CASTER SEMENYA FINALLY SPILLS THE BEANS
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 ноя 2023
- Behind the scenes at the 2009 Berlin World Championships: Semenya
I used a piece of music from Bensound.com which allows RUclipsrs to use their music for free in their videos: www.bensound.com/free-music-f..., this is the music I used: www.bensound.com/royalty-free...
Royalty Free Music: Bensound.com/royalty-free-music
License code: EZWJABODXMOHJXIF
Hearing her words totally changed my view of the situation. All I heard was the report of her being tested for gender, and assumed she was trying to cheat the system. Now I feel bad because she's truly an honest and genuine athlete. I wish her the best.
No, these tests came about because she was winning and they couldn’t stand it. They set about to destroy her
Being a man in a woman's body doesn't mean she isn't honest. She isn't trying to cheat, she was born that way. But she isn't a woman in the normal sense. Massively higher levels of testosterone than is normal in a woman leads to those performances.
Not her fault, but she should be banned from athletics.
You are wron. she is a he.
@@agnostic47people like you are so freaking weird, always worrying about other people private parts and telling them what they should identity with, whatever your definition is...creepy af.
Thank you for being so sincere.
The organization and individuals who leaked her medical examination results should have been sued. This is what caused her the most significant problems. Many athletes get tested, disqualified quietly, and never compete in athletics again. Their physical condition is not allowed to be disclosed to the public without their consent, as it's a highly personal matter beyond their control.
SHAME ON THE ORGANIZATION. IT IS CLEAR THAT THEY EMBARASS HER LEFT RIGHT AND CENTRE. HOPE CASTER FIND PEACE WITHIN.
I do not think Castor should have been allowed to compete in the women’s category. I also completely agree with you, none of this was Castors doing.
Castor is not a bad person but is disqualified from the women's events for logical reasons. Too much testosterone. If an athlete has that much "T" they don't fit that category for official sanctioned competitions for women.
Am I then wrong in coming to the conclusion that Western organisations and the people who run them still maintain a racial bias, especially against indigenous Africans❓
@@davidrosenthal5795She is a NATURAL woman, a genetic advantage. Using this logic, then why let Micheal Phelps compete ❓
Wrong to test her without informed consent. Wrong to test her without legal counsel or parents present. Wrong to publicize her medical information. Wrong to humiliate her in public. I hope she can still sue them with the government standing behind her.
NO! It was wrong to take all those medals away from deserving women! It's very unfortunate that this happened to her, but the bottom line is she should NEVER have been allowed to compete after the diagnosis because SHE IS A MAN!!! Just a slightly above average male runner who can break 2:00 in the 800. I ran the same times as she did when I was 18 and 19 years. The nearest girl would have been rounding the turn into the straight 100 meters away when the leading men were finishing. Once she was explained that she was misgendered at birth and that she must have her testicles removed so she doesn't get cancer, she decided to leave them in! Why? Because they were the reason she is built like a man. "Her" testicles request the testosterone from her brain! But she was told that if she has them removed, her career would be over... SO SHE SHE KEPT THEM IN AND COMPETED FOR YEARS!!! They left that part out. She is a cheater and the only people who should sue are those women who were denied their honor. Are you people brainwashed, stupid or what?!?!? SHE IS A MAN COMPETING AS A WOMAN, AND GIVEN A FREE PASS TO DO SO BECAUSE IT WAS NOT INITIALLY INTENTIONAL... UNTIL IT WAS ABSOLUTELY INTENTIONAL! Would you be saying this if you were one of the women who came in second at all those international championships? Reading all these stupid comments, I am loosing my faith in humanity. It's like her fucking feelings are more important than the truth or what's right. What about all those women she beat? What would you say if they were your daughters? "Oh, but she's so nice; she's so cool." Has the world lost i's mind!?!? This is sport, who cares how she identifies! For fucks sake! She's XY! PULL YOUR HEADS OUT OF YOUR ASS! She's a man!!!
I agree with everything you mentioned except using female pronouns where Caster Semenya is concerned. This is a biological male (XY chromosomes, undescended testes) whose development didn't follow the expected path. Not their fault. But society needs to create spaces for people with similar conditions so they can have a place to fit in and fully participate without being shamed or ridiculed. However, competing as a female is unfair to women.
You are very right my dear and I think that she should take them to court .
