As a Singaporean who lived in Australia, its not that the West is failing. But certainly when crisis arise Chinese people solve it with brutal efficiency while Westerners become armchair philosophers to debate human rights and governmental systems. Still baffles me, if there is a fire in your apartment you put it out right, but Westerners would spend time debating where the fire came from while criticising their roommate's way of life, who may or may not have accidentally started the fire.
You got it right. Talk is cheap. We create our own problems then blame it on others. As long as we can blame someone else, we do not have to do anything but talk about it. We are waiting for that someone else to solve the problem.
@@九州青云 and they keep on arguing still, while seeing their house being burned down because they could not anymore extinguish the fire. Then after the house turned to embers and ashes, they will still continue arguing and blaming. Having freedom of speech really makes many people idiots. And that's why the old adages such as 'Silence is golden' and 'Walk the Talk' remain more valuable.
Democractic systems have its flaws. But if I had to choose between a democractic vs a communist system, I still choose democracy. Have freedom of speech is priceless. Having you voice heard and the freedom to choose is more valuable and imo overcomes the democracy’s inefficiencies and shortcomings.
yes, because Singaporeans are ok with being oppressed and living under tyrannical rule - some of us aren’t ok with giving the government powers we know it will abuse.
It's about time the mainstream is talking about China how it should be talked about. China is not trying to destroy America itself, China is sitting back and letting America destroy itself. *Never interrupt your enemy when he is making a mistake.* - Napoléon Bonaparte
@@2005Azm The US helped fund and set up the lab in Wuhan. It was part of a US-China joint effort to monitor viruses in Asia. Samples were collected and also sent to the US Fort Detrick. So what is in the Wihan lab would also be in the US lab in Maryland.
USA: "We are wholeheartedly against authoritarian regime." USA: "Saudi, you are our best ally. “ USA: "We are totally against communism." USA: "Vietnam, you are our best partner." ......
@@Cam-nq8br dude, it’s their Agenda. They want “democracy and freedom” in every country but they themselves help countries that act in the opposite way by trading goods and services. Like China, Saudi Arabia or African countries. The US is a country of dictatorship run for imperialism. They have military all around the world and crazy secret technology.
@@batissta44 did I say United States of America? USA stands for United Snakes of America, a great nation with crooked politicians and ignorant residents.
US is trying everything to thwart China's development, but forget to work on its own problems. Democracy is only the means, not the purpose. The purpose should be making people's lives better.
@@Stack4Freedom The Spanish flu happened in 1918 when there weren’t even level four labs in existence. It was an age before even mass produced anti biotics. Try again? Or maybe you can continue commenting on something you clearly know very little about.
@@jammin1881 The fact you still believe that conspiracy this far into the pandemic is honestly concerning. Corona virus is a natural virus plain and simple and any attempt of saying China purposely leaked it is simply ridiculous. The Chinese Communist Party may not be the most democratic or the most liked government but there is no reason for them to release a virus that will negatively the entire world economy or even design it in the first place. People like to argue that the virus heavily affected the United States and therefore it must be a bio weapon from China but we have to remember that the first people to be hit by COVID-19 is the Chinese themselves. There's a reason why the lab leak remains a conspiracy and not a main stream fact in the scientific community. In fact its already been proven that the Corona virus is not engineered
I am from South East Asia. I have American friends who said America is control by Wall Street and MIC ( Military Industrial Complex like Boeing, Northrop, Lockheed-Martin, Honeycomb, etc ) and neglected the middle class and the poor while focusing on the rich. After this video, l think my American friends are right.
Borrow? You mean stealing from the US citizen. Printing more and more money. Devaluing the dollar. Soon it will cost a thousand dollars for a burger :P
USA is already a bankrupt hegemon. Only war can save it. That is why White House Regime keeps on provoking Russia( Black Sea and Baltic Sea) and China( SCS and Xinjiang).
what? do you know that china controls their currency? they control it in a way that there is "no inflation". if you put 2 billion in china..you are never gonna see that money again, let alone get it out of the china. impossibe. thats why china is winning.
As an Indian Singaporean diplomat once said: China is a 5,000 year old civilization, the US is a 250 year old state. Yet somehow the Americans think they can force the Chinese to adhere to the American model.
Lets not forget they invented paper, printing, the compass, and gunpowder. Telltale aspects of modern civilization. The US wouldn't even exist if China never invented these.
@@dotoroyuriha7411 really? Let's not forget USA invented lots of technologies and there is A COPY AND DUPLICATION of every technology that other countries make. Don't teach us. 5,000 yr old civilization doesn't mean same 5,000 year old government. US government has president, china has dictator.
China is only a poor country for 5,000 years, without any contribution. It is just a very old mediocre old man, while the United States is a talented boy. It took him 200 years to make the world so advanced
@Islndstyles I wish the CCP would disappear. But it won't be for a while... funny thing is - if the Occident, namely the Eight Nation Alliance, didn't try to colonize China, the CCP would have never existed in the first place. Also, the multiple dynastys that existed is a far cry from the current CCP.
@@pendragonaltria7141 without any contribution? Look at the gdp in the past. China topped 1 lol. Also I think US is cheating? Because they have Illuminati symbol on their dollars-
The China Model works quite well for China but it probably wouldn’t work well elsewhere. Democracy works quite well for US and Europe but it probably wouldn’t work well in Saudi Arabia for example. So stop forcing your ideology to other countries.
Yes, I agree, to be honest, Democracy should not be forced upon other nations. If China is an autocracy, we should let Beijing go its way. Democracy is not meant for every nation and the US is supposed to be a Republic, not a Democracy tbh.
Having lived through the years before China opened to the world in early 1980s, educated in the West and now living in China, I think the US failed to understand that China now has a governance system that is not based on ideology, but a system driven by targets, especially economic targets. It is absurd in China if you argue if the country is a communist or capitalist. Improving living standard is in everyone's mind. To Chinese people, the US is now probably more ideologically based. The misunderstanding of China actually put the US in disadvantages.
@@kidus_f1 Not salty at all. The US stock and real estate market are crazy bubbles, and I will make money as those pop as well. What we are seeing in China though is amazing, historical, and I love watching history unfold.
@@labkeeper7373 exactly, our leaders (and former leaders) want us to believe that we are a complete democracy. Unfortunately some ignorant Americans believe that.
You don’t have less and less democracy. This is how the system has always ran. Look at history. It’s so sad that people never payed attention to their grade school courses because nothing we do today us unique. It’s all still the same as our past.
@@labkeeper7373 it’s not fake democracy… it’s a Representative Democracy. You learn the difference in grade school. The fact that people think we are a true democracy never payed attention in class.
Bloomberg is always doing the right thing. It knows how to benefit itself all the time and shift its position is the West and the USA changes its position regarding China. It is a docile Western idiological tool + 100% economic animal.
It's true but partly coz I think it's not just china they want to keep down-India Brazil basically any non eng speaking country which has the potential to challenge american suoremacy!!!
@@sirija9190 What? What happens when you don't pay with what you agreed with paying? Have you seen the railway system they built in Kenya? We can play anecdotes all day
When a country is (politically,economically, culturally, racially ) divided , keep borrowing money, and can’t even pass (edit:SIMPLE) laws what do you expect.
America: If you fund a terrorist group to get rid of a terrorist group you funded, to get rid of a terrorist group you funded, to get rid of a terrorist group you funded.........
Whatever you say China being an oppressive, authoritarian regime, or one that is only boasting successes and concealing failures, it won’t change the fact China remains the top-most country most trusted by its own nationals. Its approval ratings > 90% is envied by all its western counterparts. The dramatic growth of its economy in the last 4 decades, making its the 2nd largest economy after the USA. Its ascension to the middle-income bracket while lifting nearly 800 million people from poverty. Its success in beating the covid-19 pandemic with the lowest infection and death rates among major economies. Advancements in 5G/6G, quantum computing/telecommunication, space exploration, Beidou navigational system, etc, all of which are making China one of the most competitive countries. This only says one thing loud and clear - its socialism model with unique Chinese characteristics is one that is working, and for that matter, it is far more efficient than Western Capitalism Model where 99% of wealth is controlled by the top 1%. China is now embracing on its latest 'Common Prosperity' program, building an even bigger middle class group as well as spreading the national wealth more evenly among its nationals. Perhaps in the not-too-distant future, China will attain its goal of national rejuvenation, regaining its leadership position in the central stage of the global arena, leading its vast population to prosperity, stability, and peace.
China has a massive population and a low per capita, about the same as Mexico's per capita. Based on my limited understanding of economics, If they manage to raise that to the same level as the U.S per capita, their economy will dwarf the U.S's. That will be wild.
@@OnlyOneGedeon Couldn’t agree more with you. Some additional points: 1) China’s GDP already surpassed the USA’s GDP years ago, if purchasing power (instead of nominal GDP) basis were used; 2) plus, a lot of the USA’s GDP has come from ‘printing money’ and that is not sustainable!
With all due respect, but you're missing the big picture. America WANTED China to rise, for decades now. America ain't backing down from this great humanitarian mission any time soon.
@@joeya6795 "Great humanitarian missions", oh yeah, of course, US spurs crisis all over the world and offers itself as the solution. does America still want China to rise?
People actually didn’t care whether it called communist, socialist or an political system. So far it works great, so why we want to change to system to these fail miserably?
To paraphrase, it's not ideology that matters. Regardless of whether it's capitalism or communism, what counts are the results ie the people can have food on the table, be decently covered, kept warm with a roof over their heads, and be educated with its history and culture as foundations. To the CCP, it's NOT the PROCEDURAL matter of having multiple parties, one person one vote (universal suffrage) nor elections every 4 -5 years aka democracy as practise currently in the liberal world. For the CCP, it's the measurable OUTCOME (as defined above) that counts via its political system and structure ... regardless of how you label it .... as communism or whatever.
The guy said in the end is just a whole bunch of wishful thinking rubbish: "the West begins to reform their governments, begins to talk about the importance of the freedom ...." Well, only talk the talk, non stop ...
Its because the people making the decisions wont be alive to see the outcome. The 2 party system doesn't help, should be hundreds of parties. You can't sort every American into 2 boxes and expect everyone to agree.
Your perception of the status of democracy in the two nations is mistaken. The United States is considered by most to be a democratic nation at best, and an anocracy at worst; the PRC is an authoritarian regime. P.S. I hope you enjoyed your fifty cents :).
@@levelazn Actually, local governhood is possibly the most democratic thing you can ever have, which prevents more control from the Federal government. The Roe vs Wade situation was about letting the federal government enforce or allow the state rights on abortion,which according to constitution is illegal, as it is not a fully federal law, which nullifies the enforcement for Roe vs Wade.
China is so obsessed with the west. They literally use westerners to legitimize their products and all Chinese propaganda on tiktok have English subtitles.
@@levinng2004 ai isn’t just going to affect china lol. It’s going to affect the whole world. Everyone will be monitored and will be rendered useless for the most part. Ai will likely destroy us
When I was in America, I felt totally unsafe. In China you will feel safe everywhere I go. Personal and family safety is the biggest Human rights to me ☺️
@@045773 I‘ve been to Sao Paulo and Rio on a business trip, I loved the friendly locals, loved the ocean view in Rio, but I never went out for a walk after dinner during my stay in Brazil, which was a shame.
**You're absolutely correct on the 1st phase of your statement _ there is no need to doubt of your own experienced !!! **I'm sure they will highly appreciate your most faithful words.** **DON'T FORGET & Don't Get Her Wrong [ Frankly (no bias) ] , China is not intended suddenly rises, but truly speeding revival to washout the past 150 years humiliations!!!**
@@hydrohasspoken6227 oh yeah I did not see it. The way you phrase it is as if western failures are fueling their economic rise, which wasn't really the point. Since the video was more about ideology, I couldn't see the connection, it confused me.
