Thise young ladies are Lubov Stekoltshikova and Evelina Drukh, students of professor Mikhail Gantvarg, and the orchestra is The Concert Chamber Orchester of Mikhail Estrin
Alberto, I'm 70 years old ,my philosophy is this I might be too old for them ,but they are not too young for me - if we stop dreaming what is there left for a man ?Musically is the same ,i like to hear as many different version of a work ,BACH is one of my favourite composer,and the concertos for 2 violins is a masterpiece ,so 2 are better than 1.Happy listening Saluti GINO
Отлично интерпретации. Хорошая работа арок и импульса справедливым, особенно 1-го движения. Существует полностью версию голландского барокко ^), но не знаю, почему я считаю, современным и привлекательным. Что-то порой размыты формулировки континуума. Поздравления и приветствия.
No puedo creer este segundo movimiento!!!! es arrancar la belleza de las notas! el lenguaje Universal de la música....me produce piel de gallina! gracias! es hermoso!
Encantada de abrir mi mente y mi corazón para escuchar a Bach en esta versión juvenil descollante. Agradezco la sugerencia de Horacio Verbitsky desde su publicación "Cohete a la Luna"- Argentina. Поздравляю Пока!!
It's definitely you! They are concentrating seriously and are very engaged with the music. What exactly were you expecting? Some smiles or other irrelevant or inappropriate gestures?
I have a Decca CD of Itzak Perlman and Pinkus Zuckerman sorry for the spelling , which is the best version . this is very close and these ladies are much better looking
Elina (Evelina) has a stronger, clearer sound and more precise intonation but she is on second violin? Perhaps they flipped a coin to see who would play first? :-) Very nice performance. Bravo!!!
Tahmini 1975 lerde girmiştim bir müzik aletleri satıcısına, aldım elime böyle bir kemenı ve Nasıl çalışsam çalabilir miyim dedim satıcıya . Adam tabi çalabilirsin aynen saz gibidir demişti, Oysaki benim saz bile çalamadığımı bilmiyordu. Ya dedim çok kolaymış . peki ben bir düşüneyim dedim ve çıktım dükkandan. çok sonraları bulduğum bir kemen ile biraz çalayım dedim yok imkansız. arkadaş bana bak sana ögreteyim dedi . Şöyle tutacaksın böyle yapacaksın diyordu ki ,ben yok kardeş yok bu benim yiyecegim b... degil dedim ve o gön bu gün bir daha bu zıkkımı elime almadım.
A little faster than other renditions I've heard, especially the 2nd movement, which is nbd... the orchestra may be a bit large for the room (can't hear the harpsichord well enough), and why didn't the filmmaker include the final movement? (I'm sure they played it; that's the part with all the fireworks!) otherwise, a nice energetic performance.
so it was pleasant to discover here so many comments yesterday . incredible, thank you all very much for your comments! every opinion is important to me, whether it be good or bad. Thanks to you I'm starting to believe in themselves and there are new forces for working... thanks to all of you! Elina.
Although this is a fantastic recording of a true master interpretation of Bach...by these young musicians....the true masterfull representation must be given to the the true masters of the violin .....Menhuhin and Oistrakh....no offence ment .....still a fantastic work ..by these young people ..
Beautiful rapport between the 2 girls (and with the orchestra). Despite the oldfashioned (typically Russian) use of vibrato it is not too heavy, due to the lively tempi, even in the famously beautiful slow movement.
It is a typically Russian performance, and after all they are students. I think it is all, including the 2nd movement, beautifully played. Too many soloists get carried away and over-romanticize the slow movement, which is beautiful enough without that.
what has this got to do with Bach's concerto for two violins and strings? I'm missing the connection, please. let's just listen to fabulous music performed by beautiful and talented young people.
Truth is, this isn't a technically demanding piece. Many professionals don't find it challenging, and have played it so many times that they've lost the joy in it - and it shows.
