Palestrina - O Magnum Mysterium

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024
  • Palestrina - O Magnum Mysterium (truncated)

Комментарии • 222

  • @auntiepicklebottom
    @auntiepicklebottom 11 лет назад +2

    I'm an atheist, however I would like to say that I did a year long choral regiment with almost all Palestrina music. I learned to understand the deep meaning behind the translations, which alone are enough to bring me to tears. Let alone the lovely and powerful notes that the words meld themselves to. Such a shame Palestrina isn't alive today. I'm sure there is so much we could learn from him.

  • @UnRoman111
    @UnRoman111 12 лет назад +1

    i am so happy when i see that Christians gather here, on these videos and praise the Lord Christ. Very happy. People, there hope, humanity is not lost. Remain in Christ no matter how hard the times will come. In the end the victory is ours. ALELUIA CHRISTUS DOMINUS DEUS

  • @nancylembisa6454
    @nancylembisa6454 8 лет назад +14

    Quel grand mystère ET merveilleux! Le mystère de la mort et de la résurrection de notre Seigneur Jesus-Christ.

  • @driverv86
    @driverv86 10 лет назад +33

    I think Palestrina would be proud that 500 years later his music is still provoking debate.

    • @jodi183
      @jodi183 10 лет назад +6

      Debate about what? I'm curious. Either way, it is still being studied by music scholars.

    • @cuerpoeperra
      @cuerpoeperra 9 лет назад +1

      jodi183 you are right!!!

    • @gopetogle
      @gopetogle 6 лет назад

      Because look at the comment section of this video. Christians vs atheists

    • @jorgelopez-pr6dr
      @jorgelopez-pr6dr 5 лет назад +3

      This is because of the neomarxist dogma of atheism.

  • @SomethingReal1119
    @SomethingReal1119 12 лет назад +9

    My goodness!! I remember performing this in a beautiful old gothic church back in college with about 7 other singers at a xmas concert. Wow! What memories; thanks for posting this. I am almost in tears.

  • @juanantoniourlaxitamul4783
    @juanantoniourlaxitamul4783 6 лет назад +2

    giovanni pierluigi para mi es uno de los maestros destacatos del canto polifoníco que nos ha dejado un legado grandísimo del arte polifonico y su riqueza espiritual inspiración para la religiosidad.

  • @not2tees
    @not2tees 12 лет назад +1

    This music sets the hair on the back of my neck to rise . . . these are alien yet human voices from another world, ours yet not ours, a separated world not in space but by time, but still here for ears that can hear. Wonderful.

  • @emmapope8979
    @emmapope8979 8 лет назад +10

    I'm thankful for this I probably wouldn't pass school if it was not for RUclips!!!

  • @maxcohen13
    @maxcohen13 12 лет назад +2

    Latin text:
    O magnum mysterium,
    et admirabile sacramentum,
    ut animalia viderent Dominum natum,
    jacentem in praesepio!
    Beata Virgo, cujus viscera
    meruerunt portare
    Dominum Christum.
    Alleluia.
    English translation:
    O great mystery,
    and wonderful sacrament,
    that animals should see the new-born Lord,
    lying in a manger!
    Blessed is the Virgin whose womb
    was worthy to bear
    Christ the Lord.
    Alleluia!

  • @NihilNominis
    @NihilNominis 11 лет назад

    1) The execution of this music, if nothing else, is an exercise in tremendous skill.
    2) Just because music doesn't sound good to you, doesn't mean it didn't sound good in its own time, and can't to a properly-attuned ear. Most music was appreciated as at least "pleasantly audible" when it was written, and can be still.

  • @4musikable
    @4musikable 11 лет назад +1

    Beautiful and elegant music.

  • @makalynlockett6808
    @makalynlockett6808 9 лет назад +4

    Doing this song for choir, so beautiful

  • @CorazonDeLeon1960
    @CorazonDeLeon1960 11 лет назад +1

    Ómnia instaurare in Cristo per Mariam. Laudetur Iesus Cristus per ómina sáecula saeculorum. Amen. Muito obrigado por haver compartido iste video.

  • @irenalaszuk5989
    @irenalaszuk5989 8 лет назад +2

    Dziękuję za piękno!

  • @monteverdi1567
    @monteverdi1567 13 лет назад +1

    This is what an "O magnum" should be, beautifully crafted, with a sense of awe, sung with intensity and wonder, and vigor where appropriate. I find it greatly preferable to many of the modern settings that border, if not cross, into the lugubrious.

