Neither Volynets nor anyone here seems to be able to say it: SHE DOESN'T SPEAK ANY ENGLISH WHATSOEVER. She wasn't able to comprehend what Volynets said at all! She just reiterated the few sentences she memorized for situations like this. What she said didn't fit the situation and wasn't a proper response to Volynets' point. Absolute language barrier. So she shouldn't just be punished for the mistake but actually not be allowed back until she can properly communicate. That's an absolute disgrace to anyone who learned English as a foreign language (like me and millions of other people). You wanna work on the WTA tour with international people from all over the world, you MUST be able to speak basic English. End of story.
Crazy that this isn't the first time I've seen her being calm in a situation where she got screwed by a comical umpire. She seems like a nice/level headed individual & it's annoying seeing these umpires messing up with basically zero repurcussions.
@@marc-andregauthier5139That’s not how the judgement system works. If volynets had hit her return out, then it would have been up to judgement. But because she returned the ball, and then it was called out, that makes it a replay. To be clear, there is NO ROOM for judgement here. It is a fact that she hit the ball back before the call was made, which by the rules means it’s a replay. You can’t just say “judgement” as an excuse. Not for this rule.
@@SeaRasp yes, but thats not the point. The ball was called out waay before the volley. You can even see how displiscent that volley was hit, so the call influenced the point. If she missed that volley, should the point be awarded to volynets? Thats another way to look at that.
4:10 Absolutely horrendous call from the umpire, clearly got the ball back before the Out call. One of the worst decisions I've ever seen. Umpire should be fined for such a bad call.
@luboradev3755 So you're pretending like there was only one woman in this situation just so that you can be misogynistic? Come on... Yes, the umpire made a mistake but that had nothing to do with the fact that she's a woman and it hindered the female player, so...
Lost some respect for Maria in that Volynets match, horrendous call from the chair umpire! And Townsend putting on a masterclass of acting, poor form! Thank you for coming back with these videos, we've missed them!!
It's not often that I side with an umpire but I'm glad Sturmer pointed out that Siegemund wasn't in a position to complain at 1:40. She complains about every little thing and in this case it's ironic she's complaining about her opponent's serve/toss while in the same match she did that thing she always does(taking her time with the towels) when her opponent is ready to serve.
Umpire Carvahlo : My only answer is "This is my judgement". This is what I learnt in the Umpire classroom so I am protected because I use the sentence: "This is my judgement!"
Serious question, is there no oversight for umpires? I understand it’s not easy but I still can’t believe an umpire is infallible and can keep continuing to call matches afterwards with no lapse
They would be under the respective tours, so there would be performance feedback. There has been instances previously where an umpire has been removed for the remainder of a tournament, and that would have financial impacts for them. Players can also stipulate if they don’t want a certain umpire, I’m not sure how that process works though.
Kostyuk's racket abuse is totally wrong decision from Thomas sweeney I don't like this guy he is too inconsistent and when he is wrong and player opposes his decision he makes decision against that player like giorgi
yes bad call but i dont mind a bad call against kostyuk already she have the NONESHAKING HAND against all the holding Russian and Belarussian nationality so... it is the same
@@kursadakpinar7671 i know what you mean i think in her case we cannot be objective and just discuss about the umpire call while the disrespect is huge in " tennis "
If Maria had missed the volley, they’d have replayed the point. Terrible decision. I would refuse to play until the supervisor came and until the umpire understood the rule and realised her mistake. The match can’t continue under the supervision of someone who isn’t fit to make such basic calls and who could easily make the same terrible mistake again straight after
that racquet abuse call on Kostyuk is so bad lol. It was the follow through of the motion of her shot. Players hit their racquet on the court making/getting to shots all the time
The sportsmanship in the WTA tour is still to be discovered. Maria and Townsend had great chances to be the bigger person and they chose to take advantage of a terrible call
That Volynets umpire is great at parroting irrelevance nonsense back as a response. She would make an excellent Line Manager in the British Gas Customer Service Department.
Umpire from Volynets María: worst umpiring in tennis history. Just look how she did volley. Nobody playing a point seriously and focused volley in that way. It clearly interfered the calling to the point. It was one of the most clear replay points ever.
That one with Kostyuk to me that’s 50/50 because she wouldn’t of meant to do that so therefore there shouldn’t have been a warning but at the same time there was a bit of force when the racket a hit the court but I don’t see it as intentional. It’s a tough one to call I would’ve just said play on but I dunno.
0 respect for Townsend for not conceding the point in this case. Clear as day it hit her racket before the ball hit the ground and there's no way she didn't know. Can't believe we have a cheater as a Wimbledon winner
I hate how women's tennis there's no sportsmanship at all. The men often allow to replay points or give points they know they lost. It's about being fair. Definitely lost respect to some of these women. It's a tennis match. Don't let it dictate a poor act of character.
