This piece is so beautiful…I intend to learn it!!! I don’t know about y’all but I imagine a girl in a ballroom with a flower garden right outside and a mysterious figure comes and dances with her. Definitely a piece I’d play for my girlfriend or wife❤️
@@luciferscatmilk I agree. and that's why I love music. it makes us imagine different scenarios! for me, the feeling described that I felt was someone playing this song on the piano and nobody pays attention, but the person playing doesn't really care and as long as they're happy.
Best performance for this masterpiece, it is one of my favorite classic piano creation, when I play or hear it, it gives me an emotional feeling of life power, something divine which we cannot get it, sublime with a combination of harmonic arpeggios and dissonance (chromatic transitions), it feels both sadness and hopefulness like Schubert wanted to convey the soundtrack of his life in one piece...
It's a great performance that warms my heart. His perfectly organized performance is always inspiring. His performance of Schubert really seems impossible to imitate anyone. I'm getting comforted today as well.
This piece is insanely difficult, I would find my self in the practice room for hours repeating the same passage just to play it perfectly. None the less, good luck
Amazing. The whole composition is sublime, and the ending is so soothing. I love those kinds of endings: The ones that finish with a extremely soft final chord.
I heard this piece outside the music room at my university and it was absolutely beautiful but I didn't know the song's name until today. So glad to have found this :) Edit: Piece, not song
Alfred Brendel plays Schubert as nobody. Perfect technique and feeling. And he's self-taught, like all the best artists: Bach, Chopin, Paganini, Wagner, Carlos Kleiber, etc
A I don’t especially think so, it just Thames ALOT of practice! Done and dusted after about a month, except I had to write down some of the “unusual” notes in the piece.
Wow! It's a very great piece by Schubert! I love it, since the first moment that I listened to it! Imagine that I had to choose a number of this Schubert's opera, to study it for my music exam, and the first number that I choosed, was this, immediatly! In other words, I love this piece, and the pianist who played in this video was very great! (anyway, sorry for my english 😅) ❤❤❤
January 2021. I haven't played for a while, I've stopped with the studio, it will be three years, but that doesn't matter. In the midst of a pandemic I listened to this piece, a probable piece to take to the conservatory exam further on. I am blocked, everything is blocked, I would like to resume my life. I am not happy, yet I lack nothing, except that freedom. I miss it all, despite the fact that I terribly hated it. I'm here, I'll print the score, I'll get up and my hands will start dancing again. Despite Covid, the psychological weakness, the inner malaise that, even if sometimes invisible, tears me apart. - Gennaio 2021. È un po 'di tempo che non suono, che sono ferma con lo studio saranno tre anni, ma questo poco importa. Nel bel mezzo di una pandemia ho ascoltato questo brano, un probabile pezzo da portare all’esame di conservatorio più in là. Sono bloccata, tutto è bloccato, vorrei riprendere la mia vita. Non sono felice, eppure non mi manca niente, tranne che quella libertà. Mi manca tutto, nonostante io l'abbia terribilmente odiato. Sono qui, stamperó lo spartito, mi rialzeró e riprenderanno le mie mani a danzare. Nonostante il Covid, la debolezza psicologica, il malessere interiore che, anche se talvolta invisibile, mi lacera.
This impromptu reminds me the Liebestraume of Liszt Changing some notes Liszt thought he can fool us . Schubert at young age composed world class masterpieces Liszt knew very well who he was stealing
I think it's beautiful, but therein lies the old classical vs. romantic rendition. Either way works for me. I love Vlad's live version, but I love this too. The music is genius.
I’d thumb it up if it were in F#M. Franz can go fuck himself. A hole. Only Bach is a bigger a hole for using C# M for Prelude and Fugue 3. Complete dick move.
Can't give it a thumbs up, not when there's so little expression going on all the way through :( Disappointing, boring, monochromatic, and generally too loud. Guess I'll be avoiding Brendel now. The piece is better than the pianist is giving it credit for.
