Prof. Alan Dershowitz Describes the Ivy League Universities' Double Standard
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 дек 2023
- Prof. Alan Dershowitz, Professor Emeritus, Harvard Law School Describes the Ivy League Universities Double Standard in conversation with i24NEWS’ Calev Ben-David - ‘The DEI (diversity, equity, inclusion) excludes Jews’
Articles: www.i24news.tv/en
Facebook: / i24newsen
Twitter: / i24news_en
Instagram: / i24news
#i24NEWS #i24NEWSDesk
Live news updates throughout the day from around the world.
I think that even more importantly there has to be a wall between free speech and harassment.
A student is walking home from class, and a mob follows him, yelling obscenities and h..eful things RUclips wouldn't let me say.
Free speech? No, harassment. Students need to be clearly told that.
Today this stuff is not allowed towards non-Jewish students. But it is allowed towards Jewish students. This is the problem.
HATE Speech is not FREE Speech
Who defines hate speech?
@@doncarlson100 Threatening, harassing and intimidating someone for their ethnicity is hate speech. Criticizing someone because you do not agree with them is not hate speech. When the person or group go beyond disagreement and engage in harassment, bullying, intimidation and threats of violence towards that person where they fear for their life is not only hate speech, it is a crime. It has to stop.
I agree.
@@doncarlson100
I agree with @bonnie.
You should really sit down and digest what s/he wrote.
You can call me names etc, but if you come up and do that right in my face, that's intimidation/harassment.
Thank you Dr. Dershowitz🙏✨💛
1:59 DEI excludes WHITE people in general. He needs to be more honest about his own culture and religion.
@@user-zq4fv8sj6vwhat heck are you promoting with this Judenhass nonsense. He never said anything about being for anti-white prejudice.
Judaism is not responsible for DEI. And he's entirely against it and always has been.
The thing that sickens me is she resigned as the President of UPenn, but stayed on in a faculty position of the University. She wasn’t punished. She was rewarded, because now she’s no longer in front of it. I hope the donors still pull contributions.
These places have been anti-American, pro-communist, and flagrantly racist for decades. People who have contributed in the last 50 years are fools or traitors. This anti-Jewish stuff doesn't change anything as far as I'm concerned.
People thought she was stupid; anything but. She is a tenured prof and simply can go back to that as she deems necessary. Better than a golden parachute. No wonder she doesn't care what she says or thinks. A protected species. Above the law. Probably very surprised ANYONE dared to challenge her and her accepted (in the academic community anyway) positions. How dare the peons question her? Oh yeah, she just forgot they can. Reality can be harsh.
@@WilliamMurphy-uv9pm One irony with that woman is that the person who gave her her biggest break was...a Jewess, namely Justice Ginsburg, who hired her as a Supreme Court clerk. Only 40 out of 40,000 law grads get that chance each year.
@@kreek22 Interesting additional comments. Thanks. I don't think she has anything against Jews; just people and groups who don't view the world and our society the way she "thinks" she does. She just accepts the propaganda without even thinking it out. That is also how academia wants the "kids" to react. After a while it is a part of you and no questions get asked. Might call it having been completely absorbed. That would be considered a successful education. Who cares if Washington chopped down a cherry tree or crossed any river. Not relevant to the targeted education system.
Foreign money to American universities should be illegal.
The professor is ABSOLUTELY right beyond doubts.
Magill stays on probably at same salary...."ouchie"
Also a "Friend" of Jeffery Epstein.
Every war was won by destroying the civilian populations… after WWII.. the shift was to endless wars…
well according to usa and canada hate speeches against hindus is free speech same countries are proud of supporting terrorism and terrorist against india its time for jews to wake up christians and muslims both have shaddy malicious agenda its time to form alliance with hindus @@williamsharp2532
He freed OJ.
I wouldn't hire a Harvard gratitude ever! High school graduates are more intelligent!
LOLOL!!
And they have more gratitude!
Not more intelligent, but more sane.
'Gratitude?'
@@autodidact537 I think he meant "gratuitous."
A brilliant scholar and a very brave man.
It is absolutely brilliant that these universities are being called out.
