I hate it when people say someone was at the wrong place at the wrong time as the reporter did in the first story at 10:32. That man was at home, where he had a right to be. That cliche puts the blame on the victims for what happened to them. Even those who may be at a store or a gas station... anywhere. The victim had a right to be there.
@@ZNCLinguistics-ne3wp First off, in you trying to be funny, you are actually not making sense. No one says a m*rdered person was at the right place at the right time. Try to think logically instead of using semantics to mock what I said. I am on the side of the victims and this cliche should not be used in that scenario.
@@LeoGirl0727 you're saying that as long as you have the right to be somewhere legally, the phrase "wrong place, wrong time" is offensive. I'm giving you a different perspective. let's say you run into someone in a rush at a Starbucks, and it so happens that he gives you a just-bought lottery ticket because you let him jump the queue. As a result you win 50 million bucks. is there any problem with describing your windfall as the result of your being at the "right place at the right time"? if there's no problem with that, then there shouldn't be any issue with "wrong place, wrong time". If you still don't get it... let me simplify. "Wrong place at the wrong time" IS JUST A FIGURE OF SPEECH. It just means BAD LUCK. There aren't any moral undertones about the word "wrong" here. It has the same meaning as "I made a wrong turn" or "I set the alarm clock wrong". Your whole issue with "wrong place, wrong time" is absurd. If you argue it's subjective, my response would be that Americans drive on the "wrong" side of the road. Remember that diplomat's wife who killed a Brit who was in the wrong place at the wrong time? But she was driving on the wrong side of the road. But she had diplomatic immunity and managed to flee - so right place (foreign country) and right time (within validity of her immunity). If you still can't see that the same word can have different meanings in different contexts, well, I'm probably replying to the wrong comment at the wrong time.
Cheats on her husband with the guy who murdered him. Continues to be with the guy who murdered her husband. Then says she was part of the greatest love story. She is equally as mental as her daughters and her defense lawyer
I'm not going to say anything about her kids because name 1 kid who wants to believe their mom had their father killed just like no parent would wanna believe their kid is a killer
My darling husband of 45 years died of cancer in late November 2017 and I am still mourning his passing. It makes me so mad when I hear stories like this. It’s just disgusting to me.
I am saddened to hear of your loss. I lost my sweet Mother in January of 2016 to that nasty C word disease. I too mourn her passing. What gets me through each day are the wonderful memories, and the LOVE. God Bless, from Laura in EU.
@@22ergie Amen. I’m sorry for your pain and sorrow. I’m soon to be 74 and my dear sweet mother died of C too. She passed in 1981 when I was 31. There are times when I wish I could pick up the phone and call her with some of my questions. I pray you will find some comfort. 🙏🏻
I watch these videos and thank God everyday for my marriage. My husband and I have been married almost 5 years and have been together 7 years. He is my 2nd marriage and I am his first. Im almost 44 and he is 45. We met at the perfect time in our lives and are truly best friends, lovers, and soul mates. He served as a machine gunner in the Marine Corps yet is so incredibly gentle to myself, his daughter from a previous relationship, and my 2 daughters from my previous marriage. I trust him completely and have never once had even the slightest hint that he would ever lift a finger to hurt me. Although I know if it came to defending me or our children he is capable of great violence from his time as a Marine Corps machine gunner in the infantry. In the few heated arguments we have had over the years I have genuinely never had to worry about him harming me physically ( unlike my ex who slapped me several times and would shove me to the ground ). I point this out because while the killer in this video was also in the Marines it doesnt mean that it is common. Military men that serve in combat roles have to be able to be able to do great violence to other humans. Sone of them are unable to compartmentalize that emotion and actions and it is always there and they cant control it. Im glad this killer was caught and I hope he lives out his life in prison in a constant state of misery.
@@honeyg3589 .... Slow down... I shared my personal experience that I have lived. I also expressed happiness that the psycho in this video is going to rot in prison. If reading comprehension isn't your strong suit and you can't grasp what someone is saying then don't be that Karen that makes a scene.
Yvonnes family are heros! They didnt give up on her and they fought for justice. They are still fighting to keep her story alive. Sharing awareness to stop this from happening to other people. We need more people like them. This is what family means!
What I would really like to know is WHY, in this day and age, do people think that they can get away with murdering their spouse? Is it greed? Is it the love of money? GET A DAMN DIVORCE!
Note that not all murders are solved. Every murderer thinks they're smart and will get away with it. They bank on that percentage that never gets caught
@user-tz3dy7mt9e then leave! The implication of 'wrong place' implies the victim was an active participant. If I choose to wander down a dark alley in a known drug area, then I have actively made a wrong place decision...sitting at home does not
I don't understand how people struggle with this. He is dead. It was definitely not the right place at that exact time. Any other place would have been the right place.
Ooh he was so disgusting, right? And still thinks people are going to fall for his lies! Hey, Mark, get a clue -- most people cry TEARS when they are crying. His fake crying sounds turned my stomach.
Maybe it's me but if the man I was in love with, chopped an innocent woman up with a machete after he stabbed her, dumped her in some horrible place and then acted like she ran off with some random person, I would definitely take a hard look at myself as I was getting as far away as possible from that psycho...yet this killers wife stayed and supports that guy, why...
@AidaShawJ.D. uh, yea, I do...I keep better company than psychotic abusive murderers...and, last I checked, the comment section is full of opinions, so you have work to do telling everyone it's not about them...
When it showed how quickly she deteriorated from cancer and was still deadset on catching that dude I definitely got a little choked up lol. She was awesome for her sister.
I find it crazy how Kristin Brimager is still married and freaking supports her murderous husband. I think I would get if he maintained his innocence, but he outright confessed to murdering his girlfriend!
What a SICK woman. Kristen is obviously smart and successful but she knows he killed his ex-girlfriend. That's the crazy part, of course, but on top of that, she chose a pos who played golf all day while she worked and now he sits in federal prison all day while she works. Yeah, what a prize, she needs help.
