You can hear in his voice on his sons video just before he killed them that something was wrong, I mean listen to how he was saying his dogs name, He said it like he was saying the dogs name to make it seem like he was genuinely looking for the dog but was preparing for what he's about to do.
The boat crash was the first domino in line and when it fell there was no stopping the downfall of Alex. My heart breaks for Mallory Beach and her family and friends.
Mallory brought the entire family down The entire family is corrupt I personally think the mom pushed the housekeeper down the stairs I think buster is involved in stephan's death Paul killed Mallory And Alex killed his wife and son And let's not forget Alex's brother removed the guns from the home... The entire Mordough bloodline is questionable
Lord these demons have access to all this money ' that could help out so many out BUT they just do evil ' yet im here and humble and just waiting on my break..ilove you O'lord ' I'll help myself but also many struggling....
@3BK235YI agree with you and the reasons behind why they do it are all illogical. These types of individuals are selfish, impulsive, and irrational giving way for their emotions to control them. They don't seem to fully think things through and realize there are consequences for their actions. Some think they're smart enough to get away with it which shows their lack of real intelligence and common sense. This applies as well to the murderers who are articulate and educated.
Because their assumption is always that they can outsmart the police and have zero consequences and instead sympathy that they can continue to use to manipulate people. Plus the above things stated like life insurance
The second one makes me sick, the fact that the daughter took her father's side and stayed silent about 5 months knowing what happened to her mother. She is sick like her Father.
Her father is the only parent she has left and is not uncommon for adult children to side with their father in these cases ... HE$ the breadWINner ~ THE KING of the CASTle ~.
@@WindDancer435i might understand that if she is not present and did not help her father in killing her mother...but she did help her father...and their conversations in the phone???...uh uh...!!..
@@Hashslingingslasherrrrrrhe does he is living with the housekeeper Blanca . She testified and did a great job . She’s a very impressive lady . I’ve watched her testimony several times . She has Bubba .
Diminished returns, the more you're exposed to something the less satisfied you are. So people that can get or do anything at the drop of a hat need more and more to feel excitement or enjoy anything. Then once you've done and have it all your just left with a feeling of disappointment and frustration. It's why money can't actually buy sustainable happiness. It can make you feel secure, it can buy you toys but how long until you're board of those?
@@mom.left.me.at.michaels9951 Just a question: so how does this explain why 'allegedly' people with less money are 'satisfied'? I mean, what is the fundamental difference? At which point in the accumulation of things or doing activities, does this change for any given person? I hope my question makes sense. I think some people with wealth are just as happy as some people without it. In the Murdaugh case, I think they enjoyed their wealth and family life and ties as much as anybody else. Clout they may have pursued, but I think wealth just came naturally for them. P.S. Did anyone try and buy you at Michaels? lol.
That sentence for Karrie was too light. I know she was manipulated by her father. But one to three years isn't punishment. She knew what she was doing. She had other choices. Including saving her mother's life.
2nd episode: the dad knew exactly which one of his daughters had his psychopathic tendencies. That woman knew how to lie as easily as breathing, cool as a cucumber like her father for the most part.
Judge Newman . He deserves an award . He still took the commitment of this trial so serious . As it was three weeks after his own son passing away. Consummate professional 👌🏾
All I can say is I pray for everyone involved including the girl who lost her life in the boat accident Paul Murdock caused. God be with the family of Mallory Beach.
@@gennamcgill4066 yep! It was WWIII in that house because Paul kept finding Alec's stashes of pills, telling Maggie and flushing them. Also, I don't buy Alec taking 60 pills a day - he wouldn't have a liver in three months doing that and he said it went on for two decades? Nah, there's a ton of money somewhere.....
I didn't even know such a thing exists in the land of the great/brave. That's animal abuse, I thought 1st world country should know better. And yet I live in 3rd world country and my dogs are all over our sofas and sofa beds . I am on the floor, and my dogs are on the sofas 😂😂😂😂😂 .. Glad this guy is caught. Hopefully, their dogs are treated better.
😢when your Dad, the one who should protect you, messes with your head so badly.....i feel for this Girl. But her Mom? Can't imagine how betrayed she must have felt in her last moments! Rest in Peace, Michelle❤❤❤❤❤
Poor Mallory and her family. It’s bad enough that Paul killed her, but then Alec tried to use her death as an excuse for the murders he committed. It’s truly appalling
Great episode. But I am surprised you left out one of the most compelling pieces of evidence, which was the way Creighton closed the case against Alex. In Alex’s interviews, when he walked through the timeline of the night of the murders, he describes checking the bodies and then says he called 911. But his car’s data indicated the time he came to a stop at the kennels. And comparing this time with the time of his 911 call, it was clear that there was no time to check the bodies before calling 911. (The logical inference is that as soon as he pulled up, he called 911 because he already knew they were dead, given that he shot them before racing to his Mother’s.) Alex tried to reinterpret his responses in the interviews, but it was futile. He was caught in yet another lie.
He def didn’t have to walk up to see if the bodies were dead???? It was clearly obvious! He should have just called 911. Cause looking doesn’t take seconds.
He was inconvenienced and financially pressured, to the point of committing double homicide. I think the son whose reckless alcohol induced boat accident caused the death of the teenage girl boat passenger, became an alcoholic because of the suspicious circumstances surrounding the death of the familys' longtime housekerper eho had also been Pauls' primary caretaker from infancy.