  • @martin11334
    @martin11334 7 лет назад +30

    To all the atheists obsessing over this being music and nothing to do with religion, here are the words for you
    O great mystery,
    and wonderful sacrament,
    that animals should see the new-born Lord,
    lying in a manger!
    Blessed is the Virgin whose womb
    was worthy to bear
    our Saviour, Jesus Christ.
    Alleluia!

    • @Lyly1396
      @Lyly1396 5 лет назад

      There is a word for peoples like you :
      Hypocrites ( And peace of shit )

    • @geot4647
      @geot4647 5 лет назад

      Many Messiah stories existed back then: www.google.com/search?&q=did+jesus+exist%3F

    • @caprolupo8321
      @caprolupo8321 5 лет назад +2

      The composer claimed to be a Roam Catholic and claimed to compose the music for purpose of the Roman Church. But the music is what it is, its sounds, its form, irrespective of the composer's religion or his religious design.
      Surely, many great European composers felt inspired by their religious experience. But, their religious inspiration did not alter the physical (acoustic) reality of their compositions. That physical reality bears its own effect irrespective of the inspiration of the person who composed it.
      An arrestingly beautiful natural landscape is arrestingly beautiful despite any religious belief that a God or gods created it.

    • @PaulDo22
      @PaulDo22 4 года назад

      @@caprolupo8321 All beauty is a reflection of the beauty, truth, and goodness that comes from the Creator. Everything that is beautiful is an attempt to emulate the Divine. This reality directly alters the acoustic reality which is why the less religious you are the harder is to emulate truth, beauty, and goodness. Denying this reality is to be blind to how artistry works.

    • @caprolupo8321
      @caprolupo8321 4 года назад

      @@PaulDo22 Nonsense.

  • @nganir
    @nganir 12 лет назад +1

    wonderful interpretation and performance - thanks for posting

  • @robert18081995
    @robert18081995 11 лет назад +4

    Music is universal, everyone can listen. But we need to remember that this music was made with a purpose, that is to praise God.

  • @AntoniodeOrnelas
    @AntoniodeOrnelas 11 лет назад

    Música grandiosa e eloquente.
    Nos leva para as altas esferas do Universo
    .

  • @DarkAngeliqe
    @DarkAngeliqe 10 лет назад +23

    this music helps me write my novels, beautiful music

    • @DonDraperism
      @DonDraperism 10 лет назад +10

      I'm sorry but your comments sounds like you're bragging not to mention it's asinine considering the piece was written to focus on the Creator of universe.

    • @heatedfrost9055
      @heatedfrost9055 10 лет назад +7

      DonDraperism It's... it's "asinine" to get inspiration from this stuff in a non-religious context? Because it would be "asinine" to say that. Or to use the word "asinine" sincerely.

    • @jodi183
      @jodi183 10 лет назад +7

      DonDraperism
      Nice run on sentence. Anyway, music shall be enjoyed by all in any way they so choose. Let us embrace the differences of each and every one of us. That is far more loving. Peace brother.

    • @OrbisTertiusChannel
      @OrbisTertiusChannel 4 года назад

      @@DonDraperism I'm sorry but your comments sounds like you're dumb donkey. Haha

  • @shamba2004org
    @shamba2004org 12 лет назад +1

    Beautiful...as always!

  • @kaznodzieja3333
    @kaznodzieja3333 5 лет назад +1

    Wenice.......... Palestrina......... Basilica san Marco........

  • @black1888tm
    @black1888tm 12 лет назад

    Not just christians, but also atheists who appreciate good music. :)

  • @carmellataylor8131
    @carmellataylor8131 11 лет назад

    Bella musica. Rinfrescante e lontano dal simbolo rame risonante e tintinnanti di questo mondo.

  • @adamsendler388
    @adamsendler388 11 лет назад +1

    Magnificient,beautifull!!!!!!

  • @acerb4566
    @acerb4566 11 лет назад +1

    I found Cathar's in Catalunya. They love Jesus and peace. That's good enough for me! They have a tiny humble chapel in Catalunya. There is no shadow of the (Medici's/Borja's), in that place.