It's irrelevant if their clients are guilty or not. Think about Lady Justice holding scales, the defense must be as strong as the prosecution. No normal person can sympathize with a killer but your job as an attorney, is to make his defense heard.
So messed up And you know she did it that way to keep herself further from the scene That’s so messed up & they definitely did it too No doubt about it Sick Defense Attorney’s
When it comes to the black widow it's comforting to know she's been in jail waiting for her trial, which has been delayed due to a choked judicial system. If the jury fail to see the truth and to find her guilty at least she'll have spent at least 8 years behind bars, without all the luxury she never earned or deserved. She turned 50 incarcerated. May Mr. Sementilli rest in peace. He was a ray of sunshine.
Yup, worst case scenario is she’s broke, old, hayted by all of society, and her boyfriend is stuck in jail. It Could be worse in case she gets off. But her case seems a complete slam dunk, they’ve gotten people with way less obvious evidence to go on.
The Donnah Winger case. I don't know why 48 hours never brought up the 911 call from Mark Winger. On that call to 911 (at 1:28.08) you can hear Roger Harrington still alive. What's not shared is Mark ended the call to 911 to shoot Roger again. This is why his body is facing the opposite way. Also, the neighbour of the Winger's say she heard a 1st shot and then minutes later, a 2nd shot. This was covered on Forensic Files. Condolences to Sarah-Jane and Roger Harrington's family. Mark Winger deserves life in prison.
My mum died on Christmas Eve just gone .. my parents had been married almost 51yrs .. my dad is heartbroken .. how can anyone do this .. get a divorce 😞
For a minute we thought this was about the show; So sorry for your loss, Claire. see if this brings healing to you and your dad. "I Still Care" Videos by FredGold&LyndaFaye
"The FBI interviewed him for four hours as he babysat his young daughter." BABYSAT?? Since when do we refer to parental care of a child as "babysitting". Of course the question is rhetorical, because if it was the mother at home with the child I'm betting 48 Hours wouldn't even think about saying, "While she babysat her young daughter".
Super odd thing to say. Most widows continue to wear their wedding rings and still consider themselves married until they adjust to the idea that their spouse is gone.
Thank you! I started yelling when I heard them word it like that. Only redeeming possibility is that it was re-aired from years ago, before we started pushing back at fathers not doing any actual fathering, but still, awful.
Oh and third story: 20/20 also does a great job on this story. They also cover how Sarah Jane (Deborah’s mom) and step Dad, Ira, were shut out of Bailey’s life until she was 16 years old. Finally the Nanny mom allowed her to meet her grandparents and now they have a relationship. But Mark basically shut out Deborah’s parents out of Bailey’s life. It totally destroyed them. Also, 20/20 covers the life of the Nanny, which was fascinating (they actually had three biological kids in addition to Bailey).
I actually question if she was even telling the truth. She probably wanted to get him back for breaking up with her or not getting back with her after her supposed friend's death. Also, I'm really suspicious of the detective that changed his mind. The first time, he said the position of Harrington's body completely matched up with what Winger said happened. Now all of a sudden, he's telling a different tale. If we analyzed them and what they say like they do suspects, then that HUGE discrepancy would be a big red flag about the detective. So to be honest, I'm not sure what happened.
Defense attorneys disgust me. Sure, I agree people deserve a fair trial which includes a competent defense. But the things they come up with are ludicrous. They look incredibly foolish 🤦♀️
I know, and it seems so pointless sometimes, but keep in mind that we want criminals to have the best defense they can get! What we DONT WANT, is for they to say their trial was not fair and be able to be set free on a technicality . When there is proof the jury usually get it right.
@@bebitamira3054 I fully understand that and agree, however, the defense should be rational and reasonable which many are not. It’s making a joke of the court systems and often times extremely insulting to the victim. Especially when it’s obvious the defendant did the crime.
@gasmith7486 how is that evil? Under the constitution, everyone is entitled to a defense. You do know that people who can't afford an attorney are appointed a defender by the state,right? Are saying that people should be found guilty (even if they aren't) just because someone of power says they are? Scary that we've had people fight for democracy and so many detest it. Wow
Being a divorced woman for more than 30 years, raising my son alone and dreaming of having had a nice, normal family: how can you do that to the love of your life??? And destroy your children's and so many other lives? She deserves to go to hell.
Yeah I'd like to have a had a nice normal family for my kids too. But, I guess not everyone gets the nice family life. I've learned to just accept that I will never have that. I've also accepted being content with being single.
You sound like me, girl. I raised 3 and always hoped for that too. Now here I am alone. I always wanted that but I feel lucky I didn't run into some sweet talker who would end up killing me or my children.
Second story…. To Beniger’s wife - wake up! He admitted to killing Yvonne- you are seriously waiting for him to get out of prison?! Do you have that low of self esteem.. wake the f up! Love Peter Van Sant btw….. he never gives up.
As sad as it is that the sister passed away, she did what she wanted for her sister and now she is with her sister! RIP!! My heart aches for the only sister a live my condolences!
How shallow is that woman who opened this story It's not about how you look or how beautiful your home is etc it's about the state of mind, my son was gorgeous and everyone wanted to be a part of his life but what they didn't know nor wanted to know was just how disturbed his mind was.
I have 2 ex husbands and wouldn't have killed either even if I knew I could get away with it. As acrimonious as the divorces were I can't imagine doing such a thing. What the hell is wrong with these people!
The “best friend.” Wow.😮 And some wonder why I have trust issues.😞. Glad 48 Hours added this older Winger story to this Marathon. Very baffling, shocking, and revealing.
Beyond crazy. All she had to do was to seek a divorce and she would have free to live with who ever she wants with a multi million dollar settlement without anyone losing their life
Hi I understand how you feel. Sometimes life is more complicated. I am married to a narcissist sociopath. I stayed in the marriage because if I divorced him it would mean I would have no control over who was in my children’s lives. We are now informally separated but I waited until the children were grown. But I do understand how you feel
Mark winger is very arrogant. How could that woman have an affair when her best friend loved her so much. Sad how women betray each other for a wicked man
“Fixated on her phone” is hardly a rare occurrence. Also, not uncommon at all to be watching your home security system either. Not sticking up for her, she’s most definitely guilty.