You probably would like the 2nd movement slower, but this is probably more like what would have been done in Bach's time. Bach does not always have to be "deep". That is a romantic conception.
A pleasant rendition of the Bach's double concerto. I have only one concern: I don't like the harpsichord with closed soundboard... it is not an additional instrument, but the *main* istrument in baroque performances.
I agree... it loses a lot of its "sparkle" beneath all the bowed strings... they should open that little cembalo! I love Julia Fischer... she's such a strong violinist... and not bad to look at either! (I mean, she is a lot prettier than Yitzhak Perlman! ;-)
+Gian Luca Marcialis It would be nice to hear the harpsichord more; difficult with so many strings and especially so many cellos, but it is nonsense to say that it is the main instrument. It is part of the continuo, just accompanying the soloists and the orchestra by filling in the harmonies of the bass parts.
"Just"? I don't agree with you, Frank. And I think that the "Maestro al cembalo" whose role wad to lead the orchestra could not. Probably the soundboard is closed because it is a neupert "Telemann" model, an "old" harpsichord whose sound quality is very poor.
+Gian Luca Marcialis In this case there is no Maestro al cembalo, there is a harpsichordist playing a continuo part. When there is someone leading the orchestra from the cembalo their leading is important but the harpsichord is still not the main instrument. In many performances in modern concert halls the harpsichord can hardly be heard at all. This is certainly a shame, but it shows that the harpsichord is by no means the main instrument. The only time it is the main instrument is if it is playing a concerto, or perhaps playing in a small ensemble such as a trio.
Благослови вас Бог, музыканты! Благослови тебя и твоё творчество на века, великий Бах!
The ladies are good! This is maybe my favorite piece in the repertoire, so spiritual, so warm, so passionate. They do well by it.
Очень люблю эту композицию! Шедевр!
Отличная мелодия и отличное исполнение. Хожу в консерваторию и восхищаюсь нашей талантливой молодежью. За ними будущее и прекрасное притом.
без Навального так и не наткнулся бы на такой замечательный концерт, наткнулся, слушая музыку из фильма про дворец
PREKRÁSNA interpretácia mladými umelcami, ďakujem bravo, Herman člen komorného orchestra Košice
Thank you🙏
Одна из солисток, прекрасна и сейчас преподает в консерватории❤
Brillantissime interprétation de ce si superbe concerto de Bach. Une articulation, un allant et un phrasé sans pareils.
Thank you
Both Technical and co-operate perfect. I see some other players but not like this two yang ladies, excellent style of performance with Bach works.
Love to see young people playing these lovely oldclaaicalo works bringing their youthful vitality for all of us to share
Thise young ladies are Lubov Stekoltshikova and Evelina Drukh, students of professor Mikhail Gantvarg, and the orchestra is The Concert Chamber Orchester of Mikhail Estrin
Thanks!
Absolutely delicious, these sounds from heaven played by angels.
Alberto, I'm 70 years old ,my philosophy is this I might be too old for them ,but they are not too young for me - if we stop dreaming what is there left for a man ?Musically is the same ,i like to hear as many different version of a work ,BACH is one of my favourite composer,and the concertos for 2 violins is a masterpiece ,so 2 are better than 1.Happy listening Saluti GINO
Beautiful :) My sister and I played the 2nd movement awhile ago for a festival. Love Bach.
MY favourite music!Thank you!
Отлично интерпретации.
Хорошая работа арок и импульса справедливым, особенно 1-го движения.
Существует полностью версию голландского барокко ^), но не знаю, почему я считаю, современным и привлекательным.
Что-то порой размыты формулировки континуума.
Поздравления и приветствия.
Muy lindo este concierto. El segundo movimiento es sublime. Bach es Bach. Ah!!! hermosas las violinistas..!!!
how on earth can this live performance sounds better than studio recording...
... ese maravilloso universo que es la música, y
Bach, es parte esencial de él ...
haute perfection,sublime
素晴らしい音色！美しい！ありがとうございます。
No puedo creer este segundo movimiento!!!! es arrancar la belleza de las notas! el lenguaje Universal de la música....me produce piel de gallina! gracias! es hermoso!
