Black Hole Bonanza: StarTalk Live! With Neil deGrasse Tyson, Janna Levin, & Jenny Greene
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 май 2024
- How did the largest black holes in the universe form? Neil deGrasse Tyson and comedian Chuck Nice come to you live to learn about the history of black holes, what’s inside them, and new discoveries with cosmologist Janna Levin and astrophysicist & supermassive black hole expert, Jenny Greene.
What is quantum foam? Learn about where relativity meets the quantum and Stephen Hawking’s bet against black holes. We explore the lifecycle of black holes and how they eventually evaporate. We discuss John Wheeler, John Michell, and the father(s) of black hole theory. How massive is a supermassive black hole?
How do we detect black holes since they do not emit light? Do all galaxies have black holes at their center? We talk accretion disks, event horizons, and the electromagnetic power of black holes. We learn about Jenny’s work with the James Webb Space Telescope and how it’s helping us see back in time. Plus, find out how scientists use a dark matter halo to see farther into the cosmos.
What is inside a black hole? We detail what exactly happens during spaghettification and what it would be like to fall into a black hole. What happens within the event horizon? Could the inside of a black hole be made up of quantum black holes? Are we inside a black hole ourselves? We explore time dilation, wormholes, and whether black holes can be created without supernovae. Plus, some cosmic perspectives on our current age of space exploration.
Thanks to our Patrons Leigh Momii, Molly Jebsen, Gilbert Cruz, Robert Colonel, Oliver Orofino, and Stephen Coleman for supporting us this week.
NOTE: StarTalk+ Patrons can watch or listen to this entire episode commercial-free.
Get the NEW Cosmic Queries book (5/5 ⭐s on Amazon!): amzn.to/3dYIEQF
Support us on Patreon: / startalkradio
FOLLOW or SUBSCRIBE to StarTalk:
Twitter: / startalkradio
Facebook: / startalk
Instagram: / startalk
About StarTalk:
Science meets pop culture on StarTalk! Astrophysicist & Hayden Planetarium director Neil deGrasse Tyson, his comic co-hosts, guest celebrities & scientists discuss astronomy, physics, and everything else about life in the universe. Keep Looking Up!
#StarTalk #neildegrassetyson
00:00 - Introduction: Black Holes Live!
02:55 - Black Hole Jets
04:00 - What is a Black Hole?
09:00 - Einstein, John Michell, & Relativity
15:45 - Why Didn’t Einstein Predict Black Holes?
22:15 - What’s Happening Around a Black Hole?
25:13 - Hawking’s Bet & The Death of Black Holes
29:52 - Where Did the Name “Black Hole” Come From?
31:07 - What Does “Supermassive” Mean?
35:13 - How Do We Detect Black Holes?
40:42 - Black Holes in the Center of Galaxies & The Messier Catalogue
44:00 - Scientific Collaboration
48:48 - James Webb Space Telescope Finding Baby Black Holes
51:30 - Pandora’s Cluster, Dark Matter, & Primordial Galaxies
1:00:00 - If You Fall Into A Black Hole Are You Lost?
1:04:20 - SPAGHETTIFICATION
1:09:35 - Other Black Hole Effects
1:11:58 - The Singularity & Quantum Wormholes
1:16:28 - Is the Universe a Black Hole?
1:20:53 - Are Wormholes Possible?
1:22:22 - Time Dilation Around Black Holes
1:25:51 - Closing Thoughts 
Наука
![Jason Aldean - Should've Been A Cowboy [Toby Keith Tribute] (Live from the 59th ACM Awards)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-B4nR-CgMVA/mqdefault.jpg)
Interested in learning more about black holes? Pick up Janna Levin's books here: www.amazon.com/Books-Janna-Levin/s?rh=n%3A283155%2Cp_27%3AJanna+Levin
I8uhczr ,
I8uhczr ,
A telescope as wide as the Earth is cool, Now after Artemis, we'll pave the way for a telescope as wide as the distance between the Earth and the Moon.
That'd be astonishing!
So he is a Fraudster
So he’s been giving out fake information all these years and lying to people?
