Open Captions VS Closed Captions ❤ Jessica Marie Flores ❤
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 мар 2018
- Support My RUclips Content:
www.paypal.me/limemoney
www.bonfire.com/store/jessica...
Instagram/Twitter: @LimeMoney
Facebook: / jessicafloreslimemoney
Website: www.JessicaMarieFlores.com
Thanks for watching! :)
❤ Jessica Marie Flores ❤
Help us caption & translate this video!
amara.org/v/fZ95/
I turn on cc enough myself as a hearing person because I couldn't understand something that was said that I don't even get why other hearing people would be annoyed about it. ALL IT DOES IS HELP!
Me to !
I agree! I always turn them on because I think it is great for spelling, when you miss something, or if I'm learning a language.
I'm a hearing person and I get annoyed by it simply because the text draws my attention; either I'm reading captions I don't need to which takes my eyes off the visuals of what's going on, or I'm constantly resisting looking down at the thing that my brain insists I should read which is very distracting. Also it can obstruct part of the image.
However, I never complain when someone needs the captions; my annoyance is not worth another person not being able to hear/read what's actually going on.
Thank you, Jessica, for reaffirming my choice to open caption all my films in class. A few of my professors are trying to discourage me from doing it because it’s not considered “the industry standard”. Open captions for everyone!
As a hearing person, I have CC on almost all the time when I’m watching Netflix, Amazon Prime, or Hulu. I don’t find them annoying or distracting at all, in fact it helps me to understand the show a lot better than if I had them off.
Elizabeth Daniel SAME!! My whole family is like this now too!! Or if a bunch of people want to talk loud, mom & i can still watch out show on low, with captions on, we are obsessed! You pick up on SO MUCH MORE!
Sorry for the question. Are You English Native speaker? If so, Why would you need captions?
@@toma1610 For me, at least, CC help to understand what's being said better. If it's a loud, action scene sometimes a word isn't clear, or if the script uses "their/they're" a lot. Other times if someone is whispering it can be hard to hear if there is any noise around myself, or when a character does an action off screen but it isn't clear WHICH character.
There's a lot of places where confusion can arise and just having confirmation of what is happening prevents a lot of rewinding. They also don't get in the way as they are small and can easily be not-focused on.
@@toma1610 I'm a native English speaker and I actually caption for a living: I personally really like using captioning because sometimes I can get easily distracted and captions help me understand what's happening if I missed a word.
That 1 dislike is from someone whose confused.
I am obsessed with captions! I use them for clarity constantly, and have turned other familiy members onto captions too (we're hearing but have close deaf friends) , I cannot BELIEVE the amount of TYPOS! It's like you just wanna scream at the caption writers ... "YOU HAD ONE JOB, LITERALLY!"😡 I definitely wish there were captions at the Movies!!📽 I'm with ya girl, we are with you! We fully support you!🤘❤
The local news is the worst. At least half the content is dropped with some stories literally being skipped entirely as the captionist tries to keep up. It's unprofessional and frustrating as all heck.
Sometimes it's nice to have captions on, even as a hearing person, I might not be paying attention to what was said in a movie and captions help with that.
"i thought captions were just captions" ok same😂 the freakout is giving me life, so relatable! love this video, keep your content up, you're awesome!
Aly Drayton you're just as awesome ❤️❤️❤️
Love your content and humor!
I actually didn't know about open vs closed captions thanks for the exploration! everything is so true about the closed caption at the theaters though. it's "so fun" when it happens!
I definitely prefer open captions to closed captions. The lag on cc is horrible especially on tv. And if the commercial doesn't have cc you are stuck looking at the last few words of the previously cc program on the tv.
Totally know the differnece now! Open captions ARE awesome! Thanks for making this video!
My biggest caption pet peeve (mostly cc on youtube videos) is when the captioner describes the persons actions -_- i can clearly see that the youtuber is "shook" marilyn, thank you.