We had a girl admitted to ER with a black eye, fractured nose, chipped front tooth and a lacerated upper lip which happened when she walked into a telephone pole while fixated on her cell phone. It’s very difficult not to laugh when these things happen. Poor girl was in some major pain.
Poor families of victims… the third family of the murdered driver for no reason broke my heart, they buried him as a murderer and they were shamed over their grief and them knowing he did not do it
So, monica was devastated. Couldn't even talk for 4 days? We were taught in nursing school that oftentimes the people seen to be grieving the most around around a death are the ones with the most ambiguous feelings. I think she was faking it. Defense is doing some insane 😂gaslighting.
As someone who always sobs in response to anyone being born, dying , having a baby , graduating , Getting married I will be uncontrollably crying and seems to be genetic on my Irish side all the men in my family too just lability characteristic but YES performative grief is different which seems more the case here
Ok. That is the most heinous set of circumstances I've seen. The lies! That poor mother & her beautiful baby! Why didn't he just divorce Donnah? Cruelty beyond belief. I'm glad he is locked up until he dies. What a dangerous man. 👹
Nate - I have no words, thank you (it's not enough) for doing this! It has been so enlightening to hear how they felt and what they thought. I pray that they all can have some peace after this difficult job❤ Can't wait to hear the other interviews you got - you are amazing!!
This was a beautiful gift to all who loved treasure hunting. Mr F.F. was such an amazing man. These people wanted the thrill and adventure of being engaged in this true treasure prosperity. ❤❤❤❤❤❤ Wish that I was an adventurous nature wilderness woman. These people are very brave to make the journey. African American woman 50s generation N.J
They offered a plea deal to save money. DISGUSTING. As a taxpayer, I would have gladly help to raise additional funds to have him go to trial on ALL charges. 26 years is a travesty.
The "best friend" in the 3rd story has more on her consciousness. For her to be so broken up about the death of Donna that she "tried to unalive herself" 4×s and was hospitalized, there's more that she's hiding. But Mark is refusing to even admit his guilt so that secret will probably never come out. Also, he's clearly a liar cause he still swearing from prison that he had a "happy and perfect" marriage... yet he was sleeping with his wife's so-called bestie. Plus, the stupidity of the hitman attempt...? Obviously, he's an idiot, regardless of his previous career. 🙄
Monica Sementilli's trial was supposed to have started in April but was delayed AGAIN when the defendants notified the judge there was new evidence that needed review before the trial commenced. The judge said the trial schedule was full and he couldn't delay for the 30 days the defense requested. The trial is now further delayed until later in 2024.
When I was 32 I was very sick and the Dr's gave my parents a zero percent chance of my survival. My body could not make oxygen and I was ventilated for 11 days. I am 66 now and the Dr's told my parents it was nothing they did. My son was 10, and I have thanked Him every day for another day he gave me to raise my child. I told a very religious friend that I searched everyday for what God saved me for. She told me, when God gives you a miracle, he doesn't expect anything from you. I was so relieved and was able to just appreciate my gift from God.
It's okay baby girl, now you are with your sister, she wanted you with her and she took you, now you both can smile together, God bless your soul and your sisters soul
I hope domestic violence victims watching this get encouragement to flee after seeing the outcome of Yvonne's relationship. Being punched in the eye and chocked by a killing machine must have been so painful. Her sister was a true warrior. May they rest in peace.
The district attorney was sweet. This case affected him. He's an empathetic person. He had me crying 😢when he choked up and cried. I pray for all of her family and friends who have been affected by this
I enjoy 48 hours. However, it always amazes me when news media or any media are surprised that people under investigation do not want to talk to them. Anyone with a lick of sense, and certainly their lawyers, know better that to do so. I have no doubt that the very reporters who try it, if in that situation themselves, would never do it either. I understand why they try it, always looking for a scoop. But stop acting befuddled when it doesn't work.
Ugh, yes… I always try to skip that part because it makes me so uncomfortable. So much fake shock at these things that they certainly have a sense of by this point in their careers. It seems so unprofessional and disingenuous. These shows usually contain absurd disbelief and at the same time criticism at liars and people who fake and overdramatize things like 911 calls, and yet they are performing in ways that I can’t imagine come from a genuine place, and that makes me uncomfortable. I think some anchors/hosts do better than others… I miss Harold Dow, he seemed pretty genuine to me.
Same I wish they just left it out considering it didn’t add to anything in the case just shows how journalists/reporters/media love to hound anyone and everyone without a second thought if it gets them a story I wouldve been more interested if they showed more of the sister than that lying murderer
Stress does not cause cancer. It may weaken the immune system which in turn increases the likelihood of contracting the disease, but it does not cause it. Or she may have been so caught up in the search for her sister she neglected the signs and symptoms of cancer until it was too late to effectively treat it.
Michelle was a phenomenal woman to testify against that animal while she was suffering from cancer. He didn't get enough time. He should have received capital punishment.
I am not even 2 min into this one and I am thinking, "Fabio sounds like a REAL cool dude.." and daughters look so sweet in photos--my heart aches for them. Mom is guilty as h#ll.
In the 2nd story, why did that Brian guy get only 27 years for killing, chopping up Yvonne and lying to the FBI? Can someone explain to me which crime qualifies for the life or death sentence?
That man is horrible - killing his girlfriend and her cute dog like that and then sitting across from her sister at a deposition while she’s dying from cancer - disgusting
“Something kind of sexually about him”. As a straight guy I will never understand why women would be attracted to certain guys. This one in particular.
First story is proof that you can give a woman everything, all the money and things she wants and she will still find a way to be unhappy and ruin your life.
I feel like they failed her terribly with that prison sentence. He should've gotten life and then some for the beatings, the dismemberment, the theft, the obstruction and the lying to authorities.
