Thanks for the report. Missing is info on how well the width continues forward into the toe box. Some might be wide at the ball, but then narrow quickly forward into pointy toe boxes. Also, the circumference within the shoe is important, as the maximum width doesn't always translate into a roomy volume.
Yeah, true enough. Solution: Follow me on Instagram @BarefootShoeJosh -- I pretty much always post a pic of the shoes from both above and below, so you can discern the shape for yourself.
I made this video before Realfoot was known really. I recently reviewed them, and they took #1 slot. You also missed Wyde which would probably be #2. Peluva and Ahinsa have been hard to work with as companies, so I haven't reviewed them. No(n) shoes has been completely unresponsive to my contact attempts. Be Lenka is up there on the list, whereas their sister company Barebarics is narrower (Both of these are on this video). Agreed on Softstar Primal (they're on this video). However, Luks and Bohempia are both wider than Softstar, Be Lenka, Barebarics, or most of the others. Thanks for commenting!
@@travispfeifer1979 I didn't forget them.. they didn't make my list. My list for 2024 is going to have a few upsets as well. There are a few new ones making the list that will shift things around quite a bit!
Can't speak to the other brands, but Be Lenka and Lems are good for those beginning their transition back to barefoot with Be Lenka being slightly wider (in my experience). The widest I've owned to date is Softstar primal, which so far is the only shoe wide enough to accommodate CorrectToes, but the sizing can be confusing, especially with one foot being larger than the other. I ordered a size up w/ Softstar and haven't had any issues since. They also use reuseable velcro packaging, which I had never seen before.
Lems are upper average width on the barefoot shoe width spectrum; but they actually have 3 different widths, depending on which model. I own a pair and like them OK; but because of the significant variance between their 3 width and the possible confusion this could cause, I didn't include them on this list. My Primal 2 are their widest width, and they look to be about 10.6 cm or so. My Be Lenka are 10.8 cm wide (and with a 6mm stack height, they are good for beginners and experienced barefooters alike IMHO), and my Softstar Primal Sawyers in their WIDE width are 11.1 cm.. so it's only 3mm difference between the two. Freet is between those two at 10.9 cm. The widest ones on my list here are Bohempia and Luks, at 11.2 cm, and they both accommodate higher volume as well as width. A couple of other extra wide brands have come out recently. I'm thinking of Wyde Footwear and Realfoot, off the top of my head; but as yet, I have been unable to get an affiliate relationship established with them, or review their shoes--although I hope to in the near future. Thanks for commenting!
I just put in another order for softstar primal shoes, but it's good to know that there are a few wider options out there. I wish you would have shown the bottom of the shoes so I could see the shape better
I tried to with several of them but I'm sure I missed a couple.. but as I mentioned a couple of times on the video.. I have individual reviews on all of these shoes on the channel where I probably did remember to show the soles.. and if I didn't, check the review for that shoe on my Instagram channel @BarefootShoeJosh, where I almost always have a pic of the soles. Best of luck finding something that suits your feet!
For EU customers I can recommend Aylla Shoes (CZ) with 112 mm of width in 44. Besides that Ahinsa (CZ) has a extra wide line of shoes from sandals to dressing shoes that have a inner width of 128 mm in 44.
No prob but I think I will be making a newer version of this video this year, as there are a few newer companies that have joined the "widest" rankings--some of which have actually taken the lead. Stay tuned! If you grab some Bohempias, please use my link bit.ly/bohempiajosh Thanks much!
@@pisarpisar9115 Get the one you like! :) bit.ly/bohempiajosh I've reviewed both their Hoska and Kolda models here on the channel. The Hoska is my fave. But they also have another couple of models I would like to try... Let me know how it goes!
Got them 2 days ago and i’m with you -> best barefoot shoes for me now! Love them 💚 Finally found perfect match after 2 years of serching through many brands Can’t wait for your updated video of widest shoes I also bought Freet Talus 3 which is also amazing! Looks like you are my favorite barefood guru 🥹
I think it's important to specify where the shoes are wide. Some have really wide toe boxes but are really narrow in the mid foot area. Many shoes that have enough room in the mid foot area aren't wide enough across the ball of the foot.
Hey, love the video. What are some shoes you recommend if I have extra wide feet in the toe area specially, that I can wear everywhere anytime that also look good and are relatively durable?
Hi.. for now, check out these 5 companies and see if you can find a shoe that meets your needs: * REALFOOT - my affiliate link: bit.ly/joshrealfoot * WYDE - my affiliate link: bit.ly/joshwyde * SOFTSTAR SHOES - my affiliate link: bit.ly/softstarjosh (specifically, look at their PRIMAL line) * BOHEMPIA - my affiliate link: bit.ly/bohempiajosh (specifically order their WIDE width) * LUKS - my affiliate link: bit.ly/joshluks and the 10% discount code is JOSHBAREFOOT I think those are your best bet as far as off-the-shelf shoes. Otherwise, you can do custom. Check out my reviews on Drifter Leather and Prime Trotter for examples. I have another custom extra-wide (especially in the toes) review coming for you within the next month or two as well!
this was super helpful and since you've tested so many of them any chance you know which brand has the thinnest / softest / most flexible sole? ideally something like the skinners and power socks but with a top that's more of a shoe?
Hi thanks for commenting.. I'd say the Freet Talus 3 is the most like what you seem to be describing.. Here's the link to my review of it: ruclips.net/video/W09kIoU_hH4/видео.html If you grab a pair, please use my affiliate link: bit.ly/joshfreet and use my discount code JB10 to get 10% OFF!
Exactly my question! What is the widest barefoot shoe - thanks for doing this review!!! I'm new to this, so I started with a pair of Whitin shoes from Amazon with the thought - don't spend a fortune on my first shoes, and see if I like it first. I ordered my size (US 12), but they were no wider than my regular shoes.
Well hopefully I answered your question in this video and gave you some good companies and/or shoe models to check out. If you found this helpful, please use my affiliate links and/or discount codes wherever possible! Thank you in advance!
I mentioned very briefly in the video that I wear 44 or 45 in all of these shoes... which is one of the many reasons to take the precise measurement with a grain of salt.. but the overall point of these being the widest barefoot brands holds mostly true, in my opinion.
