Kashmiri Pandits Exodus - Retired IPS Officer Reveals The Reality
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 июл 2023
- Watch The Full Episode Here: • Kashmir Police’s Unfil...
Follow (Retd) IPS SM Sahai's Social Media Handles:-
Instagram - / sahai.shiv
Facebook - / shiv.sahai
Twitter - / shivsahai
✅ Subscribe To Our Other RUclips Channels:-
BeerBiceps (English Channel):
/ beerbicepsofficial
Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
/ ranveerallahbadia
TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
/ @theranveershowhindi
BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
/ @bestoftrs
Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
/ @bestoftrshindi
RAAAZ. :
/ @raaazofficial
RAAAZ Shorts :
/ @raaazshorts
BigBrain Plus :
/ @bigbrain_plus
Link to our blog: beerbiceps.com/
In this episode, we have a very special guest; Shri SM Sahai IPS (Retd). He is a Retd IPS Officer 1987 batch of the J&K AGMUT cadre. He has also served as an Additional Secretary of, the Internal Affairs Division in the National Security Council Secretariat under the Prime Minister’s Office (2016-2023).
SM Sahai IPS (Retd) shared his experience and knowledge that he gained throughout his professional life. He dwelled upon topics like the truth about The Kashmir Files and the unrealistic portrayal of facts, the key difference between a terrorist and an insurgent, Article 370, and the present-day scenario of Kashmir.
It was an enlightening conversation with an amazing person. This would be a very knowledgeable episode for those who wish to learn more about India and the Police Force. I hope you enjoy this, feel free to share your opinions in the comments!
#smsahai #kashmir
--
INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
/ beerbicepsguy
LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
t.me/beerbicepsguy
SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
----------------------------------------------
About :
TRS Clips is a collection of SHORT CLIPS from The Ranveer Show podcast. Enjoy our latest knowledge-fueled videos from the BeerBiceps team. Every conversation on #TheRanveerShow is intellectual, deep & progressive. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes.
Today, The Ranveer Show or TRS - Happiness Through Curiosity. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.
![Darren Waller - Who Knew (Her Perspective) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GytDjB8u6bM/mqdefault.jpg)
I am a Kashmiri Pandit and I endorse the Kashmir Files as being 100% true...
Google jammu massacres them and muslim exodus of Kashmiri Muslim in 1987
I feel your Pain 😢😢😢
Please be careful
And please protect your family at any cost brother !
I didn't do anything for you but I pray for all Hindus for their safe & happy life.
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@kingandrew6436 aur support kro Pakistan ko
@@SushantKumar-kx7lu haha lol 😂 google how many Kashmiri Muslims(non combatants or civilians) killed by your security forces and then also Google K PANDITS killed . 1 lakh:400 ppl only. Get a life. We know these fake narratives
Infact we have faced 100times more than what was shown in the movie same goes for the hindus in kishtwar,badarwah,padar in2002when militancy was at its peak in these jammu divisions as they wanted to eradicate hindus from these areas
Not acknowledging genocide is a disservice to the victims.
Governments create genocide, why would they care about the victims?
As a Kashmiri Pandit let me make it clear the Kashmiri Pandits he is referring to, those who didn't like the movie belong to a particular section who have links to NC, PDP, JKLF and communist groups. I even know some of them in person who were paid to say so. And to what this man is saying that numbers were very less, a statement often quoted by leftist and liberals ...let me tell you there have been so many killings in villages that went unnoticed. Do you people believe that police would have covered all the cases keeping in consideration all chaos and mayhem. Till date the SC has failed to deliver the justice rather it has delayed the justice which eventually made them to say that it's too old to be heard. Not even a single perpetrator has been punished till date.