Love how Watson and Melichar are all on about ‘shouldn’t that be racket abuse’ instead of unsportsmanlike conduct … a warnings a warning, it’s not like you get a warning for each different category 🤷♂️
@@paucceri Yep, and unlike 'racket abuse' which is after all destroying your own racket, damaging the court means that someone else has to pay for the repair... hence the fine that comes with the warning.
Hate these umpires saying "from my judgement, from my point of view" STFU there's a book with rules you have to apply, just apply them! We don't care about your judgement because it's wrong! Apply the rules and that's it
while the bronzetti is perfectly right, nonetheless her ball _was_ out/going out, so she should just accept that she lost the point. in pro ping-pong, even the official umpires never give the point to the bronzetti if/when the opponent touches the ball before it actually touches the ground (=legally confirmed out). it's because EVERYONE can see that the bronzetti has just hit an outball and there's no need to wait for the ball to actually touch the ground; in ping-pong, nobody needs or insists on the legal confirmation. if the outball touches the opponent or the opponent's racket first, on its itinerary "between the table and the floor", then nobody cares. the opponent gets the point, and done! sportsmanship is the very first rule in ping-pong. In no other common sports, sportsmanship is valued and exercised higher. tennis players could learn a lot from the ping-pong sport!!
The umpire in the Volynets - Maria match should be punished for her mistake… She didn't know the most basic rule…
she did it in the potapova arango match too
And She was laughing like a bitch@@denisvavilin983
It was painful to watch, like she was chatting to a bot
Absolute gaslighting by the umpire
Neither Volynets nor anyone here seems to be able to say it: SHE DOESN'T SPEAK ANY ENGLISH WHATSOEVER. She wasn't able to comprehend what Volynets said at all! She just reiterated the few sentences she memorized for situations like this. What she said didn't fit the situation and wasn't a proper response to Volynets' point. Absolute language barrier. So she shouldn't just be punished for the mistake but actually not be allowed back until she can properly communicate. That's an absolute disgrace to anyone who learned English as a foreign language (like me and millions of other people). You wanna work on the WTA tour with international people from all over the world, you MUST be able to speak basic English. End of story.
The umpire Carvalho, the Volynets umpire, is a complete airhead and should never be allowed to umpire again.
She did the same thing in the potapova vs arango match in Guadalajara. Someone needs to teach her the rules.
‘But for me, it didn’t interfere’…what a stupid umpire. SMH
Volynets was incredibly calm for experiencing one of the worst umpiring decisions I've ever seen, I would have been livid.
Crazy that this isn't the first time I've seen her being calm in a situation where she got screwed by a comical umpire. She seems like a nice/level headed individual & it's annoying seeing these umpires messing up with basically zero repurcussions.
The volynets one is absolutely horrendous.
WDYM? To her it didn't interfere. It's a matter of judgment LMAO
@@marc-andregauthier5139 but the judgement was clearly wrong. Volynets kept the ball alive
@@marc-andregauthier5139That’s not how the judgement system works. If volynets had hit her return out, then it would have been up to judgement. But because she returned the ball, and then it was called out, that makes it a replay. To be clear, there is NO ROOM for judgement here. It is a fact that she hit the ball back before the call was made, which by the rules means it’s a replay. You can’t just say “judgement” as an excuse. Not for this rule.
@@caseygreyson4178 It's sarcasm lol
the umpire doesn't speak english right ?
Siegemund trying to be likeable challenge: Impossible.
I love how she complains about her opponents ball toss and the umpire immediately calls her out for doing the same. What a hypocrite.
Volynets (what a great name for a tennis player) got totally screwed - terrible ump.
She won the match in the end, but it did look like a bad call.
You know I never looked at her name that way before, and now I can't unsee it.
Tbf there was actually no way she would get the next ball back anyway
@@SeaRasp yes, but thats not the point. The ball was called out waay before the volley. You can even see how displiscent that volley was hit, so the call influenced the point.
If she missed that volley, should the point be awarded to volynets? Thats another way to look at that.
4:10 Absolutely horrendous call from the umpire, clearly got the ball back before the Out call. One of the worst decisions I've ever seen. Umpire should be fined for such a bad call.
There is always one like this "for me for me" . Women ... confused to the fking bone
@luboradev3755 So you're pretending like there was only one woman in this situation just so that you can be misogynistic? Come on... Yes, the umpire made a mistake but that had nothing to do with the fact that she's a woman and it hindered the female player, so...
More troubling to me is that Maria still wants this point.
@@luboradev3755 men say it all the time. Dont be such a misogynist
@@luboradev3755 Don't be absurd, there's tons of cases where male umpires said the same.
Lost some respect for Maria in that Volynets match, horrendous call from the chair umpire! And Townsend putting on a masterclass of acting, poor form! Thank you for coming back with these videos, we've missed them!!