I hate it when people say someone was at the wrong place at the wrong time as the reporter did in the first story at 10:32. That man was at home, where he had a right to be. That cliche puts the blame on the victims for what happened to them. Even those who may be at a store or a gas station... anywhere. The victim had a right to be there.
lol calm down its not that serious. what a weird thing to be bothered by. we know what they meant its not that literal. Its a saying.
So what would an example of "right place at the right time" be?
@@ZNCLinguistics-ne3wp First off, in you trying to be funny, you are actually not making sense. No one says a m*rdered person was at the right place at the right time. Try to think logically instead of using semantics to mock what I said. I am on the side of the victims and this cliche should not be used in that scenario.
@@LeoGirl0727 you're saying that as long as you have the right to be somewhere legally, the phrase "wrong place, wrong time" is offensive. I'm giving you a different perspective. let's say you run into someone in a rush at a Starbucks, and it so happens that he gives you a just-bought lottery ticket because you let him jump the queue. As a result you win 50 million bucks. is there any problem with describing your windfall as the result of your being at the "right place at the right time"?
if there's no problem with that, then there shouldn't be any issue with "wrong place, wrong time".
If you still don't get it... let me simplify. "Wrong place at the wrong time" IS JUST A FIGURE OF SPEECH. It just means BAD LUCK. There aren't any moral undertones about the word "wrong" here. It has the same meaning as "I made a wrong turn" or "I set the alarm clock wrong". Your whole issue with "wrong place, wrong time" is absurd. If you argue it's subjective, my response would be that Americans drive on the "wrong" side of the road.
Remember that diplomat's wife who killed a Brit who was in the wrong place at the wrong time? But she was driving on the wrong side of the road. But she had diplomatic immunity and managed to flee - so right place (foreign country) and right time (within validity of her immunity). If you still can't see that the same word can have different meanings in different contexts, well, I'm probably replying to the wrong comment at the wrong time.
Cheats on her husband with the guy who murdered him. Continues to be with the guy who murdered her husband. Then says she was part of the greatest love story. She is equally as mental as her daughters and her defense lawyer
😢😢😢🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤😮😮😮😮😅😊
I totally agree!
BRAVO!!!!!!! Hit the nail head on. Perfectly said, my thoughts exactly.
I'm not going to say anything about her kids because name 1 kid who wants to believe their mom had their father killed just like no parent would wanna believe their kid is a killer
My darling husband of 45 years died of cancer in late November 2017 and I am still mourning his passing.
It makes me so mad when I hear stories like this. It’s just disgusting to me.
Agree, so sorry for your loss 😢💔🫂🕊🙏🏽🪶
I am saddened to hear of your loss. I lost my sweet Mother in January of 2016 to that nasty C word disease. I too mourn her passing. What gets me through each day are the wonderful memories, and the LOVE. God Bless, from Laura in EU.
@@22ergie Amen. I’m sorry for your pain and sorrow.
I’m soon to be 74 and my dear sweet mother died of C too. She passed in 1981 when I was 31. There are times when I wish I could pick up the phone and call her with some of my questions.
I pray you will find some comfort. 🙏🏻
My condolences
@@karenjohnson1888 thank you dear.
I watch these videos and thank God everyday for my marriage. My husband and I have been married almost 5 years and have been together 7 years. He is my 2nd marriage and I am his first. Im almost 44 and he is 45. We met at the perfect time in our lives and are truly best friends, lovers, and soul mates. He served as a machine gunner in the Marine Corps yet is so incredibly gentle to myself, his daughter from a previous relationship, and my 2 daughters from my previous marriage. I trust him completely and have never once had even the slightest hint that he would ever lift a finger to hurt me. Although I know if it came to defending me or our children he is capable of great violence from his time as a Marine Corps machine gunner in the infantry. In the few heated arguments we have had over the years I have genuinely never had to worry about him harming me physically ( unlike my ex who slapped me several times and would shove me to the ground ). I point this out because while the killer in this video was also in the Marines it doesnt mean that it is common. Military men that serve in combat roles have to be able to be able to do great violence to other humans. Sone of them are unable to compartmentalize that emotion and actions and it is always there and they cant control it. Im glad this killer was caught and I hope he lives out his life in prison in a constant state of misery.
Never say never, I was with mine from 15yrs old, married at 18, divorcing at 56. I once trusted him 100% with my life. I trust NO ONE now!
@@DennisSnuffyexactly!!!
Do you know how many people express this sentiment while unknowingly being cheated on? My goodness! Your take is to defend Marines? So interesting….
@@honeyg3589 .... Slow down... I shared my personal experience that I have lived. I also expressed happiness that the psycho in this video is going to rot in prison. If reading comprehension isn't your strong suit and you can't grasp what someone is saying then don't be that Karen that makes a scene.
Just wait, lol. You'll end up divorcing eventually.
Yvonnes family are heros! They didnt give up on her and they fought for justice. They are still fighting to keep her story alive. Sharing awareness to stop this from happening to other people. We need more people like them. This is what family means!
it’s so unfortunate that her sister died just a few days after testifying and the way he was sending stuff from her computer is disgusting
What I would really like to know is WHY, in this day and age, do people think that they can get away with murdering their spouse? Is it greed? Is it the love of money? GET A DAMN DIVORCE!
It’s ego
It's 50%
It’s greed they want another person of they just plain hate them
@@paullynn4708what’s 50%
Note that not all murders are solved. Every murderer thinks they're smart and will get away with it. They bank on that percentage that never gets caught
What an amazing sister. May they both RIP❤
How could a person be in the wrong place at the wrong time in their own home? I hate that expression.
😊
@user-tz3dy7mt9e then leave! The implication of 'wrong place' implies the victim was an active participant. If I choose to wander down a dark alley in a known drug area, then I have actively made a wrong place decision...sitting at home does not
Yes, indeed. In that case that is not the accurate expression. Somebody else was certainly in the wrong place.
I thought I was hearing things. Exactly, how is being at Yr home - wron g place - obvious right place as organised by monitoring monica
I don't understand how people struggle with this. He is dead. It was definitely not the right place at that exact time. Any other place would have been the right place.
Cannot get enough of these 48 Hours episodes!! 😀💜
bathroom
48 hrs: why should we believe you.