A J yea but then you miss the fun ones like in this video. (“Ugly sobbing”) 🤣
Sobbing is technically a sound, though, so it technically makes sense to caption. I think A J was probably talking about "shook" in the same sense that some people caption something like "[youtuber stares blankly and blinks a few times haha lol shook]"
(or "OMG IS THAT PEARL?!" (...I wish someone would just finally approve my six-month-old edit to that video's captions already, because I'm so bothered about that one DX))
Exactly!! Yeah the helpful descriptions of how the person sounds are great. But when the editor puts their own opinions in like (OMG DID THEY JUST) or (THEY MENTIONED MY OTP) or describing someone's facial expression because they think they're improving the content when it wasn't theirs to improve
PREACH SISTER!!!!
I was looking up captioning etiquette when I found this video; you are such a freakin' wonderful soul! You had me nodding seriously, then laughing really hard, then nodding seriously, then laughing, haha. Thank you for making this and for making my day!
Love your videos. Always make me smile and feel less alone in a hearing world. Makes me feel inspired in life and for my channel so for that, I love you and thank you xx
❤Hahaha ur cute jessica...thanks for sharing about CC for deaf/HOH I really appreciate it Jessica love u girly....oxociez❤
I’m hearing and I love close captions (and open captions but I can’t figure out where to find them and I just learned about them from this video) for some reason it’s really nice to sometimes just read what a person is staying. Especially if they said it weirdly or too fast or you want to know how to spell it.
Of course OC over CC every time!!!! Ding-ding!!! Love your video. Keep it up! Btw, would love to meet up and chat. You seem to be fun to hang with. 😄
Your funny Jessica great video I would to hear both of your hearing aids feed back.
I have ADHD pretty bad, and captions used to be something I hated bc I thought they distracted me from the movie, but now I turn them on for pretty much everything! It helps me remember the dialogue so much better when I can read and listen to it at the same time, plus it makes me less prone to getting distracted bc my brain is having to multi-task. It also has the benefit of helping you to understand what's being said in a noisy environment! The only times I don't use them is when a family member gets really annoyed by them, if they aren't synced properly (which is more distracting), or if they block too much of the screen (I will die on my hill of begging for all captions to be adjustable). Captions are NOT just for deaf/HoH people!
Heh, on top of the worse captiview problems, my mom also complains about the fact they take away her cup holder.
(But she likes them over the assistive listening headphones she was using before she realized the theater was keeping the captioning device secret from her, because they often had interference/static problems and at one point even managed to play audio from the wrong movie, despite theoretically being tuned to the right frequency.)
Thanks for
Sharing that info!
As someone with worsening hearing loss who is just starting to need captions, this was very informative - thank you! Also, your wall behind you is EVERYTHING.
Loved this video. Great job.
I freakin' love you. Just discovered your channel and you inspire me a lot. Thanks for all 😁😁
Thank you for taking the time to make this video. I just started doing open captioning on all my videos. I read books. Thank you for explaining the difference.
Really enjoyed your video! You have great energy and explained the differences between CC and OC very clearly. Thanks for sharing!
I like watching your content because I learn more about Deaf and hard of hearing people than I usually learned in my ASL classes. Had a lot of fun learning can't wait for the next video.
The theater I go to has closed caption glasses. I mean, it's better than the other device you showed in the video, but it also sometimes skips lines. I definitely prefer open captions as well.
We don't get open captions here in Canada, just the Dolby CraptiView, system which has me just about ready to give up on going to movie theaters altogether.
Your line at the 2:05 mark - I just about pissed myself laughing, thanks!
My friend signed me up for August 2020's GISH, and I was told that the videos need to be open caption. I was, like, "Uh, what's the difference?" Thank you for explaining it so clearly and entertainingly. And, for the benefit of my viewers on my various channels, I will learn how to and start using open captioning. ACCESSIBILITY, MOTHER[censored]S!