Neil I gotta tell you. You have inspired me sooo much. I'm a high school drop out who hasn't been to school in 17 years. I got my GED. I just enrolled in college today. It's a long road ahead but I've never been this excited in my life! Thank you for making science fun for me! I will be an astronomer one day count on it!
UPDATE. Just aced my first final exam 97.5 !(8 week semesters) excited for this journey to really get started! Thank you to everyone for the positive encouragement
what the vaxx shill?
@@adgtesfgghee2143thanks for showing us all you have the maturity of a sixth grader
@@adgtesfgghee2143there’s no “x” in vaccine btw
You got it bro... All the best, keep it up.
awesome stuff. Keep being inspired and keep up the good work!
Can I just say how great it is that an astrophysicist, his colleagues, and a comedian are on stage and people flock to the event like it's a rock concert for the science of it all. Thank you, Dr. Tyson, guests, Lord Nice, and audience in attendance! You all are amazing!
yeah it’s all a show. neils one of the priests of their dogmatic religion. let us look past the corruption and listen and research all sides w an open and empathetic mind.
Chuck never ceases to amaze me. Not only he has to actively listen to the conversation but also has to come up with the jokes and occasionally translate advanced science concepts to a simpler english for us
😊😊
He's like a star 😉
@@Micheal313a black star, but he shines.
Chuck is the goat...❤
Though, what the way they were talking about it was simplified and non-advanved already.
You'd have to be very new to these topics to not understand it.
Chuck and Neil do an amazing job at humanizing the top researchers in a given field and bringing their research to us in a relatable package.
Neil gets really goofy when he gets around Chuck no matter how serious he tries to be 😂 They both have a good sense of humor and awesome chemistry
Very true...they seem like good friends. They play off eachother well. They also get blazed together 😂.
I just noticed.
Bless you for wearing a save Pluto shirt
On stage with Neil, pure love
I like to think of Pluto's demotion as being made king of all lesser planets.
If you understand what happened, you know just how bad most astronomers are. At the conference where they demoted Pluto, a committee with planetary scientists defined a planet as something large enough to have gravity making it round and small enough not to have fusion. Simple, clear, logical. At the end of the conference, after most people left, a bunch of astronomers ignored the planetary scientist and made a decision that, while dwarf stars are stars, dwarf planets aren't planets. Nonsensical and non-scientific.
@@davidt3956 dude I love Pluto, but it's demotion promoted Ceres
Who is Pluto?do they have a GoFundMe or something?
@@bansenpy5553
Another good one !
At my 76 years of life, even if I did not understood everything it helped me go beyond of what I knew before.
Thank you !
Neil and Chuck, what an amazing duo! I can never get enough of them!
This was hands down the best 1.5 hours of my life. I so want to go to one of these live shows. 🙌🏽
Me 2
This kind of thinking makes me proud of my species! MAGA, not so much!
Me 3
I'm not a physicist or scientist of any kind, just someone that gets bored easily. And these guys managed to keep me engaged for 1.5 hrs listening them talk about black holes, they are really good at making science truly fascinating.
You definitely have a mind for this. lol Sounds like intellectual conversations are difficult for you to come by. -- I can somewhat relate, if so.
You might be getting bored easily because your mind is not being challenged with subjects like in this video. If you're an intelligent person you will get bored of watching television shows or playing video games. The intelligent mind finds interest in the mysterious.
I love Janna Levin so much!
Jenny's excitement as she talks about the discovery of these amazing cosmic monsters,
Jenna's ever loving tone and the mind expanding cosmological explanations,
Chuck's refreshing and delightful inserts here and there (and how he's excited for science),
and Neil's kind of a romantic & passionate closing thoughts.....
I dreamt of becoming a cosmologist but couldn't do it because i am no smart enough but i do keep looking up and listening to these amazing people hoping and wishing that my 2 year old daughter will one day do what i couldn't and maybe even do something like this to inspire the next generations !!!
love star talk, love the universe ❤
Neil and Chuck both are designed to be on a stage. We need more live shows in an auditorium
I watch startalk every night before I go to sleep😊 love from India 🇮🇳
same!!