To answer this ignorant uncle, we have seen what all happened on streets. How Justice Neelkanth Ganjoo was gunned down in broad daylight and no one even dared to touch his body, how Tikalal Taploo's forehead was carved out (near brakuti, where we apply Tilak)...in order to send a message that they are attacking our identity, how BN Ganjoo was gunned down in a rice drum and his wife was made to eat his blood soaked rice and that too his location was revealed by his muslim neighbour, how Sarla tickoo was abducted by a group of Kashmiri Muslims (2 were here colleagues) who gangraped and sodomized her and later did cut her body using a saw, how Prana Ganjoo was gangraped and her breasts were cut and later her body was thrown on road. There are countless incidents....these Muslims used to get on roads in thousands and shout slogans like 'asy banawaw Pakistan bataw warey batnyan saan' (we will make Pakistan without pandits but with there wives), yaha kya chalega nizame Mustafa , kashmir mein rehna hoga to Allah o Akbar kehna hoga. Muslims used to barge into Kashmir pandit areas at night and shout slangs and pass remarks like, we will rape your daughter, she will sit on my lap and mark their gates. Just imagine the level of trauma and pain. And this man has the audacity to belittle our genocide.
🙏🙏🙏
Brother, may I ask you something who is responsible for this? Was it the failure of government or socity? And which government if it’s a government. I am so confused about it. I am from Haryana and i have no words
@Singhhhhh737 which government was there in 7th century ?
Very true🥺
The government was really really weak back then, now if they try this Modi will kick there ass.
I think Modi needs to take advice from Xi Jinping on how to reeducate the muslim population in India.
Every time it comes to Pandits this guy says "it's a sad story, But... "
He can't feel it. Actually most can't
Uska those koi mara jo usko Farak padega......jin Terrorists ki baar kar rahe hai wo bhi Musalmaan hi the 😅😅😂😂
He is spreading propoganda
The movie didn't villify entire Muslims of kashmir. It showed that not only terrorists from Pakistan killed people it was ALSO A COMMON NEIGHBOR who aided them. The movie clearly showed cops who were Muslims as being helpless and wanting help them... The movie did not villify the kashmiri police.
The Muslim police didn't help either . In the beginning of the film only it is shown. Maybe they were forced to do so.
@@karm4962
Don't forgot that Hari Singh Army joined Pakistan army
A snake 🐍 climbed the tree and eaten birds kid and destroy her nest 🪹 . Now while climbing down he fell from tree to thorn bushes on ground and got badly injured .
AT THIS MOMENT this gentleman came and saw injured SNAKE 🐍 . His empathy awaked for injured snake 🐍 . BUT NO TEAR FOR BIRD whose kid and nest was destroyed by the SAME 🐍
This describe him best
Time to unsubscribe
Wow well said that’s amazing very true it’s so hard to trust some of Ranveer podcast sorry
Prefect example exist
Government affiliates are known for mixing truth with fiction. Be ware.
True well said. By inviting such prejudice man he is trying to become liberal and secular and to be in good books of his celebrity cum social media peers. Survival ki baat he bhaiya Muslim subscribers bhi badhane he bhaiya. Sab paise kaa khel he Babu bhaiya paise kaa....
Exactly! A good example to show how people sympathise with Kashmiri Muslims. If you do evil, evil destroys you too. That’s what is happening to Kashmiri Muslims.
Sir this movie is not about the death of the people happening either hindu or muslim its about the exodus which happenend only with the kashmiri pandits. Leaving your home& everything for the miserable life is not easy. People now a days going back are fully excepted by the locals but again are still getting targeted.
They are still in the fear of terrorism not the locals.
Yeah right 😏
I think you don't remember the politics that played around it
If only they would understand. I am disappointed with how this country treats our community. They are always being biased towards the ones who did it. The movie clearly doesn't villify Kashmiri Muslims but it is infact the truth that most of them, if not all of them aided the terrorists and did infact, forced us to leave the valley. And even after all that, solid evidence to support our people did lose their lives, we did migrate, genocide did happen, it's still a surprise to see all these people trying to paint an entirely different narratives in which the ones who did the bad deeds get to be called the victims and the ones who actually are the victims are apparently faking it, or just aren't victims in their eyes. The debate should be about whether our people will move to Kashmir one day or even get justice ,but instead it's about trying to whitewash the ones who did it or completely ignoring the suffering Kashmiri Pandits went through.