🙏💚
Maria is nasty for cosigning that as well
Townsend should know better! She touched the ball and didn't come clean about it? Damn, it's even more dissapointing knowing she's a mother now
I don't think she noticed the ball hit her before bouncing
@@nohaybanda6738 Impossible. You can tell by her reaction she knew.
She absolutely did. ANYONE would notice that
@@nohaybanda6738 Seems as though she celebrated winning the point to cover up the fact she touched the ball
im so pissed off what a cheater she is omg
Townsend one is crazy. I know it’s not her responsibility to “call it” but come on.
T. Maria is such a poor sport. Shame on her. Terrible example for her kids there
VERY bad form for Yulia to jump around like that; who does she think she is--Penko?? haha.
notice how she treats the ballkid at the very end of the vid as well - a disgrace all around.
7:40 More horrendous line judges and umpiring. Clearly comes off the racket before going out
There are none line judges😂😂😂
The umpire in Volynets game says „i understand“ like 8 times, but i don‘t think she understood.
It's not often that I side with an umpire but I'm glad Sturmer pointed out that Siegemund wasn't in a position to complain at 1:40. She complains about every little thing and in this case it's ironic she's complaining about her opponent's serve/toss while in the same match she did that thing she always does(taking her time with the towels) when her opponent is ready to serve.
lord, iga just trying to power thru it, more patience than i've ever had
Iga is a known cheat herself so she probably didn't care what Putintseva was doing
wow.. the volynets one was a total *@#$... did this ump get to work again?! please no! LOL
I’ve been so sad without your videos!! Thank goodness you’re back!! 🙏 ❤️
🙏💚
Umpire Carvahlo : My only answer is "This is my judgement". This is what I learnt in the Umpire classroom so I am protected because I use the sentence: "This is my judgement!"
Serious question, is there no oversight for umpires? I understand it’s not easy but I still can’t believe an umpire is infallible and can keep continuing to call matches afterwards with no lapse
They would be under the respective tours, so there would be performance feedback. There has been instances previously where an umpire has been removed for the remainder of a tournament, and that would have financial impacts for them.
Players can also stipulate if they don’t want a certain umpire, I’m not sure how that process works though.
Kostyuk's racket abuse is totally wrong decision from Thomas sweeney I don't like this guy he is too inconsistent and when he is wrong and player opposes his decision he makes decision against that player like giorgi
for real, her racquet broke cuz it hit the ground after her shot for balance/follow through. Terrible call
thomas sweeney is a bad umpire tbh
yes bad call
but i dont mind a bad call against kostyuk
already she have the NONESHAKING HAND against all the holding Russian and Belarussian nationality
so... it is the same
@@qjdbtrjj-f9j Sorry you feel that way but it is not relevant , I am just commenting on umpiring decisions
@@kursadakpinar7671 i know what you mean
i think in her case we cannot be objective and just discuss about the umpire call while the disrespect is huge in " tennis "
I support women's tennis only to keep this series going.
That should not be the only reason why you support women's tennis. I like these videos too but why would you even say that?
Finally
I m so happy u re back❤
🙏💚
As if the supervisor changed anything since 17th century
there’s actually no way the umpire against volynets didn’t know the basic rule of a replay😭😭😭
Poots: "Why not warning for the tournament?" 😂😂😂
I juste discovered your channel yesterday and it's awesome bro keep up the good work!
🙏💚
If Maria had missed the volley, they’d have replayed the point. Terrible decision. I would refuse to play until the supervisor came and until the umpire understood the rule and realised her mistake. The match can’t continue under the supervision of someone who isn’t fit to make such basic calls and who could easily make the same terrible mistake again straight after
That Carvalho is the most ATROCIOUS decision I've seen on a tennis court
Very poor from Townsend. That was as clear as day
The Pliskova point penalty 😅😅
I loved İga for trying to cope, and loved here even more for wiiping the floor with her the whole match
No warning for tournament towels 😂
OMG YAY! Welcome back!
🙏💚
"Warning for the towels..." 🤣🤣🤣. Only Putintseva
carvalho like a damn robot wtf. how does anyone make such a braindead call?
The ball clearly hit Townsend before bouncing. The umpire didn't do their job following the ball and Townsend cheated.
I wanna watch a duel match Collins/Ostapenko versus Sakkari/Putinsteva. Imagine that drama :)
rare from Rybakina
7:43 lol
that racquet abuse call on Kostyuk is so bad lol. It was the follow through of the motion of her shot. Players hit their racquet on the court making/getting to shots all the time
Townsend.. tsk tsk.
Hope all is well with you guys and hope y’all are still making videos!!!
5:08 could this umpire get any stupider
Shoutout to rybakinas couch for saying that to her
Woah. I didn't have Townsend down as a cheater .....