Mark winger: why shouldn’t you believe me.
48 hrs: the jury didn’t.
Damn that was harsh lol 😝
😅😅
Ooh he was so disgusting, right?
And still thinks people are going to fall for his lies!
Hey, Mark, get a clue -- most people cry TEARS when they are crying. His fake crying sounds turned my stomach.
AND HIS FACE WHEN THEY SAID THAT 😂😭
@@JW-vd4il😊😊😊
Maybe it's me but if the man I was in love with, chopped an innocent woman up with a machete after he stabbed her, dumped her in some horrible place and then acted like she ran off with some random person, I would definitely take a hard look at myself as I was getting as far away as possible from that psycho...yet this killers wife stayed and supports that guy, why...
It’s not about you. And, you have no idea what you would do.
@AidaShawJ.D. uh, yea, I do...I keep better company than psychotic abusive murderers...and, last I checked, the comment section is full of opinions, so you have work to do telling everyone it's not about them...
Only a sicko would stay with a murderer and keep defending him. And normal sane people know that they not staying heavy emphasis on NORMAL!
@@AidaShawJ.D. morality & ethics are based on "what would/ should you do"... 🤨 you know this as a (presumed) lawyer
Yvonne's sister Michelle was so amazing fighting to put Yvonne's killer away. So sad for the parents to lose both beautiful daughters.
absolutely
When it showed how quickly she deteriorated from cancer and was still deadset on catching that dude I definitely got a little choked up lol. She was awesome for her sister.
@@taylormajors5677 Same
Rest in peace to both Yvonne and Michelle as well as Yvonne’s poor little puppy which Brian also killed😢😢🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️❤️
26 years what a joke this justice system is
Monica was treated like a queen. She sure didnt deserve him.
Where’s the he chose her? Just like plenty of people tell murdered women who husbands killed them🤔🤔🤔
@@SugaSuga008Was this supposed to be English?
I find it crazy how Kristin Brimager is still married and freaking supports her murderous husband. I think I would get if he maintained his innocence, but he outright confessed to murdering his girlfriend!
Probably for the same reason that women still write to and love convicts: she's plain crazy
Maybe because she doesn't have to sleep with him and gets his military pension. She deserves him.
I think she’s in denial or she had some kinda influence on him
Maybe because she's desperate to hold on to this guy, take a good look at her just saying..
What a SICK woman. Kristen is obviously smart and successful but she knows he killed his ex-girlfriend. That's the crazy part, of course, but on top of that, she chose a pos who played golf all day while she worked and now he sits in federal prison all day while she works. Yeah, what a prize, she needs help.
Defense attorneys should write fiction. I imagine they go home to their spouse and say "of course they're guilty, listen to all this"
They do write fiction lol...they call it opening and closing statements. 😂
@@lotekpro 😂
@@lotekpro 🤭🤣Good one
It's irrelevant if their clients are guilty or not. Think about Lady Justice holding scales, the defense must be as strong as the prosecution. No normal person can sympathize with a killer but your job as an attorney, is to make his defense heard.
@@lotekpro 💯TRUE!
I STILL don't get it, and never will, how anyone can take a life... it's just mind boggling.
1,000 % agree.
Pure EVIL!
That's very common with Affair Psychosis!
@@leojablonski2309 is that more than 100%?
wouldnt it be nice if people just didnt commit adultery
And to think she let her 16 year old daughter discover her murdered father! Pure EVIL!!!
So messed up
And you know she did it that way to keep herself further from the scene
That’s so messed up
& they definitely did it too
No doubt about it
Sick Defense Attorney’s
They were my thoughts,that's just cruel.Not only did she lose her dad ,her last image of her dad is finding his body.😢
still they stand by her. I get they have conflcited emotions as its their only parent left. but damn they must know she is guilty as hell.
Maybe she really didn't have a part in it?
@@kelliebates7643 lmao did you even watch? she is still infatuated with this killer from her prison cell. it was 100% plotted by both.
Why would the narrative say this " Man was in the wrong place at the wrong time " Fabio was in his own HOME!
Cos this programmed is so over dramatised 😂
@amirahnazario7874 on the other hand, his wife was in the 'wrong place all the time'
20yrs together and you are still not safe with your partner..
@@kadiangraham4450 I thought the same thing….very scary to think about
Not if its a psychopath!
@@thetruthwillsetyoufree9209 they don't generally wait 20 years to get rid of obstacles...they are very goal driven
especially if you have life insurance. those dreaded two words in true crime shows
Partner of what? Business? When you marry you gain a Husband or Wife.
When it comes to the black widow it's comforting to know she's been in jail waiting for her trial, which has been delayed due to a choked judicial system. If the jury fail to see the truth and to find her guilty at least she'll have spent at least 8 years behind bars, without all the luxury she never earned or deserved. She turned 50 incarcerated. May Mr. Sementilli rest in peace. He was a ray of sunshine.
Yess!! I agree 100%. 😊
Yup, worst case scenario is she’s broke, old, hayted by all of society, and her boyfriend is stuck in jail. It Could be worse in case she gets off. But her case seems a complete slam dunk, they’ve gotten people with way less obvious evidence to go on.
Only 26 years for brutally killing and dismembering someone?? and then trying to mislead the family! Why would he not get life in prison?
Latino privilege. Or patriarchy privilege? lol
@@RichardWagner-hi4zn get a heart
@@AidaShawJ.D. get a sense of irony
Connections
And lie to fbi 😠
The Donnah Winger case. I don't know why 48 hours never brought up the 911 call from Mark Winger. On that call to 911 (at 1:28.08) you can hear Roger Harrington still alive. What's not shared is Mark ended the call to 911 to shoot Roger again. This is why his body is facing the opposite way. Also, the neighbour of the Winger's say she heard a 1st shot and then minutes later, a 2nd shot. This was covered on Forensic Files.
Condolences to Sarah-Jane and Roger Harrington's family.
Mark Winger deserves life in prison.