Hearing Alec’s lawyer answer the marriage problems question with “trust me” always makes me chuckle. Ok bub, no need for a trial, everyone trusts Alec’s lawyer.
@@mariawallace1381 I agree with you. This family is fast becoming the "Jack the Ripper": of unsolved murders. I do NOT believe anyone in that family killed him.
That girl was not brainwashed Carrie was evil just as much as her creepy father despicable what they both did she helped him get into that house I hope she's in prison for life with him
Did you not watch it. The daughter got nothing no consequences for her evil actions. They gave her counseling so she can continue being among the humans.
What happened to my son ….. brainwashed into not believing what he saw and lived ….. only believing what the abuser told him was fact. Don’t know how that happens…. I think my son wants/needs his dad’s unconditional love and approval (which he will never get as his dad is incapable of giving it) that he will do anything ….. including hurting, lying and betraying me, his Mom who has given my all to him every day of his life …. to get it. I have to move on 😢. Sometimes I think Michelle is lucky as living with this heartache living hell.
@@HappyDog-rj6yk I hope you have found some peace in 'letting him go'. It is your only choice, albeit a painful one. Keep your chin up, stay in counselling so you have someone to talk to (friends may tire of it). Be careful if your son does not eventually get counselling on his own. Watch your back and finances. I don't know how long you stayed with your ex but the longer you did, your son probably sub-consciously or not sees that as 'well it couldn't have been that bad' or a betrayal on your part for staying in the relationship where abuse went on. Regardless, you did the best you could with the situation and resources you had at any given time, so there is nothing left to do except 'let go' with help in counselling. It is the only way. I feel sad you have to have this pain b/c I know it is wrenching and I hope you find enough peace that it is not on your mind daily. Just be careful. Make new friends. god speed.
For a father to give his own Daughters a Plan A and Plan B is obviously a Sociopath. No telling the mental damage done to his family, off the mother and keep Daddy’s secret. Talk about a warped minded man.
Parent alienation 🫤Karrie is her fathers child, she should of gotten the same sentence as her, or at least 15-20 years. She’s just as corrupt, villainous, and repulsive as her father! R.I.P Michelle 🌹 sorry this happened to U beautiful 💔& prayers to all these women’s families & friends🙏🏾🙏🏾❣️
💔😿 such tales of tragedy just like ancient Greece just when you think you have it all /😢it all falls a part omg great Saturday night in though thanks 48 ❤gang 🥰
Parental alienation is real for both parents…. I was a victim of it where my two sons were turned against me because I simply didn’t want to be with their father. This affected both children psychologically as one son has mental issues. Thank God, the other son came back to me at 18 and graduated with his masters in speech pathology.
I was a Child of it And I don't think people realise How it affects the Children.....I still Suffer now and I am 56 .....My mother Totally Ruined My life
Lifetime or HBO couldn’t have written a more vile or “true crime” series or movie. That’s how unbelievable this case was. Straight out of Hollywood in the backroads of a small community. It’s truly heartbreaking about the lives lost, including Paul and Maggie. Mallory Beach, Stephen Smith, and Gloria Saterfield. I remember every name because they deserve the light to shine on their stories so something like this CANNOT be commited by another man or woman ever again. It’s truly a modern crime-turned-tragedy. Alex Murdaugh will meet his maker one day, and face the same judgment.
I’m reading the comments looking for someone to mention Gloria and Stephen..they too were killed in this man’s evil path..so sad. Thanks for mentioning them! I too remember ❤️
3BK235Y is not asking to tell God what to do and when to do it. They are asking why free will (from your 1st comment) only works 1 way when it comes to evil people. Why do they get the advantage in the situation? They are asking you for guidance & you come back with not an answer, but a deflection.
35:08 He says "the _person"_ before then adding that it could've been _"people"._ I think any innocent person would totally assume 2 killers as there were 2 different weapons used.
Not their fault tho. None of them had to get back on that boat either. They all made the decision to get back on the boat after the bar stop, but when you are young like that, you feel invincible.
This comment shows you’ve never experienced an alcoholic front and center . It’s only so much you can say and do and it still doesn’t matter. The friends will never be the ones to blame!! Sick & Sad to even think that. SMDH!
My mom had been practicing parental alienation on me ever since I was a kid, yet I outgrew that and realized that my dad wasn't like everything my mom said he was. So, there's no excuse for the middle daughter who helped killing her own mom!
No excuse the drugs I have canceer and I’m them but I take them as prescribed. He was taking a shitload and if your that high your never going to be thinking rational . No excuse at all though. It’s so sad 🙏🏾😢💔
This is amazing, I’m a 63 yo malein Florida , Tampa area recovering for 2 years and would love to know more about participating in your study program , thank you 🙏
Paul was genuinely evil. Watching the videos about the boat crash was awful and cruel. How they desperately hoped the girl was still alive, while Paul just laughed and mocked the boyfriend of the victim. It really doesnt matter what your upbringing is, when your response to causing someone immeasurable grief is to laugh. I do not agree with anything Murdock did, but I for sure know that Paul will not be missed.
2:54 Old Poot, as I like to call him, is a state senator who is used to people rolling over for him. I am not a lawyer. I do not know if Johnny Cochran was a fantastic trial lawyer. But I do know that Old Poot is just that! An old poot!