Some times me too bro
Nice
I have always been interested, actually fascinated, in this area of science but feel dumb. But listening to this shows bring me wonder and joy and fascination. I follow. I wish I can share this gift with my adult kids. We are made of the stars. We need to take care of this earth.
She was saying that we are not in a black hole but then seemed to describe how we could totally be in a black hole by saying you can’t escape going forward just like it’s time. That is how we live we are just going forward in time in my mind. So interesting love it!!!🤓
Neil and Chuck both are designed to be on a stage. We need more live shows in auditoriums.
Facts.
Chick should be less ‘funny‘... just notice Jenny already reacted to his constant interruptions.
Chuck should have 10% humour, 15% being humbled, appreciative, supportive, and thankful of having such privileged lessons. (As his 25% part of a 4 parts group.)
I think they are both overdoing it by far tho..
Anyone can make elementary jokes. Chuck needs an open mic where people are searching for awful comedy
Does anyone else ever click on one of these when you’re busy and think “Okay, I’ll just watch for a minute and see what’s up…” then an hour and a half or so later think “Ehh, my errands can wait” and watch three to four more videos? Every time 🤦🏻♂...but I love it.
Consistently wearing wet clothes to work for this very reason. Do not care to get to the dryer. Would rather learn 😂
I actually love playing these in the background WHILE I do chores or run errands. Makes doing boring stuff fun
I listen while I'm working. Get paid to laugh and learn. 😁
I listen to these while doing chores and running errands
The r😅ou😮pp 😂pop just u re daq A
Watching this discussion was better than watching a movie in a cinema ❤
I love chuck and Neil together man. It’s really great. Chucks comedic relief yet his clear understanding of what they’re speaking of and Neil for being this inquisitive genius that he is. Asking all the perfect questions, both of them.
They both play crucial roles in how successful this is.
Thank you for providing this to us all. We are fortunate in this day and age to have access to things like this because of the time and energy that you put into it.
A fool and his money are soon parted ^
@@xavierharding8938 indeed. you need a better mirror.
@@xavierharding8938 don't tell people how to spend *their* money
While I get the sentiment, They’re all rich already. Save your money.
@@Jay-ft3xhaaswwww
Even though it was a difficult feat for him, Neil really did his best not to interrupt the other speakers this time. That is commendable
I agree, it could have been worse
Maybe the worst one happens at 1:19:00. Like don't set someone up to say something then immediately them off when they begin to carry the conversation. Her expression says it all.
He needs to try harder...I watch these since they always ask interesting questions, but I can't ever get the full answer.
Guy is an egomaniac, but be kind
Nah, he was his usual, annoying, spotlight-grabbing self.
I could listen to this all day! Chuck should lay off the caffeine though lol. I didn’t understand a lot BUT, I did learn a great deal.
"a bunch of cameras taking the same picture" genius. BEST Star Talk ever!!
That is what has made me wonder if you actually could resolve what we left on the moon if you coordinated thousands of cameras to take images of the moon at the same time and create on huge data set to create an image from. In the past I used to do something similar with astrophotography where I'd take hundreds of low res images of planets or the moon and stack them with software and then use software to increase the resolution by doing math on the resulting stack of hundreds of images primarily to eliminate the distortion from the atmosphere. I think I calculated that a camera image built out of cameras in a ring 40 miles across might be able to do it.
One of the BEST StarTalk episodes EVER!! ❤
This man is an entertainer at heart that is why he has been able to garner so much attention. We need more scientists like him 🥰
So much of our path is determined by our teachers. In high school I had a chemistry teacher who told me I was just not capable of understanding science, for many years after I truly hated science…however I have recently been reading a lot on physics. I am an English teacher and I love my job, but who knows what would have happened if that teacher back then had more patience and passion and inspired me.
Amazing video. Due to my ADHD i never, i mean never watch long videos. The ladies here are as awesome as Niel and Chuck on every video. Well done to all.
That was one of my favorite episodes ever. The way Chuck freaks out when he makes the connections is so fun to watch but he also summarizes so well! So much fun!
I can not recall enjoying 1.5 hours of my life so much. It is one of the finest from StarTalk.