Beautiful. It seems (to my ears, at least) to anticipate some of Liszt's more lyrical pieces. Some of the harmonies and figurations here greatly resemble the middle sections of the Pensees des Morts and Die Zelle in Nonnenwerth. I see someone below has also pointed out the Liebestraum.
Anyone in Melb Australia I will teach this to for free, it isn't very hard at all. As long as you can clutch a handful and put some love into it to bring out the melody. The themes are repetitive or tiny variations. Beautiful piece, people always respond well to it.
@steppinout67 Hehe 8D It has to to with skills. You have to be on a surtain piano level to play this. It's ectually really easy to play. If you just know how to use your skills :)
I learned this piece years ago and never understood the double cut time signature. We didn't have internet like that years ago, but we do now! Time to look that up!
What a nice description. I can hear in this how much Brendel loves Schubert but his playing does tend to have a rougher texture than the music needs. Have you heard Kempff's interpretation? It's my favorite, slower and very subtle. It's available on YT. Nevertheless, after Kempff, Brendel is my favorite interpreter of Schubert.
Interessant, dass Manfred Mann den Anfang dieses Stücks "geklaut" und dann eine der tollsten, aber gleichzeitig unbekanntesten Balladen der Rockgeschichte mit einer unwahrscheinlich dichten und intensiven Atmosphäre gemacht hat: Das Lied heißt Questions und könnte auch manchem gefallen, der mit Rock nichts am Hut hat...
Schubert wrote this piece a friend who had insomnia. It worked. The dude was out cold by measure #567. Schubert also tried to write a longer version, but could never finish it, because HE kept falling asleep.
Randy Kern it's weird because the melody and left hand seem to be counting in 8/4 but the other voices in the right hand have to be tripled because otherwise they don't fit the time
It sounds nicer and the black notes fit the hand better. Also, don't quote me on this but I think it has to do with well temperament (at least back when it was written). Perhaps another part of it has to do with where the 'singing' line sits naturally? Can anyone who knows more than me confirm?
Though Schubert only lived for 31 years, this masterpiece will be passed down by generation to generation❤️
Schubert had a one of a kind gift for melodies. Always achingly beautiful.
+ Chopin. Masters of form are Liszt, Beethoven, etc
@@PastPerspectives11 And Czerny, Cramer and Clementi, Marmontel, Mayer, Jules Schullhoff, Kohler, Kuhlau, Heller, Steibelt, Concone, Splinder, Bohm, Dussek, Duvernoy, Le Couppey, Berger, Hanon, Schaffer ,etc.
Czeyner La Mente Musical wow u can list so many 😮 😯 😲
Most deserve to be forgotten
@@PastPerspectives11 + Bach, le Roi des mélodies, pour ceux qui ont des oreilles pour l' entendre...et plus moi bien sûr...
This version helped me on my long walks to my job at night. It's just keeps going.
Keep doing the good work you doing my man.
Gentle as you go. Its so beautiful
Such a lonely piece.....
I just had a bad headache & stomach cramp. I just lay on my bed, closed my eyes, listening to this & it slowly vanished! The healing power of music.
I always appreciate being comforted by Schubert.
Seem like sounds from heaven, so calm and peaceful comforting one's soul.
This piece is so beautiful…I intend to learn it!!! I don’t know about y’all but I imagine a girl in a ballroom with a flower garden right outside and a mysterious figure comes and dances with her. Definitely a piece I’d play for my girlfriend or wife❤️
I don’t imagine that at all our thoughts are pretty unique
@@luciferscatmilk I agree. and that's why I love music. it makes us imagine different scenarios!
for me, the feeling described that I felt was someone playing this song on the piano and nobody pays attention, but the person playing doesn't really care and as long as they're happy.
If humanity would only stop and listen to this and contemplate it, perhaps hearts would be opened up to peace and love and joy.
Best performance for this masterpiece, it is one of my favorite classic piano creation, when I play or hear it, it gives me an emotional feeling of life power, something divine which we cannot get it, sublime with a combination of harmonic arpeggios and dissonance (chromatic transitions), it feels both sadness and hopefulness like Schubert wanted to convey the soundtrack of his life in one piece...