Paul got karmic payback for the terribly cruel and callous behavior he had toward others. Besides the boat wreck i suspect Paul to be resposible for the housekeepers "fall" and possibly that boys mysterious death. Imo
@@chloed1924Umm because the only ones there when the incident with the housekeeper took place was Paul and the mother. Alec was not there. You do understand how it couldn’t be him now I would hope so. 🤦🏻♂️
@@stevewhitener4903 When he told Gloria's two son's to claim off his insurance he told LE that he was there when she fell down the steps.Paul and Maggie said the dogs knocked her over but Alex told cops that it was the dogs leads that got caught around her legs and she fell.The reason he wanted the sons to claim off his insurance and he would deal with everything including legal fees and what not was because if they had done it through another lawyer they would've known how much they were awarded.Because Alex was in charge of it he never told them nothing and kept the money and split it with Corey Fleming.Karma's a beech.
The two guns are EASILY explained - he planned to use the shog^n, which he did on Paul and the AR was in case anyone ran. That's why Maggie got five shots, to make SURE she was dead.
Or he wanted to make sure she died quickly because he cared about her like a sociopath cares about those who show love and affection for them for a long time they can't let themselves believe they are horrible people who would commit crimes against humanity and they need those that love them in order to see themselves through that person's eyes ... I believe that he is most definitely guilty, Buster is just lucky that he was needed by Alex alive as someone who loved him to see himself through busters eyes . ..Paul needed to go in Alex opinion because of the shame he seen him as putting on the Murdaugh name Maggie had to die because he didn't want her opinion of him to change when the news about his thievery came out or because he could not get her to leave or maybe even because he knew she would find out who killed her precious son she would not have given up...
3:45 "I would never hurt Maggie." Yet, he nods his head up and down. I have seen this so many times in other videos about suspects who say "no" verbally but nod their head yes.
He wasn't battling his addiction he was enjoying it. He started to battle it when he was caught! People like this fella think they'll get away with anything!
Anyone else notice that A Murdaugh ever-so-slightly nods yes, while speaking, "No," in answer to the attorney's question of if he killed Maggie? I think of The Behavioral Panel (?), from whom, over time, I've learned a lot about body language, contradictions, communication nuances, etc.
you lose your job if you say anything or question a partner she doesn't know the deals they have made among one another she keeps getting her check. jenny was a bookkeeper not a partner when the time came she was ask to speak out, she did!
I watched the documentaries, i watched all the RUclips docs on this case & it still blows my mind someone would do this.......how would murdering your son & wife help cover you stealing money? Desperation? Just plain stupid? I will never understand what the ultimate goal here was
I have asked myself the same questions since this case came out. What about life insurance? It may have been a way for him to get some money 🤷🏾♀️. What do you think?
There was a motion hearing scheduled on Mark Tinsley's Motion to Compel Alex Murdaugh's financial information a day or two after the murders took place. Alex had tried to get the hearing put off, but was unsuccessful. The murders put the motion hearing off until September, which is the same month that financial improprieties were found.
I understand Karrie. My parent would constantly threaten to commit suicide if i didn't comply. It terrifies and warps the way a child views and interacts with the world. Fear stalked all my relationships. Many years of therapy helped but the fear is always at hand.
What people would give to have property 🤔 and 💰 to lived life comfortably and this asshole taking advantage of he's power i don't get it ..people want more and more is sad 😔 #NOBODYISABOVE GOD OR ANYTHING ✌🏾🙏🏾🇺🇸🇵🇷😢🤔
I simply cannot stop thinking, whenever I see the males of the Murdaugh family, that can only be the money that got them a whatever girlfriends and wife they may have had or have. They are not exactly my ideal of Adonises.
Judge Newman brought down a DRAGON scale by scale. As Alex is talking in that police car. His facial expressions tell me everything I need to know. The conflict between the heart, mind and the tongue is sooo real in his case. His t-shirt and hands were TOO CLEAN for a man who just discovered his murdered family and called 911! He didn't even try to give them resuscitation.
Harpootlian is a liar and always has been. If they were getting along so great y did she move out and was living full time at the beach house without Alex
She didn't move out. Prior to boat accident.... Alex n Maggie spent weekend together with another couple up at university football game weekend. Maggie often came home. Summer was full time living In summer home. but winter time, Maggie spent every weekend at home with alex.
@@LarryLegend3923 who said anything about the boat accident? This video is about the murders since he was on trial for and found guilty of the murders. Harpootlian said they weren’t separated at that time when asked by the press, he answered no and said he would know because he was with them every day preparing for the boat case. Did that explanation help u any at all ?
1:14:36 ... Passive Poker Face of The Year Award goes to...her attorney as she confesses to actually assisting in the hanging. This is nuts. They'd already given her a proffer. Do proffers stipulate: if you tell a new unknown crime on yourself, it is not included in what cannot be charged due to the proffer once law enforcement learns of it? 1:22:06 Geeze! They not only do not charge her more, they charge her for less! And there was no mention of psychiatric care along with that parole. Damn, I hope she realizes herself that she needs it. It makes me wonder what her sisters think and feel. What a strange story~!
51:57 Geeze! "... a case that 'didn't go away." Can't a judge see something like this and put a stop to it? It's harassment on a grand scale. 44:40 Confusing for two reasons: If Karrie's friends called her "earlier today," and her sister was with her, how come they hadn't called police sooner? AND How come police had not contacted her yet? 57:14 Not strange at all: court victory aside, a mother can still be enraged at a daughter who sides w a father in court battles.1:12:20 Geeze! Why no charges for accomplice after the deed? She literally slid him away in the back of her car! 1:13:10 That picture was taken 1 day before she died ~ after the no-show at court Friday, it said earlier. Last "good day" on earth, I guess.