This is a fantastic video! Thanks for explaining in really simple terms
I love how you present info 😂 So I just created a new channel where I talk about True Crime Stores and I've been trying to decide whether to work with closed or open captions. After spending countless hours jumping from video to video, what you have created here just solved my problem in the most fun way possible. Thanks, plenty!
I'm proceeding with the open caption!
I’m hearing and I’m totally down for open captions in theaters
Open Captions, I didn't know it had that name. Great video, Jessica.
I had such a hard time watching Black Panther! I had the caption machine positioned and was doing fine, but then they used open captions on the screen when the characters were speaking another language, but they didn't display that on the caption machine, so I had to keep leaning around the machine read the open captions and then back to read the closed captions. I tried to move the box down but it wouldn't go any lower without falling out of the cup holder. The machines at my local theater are so much better than they used to be, but gosh that was a tough movie to follow. I don't understand why so many hearing people get so upset about captions. It seems like such a small "inconvenience" to allow access for so many people.
Wow, that's awful. You'd think they'd put all the captions on the caption machine.
I hand type closed captions so they're actually accurate-
And always have them as an option, mostly because open captions doesn't work for my videos. But I love open captions and if they're an option, I use them, cause as a hearing person, because I will process my visual ques faster than my audio, so I'll process reading words rather than hearing them.
I am hearing impaired and I told my daughter they have CC devices at the theater. (we were planning on seeing Joker) She flipped her sh*t when I asked the theater about their CC devices. I guess she thought I was lying...😒 By the way - Joker was very good!
I don't always like captions on my movies and shows. Sometimes it's really frustrating to see what people are saying before they're saying it. Obviously this could be fixed by them synching up the captions better.
But frankly, if there can be two showings with and without 3D, can we not provide most showings with open captions and some without?
I'm mostly hearing. I have some problems understanding speech and also some hearing problems in the lower pitches. A lot of my dad's family, including him, are HoH or deaf. I love captions. He has only recently started liking them.
You're very funny and make sense at the same time. 🤘
Serious topic, but a very funny video. Thank you!
Subtitling a movie can't be that difficult. English language movies are subtitled into other languages for foreign language audiences all the time. Years ago, when I was stationed in Iceland I watched all kinds of American movies subtitled in Icelandic. Regular, on the screen for everyone to read, subtitles. So it can be done, just isn't.
Jessica, great video! I watch a lot of foreign films & shows. So much so that, I keep my captions on. Noticed that all the Chinese films I've seen have Chinese characters/captains. Add the English subtitles result in a lot on the screen but I quickly got use to it. If they can add these to help the HOH & deaf community, why can't we (Americans)?
So, I have a totally serious question. Why don't you use open captions on your videos all the time?
Growing up Fahmi that is a good question! I thought about doing that! I do have open captions on my Facebook book videos because I know the FB captions aren't reliable. On RUclips the CC always shows up so far, unless they haven't been working for anyone let me know!
Thanks for answering! That makes total sense. I love your videos. My daughter (13) & brother are both HOH and my daughter has been thinking about making a few videos of her own about her HOH experiences.
Growing up Fahmi she should one day! I always encourage others to share their stories. We need more Deaf/Hard of Hearing content! :)
This just might be the funniest RUclips video I’ve ever watched! 😂 And i learned what I needed to learn FTW
This girl is deaf? Her English is actually really good considering she’s deaf. Great work, Jessica
This is such a great video!! Im a person with ADD and a lot of the time because of my cognition: visual stim is easier for me to process and most of the time my brain cant focus on audio in a way that allows me to absorb things fully. I LOVE captions. My netflix has permanent captions. Plus ive seen it a lot on RUclips videos where captions add this really hilarious depth to the video!! Make content accessible!!! Woooo!!
I have ADD/ADHD too. Sometimes captions help, sometimes they interfere. Particularly during heavy action scenes, I don't like them. I would like to have a choice to not have them, but I'm ok with having to, say go to a specific time, to avoid it in those situations.