Like Alan said, it’s not enough to call them out or remove a token president here or there, the Marxist rot and Jew hatred is thicker than flies on shit!
You obviously don't believe in free speech. What it shows is unhealthy influence of 2% of the American population on the 98% of the rest of the country.In the long-run,this influence will rebound to the detriment of the two percent.
Dr. Dershowitz is correct. Note that the U.S. Supreme Court declared public universities’ speech codes to be unconstitutional in 1989, and there has been no ill effect. Private schools should also drop their speech codes.
Not knowing what aspect of code there could need clarification as foul and abusive restraints must be adhered for learning and teaching.
Minor students’ health and safety are entrusted to the schools responsibility … sue them … return tuition … send to jail
1:59 It excludes WHITE people in general.
@@steveosborne1239 Direct, immediate threats to one’s personal wellbeing cross from speech to conduct and require correction, but the public colleges have allowed free speech to flourish for almost 35 years now with none of the problems now seen at the Ivies.
Murderer OJ Simpson is on the golf course thanks to this clown.
Thank you Dr. Dershowitz....your so right it's not just about getting rid of a president here and there. This thing runs very deep. But let's get started by having all three presidents asked to resign to send a clear message.
IDF have now murdered seven thousand children. You can thank Netanyahu for any increase in antisemitism.
There are Jews in Israel that are against Zionist expansion. Those guys have real courage. Zionists are just the planet's biggest cry bullies.
Do a Search on Dershowitz , Trump & Epstein connection
Shame Epstein was EPSTEINED because Mossad could have installed him as president, like he did with the corrupt American Congress.
Free speech without threats or intimidation is good! Calling for Genocide of a protected class is not only morally equal to Nazi’s it’s illegal. Violation of civil rights. Not only these Universities but many should be ashamed of themselves.
Protected class? Brainwashed class you mean! Indoctrination is the biggest danger to peace.
Who is a "protected class"?
@@kreek22there are several groups that are protected, that is why we have such things as hate crimes. If you aren’t one of the groups it just a good old crime
@@oldman7735 "hate crimes" are simply political crimes, like not wearing a hijab in Iran. In America, that designation violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution. But, then, affirmative action also violates that clause, as does the Civil Rights Act of 1965.
Well stated Mr. Dershowitz - I stand with Israel 🙏🇨🇦
“Disabled, Transgender Zionist of color, “would make their head explode😅
I too stand with Israel...
I stand with Israel love from Canada
you stand with israel where the army kills babies
Canada has it's own history of killing children, is there really any need to associate Canada with any more murdered children?
Dr. Phil just put out a statement people should hear.
That would be the first time ever
@@adamgates1142 You win the comment section.
Prof. Dershowitz makes so much sense - we cannot have a double standard for some groups and not for others. Just look at the behavior of some of those students and one can sense that something's not right behind the scenes.
There's been a double standard since 1965, with the passage of the Anti-Civil Rights Act.
At the same time, threat of bodily harm or threats of murder is legally assault.
But he always supported Republicans double standards .
The child diddler doesn't make sense. He is just a terrible human being
Still waiting for the Presidents of Harvard and MIT to offer their resignations.
Agree with this professor 100 %. God protect Israel...
IDF have now murdered seven thousand children
@@rgghjs9270 Seven thousand children while Hamas is hiding in the protection of their tunnels they leave the kids out there to be used as martyer.
@@boynamesue7720 "they've left the kids out in the open, quick, get them!"
There are more than plenty of videos of Israelis hating on Christians, even spitting on them.
Long live Dershowitz
Thank you, keep up your work. It is not just Jews, it is Christians also.
What about whites? 🤗
@@waaromweldanAll who are perceived to be oppressors plus those in the oppressed who are deemed traitors, e.g., “black faces of white supremacy.”
All these Lefitists Universities Officers NEED TO BE REMOVED. Defund, stop Granting and Donoring these Schools!
As ever, Professor Dershowitz hits the nail on the head.