One thing that I have learnt recently is to never be invested on another person/party failure. It can make you do despicable things. I think US is focused on how to slow down China and rather it should focus on, how can we better country. Note: From this video, I don’t think China approach is: How can we slow down US but rather how can we be better
China isn't betting on the USA to fail, it is actively working so it does while also strengthening itself. And if the USA actually worked against China, it would be much better. Half of the situation the USA is in is because people with power and influence bow to chinese money and hand over anything they ask for, because they (unlike the chinese) have no love whatsoever for their country. And many foolish people who dislike to think or do basic research just blindly follow what corrupt celebrities and companies say. There's no way a country can survive like that.
Stop being so obsessed with the 'China '. Stop blaming your own government for everything including your own laziness. Invest the trillions on infrastructure and education of millennials. That's your future.
United States and European Union are two extremely weak and declining subjects. One has an astronomic national dept, fighting numerous super expensive wars (same as Vietnam was in 1970's) in Afganistan, Iraq, Syria and Ukraine, declining industry, collapsing infrastructure and vast trade deficit with China. The other is one of the most impotent and incompetent political Union on the face of the planet earth that is extremely fragmented along the national, religious, political and ideological lines. Has already experienced Brexit (and will probably experiance similar exits in future). And has huge problems with Islamic migration from Africa and Arabia. On the other hands China has close friends, trading partners and allies all across the globe (from independent nations in Europe like Russia, Hungary, Turkey...all the way to Indonesia and ASEAN).
Just like the West says their three gorges dam will collapse EVERY SINGLE YEAR. The West always wishes the misery to others and actually participated in most of it. Be it be in Africa, South America or Asia.
actually it was a Chinese scholar that came up with the collapse theory. It's become a meme on Chinese Internet. We jokingly say that he did that on purpose to fool the Westerners. Worked quite well if you ask me XD
@Duffy63 Just think about it, how many countries in world owns the big data of their own citizens and think about how many Chinese have passports and have travelled overseas
@Duffy63 The point is, internet is not truly owned by the people around the world. The service providers are from different countries to which China's laws are not applied. It's common misconception that Chinese government banned Google, RUclips, Twitter and etc., whereas the fact is that these big names refused to comply with Chinese laws when operating in China. Does this make sense?
It is very funny that when I started to contact the Western media, the Western world thought that China would collapse tomorrow But five years have passed, and we have become stronger 😂😂😂 Initially, I felt that the CCP was lying, but now, I feel that compared to the Western media, the CCP is the cleanest, cleanest, and most efficient government in the world
How many times do us Chinese people need to repeat ourselves? We are not interested in replacing the western political system. How about you can have your political system and we can have ours? I don’t see how this stop us from doing business with each other.
One of the biggest failures of western countries I observed is that instead of acknowledging and working on their own social, political or racial problems, they tend to blame all problems on someone else or divert the focus by making new problems just because it's easier. Fundamentally it's lacking of accountabilities. I believe competition is essential for improvements, why do we always have to spilt the world by ideologies such as democracy vs autocracy, capitalism vs communism, liberalism vs conservatism? Wouldn't the world be a better place if everyone can learn from their counterparty, compete freely and evolve?
Exactly as you mentioned, always easier to blame on others than to resolve the problem. If the west is going to fall, it wouldn’t be from China, it would be from itself, yet they will for sure blame on China…
@@madiosc Just like athletes racing on tracks, it just doesn't make sense to say because some one runs slower so he/she makes the others run faster, or in this video's term, fueling the others' speed.
If the trade war fails, there will be a pandemic in China. Every step the United States takes is digging its own grave. The United States thinks that the whole world is a fool
social unrest is quite a threat to any society when the poor gets all enti elitist chaos will eventually come at the same time we cannot ignore indeed the social inequalities between everyone as for democracy theres still enough of it although not perfect it's persevered for many many years
50 years ago, USA: "China is collapsing." 30 years ago, USA: "China is collapsing." 10 years ago, USA: "China is collapsing." Present, USA: "China is collapsing." .... Who is collapsing?
If the Chinese believe the words of the United States and collapse, it will cause countless deaths. The Chinese cannot bear the mistakes made by the United States and therefore remain vigilant towards the United States. This behavior is considered by the United States to be China's mistakes. Many countries and nations in this world have lost their lives, money, and future because of the "mistakes" of the West. Some ethnic groups have even been unable to speak out because they have been extinct. They are buried under the soil of the United States, Australia and Canada.
Can anyone of us imagine the quality of life the Americas would have if the USA tended to its own affairs and leave the other regions of the world o tend to theirs. Personally I’d just settle for a US high speed rail service.
not so much better i assume, US intervention and unipolar hegemony kept the world a relatively stable place after the end of the 2 world wars and the cold war, replacing it with lesser conflicts around the globe
China and Russia: the new balance of power More than a year after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, how has the war reshaped global politics? Apr 17th 2023 [The Economist] "If interested, read on. We read! Agreeing and understanding is for another department." 1:12
Even pushing aside the Chinese political system, that the USA is the beacon of democracy is ridiculous. Within the western countries, many countries are showing better performance than the USA in terms of the benefit and equality, such as north European countries. Speaking of taking care of the working class, contrary to the USA which has been abducted by the capitalists, German has a healthier and more balanced economical structure. So the problem is not about the communism or authoritarian. It’s the declined hegemony that the USA is facing.
Northern European countries are very homogeneous, there are social realities they don’t have to deal with, they are 100 times tougher on immigration, rely heavily on natural resources and have a smaller population.
@@xblade11230 oh, of course. I'm pretty sure that the interests of the US working class is almost fully heard in the us Congress, and that big corporations don't take any advantages from the politicians in USA.
@Raman 556 Ah yes play the racial card. The Japanese are a very proud nation with a long history and culture just like China. They don't fantasize about anything more than being Japanese.
@@Andy-P 😂 They do seem themselves as white and above all other Asians. Don’t you see white nationalist going to Japan, and wanting an Ethnostate and homogeneous country like Japan. Japan mono ethnicity is because Japanese island was isolated from the rest of the world
I've been living in China for more than 20 years. I want to point out that "one-party" or "No general election" doesn't mean that Chinese people cannot express their opinions or criticize the government. The West always tends to describe China as a nation without "freedom" and the people living there are "unhappy" under the high pressure of the central government. But the fact is actually the opposite. Chinese people are satisfied with their leader and system. They trust the government because the system enables the government to find the most capable politicians to "Serve the people" but not make the election become a ridiculous game of the rich.
Absolutely agree. I find it interesting how Chinese and people from many democratic countries have a completely different mindsets in terms of government. Eg when facing the pandemic, many people in the western countries view the measurements taken by their government such as lockdown and vaccine as a violation to liberty/human rights. However in China, people see these measurements as an inherent responsibility of the government. They think that by doing so, the government is caring about the people's live, and they willing to participate together to achieve the same goal as with the government. I think this mindset is the crucial point of why the virus has been contained so well in China, and this willingness to cooperate with the government is unseperatable with the China model.
the Chinese aren’t forcing anyone else to adopt their system. They do their own thing, the US has a problem with that because they’re being too successful.
@@Huuuef That's right, We reach to the point to depend and survive exclusively by everything coming fronm China, the scary part is that country is comunist imposing their rules, way of life to the rest of the world, and even indoctrinating our minds loosing our freedoms every day. making us believe that is perfectly normal.
@@Huuuef Our dependance from China become so powefull that we can not even investigate the origin of their bioweapon called Sars Covid -19, They can do whatever they want knowing that rest of the worls goverments are afraid that China can cut all the supplies and resourses if they insist on that.
“You wouldn’t want to be in Iran during the outbreak” while his statement is true, he casually forgot to mentioned that we sanctioned them, including medicine and food, for FOLLOWING the nuclear agreement according to the IEAE. At least make an honest argument.
It's funny how in the simple Western mind, all countries that are not liberal democracies are "authoritarian". Chinese government is vastly different from Iranian gov, Venezuelan gov, Saudi gov, Jordanian gov, etc. The West cannot speak in nuance.
The exceptionals don't see them selevs as failures but they blame others for their failure , they can't swallow others taken over the empirical helms .. typical cowboys riding donkey's..
It's amazing how human beings are effortlessly biased,. When the gentleman talks of the successes of democracies in handling covid19 he conveniently leaves out Brazil and India which are amongst the world's largest democracies and have failed extensively even when compared with the likes of Iran and the rest of the "stans". His examples of democratic successes reveal bias towards Western nations.
When one continue to engage in Lies to prevail over others, he will ultimately fail, as truth will triumph over falsehood. For we are intelligent humans.
Don't be fooled that china is winning. It is not era of common people of China. It is actually era of artificial intelligence. The ongoing trade war is just an excuse for rich people to make artificial intelligence more powerful because they say they need to compete. But it doesn't matter who is leading artificial intelligence because artificial intelligence have machine learning to replace skilled and unskilled workers. AI can download knowledge of university students and it means they can replace university students too.
@@literung8767 some people may think people of china can grow food. Don't be fooled by it because artificial intelligence can control robots to grow food too, it can sell cheaper too. Imagine farmers need to take bank loans but when farmers cannot pay the debts because ai sell food cheaper than them, the banks will take away their lands and the land will goes to the rich people. AI only make rich people richer and AI can do more than just simple jobs because AI can download knowledge so AI can replace skilled workers too.
The US only became the leader because they weren't leading in combating the conflicts that led to the two wars. Actually the US benefited very much from the two wars.
No, America DID NOT benefit from the two wars. And China is about to make the very same mistake. No nation has ever survived it's own 'Empire status". China wont either. It's simply not possible.
A better way of looking at it is that the west had cultural advantages which enabled it to come out on top. The question is whether the countries of east asia will rise due to being strong where the west isn't.
@@scottenosh4548 Wow, Europe in tatters and allowed to fall to American influence while the British Empire, a potential rival on the world stage, is dismantled and becomes a second rate power. Totally not beneficial to the US.
Chinese success is due largely to captured american capitalists. If you ask apple who they really want to work for, they will tell you, if they are honest, communists. Americans are the real unsung heroes of chinese success.
The Chinese success is actually more about east Asian culture, not democracy or authoritarianism. We can look at another issue that the Asians have been doing much better than the west, especially America: drugs. In China, and all other countries that have been influenced by Chinese culture in the region, have very strict laws against drugs. Users would be sent to forced withdrawal, drug dealers can be put to death. This is completely unimaginable for westerners.
@@gokulkrishna7173 same as recently new claimed that 1million xinjiang citizens in jails. Just some claims made by westerners in order to collapse China.
It is not China but the US that is threatening the world with war. The US needs enemies to justify the military expenditures that concentrate our country's wealth in the hands of the few.
@Jdjdjd Ridid Europe is not safe, just like the rest of the world. You have to understand that just because it's Europe, doesn't mean Russia and the wars in the Middle East isn't a problem. And in fact unemployment wouldn't be an all time low in Europe without COVID. Because in 1930's Germany, 100% of the population was employed... And also very happy, because all those who were not happy disappeared. I do have to point out that measuring safety and harmony is quite a dangerous metric. The perfect system according to this model, would be a system where feeling anything other than safe happy is illegal, and every group that is perceived a "threat" to their group are wiped out, and everyone are educated to believe that their lives are perfect.
@Jdjdjd Ridid Lucky for Europe to get what they think works for them, also lucky for China to get what works for them, now the problem is that the west want China to follow their direction, the Chinese are smart enough to choose to learn selectively, they don’t need a 100% copy.
@@koka1571 US has created and pushed a lot of Refugees from Middle East to Europe to make Europe ' unsafe ' . US is the main source of most of the chaos at present ........