Before saying people are wrong we should ask ourselves a few questions. Let me give an example l am over sixty years of age and train very hard to run a 5000 metres veteran race. At the start line l see a guy who seems to be in his thirties. Obviously l would querry the situation . Fast forward to this situation you are a female and you see someone who looks masculine wouldn't you ask questions. Caster Semenya is definitely not a female end of story.
I agree with you. As we can see society is bias when it comes to pick and choose what they support. Look what's going on with the movement and people changing their sex to play in the sports with the opposite sex from them. The government sue the organization, or the person sue the government. This letter movement is so confusing. Caster's situation was treated unfairly. @@rosam674
This world is very cruel, God bless this lady🙏❤️😀
I met Caster at the world championships in 2022, she's one of the coolest, kindest, and most resilience women I've ever met.
Caster was not targeted. Having internal testicles, like a rooster, is why Caster was not allowed to continue to compete as a women. Wouldn't be fair to allow such individuals to compete with women with normal levels of testosterone which are naturally far lower.
@mxRian4, only he is not a she. He may be kind, cool, and resilient but kind, cool, and resilient does not make him a female. Besides which, the women who have competed with him can be said to be even more kind, cool and resilient because they have competed with a man and lost to him and he has gotten the accolades for being a remarkable ‘woman’ athlete. Such a travesty and such a horrendous lie. He is a man and all those times he won against women he did so because he had the advantages that come with being a man competing with women in a sport.
@@wuncieadams1352 It seems that you aren't clear about what a hermaphrodite is. The definition of a hermaphrodite says that the person has genetalia of both genders. Undescended testicles, but no penis. Breast development, no uterus. With no penis, she was called a girl on the birth certificate and was raised a girl. No one has a clue about how things are different inside their body until puberty, when the lack of period eventually triggers a visit to the gynecologist for testing. At that point, you think someone should be changed to "he"?
If Caster had not been an athlete, this diagnosis may have been revealed during efforts for Caster to try to get pregnant. And, it seems that there is a vagina as well. I say... it's none of our business -- this is extremely personal!
This is so unfair to her and other African athletes in similar situations, that's the way they were born, natural, not altered, yet transgenders are being allowed to compete against females,how can this be justified. Does this have to do with who they are and not what they are supposed to be??
I am curious to know if she commits a crime that needs sentencing which prison she would be expected to spend her time?
None of the African biological males who were competing as females competed this year. Without the testosterone being pumped out by their internal testes they aren’t competitive against even female athletes. Not a single one was at the World Championships.
It is certainly sad this genetic reality had to be exposed to the world. Caster has the unfair advantage of a genetic male, so can’t compete in female elite sports. Most males also can’t compete at elite female sports levels but if we let males in, top males would dominate all top positions over all females. Caster could compete in a male or open sports but would fall in rankings. Sad but necessary for fairness.
You would think her case would have been precedent setting!All other cases would have been decided with this in mind!Apparently not!All a male needs to do now is feel like a female ,regardless of his hormone levels,his muscle mass and obvious advantages not to mention his lac of shame,to compete against females!Shame! Time for a boycott!
@@aresmars2003u sound stupid
I think it’s disgusting that they put her under such scrutiny. She did not make herself and because she won many events they found a way to embarrass her and her family. That was unfair mental anguish!
Yes. But you also need to see the side of her fellow female competitors: it's just very rough for xx-chromosome women to compete against an xy-chromosome woman. Just think about this term "xy-chromosome woman" - I don't even know what to make of this.. Caster didn't do anything wrong. But if her case is controversial, how come xy-chromosome transgender hulks are shattering records across women sports nowadays? Can we please all agree that those cheating guys should be banned from women sports?!
It was not
@@Horizont. But Caster never broke the world record. The two drugged Eastern European women with faster times still have their records in the books. Where's the justice there?
The real question has always been is Castor an advantaged woman or a disadvantaged man.
What's "disgusting"?
Semenya is biologically more Male than Female and the only 'thing' missing from the body, is a 'penis'.
It is astonishing that Semenya and coaches et al, never thought it strange that there was no monthly menstruation!
The female athletes that competed against people like Semenya, Nyonsaba and Wambui, who were robbed of winning World and Olympic medals because of their participation, have a right to be angry and let down, by earlier PC BS.
Ms, Semenya, you truly have the choice of being the kind of person you want to be. Best wishes in any decision you make. God bless you.