@dok no it's the fault of Kashmiri Muslim they are blood brothers by only name in reality they are just Mohammad followers now
Now do u have guts to call few kashmiri pandits on ur podcast and say kashmir files isnt accurate ?
Te khud ka kiya
💯 correct 💯
Many Kashmiri Pandits themselves had denounced the movie. The movie, just like many opportunistic politicians over the years, uses the pain of Kashmiri Pandits for their own benefit without any actual efforts to transform their plight.
@@JJ-hp6mb point is not whether KPs have denounced or appreciated. Point is , is the movie factual or not. By calling it false, is rubbing salt on their wounds. And creating false propaganda , which ranveer shd NOT have done.
My friend and kashmiri pandit whose father served with mine in kashmir as a part of the rashtriya rifles calls the movie a lie.
Won't be surprised if he says Kashmir is occupied by India
I’m a Kashmiri it is occupied by india illegally
@@Pajeetkiller.2789madarsa chap
@@Pajeetkiller.2789nice try my guy
That guy- ok! Pandits faced it but Muslims faced it more. Ex- i saw one guy and other 70% (based on that ) faced it too... 😂
Matlab jabardasti Muslim prem dikhana ha
Still I didn't get which part was wrong?? All the incidents that were shown has been based true incidents. Their names are present as well as their articles in local newspapers are also present. All the characters potrayed negatively are present in reality and have given those speeches. No where did it mention that all Muslims have done it. Infact i remember a scene where a muslim family helps and he and his son are killed. Even in the speech sufferings of the Muslims were told. And it's a fact that from there masjids such announcements were made like leave your women back. So what exactly was wrong part. And 70% Muslims would have helped a lot then such thing wouldn't have happened in the first place but they didn't which is a fact so what can a director show??
Correct 💯
It's typical face saving excuse that since Muslims also died therefore Muslims can't be blamed. Just like Pakistani Government says that we are also victims of Terrorism. Question is who's killing the Muslims in Pakistan?? Who killed those Muslims in Kashmir?? Who were threatening the Hindu Pandits to leave the Valley without your Women?? Who were the people who raped and Murdered Girija Tikoo and Sarla Bhat??
I totally agree with your point.
Sorry, I do not agree to the officers narrative that Kashmir Files vilified all muslims. The truth was shown in the movie. Ranveer should have asked his opinion on the movie Mulk which shows Kashmir Files done to muslims.
People who were victims have said their story
So you just need to be human to support that
You can't force your propaganda
request u not to bring such guest to talk on the GENOCIDE OF KASHMIRI PANDITS ... just being a IPS is not enough .....
This is how people react when reality doesn't feed their confirmation bias. 😂
Just watching a movie isn't enough the person was tgere broo
Spot on .. this person has zero credibility and wisdom to talk about j&k. Imagine how he would have handled law and order with such misguided thinking .. this is why Kashmir suffered ..
This guy thought of Jurisdiction at the time he heard the blast, wow, it shows the level of commitment to his people. I am glad he is retired and ashamed that he even served our country's people.
Please continue to bring such fake IPS officers on your show to bring out their true colours in front of our nation.
Also I'm pretty sure that he has served to the fullest to our beloved Congress 😊
Exactly, that's what I was wondering and thinking while watching this.
maybe he cleared UPSC under reserved quota and only studies just enough history to pass the exam....cant believe he served our nation as an IPS
It was people like him who couldn't understand kashmiri muslim psyche and it took forces five years to understand the situation when it was too late.
Jk police was back in action after 95 when ethnic cleansing was complete and they had to fight for kashmir which was only theirs
Now bring the victims whos stories were told let him say to them what they went through was "fake".
This officer should be a precious possession of The Wire and Aljazeera...🤣🤣😂😂...hilarious..
kashmir files movie actually down played the violence
Its a shame mr ranveer to even upload such a video
Make money at any cost even at the cost of Kashmiri Pandit Genocide
@@shaktimunshi3596 true😪
Very disappointed
Vilification of Kashmiri Muslims is unjust, I agree on that but the exodus, rape, killing & torture of the Kashmiri Pundits was solely religious in nature. Sermons were used to incite & instigate mobs to attack Hindus which can not be denied. Neighbors became informers to the mobs who carried out the genocide. Kashmir Files if anything did not show the full extent of what happened to Kashmiri Pundits, it was much more horrific & shocking.