The problem is when people compare Communism to Democracy. The comparison should more properly be between Communism and Capitalism. There's nothing stopping a Communist society from being democratic. Communism and Capitalism are economic systems. Democracy and Totalitarianism are another thing all together. It is possible to have a totalitarian Capitalist state and it is also possible to have a democratic Communist state. It's a mistake to equate Democracy with Capitalism and Totalitarianism with Communism.
Let's be serious, China is not communist at all. Yes, they have a controlled economy, but that is far from communism. It is even more close to capitalism. But capitalism under government regulation.
China is practising Socialism + Capitalism. This has been put into China's constitution, and it calls "Socialism with Chinese Characteristics". China is NOT a Communist society. If you don't understand this, you don't under China.
I think the interesting part is so many people equating democracy with voting, especially popular voting. Does voting always signify democracy? Does no voting always signify no democracy?
17:27 - "No two leaves in the world are identical, and no histories, cultures or social systems are the same. Each country is unique, with its own history, culture and social system, and none is superior to the other." - President Xi A clear and simple statement, yet the West failed to understand and forced their far from perfect democracy system to others.
Politicians and mainstream medias are all backed by the top 1%. It doesn't matter how the 99% vote, the 1% will rule, and their interest will never align with the 99%.
In China we call these volunteers in hospitals 白衣天使and白衣战士,which means The Angel in White and The Warriors in White. They come from all over China, some medical staff, some soldiers, some just normal citizens, answering the nation’s call for help and organization. Many of them are ones of the new generation (born in 2000s), who many consider to be young foolish and lazy people. But they bravely stepped forward, not seeing family for months, fainting from the heat in their protection gear, faces swelling up from long hours with masks, hard work in exchange for the happiness and security of their homeland and their fellow people. They proved those accusing voices wrong, and in doing so earned all of our respects. Salute to them❤️
A taxi driver in Singapore pointed out to me all the tall sky scrapers and explained to me how each one was owned by some corrupt politician or relative of a politician. He had to drive a taxi 6 days a week 12 hours a day to earn a pittance.
Democracy only works when the entire population is well educated, when there is culture and respect among one another. Democracy in the west isn't working and will not work because everyone is different. Has different cultures, believe in different gods, beliefs on what's right or wrong, everyone looks different. How long can one another live together with opposing forces, you can only respect differences for so Long until you can no longer avoid confrontation.
@@TrendyStone not to defend china but does two-party system any better? when two party essentialy does the same thing on the things that really matters just different populist promises and policies (that didn't really set in stone) just to secure next period's vote count.
@@FathinLuqmanTantowi The US two party system works great. It’s self correcting and keeps fringe groups in check. Study a little American history. The two party system…with all its flaws…is a feature, not a bug.
Completely wrong approach from The West and the US. Instead of trying hard to prevent China from growing, they need to focus more in improving themself.
@@Cam-nq8br nothing wrong with that. One of the reason I know is that they claimed to be "developing" to benefit from WTO's policy. The US and other member are heavily against that claiming that China is developed.
@@Cam-nq8br and if you just visit China, you will be shocked how modern they are. Given your hatred against them, I would advise you not to go in order to protect you from the truth.
@@user-zy2nw3ug6q i get your sacarsm but it wont get you anywhere. China is defenitely not a dream nation (I know for a fact that there are coruption, injustice, racism). But, they are getting to their goals by hardwork and technology no matter how much hate you blindly put out.
**You're absolutely correct on your statement !!!** **I'm sure the truly Chinese will highly appreciate your most faithful words.** **DON'T FORGET & Don't Get Her Wrong [ Frankly (no bias) ] , China is not intended suddenly rises, but truly speeding revival to washout the past 150 years humiliations!!!**
The wisdom of the Chinese people is not just material rational civilization. Wisdom in culture and art is also worthy of admiration and learning. Compared with many hegemonic countries, he prefers to enhance his competitiveness and do his own thing well, so that his perseverance is in the world of civilization.
"know the enemy and know yourself, and you can fight a hundred battles with no danger of defeat" if you are failing to do so, then the result will be crystal clear.... simple as that~
To join a party in US, you just need to register. To join CCP, you need consistent performance merit and the will to serve the people. When disaster strikes, have you seen party members are volunteering to go to help in US ? Therefore, I rather question the purpose of US parties since any party in US is not for the people in this core. The election is a procedure which can be influenced by media and by propaganda (Yes, election slogan) of parties. The life of common citizens have not changed for years.
You know what a joke is? Singapore is rated higher in democracy index than countries like India and Indonesia 😂 eventhough in Singapore there is no freedom of press, and the emergency law ISA (Internal Security Act) is still pretty much alive. Its a joke. Basically if youre an allied to america youre a "democracy" country 😂
One of the things I hear that’s commonly repeated by western media is how the cultural revolution and agriculture reforms were an economic failure for China. While if you are judging from the economic perspective, that is true. But, that is where the point is missed. The point of the reforms weren’t to make China rich at the time, it was to change the culture of bourgeoisie and elitism to “re-set” the nation together so it wouldn’t grow apart, so people were United in mind, spirit, and actions. Money wasn’t on their mind, because that wasn’t important for the whole at the time. It was not about the individual but creating a new culture. This wasn’t just communism that caused this but they were searching for this new culture since the early 1900s with the decline of the Qing Dynasty, and inability of the old system from protecting Chinese peoples and lands. It’s hard to interpret another system if you don’t understand the history and context. Every analysis I hear from the west is from the Western perspective and applying western understandings and their own beliefs onto China. That in itself is a fallacy. If you are a plumber and judging everything like a broken window from the plumbing perspective you are not getting the whole picture and misconstruing facts to fit into your own narrative.
Economic failure in the sense that millions of people died. I bet that was an humbling experience indeed. It is hard to grow apart when one simply cuts off the part growing away.
Well said. The video mentioned that China government forced a lot of young men and women to rural area...Well, that's because the cities can't offer enough jobs to young men then, it was a strategic decision to let them work in rural so they can be feed at least, and come back once more jobs can be offered with the economic growth in cities. Collectivistic economy model in China rural area at that time allows Government to have the ability that can arrange millions of jobless young men/women to work in the land of the rural. If the land is private owned by farmer that wouldn't be possible.
It is easier to control people when they are poor. Now that they have basic necessities, Chinese people will explore freedom, expression of thought. With no diversity and immigration tolerated, new ideas will die. It will be interesting to see how the CCP then repeats the Tianmen Square massacre.
I would say the eyeopener in recent decades is not so much China but how the US itself has changed. It is no longer the utopia of freedom that I grew up respecting but a divided nation split along the different interests of the Uber rich who own the media(including social media and Bloomberg) who control the narrative competing against each other.
@@xhaolee1920 people are more likely to turn against their government when they are poor. How many violent revolutions happened in countries with a high standard of living? The more a government improves the lives of its people (which is it's main job), the more loyal the people will be.
He mentioned Australia, New Zealand, South Korea and Singapore - all countries are basically islands (including South Korea because the border with North Korea isnt crossed at all). And you can handle pandemic much better when you are an island than an inland country. Oh, btw Brazil, UK and other countries in the EU are democracies and look how they failed.
the man is deluded; he concluded that is better to not be Iran, North Korea based on nothing (I specifically replayed that part several times thinking I missed the reason why he said that)
The amount of self hatred by people living in western countries in this comment section is astonishing. Need I remind you, that the only reason you're even able to discuss these things is that you live in a democracy?
And that's about it. People talk, march, protest, vote, and yet Afghanistan, Syria, Iraq, the financial crisis, covid and Trump happened. More are on the way, and few of them are because of China. It makes this whole video absurd - pointing finger at China, saying it "promotes" its model and questioning its sustainability...does little in sorting your own house out. Anxiety and fear is making people losing ability to concentrate and on prioritize on the urgent.
That's one thing in which I believe we should be more like China. In the end both China, America and their allies are countries fighting for their own interests. China's restrictive system gives them a huge advantage to do pretty much whatever they want without internal opposition that the US and Europe don't have.
There’s nothing wrong with self reflection and admitting that there are flaws in your system it’s the only way to make things better. China does this very well… they identify their deficiencies and take action to improve.
Every western, anti-communist trope in one video presented as an "analysis". The downfall of the western "democracy" isn't coming from competition overseas, its coming from its own internal contradictions and failure to deliver a stable life for its people.
@@karankapoor2701 As a Chinese, we want India to grow and achieve the same economic growth like China. That’s might be the difference of these two countries.
@@karankapoor2701 keep fooling yourself. Don't go and fight corruption in your country. So, at least, it can experience a sensible growth rate in the coming century. Else, the only thing, your country may be able to achieve, is simply an explosive increase in population and birth rate, but definitely not in economy size.
It is common that when you find something infallible as it is, you wish somehow something goes wrong from within so that you do not have to change your way of thinking.
It is easier to control people when they are poor. Now that they have basic necessities, Chinese people will explore freedom, expression of thought. With no diversity and immigration tolerated, new ideas will die. It will be interesting to see how the CCP then repeats the Tianmen Square massacre.
The analysis is too ideological. Ideology is mostly just used to get people riled up enough to get into a fight, it does not do much to help understand what is actually happening.
I beg to differ. We all know what is actually happening in the world, it is all in the news however, what is behind all that is happening is largely due to the country's concept of such ideology adopted, which is a sensitive word for the west that has been overly use to dictate "which ideology is the best" instead of understand all the pros and cons of ideology and come to embrace the differences of system. Unless if you are questioning the history and origin of ideology, that is a different story in this discussion.
@@JustinLBK I am not sure we do all know what is actually happening in the world. A lot of things are underreported. Other things are widely reported, but in a misleading way. Occasionally we are blatantly lied to. In general I think that ideology of all forms is typically used to try to persuade people go to war against some adversary. The truth is never ideological. The truth is not a crusader.
No expert wanted to back their claim, the segment with the editor In chief felt like they just took a recording of the editor in chief rambling on about democracy superiority during their lunch break
Exactly.....f*^k bloomberg john mickletwait.... at 11:00 Singapore is also partly authoritarian country, why didn't he chose India ?. India is the most populated democratic country. How did they fare in during this covid pandemic ?. Bloody hypocrite, the west is getting worse and worse trying to spin something to their favor when the evidence clearly suggest otherwise
There are inaccuracies by your guest speaker. China did NOT become a republic under the Communist revolution of 1949, this was 3 decades earlier; It forced the last Qing boy emperor Pu Yi, to abdicate in 1912, with the early republic under it's first President Sun Yat-sen.
Deng Xiaoping was one of the greatest political and government leaders of all time. Very few people can claim that they have affected not only their nation, but the world, as much him. He is easily on par with the Founding Father's in America, and should be studied by all people interested in politics and governance. The fact that most people in the west do not know his name is a true shame; we could learn a lot from him.
Your point is interesting. Deng Xiaoping was a great statesman and strategist. He experienced many wars and political struggles in his life. And successfully grasped the power of a country, and chose a correct path for China at a critical point in time. He is a legend in his own right.
US is always judging other nation from its own, lot of times, selfish perspective: 1) China never intended to export its system (one system only fits its special condition) to other countries, IT IS THE US that feels can not dictate its own system onto China; 2) US always blame others for its failure, so it thinks that China's success is due to Western's failure. NO, China's success is because Chinese government adopted the social and economic policies that fits China and hard-working from Chinese people. By the same token, the decline of the US is not because of China, it is solely its own problem. China doesn't invade, doesn't sanction, doesn't arrest entrepreneur, academics from US. IT IS TIME for US to CLEARN ITS OWN MESS!
@@beto8493 Learn some history, First HK and Taiwan is China's territory, secondarily China is flexible enough to let people in there keep their own ways of life (One country two systems). Only those want to be independent are stopped.
The fact that they have this relatively neutral video by Western media standard is because they start to recognize China's success and the impact on their claim.
@@domitravel795an incomplete truth is a lie. For example, London is the most monitored city in the world. But in this video, it only show camera in China. Obviously, they want to mislead you. There are many similar examples in this video.