@Josh's Barefoot Shoes Reviews yeah fair enough, the order you gave gives an idea of the width in relation to each other, I just wanted to compare some shoes I have with the width measurements you gave to see how my shoes compare to see how much more width I'd be getting by trying those other brands. The only brand on your list I have is Freet so I can use that as a reference point.
Came to this video after you suggested it in another video. I have printed out the insole charts for any company that offers, still too narrow, lol. Bohempia in size 45 is about as close to width and length as I can get and according to the template it is a no go. The issue isn't the toe box. My left foot is a solid 4E and my right foot is pushing wider. That and I have a really wide midfoot and forefoot, more so than my toe splay. I really wish some of these companies would release an extra wide last rather than just an extra wide toe box. As an aside, of the shoes I have tried I have found them to all run short. I'm a 10 4E in New Balance and an 11 in Lems (and I could probably be more comfortable in a 12) and a 12 in Xero. This is just the length, as both Lems and Xero are too narrow but just to give an idea. Not being able to try shoes on in person is a pain, lol. I'll keep watching along in hopes that someday one of these companies releases an extra wide shoe. Until then Jim Green is what I am going to try next. Supposedly a 3E, stich down, barefoot boot and all of the should mean a wider fit.
Hi there. Here's what I can tell you . If you are fitting into New Balance (narrow), Xero (narrow) and Lems (medium), virtually any of the shoes in this review are wider. The shoe outlines can be a bit deceptive, as they are essentially the outline of the insole--which isn't all there is to it in terms of width in the actual fit. Very important is volume and the flexibility or "give" in the material on the sides of the shoe. Also, as another detail. Bohempia has two widths, so be sure you look at their "Wide" width. If you fit Lems or NB, Bohempia's wide width has more space than either of those. Unfortunately, saying things like 4E isn't specific enough for me to offer much help. Instead, please tell me: * How long is your longest foot, in centimeters/mm? * How wide is your foot at the widest point of your forefoot, in centimeters/mm? * Is your foot low, medium, or high in VOLUME? * What is the shape of your foot (slope, plateau, mountain, or square? Answer these and I can possibly be of more assistance, if needed...
@@barefootshoejosh I wouldn't call a 4/6E (double extra wide) new Balance narrow anywhere outside of the toe box. My 10 4E insole is MUCH bigger than my Lems 11 at the mid and forefoot and identical in length. Without socks I am 27.5 cm length by 11.43 cm wide, which on the Bohempia chart puts me at a 43(ish) length and between a 46-47 in wide width. But by the printout I think a lot of the issue is the shape of my foot. Their shoes are kidney bean shaped and mine is like a splitting wedge, lol. Anyway, the problem is I don't really fit in Lem's, which is why I don't love mine. an 11 is the right length but they are way too narrow. A 12 is closer but way too long. I've bought shoes that are too long for like 30 years to get my feet into them, sadly. Mountain shape, high arches, and overall high volume. Anyway, I apricate the help. Like I said, trying these things on in person would be so much better but with small companies it doesn't really work that way. Edit: I forgot to mention that a Luna Origin Lite in size 11 is almost a perfect fit or as close to one as I have ever had. Idk if that helps or not.
@@kitcraft9516 helpful info. I am 11.1 x 27cm, medium-high volume/arches, and mountain shaped--so our feet are very similar, I am just a size or 1/2 size smaller. Like you, I probably go longer than I need to for the sake of gaining width. I wear Bohempia Hoskas in size 44W, and they are an amazing fit. I also have their Kolda model which has a hair less volume, but still comfortable for me. If you want to ask about another specific shoe, feel free.
@@barefootshoejosh Thank you. I am chasing that Converse look so the Orik 2.0 is what I am looking at. In my teens I wore my converse 2 sizes too big. I wouldn't try that now. Narrowness aside the squishy insoles destroy my arches. Anyway, I am kind of curious about the Vivo Gobi boot. I hear it is pretty wide for a Vivo. I need to add an unlined 6(ish) inch boot to my lineup. Thank you again for taking the time, I really do apricate your videos and responses.
@@kitcraft9516 I have a pair of dark blue Vivobarefoot Gobis. I reviewed them here on the channel a long time ago. They fit pretty comfortably, although Vivo is toward the narrower end of the spectrum. These seem to be not bad. They are kind of a "mid" height boot, and the top edge of the boot touches me in a way that I don't love, but I think that's more me and my sensory issues than it is the boot. Meanwhile the brown chelsea boot I reviewed from Atlantis handmade feels great to me (reviewed here on the channel). I also have an unlined black leather chelsea boot made custom from The Drifter Leather (also reviewed here on the channel), which is like butta. But yeah, the Vivo Gobi's width isn't terrible.
I’m thinking about buying Splay and have few question to the expert :) I’m wearing Bohempia 45W 1. what size should I order in Splay Freestyle? 2. are Splay also so comfortable or not worth buying (comparing to Bohempia)? I have only one shot as i will be ordering Splay from US so no chance to send it back :(
Hi.. rather than telling me your Bohempia size, please tell me your foot length in centimeters, and the width at the widest point of the forefoot. Also what is your foot shape (slope, plateau, mountain, square), and are you low/med/high volume?
@@pisarpisar9115 My Splay Freestyle lace-ups are 10.8cm wide and comfortable medium volume. My Bohempia are 11.2 cm wide and slightly higher volume. So if you have a little extra room to spare in your Bohempias, then you should be fine with Splay LACE-UPs, and they are about half the price. However, Splay slip-ons are lower volume, and significantly tighter. I ended up giving them to my son because I couldn't wear them.
@@pisarpisar9115 There is no direct conversion from Bohempia sizing to Splay sizing. Best thing to do is measure your feet, length and width, look at Splay's sizing chart, and follow their guidance. My guess is you'll be like a 12 or so, but I don't want to pick wrong for you. Please use my link bit.ly/splayjosh and use code JOSHBAREFOOT to save 10%
I think I screwed up. I've never ordered a European shoe and I ordered a pair of be lenka shoes last night in 42 and I think I need 45. Im A size 10 1/2 US. Any advice?
I would reach out to them immediately by multiple means (phone, email, webchat or anything they have available) and try to catch them before they ship.