My mum died on Christmas Eve just gone .. my parents had been married almost 51yrs .. my dad is heartbroken .. how can anyone do this .. get a divorce 😞
I am sorry for the loss of your precious Mother. God Bless.- Laura in EU
Bless your mom and dad
That’s hard but lovely they had all those years together ❤
God bless you
❤❤❤
For a minute we thought this was about the show;
So sorry for your loss, Claire.
see if this brings healing to you and your dad.
"I Still Care"
Videos by FredGold&LyndaFaye
@@caroljohanson2807❤
Waaw she stayed with him after finding out he chopped his previous wife up with a machete
Just 26 years for chopping up a person is a joke!
Exactly my thoughts!
Omg where was that mentioned yikes
1:16:57 says it right here !
Kristin is one desperate woman to continue to stay with and support that killer!
Yvonne was dismembered and he only received 26 years. How??? Pure evil
He’s white
The greatest love story. What a joke! Monica was cheating!
And Fabio cheated and left his first wife for Monica!
@@xxNinjaclanxx-id9rswow! Karma got him!
R.I.P. YVONNE & MICHELLE ~ TWO GORGEOUS ANGELS WHO WERE TAKEN WAY TOO SOON. ❤❤
Have a nice Saturday evening!
✌️from Sweden ✌️
Happy Saturday morning from the US
Hello to you from Kentucky, USA...
Du också 😊, från Sverige här med.
Hello from Ireland 🇮🇪 nice sunny evening here
@@nancymulvany2045Sláinte!
"The FBI interviewed him for four hours as he babysat his young daughter." BABYSAT?? Since when do we refer to parental care of a child as "babysitting". Of course the question is rhetorical, because if it was the mother at home with the child I'm betting 48 Hours wouldn't even think about saying, "While she babysat her young daughter".
These are all sad obviously, but the second one is extremely sorrowful. Condolences to the family, RIP to the beautiful sisters Yvonne, and Michelle.
Amen 🙏🏼💙
It's sad yet beautiful that Yvonne and her sister has met again in the afterlife
is it called 48 hours because thats how long it takes to watch one episode because of all the adverts ?
Lol😂good one
Premium.. no ads. 😅
And loving it ❤ @@larac.8797
COOORRECT ✅ ✅
Go premium...you'll never go back! ;)
Rest in peace Yvonne and Michelle 💜
Who says "I'm not a wife anymore" right after their husband is murdered. Sounds like "I'm single now".
Right? So strange! I thought the same thing.
It’s not what you say, but how you say it.
Super odd thing to say. Most widows continue to wear their wedding rings and still consider themselves married until they adjust to the idea that their spouse is gone.
Right? I'm a widow now would've made more sense!
Yvonne is so lucky to have s family and sister like her. May them rest in peace. What a evil to do that to her
😂😂😂😂 He sang ‘like a hound dog on a porch’. 😂😂😂😂
Dear CBS: Brian Brimager was not babysitting his own child.
Thank you! I started yelling when I heard them word it like that.
Only redeeming possibility is that it was re-aired from years ago, before we started pushing back at fathers not doing any actual fathering, but still, awful.
@@dop1611Exactly!!
@@dop1611and he was out golfing while his wife was working. I wonder if she still stands behind him
His wife must be totally ignorant , oh that poor puppy died with Yvonne too may they both rest in peace🙏🙏🙏😢😢😢😢
My first thought was the host must not have children. You don't babysit your own children - it's called parenting.
Oh and third story: 20/20 also does a great job on this story. They also cover how Sarah Jane (Deborah’s mom) and step Dad, Ira, were shut out of Bailey’s life until she was 16 years old. Finally the Nanny mom allowed her to meet her grandparents and now they have a relationship. But Mark basically shut out Deborah’s parents out of Bailey’s life. It totally destroyed them. Also, 20/20 covers the life of the Nanny, which was fascinating (they actually had three biological kids in addition to Bailey).
Wow mark a pos father as much as he was a pos husband
Thank you for adding this. I was really wondering what happened!
Schultz only told the truth because Winger ended the affair. She was not a good friend.
She was never a friend, but I agree. She only told the truth because he dumped her.
I actually question if she was even telling the truth. She probably wanted to get him back for breaking up with her or not getting back with her after her supposed friend's death. Also, I'm really suspicious of the detective that changed his mind. The first time, he said the position of Harrington's body completely matched up with what Winger said happened. Now all of a sudden, he's telling a different tale. If we analyzed them and what they say like they do suspects, then that HUGE discrepancy would be a big red flag about the detective. So to be honest, I'm not sure what happened.
Defense attorneys disgust me. Sure, I agree people deserve a fair trial which includes a competent defense. But the things they come up with are ludicrous. They look incredibly foolish 🤦♀️
Most pencil pushers don’t have a lot of sense. Just book smarts and manipulative mind.
I agree Ms. Katie!
I know, and it seems so pointless sometimes, but keep in mind that we want criminals to have the best defense they can get! What we DONT WANT, is for they to say their trial was not fair and be able to be set free on a technicality . When there is proof the jury usually get it right.
@@bebitamira3054 I fully understand that and agree, however, the defense should be rational and reasonable which many are not. It’s making a joke of the court systems and often times extremely insulting to the victim. Especially when it’s obvious the defendant did the crime.
They really are the most despicable people.
Defense attorneys are just insane 🤣🤣🤣
Unfortunately they are just doing what they are paid to do even if they know the suspect is guilty they still have a job to do
That was my next observation. Defense attorneys are psychopaths.
@@kaitlynking3827that’s evil
@gasmith7486 how is that evil? Under the constitution, everyone is entitled to a defense. You do know that people who can't afford an attorney are appointed a defender by the state,right? Are saying that people should be found guilty (even if they aren't) just because someone of power says they are? Scary that we've had people fight for democracy and so many detest it. Wow
I may have read it wrong, but either I’m right or I’m on your side. Give me some time to put this together. And I will have a response.
Being a divorced woman for more than 30 years, raising my son alone and dreaming of having had a nice, normal family: how can you do that to the love of your life??? And destroy your children's and so many other lives? She deserves to go to hell.