Our daughter was at her grandparents’ when she fell on her head. The Sheriff had never seen so much blood and was sure one of her antique grandparents had shot her. No. She was trying to clean up the blood as her heart pumped it everywhere.
After years of painkiller abuse the body develops a high tolerance to the pills so they have to keep taking more and more just to feel the effects of the medicine. 60 is a crazy amount though even with a very high tolerance.
Matthew Perry book he said he took 60+ A day. Radio host the screamer.. He took 100 A day. Went to NYC for blood detox when he reaches 100. Rush Limbaugh.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
I have watched every show about this tragedy, and I still can't get enough. It's that unbelievable, even now.
You can hear in his voice on his sons video just before he killed them that something was wrong, I mean listen to how he was saying his dogs name, He said it like he was saying the dogs name to make it seem like he was genuinely looking for the dog but was preparing for what he's about to do.
Neither can I. A true American horror story. This would make a great read too!!! A Grisham or a Baldacci sort of tale
Same, I've heard this case several times and it's still fascinating
It’s literally my Roman Empire 😅
What Tragedy? Its just Karma.
The boat crash was the first domino in line and when it fell there was no stopping the downfall of Alex. My heart breaks for Mallory Beach and her family and friends.
@@hagakure74They definitely murdered the housekeeper.
Mallory brought the entire family down
The entire family is corrupt
I personally think the mom pushed the housekeeper down the stairs
I think buster is involved in stephan's death
Paul killed Mallory
And Alex killed his wife and son
And let's not forget Alex's brother removed the guns from the home...
The entire Mordough bloodline is questionable
@@KatharineLeeS”questionable?” That sure is a polite way to put it. 😊
Lord these demons have access to all this money ' that could help out so many out BUT they just do evil ' yet im here and humble and just waiting on my break..ilove you O'lord ' I'll help myself but also many struggling....
@@Scottallen8909 Yes..
I love that Paul had the evidence to prove what happened.
Thank GOD❣️
Why is their 1st solution always killing the wife? It baffles me all the time. It makes everything 10 times worse
Not if you’re a narcissist
@@caroleminke6116more to do with psychopathy
@3BK235YI agree with you and the reasons behind why they do it are all illogical. These types of individuals are selfish, impulsive, and irrational giving way for their emotions to control them. They don't seem to fully think things through and realize there are consequences for their actions. Some think they're smart enough to get away with it which shows their lack of real intelligence and common sense. This applies as well to the murderers who are articulate and educated.
To get insurance money
Because their assumption is always that they can outsmart the police and have zero consequences and instead sympathy that they can continue to use to manipulate people. Plus the above things stated like life insurance
The second one makes me sick, the fact that the daughter took her father's side and stayed silent about 5 months knowing what happened to her mother. She is sick like her Father.
There are suspicions that they had a romantic relationship too. 🤮
Her father is the only parent she has left and is not uncommon for adult children to side with their father in these cases ... HE$ the breadWINner ~ THE KING of the CASTle ~.
Basically, he is the only family she has left and whilst it may be hard to understand, like someone else has posted, this is not unusual.
@@WindDancer435i might understand that if she is not present and did not help her father in killing her mother...but she did help her father...and their conversations in the phone???...uh uh...!!..
@@wildwillow1945where did you get this from? This would be awful…
RIP to those who were lost, healing for those left behind.
For the Algorithm.
Thanks for the content.
Good job, Bubba .. you cracked the case
Love this! So true!💪🏽
@@lizg.8626 I know! It’s crazy isn’t it?
Hope bubba has an amazing home now ❤
@@Hashslingingslasherrrrrrhe does he is living with the housekeeper Blanca . She testified and did a great job . She’s a very impressive lady . I’ve watched her testimony several times . She has Bubba .
Bubba is the only one in that family I have any sympathy for.
Thats the problem with a lot of really wealthy people, they are never content and happy with what they have and always want more
True
Diminished returns, the more you're exposed to something the less satisfied you are. So people that can get or do anything at the drop of a hat need more and more to feel excitement or enjoy anything. Then once you've done and have it all your just left with a feeling of disappointment and frustration. It's why money can't actually buy sustainable happiness. It can make you feel secure, it can buy you toys but how long until you're board of those?
@@mom.left.me.at.michaels9951 Just a question: so how does this explain why 'allegedly' people with less money are 'satisfied'? I mean, what is the fundamental difference? At which point in the accumulation of things or doing activities, does this change for any given person? I hope my question makes sense. I think some people with wealth are just as happy as some people without it. In the Murdaugh case, I think they enjoyed their wealth and family life and ties as much as anybody else. Clout they may have pursued, but I think wealth just came naturally for them. P.S. Did anyone try and buy you at Michaels? lol.
@@mom.left.me.at.michaels9951 # facts!!
It takes $ to make $ and keep it
That sentence for Karrie was too light.
I know she was manipulated by her father.
But one to three years isn't punishment.
She knew what she was doing. She had other choices.
Including saving her mother's life.
2nd episode: the dad knew exactly which one of his daughters had his psychopathic tendencies. That woman knew how to lie as easily as breathing, cool as a cucumber like her father for the most part.
3rd episode....thank you to the neighbor who fought for justice for Leslie. Doing the right thing is admirable!
That judge was the best judge I've ever watched before. Cool, calm, fair and extremely intelligent. Too bad he retired. Hope he's enjoying his life.