@@shylockjohnson2076 "Most monitored city in the world" means nothing... it is just one city. China contains most of the surveillance cameras in the world. It is how they keep full control on their population. This video is actually very unbiased and relies on facts. "According to industry researcher IHS Markit, at the end of 2019 there were 770 million surveillance cameras in China, and this was expected to exceed 1 billion by the end of 2021"
As a Chinese, China has many problems, but problems and achievements coexist. I often scold Xi jinping at home, but we don't seek to replace him unless he can't solve the Taiwan issue in the next five years.
Yup, an oligarchy of the rich who manipulate the political class. But it can be argued, that's how America was originally designed--to be a democracy for the elite while spouting enlightened rhetoric to the poor.
![Baby Kia - GLOVES & DRACS (BLACK AF1s) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ajm8LeB0qQk/mqdefault.jpg)
As a Singaporean who lived in Australia, its not that the West is failing. But certainly when crisis arise Chinese people solve it with brutal efficiency while Westerners become armchair philosophers to debate human rights and governmental systems.
Still baffles me, if there is a fire in your apartment you put it out right, but Westerners would spend time debating where the fire came from while criticising their roommate's way of life, who may or may not have accidentally started the fire.
You got it right. Talk is cheap. We create our own problems then blame it on others. As long as we can blame someone else, we do not have to do anything but talk about it. We are waiting for that someone else to solve the problem.
And later it turns out the fire started from their own stove.
@@九州青云 and they keep on arguing still, while seeing their house being burned down because they could not anymore extinguish the fire. Then after the house turned to embers and ashes, they will still continue arguing and blaming. Having freedom of speech really makes many people idiots. And that's why the old adages such as 'Silence is golden' and 'Walk the Talk' remain more valuable.
Democractic systems have its flaws. But if I had to choose between a democractic vs a communist system, I still choose democracy. Have freedom of speech is priceless. Having you voice heard and the freedom to choose is more valuable and imo overcomes the democracy’s inefficiencies and shortcomings.
yes, because Singaporeans are ok with being oppressed and living under tyrannical rule - some of us aren’t ok with giving the government powers we know it will abuse.
It's about time the mainstream is talking about China how it should be talked about. China is not trying to destroy America itself, China is sitting back and letting America destroy itself. *Never interrupt your enemy when he is making a mistake.* - Napoléon Bonaparte
That is completely made up.
You think China is just sitting back? What if all conflicts and crises were directed by the Chinese party? For example, covid.
@@elilee2075 China may have first reported the case, but there is no proof that China got the virus first.
@@elilee2075 Who owns Wuhan laboratory ? and who was financing it ?
@@2005Azm The US helped fund and set up the lab in Wuhan. It was part of a US-China joint effort to monitor viruses in Asia. Samples were collected and also sent to the US Fort Detrick. So what is in the Wihan lab would also be in the US lab in Maryland.
USA: "We are wholeheartedly against authoritarian regime."
USA: "Saudi, you are our best ally. “
USA: "We are totally against communism."
USA: "Vietnam, you are our best partner."
......
Hypocrites
Who said that?
@@Cam-nq8br dude, it’s their Agenda. They want “democracy and freedom” in every country but they themselves help countries that act in the opposite way by trading goods and services. Like China, Saudi Arabia or African countries. The US is a country of dictatorship run for imperialism. They have military all around the world and crazy secret technology.
Hahahahahahaha 😂
@@batissta44 did I say United States of America? USA stands for United Snakes of America, a great nation with crooked politicians and ignorant residents.
US is trying everything to thwart China's development, but forget to work on its own problems. Democracy is only the means, not the purpose. The purpose should be making people's lives better.
true
Like when China leaked the corona virus? Those kind of steps “in making people lives better?”
@@jammin1881 like when the US leaked the Spanish flu? Those kind of steps in “making peoples lives better”
@@Stack4Freedom
The Spanish flu happened in 1918 when there weren’t even level four labs in existence. It was an age before even mass produced anti biotics.
Try again? Or maybe you can continue commenting on something you clearly know very little about.
@@jammin1881 The fact you still believe that conspiracy this far into the pandemic is honestly concerning. Corona virus is a natural virus plain and simple and any attempt of saying China purposely leaked it is simply ridiculous. The Chinese Communist Party may not be the most democratic or the most liked government but there is no reason for them to release a virus that will negatively the entire world economy or even design it in the first place. People like to argue that the virus heavily affected the United States and therefore it must be a bio weapon from China but we have to remember that the first people to be hit by COVID-19 is the Chinese themselves. There's a reason why the lab leak remains a conspiracy and not a main stream fact in the scientific community. In fact its already been proven that the Corona virus is not engineered
I am from South East Asia. I have American friends who said America is control by Wall Street and MIC ( Military Industrial Complex like Boeing, Northrop, Lockheed-Martin, Honeycomb, etc ) and neglected the middle class and the poor while focusing on the rich. After this video, l think my American friends are right.
so basically singapore?
It's probably at least partially right, but it is fully in the hand of Americans to change it, if they started to vote for it :)
Yes, but they were happily enjoying life gifted to them for toeing the line. Whose fault?
Keep saying China’s system is unsustainable yet never questioned how long the US can carry on borrowing humongous amounts of money to survive.
Borrow? You mean stealing from the US citizen. Printing more and more money. Devaluing the dollar. Soon it will cost a thousand dollars for a burger :P
USA is already a bankrupt hegemon. Only war can save it. That is why White House Regime keeps on provoking Russia( Black Sea and Baltic Sea) and China( SCS and Xinjiang).
Lol China runs a ton of deficit too
@@qiensong7621 True but all domestic debt unlike the US owing trillions to China and Japan.
what? do you know that china controls their currency? they control it in a way that there is "no inflation". if you put 2 billion in china..you are never gonna see that money again, let alone get it out of the china. impossibe. thats why china is winning.
As an Indian Singaporean diplomat once said: China is a 5,000 year old civilization, the US is a 250 year old state. Yet somehow the Americans think they can force the Chinese to adhere to the American model.
Lets not forget they invented paper, printing, the compass, and gunpowder. Telltale aspects of modern civilization. The US wouldn't even exist if China never invented these.
@@dotoroyuriha7411 really? Let's not forget USA invented lots of technologies and there is A COPY AND DUPLICATION of every technology that other countries make.
Don't teach us. 5,000 yr old civilization doesn't mean same 5,000 year old government.
US government has president, china has dictator.
China is only a poor country for 5,000 years, without any contribution. It is just a very old mediocre old man, while the United States is a talented boy. It took him 200 years to make the world so advanced
@Islndstyles I wish the CCP would disappear. But it won't be for a while... funny thing is - if the Occident, namely the Eight Nation Alliance, didn't try to colonize China, the CCP would have never existed in the first place.
Also, the multiple dynastys that existed is a far cry from the current CCP.
@@pendragonaltria7141 without any contribution? Look at the gdp in the past. China topped 1 lol. Also I think US is cheating? Because they have Illuminati symbol on their dollars-
The China Model works quite well for China but it probably wouldn’t work well elsewhere.
Democracy works quite well for US and Europe but it probably wouldn’t work well in Saudi Arabia for example.
So stop forcing your ideology to other countries.
Yes, I agree, to be honest, Democracy should not be forced upon other nations. If China is an autocracy, we should let Beijing go its way. Democracy is not meant for every nation and the US is supposed to be a Republic, not a Democracy tbh.
forcing your ideology to other people is what every empire ever has done
@@noelsolomon6854 i didnt see rome did the same
@@yonathanrakau1783 rome were a little special, but they did do the same in my places
I didn't see it works well in American, at least not for recent years.
It's not about autocracy or democracy, it's about effective governing.
TOTALITARIAN REGIME CAN BE EFFECTIVE AT THE COST OF INDIVIDUALS SACRIFICES IT WILL EVENTUALLY PUT PEOPLE IN MIGERY
@@진수향-g8m I am blind now THANK YOU
You're absolutely right. Now the question, of course, is whether you'd consider China's governance effective.
This. No matter the system, if it is made by competent and effective people the country will grow
@@keaixiaomeinv Yes. It's complicated.
Having lived through the years before China opened to the world in early 1980s, educated in the West and now living in China, I think the US failed to understand that China now has a governance system that is not based on ideology, but a system driven by targets, especially economic targets. It is absurd in China if you argue if the country is a communist or capitalist. Improving living standard is in everyone's mind. To Chinese people, the US is now probably more ideologically based. The misunderstanding of China actually put the US in disadvantages.
In China the ideology is money. And Xi thought.
@@apvial That's funny, tell me in your country that living is no need of money.
Enjoy ride of the economic collapse of the greatest debt trap ponzi scheme in the history of human history. I will enjoy it.
@@8cor153 Salty
@@kidus_f1 Not salty at all. The US stock and real estate market are crazy bubbles, and I will make money as those pop as well. What we are seeing in China though is amazing, historical, and I love watching history unfold.
But here in the west we have less and less democracy. More and more are we dictated from private corporations.
The main problem is: The West is practicing fake democracy ~ capitalism democracy
@@labkeeper7373 exactly, our leaders (and former leaders) want us to believe that we are a complete democracy. Unfortunately some ignorant Americans believe that.
You don’t have less and less democracy. This is how the system has always ran. Look at history. It’s so sad that people never payed attention to their grade school courses because nothing we do today us unique. It’s all still the same as our past.
@@labkeeper7373 it’s not fake democracy… it’s a Representative Democracy. You learn the difference in grade school. The fact that people think we are a true democracy never payed attention in class.
M G A F A
It's amazing how little Bloomberg understands China.
Bloomberg is always doing the right thing. It knows how to benefit itself all the time and shift its position is the West and the USA changes its position regarding China. It is a docile Western idiological tool + 100% economic animal.
It won't be surprising if that's the case, it's after all a Western News Agency
blinded by greed, yeap
Just simply, Bloomberg can lobby the US government which is also a weakness of the US government.
Bloomberg understands China better than most other english speaking mainstream media. I know it's not a high bar, but it's still worth noting.
In other words, Western success is to keep China down. The West was very successful in keeping Africa down until China helps Africa to rise.
Then it will be China who will keep Africa down once we become more competitive
@@dishydez Nope, those are China's allies. They will do that to the west.
@@markusoreos.233 Really? Do you not see what happened to Sri Lanka's port?
It's true but partly coz I think it's not just china they want to keep down-India Brazil basically any non eng speaking country which has the potential to challenge american suoremacy!!!
@@sirija9190 What? What happens when you don't pay with what you agreed with paying?
Have you seen the railway system they built in Kenya?
We can play anecdotes all day
When a country is (politically,economically, culturally, racially ) divided , keep borrowing money, and can’t even pass (edit:SIMPLE) laws what do you expect.
Says Britannia, the goddess of doing exactly that to other countries..
Get woke go broke
I thought that’s called democracy
not their land to begin with. the real people of the land are now living in poverty inside concentration camps called Indian Reservations.
Chinese say, Democracies are not agile.
COVID showed USA’s weaknesses.
When u support riots and separatists in other countries, then u should not complain when those riots happen at your own home.
Truth
China should learn yeah
America: If you fund a terrorist group to get rid of a terrorist group you funded, to get rid of a terrorist group you funded, to get rid of a terrorist group you funded.........
@biji apel They so called BLM protests were ilieagl and violant most of the time
@biji apel Its just the Media who push things up and make rumours, unlike in China were the most of the Media are Government controlled etc...
Whatever you say China being an oppressive, authoritarian regime, or one that is only boasting successes and concealing failures, it won’t change the fact China remains the top-most country most trusted by its own nationals. Its approval ratings > 90% is envied by all its western counterparts. The dramatic growth of its economy in the last 4 decades, making its the 2nd largest economy after the USA. Its ascension to the middle-income bracket while lifting nearly 800 million people from poverty. Its success in beating the covid-19 pandemic with the lowest infection and death rates among major economies. Advancements in 5G/6G, quantum computing/telecommunication, space exploration, Beidou navigational system, etc, all of which are making China one of the most competitive countries.