It's a great performance that warms my heart. His perfectly organized performance is always inspiring. His performance of Schubert really seems impossible to imitate anyone. I'm getting comforted today as well.
dang, that's a lot of flats.
thank you for the theory lecture, her ludvig.
Margo Polo yh they like lil Bs innit
Actually, it's only two notes without flats. Quite easy if you think about it this way ;)
actually just 1 without flat (F)
you gotta stay sharp
G-flat major, a truly sublime key. Especially in the combined hands of Schubert and Brendel.
My professor just assigned me this piece to work on over fall break and I’m so excited!!! This melody is absolutely beautiful!
This piece is insanely difficult, I would find my self in the practice room for hours repeating the same passage just to play it perfectly. None the less, good luck
Took me a year to play it at an “acceptable” level...Right hand finger control of lift is challenging.
My piano teachers always said "Not that one" I played op. 90 no. 2 & 4 though. Soon I will try to learn the number 3.
@@FirstGentleman1 boo to them! At this level, I’d say play the pieces you want to!
I love Playing this, the first piece i taught myself. Schubert was such a lyrical maestro!
I always appreciate being comforted by Schubert.
Bellissimo questo brano❤️
Lo ha suonato mia zia al suo concerto qualche giorno fa e dal vivo è ancora più bello😍🎹❤️
Amazing. The whole composition is sublime, and the ending is so soothing. I love those kinds of endings: The ones that finish with a extremely soft final chord.
This piece is one of the best things in life for your soul ! Thank you Franz!
The music is beautiful... this music makes me dream... ❤
From Bolivia greetings to all persons in this world ❤
Just beautiful, I love it, particularly the measured slower pace.
Brendel is just supreme in the lovely music of Schubert.
I heard this piece outside the music room at my university and it was absolutely beautiful but I didn't know the song's name until today. So glad to have found this :)
Edit: Piece, not song
It's a piece - not really a song - as it has no words.
It‘s a piece.
Piece, song.... doesn’t really matter. Music transcends language, don’t get so hung up on syntax :)
It is also called a song without words. ;)
The same thing happened to then this piece changed my life!
It takes me to another dimension!
Magnificent!
Alfred Brendel plays Schubert as nobody. Perfect technique and feeling. And he's self-taught, like all the best artists: Bach, Chopin, Paganini, Wagner, Carlos Kleiber, etc
I am sure that's the spirit of the piece. The master would be pleased.
Amazing performance by Brendel, l learned to play only the first 4 pages of this masterpiece and it worth my efforts..
Yossi Schneider why stop at page 4? After 4 is a repeat or quasi repeat of pages 1 and 2 and much easier than pages 3 and 4.
@@pascalcs True. I chose this piece to learn simply because it's repetitive. Memorised the first page just today.
I’ve been playing this for months now but still cannot get it perfect. Monstrously difficult.
A I don’t especially think so, it just Thames ALOT of practice! Done and dusted after about a month, except I had to write down some of the “unusual” notes in the piece.
@@michaelglk Why did you have to write them down? They are already written down.
Schubert is such a lyrical genius!
AMOUR also brought me here.
I have been listening to the different versions of this divine piece.
Pour Schubert, toujours! Merci!
Wow! It's a very great piece by Schubert! I love it, since the first moment that I listened to it! Imagine that I had to choose a number of this Schubert's opera, to study it for my music exam, and the first number that I choosed, was this, immediatly! In other words, I love this piece, and the pianist who played in this video was very great! (anyway, sorry for my english 😅) ❤❤❤
Schubert music has a story which has emotional episodes 😌😌😌
January 2021. I haven't played for a while, I've stopped with the studio, it will be three years, but that doesn't matter. In the midst of a pandemic I listened to this piece, a probable piece to take to the conservatory exam further on. I am blocked, everything is blocked, I would like to resume my life. I am not happy, yet I lack nothing, except that freedom. I miss it all, despite the fact that I terribly hated it. I'm here, I'll print the score, I'll get up and my hands will start dancing again. Despite Covid, the psychological weakness, the inner malaise that, even if sometimes invisible, tears me apart.