Judge Newman . He deserves an award . He still took the commitment of this trial so serious . As it was three weeks after his own son passing away.
Consummate professional 👌🏾
@@LadyChannYes, 1 truly amazing man.
He is as a matter of fact he was at a dinner with us over the winter at our dog kennels just like the ones in this video that u claim r inhumane
@@joecrosby5427 who claimed that ?
@@LadyChann who claimed what ??
Imagine what went through his head when he heard himself on his son's phone,,
He’d …… Up big time
Now just imagine what came out of his arse when he heard himself on his son's phone !Brown water. lol
Yep, game set and match
Although I had already watched these three episodes, it's a good thing I watched this Marathon because 48 Hours episodes are awesome!
All I can say is I pray for everyone involved including the girl who lost her life in the boat accident Paul Murdock caused. God be with the family of Mallory Beach.
Alec Murdaugh: Busted by the dog!! The high and mighty Murdaugh brought down by the lowly but affable Bubba! Maggies dog...poetic justice.
Paul’s nickname was “little detective” how crazy he provided the evidence even in his death to get justice for his mother and himself.
Justice for keeping them locked up in those kennels that get boiling hot in the summer and freezing cold in the winter.
@@gennamcgill4066 yep! It was WWIII in that house because Paul kept finding Alec's stashes of pills, telling Maggie and flushing them. Also, I don't buy Alec taking 60 pills a day - he wouldn't have a liver in three months doing that and he said it went on for two decades? Nah, there's a ton of money somewhere.....
I didn't even know such a thing exists in the land of the great/brave. That's animal abuse, I thought 1st world country should know better. And yet I live in 3rd world country and my dogs are all over our sofas and sofa beds . I am on the floor, and my dogs are on the sofas 😂😂😂😂😂 .. Glad this guy is caught. Hopefully, their dogs are treated better.
Well said
😢when your Dad, the one who should protect you, messes with your head so badly.....i feel for this Girl. But her Mom? Can't imagine how betrayed she must have felt in her last moments!
Rest in Peace, Michelle❤❤❤❤❤
Paul's head was literally blown off. Alex is a lifelong hunter. He knows what dead looks like. His constant asking if "are they dead" is ridiculous.
Poor Mallory and her family. It’s bad enough that Paul killed her, but then Alec tried to use her death as an excuse for the murders he committed. It’s truly appalling
Great episode. But I am surprised you left out one of the most compelling pieces of evidence, which was the way Creighton closed the case against Alex.
In Alex’s interviews, when he walked through the timeline of the night of the murders, he describes checking the bodies and then says he called 911.
But his car’s data indicated the time he came to a stop at the kennels. And comparing this time with the time of his 911 call, it was clear that there was no time to check the bodies before calling 911. (The logical inference is that as soon as he pulled up, he called 911 because he already knew they were dead, given that he shot them before racing to his Mother’s.)
Alex tried to reinterpret his responses in the interviews, but it was futile. He was caught in yet another lie.
I heard he also showered and changed clothes before being interviewed by police.
He def didn’t have to walk up to see if the bodies were dead???? It was clearly obvious! He should have just called 911. Cause looking doesn’t take seconds.
3:45 Denying while nodding yes. It remains a classic.
He also keeps his hand literally touching his balls during his police interview in the car. It’s just weird.
Indeed.
@@TentinQuarantino_🤮
@@TentinQuarantino_self soothing
Jenna's voice just ripped my heart out. Screaming out to her mommy like that. Then screaming at her dad to stop doing that stop moving her!
the father is INSANE..but knew EXACTLY what he was doing when he murdered his wife and son...
He was inconvenienced and financially pressured, to the point of committing double homicide. I think the son whose reckless alcohol induced boat accident caused the death of the teenage girl boat passenger, became an alcoholic because of the suspicious circumstances surrounding the death of the familys' longtime housekerper eho had also been Pauls' primary caretaker from infancy.
@@m_christine1070plenty of people go through the same thing and instead of killing they go to therapy or talk to someone they trust.
@@m_christine1070this feel like an excuse to me and it’s disgusting
There was also another suspicious death between the housekeeper and the wife and son and it was a classmate of the son
Murdock was absolutely NOT insane because he knows right from wrong. He is just evil and calculating, but not crazy by a long shot.
Hearing Alec’s lawyer answer the marriage problems question with “trust me” always makes me chuckle. Ok bub, no need for a trial, everyone trusts Alec’s lawyer.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
He’s Harpootlian!
This was trial of the century . I consumed every , last morsel of it .
Dayum!!!
Same, and just when I thought police couldn’t get worse the Karen Read case proved me wrong.
We need to talk more about the young gay man who one of the Murdaugh sons (the youngest one) likely killed AND their maid who they also killed.
Why do you think Paul killed Stephen?
No we do not. It’s unfair to do this to an innocent person
@@blingqueen2235 his alter ego alcoholic Timmy did it
@@biancamaclean4794 o yes! Forgot about “Timmy”
@@mariawallace1381 I agree with you. This family is fast becoming the "Jack the Ripper": of unsolved murders. I do NOT believe anyone in that family killed him.
Karrie should serve more time
She’s not that innocent, she didn’t come clean until the police cornered her
Crocodile tears!!!
Agreed her sentence should’ve been longer, to keep her away from the other two sisters
That girl was not brainwashed Carrie was evil just as much as her creepy father despicable what they both did she helped him get into that house I hope she's in prison for life with him
I would say brainwashed for her entire childhood but yeah in the end evil just the same.