@@frankietomecek6712 as I mentioned, their customer service is best to ask in this case. However, the best thing to do, for future reference, is to trace your feet, then measure your length and width in centimeters. Know your measurements. I wear three different European sizes (44, 45 and 46) depending on the shoe and manufacturer. So get to know your foot measurements. Then when you go to buy shoes, look at the shoe company's sizing chart/guide. Allow approximately 1.5 cm extra length for wiggle/swell room, and get the size that would accommodate you best.
It's not just you, I've seen various people online say Bohempias are wider than Softstar Primals. May vary according to size, but for me, the Softstars are wider and much more comfortable as such. I've reached a point where the Softstars are all I want to wear. Elsewhere in these comments, I've said Lems work for me. They don't now. After sustained use of the Softstars, everything else feels too narrow. I just wish I could get (a) a vegan shoe or boot that was as wide as the Softstars and (b) that it could have at least a little grip. The Softstar Sawyers are smooth and I've often come close to slipping over in the rain in them. Despite my veganism, I may have to get a pair of Softstar's Switchback boots for winter and other wet days. Before anyone suggests them, I've tried two vegan brands that might appear to meet all my criteria: Ahimsa and Realfoot. Nope. Ahimsa use a vegan 'leather' that's too hard and too obviously, and unbreathably, plastic and the wide version are not as wide as they claimed on the website, not even measuring by the outsole. I pointed this out to them and they said they'd made a mistake. Realfoot looked like the great hope, but they're not and it's odd. The main thing that makes them look so wide is that the heel is very narrow, so it's a pronounced V-shape overall. They also have measurements on the website that could be said to be misleading: the diagram shows it, but it's easy to miss: the measurement is a somewhat arbitrary diagonal, meaning that straight across, the measurement comes out smaller. So while other brands are scared that wide-looking shoes will scare off the customers, this one seems to be wearing it as a badge of honour - without doing it properly. Shame, because the sole is great, both for ground feel and grip.
I hear you man. I will say this though. The last time I put on my Softstar Sawyers, believe it or not, I felt limited in the width... but when I put on my Bohempia Hoska, I don't feel that same restriction. I still do love my Softstars though, as they are definitely in the top wide companies. You might want to check out Wyde at my affiliate link: bit.ly/joshwyde Also, I have a couple of other wide reviews coming pretty soon. Stay tuned!
@@barefootshoejosh Weird and interesting. I guess it may just come down to the specifics of different foot shapes. I may try some Wydes at some point. I've been disappointed so many times before that I've almost given up, but I'll check out your review of them.
@@barefootshoejosh Ah, I guess you haven't reviewed Wyde yet. But I given that, in my size, the insole measurement is wider than that for Sawyers, and that sole looks grippy, these could be winners. Also seems very clear they've accounted for the need for big toe splay, which, as I've mentioned before, is unusual.
What is the widest shoe that ALSO has support for a high arch(Edit: I meant bridge)? Because all the ones I've tried(barefoot) are all so restrictive on the arch that I can't get my foot into them
@@barefootshoejosh Yes, sorry, English isn't my first language so I used the wrong term. It's the bridge I was referring to. My bridge is so high that when I was trying all these different barefoot shoes I couldn't get into them without sizing up to the point of having the whole toebox dangling at the front by itself, empty and alone :D My problem is 3-fold. Very short foot (EU 41), very wide as well (there exist no shoes currently in my length that are wide enough, that I have found), and and absurdly high bridge :D
@@freyrh3582 Well here are some things to consider trying: • Bohempia - Please use my link bit.ly/bohempiajosh • Softstar Shoes - Please use my link bit.ly/softstarjosh • Freet Footwear - Please use my link bit.ly/joshfreet and use code JB10 to save 10% Alternatively, you may want to do something CUSTOM. CUSTOM SHOES/SANDALS FOR ANY WIDTH YOU NEED: • The Drifter Leather - Link: www.thedrifterleather.com/ • Prime Trotter - Link: primetrotter.bigcartel.com • Deliberate Life Designs - Use link www.deliberatelifedesigns.com and Use code JOSHBAREFOOT at checkout to save 10% • Paisley Running Sandals - Link: paisleyrunningsandals.com If you want to see my recent video that features all of these: ruclips.net/video/DPvEa7grwOQ/видео.html I hope something here helps you!
Hey! What happened to Unshoes Terravida? Just watched your video on those and you said they'd be in this rundown. Certainly sounds as if they deserve to be.
John! Dammit! You are absolutely right, and this was a complete oversight on my part!!! Ugh. My Unshoes Terra VIda comes in at like 10.5 cm, so it should be in this list. Somehow I just didn't come across them when I was doing my planning for this video. Horrible!! I added it into the appropriate slot in the Video Description. Thanks so much for calling this to my attention.
@@barefootshoejosh Ha. 'Dammit!' is exactly what I thought you'd say, probably because I would've too. Happens to the best of us -as well as to me. Oh well. With any luck, in a year or so there'll be new super-wide barefoot shoes available and it'll be time for an update.
@@JohnMoseley Yeah we'll see if I do another one of these in a year.. this one was a pain. But the good news is that I can get it right on Instagram! Thanks again..
Well in the barefoot world, we're normally looking for THINNER soles, so this is an unusual question. Of the shoes included in this video, here are the top 3 thickest: * Unshoes - 7mm * Splay Athletics - 6.5mm (this brand's sole thickness varies, depending on the shoe's SIZE though...) * Saguaro - 6mm There are other shoes reviewed here on the channel with thicker soles as well. Just a few examples: * Atlantis Handmade - 7mm (or 9-10mm if you add the rubber sole option) * Bahé - 10mm * Flux Adapt Runner - 22mm * Flux Adapt Trainer - 10mm * Lems Primal 2 - 9mm * Softstar Switchback - 9mm I hope this helps you. If this is helpful, and you end up buying any of these, please use my affiliate link and/or discount code from the video description on the review so you can save some money, and it helps me out as well. Thank you!