  • @skhcara
    @skhcara 10 лет назад +21

    doesn't matter if you believe in God or not
    the music is truly beautiful

  • @carloslopezluna
    @carloslopezluna 11 лет назад

    VUELA EL ALMA. HERMOSO!!!

  • @insaneunicorn5266
    @insaneunicorn5266 8 лет назад

    there is a concert band rendition of this song and I played it two years ago in my High School Wind Ensemble, you think the choral rendition is beautiful, wait till you hear the instrumental rendition

  • @deibele1
    @deibele1 9 лет назад +20

    The mantra of rock music is "Emotion over Beauty" I think It self evident to all healthy minds that the works of Palestrina and Michelangelo are more beautiful than the works of Elvis or Picasso. Given the premise, the real question isn't which is more beautiful, but rather the purpose of art. If the purpose of art is to express the feelings of the artist, modern art may be superior. But, if the purpose of art is to be a medium of objective beauty, there can be no contest, the art of the Renaissance is far far superior.

    • @TheOtherBoobJustDropped
      @TheOtherBoobJustDropped 7 лет назад +2

      Amd I've never heard it put that way. Now I have something to think about...Thanks for the comment!

    • @gdpcpa
      @gdpcpa 7 лет назад +2

      Excellent distinction AMD, objective beauty in this case being the Glory of God.

    • @DrJonathanGemmill
      @DrJonathanGemmill 6 лет назад +2

      Excellent comment. God bless you.

    • @peterboersema7348
      @peterboersema7348 5 лет назад

      This is one of the more thought-provoking comments I've found on RUclips.

  • @TheDerrickoh
    @TheDerrickoh 11 лет назад

    Nobody has the "right" to force their opinions on someone else. A child deserves to think for himself/herself.

  • @carolineleiden
    @carolineleiden 11 лет назад +1

    Just my two cents, but I was raised to be an atheist. They did this by simply NOT telling me anything, by not showing me anything, by keeping me ignorant. They thought they were letting me believe whatever I wanted, they figured they were giving mefreedom to think for mlf, but they denied me of knowledge, of any possibility of believing anything at all. That is not good either. Teach your children, but do not force them.

  • @GBWPawel
    @GBWPawel 13 лет назад

    Palestyna jest stolicą Izraela. Kocham Palestyne.

  • @willemvansoest2464
    @willemvansoest2464 6 лет назад

    Beautiful.

  • @RichardIIfan
    @RichardIIfan 9 лет назад +23

    The debate is self-evident. How can the glories of Renaissance a capella music survive the onslaught of the drivel that abounds today? The answer is partly that we have become so inured to execrable crap that many have no ability to judge modern rubbish and see it for what it is. That Rensaissance music is still sung is a testament to its brilliance, just as we can know that the vast majority of what has been issued in the last 100 years will not see the light of day in 100 years... or at least it should not!

    • @TeleBachHand
      @TeleBachHand 9 лет назад +10

      I certainly concur with your viewpoint here; oh, how I pray for the DAY that decency will return to the 'arts', especially this genre of music to soothe our hearts and souls!

    • @OQMusic
      @OQMusic 9 лет назад +1

      Baroque Hearted Trying to seek mainstream music that is of this caliber would be pointless because of the audience and the free market place that it is marketed to the intellects are different the cultures and the styles are different This music does not survive as a testament to the times that it was written as much of it survives for the Understanding and analyzation and development of all different types of music also it is purely beautiful and I am a huge fan of all types of music From pop to hip-hop to atonal classical to jazz to fusion to instrumental and so on

    • @cuerpoeperra
      @cuerpoeperra 9 лет назад +8

      Baroque Hearted all of you think in terms of art like bricks without any connection....today´s "musical" or art chaos is the natural response and evolution that all this renaissance "beauty"........to gregorian singers (IX) the palestrina counterpoint would sound shit to him............And thanks to the gregorian chant we got Palestrina, Bach , Mozart, Wagner, Bartok or the rollig stones indeed............it´s our occidental culture flowing on.....then never "the decency will return to the arts" . That music cause connmotion to the purist of the time....think about it and do not idealize the "old better times" -that never was better

    • @TeleBachHand
      @TeleBachHand 9 лет назад +5

      cuerpoeperra There's no doubt I stand 'corrected' on this issue...we 'got to see the reality of variety of music genres in our times, whether we 'approve' of them or not...they all have their role in our society.