Did you not watch it. The daughter got nothing no consequences for her evil actions. They gave her counseling so she can continue being among the humans.
What happened to my son ….. brainwashed into not believing what he saw and lived ….. only believing what the abuser told him was fact. Don’t know how that happens…. I think my son wants/needs his dad’s unconditional love and approval (which he will never get as his dad is incapable of giving it) that he will do anything ….. including hurting, lying and betraying me, his Mom who has given my all to him every day of his life …. to get it.
I have to move on 😢. Sometimes I think Michelle is lucky as living with this heartache living hell.
@@HappyDog-rj6yk I hope you have found some peace in 'letting him go'. It is your only choice, albeit a painful one. Keep your chin up, stay in counselling so you have someone to talk to (friends may tire of it). Be careful if your son does not eventually get counselling on his own. Watch your back and finances. I don't know how long you stayed with your ex but the longer you did, your son probably sub-consciously or not sees that as 'well it couldn't have been that bad' or a betrayal on your part for staying in the relationship where abuse went on. Regardless, you did the best you could with the situation and resources you had at any given time, so there is nothing left to do except 'let go' with help in counselling. It is the only way. I feel sad you have to have this pain b/c I know it is wrenching and I hope you find enough peace that it is not on your mind daily. Just be careful. Make new friends. god speed.
Absolutely right my friend, pure evilness.
For a father to give his own Daughters a Plan A and Plan B is obviously a Sociopath.
No telling the mental damage done to his family, off the mother and keep Daddy’s secret.
Talk about a warped minded man.
Maybe all of the so called "legal dynasties " need to be investigated.
My same thoughts.
💯percent agree
The daughter should’ve gotten 15 to 20! SMH all that lying, all that plotting. She’s no better than the father
Parent alienation 🫤Karrie is her fathers child, she should of gotten the same sentence as her, or at least 15-20 years. She’s just as corrupt, villainous, and repulsive as her father! R.I.P Michelle 🌹 sorry this happened to U beautiful 💔& prayers to all these women’s families & friends🙏🏾🙏🏾❣️
Carrie is guilty just like her dad!! Evil girl! She should have got 15 years or more years in jail.
Traded the life of a loving parent who wanted the best for her to a pyscho who just wanted absolute control 😢
@@mom.left.me.at.michaels9951 she’s a pure narcissistic.
Karrie should have gotten life without parole aswell.
I didn’t fall for that baloney either. I think we might see her again.🫥
a mini me of her father.
Hard to have empathy for Paul, too much like his "daddy."
You mean “Paw Paw”? 🙄
🥇 whats up 48 Gang
I should be grocery shopping just not right now lol👋👍
@@Patti-sg1fv what 3 items will you be buying for the week.
@@donnaadams5217 butter, bag of potatoes, and mandarins 😊
💔😿 such tales of tragedy just like ancient Greece just when you think you have it all /😢it all falls a part omg great Saturday night in though thanks 48 ❤gang 🥰
What'd ya say ya ate ?
Parental alienation is real for both parents…. I was a victim of it where my two sons were turned against me because I simply didn’t want to be with their father. This affected both children psychologically as one son has mental issues. Thank God, the other son came back to me at 18 and graduated with his masters in speech pathology.
I was a Child of it And I don't think people realise How it affects the Children.....I still Suffer now and I am 56 .....My mother Totally Ruined My life
That Carrie girl is a horrible and evil daughter! Shame on her! 😢
Glad the jury got it right in the last case
Both times
True-crime enthusiast since the genre’s inception. This sht is one of thē most intriguingly intricate situations I’ve since known.
Lifetime or HBO couldn’t have written a more vile or “true crime” series or movie. That’s how unbelievable this case was. Straight out of Hollywood in the backroads of a small community. It’s truly heartbreaking about the lives lost, including Paul and Maggie. Mallory Beach, Stephen Smith, and Gloria Saterfield. I remember every name because they deserve the light to shine on their stories so something like this CANNOT be commited by another man or woman ever again. It’s truly a modern crime-turned-tragedy.
Alex Murdaugh will meet his maker one day, and face the same judgment.
@3BK235Yyou seem very confused. But who am I to Judge.
@@Ecaterina-ih5qbBeautifully said👏♥️ God bless you always in Jesus mighty and precious name🤗
I’m reading the comments looking for someone to mention Gloria and Stephen..they too were killed in this man’s evil path..so sad. Thanks for mentioning them! I too remember ❤️
3BK235Y is not asking to tell God what to do and when to do it. They are asking why free will (from your 1st comment) only works 1 way when it comes to evil people. Why do they get the advantage in the situation? They are asking you for guidance & you come back with not an answer, but a deflection.
No Stephens death has had zero connection after being investigated. @@blaze_haze_sunnydayz
35:08 He says "the _person"_ before then adding that it could've been _"people"._ I think any innocent person would totally assume 2 killers as there were 2 different weapons used.
Thank God for that Snapchat if that Snapchat video did not come into play he probably would not have been found guilty
Onstar gave the prosecution his car's GPS information proving he was lying about where he was during the murders so that was extremely helpful too
@@layla2115 true
Rest in peace to all the victims
I'm obsessed with ALL of it
Iv been waiting so patiently for this to come out
The daughter in the second story is a absolute disgrace
How does this channel only have 1.5 subscribers!!! That’s crazy only 1.5 million of us out there that deep into true crime
I wonder how many people went from disliking Paul, ,,
To realizing how his up bringing put him where he ended ,,
None.