-
Gennaio 2021. È un po 'di tempo che non suono, che sono ferma con lo studio saranno tre anni, ma questo poco importa. Nel bel mezzo di una pandemia ho ascoltato questo brano, un probabile pezzo da portare all’esame di conservatorio più in là. Sono bloccata, tutto è bloccato, vorrei riprendere la mia vita. Non sono felice, eppure non mi manca niente, tranne che quella libertà. Mi manca tutto, nonostante io l'abbia terribilmente odiato. Sono qui, stamperó lo spartito, mi rialzeró e riprenderanno le mie mani a danzare. Nonostante il Covid, la debolezza psicologica, il malessere interiore che, anche se talvolta invisibile, mi lacera.
You can do this! Schubert (from beyond the grave) and I believe in you ~
I like your writing you should write a book 😃
@@612curtis 🙏🏻🥺
@@katlarabi-tchalaia2264 wow! Thanks❤️
This impromptu reminds me the Liebestraume of Liszt Changing some notes Liszt thought he can fool us . Schubert at young age composed world class masterpieces Liszt knew very well who he was stealing
Friend, do not say that. Liszt’s pieces have their own beauty.
He also "stole" from Paganini. And like always made something absolutely untouched by anyone out of it
It's one of the hardest impromptus by Schubert.
Beautiful beautiful…learning this
Just sublime! Best version.
あまりにも美しい❗素晴らしすぎます🎶🎶❤️
wHAT joy! what perfection! thank you! ! !
Brendel version is the Best
Schubert might just be my favorite composer after Bach.
Esa pieza de piano es muy chula y es de schubert. Vaya temazo del siglo XIX
I think it's beautiful, but therein lies the old classical vs. romantic rendition. Either way works for me. I love Vlad's live version, but I love this too. The music is genius.
This melody is chasing me around
Don't thumb down this for god's sake !
I think god's got bigger things on his plate
I’d thumb it up if it were in F#M. Franz can go fuck himself. A hole. Only Bach is a bigger a hole for using C# M for Prelude and Fugue 3. Complete dick move.
Can't give it a thumbs up, not when there's so little expression going on all the way through :( Disappointing, boring, monochromatic, and generally too loud. Guess I'll be avoiding Brendel now. The piece is better than the pianist is giving it credit for.
Sooo beautiful!
This song reminds me of Christmas.
oh ~ Mr. Brendel will be happy for that piece of advice ... (pardon the pun)
Thank you Amour
Pour Schubert Hipipip, Hourra !
Only Mozart and Bach can be this wrist-slashingly sad in a major key. It is beyond loneliness: utter isolation.
Gattaca!!
Gorgeous
Trust Brendel - beautiful control & tone. To bring out the cantabile melody with all that undertow AND six flats ain’t easy!
Sounds a lot like Liebestraum no.3
Yes it was definitly a inspiration to Liszt!
Lindo demais !!!!!!!!!!
Beautiful. It seems (to my ears, at least) to anticipate some of Liszt's more lyrical pieces. Some of the harmonies and figurations here greatly resemble the middle sections of the Pensees des Morts and Die Zelle in Nonnenwerth. I see someone below has also pointed out the Liebestraum.
Exactly what I thought! But it still is very unique as an own piece I think
In my opinion, Schubert’s sublimity surpasses Liszt’s commonplace triviality.
Anyone in Melb Australia I will teach this to for free, it isn't very hard at all. As long as you can clutch a handful and put some love into it to bring out the melody. The themes are repetitive or tiny variations. Beautiful piece, people always respond well to it.
amo demais essa música
Refreshing performance, slower than normally but I like it a lot.