    • @scriptmusiconline
      @scriptmusiconline 9 лет назад +1

      RichardIIfan And how about pieces like Durufle's Tantum Ergo?

  • @TomasMikaX
    @TomasMikaX 11 лет назад

    And yet I am the more polite one in our conversation.

  • @KTebay
    @KTebay 11 лет назад +1

    Beautifully said, and it is the Truth:)

  • @jonyqueespeut
    @jonyqueespeut 12 лет назад

    So true

  • @thornhillmiracle
    @thornhillmiracle 12 лет назад

    From the Light that burns in Far Behind, to the rise of Gloria at Red Rocks, my soul comes to rest in sublime wonder...were song carries the spirit to the Heart of Grace...until silence...in the Gift of God.
    Today is a good day; today He has loosened thy lips to give Witness to His Glory...to point to His Holy Word...for the love of His Children; For the Sake of His Sorrowful Passion. He is Born!
    MASS READINGS 8/26/2012
    1: Josh 24:1-2,15-18
    R: Ps 34:2-3,16-21
    2: Eph 5:21-32
    G: Jn 6:60-69

  • @ivandossantostorres6935
    @ivandossantostorres6935 6 лет назад +1

    muito lindo!

  • @PARTYable123
    @PARTYable123 11 лет назад +1

    you know, I never understood why this music was associated with church and all that jazz when I was younger. Today, I still try not to look at sacred music as "Christian" music. It is beautiful, and that is what moves me.

  • @jillgivler
    @jillgivler 15 лет назад

    It is impossible to find a complete version of this motet anywhere. I had a long-lost vinyl album years ago with the whole thing. Why is this truncated? Can you steer me toward a complete recording? I would greatly appreciate it.

  • @jamesbond-fj5ri
    @jamesbond-fj5ri 11 лет назад

    i appologize and i agree

  • @Mrjonsonable1
    @Mrjonsonable1 11 лет назад

    Agreed!!

  • @MsCarlosPS
    @MsCarlosPS 8 лет назад +3

    Is it mute from 6:26 to the end?

  • @MINIKIMFTW
    @MINIKIMFTW 11 лет назад

    Apart from all the athiest and christian discussion, i must admit this music is truly beautiful,

  • @VicRattlehead713
    @VicRattlehead713 13 лет назад +1

    love this rendition. i think i still like the rendition by Victoria more though.

  • @Ceylin_Kurtbogan
    @Ceylin_Kurtbogan 8 лет назад +42

    I became a christian from agnostic atheism and before that islam.

    • @mariaashot5648
      @mariaashot5648 8 лет назад +5

      +An Infidel Turk The Mother of Jesus lived not far from Ephesus. You are fortunate to have roots in such a blessed land!

    • @megadocalex8154
      @megadocalex8154 8 лет назад +3

      More muslim should do that like you. God bless you.

    • @nadadhibi
      @nadadhibi 8 лет назад

    • @medievalmusiclover
      @medievalmusiclover 8 лет назад +6

      Jesus Christ bless You and all the Islam Brothers. Welcome to the House of Jesus!!!! Brother...

    • @nassmatic
      @nassmatic 7 лет назад +1

      Amen brother!

  • @UnRoman111
    @UnRoman111 11 лет назад

    Convert or die. Not by my own hands, but from your own hands. If you dont believe me, believe the day of your death, believe the end of the world. Believe it if you want to be saved. Salvation of your soul from your ignorance. Take your time and read St Pavel!

  • @CastillejosJavier
    @CastillejosJavier 11 лет назад

    It is Christian because it was composed to tell about the love, the beauty and the glory of God.

  • @jupiterpomme
    @jupiterpomme 7 лет назад +1

    É pra isso que eu pago internet!

  • @black1888tm
    @black1888tm 11 лет назад

    That's OK. We still love you. ;)

  • @weirdunclebob
    @weirdunclebob 9 лет назад

    Great upload. Beautiful music. I 'liked' it but didn't like all the silence at the end. Hope your editing skills have improved in the past six year! lol ;)

  • @averymarly
    @averymarly 11 лет назад +1

    no piano, no guitar, just their voices

  • @Kanchoba
    @Kanchoba 11 лет назад

    Hello I am Dog and I am from the future. Thank you.