It's such a shame - a little common sense and courage from any of Paul's friends and the boat accident wouldn't have happened
Exactly. SMH
Not their fault tho. None of them had to get back on that boat either. They all made the decision to get back on the boat after the bar stop, but when you are young like that, you feel invincible.
This comment shows you’ve never experienced an alcoholic front and center . It’s only so much you can say and do and it still doesn’t matter. The friends will never be the ones to blame!! Sick & Sad to even think that. SMDH!
My mom had been practicing parental alienation on me ever since I was a kid, yet I outgrew that and realized that my dad wasn't like everything my mom said he was. So, there's no excuse for the middle daughter who helped killing her own mom!
GREED & MONEY, THEY ARE MORE IMPORTANT THAN YOUR FAMILY?? YOUR CHILDREN?? 🤷♀️
No excuse the drugs
I have canceer and I’m them but I take them as prescribed. He was taking a shitload and if your that high your never going to be thinking rational . No excuse at all though. It’s so sad 🙏🏾😢💔
$ is the 'root' of all 'evil'
Pretty simple to me. Blood splatter all over the freaking bedroom is not indicative of a slip and fall in the shower. Right?!
"Well I'm just a simple country lawyer" says the great prosecutor, you could feel the discust he had for AM in every word he said through this trial
Thank you for posting!
This is amazing, I’m a 63 yo malein Florida , Tampa area recovering for 2 years and would love to know more about participating in your study program , thank you 🙏
He lives as he will pass away, playing judge and jury always hiding from the real judge and jury.
Profound.
Paul was genuinely evil. Watching the videos about the boat crash was awful and cruel. How they desperately hoped the girl was still alive, while Paul just laughed and mocked the boyfriend of the victim. It really doesnt matter what your upbringing is, when your response to causing someone immeasurable grief is to laugh.
I do not agree with anything Murdock did, but I for sure know that Paul will not be missed.
The turning point when the divorce 🤔 is a go 😢
I will never understand how some people find it so easy to take someone's life. I just don't get it. How do they sleep at night?
This will go down as one of the most captivating tragedies ever…still so shocking.
He wasn't very good at problem solving, seemingly
2:54 Old Poot, as I like to call him, is a state senator who is used to people rolling over for him.
I am not a lawyer. I do not know if Johnny Cochran was a fantastic trial lawyer. But I do know that Old Poot is just that! An old poot!
I think he extremely creepy 🤢
My disappointment when I clicked on this video and realized I had already watched all three of the episodes included in this video 😔💕
Paul got karmic payback for the terribly cruel and callous behavior he had toward others. Besides the boat wreck i suspect Paul to be resposible for the housekeepers "fall" and possibly that boys mysterious death. Imo
Why do you think it was Paul who was responsible for the housekeeper rather than his father?
Why do u think Paul is responsible for the housekeeper’s (Gloria) & that boy’s (Stephen) death???
@@chloed1924Umm because the only ones there when the incident with the housekeeper took place was Paul and the mother. Alec was not there. You do understand how it couldn’t be him now I would hope so. 🤦🏻♂️
@@stevewhitener4903 When he told Gloria's two son's to claim off his insurance he told LE that he was there when she fell down the steps.Paul and Maggie said the dogs knocked her over but Alex told cops that it was the dogs leads that got caught around her legs and she fell.The reason he wanted the sons to claim off his insurance and he would deal with everything including legal fees and what not was because if they had done it through another lawyer they would've known how much they were awarded.Because Alex was in charge of it he never told them nothing and kept the money and split it with Corey Fleming.Karma's a beech.
The two guns are EASILY explained - he planned to use the shog^n, which he did on Paul and the AR was in case anyone ran. That's why Maggie got five shots, to make SURE she was dead.
Or he wanted to make sure she died quickly because he cared about her like a sociopath cares about those who show love and affection for them for a long time they can't let themselves believe they are horrible people who would commit crimes against humanity and they need those that love them in order to see themselves through that person's eyes ...
I believe that he is most definitely guilty, Buster is just lucky that he was needed by Alex alive as someone who loved him to see himself through busters eyes . ..Paul needed to go in Alex opinion because of the shame he seen him as putting on the Murdaugh name Maggie had to die because he didn't want her opinion of him to change when the news about his thievery came out or because he could not get her to leave or maybe even because he knew she would find out who killed her precious son she would not have given up...
@@anitagoodman4657yeah that’s a possibility but unfortunately we’ll never know. So sad.
3:45 "I would never hurt Maggie." Yet, he nods his head up and down. I have seen this so many times in other videos about suspects who say "no" verbally but nod their head yes.
Wow!! so satisfying crime compilation... so interesting and very informative content t. y watching from the Philippines "Mabuhay 48 hrs"
This case had me in a chokehold
Mr. Creighton was great throughout the trial, all on his team.
cries and stops and nothing - he is normal.
also no tears , here we go again
If “Full of 💩” was a person it would be Alex Murdaugh!!!
He wasn't battling his addiction he was enjoying it. He started to battle it when he was caught! People like this fella think they'll get away with anything!
Anyone else notice that A Murdaugh ever-so-slightly nods yes, while speaking, "No," in answer to the attorney's question of if he killed Maggie? I think of The Behavioral Panel (?), from whom, over time, I've learned a lot about body language, contradictions, communication nuances, etc.