@barefootshoejosh I ask because I was playing basketball in whittins trail runners, I think. I came down from a jump and bruised my foot. I need something for playing basketball on a concrete court. I been wearing barefoot shoes for a 2 1/2 years
@@GG-zk2xm OK gotcha. You might look at my reviews of Origo Shoes Everyday Sneaker, and Flux Footwear's Adapt Trainer. I have another shoe I'm reviewing pretty soon that would be applicable here as well.
@@GG-zk2xm Hi yes.. that's correct. Flux suddenly changed to a different affiliate program, and I haven't gotten the new one to work correctly yet. I'm trying to communicate with the program people (not Flux), but as of right now, it's not working. My apologies. Will continue to try to get it going.
Oh, but I would beg to differ. Yes yours are wide feet, but custom shoes can fit you just fine. I mentioned a few in the video: CUSTOM SHOES/SANDALS FOR ANY WIDTH YOU NEED: • The Drifter Leather - Link: www.thedrifterleather.com/ • Prime Trotter - Link: primetrotter.bigcartel.com • Deliberate Life Designs - Use link www.deliberatelifedesigns.com and Use code JOSHBAREFOOT at checkout to save 10% • Paisley Running Sandals - Link: paisleyrunningsandals.com ...and there are several others out there I didn't mention. I should be doing two more custom shoes reviews pretty soon, and one of them mostly makes women's shoes... Stay tuned!
Thanks for this rundown - and for stating upfront just how big a deal this is for a lot of us. Given how many people are - sometimes desperately - looking for the widest possible barefoot shoes, it's absolutely amazing to me how few companies are filling this gap. Absent the webbing, I'm a total duck foot: 26cm long, almost 12cm when fully splayed, but closer to 11 normally. Here's my little take: I have two pairs of Softstar Sawyers and I love them. Didn't know anyone else was going that wide, let alone a tiny bit wider. Interested in some Bohempia's now, especially as I've recently gone vegan and will probably never buy another pair of leather shoes. I wish Softstar would do a canvas version of the Sawyers. Used to be a big fan of Freet too, but eventually came to feel I wanted more space for my big toe to splay. Freet do make great shoes, but share a blindspot with a lot of other manufacturers on big toe splay. Also, Josh, to back up your point on how measurements aren't everything, Freet actually provide width measurements on their site, but it can be misleading. Their Connects are technically a little narrower than their Tangas, but because of the material of the uppers, I found the Connects felt much wider - and very comfortable - but couldn't wear the Tangas. Other than that, I lived in my Lems Boulder Boots this winter. Would love a wider version, but they didn't hurt my feet. And Lems Primal 2s actually seem to be wider and offer me enough space.
John--Great comments here. I agree that this is a gap that needs to be filled. Even among these top 10 widest companies, only three of them "technically" are wide enough for my feet according to their listed measurements (Bohempia's WIDE WIDTH shoes, Softstar's primal line, and Luks Shoes. If you're going to check out Bohempias for your feet, you're going to want the WIDE WIDTH, specifically. I agree on the big toe side of the Freets (and almost every other barefoot brand for that matter).. that they should probably allow for more splay, and agree that there is variance in fit between models because of the various materials.. Have you tried the Talus 3 slip-ons? They're not for everyone, but those are potentially the most comfortable and most minimalist shoes I own, and the material has plenty of give so they feel even wider. I have some Lems Primal 2s and they fit OK, but several others I have seem to fit wider for me. I have never owned any of their Boulder Boots though.. they've always looked interesting to me, but I'm not a huge boot-wearer (except for occasional rougher hiking) due to living in San Diego where it's pretty temperate most of the time. Thanks again for the comments!
@@barefootshoejosh Yeah, the boulder boots are lined and probably wouldn't work in hot weather. They're also not very grippy, so barely suitable for hiking. But they were great for being out on a bike or walking in the city in cold weather. I did get the Talus slip-ons at one point. As you suggest, they may have some claim to be the world's most minimalist shoe. But, another tricky sizing matter: I got the same size that had worked for me perfectly with the Connects, but it was too big in the Talus, and I was worried that smaller would be too narrow, even with the very socklike upper, so I opted to return them for a refund. Might try again sometime soon, based on how good you make them sound. Thanks for the advice on the Bohempia wide models. A bit more info for anyone else interested: the website's mildly confusing on this: unlike with Softstar, there's no specific feature for choosing width, it's all just part of one sizing menu: 43, 43w etc.
@@christianlangfield9303 That's really interesting about the Talus. I don't quite know what to make of that. Given that it's a shoe with no lacing and a very soft upper, it was absolutely clear that size 43, which was my size in Connect, wasn't going to stay on my feet with Talus. Sorry you've had these quality control issues with Freet. Hadn't heard that from anyone else or experienced it, and they were helpful with my Talus return, even giving me a discount on my next purchase, but not saying any of that to deny your experience.
@John Moseley on a more positive note the Talus 3 makes a great indoor slipper, been wearing them all this winter. Wouldn't want to wear them outside though unless I was appearing as an extra in a Chinese martial arts film!
Thanks for the report. Missing is info on how well the width continues forward into the toe box. Some might be wide at the ball, but then narrow quickly forward into pointy toe boxes. Also, the circumference within the shoe is important, as the maximum width doesn't always translate into a roomy volume.
Yeah, true enough. Solution: Follow me on Instagram @BarefootShoeJosh -- I pretty much always post a pic of the shoes from both above and below, so you can discern the shape for yourself.
The widest are Realfoot, FiveFingers, Peluva, Belenka/Barbarics, SoftStar Primal, Ahinsa, No(n)shoes. All others are less wide.
I made this video before Realfoot was known really. I recently reviewed them, and they took #1 slot. You also missed Wyde which would probably be #2. Peluva and Ahinsa have been hard to work with as companies, so I haven't reviewed them. No(n) shoes has been completely unresponsive to my contact attempts. Be Lenka is up there on the list, whereas their sister company Barebarics is narrower (Both of these are on this video). Agreed on Softstar Primal (they're on this video). However, Luks and Bohempia are both wider than Softstar, Be Lenka, Barebarics, or most of the others. Thanks for commenting!
You forgot Lems.
@@travispfeifer1979 I didn't forget them.. they didn't make my list. My list for 2024 is going to have a few upsets as well. There are a few new ones making the list that will shift things around quite a bit!
