in that last couple of minutes.
Bass player is fantastic
every pf full band cover deserves an applaud.
edit: good job ladies!!
(hats off to the bassist)
These kids just dropped a song most players would be intimidated to attempt live. Bravo
They are all brilliant, guitarist even has the hair of Gilmour
Everyone - fantastic job!
But that bass player - O. M. G.!
Stunned - end overjoyed. So much talent, so much energy. A bloody good cover in any measure. With the age of the musicians, it is simply off the scale.
That was brilliant by the whole band, as others have said the Bass guitar girl was killing it. Great choice of song too, not the usual Pink Floyd covers we often hear.
Extremely well done! Each member was individually excellent and it all came together nicely.
Awesome. Well done everyone involved here. When I was this age, I was playing 3 chord songs in my bedroom - they’re out doing Floyd on stage. I’m now fearfully old but play theatres in a Floyd show - this lot will be doing the same before too long, if they wish to.
Not an easy song to cover, great job in my opinion keep it up and you'll be rock stars!
Floyd lives on. Forever!
real good bass.
Great musicians especially the guitarist and bassist with great taste in music.
Keep on rocking !
It makes me very happy to see kids doing this. Freakin amazing !!!!
These youngsters have great taste in music. Great job also!
Loved this!!! These kids are already more musically talented than I will ever be. It does my old heart good to know kids this young are not only listening to Pink Floyd, they’re learning how to play Pink Floyd songs. Rock on!
Bass player is killing it🤘
Awesome to see these kids playing Pink Floyd.
Impressive. You did this song justice.
That was amazing! Not an easy or short song to perform in front of crowd specially. They are all great and definetely on a path to become even greater
This song is called Pigs 3 Different ones. It's a great song and these guys nail it. Great Job..
Thank you for keeping ROCK ALIVE!!!
Well done girls, I was about your age when I saw Pink Floyd live in England on the Animals tour in 1977....I also play the guitar and the guitar work on Animals is some of Gilmour's best.
I saw them around 8 times in all, but the Animals show was special for me because it was the time I saw them. No one compared to them live, they were in a league of their own, but they had the best technicians in the world and their sound systems were the most expensive out there. I later became friends with some one who knew them very well.
The lighting and effects were sensational and the sound quality just fabulous.....bravo !
Wow! Really a very good job - especially because they are teenagers! The harmony mic definitely needed to be turned up, could barely hear her. The Gilmour solo is a hard one - especially to bring out the passion he evokes, but I applaud this girl for the effort. The most impressive (that never gets the attention due) was the bass player. She absolutely killed the Water's part, and added in her own flair! Excellent!
Don't worry, I am a life-long Floydian, so I am not so much criticizing as comparing, so when I say excellent job, I really do mean it.
I've been listening to the Floyd since 72 and I agree, this took practice. And talent.
@👁️Noah Lott I too, heard that, but Waters is so determined to get the album reissue released and he is going to tour the entire album this year, and the fact the Floyd toured the album without a back-up bass player, so I find that to be an urban legend.
David originally played bass on pigs and sheep and then when they played live, their second guitarist played bass on those songs and roger played rhythm guitar while david played lead. Rog still played bass on dogs though
As a massive pink Floyd fan that was brilliant your drummer is amazing
thanks Dad!
Watching this was a really nice way to start the day. The kids are definitely alright! :)
bass chick is EXCEPTIONAL
Totally awesome!! Killn it!!
Y'all should cover ac/dc soul stripper and squiler good base lines.
Fantastic !!! 👏👏👏👏👏
🙌
Thanks from Brazil 🇧🇷
A really ambitious song .. followed up with a great performance of it! More please.
I was in a band similar to this one in high school, although sadly, we were playing mostly Weezer, Foo Fighters, and Imagine Dragons.
Just love that bass player
Keeping it alive... Super job to all involved!
Great job. We've played this song live for years and it's not as easy as the people who obviously have never picked up an instrument think it is. Keep up the great work!
Wow..awesome! I love that you younger folk are playing music I listened to way back in the day, and still do. As usual the bass player is driving the train! You girls ROCK!...and you guys too. Im a girl dad, so I love seeing this!
🎉🎉🎉❤ Fantastic!! Y'all nailed it!! One of my favorite Pink Floyd songs!! I love it!
Ok...so they aren't Pink Floyd...but they are only youngsters...they did a great job....they will only get better with age...so props to them...I loved it...rock on kids...you're magnificent...great cover from one of the greatest songs ever recorded
All performers are to be commended. In my opinion, the one musician that really stood out would be the bass player. She really brought the thunder to this performance. As I said, all are to be commended, but, in my opinion, the bass player was the one that really stood out. Again, only my opinion.
Working from home now. And listening to this and this is amazing.