I wish Caster the very best in life. I’m so sorry she was treated so badly. She deserves better. She was born the way she is. Nothing wrong with that. She should be given all the respect she deserves. She is a Champion ❤
No. Her situation was not handled properly. I feel so bad for her. Imagine how this has changed her world.😠
@velmathomas5000 Actually being allowed to keep the awards and medals is quite generous. An athlete's career is short so retirement was nigh and it was already time to say "Bye Bye!"
I still cannot believe that we witnessed such an inhumane attack on Caster. I remember when this first happened and I knew their agenda was to destroy her. I pray that she finds comfort and healing in knowing that she is loved by many of us. 😢❤
Beautifully said.
Not in inhumane at all. Not a normal woman and not admissible in events for women.
@@vernonfrance2974They treated Lia Thomas so sweetly. Very different approaches to one who was a cheat or sick in the head and one who had no idea.
My cousin was born with both male and female sexual organs. Although she looked female she always felt she was a male. In middle school her parents with a push from the Church decide to have the male genitalia surgically removed which was a huge mistake. As it turned out she was more he than she and grew to hate everything about her parents and the Church. Today she is retired Military and has nothing to do with her parents or the church. Her parents who are more informed on this condition regrets their decision blaming the Church. My cousin competed in all female sports in school but never felt she belonged.
Your cousin should be specific about the church leader who gave such bad advice not run away from the church as a whole. They acted out of ignorance and should have waited.
It's a shame that a woman who was born female is being disgraced by many who honor those who were born male and transition to female surgically. It's a warped twisted world we are living in...
Roosters and all male birds are born with internal testicles just like Caster but they aren't considered to be females either.
@@vernonfrance2974 Yes but a rooster has a male genitalia she doesn’t but many of the so-called trannys have both male genitals and tentacles and they are allowed to compete. Plus even if they did the surgery they still have male DNA. She was born with female genitalia and from birth she was identified as female. They should leave her alone.
FINALLY someone who is speaking sense❗It really feels racially motivated, because something similar happened to Mutolo (pronounciation could be incorrect), another indigenous African and a former coach of Caster.
@@vernonfrance2974Wait... Did you just compare a HUMAN BEING to animals❓ Wow, yah ne...
@@vernonfrance2974Males have penises. SHE doesn't! Case closed.
I always thought she was being treated unfairly,but I never knew it was this bad. Good luck to you, Caster. You deserved better.
Talk about PREJUDICE !
HORRIBLE. DESPICABLE.
TIME TO SUE SHOULD NEVER RUN OUT.
HER PARENTS SHOULD ALSO SUE.
EVERYONE WHO ASKED FOR AND AGREED TO THIS IS LIABLE.
I DON'T KNOW HOW OR WHY TRANSGENDERS ARE ALLOWED TO RUN AND SHE CAN'T .
😂😂😂😂 !!!!
.
She's absolutely fantastic. Peace and Love to her ❤
Leaking her medical info was such a violation of her privacy and caused her & her family such anguish. As an American, I think she should sue those responsible.
It’s a man. Get use to it
@@queenofallusa5391 so you didn't watch the video
@@tiffanyanderson9437sorry bro but that's a dude
I am no body to say anything about her. But, what I can do is to purchase her book, to support her. Thank you for bringing the spot light to her. Hopefully the people that watch this video and comment support her getting her book.
May god truly bless her and encourage her.
You are who you're n what God wants you to be. However you feel don't bash urself. Like everyone, u never created urself. Just know that we love u. Be happy for having such an impact ,not to South Africa 🇿🇦 alone but Africa 🌍 n the world 🌎 at large.
Her case was handled wrong. They treated Caster like skin human. Her situation is very sad
I am glad she speak up for herself, so people can have clear understanding of what went on with these unethical Organization in sports, she needs to sue them for for Ruin her career.
Keep on keeping on legend 👍🙏🏾🙏🏾
God made you Castor. Who is anyone to question him? You're beautiful African woman superior to women in the rest of the world, this is God's blessing to you. God and some of us love you; the rest of them God is not pleased with.
Very informative, but a real difficult awkward situation.
So is Ms Semenya exiled from competitive sports because she's classified differently? Her identity has been female and only changed because she was kicking everyone's ass in track and field. She's being targeted for no fault of her own. I'm sure there's some naturally occurring biological condition that differentiates the top athletes from mediocre athletes. Ms. Semenya's personal medical history is public against her will violating her individual rights. This is the way track & field officials cover their asses. All Tyger were required to do was to verify she was female, yes or no! Keep your head up Ms. Semenya.