@travispfeifer1979 lems feel like they got narrower to me with my new pair of the same style 😢
Can't speak to the other brands, but Be Lenka and Lems are good for those beginning their transition back to barefoot with Be Lenka being slightly wider (in my experience). The widest I've owned to date is Softstar primal, which so far is the only shoe wide enough to accommodate CorrectToes, but the sizing can be confusing, especially with one foot being larger than the other. I ordered a size up w/ Softstar and haven't had any issues since. They also use reuseable velcro packaging, which I had never seen before.
Lems are upper average width on the barefoot shoe width spectrum; but they actually have 3 different widths, depending on which model. I own a pair and like them OK; but because of the significant variance between their 3 width and the possible confusion this could cause, I didn't include them on this list. My Primal 2 are their widest width, and they look to be about 10.6 cm or so.
My Be Lenka are 10.8 cm wide (and with a 6mm stack height, they are good for beginners and experienced barefooters alike IMHO), and my Softstar Primal Sawyers in their WIDE width are 11.1 cm.. so it's only 3mm difference between the two. Freet is between those two at 10.9 cm. The widest ones on my list here are Bohempia and Luks, at 11.2 cm, and they both accommodate higher volume as well as width.
A couple of other extra wide brands have come out recently. I'm thinking of Wyde Footwear and Realfoot, off the top of my head; but as yet, I have been unable to get an affiliate relationship established with them, or review their shoes--although I hope to in the near future.
Thanks for commenting!
I just put in another order for softstar primal shoes, but it's good to know that there are a few wider options out there.
I wish you would have shown the bottom of the shoes so I could see the shape better
I tried to with several of them but I'm sure I missed a couple.. but as I mentioned a couple of times on the video.. I have individual reviews on all of these shoes on the channel where I probably did remember to show the soles.. and if I didn't, check the review for that shoe on my Instagram channel @BarefootShoeJosh, where I almost always have a pic of the soles. Best of luck finding something that suits your feet!
Thanks Josh, very good explanation.
Thanks.. I hope it helped you in some way!
For EU customers I can recommend Aylla Shoes (CZ) with 112 mm of width in 44.
Besides that Ahinsa (CZ) has a extra wide line of shoes from sandals to dressing shoes that have a inner width of 128 mm in 44.
Yes I contacted Ahinsa, they are pretty nice shoes but their affiliate situation wasn't good, so I stopped pursuing them.
This is video i needed
Thx my friend!
I’m in the process of ordering Bohempia shoes but will try other one too 🤝
No prob but I think I will be making a newer version of this video this year, as there are a few newer companies that have joined the "widest" rankings--some of which have actually taken the lead. Stay tuned! If you grab some Bohempias, please use my link bit.ly/bohempiajosh Thanks much!
Cool, can’t wait for new list
Looks like link is taking me to Bohempia site…what i will get if i use it?
+ it would be cool to do the lightest (in terms of heat) shoes for summer time
@@pisarpisar9115 Get the one you like! :) bit.ly/bohempiajosh
I've reviewed both their Hoska and Kolda models here on the channel. The Hoska is my fave. But they also have another couple of models I would like to try... Let me know how it goes!
Got them 2 days ago and i’m with you -> best barefoot shoes for me now! Love them 💚
Finally found perfect match after 2 years of serching through many brands
Can’t wait for your updated video of widest shoes
I also bought Freet Talus 3 which is also amazing!
Looks like you are my favorite barefood guru 🥹
I think it's important to specify where the shoes are wide. Some have really wide toe boxes but are really narrow in the mid foot area. Many shoes that have enough room in the mid foot area aren't wide enough across the ball of the foot.
true!
Hey, love the video. What are some shoes you recommend if I have extra wide feet in the toe area specially, that I can wear everywhere anytime that also look good and are relatively durable?
Hi.. for now, check out these 5 companies and see if you can find a shoe that meets your needs:
* REALFOOT - my affiliate link: bit.ly/joshrealfoot
* WYDE - my affiliate link: bit.ly/joshwyde
* SOFTSTAR SHOES - my affiliate link: bit.ly/softstarjosh (specifically, look at their PRIMAL line)
* BOHEMPIA - my affiliate link: bit.ly/bohempiajosh (specifically order their WIDE width)
* LUKS - my affiliate link: bit.ly/joshluks and the 10% discount code is JOSHBAREFOOT
I think those are your best bet as far as off-the-shelf shoes. Otherwise, you can do custom. Check out my reviews on Drifter Leather and Prime Trotter for examples. I have another custom extra-wide (especially in the toes) review coming for you within the next month or two as well!
this was super helpful and since you've tested so many of them any chance you know which brand has the thinnest / softest / most flexible sole? ideally something like the skinners and power socks but with a top that's more of a shoe?
Hi thanks for commenting.. I'd say the Freet Talus 3 is the most like what you seem to be describing..
Here's the link to my review of it: ruclips.net/video/W09kIoU_hH4/видео.html
If you grab a pair, please use my affiliate link: bit.ly/joshfreet and use my discount code JB10 to get 10% OFF!
@@barefootshoejosh thanks a lot
Exactly my question! What is the widest barefoot shoe - thanks for doing this review!!! I'm new to this, so I started with a pair of Whitin shoes from Amazon with the thought - don't spend a fortune on my first shoes, and see if I like it first. I ordered my size (US 12), but they were no wider than my regular shoes.
Well hopefully I answered your question in this video and gave you some good companies and/or shoe models to check out. If you found this helpful, please use my affiliate links and/or discount codes wherever possible! Thank you in advance!
Hi Josh, it would be helpful to know what size you are in those brands because the width increases a bit with each size.
I mentioned very briefly in the video that I wear 44 or 45 in all of these shoes... which is one of the many reasons to take the precise measurement with a grain of salt.. but the overall point of these being the widest barefoot brands holds mostly true, in my opinion.
@Josh's Barefoot Shoes Reviews yeah fair enough, the order you gave gives an idea of the width in relation to each other, I just wanted to compare some shoes I have with the width measurements you gave to see how my shoes compare to see how much more width I'd be getting by trying those other brands. The only brand on your list I have is Freet so I can use that as a reference point.
@@christianlangfield9303 just saw this comment; but yes that makes perfect sense!