In every community there are some monstrous people filled with greed and these monstrous people mislead the whole community.And don't pretend your previous generations didn't do anything wrong with Kashmiri Muslims during the Dogra Dynasty.If you don't have the guts to criticize and condemn the wrong doings of yours community then you don't got any right to criticize and condemn the wrong doings of others.
Thank you
@@mrsheikh56Yes, we can because Hindus aren't responsible for what happened to them.
Boss the 90 percent muslim community of Kashmir wanted to join Pakistan...this shows how he did his duty at that time in "Balanced Way"
No not true..
What Bullshit is he speaking! Just quotes one incident of terrorists killing a person from the other community, who is supposed to be a govt servant and white washed a genocide that led millions to leave their homes. Genocide of pundits is more to do with the Civil society who used to be the neighbours of pundits. They were the one's who resorted to Voilence led by separatists groups. Even IAF officers were killed by these terrorists because they see those working in the govt irrespective if their religion, as those supporting Indian state. That is not the issue here. Who were the perpetrators and who were involved in the genocide of pundits. Not a handful of terrorists. Definitely not!
Reported this video for misinformation and for denying a genocide.
I am kashmiri pandit leaving India soon... Most of Kashmiri pandits have left India.. To developed countries which respect our education and talent.. As Acharya Chanakaya said, " leave that country which does not give you justice and dignified life "... Thanks.. Take care.. We leaving is India's loss.. Not only ours
Please comeback 😢we the people of Karnataka have respect for Kashmiri pandits the strongest and smartest of people are kashmiri pandits ❤
Reporting for misinformation and propaganda.
This is not the first time , extremely disappointed.
Administration & the silent majority of the society had greater responsibility to prevail over the minor groups of violent aggressors feeded by the external forces involved in ethnic cleansing.
"Villification of muslims" bro hindus didn't got up took arms chanted "ralib galib chalib" and did genocide of kashmiri pandits. Stop defending their action. Saying we shouldn't call on the kashmiri muslims bcs some of them are in police like WTF why shouldn't we call on those who did the genocide just cuz some members of their community are also in police. F logic.
Shame on both the people in the video
He cannot be everywhere, he may not be aware of the otherside that was shown in the movie
As a kashmiri pandit i totally support whatever has been shown in kashmir files infact i would say it was very less they should have shown it completely. Whatever he is saying is BS.
His whole point is kashmiri pandits should compromise or otherwise they won't be able to resettle. This is such a stupid premise. These are our ips officer on whom we depend to defend us. We could have protected localities then you should have done that now he is all talk. Kashmiri muslim died well we pandits didn't kill them they used to pass on information from police directly to terrorist when they lost their usability or acted as double agent they were killed. Kashmiri muslim used to send their children to training camps in pok. About kashmiri pandits who oppose this movie they do it either there property is stuck there or they just want to live in kashmir even if that means giving up your religion . Such people are selfish and cowards
I don’t know why people always try to shy away from reality and they always try to be politically correct.
This has been the scenario since ages.
Even Ranveer is trying to be politically correct …
What is meant by politically correct, can you please explain?
Ur filled with propaganda, ur unable to accept reality which real officers tell😂
Same thing happened to Sindhis and Punjabis during partition. Uprooted overnight. Agree then also there might be many who didn't support it but they just watched in silence rather than taking action. One who watches a wrong happening and doesn't do anything about it equally responsible. As a Sindhi I have made my life hear in India but that doesn't corrects the wrongs that happened.
Lo ek aur Vikas Divyakirti ka bichra hua bhai.......ab samajh aaya UPSC Jihad
Mr. Allahabadia, We really appreciate your efforts and passion towards learning and making people aware about the adversities that we Kashmiri Pandits had to face but DO NOT bring such coward, self consumed and unreliable people to speak or enlightened others on our story. If you're genuinely curious try to connect with people on ground level or the actual survivors. As a proud Kashmiri Pandit woman I just can't stand any random guy portraying whole picture in whatever way tht serves their purpose. If doing all tht is too much for you thn don't make content on such topics where you clearly know that majority of traffic will be from a particular community. Don't cause more pain by constantly touching those wounds if you don't hold the potential or intention to heal it.