And now her times aren't even faster than the current 800m champion. So it was really all for nothing, an attempt to keep black women from dominating a sport they already own.
We have no right to judge a person we don't know let alone Ms. Semenya ..God bless you girl ❤❤
bless you young lady....keep going
I feel for her for sure. However, someone close to her or a coach should have prepped her and her family for what was inevitable to come.
🎉 there was racism
If you are real woman you need no prepping
The asa tested him in 2009 but they tried covering it up so he could compete against the women now it’s all coming out and sanctions will be in their way against South Africa
@@peterhall6460 whatever that means smh
I have every sympathy for Caster but tell that to the women who were denied medals and unable to enjoy what should have been their special moment.
Yes l totally agree her case was miss juged she is truely a beautiful girl no question about it Bless her .
what they did to this woman was savagery. just couldnt stand the fact that she was kicking ass
With levels of testosterone far beyond accepted levels the fact that many perks and trophies were not taken away should have this person ecstatic for pulling a fast one.
Yes❗
@@vernonfrance2974 she had lower testosterone levels than world record holder and a much slower time. I find all of this laughable. No woman will ever break the 800m world record. The current world champion is faster than Semenya and she's still not close.
@@monica012077 I suspect that the World Record Holder, Jarmila KRATOCHVÍLOVÁ, set the record with the use of testosterone although the existence of high levels and the possible sources of it were not tested at that time so we will never know for sure.
We often see things as black and white, but when it comes to the sexuality of humans there are many shades of grey.
Yeah that's a dude sorry
Why haven’t they done this to the white European women that also looks and acts like men?
Some humans are below contempt. She was targeted because of her exceptionality that gave her an advantage.All the best to Caster Semenya!
@tyaajathailani I totally disagree. I don't think we should feel contempt for Caster just because the testosterone levels in the blood samples are in the male range rather than in the female range.
@@vernonfrance2974 I think you misunderstood me. I am on her side all the way.
That is absolutely not true. He was targeted because there were doubts about whether he was really a woman or just competing as one. Turns out he was and will ever be a man and should not be allowed to compete against women in competitive sports. He should compete with men like himself and endeavor to be a successful athlete.
@@wuncieadams1352 Exactly! Just because it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck does not mean it is a duck. Caster outwardly looked a lot like a woman but with internal testes is NOT a woman.
This individual is biologically "intersex" meaning that the gonads were male and NOT ovaries like a female. The testes are hidden inside the body in Caster, not hanging freely as with normal males. This is much the way it is in birds, reptiles and fish. Roosters are clearly male though you see nothing dangling below their tail.
In humans this is called DSD, Differences of Sexual Development. All DSD athletes have to do in order to compete again as a woman is to bring their blood levels of testosterone down to the normal range for females.
The World Athletics policies apply to women with 46, XY DSD-they have an X and Y chromosome in each cell (a typical male pattern) and male-range testosterone levels, as well as genitalia that is not typically male or female.
According to Children’s National Hospital, DSD is not as rare as most people assume and can affect about 1 in 100 newborns.
World Athletics has restricted women with DSD from competing on the track because, officials argue, that they have an unfair advantage in strength, muscle mass, and the increased testosterone levels improve oxygen-carrying capacity are required to have testosterone levels below 5 nmol/L. It is possible for women with DSD to lower their testosterone levels through medication, like birth control or injections, or through surgery to remove internal testes (which can produce testosterone)."
www.womensrunning.com/culture/dsd-athletes-meaning-and-world-athletics-rules/
Transsexuals also are banned from women's athletics on the international level, as they should be. For the reasons that males going through puberty develop stronger skeletal structures, greater muscle mass and strength and can carry oxygen throughout their bloodstreams better, it leaves them with some advantages even after their dangling testicles have been lopped off and makeshift vaginas surgically installed.
I'm so sorry she had to deal with this without the protection of a team ... they should have done a better job at this process. Shame.
I feel so bad for her; I always complain about how horribly she’s been treated. I’m very frustrated about Mboma, as well. This is disappointing.
This was against Caster's human rights and that's why the court of human rights found in her favour, and quite rightly so.