  • @drhedi
    @drhedi 12 лет назад

    @GBWPawel Sameś jest Palestyna, stolicą Izraela jest Tel-Aviv s. Jerusalaim ;P

  • @tym1682
    @tym1682 10 лет назад

    O Magnum Mysterium sounds like an sacred song. There are both male and female voices and it sounds like they are singing in alto ans soprano. Not sure.

  • @Naul0106
    @Naul0106 5 лет назад

    Si tu es là pour l'examen d'HDI de l'IHECS sache que je suis avec toi ahaha

  • @alexanderstrelnikov
    @alexanderstrelnikov 10 лет назад +1

    Nu har i liket det. Hvad handler "O Magnum Mysterium" så om? Friske bud?

    • @jesperhedegaardkonrad8465
      @jesperhedegaardkonrad8465 10 лет назад

      Det store mysterium er selve eksistensen, bevidstheden og hjertets kærlighed, der giver mening (til de to andre).

    • @alexanderstrelnikov
      @alexanderstrelnikov 10 лет назад

      og så ..? Men musikken kender jeg. Den er uovertruffen.

  • @CarmeloBonifacioMalandrino
    @CarmeloBonifacioMalandrino 11 лет назад

    Quando voglio entrare a respiro della mia anima mi faccio aiutare da Giovanni Pierluigi che aveva prima di me fatto il cammino di ricerca di Dio attraverso la sua musica.

  • @jscottbball
    @jscottbball 10 лет назад +1

    O Magnum Mysterium by Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina is very slow and sound like as if multiple people are singing

  • @user-rr5zc6wn8o
    @user-rr5zc6wn8o 10 лет назад +1

    Quo Vadis Domine?

  • @Worrell057
    @Worrell057 11 лет назад

    If I was the person who posted this song here, I would definitely remove all of your comments, buddy-boy. Such unnecessary trollage.

  • @scalls95
    @scalls95 11 лет назад

    Palestrina actually did tastefully use tritones... :P

  • @TheDerrickoh
    @TheDerrickoh 11 лет назад

    That doesn't mean you were raised atheist, since they didn't force you to reject God. Your parents were letting you believe whatever you wanted by not forcing you to follow their beliefs. This was not keeping you ignorant, but giving you the option to choose for yourself. You were free to research or explore different religions, and I'm sure if you asked your parents questions they would have answered.

  • @frlouiegoad4087
    @frlouiegoad4087 9 лет назад +3

    08/16/2015:
    Thank You. In a world today, we are in great need to be still, stop, and hear God.
    apointofdeparture.

  • @JohnTheMick94
    @JohnTheMick94 13 лет назад

    Swag

  • @afroclamn
    @afroclamn 11 лет назад

    Indeed. The even the ones who hate Him. Just as Jesus Christ forgave those who crucified him, so should you forgive those who hate Him. Don't be so volatile.

  • @pawsoned
    @pawsoned 12 лет назад

    The piece ends at 6:25 why did you make it last 9:45?

  • @renzosax
    @renzosax 8 лет назад +2

    diablus everywhere

  • @UnRoman111
    @UnRoman111 11 лет назад

    i am a fighter for Christ.

  • @avdltd
    @avdltd 11 лет назад

    That's a contradiction in terms!

  • @TheDerrickoh
    @TheDerrickoh 11 лет назад

    Well then that contradicts what you were saying. I took your previous comment to mean they didn't force you to hate God and they didn't force you to believe in him either. If they raised you with a hatred of God, that's also wrong. I think that is something we can both agree on. But the reality is that far more children are being raised Christian than atheist.

  • @muel0341
    @muel0341 12 лет назад

    Do not be afraid! Christ loves you.

  • @edthewave
    @edthewave 11 лет назад

    I think he means that the internet population is overrepresented by atheists and agnostics compared to the "IRL" world.

  • @ninjaassassin27
    @ninjaassassin27 11 лет назад

    This is disgraceful behavior. How can any of you justify arguing whether there is god or not on a video so beautiful as this? Can't you set down the sword and shield for a single second and close your eyes to let the beauty encapsulate you? The people you say cause all the problems~ turn that finger around back at yourselves. I'm here to hear this piece, not read a childish debate.

  • @mirandusings
    @mirandusings 11 лет назад

    I see what you did there...

  • @scalls95
    @scalls95 11 лет назад

    Nope... For a start, the dominant 7th chord... need I say more?

  • @OurSeaBee
    @OurSeaBee 11 лет назад +1

    The idea that Christians love their enemies isn't a standard we're held to by atheists, it's a standard imposed by Jesus. He's fairly significant to the faith, he is.