I'm glad to live in a era where girls are no longer put in the second row or kept in the shadow of mans. Janna and Jenny are amasing and I hope they can inspire young woman to go full geek.
These four need to come on stage once a month and chit chat. Love it! Need it!
These live events are great. It makes Neil way more likable and Chuck, funnier
I am so happy we are back to live shows with audience now, it feels so good to watch ❤
I must say....I learned so much from this guy. Not only that he knows the science...but the way he introduce science to us in a very good narrative is for every respect!!! And in combination with Chuck it is so funny and even more interesting and entertaining and this is exactly what science should be! When you see Neil you can see that little boy in him that dreams of a space...and you can recognize that child you were that shared the same dream! And I must say...thank you!!! Thank you for all of us!
Chuck really made this one for me. Neil does really well in explaining points for the Layman, but i find if Chuck understands something then explains it back to double check he got it right, i always follow that point along.
Chuck and Neil are the perfect educating pair, imo
That was one of the best episode of star talk
The two ladies shine like beautiful stars because they conduct themselves with the humility of scientists. Scientists are by far a higher stature than the showmen. I love Neil deGrass because of his intellectt and knowledge.
39:45 "There are many jokes l am not doing right now" -Chuck Nice😂😂😂😂
We need to keep John Mitchell’s name alive. The fact that a black man was the first to speak of the Black Hole is fascinating. So many Black stories were hidden and buried! We see you John Mitchell. ✊🏾🫶🏾
"Black of complexion" he wasn't black, he was white as snow and the fact that u though it means something just because he is black is racist.
@@retr0.1337 Do you even know the definition of racist??? You absolutely do not!
@@JuleneSings Point is he was white, yes ur racist for pretending that i don't have enough knowledge about country i don't even live in since surivailence is increasing and idc bout your You are not! 👆👇
@@JuleneSings point is he was white✊🏿👍🏿
@@JuleneSings Ooh then correct me :D white can be racist but black can't isn't reverse manipulation of blacks trying to use racism against white it self a notion of a racism? Lol please shut
StarTalk normally is fine, but StarTalk like this is amazing!
The world needs more of these conversations
Minus the world's worst comedian.
@@joeh9009 you've clearly never been to a comedy club for a spot show. There are hundreds of comics worse than Chuck.
@@kylecarter1599 Every comedy show i have been to is in the UK and every comedian was hilarious. It must be my British sense of humour that doesn't get his so called humour.
@joeh9009 Yeah, there's a major disconnect between US and UK comedy. I've never been able to figure out why.
Wow! Just incredible!! No other words! The guests are amazing, Neil’s ability to decipher and explain things is amazing, the way the astro community is working together is amazing!! I'm just blown out!! Why did we not learn even 0.1% of this in school!!! It would have made so many people go for astronomy!!
It's an ever growing field. Most of this wasn't known a few decades ago.
yes i believe i really might have then followed the passion I didn't know I had yet in astronomy....now my life is in shambles
Neil, thank you for continuing to forge the scientific community Carl Sagen birthed for us 🙏 you are a blessing to me and the world 🙏
I am from Majuli ,assam. The largest river island in the world. Star talk really inspire me . I am a Chemistry master student. When I open this channel my mind completly stresless .it Inspire my life . Thank you STAR TALK❤ I am a. Biggest fan of Neil de Grass Tyson.
Cool!
Way more educational than the last black hole bonanza I watched!
You must have missed the black hole cornucopia last Tuesday.
😂🤣
I both liked and missed Schrodinger's black hole bonanza.
😂😂
Comment matches your screen name
love the talk thank you
Chuck and Neil , greatest duo ever
Thanks for all you do Neil. You are truly amazing my brother!
Normally a star is stable because the its own gravity is balanced by force produced inside the star due to nuclear fusion. How are black holes stable then?
10:51 10:58 13:12 13:18
Wow! I was so reluctant to spend an hour and a half plus watching folks talking about black holes. This was definitely an educational, entertaining and enjoyable experience. Time well spent😉. Thank you to the entire panel and those behind the scenes 😊🙏💜...