Didn’t he defend epstein
He definitely does not know the history of WW2...his comments were blatantly false
@@tylerschlegel2242 Figures he has a forked tongue
The name 'Harvard' has lost any cachet it once had. If someone says, "I'm a Harvard grad", I'd avoid hiring them or interacting with them.
I would give a pass to Harvard students who graduated before 2000.
Three comments in a row talking about intelligence all having spelling errors.
They must be Harvard gratitudes with cachet.
Something like 1/3 of all missiles that Hamas fires into Israel (12,000 since the conflict started) fall short and land in Gaza.
The Hamas-run 'Health Ministry' counts in their casualty counts Gazan civilians killed by Hamas, by Palestinian Islamic Jihad, by friendly fire, by stray fire, by death from illness and dehydration, by death from Israeli fire. They combine terrorists and civilians into a single number, and the number of deaths is likewise exaggerated.
It is truly remarkable how the Hamas ‘Health Ministry’ was and is able to produce and provide data of casualties in the multiple thousands in a matter of minutes, or even hours, like 5,000 children, 12,000 people without the benefit of fuel and electricity.
We are being asked to believe that within hours, Hamas ‘Health Ministry’ is able to put out fires, clear the rubble, and accurately count how many people died in an explosion or strike. That is simply impossible, even as a close estimate.
The best governments in the world would weeks to figure out a preliminary number of dead in a situation like this.
Where is the Hamas Health Ministry located exactly? In the tunnels, the bunkers? Where? They seem to manage the feat of being invisible, or is it a matter of there's no there there?
It took Israel 5 weeks which was last week to get an exact figure on their dead civilians, with the most up to date forensic technology & several hundred dedicated medical team 24/7 on the case so it’s impossible for the Hamas controlled terrorist health ministry to know how many dead there are in minutes, the majority of their figures must not be civilians but Hamas combatants. They are providing figures on which would be easier for them to count.
Take all that together and you begin to understand why the numbers are jumping from day to day, from 10,000 to 12,000 to 15,000 to 18,000 to 20,000. Basically, add up the number of people who typically die in Gaza on an ordinary Tuesday + the extra people who have died due to general military conditions on the ground + people who are killed by Hamas + terrorists who are killed by Israel, and you can approach the numbers that the Hamas ‘Health Ministry’ puts out.
@@barbaracollins5605
@@samuelross9884 Israel may have taken 5 weeks to get their figures straight, but they released their estimate of deaths very quickly--then lowered the numbers in the following weeks. Should Hamas release no estimates, given the example Israel set?
Imagine an "intelligent" ant in a ten-story cargo ship, could it ever get to understand where is it and who could have designed and built the ship, its "world"?
Well, we are even smaller in relation to the Universe and are pretending to decipher and comprehend how it all works and how it was created or started. We are still very far from being able to have a mere idea!
@@kreek22
Dershowitz gives me hope there are still a few decent non-hypocritical Democrats left.
Dershowitz is a convicted pedophile who visited Epstein's island.
Nobody cares what this guy has to say!
Don't hold your breathe... He has to stand with Israel, he's Jewish...
@@jenscheibner792 Why shouldn't he stand with Israel? He is Jewish but not only that, he is standing against the barbarians at the gate who are seeking to eradicate the Jews from the earth. Let that sink in for a moment. Also, Dershowitz does not support a number of leftist regressive positions. Dershowitz is not the average democrat who follows lock step in line with whatever the issue of the moment is that democrats are pushing. He is a critical thinker and often disagrees with the democrat leadership in the Senate and Congress. Dershowitz is a breath of fresh air.
@@jenscheibner792Read his book, “The case for Israel.” It’s good.
Check out Norman Finkelstein & Dershowitz Debate to see what a dirty liar Dershowitz really is. Also, Check out his relationship with the Nasty Dirty Epstein.
Thank professor for telling the truth 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
The truth is there are now seven thousand dead children thanks to Netanyahu's IDF. How many of those children voted for Hamas in 2006? They weren't even born...
Suspend the schools tax exempt status! Their endowments could now sustain them. You foment division within the US you lose your exemption!