Knowing they WA and Coe would lose the human rights case with Castor the WA hurriedly changed the rules for March 2023 testosterone levels. They reduced the levels from 5ml cut off point to 2.5ml for 6 continual months. WA has dropped the ball, this allows Mboma to reduce her testosterone levels in time for next season and anytime now. This applies to Masilingi and any other mainly Africans who wish to try to reduce their testosterone levels. Their South African coach says reducing will make no difference as they are just both very fast and the latest Testosterone investigation doesn't support the previous findings.
The correct decision would have been to introduce a 3rd category for these intersex DSD athletes, running alongside females in female events, but separately awarded medals or positions. You have to wonder why they decide this way, is it because they know more than they are telling us.
Really they are changing the rules to protect female sport and unfortunately this is the correct decision. It has always been around just not detected before or so prevalent. Mary Decker had raised Testosterone, but to a less extent 1.25mls and she had children, so obviously 100% female. However there have been other intersex athletes before but undetected as just not fully known then.
So in summary yes female athletes should be protected 100%. Those outside this will have to reduce their Testosterone level to 2.5mls for a duration of 6 months then be able to compete in the female category for any track event from 100m to 10,000m.
The wiser choice would have been to introduce a 3rd category?
Note I am just reporting so everyone has full understanding and not speculation. I am not taking sides.
All the havevto dobis jus put all of those ppl in there race.. not with 100 percent females..bcz of there hi testosterone..and let she ran like the others
@@bernardm2528 Precisely your proposed solution has long been implemented in regional masters athletics in some regions. Instead of banning athletes from outside the region from participating in regional championships, the organizers arrange an open competition in which two categories of awards (eg regional athletes 1-2-3 and non-regional athletes 1-2-3) are based on whether the athlete is from inside or outside the region. All participants feel they have been treated fairly and have a great sporting experience.
@@siamkarlSeems the obvious solution eventually.
Not at all
These people have no right to treat a human being like a monster
It's very sad to what they did to you no one who will like to be treated the way you were treated what I like about you your the humble soul God to abundantly bless you 🙏
Absolutely disgusting the way they treated her
@@anewx her/him regardless , it’s disgusting how they treated a human being. You should look in the mirror
The hate and ridicule she faced was horrendous- her strength was incredible
They question Usain Bolt's performance .. and he became the most tested athlete ever. Not one time he tested positive for Amy, known human substance
He was born a male and all his chemistry and hormones ALL his life proved that, that's why he never tested positive.
"Clean" tests mean nothing; Lance Armstrong never tested positive and neither did Marion Jones who dominated the Sydney Olympics but confessed after the fact.
That's so disgusting and disrespectful. How are they gonna punish her like that. She was born that way. She's a gift from God. Now, you have ruined her track career and poisoned her life.
They will always find a way to destroy the BLACKS but Caster, I would like you to say NO to them because there are so many things out there you can do to remain shining like the STAR YOU Are.
Never let anyone reduce you and your capabilities.
You are a STAR ans world LOVE YOU.
She was treated appallingly by everyone. The IAAF especially were a disgrace. She had no support and the whole debacle was a real stain on athletics.
It really is very sad how she has been treated. Through no fault of her own. I guess the science has to catch up. This is very sad but also very true.
Catch up to what? You think it's fair to CIS females to run against someone whose biology gives them an advantage?
Law suite is the only open gate to give justice to the disgrace
She should have gone with a lawyer and her own gynecologist. All that nice, polite talk with that doctor did nothing to protect or shield her. Don't trust these people.
I remember a runner from UK who teared because Caster was part of the competitors. All these served to bring about the institutionalised discrimination .
semenya is a nice name
In My Opinion, nothing is her fault, the young lady did nothing wrong.. It's a very sad situation.. She has every right to be who she was Born...
She should be allowed to run. The trans genders are allowed so why not her?
The biggest conman 😂
Sounds like he’s male with one defect. His pediatrician should lose his license. How the heck did Caster get that big age and not know.
Sad, but not fair for other female athletes who are undoubtedly at a disadvantage.
Actually before there were several biological women athletes contesting that Caster is a man. i remember the 1 female athlete commented that Caster won the race because he is a MAN and it is not fair....
Person like tht has no place to compete. Not its fault, not anybody elses either.
They handled her case wrongly . Very sad to handle her like this.i hope someone speaks for semenya. The scars tattoeď on her will haunt her forever.
I hope the comes a time that Africa, especially gives up on Western civilization. So, we may learn to accept and love ourselves as we are, not as someone else's version of the truth. I truly hope that comes...