Just simply amazing! Thank you all. Love how Chuck provides not only comic relief but explains and points out things for the non-astrophysicists. We need more of these discussions. I learned a few things. Amazing panel.
Damn, I love this man! And Chuck!
The Beatles was an accident in our lifetime, and so is this quartet of astrophysicist. Please keep the band together to give us more enlightening in our lifetime. I have no word to express my appreciation. As educator, I will cite Dr. Tyson's words: "engineers empower science". Thank you.
Science is amazing and Neil DeGrasse Tyson is awesome, I do enjoy learning about science!
Chuck will be in for repairs !!!
I'm with him! It's amazing !
Be Healed !!!
Good to see an in person event. Reminds me of the old days when Startalk was on National Geographic.
I love it when you do live shows in front of an audience. It's so much more fun.
Wish I could go to one of them
to meet Neil is on my bucket list.....he is amazing!
I like startalk always educating in a fun way
Wow! Science and comedy together is the recipe for the most entertainment moments in life
I never leave comments on RUclips, but, eversince I've started listening to you and following you on Insta, Meta, MasterClass, etc, I've just become a dedicated fan of your breathe of knowledge and presentation style. I think your advocacy for the pursuit of knowledge and curiosity is inspirational to this generation of thinkers and non-thinkers, like Carl Sagan was for his generation. And, having a hilarious co-commentator like Chuck is like the cherry on top. Keep up the great work.
Man ! Neil's closing remarks are him at his best. Thanks for being you bro!!
startalk is the very best channel on youtube!
NDT making science fun and entertaining! Thank you
Chuck is everything! Cuz I myself feel the energy he’s exerting in the midst of comprehending all this information! I understand the professionals don’t feel like that cuz it’s a normal Tuesday but this is what education is missing! The excitement and jokes to retain the information 🫶🏽 Neil is the educator we all wish we had since day one! This information was never given like this and i appreciate the delivery of from star talk!l
Or maybe you was just sleep during class. Could be the case no?🤔
He just need to improve his timing. Sometimes he makes a unecessary joke in the middle of a important explanation and it distract you. It just like in the class when people can't stop talking behind you while the teacher is explaining.
@@MarquiseKendrid Or maybe you was just sleep during class. Could be the case no?
Really? That Is the format you are going to use the English language, to disparage someone?
@@Luiz-jv8luliterally this dude. Most god awful timing
Lmao I just love Chuck’s enthusiasm. I share the same excitement. Like how can somebody not LOVE the combination of science and comedy? Like you feel good, AND you’re learning. Fantastic.
It is a pleasure witnessing Neill deGrasse Tyson joining the "universes in the center of black holes" camp more seriously. Speculative science needs these types of camps in which losing is as beneficial as winning and maybe we may never know the exact answer.
Fun, Educative, Comic, and above all KNOWLEDGE gained!!!. Chuck and Neil are the best duo💯❤
Loving the professors Tshirt trolling Neil. PLUTO never forget 1930-2006. 😂 Fascinating show. Inspirational women of science.
She's a legend for that t shirt! 😅
Cute ending 😅. Watching this made me realise I need some more science friends. I love hearing people talk about science, even though I wouldn't say I'm a science guy. Its just really interesting and always gets my mind moving and questioning.
Easily among the top 3 best media I ever watched my entire life.
It really changed my perspective.
gotta say, after watching this, I bought the survival guide. Who knows, it might come in handy :D
Also, love the little jab by Jenny wearing the never forget Pluto shirt. Always good to nudge the host of the show once in a while :)
I just listened to your podcast of two years ago with Malcolm Gladwell and Chuck Nice. Three towering, brilliant minds in the bodies of regular doods with a sense of humor that had me rolling on the floor. MORE of that, please!
Love Star Talk. This was one of the best episodes I've seen. As always, looking forward to seeing more.
Fun watch 😊... Good thing they've discussed the new discoveries found by janes webb.
Love this so far. Janna explains great, and she's so inspiring ✨️
Isn't she?!! Her husband is also inspiring, an amazing singer/musician/songwriter as is their son Gibson.