Yeah I'd like to have a had a nice normal family for my kids too. But, I guess not everyone gets the nice family life. I've learned to just accept that I will never have that. I've also accepted being content with being single.
? Normal? Most of the murders here are from people they are married to or dating 😂
You sound like me, girl. I raised 3 and always hoped for that too. Now here I am alone. I always wanted that but I feel lucky I didn't run into some sweet talker who would end up killing me or my children.
@@mwahha6965yes? That's what she's talking about.
@@Confessions089 It's not sth you just get. You choose. And you chose wrong. No need making a fate fairy tale out of it. lol
Second story…. To Beniger’s wife - wake up! He admitted to killing Yvonne- you are seriously waiting for him to get out of prison?! Do you have that low of self esteem.. wake the f up! Love Peter Van Sant btw….. he never gives up.
She’s definitely sleeping with another man. She’s staying with him so that she can be entitled to his military benefits.
Like why? What happened to divorce??? These kind of mindsets will never make sense to me
As sad as it is that the sister passed away, she did what she wanted for her sister and now she is with her sister! RIP!! My heart aches for the only sister a live my condolences!
Rip bothamazing ladies ❤❤Yvonne sister is a hero ❤❤
How shallow is that woman who opened this story It's not about how you look or how beautiful your home is etc it's about the state of mind, my son was gorgeous and everyone wanted to be a part of his life but what they didn't know nor wanted to know was just how disturbed his mind was.
I understand what you are conveying but don't forget this program is producex for the masses who generally speaking are shallow and materialistic
@2358H who disturbed here ?
You can't expect anything from women who find it normal to watch a show on their phone wile walking!
@@chloeuntrau4588What?
I understand what you are saying. As you can see from most of these comments youtube is not always a place of thoughtful discourse..
As of June 2024, Monica Sementilli's trial has not started yet.
Thank you
Jail is not working for her. She looks awful, like someone who is in jail.
😂😂😂. She probably doesn’t have access to expensive, professional beauticians and stylists.
I have 2 ex husbands and wouldn't have killed either even if I knew I could get away with it. As acrimonious as the divorces were I can't imagine doing such a thing. What the hell is wrong with these people!
You probably had two broke ex-husbands.
I feel Ive watched every 48hours episode now. I start watching an ep & within 2 minutes Im like oh fck Ive seen this one already.
Hi I actually tick the like button to show me I've seen this one. 🇿🇦🙏
@@CleopatraR-m5p thats a good tip
Fabio’s sister is so dramatic, but in a good way. I could listen to her read the phone book and enjoy every moment.
The “best friend.” Wow.😮 And some wonder why I have trust issues.😞. Glad 48 Hours added this older Winger story to this Marathon. Very baffling, shocking, and revealing.
Beyond crazy. All she had to do was to seek a divorce and she would have free to live with who ever she wants with a multi million dollar settlement without anyone losing their life
Hi
I understand how you feel.
Sometimes life is more complicated.
I am married to a narcissist sociopath. I stayed in the marriage because if I divorced him it would mean I would have no control over who was in my children’s lives.
We are now informally separated but I waited until the children were grown. But I do understand how you feel
Girl, just in case you are tempted, its not worth it. Ok?@@shelteredsparrow2736
Mark winger is very arrogant. How could that woman have an affair when her best friend loved her so much. Sad how women betray each other for a wicked man
The children in this are the ones that truly suffer from a selfish, cruel act such as this. Bless these families.
I've seen the one about Mark Winger killing his wife and blaming Mr Harrington. He was buried as a killer, unable to defend himself
The FBI officers were awesome. They saw how much she missed her sister and stood by her till the end.
Cars and money and a maid is considered "having it all" 😂😂
“Fixated on her phone” is hardly a rare occurrence. Also, not uncommon at all to be watching your home security system either. Not sticking up for her, she’s most definitely guilty.
We had a girl admitted to ER with a black eye, fractured nose, chipped front tooth and a lacerated upper lip which happened when she walked into a telephone pole while fixated on her cell phone. It’s very difficult not to laugh when these things happen. Poor girl was in some major pain.
Poor families of victims… the third family of the murdered driver for no reason broke my heart, they buried him as a murderer and they were shamed over their grief and them knowing he did not do it
Did they ever convict him for murdering the poor man. Think I missed that.
Thanks for sharing this story 😊
48hrs has the best intro music ever!
So, monica was devastated. Couldn't even talk for 4 days? We were taught in nursing school that oftentimes the people seen to be grieving the most around around a death are the ones with the most ambiguous feelings. I think she was faking it. Defense is doing some insane 😂gaslighting.
As someone who always sobs in response to anyone being born, dying , having a baby , graduating , Getting married I will be uncontrollably crying and seems to be genetic on my Irish side all the men in my family too just lability characteristic but YES performative grief is different which seems more the case here
@@lorishu48103 pointless comment to this
I'm a nurse and have never heard such a thing.
@@girlygal098 Also a nurse and also never heard of this.
@texasrefugee78 According to her friend she was "decimated". 😂😂 gotta love when ppl try to sound intellegent and misuse words.
Ok. That is the most heinous set of circumstances I've seen. The lies! That poor mother & her beautiful baby! Why didn't he just divorce Donnah? Cruelty beyond belief. I'm glad he is locked up until he dies. What a dangerous man. 👹
Nate - I have no words, thank you (it's not enough) for doing this! It has been so enlightening to hear how they felt and what they thought. I pray that they all can have some peace after this difficult job❤ Can't wait to hear the other interviews you got - you are amazing!!
26 years for chopping up a human being after you've murdered them?😮😮😮
"Justice".
This was a beautiful gift to all who loved treasure hunting. Mr F.F. was such an amazing man. These people wanted the thrill and adventure of being engaged in this true treasure prosperity. ❤❤❤❤❤❤ Wish that I was an adventurous nature wilderness woman. These people are very brave to make the journey. African American woman 50s generation N.J
They offered a plea deal to save money. DISGUSTING. As a taxpayer, I would have gladly help to raise additional funds to have him go to trial on ALL charges. 26 years is a travesty.