Captions in general have come a looong way over the last 10-15 years. I remember watching the news and all the retractions and corrections constantly spewing on the screen. Awful! It's bad enough not hear at all, but to get your brain to follow along with all the corrections...shoot me now please! Unfortunately when it comes to theatres most smaller towns do not offer devices, but in my experience the glasses provided the best experience. The still have a little ways to go but accommodations are getting better in general.
Awesome personality, I enjoy the video you make. :)
I LOVE YOUR ENERGY. I'm currently writing captions for my short film and didn't know how difficult it is for hearing a person struggle through. Despite it being new and hard for me to think and describe each scene. But now when I watched your video I think it's worth the effort.
I love how you add signing to your words, it is super fun to watch as I am learning sign language myself😁 Love this channel🤟🏼
I'm here from Dog Vlog. You are pretty and funny.
thanks!! I'm hard of hearing and never understood the difference until now!
Nice tutorial hehehe that's big help
This video is great! I used the caption device a few years ago and was so embarrassed. 😭 I’m going to see a movie this weekend and the theater I’m going to has open captions. Excited to try it for the first time!
Those things are the WORST! I would prefer OC over any captions any time in theaters, but my second choice would be the glasses. Yes, they're bulky and irritating, but for some reason, they seem to work better than the CaptiView devices, and they block way less of the screen (re: none of it).
Rogan Shannon they have caption glasses? That’s definitely something I have to look out for.
Yeah! All Regal theaters carry them, they're created by Sony and called Sony Entertainment Access Glasses.
Cool thank you. I had too look them up because I didn’t even know I had a regal theater in my town. I’m looking forward to trying it out and seeing if it works for me. 🤩
then oh how do we love the marks on our faces we get from the glasses right?😂
They're so gorgeous! 😂
sub'd. sent from Drew Lynch's channel!
Your so awesome
Pay your pal ..NIce..love the video
I think you could expand your content way beyond how or deaf content and could hit a huge audiance you have a real good personality
Yes!! I plan to do that! Working on some stuff in September! :D
Hey Jessica! Recently in Mexico a law was passed so that all cinemas use open captions (This is in favor of people who have hearing problems).
Honestly, it seems somewhat strange to me since most of the movies the subtitles do not match the audio which is somewhat uncomfortable.
What he didn't know was the other side of the coin. I have always believed that technology solves many problems and from my opinion closed captions were better.
But watching your videos I can realize that it is not like that and that there is still much to do. I hope the technology improves so that everyone can enjoy the movies.
you are funny. im going to open cation my videos now
Do they have (and if they don’t why not?) movie theaters that provide times with open captions on the screen? I feel like at busy theaters there’s at least a third of the population if not more that would want open caption viewing times. I know pretty much nothing about the subject but would it be that hard for movie viewing equality and just sticking the captions on the screen for everyone? Or like 3D glasses but instead they pick up the open captions on the screen
Finally, the difference between the open and the closed ones???
Well, I'm deaf and I use an apparatus to listen, but unfortunately I can't understand anything in the movie without subtitles/captions, because there's so many reasons, but the principal one is that in the movie they speak so freaking fast or that there's some scenes that there's no actors speaking directly, a very common example is when one actor is in the middle of call... but whatever... I live in Mexico and in the movie theater's in Mexico when the movie are foreigner they always show the "open captions" to understand which I'm very grateful, but... soon I'm moving to Canada and I figured that it doesn't exists movie theaters with "open captions" which it make me feel sad and disappointed because I like a lot to watch movies... so this means that I need to wait months of months to be released online or just in popcorn4time to watch it... in my home with TV small screen... which it baffles me because we're in 2019 and they doesn't offer a movie with "open captions" even the movies are in English... it doesn't MATTEEERRRR !!!! Maybe we're a minority of deaf people but we have all the rights to watch a movie and to enjoy it... not to just been waiting since the release date in the movie theaters to watch online... so yeah... this sucks a lot and it's sad...