Mahra kyuk chukh
Well said, beta ji
It may be true that some muslims in the security forces too would have lost their lives while on duty, for the terrorists do not discriminate among whom they consider their enemies. The name of Abdul Hameed, a param veer chakra awardee in the 1965 Indo-pak war, always remains in memory.The sacrifice of these muslims while discharging their duties is as noble as anybody elses', yet they do not in any way mitigate the gravity and horror of islamic barbarism ever since their invasions began in the middle ages, right through to the present period in kashmir. The main target of the terrorists have always been the Hindus, while the muslims in security forces lost their lives only because they came in the way of the terrorists, though as stated before now, their sacrifice in the call of duty is no less noble. The Kashmir files strove to depict the diabolical nature of the terrorists' acts of violence against the Hindus as accurately as is cinematically possible. It is not correct to charge the makers of Kashmir Files with false depiction, for not exonerating the muslims by not specifically including those muslims in the security forces who laid down their lives. The movie was about Kashmiri Pandiths, not about security forces.
Kashmir files was accurate but he isn't..
Bureaucracy at its worst. When you'll die MR. IPS, you'll have to justify these few mins of interview in the hell.
Reported for misinformation!!!
Kashmir pandits killed for being hindu. But they bombed the police man for working for govt of India. Both r same?
He has not seen the movie, he described the plot of Shikara. He is just parroting the criticism seen online.
But what happened with Kashmiri pandits can’t be denied, and pandits were told to convert to islam and there is one question also why only Hinduism targeted.
While the movie was on pandits...those man spoke 90% of the time about Muslims..
Disliking the video only cuz ranveer did not interrupt and ask tough questions or cross question...I guess that's the diff in a youtuber and good journalist
Does it matter if it was just a minority of Ms? The fact is, WHENEVER and WHEREVER Ms are a majority, this dangerous minority always pops up. Century after century. Is it ethical to sentence future generations to this conflict as well? As soon as someone professes faith in reducing God to One and humanity into Two - they have already betrayed what is ethical and righteous for a unified humanity. No matter how peaceful they are, they have sown the seeds for future conflict.
Now pls invite Vivek agnihotri ji and persecuted pandits ..
He is trying to say that kasmiripandit not killed
But muslim killed
He is blabbering 😡😡
He is saying truth as he served in Kashmir for many years
For sure this IPS officer didn't move out of his office to prevent the blasts.
He was there to spend his tenure.
He calls KF was unrealistic.
Non sense
Looking at this clip makes me realise:
people with vast on-ground real life experience can still end up with half baked perspectives of a situation. We sometimes expect too much from career policeman, bureaucrats etc. They aren’t always perfect thinkers/analysts.
And no, I do not think ‘the Kashmir files’ vilified the entire Muslim community. It just told a particular story, a story where, for a Kashmiri pandit, the moderate/peaceful Kashmiri Muslim had become largely irrelevant. That does not mean that the film by omission, vilified all Muslims. An implication of this sort can be made by a viewer (which would be erroneous). That’s not the fault of the movie.
And no, to focus on ‘mistakes’ of the Jagmohan administration are just ways to deflect attention from the perpetrators and conspirators. What can a governor do when an entire region’s administration has been overrun by armed terrorists and their sympathisers and there is zero political will at the centre to take significant wholesome steps for KP security. At least he facilitated an escape and saved lives of many KPs.
@@rishankkaul Very sensible comment!
I think he is part of peaceful community
Ranveer you need to invite Dr. Ajay Churungoo. I think this problem needs a deeper analysis than what is being said here.