The sportsmanship in the WTA tour is still to be discovered. Maria and Townsend had great chances to be the bigger person and they chose to take advantage of a terrible call
7:43 uhh what? Stunning incompetence
That Volynets umpire is great at parroting irrelevance nonsense back as a response. She would make an excellent Line Manager in the British Gas Customer Service Department.
They did dirty on Kostyuk CV, totally not on purpose, accidentally broke in the search for the ball
Omg REPLAY THE POINT Volynets had a play on the ball wtf
The Volynets Umpire makes me aggressive.
Umpire from Volynets María: worst umpiring in tennis history.
Just look how she did volley. Nobody playing a point seriously and focused volley in that way. It clearly interfered the calling to the point. It was one of the most clear replay points ever.
Lol warning the tournament for dirty towels...that's awesome
Any one lose track of how many times the Volynets umpire said the same thing?
Siegemund is so unfair. Complaining during serving motion of her opponent. Wow. Never seen this from any other player.
That one with Kostyuk to me that’s 50/50 because she wouldn’t of meant to do that so therefore there shouldn’t have been a warning but at the same time there was a bit of force when the racket a hit the court but I don’t see it as intentional. It’s a tough one to call I would’ve just said play on but I dunno.
That was very poor sportmanship from Townsend
Bronzetti 100% reason too
2:12 why would you even care about that? is the fine for racket abuse lower than the one for unsporstmanship conduct or what?
I Think so.
Now I like townsend but she knew good and well that ball hit her before it bounced lol
Siegemund always has and always will be a poor sport and classless
volynets' umpire wasn't even able to communicate properly... she should be absent from work til she learns English and the rules...
how can 250 cluj napoca not havae challenge system on centre court? embarrasing!
Of course siegmund is here 😂
same with yulia putintseva. Hope she will play for more years. I will miss her so much in this videos.
4:15 was crazy, that is a fucking terrible decision (at least the ump is pretty)
Carvalho is a terrible umpire.
Really bad call.
0 respect for Townsend for not conceding the point in this case. Clear as day it hit her racket before the ball hit the ground and there's no way she didn't know. Can't believe we have a cheater as a Wimbledon winner
Putintseva as always in her best form... 🤣👏
Volynets 100% reason
terrible to see a couple of mothers cheating in this video. First Maria then Townsend. Both terrible sports and terrible example for their kids :/
I hate how women's tennis there's no sportsmanship at all. The men often allow to replay points or give points they know they lost. It's about being fair. Definitely lost respect to some of these women. It's a tennis match. Don't let it dictate a poor act of character.
ostapenko and yulia are a must
siegment is kinda awful
Putintseva. 😊🎾
disgusting act from putintseva against the 2 umpire and the tournament and iga
and she is never Shamed about herself
she is even worse than Ostapenko
that carvalho umpire needs to go back to school and maybe learn some english too. seemed like she was not getting a single word volynets was saying
Sigemund is just annoying like shit up
Volynets is a funny name for a tennis player. (she was right btw)
Volynets Umpire needs firing immediately, she shouldn’t be umpiring junior tennis let alone pro level
Volynets dips into an English accent every now and then lol
Townsend cheating now?
Love how Watson and Melichar are all on about ‘shouldn’t that be racket abuse’ instead of unsportsmanlike conduct … a warnings a warning, it’s not like you get a warning for each different category 🤷♂️
unsportsmanlike is an automatic fine, unlike other warnings
@@paucceri Yep, and unlike 'racket abuse' which is after all destroying your own racket, damaging the court means that someone else has to pay for the repair... hence the fine that comes with the warning.
Hate these umpires saying "from my judgement, from my point of view" STFU there's a book with rules you have to apply, just apply them! We don't care about your judgement because it's wrong! Apply the rules and that's it
NPC refereeing Volynets
Kostyuk is so fine.
Putinseva is a jerk but I giggled at the towels remark
Siegemund is garbage. Entitled, plays mind games - funny how they put her in her place at the open.
while the bronzetti is perfectly right, nonetheless her ball _was_ out/going out, so she should just accept that she lost the point. in pro ping-pong, even the official umpires never give the point to the bronzetti if/when the opponent touches the ball before it actually touches the ground (=legally confirmed out). it's because EVERYONE can see that the bronzetti has just hit an outball and there's no need to wait for the ball to actually touch the ground; in ping-pong, nobody needs or insists on the legal confirmation. if the outball touches the opponent or the opponent's racket first, on its itinerary "between the table and the floor", then nobody cares. the opponent gets the point, and done!
sportsmanship is the very first rule in ping-pong. In no other common sports, sportsmanship is valued and exercised higher. tennis players could learn a lot from the ping-pong sport!!
Crazy take. Like really really crazy.
Ok putinseva is always causing drama yes. But she was definitely just getting set to hit a return. Iga should be able to zone out and hit that serve.