This only says one thing loud and clear - its socialism model with unique Chinese characteristics is one that is working, and for that matter, it is far more efficient than Western Capitalism Model where 99% of wealth is controlled by the top 1%. China is now embracing on its latest 'Common Prosperity' program, building an even bigger middle class group as well as spreading the national wealth more evenly among its nationals.
Perhaps in the not-too-distant future, China will attain its goal of national rejuvenation, regaining its leadership position in the central stage of the global arena, leading its vast population to prosperity, stability, and peace.
yes
China has a massive population and a low per capita, about the same as Mexico's per capita. Based on my limited understanding of economics, If they manage to raise that to the same level as the U.S per capita, their economy will dwarf the U.S's. That will be wild.
@@OnlyOneGedeon Couldn’t agree more with you. Some additional points: 1) China’s GDP already surpassed the USA’s GDP years ago, if purchasing power (instead of nominal GDP) basis were used; 2) plus, a lot of the USA’s GDP has come from ‘printing money’ and that is not sustainable!
True that! Let us witness the Rise of the Chinese era! Of which a peaceful era!
准确！
Precise
look at the title, you will see the reason.
someone's success is based on itself not rather than other people's failure.
With all due respect, but you're missing the big picture. America WANTED China to rise, for decades now. America ain't backing down from this great humanitarian mission any time soon.
@@joeya6795 "Great humanitarian missions", oh yeah, of course, US spurs crisis all over the world and offers itself as the solution. does America still want China to rise?
not necesaryly ie if a person loses their job because their company went bankrupt is it their fault?
@@Cecilia-ky3uw but i don't think either the US or China works for each other. they just work with each other.
@@joeya6795 I don't really get the "WANT" means
"Black cat, white cat, doesn't matter to me. I want the cat that catches the mouse!" - Deng Xiaoping
Han cat edits out black cat.
People actually didn’t care whether it called communist, socialist or an political system. So far it works great, so why we want to change to system to these fail miserably?
Now it sounds like: "Black cat, white cat, doesn't matter to me. So long as I'm in power!"
All Men and Women created by the you know "The Thing"
-Joe Biden(2020)
To paraphrase, it's not ideology that matters. Regardless of whether it's capitalism or communism, what counts are the results ie the people can have food on the table, be decently covered, kept warm with a roof over their heads, and be educated with its history and culture as foundations. To the CCP, it's NOT the PROCEDURAL matter of having multiple parties, one person one vote (universal suffrage) nor elections every 4 -5 years aka democracy as practise currently in the liberal world. For the CCP, it's the measurable OUTCOME (as defined above) that counts via its political system and structure ... regardless of how you label it .... as communism or whatever.
The guy said in the end is just a whole bunch of wishful thinking rubbish: "the West begins to reform their governments, begins to talk about the importance of the freedom ...." Well, only talk the talk, non stop ...
Yep! Talk is cheap. "Actions speak louder than words"
Its because the people making the decisions wont be alive to see the outcome. The 2 party system doesn't help, should be hundreds of parties. You can't sort every American into 2 boxes and expect everyone to agree.
@Stephen lee in the US dead people might not be able to talk but they can still vote
@Stephen lee Incredibly well put.
Wumao comemnts everywhere.
Everything described as “autocratic” in this video aptly applies to the US far better and more conclusively than China.
Your perception of the status of democracy in the two nations is mistaken. The United States is considered by most to be a democratic nation at best, and an anocracy at worst; the PRC is an authoritarian regime.
P.S. I hope you enjoyed your fifty cents :).
15:50 america just banned abortion in half the states. Thats autocracy via democracy
@@levelazn Actually, local governhood is possibly the most democratic thing you can ever have, which prevents more control from the Federal government. The Roe vs Wade situation was about letting the federal government enforce or allow the state rights on abortion,which according to constitution is illegal, as it is not a fully federal law, which nullifies the enforcement for Roe vs Wade.
@@levelazn The same thing happen in China everyday, and think a little why there are almost no voice of revolt.
Singapore Democratic? It was what inspired Deng's authoritarian capitalism in the first place.
loose mouth as usual. just like they put 'genocide' to xinjiang and tibet.
@@cheval63sg That has nothing to do with what I just said.
@@cheval63sg you have never been to xinjiang and tibet, and there was no genocide here. exprience and then give your comment
Yup Singapore was always been called authoritarian, dictatorship, and has no freedom. Until when the Americans need something from us.
Oh dear. I lived in Singapore. It’s democratic for sure. Unless you can show me facts that counter my knowledge.
America is so obsessed with china, it's embarrassing itself
They are crapping their pants!
Afraid, no. Wanting a fight, maybe
China is so obsessed with the west. They literally use westerners to legitimize their products and all Chinese propaganda on tiktok have English subtitles.
Then how come China has Wolf Warrior diplomats whose jobs is to literally harp on the West?
@@Toe_Merchant Politics
China has come a long way man. From japan's punching bag in ww2, to this...
@@levinng2004 and it's China that leads AI
@@levinng2004 ai isn’t just going to affect china lol. It’s going to affect the whole world. Everyone will be monitored and will be rendered useless for the most part. Ai will likely destroy us
@@levinng2004 well said. People tend to struggle to think like this.
PRC defeat UN in Korean War, not just today's powerful China.
To Japans nightmare
When I was in America, I felt totally unsafe. In China you will feel safe everywhere I go. Personal and family safety is the biggest Human rights to me ☺️
@@045773 unluckily , US always focus on somewhere else !
@@045773 I‘ve been to Sao Paulo and Rio on a business trip, I loved the friendly locals, loved the ocean view in Rio, but I never went out for a walk after dinner during my stay in Brazil, which was a shame.
Sent my regards to your beloved leader Winnie The Pooh.
In fact try to post a Winnie the Pooh image on Weibo and we'll how safe you really are.
@@TheBatman39 By the way it's ok to post Winnie the Pooh image on Weibo. You will only get banned when you are implying it is related to Xijing ping
I was in China once. It seemed to me they are rising through their own hard work. I may be wrong though, but i doubt it.
on them news, We were abused and suppressed by our own government, but it didn't matter, just let them think so..... we dont care
**You're absolutely correct on the 1st phase of your statement _ there is no need to doubt of your own experienced !!! **I'm sure they will highly appreciate your most faithful words.**
**DON'T FORGET & Don't Get Her Wrong [ Frankly (no bias) ] , China is not intended suddenly rises, but truly speeding revival to washout the past 150 years humiliations!!!**
In which part of the video it was mentioned that they weren't rising through their own hard work?
@@ribez101 , in the title, in case you did not see it
@@hydrohasspoken6227 oh yeah I did not see it. The way you phrase it is as if western failures are fueling their economic rise, which wasn't really the point. Since the video was more about ideology, I couldn't see the connection, it confused me.
One thing that I have learnt recently is to never be invested on another person/party failure. It can make you do despicable things.
I think US is focused on how to slow down China and rather it should focus on, how can we better country.
Note: From this video, I don’t think China approach is: How can we slow down US but rather how can we be better
True
Can’t agree more. Chinese mentality is totally different from its counterparts
Facts man if only more people can see that
China isn't betting on the USA to fail, it is actively working so it does while also strengthening itself. And if the USA actually worked against China, it would be much better. Half of the situation the USA is in is because people with power and influence bow to chinese money and hand over anything they ask for, because they (unlike the chinese) have no love whatsoever for their country. And many foolish people who dislike to think or do basic research just blindly follow what corrupt celebrities and companies say. There's no way a country can survive like that.
@@aracnodoggo4812 lies
Stop being so obsessed with the 'China '. Stop blaming your own government for everything including your own laziness. Invest the trillions on infrastructure and education of millennials. That's your future.
United States and European Union are two extremely weak and declining subjects. One has an astronomic national dept, fighting numerous super expensive wars (same as Vietnam was in 1970's) in Afganistan, Iraq, Syria and Ukraine, declining industry, collapsing infrastructure and vast trade deficit with China. The other is one of the most impotent and incompetent political Union on the face of the planet earth that is extremely fragmented along the national, religious, political and ideological lines. Has already experienced Brexit (and will probably experiance similar exits in future). And has huge problems with Islamic migration from Africa and Arabia.
On the other hands China has close friends, trading partners and allies all across the globe (from independent nations in Europe like Russia, Hungary, Turkey...all the way to Indonesia and ASEAN).
@@northernstar3960 How much did you get paid to write that
@Sister Supersonic American zoomers are hopeless at least on tiktok and other social media.
also invest in science and technologies is the same important as education.
@Sister Supersonic im a zoomer, i can confirm
It's not about making a more efficient political system, it's about making one that people want to live in...
The Chinese want to live how they do now, 95% of then don't want it to change.
@@haroldbn6816 that is why they start to have the "let it rot" mentality in the younger generation right?
Civilisations rise and fall, it’s just a repeat of history. There’s nothing new under the sun.
@@jkdm27 china was no 2 , india was no1 one until 1750.
Yes, the Chinese know this better
@@monarch3724 India wasn’t even a country before the British conquered all the tribes and created British India.
wait what? why is yours still up? when will it fall. becosed i personaly feel like you are an old nation that just got bigger and bigger.
@@jkdm27 lol what time was China number One ???????
There's a time when almost every west media were busy saying China will collapse ,but now I don't know where those theories???
They belong in the trash.
Just like the West says their three gorges dam will collapse EVERY SINGLE YEAR. The West always wishes the misery to others and actually participated in most of it. Be it be in Africa, South America or Asia.
Now is the brand new ‘China Threaten’ theories!
They won't collapse while they own slaves.
actually it was a Chinese scholar that came up with the collapse theory. It's become a meme on Chinese Internet. We jokingly say that he did that on purpose to fool the Westerners. Worked quite well if you ask me XD
if you're so confident with democracy why are you feeling so threatened LOL
who fears more to show their citizens the outside world? America or China
I want to challenge you but damn....I can't think of any words.....
@Duffy63 The part of the internet that owns by US companies and censored by them, take youtube as an example.
@Duffy63 Just think about it, how many countries in world owns the big data of their own citizens
and think about how many Chinese have passports and have travelled overseas
@Duffy63 The point is, internet is not truly owned by the people around the world. The service providers are from different countries to which China's laws are not applied.
It's common misconception that Chinese government banned Google, RUclips, Twitter and etc., whereas the fact is that these big names refused to comply with Chinese laws when operating in China. Does this make sense?
@@edenli9208 at lease the Chinese know about the censorship, unlike Americans, who believe their access to information is unadulterated
It is very funny that when I started to contact the Western media, the Western world thought that China would collapse tomorrow
But five years have passed, and we have become stronger 😂😂😂
Initially, I felt that the CCP was lying, but now, I feel that compared to the Western media, the CCP is the cleanest, cleanest, and most efficient government in the world
The entirety of Shanghai would beg to differ
@@AGP335 says the crumbling westerner 👏👏👏
@@sayitnow7748 there are other countries except US
@@AGP335 sorry bro I live in Shanghai and nope
@@Lucas-vr1qr Ah. Well at least your VPN is working well!
How many times do us Chinese people need to repeat ourselves? We are not interested in replacing the western political system. How about you can have your political system and we can have ours? I don’t see how this stop us from doing business with each other.
@@sggamingzone4284 Maybe you should actually visit China and see for yourself, try talk to real people in China, not just the China from your news
@@sggamingzone4284 Could you just pay a visit to China?
@@12315yh what about the Uyghurs
I don't think China will "replace" democracy, democracies will do that themselves over time.