The IRS doesn’t even have the balls to do that with the Catholic Church after the voluminous amount of accusations, lawsuits, JUDGMENTS and BANKRUPTCIES! Biden is an Irish Catholic making justice futile for true victims in that realm. He’s too mentally ill to do anything of substance as it is.
They're not fomenting division, they're pushing biocommunism--and have pushed it for 50 years with the express approval of clan members like Dershowitz.
Alan Dershowitz. A true mensch.
Except he still votes for Democrats. They HATE US!
Longtime freund of Epstein 😜
I like Dershowitz but I can’t forget he was a bleeding heart liberal for a long time. Also defended O.J. Simpson knowing he was double murderer. Glad he has come over to the right side. Israel Strong🇮🇱
Don't forget that he was a pal of Jeffery Epstein.
I wished that Professor Alan Dershowitz was 25 years younger as he would be my vote for president.
Age has nothing to do with it. When I was a university student our professors were in their 70s and 80s! This was normal.
It would be interesting to have a Dem President who was really an Israeli rather than the usual situation where he's really a communist.
@@heather725 Thank you for your reply. Age has everything to do with it as the professor is currently 85 and if elected he would be 86 and at the end of his term he would be 90. At his current age, he is not electable by the American public.
Iran is backing Hamas. If the current Hamas leadership agreed to peace, then Iran would move its support to a splinter group that did not support peace. This is the fact that helps explain why people would want a war with Israel that results in things like disruptions to their hospital's neo-natal intensive care unit. They don't. The people want progress, not war.
Qatar is also.
Agreed, except for that last sentence, which has a communist ordure about it.
@@kreek22 I was thinking progress as in Starbucks, PlayStations, and free vaccines.
@@crimony3054 Better than communism.
I think, for it to be more than a resurfacing project, that they'll have to start with Enlightenment, Science, and Industrialization.
💯 correct.
North America better be really careful, cause even our country can be occupied. Close your border MEN.
University leaders can resign and return to teaching or research with no diminution of salary and benefits. Resignation is a symbolic gesture, not necessarily punitive.
And that's what Magill is doing .
Wrong. Presidents make far more money than professors.
Right on Mr. Dershowitz!
The codes of conduct at the Universities don't have to be reworked. They merely have to be applied fairly and to all. For almost decades, and certainly the past 15 years, these 'codes' did not apply when Jewish students were being harassed and threatened.
Oh please. AIPAC spends millions to suppress criticism of Israel on campus by slandering people as antisemitic and getting them fired if they're faculty.
Even since Dershowitz and his clan got the civil rights act (so-called) passed, anti-white attacks have been endless and unremarked in clan media.
Professor, you're my hero! You are man of principle and integrity, even if I may disagree with you on some issues.
Professor Alan Dershowitz is an outstanding contributor and knowledgeable and respected. Thanks for bring him on! And a special note to Prof. Dershowitz, "We need your brilliant mind writing and speaking which is also a Battlefield arena, just without a gun".
THE TRUTH. PERIOD.
Sad how colleges on run
Correct .....double standards ......Gay must resign or be fired
Helpful hint for the interviewer: Speak in complete sentences. You're welcome.
God save us from the “graduates” of these universities
I graduated from one of them (twice) and have never voted for a Democrat in my life.
@@kreek22 You’re a survivor.
Thank you Dr. Dershowitz.❤🙏🙏🙏
It's not just a double standard against Jews but also against whites and particularly white men. It is crazy to me that it has to be said - but there shouldn't be calls to commit genocide against anyone or discrimination against anyone based on their race, skin color, gender, or national origin. Where have I heard that before? Oh, in the Civil Rights Act. Why do people talk and act like these are not our established principles?? As if we didn't learn anything from the past. ☹️
The elite seeks to impose communism on the non-elite, which entails racism in order to force equalization. If you cannot raise Africa (and that hasn't happened at all), then you must lower Europe and Asia.
Bravo dr prof Dershowitz, I too would go if I would be younger.
DEI = disgrace
On point Dr. Dershowitz!
Dr is correct
A U.S. Representative pointed out that, while the country is about 50-50 regarding former Pres. Trump, at Harvard only one percent of the Harvard faculty identified itself as supporting Trump. One percent.