Your but.. Destroyed the sadness of what happened to Kashmiri Pandit... You are comparing death of 2-3 Muslims to whole kashmiri pandit genocide.. Really? You have the 16 minute story for them but you are speaking ifs and buts for Kashmiri pandits? Not acceptable. And in the movie they have not shown each and every muslims as a bad person do not spread unnecessary lies
This retired ips officer is graduated from JNU 😂 and did internship in The quint and the Wire
"Wow" talk about not excepting
Sir, saying that a police office was a Muslim and that is why Kashmiri Pandits and the torture they faced is not accurate. Sorry to say, you are just being biased. Yes, Muslims were killed and those killed were considered as moderate Muslims and they were killed because they were not in agreement to wht the terrorist were doing to the Hindus.....i.e ethnic cleansing.
You are talkin from a POV of a Gov servant who was posted there.....had it been your family or ancestral place.....I am sure you would have seen this in a different light.
Not understanding which part of Kashmir Files is wrong.everything shown has a proof... This guy is deliberately trying to take other side... Ranveer, request you to not call such guests on your show who are not telling the facts. Now, do invite Vivek Agnihotri and all the Kashmiri Pandits and ask the same que to them. People at such level using your podcast to create their own propaganda... Not accepted
Why don't you speak about Mulk, mission kashmir and all the films which were actually propaganda films, no he wont say anything about that which were fiction but here is one film which showed the truth and he has to criticize and say it was not accurate, what a joke, bloody pseudo secular.. hindu ko koi kuch bolde chalega koi defend karne nahi aaega but muslim ko koi kuch bolde aur woh sach bhi ho toh aajenge defend karne
So if most of them did not want it to happen - why did they not come out in support in large numbers against the minority who wanted the Pandits out?
People should read the book My Frozen Turbulences in Kashmir and Our moon has blood clots. They will come to know what used to happen during 80s and 90s in Kashmir with Kashmiri Pandits and anybody with the tag Indian.
We kashmiri pandits can definitely say the movie is totally real.
He being from the police is difficult for him to acknowledge. Kashmiri muslims majority was either involved or had sympathy for terrorist.
Telling barkhadutt story he is completely left side
What else do expect from the guy name “raneveer ALLAHbadia”…Ranveer You lost my all respect here
People who are criticizing him,
He is making it clear that as shown in movie kashmiri files,that's not true, in real kashmiri muslims themselves were victims of terrorism.
He is not talking about pandits.he is talking about propaganda against kashmiri muslims depicted in movie
Hm. This movie, along with international terrorism, has made me super angry on every muslim
In quora, i have read and heard many things related to this well planne genocide, one among all was 73 terrorists getting released days before this happened, which is 19th january
Mulla's feeling bad for pandits is different. But the reality is none of the so called non kaafirs came to save them
And pandits being kaafir hindu's never took revenge. That's the main problem
*Is this person gone case? 🙄*
No of kashmiri pandits who died was less as said by the guest but what was their fault. they were not asking for azadi or pakistan. secondly even senior officers in the govt commented to kashmiri pandits that 26-jan-1990 , pakistani flag will be flown in kashmir. thats why genocide of kashmiri pandits took place and aftermath the mass migration took place. if they would have stayed in kashmir, they would have been killed in large numbers.
Not relatable ❌ Time waste, had to stop in half.
I want to honour this conversation by saying Idiotic stuff.
If u want to do podcast on kashmiri pandit ...bring them not any third person ...they will tell u the truth...here u both are playing 50 50 games
MOdern day television did not tell the truth about the Kashmiri Hindu Pandits. Why ? Did not K-Files tell that part of the story. It is a long process to tell the Whole truth. Did not Vishal Bharadwaj's movie Haider tell only 1 side of the story? So, As many sides there is to J&K situation, those many stories need to be made in Movies, podcasts etc.
But to start that the K-Files is INCORRECT is blatantly wrong way to start the podcast. Again only partially truth cannot be rubbished away by saying that the K-Hindus did not face what was depicted in K-Files. So PLease do not make these kind of incorrect statements. - The Movie never said that the K-Muslims did not face the brunt of the terrorism in Kashmir. The movie is correct. Agree with it.
Has very smartly saved Farooq Abdullah and blamed it all on Jagmohan.