Bach hera Diabólico. Genial!
Encantada de abrir mi mente y mi corazón para escuchar a Bach en esta versión juvenil descollante. Agradezco la sugerencia de Horacio Verbitsky desde su publicación "Cohete a la Luna"- Argentina. Поздравляю Пока!!
It's definitely you! They are concentrating seriously and are very engaged with the music. What exactly were you expecting? Some smiles or other irrelevant or inappropriate gestures?
I have a Decca CD of Itzak Perlman and Pinkus Zuckerman sorry for the spelling , which is the best version . this is very close and these ladies are much better looking
SO WONDERFULL!!!
Thank you for your valuable informations regards Gino
Вечная музыка, господа.
Almost linking with the universe. Wonderful!
Молодцы, девушки, я бы вас сразу же пригласил!
Bach with vibrato! Love it.
AMAZING MIRACLE
mon enfance... merci à mes professeurs de m'avoir fait rêver si haut. Merci pour cette belle discipline du coeur. j'ai aimé chaque cours.
Really unsurpassed performance! Leningrad(Saint Petersburg) conservatory! Rachmaninoff, Tchaikovsky and Prokofiev were educated in here..
+Hyunjae Kwon So were Heifetz and Milstein. But it's not the same school anymore. It's in crisis.
gran ejecución, pura belleza en todos sentidos , la sala magnífica ,es una entrada al paraíso,si es que existe
One of my favourite pieces that I ever played when I was learning the Viola
beautiful
Nice dress.
Great tempo and well balanced. Excellent performance!
Fan of metallica. and of classical music :P
Elina, where are you.....come back....come back and play...please...come back....
Piękna potoczystość.
Brylant
люблю этот зал
Elina (Evelina) has a stronger, clearer sound and more precise intonation but she is on second violin? Perhaps they flipped a coin to see who would play first? :-) Very nice performance. Bravo!!!
The second is more difficult
Yes. I have played first and second solo parts (in concert) as well as first and second violin in the orchestra. It's a very popular work.
Are the players breathing while playing? Tooo fast!
The authority on tempo has spoken!
Great performance! So clean and perfectly in tune! Excellent. thanks for sharing
Me gusta mucho, excelente!
Thank you🙏
amasing beauty
TEŞEKÜRLER J.S. BAH
Tahmini 1975 lerde girmiştim bir müzik aletleri satıcısına, aldım elime böyle bir kemenı ve Nasıl çalışsam çalabilir miyim dedim satıcıya . Adam tabi çalabilirsin aynen saz gibidir demişti, Oysaki benim saz bile çalamadığımı bilmiyordu. Ya dedim çok kolaymış . peki ben bir düşüneyim dedim ve çıktım dükkandan. çok sonraları bulduğum bir kemen ile biraz çalayım dedim yok imkansız. arkadaş bana bak sana ögreteyim dedi . Şöyle tutacaksın böyle yapacaksın diyordu ki ,ben yok kardeş yok bu benim yiyecegim b... degil dedim ve o gön bu gün bir daha bu zıkkımı elime almadım.
спасибо
magnifico parabens
A little faster than other renditions I've heard, especially the 2nd movement, which is nbd... the orchestra may be a bit large for the room (can't hear the harpsichord well enough), and why didn't the filmmaker include the final movement? (I'm sure they played it; that's the part with all the fireworks!) otherwise, a nice energetic performance.
Impresionante !!
I agree ,but A DOZEN each is more in order Beautiful interpretation really well played .happy listening GINO
Very good, gals got the chops for JSB.
Would like closer micing on solo fiddles.
Interesting and beautiful venue. Appropriate for this kinda tunes.
so it was pleasant to discover here so many comments yesterday . incredible, thank you all very much for your comments! every opinion is important to me, whether it be good or bad. Thanks to you I'm starting to believe in themselves and there are new forces for working... thanks to all of you! Elina.