Came to this video after you suggested it in another video. I have printed out the insole charts for any company that offers, still too narrow, lol. Bohempia in size 45 is about as close to width and length as I can get and according to the template it is a no go. The issue isn't the toe box. My left foot is a solid 4E and my right foot is pushing wider. That and I have a really wide midfoot and forefoot, more so than my toe splay. I really wish some of these companies would release an extra wide last rather than just an extra wide toe box.
As an aside, of the shoes I have tried I have found them to all run short. I'm a 10 4E in New Balance and an 11 in Lems (and I could probably be more comfortable in a 12) and a 12 in Xero. This is just the length, as both Lems and Xero are too narrow but just to give an idea. Not being able to try shoes on in person is a pain, lol.
I'll keep watching along in hopes that someday one of these companies releases an extra wide shoe. Until then Jim Green is what I am going to try next. Supposedly a 3E, stich down, barefoot boot and all of the should mean a wider fit.
Hi there. Here's what I can tell you . If you are fitting into New Balance (narrow), Xero (narrow) and Lems (medium), virtually any of the shoes in this review are wider. The shoe outlines can be a bit deceptive, as they are essentially the outline of the insole--which isn't all there is to it in terms of width in the actual fit. Very important is volume and the flexibility or "give" in the material on the sides of the shoe.
Also, as another detail. Bohempia has two widths, so be sure you look at their "Wide" width. If you fit Lems or NB, Bohempia's wide width has more space than either of those.
Unfortunately, saying things like 4E isn't specific enough for me to offer much help. Instead, please tell me:
* How long is your longest foot, in centimeters/mm?
* How wide is your foot at the widest point of your forefoot, in centimeters/mm?
* Is your foot low, medium, or high in VOLUME?
* What is the shape of your foot (slope, plateau, mountain, or square?
Answer these and I can possibly be of more assistance, if needed...
@@barefootshoejosh I wouldn't call a 4/6E (double extra wide) new Balance narrow anywhere outside of the toe box. My 10 4E insole is MUCH bigger than my Lems 11 at the mid and forefoot and identical in length.
Without socks I am 27.5 cm length by 11.43 cm wide, which on the Bohempia chart puts me at a 43(ish) length and between a 46-47 in wide width. But by the printout I think a lot of the issue is the shape of my foot. Their shoes are kidney bean shaped and mine is like a splitting wedge, lol.
Anyway, the problem is I don't really fit in Lem's, which is why I don't love mine. an 11 is the right length but they are way too narrow. A 12 is closer but way too long. I've bought shoes that are too long for like 30 years to get my feet into them, sadly.
Mountain shape, high arches, and overall high volume.
Anyway, I apricate the help. Like I said, trying these things on in person would be so much better but with small companies it doesn't really work that way.
Edit: I forgot to mention that a Luna Origin Lite in size 11 is almost a perfect fit or as close to one as I have ever had. Idk if that helps or not.
@@kitcraft9516 helpful info. I am 11.1 x 27cm, medium-high volume/arches, and mountain shaped--so our feet are very similar, I am just a size or 1/2 size smaller. Like you, I probably go longer than I need to for the sake of gaining width. I wear Bohempia Hoskas in size 44W, and they are an amazing fit. I also have their Kolda model which has a hair less volume, but still comfortable for me. If you want to ask about another specific shoe, feel free.
@@barefootshoejosh Thank you. I am chasing that Converse look so the Orik 2.0 is what I am looking at. In my teens I wore my converse 2 sizes too big. I wouldn't try that now. Narrowness aside the squishy insoles destroy my arches.
Anyway, I am kind of curious about the Vivo Gobi boot. I hear it is pretty wide for a Vivo. I need to add an unlined 6(ish) inch boot to my lineup.
Thank you again for taking the time, I really do apricate your videos and responses.
@@kitcraft9516 I have a pair of dark blue Vivobarefoot Gobis. I reviewed them here on the channel a long time ago. They fit pretty comfortably, although Vivo is toward the narrower end of the spectrum. These seem to be not bad. They are kind of a "mid" height boot, and the top edge of the boot touches me in a way that I don't love, but I think that's more me and my sensory issues than it is the boot. Meanwhile the brown chelsea boot I reviewed from Atlantis handmade feels great to me (reviewed here on the channel). I also have an unlined black leather chelsea boot made custom from The Drifter Leather (also reviewed here on the channel), which is like butta. But yeah, the Vivo Gobi's width isn't terrible.
How much difference is there between Freet and Saguaro in width?
It looks like the Freet Tanga is around 3-4 mm wider than the Saguaro trail shoes I reviewed.
I’m thinking about buying Splay and have few question to the expert :)
I’m wearing Bohempia 45W
1. what size should I order in Splay Freestyle?
2. are Splay also so comfortable or not worth buying (comparing to Bohempia)?
I have only one shot as i will be ordering Splay from US so no chance to send it back :(
Hi.. rather than telling me your Bohempia size, please tell me your foot length in centimeters, and the width at the widest point of the forefoot. Also what is your foot shape (slope, plateau, mountain, square), and are you low/med/high volume?
Don’t know all these answers
For me the easiest way is to compare Bohempia size to Splay size form user of both
@@pisarpisar9115 My Splay Freestyle lace-ups are 10.8cm wide and comfortable medium volume. My Bohempia are 11.2 cm wide and slightly higher volume. So if you have a little extra room to spare in your Bohempias, then you should be fine with Splay LACE-UPs, and they are about half the price.
However, Splay slip-ons are lower volume, and significantly tighter. I ended up giving them to my son because I couldn't wear them.
Thx for info…so if i wear 45W Bohempia which size should i take in Splay’s (lace ups)?
@@pisarpisar9115 There is no direct conversion from Bohempia sizing to Splay sizing. Best thing to do is measure your feet, length and width, look at Splay's sizing chart, and follow their guidance. My guess is you'll be like a 12 or so, but I don't want to pick wrong for you. Please use my link bit.ly/splayjosh and use code JOSHBAREFOOT to save 10%
I think I screwed up. I've never ordered a European shoe and I ordered a pair of be lenka shoes last night in 42 and I think I need 45.