Taking a case to trial comes with the risk of an acquittal. At least with a plea deal, he will serve time.
1:21:32 The seashell that they put Yvonne's remains in and sent into the ocean was absolutely beautiful 😢❤
I think it would be nicer to have kept it.
The "best friend" in the 3rd story has more on her consciousness. For her to be so broken up about the death of Donna that she "tried to unalive herself" 4×s and was hospitalized, there's more that she's hiding. But Mark is refusing to even admit his guilt so that secret will probably never come out. Also, he's clearly a liar cause he still swearing from prison that he had a "happy and perfect" marriage... yet he was sleeping with his wife's so-called bestie. Plus, the stupidity of the hitman attempt...? Obviously, he's an idiot, regardless of his previous career. 🙄
Monica Sementilli's trial was supposed to have started in April but was delayed AGAIN when the defendants notified the judge there was new evidence that needed review before the trial commenced. The judge said the trial schedule was full and he couldn't delay for the 30 days the defense requested. The trial is now further delayed until later in 2024.
Really? I didn't know that. So when is it supposed to start now?
When I was 32 I was very sick and the Dr's gave my parents a zero percent chance of my survival. My body could not make oxygen and I was ventilated for 11 days. I am 66 now and the Dr's told my parents it was nothing they did. My son was 10, and I have thanked Him every day for another day he gave me to raise my child. I told a very religious friend that I searched everyday for what God saved me for. She told me, when God gives you a miracle, he doesn't expect anything from you. I was so relieved and was able to just appreciate my gift from God.
God is all made up fiction. Grow up ffs.
It's okay baby girl, now you are with your sister, she wanted you with her and she took you, now you both can smile together, God bless your soul and your sisters soul
I hope domestic violence victims watching this get encouragement to flee after seeing the outcome of Yvonne's relationship. Being punched in the eye and chocked by a killing machine must have been so painful. Her sister was a true warrior. May they rest in peace.
Watching so many true crime stories , showing people are getting married to the most dangerous people in their lives
like a hound dog on a porch lmao MAN I LOVE THAT DUDE
The district attorney was sweet. This case affected him. He's an empathetic person. He had me crying 😢when he choked up and cried. I pray for all of her family and friends who have been affected by this
I enjoy 48 hours. However, it always amazes me when news media or any media are surprised that people under investigation do not want to talk to them. Anyone with a lick of sense, and certainly their lawyers, know better that to do so. I have no doubt that the very reporters who try it, if in that situation themselves, would never do it either. I understand why they try it, always looking for a scoop. But stop acting befuddled when it doesn't work.
Ugh, yes… I always try to skip that part because it makes me so uncomfortable. So much fake shock at these things that they certainly have a sense of by this point in their careers. It seems so unprofessional and disingenuous. These shows usually contain absurd disbelief and at the same time criticism at liars and people who fake and overdramatize things like 911 calls, and yet they are performing in ways that I can’t imagine come from a genuine place, and that makes me uncomfortable. I think some anchors/hosts do better than others… I miss Harold Dow, he seemed pretty genuine to me.
Same I wish they just left it out considering it didn’t add to anything in the case just shows how journalists/reporters/media love to hound anyone and everyone without a second thought if it gets them a story I wouldve been more interested if they showed more of the sister than that lying murderer
It’s perfect actually. It’s the intrusion into their personal space that widens the cloud of the suspicion for the on lookers. Pressure bursts pipes.
Her sister is amazing ❤hope they both RIP
The trauma and struggle for the search of her sister caused her the cancer. Beautiful sister. Both of them...
Tough lady. But yes it killed her finally.
Stress does not cause cancer. It may weaken the immune system which in turn increases the likelihood of contracting the disease, but it does not cause it. Or she may have been so caught up in the search for her sister she neglected the signs and symptoms of cancer until it was too late to effectively treat it.
Good story document
Very interesting and alarming trend I see in these cases…. The young adult children stand by the murderer parent.
Same with Chad Daybell's kids. They are blind to the mountain of incriminating evidence against him.
Michelle was a phenomenal woman to testify against that animal while she was suffering from cancer. He didn't get enough time. He should have received capital punishment.
48 hour. Is good tv show i love that tv show im a fan
Sounds like investigators are good people thank you
Why is it so difficult to get justice!
Nah she guilty af! No way that attorney even believes the BS she’s spewing
saying that the country is an ugly & dangerous place wasn't nice of them. It was BRIAN who is ugly. Not the country. Glad he got locked up.
Why would anyone date a sex offender
They are damaged themselves with very low self worth!
Women marry them.
I am not even 2 min into this one and I am thinking, "Fabio sounds like a REAL cool dude.." and daughters look so sweet in photos--my heart aches for them. Mom is guilty as h#ll.
that woman is soooooo wrong …. someone giving the convicted killer the code to enter her home is big
Wow, imagine killing loved ones and then going about your merry way to shop or play golf...that's cold
In the 2nd story, why did that Brian guy get only 27 years for killing, chopping up Yvonne and lying to the FBI? Can someone explain to me which crime qualifies for the life or death sentence?
That man is horrible - killing his girlfriend and her cute dog like that and then sitting across from her sister at a deposition while she’s dying from cancer - disgusting
“Something kind of sexually about him”. As a straight guy I will never understand why women would be attracted to certain guys. This one in particular.
As a female, I honestly can't see anything attractive about him. 🤔
First story is proof that you can give a woman everything, all the money and things she wants and she will still find a way to be unhappy and ruin your life.
Your comment sound bitter!
He cheated on his 1st wife wnd dumped her for Monica. Proof that got what he deserved
Yuck searching through those swamps in Panama I would be terrified😢
Exactly. Must have been sweltering, as they were fully clothed, plus wellingtons.
I feel like they failed her terribly with that prison sentence. He should've gotten life and then some for the beatings, the dismemberment, the theft, the obstruction and the lying to authorities.
She was absolutely cheated in life and in death. So incredibly sad.
De@th penalty
This is why there should be legal consequences for affairs…they always result in harming someone …