Reminds me of Chopin
I can play this. It's my favourite piece in my repertoire, alongside Schubert's Andantino from the D. 959 and Mozart's K. 397.
Is it hard to learn?
@@MDkid1 it's on the DipABRSM repertoire but it's probably one of the easiest pieces on there.
Great playing!I just uploaded this piece too:)!
Magical
Im 10 and I might play this for my diploma exam
I really love this song! 8D I have to play it for my ricital! It's wonderfull!
2:29
Gattaca !
@steppinout67 Hehe 8D It has to to with skills. You have to be on a surtain piano level to play this. It's ectually really easy to play. If you just know how to use your skills :)
Why isn't anyone talking about the TWO CUT TIME SIGNATURES?
I learned this piece years ago and never understood the double cut time signature. We didn't have internet like that years ago, but we do now! Time to look that up!
Maravilha !!!
What a nice description. I can hear in this how much Brendel loves Schubert but his playing does tend to have a rougher texture than the music needs.
Have you heard Kempff's interpretation? It's my favorite, slower and very subtle. It's available on YT.
Nevertheless, after Kempff, Brendel is my favorite interpreter of Schubert.
Fuzzy fidelity for important music
Just now noticed: there are many *repeating* notes
@3:07
This transition
Listening u here
Interessant, dass Manfred Mann den Anfang dieses Stücks "geklaut" und dann eine der tollsten, aber gleichzeitig unbekanntesten Balladen der Rockgeschichte mit einer unwahrscheinlich dichten und intensiven Atmosphäre gemacht hat: Das Lied heißt Questions und könnte auch manchem gefallen, der mit Rock nichts am Hut hat...
May I turn your attention toruclips.net/video/FfHlJU-vjE4/видео.html Thank you!
Schubert wrote this piece a friend who had insomnia. It worked. The dude was out cold by measure #567. Schubert also tried to write a longer version, but could never finish it, because HE kept falling asleep.
really?
Chauncy Cummings there aren’t even 567 measures.
When someone invites their crazy uncle to the comment section.
You tried to write a review here, but were unable because you had been born without ears.
😂😂😂
looks like an etude
Yup ! Keeping the inner voice soft with the strong thumb is difficult indeed.
+custardapple777 you mean strong little finger and ring finger...
Thats easy.
@@custardapple777jazz play with the wrist, not the thumb
ロマンチックですね。
Did Schubert used Liszt's Un Sospiro as inspiration or the other way around? Wait, Who died before who?
How does one count this exactly? Never seen this time signature before
Randy Kern it's weird because the melody and left hand seem to be counting in 8/4 but the other voices in the right hand have to be tripled because otherwise they don't fit the time
There are four half notes in a measure.
It’s in 4/2
Just count two slow beats per bar and fit all the smaller notes evenly in like a peaceful flowing ripple.
3:22 Vincent Reynouard :D
곰스크로가는기차에 나왔던곡
Tenho um album antigo com os impromptus de shubert e o nr 3 esta´em sol M com um sustenido em fa,mas outros não
1:25
Have you listened to Horowitz's rendition? He plays is slower.
Genuine question, why G flat?? Why not G or F?
It sounds nicer and the black notes fit the hand better.
Also, don't quote me on this but I think it has to do with well temperament (at least back when it was written). Perhaps another part of it has to do with where the 'singing' line sits naturally?
Can anyone who knows more than me confirm?
I do think the player could have done so much more with the music. It feels a bit static and uniform. Still a very good performance, great job.
das ist Schumann,net?
ludwig beethoveen Nein, Schubert.
How old are the people who are able to play this?
Anyone can play this piece if they practice.
This piece is not particularly difficult, at least technically.
Sres. en ingles,frances o portugues Schubert e's !!!.-
net net net
Brendel played everything as if it was Beethoven.
Beautifully played. However, lacks the ethereal dimension that you find in Horowitz and Rubinstein.
Better than any Chopin piece
Good one 💀 lol
****** я от тебя отпишусь , не буду наблюдать
3:10
1:31
1:15
1:20