So much for diversity at Harvard.
Who says the country is 50-50 on Trump. As I recall he lost in a landslide.
No it's because Harvard profs are high iq. .
@@Susan-lf2hl Hahaahahahahhahahahahahahaha! HAH!
This effectively means there is no use entering Harvard because, with such a bias, you would be prevented from graduating.
The President of Harvard should be fired.
Calling for the genocide of ANY group of people should not be allowed in ANY circumstance and the fact that this is protected speech in the US may just be one of the most disturbing things about the US. Talk about taking free speech to the extreme. I’m all for free speech and think limitations should be applied sparingly however this if anything should be one of those limitations. In this instance the line between advocacy and incitement is very nebulous while advocacy alone is heinous enough that it should not be tolerated in any way shape or form. Would any of these naive and low IQ free speech absolutists still support the right for Nazi Germany to advocate for the genocide of a particular group in WWII?
I agree that calling for genocide is morally reprehensible. The problem is that language is flexible and sometimes we exaggerate and overstate. What about a statement like "all murderers should be executed?" Should that not be allowed? What about a statement like "I think the world would be better off if there were no redheads in it" (sorry redheads just a hypothetical). Does that count as a call to genocide? What about language such as "we are in a war with cops" or "we are in a war with [insert group here]"? Isn't that similar to a call for violence/genocide? Who gets to decide what is "extreme"? And that ultimately is the scariest question. The example here with the University presidents should actually teach us that we should not restrict any speech unless it is a direct and immediate call to violence. The Universities have cancelled speech they don't like and claim that such speech is harassment. Many people on the left think that speech alone is violent and if someone states something that contradicts their opinion, they will claim it is an act of genocide. No thanks! I do not want people's philosophical statements (even ones I think are morally reprehensible) subject to legal action by politically motivated judges.
By the way, yes, we would support the Nazi's right to free speech. Once upon a time the ACLU (which I have many political disagreements with) advocated for the right of a group of neo-Nazis to conduct a rally in the late '70s in Skokie, Illinois. I only wish they still believed in free speech like they once did.
Finally, I say allow them to spout their evil, so everyone can know who stands for what. Free speech makes it a lot easier to know who our enemies are.
All victims are equal but some are more ‘equal’ than others.
You are a man Doctor ❤
Poison Ivy
Well stated - thank you 🙏 🇮🇱
Bravo and well said on all points!
Double standard until you threatened them with taking your donation back😂😂😂..then it seems like these schools are biting the hands that feeds them😮😮..
Jews today, Christians tomorrow then???
Any illegal that here with a criminal record or anything needs to be deported! Get them out!!
A college degree is grossly over rated, but there is an erroneous presumption that it a indicator of competence for a job.
With freedom comes responsibility...freedom of speech is no exception.
Didn’t this guy negotiated the sweet heart deal for Epstein?
It also excludes Christians, Jews, and Whites.
Harvard has a $50 billion dollar endowment. They laugh at their critics.
Congratulations Prof. Dershowitz.
Those university leaders were despicable. How the top institutions can have such people in charge beggars belief.
Follow the funding…then you will have an aha moment, unfortunately .
Just think of them like Soviet apparatchiks, whom they closely resemble. All that matters in the educational bureaucracy is loyalty to the Party, the Dem Party, of course. One and all, they are biocommunists. That Harvard President has published a total of 11 academic papers in her career. In her field, the average professor publishes that many each year. Academic merit is irrelevant, only Party loyalty counts. This is also why their words and thoughts are almost identical: they all follow the Party Line, which is how they rose to lead their universities.
Mr. Rajiv Malhotra of Infiniti Foundation has been talking about this for years and years because Harvard also has an anti Hindu agenda similar to anti Semitism. Hope people will sit up and take notice of that issue as well. India 🇮🇳 stands with Israel 🇮🇱
In democratic country we are allowed free speech but there is law in our democracy also that does not allow profanity. It means there is boundary to free speech. Anyone can be taken to court for using profane languages and behaviors. We have laws that govern our morality. No one is above the law in democratic country.