@@brendanrodgers9753 Uyghurs get treated better than American Blacks by the Police and Karens
One of the biggest failures of western countries I observed is that instead of acknowledging and working on their own social, political or racial problems, they tend to blame all problems on someone else or divert the focus by making new problems just because it's easier. Fundamentally it's lacking of accountabilities.
I believe competition is essential for improvements, why do we always have to spilt the world by ideologies such as democracy vs autocracy, capitalism vs communism, liberalism vs conservatism? Wouldn't the world be a better place if everyone can learn from their counterparty, compete freely and evolve?
Exactly as you mentioned, always easier to blame on others than to resolve the problem. If the west is going to fall, it wouldn’t be from China, it would be from itself, yet they will for sure blame on China…
@@madiosc Just like athletes racing on tracks, it just doesn't make sense to say because some one runs slower so he/she makes the others run faster, or in this video's term, fueling the others' speed.
China isn't that much better. Heaps of corruption.
China will have a big issue soon with its housing bubble as well as other internal issues.
@@GameFuMaster this is the mentality that has failed the west. Perfect specimen!
They got used to setting rules n become too complacent to grow in their own expense.
America has nothing to hide. So why is Assange in jail?
and snowden
And Fort Detrick
If the trade war fails, there will be a pandemic in China. Every step the United States takes is digging its own grave. The United States thinks that the whole world is a fool
1.4 billion chinese r in jail. Why?
@@offred6013 America actually has the most incarcerated population in the world. They're mostly blacks and Latinos.
You are wrong. It is US who's wondering about communism or capitalism. We Chinese only focus on one thing: developping.
The politicians keeps talking about democracy in the US, but are there really democracy for the non-elites?
social unrest is quite a threat to any society when the poor gets all enti elitist chaos will eventually come at the same time we cannot ignore indeed the social inequalities between everyone as for democracy theres still enough of it although not perfect it's persevered for many many years
Nah , more like a zio-cracy..
@@Cecilia-ky3uw
Yah for those years we have had an active socialist party. F**k usa
50 years ago, USA: "China is collapsing."
30 years ago, USA: "China is collapsing."
10 years ago, USA: "China is collapsing."
Present, USA: "China is collapsing."
....
Who is collapsing?
China's nominal GDP will surpass the U.S in 5 years and military in 15 years.
@@wulei7366 Nominal GDP is not as accurate as PPP. In reality, China has already surpassed US in GDP.
If the Chinese believe the words of the United States and collapse, it will cause countless deaths. The Chinese cannot bear the mistakes made by the United States and therefore remain vigilant towards the United States. This behavior is considered by the United States to be China's mistakes. Many countries and nations in this world have lost their lives, money, and future because of the "mistakes" of the West. Some ethnic groups have even been unable to speak out because they have been extinct. They are buried under the soil of the United States, Australia and Canada.
@@wulei7366 military is supposed to be set for 2300 in navy and air force which as an American is very unnecessary
It looks more like the other way round, how long can the USA's plutocracy last?
The best way to describe Bloomberg's effort: Bloomberg tried to interview a lot of BELIEVERS, but avoided to interview any analyst.
Can anyone of us imagine the quality of life the Americas would have if the USA tended to its own affairs and leave the other regions of the world o tend to theirs. Personally I’d just settle for a US high speed rail service.
You and me both, if the USA would just focus on it’s internal issues, it could match Norway
No not match Norway, but surpass Norway.
It would surpass Norway if Americans weren't so dumbly attached to the purest capitalism. Thanks an issue of people, not of government.
not so much better i assume, US intervention and unipolar hegemony kept the world a relatively stable place after the end of the 2 world wars and the cold war, replacing it with lesser conflicts around the globe
@@sleepless2541 would you say that the vietnam and the creation of isis and international Islamic terror were peaceful
Since WHEN the US has a true democracy?!
Never
Right! Since when?
true democracy requires an educated public, most americans are high school grads. hence no true democracy
@@levelaznbut more people are going to college than ever before
@@mohamedsaid9416 wrong. College education stayed the same at 30 percent for the last 60 years
I never saw China pose Thier model on other countries except America .every country have the right to choose itself which system they want .
@Wrulol Both territories are Chinas,Tiber platau and the Island are claims of China, which btw Taiwan also claims Tibet.
@@SVTDI Taiwan is republic of China yes, never communist china.
@@MrmilesAllister Taiwan is China, the PRC is China, not hard to understand.
@@MrmilesAllister So what? Taiwan is still claiming Tibet (and mongolia)
@@MrmilesAllister It will be, soon.
The US liberated 1 million Iraqis by giving them democracy.
You mean death
Democracy is demon-crazy
And where did that bring them? Is Iraq today any better than 1980s? What about Libya? Or Afghanistan?
You forgot this /s
same as afghanistan
I love that when he mentions democracies, he forgets to mention the rest of the worlds democracies that aren’t Japan and South Korea
China and Russia: the new balance of power
More than a year after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, how has the war reshaped global politics?
Apr 17th 2023 [The Economist]
"If interested, read on. We read! Agreeing and understanding is for another department." 1:12
Even pushing aside the Chinese political system, that the USA is the beacon of democracy is ridiculous. Within the western countries, many countries are showing better performance than the USA in terms of the benefit and equality, such as north European countries. Speaking of taking care of the working class, contrary to the USA which has been abducted by the capitalists, German has a healthier and more balanced economical structure. So the problem is not about the communism or authoritarian. It’s the declined hegemony that the USA is facing.
Northern European countries are very homogeneous, there are social realities they don’t have to deal with, they are 100 times tougher on immigration, rely heavily on natural resources and have a smaller population.
@@garciapedro7554 really? Where do you live? EU countries are a huge mess!
you closed the mouth of anothers by saying this unwanted truth-wow
"Equality" isn't an aim of democracy. It is a socialist buzzword.
Democracy isn’t equality or high standards of living it’s just a political system but still the rest of what you said stands
Conclusion : There is no perfect or superior system, but which one brings the most optimum (not total) welfare for its people.
Rule by the masses is always superior by rule by the few
@@xblade11230 nowadays the usa is ruled by few
@@marceloduarte1746 The president of the US and congress are all chosen by the people
Therefore the people rule the US, not individuals
@@xblade11230 oh, of course. I'm pretty sure that the interests of the US working class is almost fully heard in the us Congress, and that big corporations don't take any advantages from the politicians in USA.
@@xblade11230 chosen by the people yet ain’t working for the people.
Fascists in USA talking about democracy. How is it democracy when you intervene in other countries matters.
US is basically an arrogant bully. Bombs every country it doesn't like, even nuked twice.
@@bobbyh4957 Yes but that country - Japan fears a world run by China. So is a natural ally of America. China wants islands currently owned by Japan
@Raman 556 Ah yes play the racial card. The Japanese are a very proud nation with a long history and culture just like China. They don't fantasize about anything more than being Japanese.
@@Andy-P 😂 They do seem themselves as white and above all other Asians. Don’t you see white nationalist going to Japan, and wanting an Ethnostate and homogeneous country like Japan. Japan mono ethnicity is because Japanese island was isolated from the rest of the world
@@jaybee4577 Yep and also Japanese rarely marry foreigners, this is why they are mostly "pure".
I've been living in China for more than 20 years. I want to point out that "one-party" or "No general election" doesn't mean that Chinese people cannot express their opinions or criticize the government. The West always tends to describe China as a nation without "freedom" and the people living there are "unhappy" under the high pressure of the central government. But the fact is actually the opposite. Chinese people are satisfied with their leader and system. They trust the government because the system enables the government to find the most capable politicians to "Serve the people" but not make the election become a ridiculous game of the rich.
Absolutely agree. I find it interesting how Chinese and people from many democratic countries have a completely different mindsets in terms of government. Eg when facing the pandemic, many people in the western countries view the measurements taken by their government such as lockdown and vaccine as a violation to liberty/human rights. However in China, people see these measurements as an inherent responsibility of the government. They think that by doing so, the government is caring about the people's live, and they willing to participate together to achieve the same goal as with the government. I think this mindset is the crucial point of why the virus has been contained so well in China, and this willingness to cooperate with the government is unseperatable with the China model.
the Chinese aren’t forcing anyone else to adopt their system. They do their own thing, the US has a problem with that because they’re being too successful.
We are the stupids idiots to buy everything made in china, making them richer and powerful and giving them all the tools to take the world.
@@dardotoscano9319 Lol tell your country to make what u use in your daily life..
@@Huuuef That's right, We reach to the point to depend and survive exclusively by everything coming fronm China, the scary part is that country is comunist imposing their rules, way of life to the rest of the world, and even indoctrinating our minds loosing our freedoms every day. making us believe that is perfectly normal.
@@Huuuef Our dependance from China become so powefull that we can not even investigate the origin of their bioweapon called Sars Covid -19, They can do whatever they want knowing that rest of the worls goverments are afraid that China can cut all the supplies and resourses if they insist on that.
@@dardotoscano9319 Lol whatever make u happy at night poor kid!
“You wouldn’t want to be in Iran during the outbreak” while his statement is true, he casually forgot to mentioned that we sanctioned them, including medicine and food, for FOLLOWING the nuclear agreement according to the IEAE. At least make an honest argument.
It's funny how in the simple Western mind, all countries that are not liberal democracies are "authoritarian". Chinese government is vastly different from Iranian gov, Venezuelan gov, Saudi gov, Jordanian gov, etc. The West cannot speak in nuance.
The exceptionals don't see them selevs as failures but they blame others for their failure , they can't swallow others taken over the empirical helms ..
typical cowboys riding donkey's..
It's amazing how human beings are effortlessly biased,. When the gentleman talks of the successes of democracies in handling covid19 he conveniently leaves out Brazil and India which are amongst the world's largest democracies and have failed extensively even when compared with the likes of Iran and the rest of the "stans". His examples of democratic successes reveal bias towards Western nations.
How are India and Brazil Western Democracies??
It’s amazing how ignorant people you can find on the internet making comments like this.
@@unlockwithjsr specially India, that is no western country.
By this standard, Russia too is a democracy.
His point was that people draw the wrong conclusion that all democracies handled Covid poorly and all authoritarian regimes handled it well.
China spends three years in building a high speed rail road. America spends 30 years in arguing about how to build the high speed rail road.
So? The US does not operate on China or world time but it's own.
"Weakness and ignorance are not barriers to survival, but arrogance is." - Liu Ci Xin
When one continue to engage in Lies to prevail over others, he will ultimately fail, as truth will triumph over falsehood. For we are intelligent humans.
Don't be fooled that china is winning. It is not era of common people of China. It is actually era of artificial intelligence. The ongoing trade war is just an excuse for rich people to make artificial intelligence more powerful because they say they need to compete. But it doesn't matter who is leading artificial intelligence because artificial intelligence have machine learning to replace skilled and unskilled workers. AI can download knowledge of university students and it means they can replace university students too.
@@Sam-us8qt then it augurs well for all communists.
@@literung8767 some people may think people of china can grow food. Don't be fooled by it because artificial intelligence can control robots to grow food too, it can sell cheaper too. Imagine farmers need to take bank loans but when farmers cannot pay the debts because ai sell food cheaper than them, the banks will take away their lands and the land will goes to the rich people. AI only make rich people richer and AI can do more than just simple jobs because AI can download knowledge so AI can replace skilled workers too.
your speech really makes sense.
The US only became the leader because they weren't leading in combating the conflicts that led to the two wars. Actually the US benefited very much from the two wars.
That's an extremely narrow and poor line of thinking.
So did CCP
No, America DID NOT benefit from the two wars. And China is about to make the very same mistake. No nation has ever survived it's own 'Empire status". China wont either. It's simply not possible.
A better way of looking at it is that the west had cultural advantages which enabled it to come out on top. The question is whether the countries of east asia will rise due to being strong where the west isn't.