Im A size 10 1/2 US. Any advice?
I would reach out to them immediately by multiple means (phone, email, webchat or anything they have available) and try to catch them before they ship.
@barefootshoejosh I'm a size 10 1/2 US, should I get size 45 European?
@@frankietomecek6712 as I mentioned, their customer service is best to ask in this case.
However, the best thing to do, for future reference, is to trace your feet, then measure your length and width in centimeters. Know your measurements. I wear three different European sizes (44, 45 and 46) depending on the shoe and manufacturer.
So get to know your foot measurements. Then when you go to buy shoes, look at the shoe company's sizing chart/guide. Allow approximately 1.5 cm extra length for wiggle/swell room, and get the size that would accommodate you best.
It's not just you, I've seen various people online say Bohempias are wider than Softstar Primals. May vary according to size, but for me, the Softstars are wider and much more comfortable as such.
I've reached a point where the Softstars are all I want to wear. Elsewhere in these comments, I've said Lems work for me. They don't now. After sustained use of the Softstars, everything else feels too narrow. I just wish I could get (a) a vegan shoe or boot that was as wide as the Softstars and (b) that it could have at least a little grip. The Softstar Sawyers are smooth and I've often come close to slipping over in the rain in them. Despite my veganism, I may have to get a pair of Softstar's Switchback boots for winter and other wet days.
Before anyone suggests them, I've tried two vegan brands that might appear to meet all my criteria: Ahimsa and Realfoot. Nope.
Ahimsa use a vegan 'leather' that's too hard and too obviously, and unbreathably, plastic and the wide version are not as wide as they claimed on the website, not even measuring by the outsole. I pointed this out to them and they said they'd made a mistake.
Realfoot looked like the great hope, but they're not and it's odd. The main thing that makes them look so wide is that the heel is very narrow, so it's a pronounced V-shape overall. They also have measurements on the website that could be said to be misleading: the diagram shows it, but it's easy to miss: the measurement is a somewhat arbitrary diagonal, meaning that straight across, the measurement comes out smaller. So while other brands are scared that wide-looking shoes will scare off the customers, this one seems to be wearing it as a badge of honour - without doing it properly. Shame, because the sole is great, both for ground feel and grip.
I hear you man. I will say this though. The last time I put on my Softstar Sawyers, believe it or not, I felt limited in the width... but when I put on my Bohempia Hoska, I don't feel that same restriction. I still do love my Softstars though, as they are definitely in the top wide companies. You might want to check out Wyde at my affiliate link: bit.ly/joshwyde
Also, I have a couple of other wide reviews coming pretty soon. Stay tuned!
@@barefootshoejosh Weird and interesting. I guess it may just come down to the specifics of different foot shapes.
I may try some Wydes at some point. I've been disappointed so many times before that I've almost given up, but I'll check out your review of them.
@@barefootshoejosh Ah, I guess you haven't reviewed Wyde yet. But I given that, in my size, the insole measurement is wider than that for Sawyers, and that sole looks grippy, these could be winners. Also seems very clear they've accounted for the need for big toe splay, which, as I've mentioned before, is unusual.
@@JohnMoseley Yes, hence the recommendation! I hope they work out for you if you feel like taking the gamble bit.ly/joshwyde
@@barefootshoejosh I tried. They're out of the ones I want. But when they get them back in, I'll use your affiliate link.
What is the widest shoe that ALSO has support for a high arch(Edit: I meant bridge)? Because all the ones I've tried(barefoot) are all so restrictive on the arch that I can't get my foot into them
Well barefoot shoes, by definition, have NO arch support. So it's possible I'm misunderstanding your question... help me understand?
@@barefootshoejosh Yes, sorry, English isn't my first language so I used the wrong term. It's the bridge I was referring to. My bridge is so high that when I was trying all these different barefoot shoes I couldn't get into them without sizing up to the point of having the whole toebox dangling at the front by itself, empty and alone :D My problem is 3-fold. Very short foot (EU 41), very wide as well (there exist no shoes currently in my length that are wide enough, that I have found), and and absurdly high bridge :D
@@freyrh3582 Well here are some things to consider trying:
• Bohempia -
Please use my link bit.ly/bohempiajosh
• Softstar Shoes -
Please use my link bit.ly/softstarjosh
• Freet Footwear -
Please use my link bit.ly/joshfreet and use code JB10 to save 10%
Alternatively, you may want to do something CUSTOM.
CUSTOM SHOES/SANDALS FOR ANY WIDTH YOU NEED:
• The Drifter Leather -
Link: www.thedrifterleather.com/
• Prime Trotter -
Link: primetrotter.bigcartel.com
• Deliberate Life Designs -
Use link www.deliberatelifedesigns.com and
Use code JOSHBAREFOOT at checkout to save 10%
• Paisley Running Sandals -
Link: paisleyrunningsandals.com
If you want to see my recent video that features all of these:
ruclips.net/video/DPvEa7grwOQ/видео.html
I hope something here helps you!
Hey! What happened to Unshoes Terravida? Just watched your video on those and you said they'd be in this rundown. Certainly sounds as if they deserve to be.
John! Dammit! You are absolutely right, and this was a complete oversight on my part!!! Ugh. My Unshoes Terra VIda comes in at like 10.5 cm, so it should be in this list. Somehow I just didn't come across them when I was doing my planning for this video. Horrible!! I added it into the appropriate slot in the Video Description. Thanks so much for calling this to my attention.
@@barefootshoejosh Ha. 'Dammit!' is exactly what I thought you'd say, probably because I would've too. Happens to the best of us -as well as to me.
Oh well. With any luck, in a year or so there'll be new super-wide barefoot shoes available and it'll be time for an update.
@@JohnMoseley Yeah we'll see if I do another one of these in a year.. this one was a pain. But the good news is that I can get it right on Instagram! Thanks again..
@@barefootshoejosh A pleasure. Glad it was helpful.
Video starts at 6:00
There's relevant info in the first 6 minutes; but if you mean the individual company specifics, then yes.. at the 6min mark.
Great vid
Glad you enjoyed and/or found it helpful!
Which shoes have the thickest sole?