@@joebrewer4529 your comment is out of context
Dersh is the man
Allen Dershowitz is talking Ethics, seriously now ? Wow oh wow.
None of these schools should be receiving and Federal money.
@stevebeimler2579
1 second ago
I went to UC Berkeley and free speech was the norm - BUT only if one’s arguments were factually based and presented using an educated Socratic-like method of dialogue; Certainly not a free-for-all screaming match - peppered with cultural and political bias - oh vey
Yes, let's talk double standards. Prof. Dershowitz advocates for a political party that not only accepts support from right wing antisemities but won't denounce those supporters antisemitic rhetoric. The Nazis that marched in Charlllottesville we're pronounced "very fine people". Apparently that double standard doesn't disturb Prof. Dershowitz.
The Supreme Court has roundly rejected prior restraint.
Agree!
Who is the "French philosopher" Dershowitz mentions at 5:02 ?
I'm with Prof Dershowitz. It's the double standard when it comes to speaking against all other minority groups that constitute hate speech , bullying and harassment which these universities do not apply to the Jews
Substitute black for Jew. Is it acceptable?
The should not be a double standard for free speech on University Campuses.
If we examine these universities, you will find many different such issues that all need to be looked into prior to implementing improvement changes.
Sorry, no. Universities should not be allowed to tolerate calls to violent action. Calls for river to the sea and globalize the intifada are direct calls for violent action. Though racist comments about black inferiority or different views about pronouns could imply action, they merely express opinions without directly calling for action or inciting violence. Calling for and inciting violence should certainly go against university policy as well as explicitly tolerating and condoning it.
As a white male conservative and Christian, I just cannot understand the Jewish position on these double standards. Glad we haven't been facing that for years upon years.
There’s such moral rot in these universities.
The single standard violates repressive tolerance
Mr Dershowitz is a good man. I stand for Israel
It's not a double standard, it's racism. If you cannot criticize--rightly criticize--a group or a member of that group, it's racism. There are groups that NEED criticism. To deny critical thought and critical commentary is to deny the whole premise of education.
Happy Hanukkah professor 🎉
Even a broken clock...
She resigned into a tenured position 😂😂😂
What a complete white wash.
It's about time this DEI ideology is exposed and trashed.
When Deshowitz was a young man He advised us to take action on campus but did not do so himself!
Once the women took over these universities they all became emotional cat houses. Very typical of an eighth grade lunch room.
Calev Ben-David needs to get off the speed and testosterone combo asap, as well as turn his hearing aid up or down, whichever will help stop him shouting
Free speech is only free when its respectful and is used in truth or condemnation, correction and reasoning not for prupose of an nature of threatening to fear of ones life then it becomes criminal and abusive speech should be used for civil discussion and thought not to incite terrenity and riots of harmful destruction property and life. Freedom is not something to be taken to do what ever but carries consequences and personal responsibility to which can yield harm or good . So that I think was the intent even of the bill of rights as was intended
He’s absolutely right about DEI but wrong about Gaza.
Professor Dershowitz and others should consider the impact of the Frankfurt School. They are mesmerized by the school's Critical Race Theory. The school, whose advocates were mostly Jewish, was founded in the Weimar Republic after WWI. German Gentiles saw the school's left-wing ideology as an attack on traditional German cultural values which in turn, contributed to the rise of Hitler.
It is all well and good for Professor Dershowitz to have reached out to the greater American community, but more must be done. Greater transparency is required, from him and many, many others.
Free speech that incites violence, whether it be in the form of threatening words or actions, never trumps the safety of students. Never.
This is what intersectionalism means. All groups which favor socialist solutions are part if the team, and you may not criticize any part of the left.
Please protect this man!
🇮🇱 🇺🇸 I STAND WITH ISRAEL! 🇮🇱 🇺🇸
Netanyahu's IDF have now killed 1% of Palestinians.
1% of USA would be 3,350,000 people.
70% of those killed were women and children. Nearly half children.
Woohoo..?
That interviewer is the most inarticulate, hard to listen to person in the whole wide world.
My only issue with this is, where was this guy before when the culture war was raging. It’s been going for a long time.
DEI IS RACIST