  • @ninjaassassin27
    @ninjaassassin27 11 лет назад

    Can you all just stop arguing and enjoy the fucking music?

  • @solareclipseaboveus
    @solareclipseaboveus 11 лет назад

    Good christians respect other people and their beliefs. Stop being so rude! Btw I'm a christian if you wonder.

  • @UnRoman111
    @UnRoman111 11 лет назад

    forgiving on whom? of the ones who hate Him? Are you Blind?

  • @charlottewhyte9804
    @charlottewhyte9804 9 лет назад +1

    the poor sound quality does nothing for the choir at all.shame

  • @sarum1surplice
    @sarum1surplice 14 лет назад

    This Motet is for Christmass, not the the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus.

  • @carolineleiden
    @carolineleiden 11 лет назад

    Faith is something that has to be instilled in a child at a very young age. After the age of 7, it is too late. They have become rational by then. The door closes.
    You cannot choose to become a believer a later age. So when parents deny this opportunity to their children by deliberately keeping them unaware of God or even hating him, they are taking away their children's one and only chance to ever have faith.
    The other way around is no problem. You can lose your faith anytime later in life.

  • @TomasMikaX
    @TomasMikaX 11 лет назад

    So you don't care about what Jesus said?

  • @Sefashfasoula
    @Sefashfasoula 11 лет назад

    A christian on the internet is like a tritone in a Palestrina composition.

  • @TomasMikaX
    @TomasMikaX 11 лет назад

    Did Jesus teach you to be rude to strangers or is that just you?

  • @AstolfoHynkel1
    @AstolfoHynkel1 11 лет назад +1

    Atheists appreciate "Quadradinho de 8". Joke.

  • @mad0racle771
    @mad0racle771 10 лет назад +1

    O? You didn't achieve immortality while still alive? So you're just going to disappear along with everything you've ever accomplished? Sounds like you just wasted your life along with the rest of human kind.

    • @classicaldeb
      @classicaldeb 10 лет назад +3

      warlockmohl whose, not who's.

  • @TheDerrickoh
    @TheDerrickoh 11 лет назад

    No, they don't hate God. They may hate religion, or some of the radicals that participate in that religion, but they do not hate God because they do not believe in him.

  • @christopherolsen1225
    @christopherolsen1225 10 лет назад +2

    poor nietzche :( so misquoted by the stupid masses (YES YOU Mauro BARBOSA VIERIA)..... if there were gods, how could i endure not to be a god. Therefore there are no gods. Besides using his quote in that manner tells me you havent read thus spoke Zarathustra. Remember "My brothers in war! I love you from my very heart, I am and have always been of your kind. & am also your best enemy. So let me tell you the truth!".

  • @afroclamn
    @afroclamn 11 лет назад

    That isn't the way to go about convincing others of your faith. It's unnerving to see Christians like yourself, if you truly are such, acting in that way. I believe Christ teaches us to be always kind and forgiving, and to love your fellow man, who is your brother. Convince others by way of example, not hatred.

  • @PointyTailofSatan
    @PointyTailofSatan 8 лет назад +5

    That stained glass of Jesus makes me laugh. He looks like a Swedish beatnik. lol

  • @TomasMikaX
    @TomasMikaX 11 лет назад

    Do you think Jesus would approve of such a behavior?

  • @TomasMikaX
    @TomasMikaX 11 лет назад

    I don't think you are for real.

  • @rusoviettovarich9221
    @rusoviettovarich9221 5 лет назад

    This is one of the reasons for those who left Catholicism for evangelicalism to return. The traditions and rituals of the church have no equal anywhere and 'homilies' only go so far - as to 'contemporary' worship music. That alone is the reason to run from any 'pro-tes-tant' service.

  • @jamesbond-fj5ri
    @jamesbond-fj5ri 11 лет назад

    exuse me? culture? the christian culture is still there to enjoy
    it's just that we have matured past superstitious belief. This music is still our heritage as well as the architecture
    do u see?
    an atheist would have never thought of insulting someone with such IGNORANCE
    i believe i am trying to get a message across

  • @TomasMikaX
    @TomasMikaX 11 лет назад

    Would Jesus approve of your behavior?

  • @geot4647
    @geot4647 5 лет назад +1

    Edward Abbey brought me here.