Well in the barefoot world, we're normally looking for THINNER soles, so this is an unusual question. Of the shoes included in this video, here are the top 3 thickest:
* Unshoes - 7mm
* Splay Athletics - 6.5mm (this brand's sole thickness varies, depending on the shoe's SIZE though...)
* Saguaro - 6mm
There are other shoes reviewed here on the channel with thicker soles as well. Just a few examples:
* Atlantis Handmade - 7mm (or 9-10mm if you add the rubber sole option)
* Bahé - 10mm
* Flux Adapt Runner - 22mm
* Flux Adapt Trainer - 10mm
* Lems Primal 2 - 9mm
* Softstar Switchback - 9mm
I hope this helps you. If this is helpful, and you end up buying any of these, please use my affiliate link and/or discount code from the video description on the review so you can save some money, and it helps me out as well. Thank you!
@barefootshoejosh I ask because I was playing basketball in whittins trail runners, I think. I came down from a jump and bruised my foot. I need something for playing basketball on a concrete court. I been wearing barefoot shoes for a 2 1/2 years
@@GG-zk2xm OK gotcha. You might look at my reviews of Origo Shoes Everyday Sneaker, and Flux Footwear's Adapt Trainer. I have another shoe I'm reviewing pretty soon that would be applicable here as well.
@@barefootshoejosh the Flux adapt runner link doesn't work. There was not any applied discount.
@@GG-zk2xm Hi yes.. that's correct. Flux suddenly changed to a different affiliate program, and I haven't gotten the new one to work correctly yet. I'm trying to communicate with the program people (not Flux), but as of right now, it's not working. My apologies. Will continue to try to get it going.
I am a woman and would like to have feet as narrow as you 😂. My size is 7-8 and my width is 12 cm. There are no shoes for me in the world.
Oh, but I would beg to differ. Yes yours are wide feet, but custom shoes can fit you just fine. I mentioned a few in the video:
CUSTOM SHOES/SANDALS FOR ANY WIDTH YOU NEED:
• The Drifter Leather -
Link: www.thedrifterleather.com/
• Prime Trotter -
Link: primetrotter.bigcartel.com
• Deliberate Life Designs -
Use link www.deliberatelifedesigns.com and
Use code JOSHBAREFOOT at checkout to save 10%
• Paisley Running Sandals -
Link: paisleyrunningsandals.com
...and there are several others out there I didn't mention. I should be doing two more custom shoes reviews pretty soon, and one of them mostly makes women's shoes... Stay tuned!
Thanks for this rundown - and for stating upfront just how big a deal this is for a lot of us. Given how many people are - sometimes desperately - looking for the widest possible barefoot shoes, it's absolutely amazing to me how few companies are filling this gap.
Absent the webbing, I'm a total duck foot: 26cm long, almost 12cm when fully splayed, but closer to 11 normally. Here's my little take:
I have two pairs of Softstar Sawyers and I love them. Didn't know anyone else was going that wide, let alone a tiny bit wider. Interested in some Bohempia's now, especially as I've recently gone vegan and will probably never buy another pair of leather shoes. I wish Softstar would do a canvas version of the Sawyers.
Used to be a big fan of Freet too, but eventually came to feel I wanted more space for my big toe to splay. Freet do make great shoes, but share a blindspot with a lot of other manufacturers on big toe splay. Also, Josh, to back up your point on how measurements aren't everything, Freet actually provide width measurements on their site, but it can be misleading. Their Connects are technically a little narrower than their Tangas, but because of the material of the uppers, I found the Connects felt much wider - and very comfortable - but couldn't wear the Tangas.
Other than that, I lived in my Lems Boulder Boots this winter. Would love a wider version, but they didn't hurt my feet. And Lems Primal 2s actually seem to be wider and offer me enough space.
John--Great comments here.
I agree that this is a gap that needs to be filled. Even among these top 10 widest companies, only three of them "technically" are wide enough for my feet according to their listed measurements (Bohempia's WIDE WIDTH shoes, Softstar's primal line, and Luks Shoes.
If you're going to check out Bohempias for your feet, you're going to want the WIDE WIDTH, specifically.
I agree on the big toe side of the Freets (and almost every other barefoot brand for that matter).. that they should probably allow for more splay, and agree that there is variance in fit between models because of the various materials.. Have you tried the Talus 3 slip-ons? They're not for everyone, but those are potentially the most comfortable and most minimalist shoes I own, and the material has plenty of give so they feel even wider.
I have some Lems Primal 2s and they fit OK, but several others I have seem to fit wider for me. I have never owned any of their Boulder Boots though.. they've always looked interesting to me, but I'm not a huge boot-wearer (except for occasional rougher hiking) due to living in San Diego where it's pretty temperate most of the time.
Thanks again for the comments!
@@barefootshoejosh Yeah, the boulder boots are lined and probably wouldn't work in hot weather. They're also not very grippy, so barely suitable for hiking. But they were great for being out on a bike or walking in the city in cold weather.
I did get the Talus slip-ons at one point. As you suggest, they may have some claim to be the world's most minimalist shoe. But, another tricky sizing matter: I got the same size that had worked for me perfectly with the Connects, but it was too big in the Talus, and I was worried that smaller would be too narrow, even with the very socklike upper, so I opted to return them for a refund. Might try again sometime soon, based on how good you make them sound.
Thanks for the advice on the Bohempia wide models. A bit more info for anyone else interested: the website's mildly confusing on this: unlike with Softstar, there's no specific feature for choosing width, it's all just part of one sizing menu: 43, 43w etc.
@@christianlangfield9303 That's really interesting about the Talus. I don't quite know what to make of that. Given that it's a shoe with no lacing and a very soft upper, it was absolutely clear that size 43, which was my size in Connect, wasn't going to stay on my feet with Talus.
Sorry you've had these quality control issues with Freet. Hadn't heard that from anyone else or experienced it, and they were helpful with my Talus return, even giving me a discount on my next purchase, but not saying any of that to deny your experience.
@John Moseley on a more positive note the Talus 3 makes a great indoor slipper, been wearing them all this winter. Wouldn't want to wear them outside though unless I was appearing as an extra in a Chinese martial arts film!
@@christianlangfield9303 😊They literally should be marketing them aggressively to that precise market. That's if Freet marketed anything aggressively.