Open or closed, it is good. Acting is outclass
Curious your opinion on open captions in the tiktok-esque way where the eords appear as they say the individual words rather than a while sentence
Everyone: talks about captions
Me: *wait she’s deaf?*
I just checked my vids , you can click on the cc button. But we are mainly talking automatic cc captions..I will so it now in all future videos. 👍😊
My family is all hearing but we have closed captions turned on all the time. My "favorite" is when the dialogue is in another language and the closed captions say "Speaking in another language." or when the captions are completely different from the spoken dialogue. 🤦
Crazy cat lady. :P
Oddly, for somebody who prefers open captions, this video hardly has any of them.
I didn't know there was more than one type of captioning. Thank you for explaining that. Sometimes the spelling of some words in cc is wrong. Like death for deaf.. very annoying.
YESSS!!! It happens to me all the time!!
After watching this videos- I got confused and I am not able to recognise Closed Caption and Open captions
Can you do a video about cochlear implant
Yes! Stay tuned for that video! I will be a few months before I make one but I will be making one for sure! Anything you would like to see me cover about implants in the video?
Yeh if you would advised deaf people to get them
Thank you for this video. I was just curious looking this up. I live in Sweden. Since 2014 all movies have to have subtitles even movies in our language and especially for children movies. The only problem is that the SUB follows the original language and not the dub which can be confusing but oh well. So no stupid devices that need batteries, mulfunction or make houndreds of small problems and I am sure sadly the staff dose´t get taught how they work and just on that day the one girl who knows how it works is on vaccation so. Just have subtitles on the screen. I may not like the "dramatic music" only have the speak sub. Sure I wish you could chosse when you order a ticket to fill in. "Do you requier captions?"
But then we will have people troll others or in the theatre people wishing it won´t have captions and when they see it make a big deal out of it an yell. "WHO THE F WANTED CAPTIONS!"
So I have to say include subs, they are not that distracting, can say as someone growing up with sub for ALL movies, becuse they are in a diffrent language not becuse of having hearing problem.
Why the terms "open" and "closed"?
Who came up with the stupid naming convention: OPEN sounds like editable, CLOSED sounds like baked in. It's the other way around.... PFFF.
BTW where are your open captions?
Aren't captions just subtitles?
Are you ok ?
It seems like the Deaf community needs to create their own theaters and re-invent the movie experience. Use whatever caption system works best, and any employee that neglects the captions or other adaptive technology with not just be fired, but contractually required to commit seppiku to atone for their failure!
0:13 ummmm you okay or am I going to have to call 911?
call 922 its faster lol
M
oh fuck
come on
I wish you come visit Miami so we could do the challenge or interview..
still confused
Gabrielle D. I can explain more if you'd like 😊
that would be helpful, Jessica. I understand what closed captions are and how they work. Open captions seem like the same thing as closed captions.
By the way, I love watching your videos you make me laugh so much and I enjoy your videos. this probably should have been my first comment. I am hearing person currently taking ASL and I love it.
Gabrielle D. Cool! Glad you like the videos! :) So open captions are when the words are already on the movie/film. So you know when movies show subtitles on the screen for when someone is speaking a different language?
Most of time when films are in English and then someone suddenly speaks a different language they include subtitles for that on the screen. When the film is made, those words are are already stuck on the film and you don't need to press an on/off button to see or get rid of the words. The words (subtitles) are officially part of the movie.
Hope this helps a bit! There is a captioning website called AI media and they show the difference between the two if you want to search more about them! Take care!
Yes, I do. I think I understand. So open captions are when the words are already on the screen but closed captions have to manually added on the screen? Is that correct? Are open captions always different colors?
JFX, loose the screaming and the drama!
Why do you talk weird no hate
I have a deaf accent that comes with trying to learn how to talk when you can't really hear your own voice.
thanks, but you are irritating, I know, I know you are trying to be cool, funny and interesting but sorry it is contrary to it. Be simple next time will you?