Hats off to this man. Not many people dare to speak the truth👍
Kashmir files is a very clear depiction of what happened with usm IPS Sahai did not serve downtown or else he too would have been liquidated. Muslims too suffered, but they were made part of conspiracy by Farooq, Rajiv & ISI.
this is what happens when you passed UPSC with reserved quota
He is a pro khangresi,and Ranbir is trying to impress left
Ranveer please stop this balancing act just to gain the wider scope of attention. Already we hindus are not united due to caste system and all which consequently makes lesser no. of ppl believing in our narrative. This divisions in our hindu society has cost us a lot in terms of not having stable govt at centre bcoz muslims dont vote for bjp anyway. Now after 75 yrs we are trying to catch up the rest of the world in development, we need very majority govt at centre. So by making such utterly nonsensical podcast plzzzzz dont ruin our belated efforts.
Call a kashmir pandit a victim ? Who has suffered
Never called a Kashmiri Pandit to discuss the film but somehow a police officer serving the state which itself has done a disservice to Kashmiri Pandits when he himself was a part of the service is the best person to give a perspective on the conflict. How can the host choose to be this ignorant.
Tyranny of the minority? What nonsense. Say that about the Jews and you will have Mossad knocking your door down.
The people in the J&K Police are Muslim because of the region's overwhelmingly huge Muslim population, it is not a marker of patriotism or commitment to the Indian cause.
The number of Pandits killed is small because you are not recording how many Pandits have died for the past seven hundred years or so.
Sure not every Kashmiri Muslim is a terrorist as a Kashmiri Pandit I agree, but there's just radio silence when you ask them to surrender their uncles,fathers and now even grandfathers who were very complicit in the killing.
I am a Kashmiri Pandit born after 1990, even if I wanted to go back, I cannot. However never for a minute is it correct to assume I am distant from my culture. My forefathers have continued their traditions, I continue to practice them even today even if they make no sense in my geography, and so will my progeny. They kill us, the state buries us and that is a reality we accept, we just leave it up to our fellow countrymen and countrywomen to either join us or leave us, however we cannot be stopped. We were part of the Cabinet once, we will be in the PMO too.
Very good
Now let the IPS guy answer who were the ones responsible for the exodus & deaths in Kashmir?
1 guy from muslims killed by muslims=painful
1000s hindus killed by Muslims= sab hi to mare gaye the
Nice
Both are pretenders here
As for the dreadful Kashmir problem kindly ask the Gandhi family/ Congress for answers .
This is one of your worst podcast. Because the people who has suffered it knows it well. Giving speech is always easier than facing such horrible situation. Please do not promote such misinformation just to increase your viewers.😒
No body accepts reality
the highlight of the podcast is "THE STATE FAILED". Exactly what is going on in Manipur right now. I am not blaming any of the communities here, but nobody can deny that the state doesn't pay any heed to the problems when it is prevailing at present. I am 100% sure five years or ten years down the line a beautiful decent budget Bollywood movie will be made named 'MANIPUR FILES", where people will watch the movie, one section will blame the kukis, other section will blame the Meiteis...but none will say now that why didn't Modi or Shah bother to visit the state even once. Where is the national media who cried so much on the ISRAEL-PALESTINE war, but took 3 months to telecast the atrocities taking place in the Manipur Valley.