美しい‼︎
この曲好き
Браво
Bach is de meester van de Europese dominantie van Westerse cultuur!!
60 people don't like classic music :'(
Beautiful!
Браво !
no wonder 2nd mvt was too fast, where did the conductor go?
wonderful
yes, rushed, nervousness but potential & jolly well done.lovely job.
they certainly did a fine job.
Great performance! *applause*
Merci !
really good!!!!
Respect you
Keep playing. Keep playing. :)
Which one are you? The one in white dress or black? Anyway both of you played very well, although you are still in the conservatory, I presume.
Although this is a fantastic recording of a true master interpretation of Bach...by these young musicians....the true masterfull representation must be given to the the true masters of the violin .....Menhuhin and Oistrakh....no offence ment .....still a fantastic work ..by these young people ..
great
очень понравилось!
ちょっと速いけど好きです
c'Est très beau
Beautiful rapport between the 2 girls (and with the orchestra). Despite the oldfashioned (typically Russian) use of vibrato it is not too heavy, due to the lively tempi, even in the famously beautiful slow movement.
Maravilhoso!!!
Amazing!!!
geweldig heerlijk om naar te luisteren
It is a typically Russian performance, and after all they are students. I think it is all, including the 2nd movement, beautifully played. Too many soloists get carried away and over-romanticize the slow movement, which is beautiful enough without that.
A perfect thing!
Good job
Korsakov? It's close to Japan isn't it? People live in Wakkanai Hokkaido must be good at instrumental playing.
what has this got to do with Bach's concerto for two violins and strings? I'm missing the connection, please. let's just listen to fabulous music performed by beautiful and talented young people.
Too fast? Come on! The speed is ok, but where is the 3-rd part?
ruclips.net/video/IKsCVvYtA80/видео.html
Best one! yet I'm working on this piece
Truth is, this isn't a technically demanding piece. Many professionals don't find it challenging, and have played it so many times that they've lost the joy in it - and it shows.
You probably would like the 2nd movement slower, but this is probably more like what would have been done in Bach's time. Bach does not always have to be "deep". That is a romantic conception.
Good ears!
BRAVO
A pleasant rendition of the Bach's double concerto. I have only one concern: I don't like the harpsichord with closed soundboard... it is not an additional instrument, but the *main* istrument in baroque performances.
I agree... it loses a lot of its "sparkle" beneath all the bowed strings... they should open that little cembalo! I love Julia Fischer... she's such a strong violinist... and not bad to look at either! (I mean, she is a lot prettier than Yitzhak Perlman! ;-)
+Gian Luca Marcialis It would be nice to hear the harpsichord more; difficult with so many strings and especially so many cellos, but it is nonsense to say that it is the main instrument. It is part of the continuo, just accompanying the soloists and the orchestra by filling in the harmonies of the bass parts.
"Just"? I don't agree with you, Frank. And I think that the "Maestro al cembalo" whose role wad to lead the orchestra could not. Probably the soundboard is closed because it is a neupert "Telemann" model, an "old" harpsichord whose sound quality is very poor.
+Gian Luca Marcialis In this case there is no Maestro al cembalo, there is a harpsichordist playing a continuo part. When there is someone leading the orchestra from the cembalo their leading is important but the harpsichord is still not the main instrument. In many performances in modern concert halls the harpsichord can hardly be heard at all. This is certainly a shame, but it shows that the harpsichord is by no means the main instrument. The only time it is the main instrument is if it is playing a concerto, or perhaps playing in a small ensemble such as a trio.
I loved it! They were amazing and I think this is one of the best recordings I have heard. Only one problem. They didn't play the third movement.
.. "la juventud se impone "
Sorry, I forgot to say that I really enjoyed the 2 beauties playing the violin.
Elina.
Marry them first ,than you can enjoy the playing even more ! Saluti e buon ascolto GINO
Nice video