The case was not handled properly. Shame on those persons who leaked the info to the media and not afford her the courtesy of knowing what the results were before doing so.
No that was wicked they way they treated her
I plan to read her bio.
As a South African, I have NEVER supported Caster Semenya, who knowingly presented himself as a female with a testosterone issue, instead of as an xY male with an unfair advantage.
Caster has a child by his wife but has never admitted to being the genetic father of the child.
Semenya must stay out of Women's athletics.
Where are the real South African xx women in athletics? I will rather support them.
I am sorry for what you went through no one is to blame neither you nor the athletic body. In Swahili we say " kazi ya Mungu haikozolewi" meaning God's doing is never criticized.
This dose not age well for the media and the governing body of athletics most people have forgotten about this or have not seen it! Only a strong person would make it through that.
Wicked systems in this world.
Humans can be very cruel to fellow human beings. Everyone should have left the woman/girl alone.
Life can be so unfair
Not life, PEOPLE!!
Mean while in Europe "miss Portugal " its a male who will compete with womans at Miss Universe😂😂
I've always supported her. From the first time I saw her dominance. It just goes to show, the people that make the rules/laws, actually have no clue on real life. And no she has not been treated fairly, and no the case was not handled properly.
And why was she tested?
If Coe didnt stop her she would have broken the 800m WR by now!!
What you mean she? That's a dude
No she wouldn't lmao
Maybe but the current record holder had the advantage of being DSD and on steroids, she also had the disadvantage of almost never running the 800m. If she would have focused on it, she was a 400m specialist, should would have run much faster.
@@davidrosenthal5795 What is DSD?
@@imanal2543 Proof it!
Caster as a teenager was ridicule and discriminated mercilessly by the media. The young lady underwent personal examinations unaware of the propose and not in the presence of an Attorney.
Thanks for sharing your commenting on my post. I would be happy if you could subscribe to support my channel. Happy new year
Pain is caused by the parents ignorance, they should have had this child tested to find out whether boy, or girl, obviously he is a boy, not a girl that's why he was faster than the girls he was competing with.
I am going to buy her book. Poor girl. She was treated inhumanely.
She’s a wonderful specimen. It is tricky but bearing in mind all the trans gender shenanigans, she should definitely be allowed to run
he should run under mens category.
now they allow real men who had decided to be addressed as women to take part in women sport.
What a terrible ordeal for a young person to go through privately, let alone as a top athlete on the international stage. The reality is that sex and gender is not a black and white issue. Those who say it is are either ignoring or unable to understand the science of it. We must find a way to be fair to the athletes who are competing and the non-athletes as well. In my opinion, if it is biological like in Caster's case, she should have been able to compete. ALL top athletes are biologically gifted in some way. They have that advantage over the rest of us. If you don't have the genes that give you that superiority, no amount of hard work is going to overcome that.
Yes, we should ignore science.
but isn't Caster technically intersex?
The exception doesn't make the rule, and nature usually makes the exceptions sterile. Putting females in harms way for the sake "inclusion" is preposterous.
@davess61 that's what makes the case against her cruel. She was 18 dealing with an issue that is biological n WA just decided to outright embarass her instead of seeing how best to help her n future intersex athletes
No, male.@@davess61
I dont care what these doctors say you are who you are my girl love your self. What ever goes wrong during conception and development of embro you are here alive and strong, adopt a child if needs be. Been a mother not necessarily means you must give birth, its the process of being able to give unconditional love, care, devotion, spiritually, emotionally, physically and mentally to a child. How màny women who give birth can do that,give GOD thanks for life
All the Best to Caster Love to watch her run...❤❤ I hope she sues n wins what she deserves...had she been European that test shite would never happened to her.....But now with all they have done to her..they are now allowing men to run/participate in women's sports as transgender 😢..Much love Caster❤❤❤
I’m with you Semenya! I feel sorry for what you had to endure! You are a woman and that’s all it is to it!
DEFINITELY SHE WAS UNFAIRLY TREATED. TOO BAD. CASTER SEMENYA!!! TAKE IT TO HEART THAT GOD LOVES YOU SO MUCH REGARDLESS. LET HIM GUIDE YOU AND BLESS YOU IN ALL YOUR ENDEAVOURS.
Oh, get that lisping, tinkly backing music. Was it music to be sad by or sort of sad but not really?