Words have no meaning action does! I was posted in Kashmir thus understand her and her people in great depth also due to my interest in this region of India. Who are the genuine Kashmiris? They belong to the Central Asian Aryan stock and many have converted to Semitic-Islam a good religion like any other. Thus, the Kashmiri Pandits and Kashmiti Muslims have the same ethnicity, culture, language, etc. The only difference is religion. Thus, Kashmiriyat will survive. What happened in the late 80s and early 90s should not surprise anyone. Tiny Pakistan a pimp state was used to create trouble for India by her backers. Our brother USSR was then reorganizing and thus India was left on her own. The aim was to fragment India but since we had nuclear weapons our enemies were frustrated and the brilliant Dr. Raja Ramanna the defense minister of V.P. Singh made it clear that the next nuclear test would be on China and Pakistan. The Pandits are the tiniest of the tiny communities (hence easy targets) and their contribution in most disciplines is second to none. Even in the armed forces they have played a great role and the bravery demonstrated by Capt. M.N. Mulla was second to none. One of the best commanders of the great Maharaja Ranjit Singh Sandhu’s army was a Kashmiri Pandit Col. Ayodhya Prasad. Like the Zoroastrians they lack numbers and I am a witness to the fact that their physical and mental capabilities are extraordinary. The Great Gama came from the family of converted Kashmiri Brahmans. Only Mr. Putin comes close to Indira Gandhi as a great leader. India now has the means to bring back these people to their beloved home Kashmir (India) and this must be done as quickly as possible. India is a diverse thus colorful country hence this tiny community adds flavor to India. Kashmiriyat will and must survive and let all the terrorists be liquidated and the Kashmiris love India as the Chechens do to their beloved Russia and Mr. Putin. The latter loves the Chechens and they him and he only liquidated the terrorists.
Highly disappointed with this man's failure to acknowledge the atrocities faced by Kashmiri Pandits!! YES THE KASHMIR BELONGS TO THE KASHMIRI PANDITS AND NOT THOSE INVADERS !!!!!!
Girja Tikoo or Sarla Bhatt ki family ko leke aa wo batayenge sach ki unke saath kha hua tha kyuki jis pe bit ti hai use hi pta hota hai ki usne kya khoya hai
And the state failed, not Jagmohan. It's by his mercy that we are atleast alive and are able to narrate our story or atleast counter people like you. Nhi toh aap jaise log pta nhi Kaunsi nayi kahani boldete. Just see how these KMs celebrated the targeted killings that happened over last two years. I have read those monstrous comments.
Majority is silent means what acceptance of ethnic cleansing....than why this guy is crossing his own statement
Very good analysis but still the truth is to be Muslim they need to support the smaller fraction at any cost.
Wrong.they feared for their lives too .. they would kill their families too ..
Wow, trying to change perspective when the people who have faced had been trying to tell what happened, appeasement and liberalism will lead to this.
Bring Kashmiri pandits to your podcast.Ranveer..! not congressi haajaam.
🚩Raj thakare ji ko bulayiye
Then why pandits leave from valley 😢 😢😢
Bring Kashmir Pundit to know their stories. This person is telling as if all the bad happened to Pundit without fault of anyone
if not movie people can check all documentary, movie portray similar. he just doing his best for sake of secularism,.
When you don’t want to loose muslim followers….. at the end subscriptions ka hi khel ban jata h kabhi na kabhi
Please dont do podcast if you cant speak straight on such sensitive topics.. ddint enjoy this one
reported the video for misinformation.
Report it for 'supporring terrorism '. By refuting genocide and targetted killings, they r actually justifying terrorism.
@@1abc546 done that as well
People like Shiv Sahai, even though he is honest as per his perception, I feel that he is trying to balance. You do not have to balance Sir. The viewers can balance themselves. The horrors of holocaust did happen even though there could be few Schindlers. In Kashmir, the neighbours did help the terr**ist to mark the houses occupied by the Pandits.
Report the video for spreading misinformation and promoting Terrorism.
1st i am not a person who like to write comment just because it doesn't impact but i am compelled to write on it being a kashmiri pandit myself
It is laughable what he is talking about no one is question people of kashmiri muslim decent who laid down their life for nation captain umar faiyaz sepoy aurangjeb are few examples
Unfortunately this man who served in ips have been blabbering about all communist narrative officially 219 kashmiri pandits had been killed that consistent of 1% of total population. If gentleman says that kashmiri Muslim died more in numbers of course they consist 99% population even it is straight math . Every death is unfortunate but he trivialises genocide of a minority by an equally supporting majority and what gatted community he is talking about i live in babapora shopian district kashmir my home is only Kashmiri pandit home how can forces be near my home 24×7 the gentleman might have cleared upsc but reality is out of focus for him and he blamed jagmohan he saved pandit what else would he have done took guns and fought terrorist that was police job what a delusional person he is