@@scottenosh4548 Wow, Europe in tatters and allowed to fall to American influence while the British Empire, a potential rival on the world stage, is dismantled and becomes a second rate power. Totally not beneficial to the US.
how about reframing the narrative as "How Chinese successess are fueling China's rise?"
No, it's sound positive, they never did that
Chinese success is due largely to captured american capitalists. If you ask apple who they really want to work for, they will tell you, if they are honest, communists. Americans are the real unsung heroes of chinese success.
thats too pro China
I think the point of the title is to say the west needs to improve itself not to degrade the achievements of china
The Chinese success is actually more about east Asian culture, not democracy or authoritarianism.
We can look at another issue that the Asians have been doing much better than the west, especially America: drugs.
In China, and all other countries that have been influenced by Chinese culture in the region, have very strict laws against drugs. Users would be sent to forced withdrawal, drug dealers can be put to death. This is completely unimaginable for westerners.
Unfair Democracy has taken many lives
yea but mao killed 45 million in great leap forward
@@gokulkrishna7173 same as recently new claimed that 1million xinjiang citizens in jails. Just some claims made by westerners in order to collapse China.
@@celine7511 proof?
any news articles about that
my reason has some proof since there was a book about that
@@celine7511 I guess all those "xinjiang citizens" who escape to turkey and Pakistan are lying about their missing relatives and persecution.
@@gokulkrishna7173 lol, a Japanese here pretend to be a victim, forget massacres you made to Singapore, Philippines and Indonesia?
When two empires go to war, it’s got nothing to do with ideology. It’s simply down to spheres of influence or simply put, who holds the most power.
It is not China but the US that is threatening the world with war. The US needs enemies to justify the military expenditures that concentrate our country's wealth in the hands of the few.
@Robert Jameson American Bot
@@denisrichu5697 okay Chinese bot
@@user-ll9nu8fb7j Not OK, US bot
And as a country leader they were forced to take aggressive action otherwise they were blamed
Which system is correct. Who cares? Most importantly, people in the county feel safe, happy and harmony.
No. We need to get work in the west, something has to change!
@Jdjdjd Ridid Europe is not safe, just like the rest of the world. You have to understand that just because it's Europe, doesn't mean Russia and the wars in the Middle East isn't a problem. And in fact unemployment wouldn't be an all time low in Europe without COVID. Because in 1930's Germany, 100% of the population was employed... And also very happy, because all those who were not happy disappeared.
I do have to point out that measuring safety and harmony is quite a dangerous metric. The perfect system according to this model, would be a system where feeling anything other than safe happy is illegal, and every group that is perceived a "threat" to their group are wiped out, and everyone are educated to believe that their lives are perfect.
@Jdjdjd Ridid Lucky for Europe to get what they think works for them, also lucky for China to get what works for them, now the problem is that the west want China to follow their direction, the Chinese are smart enough to choose to learn selectively, they don’t need a 100% copy.
@@koka1571 US has created and pushed a lot of Refugees from Middle East to Europe to make Europe ' unsafe ' .
US is the main source of most of the chaos at present ........
@Jdjdjd Ridid hmm... I didn't know that. But earth is the first most safest place on earth. So you clearly don't live on earth.
中国成功的秘诀：
1. 一党制，一党制效率很高，当然做坏事效率也很高。
2.在精英层的小范围的民主，让聪明的人来决策，让中国的大脑不但高效，而且尽可能少犯错。信息社会想搞独裁很难。
3.国有企业，国有企业就是一个人的四肢，没有听话的四肢，你做事肯定很不顺利。有些事情挣钱不是第一位的，比如高铁，私企肯定不会去干这种赔钱的生意。
4.中文的使用，中文是表意文字，虽然各地方言不同，但是文字一样，沟通无障碍，这也是中国能保持大一统的原因，而欧洲碎片化。团结就是力量，统一也是力量，对于潜在的敌人，美国一定要让他碎片化消除威胁，比如苏联，南斯
拉夫。
5.中国人绝大多数是无神论者，不相信来世，所以必须全力以赴过好这一辈子，工作的动力来自对财富的渴望。
当然上面1,2,3,5条，在西方国家看来，全都是政治不正确。西方媒体用放大镜仔细检查中共是件好事，可以督促他们更好的为人民服务。15:40 拜登关于民主和专治的讲话实在是很幼稚，不过西方国家老百姓就喜欢这一套。
China: Sorry, I ll catch up with you later. Got to go
Western Countries: Don’t go too fast or I’ll break your legs
The problem is when people compare Communism to Democracy. The comparison should more properly be between Communism and Capitalism. There's nothing stopping a Communist society from being democratic. Communism and Capitalism are economic systems. Democracy and Totalitarianism are another thing all together. It is possible to have a totalitarian Capitalist state and it is also possible to have a democratic Communist state. It's a mistake to equate Democracy with Capitalism and Totalitarianism with Communism.
Let's be serious, China is not communist at all. Yes, they have a controlled economy, but that is far from communism. It is even more close to capitalism. But capitalism under government regulation.
China is practising Socialism + Capitalism. This has been put into China's constitution, and it calls "Socialism with Chinese Characteristics". China is NOT a Communist society. If you don't understand this, you don't under China.
I think the interesting part is so many people equating democracy with voting, especially popular voting. Does voting always signify democracy? Does no voting always signify no democracy?
The US should look at their problems honestly instead of blaming China for her woes.
I agree
17:27 - "No two leaves in the world are identical, and no histories, cultures or social systems are the same. Each country is unique, with its own history, culture and social system, and none is superior to the other." - President Xi
A clear and simple statement, yet the West failed to understand and forced their far from perfect democracy system to others.
So that others are doomed to fail by copying their system without
the favourable conditions that prospered USA
Tell Winnie the Poo it was inspiring.
@@superleipoman
haha...keep hating, while China is busy progressing.
it's all because of arrogance
"you can't blame China on how the pie is cut and distributed in US"
one of the vid here said that
Work hard slaves
You miss the most important thing: align the interest of the party with the people.
The Democrat and Republican parties have betrayed the American people, selling them out for corporate profits
Politicians and mainstream medias are all backed by the top 1%. It doesn't matter how the 99% vote, the 1% will rule, and their interest will never align with the 99%.
In China we call these volunteers in hospitals 白衣天使and白衣战士,which means The Angel in White and The Warriors in White. They come from all over China, some medical staff, some soldiers, some just normal citizens, answering the nation’s call for help and organization. Many of them are ones of the new generation (born in 2000s), who many consider to be young foolish and lazy people. But they bravely stepped forward, not seeing family for months, fainting from the heat in their protection gear, faces swelling up from long hours with masks, hard work in exchange for the happiness and security of their homeland and their fellow people. They proved those accusing voices wrong, and in doing so earned all of our respects. Salute to them❤️
Singapore being so successful is because of its one party system for the past 50 years.
and what about India?😂😂
whts their party system
@@vanessaaventura 2000 political parties who never agree with each other
A taxi driver in Singapore pointed out to me all the tall sky scrapers and explained to me how each one was owned by some corrupt politician or relative of a politician. He had to drive a taxi 6 days a week 12 hours a day to earn a pittance.
@@Andre_XX dude , check out the tent city in LA or west coast, go find out who’s corrupting
For once, people will finally ask:
"Is democracy really the best for our particular country?"
Democracy only works when the entire population is well educated, when there is culture and respect among one another.
Democracy in the west isn't working and will not work because everyone is different. Has different cultures, believe in different gods, beliefs on what's right or wrong, everyone looks different.
How long can one another live together with opposing forces, you can only respect differences for so Long until you can no longer avoid confrontation.
@@Sora_Nai true, social solidarity is strained the more diverse and pluralistic a society is.
@Oscar Strokosz China is democratic? Ha ha! One party rule is not democracy.
@@TrendyStone not to defend china but does two-party system any better? when two party essentialy does the same thing on the things that really matters just different populist promises and policies (that didn't really set in stone) just to secure next period's vote count.
@@FathinLuqmanTantowi The US two party system works great. It’s self correcting and keeps fringe groups in check. Study a little American history. The two party system…with all its flaws…is a feature, not a bug.
Completely wrong approach from The West and the US. Instead of trying hard to prevent China from growing, they need to focus more in improving themself.
why is china still classified as a developing nation if it claims to be on par with america
@@Cam-nq8br nothing wrong with that. One of the reason I know is that they claimed to be "developing" to benefit from WTO's policy. The US and other member are heavily against that claiming that China is developed.
@@Cam-nq8br and if you just visit China, you will be shocked how modern they are. Given your hatred against them, I would advise you not to go in order to protect you from the truth.
@@user-zy2nw3ug6q i get your sacarsm but it wont get you anywhere. China is defenitely not a dream nation (I know for a fact that there are coruption, injustice, racism). But, they are getting to their goals by hardwork and technology no matter how much hate you blindly put out.
**You're absolutely correct on your statement !!!**
**I'm sure the truly Chinese will highly appreciate your most faithful words.**
**DON'T FORGET & Don't Get Her Wrong [ Frankly (no bias) ] , China is not intended suddenly rises, but truly speeding revival to washout the past 150 years humiliations!!!**
The wisdom of the Chinese people is not just material rational civilization. Wisdom in culture and art is also worthy of admiration and learning. Compared with many hegemonic countries, he prefers to enhance his competitiveness and do his own thing well, so that his perseverance is in the world of civilization.
Chinese no smarter than anyone else.
@@MrCleitus no they’re not. But they’re a lot more United.
@@MrCleitus IQ higher
"know the enemy and know yourself, and you can fight a hundred battles with no danger of defeat"
if you are failing to do so, then the result will be crystal clear.... simple as that~
And if you really wise you even don't need to be involved in battles, victories or defeats.
how about don't fight, work together. both can thrive. do we really need to find out who is the strongest?
@@vladimirseven777 I think u r right, one haven't fought a war for 40+ years ,the other one fighting basically every other day until recently…
@@eternalobi For leaders of a country, yes.
Great quote！知己知彼 百战不殆
In China, I can hanging around outside in the midnight. In the US, I don't even allow my children to go out late.
🙄
What state? Many states are open, where as LA just closed back down. It also depends where in China, the virus is alive and well in China.
@@thomasalvarez6456 the fact is that virus is alive in western countries everywhere🥳🥳🥳
Unless they voice any negative opinion about the state that is
@@jiahewen3724 so is China, but we won't hear about it.
To join a party in US, you just need to register. To join CCP, you need consistent performance merit and the will to serve the people. When disaster strikes, have you seen party members are volunteering to go to help in US ? Therefore, I rather question the purpose of US parties since any party in US is not for the people in this core. The election is a procedure which can be influenced by media and by propaganda (Yes, election slogan) of parties. The life of common citizens have not changed for years.
Well said. Masses had have always been cattles to be herd
他们只在乎怎么骗取人民手中的选票。然后继续剥削这些民众。既得利益只属于那些政客。比如最大傀儡瞌睡拜登。
A single party system that requires loyalty is a perfect system to create corruption.
It's members only for the family of CCP officials.
@@fallen546 democrats vs republicans will soon go to a civil war.. karens vs karens!
Americans are giving themselves way too much credit for China' success.
Singapore a democracy ? That is highly questionable. Failure to mention Taiwan.
17:18
Yeah agreed. They forgot to mentioned that Taiwan is such a failure.
You know what a joke is? Singapore is rated higher in democracy index than countries like India and Indonesia 😂 eventhough in Singapore there is no freedom of press, and the emergency law ISA (Internal Security Act) is still pretty much alive. Its a joke. Basically if youre an allied to america youre a "democracy" country 😂
@@harukrentz435 What nonsense are you spouting. We do HAVE freedom of speech. i sense dome salty butter cookie here.