A person's sex is determined by their chromosomes not their external genetalia or their upbringing. If you have XY Chromosomes you are biologically male, if you have XX chromosomes you are biologically female. And yes you can be biologically male with a vagina and testicles instead of ovaries, which is the case with Caster Semenya. This is very easy to explain and can be established with a simple blood test. This we see here is the damage caused when arrogance ànd ignorance, helped along in no small way by insensitive fools in the media, are allowed to hold sway. It's nothing short of appalling.
She actually brought this on herself, whats not mentioned here was she took the athletic commission to court because she stated she was being punished because of her high levels of testosterone and the drugs she was told to take to lower her testosterone made her not able to run like she use to she said she felt sick , slow and weak but uet her level were still well over 10.4 , she said it was unfair punishment that her , the court award her money but was appealed and in the appeal she she was asked about a doctors report from her earlier years , so to win her court case and to get the settlement tests were done on a chromosome basis and exam , she agreed to this knowing she did on the outside in the private area she had a female part ,and would be a done deal but the other test showed she was a 100% male . She knew she was a male on the inside for years , but at least she can still have a baby becuse her partner in life who she loves which is awesome is a female so he can donate his semen to her .
Can she compete in the mens category? You never know..she could excel there too...
It was the most cruel thing I’ve ever witnessed!
After all she wanted was to make family and country proud and labelling has become the biggest challenge in her life to overcome. It's horrible how they dealt with it
She also wanted to make a bunch of money. Which she did.
@@davidrosenthal5795 She also wrote a book for you to go and read
Go look at the South African Rugby team that won the world Cup.Its all about doing our country proud and having your people look up to you. For formerly underprivileged people to reach that far its all about showing your community's kids that's what you can achieve .Most of them.go give back to those communities
It is what it is. they can't compete because they have an advantage and that's it.
Trans genders compete 🤔
Nope!!! Her case was not handled fairly.
Per thumbnail. Spilled the beans or the balls?
She's intersex and that's nature.Obviously male features kicked in as she got older.
They were incredibly cruel to her. Why did they think it was ok to leak the news before she was even told herself? She was 18.
Think about how you'd feel if someone just determined, by a scientific analysis that you didn't understand, that you weren't the sex that you believed yourself to be. Put yourself in her shoes. Why all the cruel comments here as well. People get very threatened when they learn that sex and gender aren't always an easy binary.
I'm not a supporter of men transitioning to be a woman and then competing against women. Its not fair because the hormones they take are usually not enough to compensate for living with testosterone coursing through your veins for a decade while growing up. That's not what this is. I watched Caster run and yes, she looks more masculine than any other woman competing. But she's not a cheat. She was born that way. What's more is she may not even known. In this case, world athletics was wrong to ban her. She did nothing wrong.
What happened to Caster before Caster was born isn't Caster's fault! But Caster is a man, not a woman!
Wow sad 😭
She should su the athletic association
I Am Not In Agreement With That Level Of Public View, She Underwent Due To Her Level Of Length She Have On The Orher Amount Of Artifliets In World Class International Championship Meets. I Admired Her Level Of Humility And Cooperation She Had Given To The Officials And They Requierments. I Agree That They Was A Need For It, And She Actually Is An Female,And Should Be Allowed To Praticipate In All Future Worldclass Internatioan Meets Worldwide . All The Best To Her In Her Furture Endeavors.
That poor girl!
If she was losing to the Europeans runners nothing would've been said.
It was a hard pill for every one all the way around I was at that race in Berlin then I stop watching women 800 . unfair to her what they put her though all that some one should have stop it I would not want my child to go through what she did and do what was best for her After every race she win the other runners bend over and avoid making eye contact .It was also hard for them they felt cheated
The same whn they put mboma in the females race to beat the Jamaicans..but shellyann went to 🇰🇪 to compete with her & soon as shellyann out the block ..she jus blow the dragon fire & one hit to the ground & frm tha t day no more mboma..got not sleeping..
How unbelievably sad…
It was absolutely inappropriate and unkind to her she didn’t have to go through such yet there are real biological men imposed into women games it’s not acceptable I fully condemn the injustice.
what is a woman?
Who made these people God over people lives the heavenly created her in his own likeness These men are not God stop mess up people lives allow the to live their lives I wish her all the best go live your lives girl with God help stand firm 🙏 ❤️
She has a girlfriend right?????