30:29 Jean Secenger should have caught the theft of funds years before. 😢 Blows my mind that millions were missing and she didn’t catch it. 🥺
Ya think?!?
I know, right?! SMH
you lose your job if you say anything or question a partner she doesn't know the deals they have made among one another she keeps getting her check. jenny was a bookkeeper not a partner when the time came she was ask to speak out, she did!
How ironic the dog was named bubba...guess the name of his husband in jail.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
This men Alex is very sick.A guy who really needs help 😢
I watched the documentaries, i watched all the RUclips docs on this case & it still blows my mind someone would do this.......how would murdering your son & wife help cover you stealing money?
Desperation?
Just plain stupid?
I will never understand what the ultimate goal here was
I have asked myself the same questions since this case came out. What about life insurance? It may have been a way for him to get some money 🤷🏾♀️. What do you think?
There was a motion hearing scheduled on Mark Tinsley's Motion to Compel Alex Murdaugh's financial information a day or two after the murders took place. Alex had tried to get the hearing put off, but was unsuccessful. The murders put the motion hearing off until September, which is the same month that financial improprieties were found.
How he murdered his wife and son....evil.
I understand Karrie. My parent would constantly threaten to commit suicide if i didn't comply. It terrifies and warps the way a child views and interacts with the world. Fear stalked all my relationships. Many years of therapy helped but the fear is always at hand.
Told the whole story in the first 4:30 seconds. Awesome
Paul smiling and laughing at the boat crash scene..?
Karma
What people would give to have property 🤔 and 💰 to lived life comfortably and this asshole taking advantage of he's power i don't get it ..people want more and more is sad 😔 #NOBODYISABOVE GOD OR ANYTHING ✌🏾🙏🏾🇺🇸🇵🇷😢🤔
I simply cannot stop thinking, whenever I see the males of the Murdaugh family, that can only be the money that got them a whatever girlfriends and wife they may have had or have. They are not exactly my ideal of Adonises.
Judge Newman brought down a DRAGON scale by scale. As Alex is talking in that police car. His facial expressions tell me everything I need to know. The conflict between the heart, mind and the tongue is sooo real in his case. His t-shirt and hands were TOO CLEAN for a man who just discovered his murdered family and called 911! He didn't even try to give them resuscitation.
See why we can't be too soft with children? This all started because parents didn't put the fear of god in one of their children.
very fair representation of the trial.
Strange, I was just re-watching portions of the trial for the past few days
Harpootlian is a liar and always has been. If they were getting along so great y did she move out and was living full time at the beach house without Alex
She didn't move out. Prior to boat accident.... Alex n Maggie spent weekend together with another couple up at university football game weekend. Maggie often came home. Summer was full time living In summer home. but winter time, Maggie spent every weekend at home with alex.
@@LarryLegend3923 who said anything about the boat accident? This video is about the murders since he was on trial for and found guilty of the murders. Harpootlian said they weren’t separated at that time when asked by the press, he answered no and said he would know because he was with them every day preparing for the boat case. Did that explanation help u any at all ?
She could have gone to the police or tell someone else she had more than 2 choices she is a psychopath just like her father and she should be in jail
1:14:36 ... Passive Poker Face of The Year Award goes to...her attorney as she confesses to actually assisting in the hanging. This is nuts. They'd already given her a proffer. Do proffers stipulate: if you tell a new unknown crime on yourself, it is not included in what cannot be charged due to the proffer once law enforcement learns of it? 1:22:06 Geeze! They not only do not charge her more, they charge her for less! And there was no mention of psychiatric care along with that parole. Damn, I hope she realizes herself that she needs it. It makes me wonder what her sisters think and feel. What a strange story~!
I should not be this engulfed in a murderer yet here I am! Sick & Sad !!!!
51:57 Geeze! "... a case that 'didn't go away." Can't a judge see something like this and put a stop to it? It's harassment on a grand scale. 44:40 Confusing for two reasons: If Karrie's friends called her "earlier today," and her sister was with her, how come they hadn't called police sooner? AND How come police had not contacted her yet? 57:14 Not strange at all: court victory aside, a mother can still be enraged at a daughter who sides w a father in court battles.1:12:20 Geeze! Why no charges for accomplice after the deed? She literally slid him away in the back of her car! 1:13:10 That picture was taken 1 day before she died ~ after the no-show at court Friday, it said earlier. Last "good day" on earth, I guess.
Why a successful person chose to become an addict and a killer? Why some humans let drugs destoy their lives?
This case is so sad. How did he think he would not get caught?
He is a Monster, keep him locked up forever
Our daughter was at her grandparents’ when she fell on her head. The Sheriff had never seen so much blood and was sure one of her antique grandparents had shot her. No. She was trying to clean up the blood as her heart pumped it everywhere.
Who can take up to 60 pills a day, wouldn't that be an OVERDOSE???
After years of painkiller abuse the body develops a high tolerance to the pills so they have to keep taking more and more just to feel the effects of the medicine. 60 is a crazy amount though even with a very high tolerance.
@@marlonisaac1 EXACTLY!!! How would he function??? NOT BUYING IT!!! Just want to make his case believable!!
Matthew Perry book he said he took 60+ A day. Radio host the screamer.. He took 100 A day. Went to NYC for blood detox when he reaches 100. Rush Limbaugh.
Narcissistic fathers.....don't ignore the red flags..it only gets worse.
Money doesn't bring happiness. RIP ANGELS 😇
1:58:10 WHO would anyone put 911 ON HOLD for😢