One of the things I hear that’s commonly repeated by western media is how the cultural revolution and agriculture reforms were an economic failure for China. While if you are judging from the economic perspective, that is true. But, that is where the point is missed. The point of the reforms weren’t to make China rich at the time, it was to change the culture of bourgeoisie and elitism to “re-set” the nation together so it wouldn’t grow apart, so people were United in mind, spirit, and actions. Money wasn’t on their mind, because that wasn’t important for the whole at the time. It was not about the individual but creating a new culture. This wasn’t just communism that caused this but they were searching for this new culture since the early 1900s with the decline of the Qing Dynasty, and inability of the old system from protecting Chinese peoples and lands. It’s hard to interpret another system if you don’t understand the history and context. Every analysis I hear from the west is from the Western perspective and applying western understandings and their own beliefs onto China. That in itself is a fallacy. If you are a plumber and judging everything like a broken window from the plumbing perspective you are not getting the whole picture and misconstruing facts to fit into your own narrative.
Excellent point
@@AvelierPlays india need one
Economic failure in the sense that millions of people died. I bet that was an humbling experience indeed. It is hard to grow apart when one simply cuts off the part growing away.
Well said. The video mentioned that China government forced a lot of young men and women to rural area...Well, that's because the cities can't offer enough jobs to young men then, it was a strategic decision to let them work in rural so they can be feed at least, and come back once more jobs can be offered with the economic growth in cities. Collectivistic economy model in China rural area at that time allows Government to have the ability that can arrange millions of jobless young men/women to work in the land of the rural. If the land is private owned by farmer that wouldn't be possible.
1989 China would have become 2011 Libya if nothing was done.
It is easier to control people when they are poor. Now that they have basic necessities, Chinese people will explore freedom, expression of thought. With no diversity and immigration tolerated, new ideas will die. It will be interesting to see how the CCP then repeats the Tianmen Square massacre.
I would say the eyeopener in recent decades is not so much China but how the US itself has changed.
It is no longer the utopia of freedom that I grew up respecting but a divided nation split along the different interests of the Uber rich who own the media(including social media and Bloomberg) who control the narrative competing against each other.
spot on
Exactly, america is the biggest threat to this world.
@@xhaolee1920 people are more likely to turn against their government when they are poor. How many violent revolutions happened in countries with a high standard of living?
The more a government improves the lives of its people (which is it's main job), the more loyal the people will be.
Love and support China 🇨🇳💙🇮🇶😘😘😘
He mentioned Australia, New Zealand, South Korea and Singapore - all countries are basically islands (including South Korea because the border with North Korea isnt crossed at all). And you can handle pandemic much better when you are an island than an inland country. Oh, btw Brazil, UK and other countries in the EU are democracies and look how they failed.
the man is deluded; he concluded that is better to not be Iran, North Korea based on nothing (I specifically replayed that part several times thinking I missed the reason why he said that)
He conveniently omitted Vietnam.
The amount of self hatred by people living in western countries in this comment section is astonishing. Need I remind you, that the only reason you're even able to discuss these things is that you live in a democracy?
And that's about it. People talk, march, protest, vote, and yet Afghanistan, Syria, Iraq, the financial crisis, covid and Trump happened. More are on the way, and few of them are because of China. It makes this whole video absurd - pointing finger at China, saying it "promotes" its model and questioning its sustainability...does little in sorting your own house out. Anxiety and fear is making people losing ability to concentrate and on prioritize on the urgent.
Plenty of western tankies and philotyrants, sadly thats nothing new.
That's one thing in which I believe we should be more like China. In the end both China, America and their allies are countries fighting for their own interests. China's restrictive system gives them a huge advantage to do pretty much whatever they want without internal opposition that the US and Europe don't have.
There’s nothing wrong with self reflection and admitting that there are flaws in your system it’s the only way to make things better.
China does this very well… they identify their deficiencies and take action to improve.
@@Dfgbuiiyyyybb bfffffffffffffff... 🤣🤣 Tiananmen square anyone? Is that how China self reflects?
Every western, anti-communist trope in one video presented as an "analysis". The downfall of the western "democracy" isn't coming from competition overseas, its coming from its own internal contradictions and failure to deliver a stable life for its people.
Agreed, the last part of this video is a strong indication of what would be best for all western countries.
Dumb comment. Get educated, avoid addiction, stay out of jail. That’s it…and it’s pretty darn easy to have a great life in the US.
USA: the rich controls politician
CHN: politician controls the rich
If the Florida collapsed building happened in China,there would be over thousand rescuing crew came and dig with basic tool with hand.
Yep. As a Chinese, what happened to Florida building in unimaginable in China.
@AOA S Florida people eat bats too
China has mandatory period for obsolescence of buildings, so even your question's precondition does not exist.
@@zhongxingjin846 Those random RUclips videos of Chinese buildings collapsing because of poor conditions were all fake then?
@@theroman2130 At least there won't be only 5 people in the rescuing crew pretend they are rescuing like Florida.
Go visit an American city center, then go visit a Chinese city center. That will tell you everything you need to know.
As an Indian , we want china to collapse 😅
@@karankapoor2701 As a Chinese, we want India to grow and achieve the same economic growth like China. That’s might be the difference of these two countries.
@@humphreywu9039 you mean by grabbing other countries land and bullying them and illegally occupying Tibet and HK
@@karankapoor2701 keep fooling yourself. Don't go and fight corruption in your country. So, at least, it can experience a sensible growth rate in the coming century.
Else, the only thing, your country may be able to achieve, is simply an explosive increase in population and birth rate, but definitely not in economy size.
Man, a battle between state capitalists and liberal capitalists sounds dystopian af.
The government works against itself in four year cycles. Democrats come in 4 years progress, Librals come in and reverse it.
This report neglects the main cause of US and Western decline: financialized capitalism and plutocracy.
The bold guy ( sorry, don’t know his name)’s talking is full of prejudice.
Lies don’t last forever.
Some ppl believe that by telling a lie hundred time it will become the truth... Lol...
Unless you own the media in your country like the CCP.
@@boingbryan8123 Correct, Westerners strongly believe that people believe when the lies are repeated many many lies.
@粉絲 propaganda 101 - accuse your enemy of what you are doing - if anyone does brainwashing and propaganda, it is the CCP.
@粉絲 what's the lie? Genuinely curious.
China's success is not fueled by Western failures, it is fueled by our hardwork.
"偷"的努力?
It's based on Western education and western investments.
@@nasu-o3y 偷都能偷到第二你气不气？
@@nasu-o3y , 偷？你哪来的証据証明偷啊？你什麽年代的？旧時代可以乱指責别人, 并且不需証据, 現在是21世紀了, 认清事實吧, 虽然中國依然還在發展阶段, 但不影响中國人民努力學習向上發展的毅力
@@neezhenchui6991 Isnt RUclips banned in China? Does Daddy Xi know you are here?
It is common that when you find something infallible as it is, you wish somehow something goes wrong from within so that you do not have to change your way of thinking.
China's economy is a bubble
It is easier to control people when they are poor. Now that they have basic necessities, Chinese people will explore freedom, expression of thought. With no diversity and immigration tolerated, new ideas will die. It will be interesting to see how the CCP then repeats the Tianmen Square massacre.
@Tim Loo Friendly fire.
@@xhaolee1920 I think this is the same thing the West has been saying for over five decades now mate.
Who's quote?
And one year later the Zero COVID-19 policy collapses & Xi is Chairman for life.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
We don't have a democracy. We have an oligarchy who benefit from Chinese mercantilism.
The analysis is too ideological. Ideology is mostly just used to get people riled up enough to get into a fight, it does not do much to help understand what is actually happening.
I beg to differ. We all know what is actually happening in the world, it is all in the news however, what is behind all that is happening is largely due to the country's concept of such ideology adopted, which is a sensitive word for the west that has been overly use to dictate "which ideology is the best" instead of understand all the pros and cons of ideology and come to embrace the differences of system. Unless if you are questioning the history and origin of ideology, that is a different story in this discussion.
Glad you’ve noticed what mainstream media loves to do.
Nothing but an agenda.
@@JustinLBK I am not sure we do all know what is actually happening in the world. A lot of things are underreported. Other things are widely reported, but in a misleading way. Occasionally we are blatantly lied to.
In general I think that ideology of all forms is typically used to try to persuade people go to war against some adversary. The truth is never ideological. The truth is not a crusader.
If you know that
Then you know to eat the small amount of meat around the bones
And leave bones for others to fight over.
@@TheLabecki Hi
You seriously put your own editor in the video to give his opinions like he's some sort of expert? 🤡
No expert wanted to back their claim, the segment with the editor In chief felt like they just took a recording of the editor in chief rambling on about democracy superiority during their lunch break
Exactly.....f*^k bloomberg john mickletwait.... at 11:00
Singapore is also partly authoritarian country, why didn't he chose India ?. India is the most populated democratic country. How did they fare in during this covid pandemic ?. Bloody hypocrite, the west is getting worse and worse trying to spin something to their favor when the evidence clearly suggest otherwise
There are inaccuracies by your guest speaker. China did NOT become a republic under the Communist revolution of 1949, this was 3 decades earlier; It forced the last Qing boy emperor Pu Yi, to abdicate in 1912, with the early republic under it's first President Sun Yat-sen.
Deng Xiaoping was one of the greatest political and government leaders of all time. Very few people can claim that they have affected not only their nation, but the world, as much him. He is easily on par with the Founding Father's in America, and should be studied by all people interested in politics and governance. The fact that most people in the west do not know his name is a true shame; we could learn a lot from him.
He is studied. But in the West studious people do not govern, rich people do.
Your point is interesting. Deng Xiaoping was a great statesman and strategist. He experienced many wars and political struggles in his life. And successfully grasped the power of a country, and chose a correct path for China at a critical point in time. He is a legend in his own right.
US is always judging other nation from its own, lot of times, selfish perspective: 1) China never intended to export its system (one system only fits its special condition) to other countries, IT IS THE US that feels can not dictate its own system onto China; 2) US always blame others for its failure, so it thinks that China's success is due to Western's failure. NO, China's success is because Chinese government adopted the social and economic policies that fits China and hard-working from Chinese people. By the same token, the decline of the US is not because of China, it is solely its own problem. China doesn't invade, doesn't sanction, doesn't arrest entrepreneur, academics from US. IT IS TIME for US to CLEARN ITS OWN MESS!
The example of Hong Kong and the threats to Taiwan destroyed your argument
@@beto8493 Learn some history, First HK and Taiwan is China's territory, secondarily China is flexible enough to let people in there keep their own ways of life (One country two systems). Only those want to be independent are stopped.
This video represents a western point of view. So what we get is a one-sided point of view.
I dont know there is a lot of truth in this video and they dont make propaganda
The fact that they have this relatively neutral video by Western media standard is because they start to recognize China's success and the impact on their claim.
@@domitravel795an incomplete truth is a lie. For example, London is the most monitored city in the world. But in this video, it only show camera in China. Obviously, they want to mislead you. There are many similar examples in this video.
@@shylockjohnson2076 "Most monitored city in the world" means nothing... it is just one city. China contains most of the surveillance cameras in the world. It is how they keep full control on their population. This video is actually very unbiased and relies on facts.
"According to industry researcher IHS Markit, at the end of 2019 there were 770 million surveillance cameras in China, and this was expected to exceed 1 billion by the end of 2021"
I'd love to hear the chinese point of view
OH I FORGOT! The CCP won't allow me to see what real chinese people think!
As a Chinese, China has many problems, but problems and achievements coexist. I often scold Xi jinping at home, but we don't seek to replace him unless he can't solve the Taiwan issue in the next five years.
America is more heading towards an oligarchy rather than a democracy these days (on the federal level at least)
Heading? You’re arrived since the 19th century. Remember the robber baron era? That never really went away
Yup, an oligarchy of the rich who manipulate the political class. But it can be argued, that's how America was originally designed--to be a democracy for the elite while spouting enlightened rhetoric to the poor.