Janna's awesome and gotta say I love Jenny's shirt: a eulogy for Pluto the planet.😊
This talk was great, can't wait for more. Love Chuck! You can tell he is honestly curious about these subjects just by how he sits and watches the other speakers. And I friggin love that.
My point here is that so much of what is on television & radio is often overblown or just plain false - this is such a breath of fresh air.
As much as I love how well NDT and chuck nice work together, the rate at which they'd cut off their guests just seconds into trying to answer a complex question wasn't just rude but beyond unprofessional as members of the science community
Alright, that was outstanding ❤
What a great event! This shows completely new approach on how to talk about science and educate people in a digestible way. You kept attention for more than an hour and half and I still feel that I am ready for more :-) I wish I was there on live but so far away, I hope you will visit Poland in Europe some time. It would be great! All the best to you all!
Forever StarTalk !!! Loved the show , extremely enlightening, plus Ms Levin is always a joy to watch and admire.👽🛸
If we are indeed in a black hole, I'm glad and honored to share my space - time with you four. 🤗
24:00 "We see nothing and know everything" had me rolling. 😂😂😂 Top tier educational long form content, thanks to everyone involved
Beautiful and insightful. I thought I knew all I wanted to know about black holes, but that thing about it being a bunch of quantum wormholes or the small black holes in the early universe made me want to hear so much more!
More live startalks please, it is absolutely dope. Cheers from Brazil!!
At the end there i caught some 1:31:07 "Carl Sagan Pal Blue Dot Vibes" I know the previous generation like Carl is looking down from the cosmos so very proud of that little boy he met all those years ago excited to learn science has grown into such a fine man. Meeting Carl was destiny for Neil. Moments like this one remind us all of that fact so fondly.
The Show was and is Amazing!!!
Thanks all 4!!!
such a great talk
i feel like i am actually learning stuff by watching start talk as i am starting to have a deeper understanding on how much we don't know
Don't we just ❤ when an Astrophysicist gives such a deep Laugh to our 'Man on the Street,' Chuck??!!
Mr. Nice lets us see that an actual geniuses like the Neil deGrasse Tyson is truly human (and curious)
Such a great panel, thank you!! The women were awesome, the comedian enjoyable, Neil rocked the role of facilitator and all in all, totally engaging. I can't get enough of this stuff and always appreciate it being put in layperson's terms. Thank you!!
Can we all agree, Chuck is such a great addition to the panel.
More. We need more of this sort of thing. This is engaging even if you are new to Science. Excellent!
This was amazing!!! Thank you all so very much❤❤❤
This StarTalk has a rating of five Chuck's. How many times Chuck's mind was blown! Lol a beautiful blend on stage great job guys and girls SCIENCE! 👏👏👏🤩🖖🏽♾️
Makes me think what if our universe is on the other side of a black hole through a wormhole
I concur
Chuck's genuine excitement when he gets it. He literally speaks for most of us 😅
Lofl I always wait for him to break it down and explain it for simpler people to understand too 🤣
Kind of. Sorry to burst your bubble, it's not quite genuine.
He's been doing StarTalk with Neil and guests for years, and he now knows much more than he let's on, for the comedic value. He's a great comedian, and a great actor playing the part of "the audience" learning about the cool stuff.
If you watch or hear him over the years, they sometimes revisit repeat subjects, and sometimes he feigns ignorance to help drive "natural" explanations into the conversation, reminding us or helping newcomers to these topics get up to speed, and he does it brilliantly while integrating his comedy into it, and that's why most of the community loves him. Either that, or Ms. Mary Jane is > genuinely < making him forget about the stuff between shows. I strongly believe the first rather than the latter.
@@Zlist1994
Degrass follow myth, not science fact !
@@KynosMusic fair point - I had the impression he was smarter than he shows the audience, however, take away the genuine his reactions still speak for me 🙈
Great talk, fantastic panel. Well done, extremely entertaining and informative!
If from watching back of ypur phone, youll see light pass from the dark side of it based on ones perspective. Good job! Tysm
A worth video to watch, period!
Cant get enough of this. Hard to understand sometimes but. Getting there:)